BTW Penny isn't in this list because she had ALL of her star powers and gadgets reworked. Penny was the problem and not her items, so its fair to leave them out of here Also she would take up like half the video lmao

Theres also pipers old gadget that shoots 4 tiny shots that deal 500 dmg each and it was so useless because it only hits when enemies are moving in a straight line and it tanks could just walk up to her and she wouldnt be able to defend herself but it was reworked to the auto aimer gadget we have now which is way better

Actually, Bea's Honey Coat SP was way more OP on release that everyone was saying she is S tier in Bounty during that time. When her 2nd SP was released, Honey Coat can be activated again even after dying in a non-Solo SD match.

RIP extra life. Back then I loved the game.

8-bit's SP was never "broken", it was absolutely useless outside of showdown, it would've been good for knockout, but 8-bit is too slow for knockout for him to be viable even with the revive

The 1000 hp from pocos star power was 4000 because this was before the 4x increase to all stats for easier balances

You forgot Vengeful Spirits(2nd Gadget on Gene)rework,Steel Hops(1st sp on Darryl)and Recoil Rotator(2nd sp on Darryl)

Pro players in 3v3: SPIRIT SLAP IS USELESS DON'T HOLD YOUR SUPER. Also pro players using their 1st gene super 3 seconds before the end of the match:

Honey coat was changed several times, they changed it i think like 5 times, making it one time in a game, or one time every time she dies and comes back. The reset was too op, but the 1 in a game was very bad. So they changed it back and fourth and after several times they reworked it.

I miss support Gale, back when he had a wider but weaker attack, Second Wind was an interesting idea i wish they simply buffed instead of removed.

Extra Life is by far the most liked in the community despite it being OP by far, and that's saying something cause I remember people seething in anger over it, it's just so unique and fitting for a brawler like 8-bit

I think it's just fair for mr p to get his 1st revolving door star power back, you know a max who has infinite ammo, reload speed, and movement speed? Yeah she can boost the entire team to approach you quicker, instantly destroy porters, and make you cry in the corner. Both of mr. p's gadget and star powers are below average, and since he's easily countered by aggro brawlers (Sam-phobia), he needs a buff since he is hot garbage. Heck spike and gene are everywhere since mr.p is their only best counter if you can't hit your long range shots. For once I don't want spike and gene to be meta since no skill curveball and best super in the game.

I remember when shelly's band aid was a thing when it healed you full hp, that was like a second life in showdown, it lasted a long time since the devs were on vacation

I miss when extra life star power existed, it was so broken on later matches on solo showdown lol.

What about old mortis star power when instead of killing enemy for 1000 hp, you just could pick a tiny ghost that healed you

You didn't include Darryl's star power rolling reload. Instead of giving him a reload buff it used to instantly reload his ammo. Most of the time it was pretty useless because you rather roll with full ammo

I think Swan Song would be a good mythic gear if they buffed the healing and would probably be great in Hot Zone

Everyone’s talking about how op the old sp and gadgets were when I’m just enjoying the Tara’s Bazaar music in the background lol

Poco's first ever star power back when you could play brawl in portrait mode was that every time he died, he would basically unleash his super but in a full 360 degrees radius.

I think either Supercell forgot or either don't want to make changes to base dmg/heal abilities such as (combo spinner) bc with the addition of the new lvl 10 and 11, brawlers got more dmg and hp, essentially it widens the gap between things like (combo spinner) and (survival shovel), same thing with others like (T-bone injector) bc they don't provide the same value as before at lvl 9 max.

The 8 bit one was ahead of its time

The honey coat star power of Bea was also annoying and broken in brawl ball, where you could tank all the shots by that star power and put your ball into the goal.

Man I miss Surge's teleport, on Brawl ball I always used this gadget to teleport use super and kill 3 ppl at a time or defend us from goal u know

I mean the poco old super with 1k healing seems weak until you realize back then health was much smaller and so was damage. Like primo's each punch dealt like 49 damage or something like that

I don't think this is counted, but Mortis had a star power where he could collect dead souls and heal 1000 HP. It got reworked to today's unused star power which Heals Mortis by 1000 HP when he kills a brawler

Supercell: Avoiding death that easily is too strong (although it was only once and you were very likely to die after anyways) Also supercell: Let's create a brawler that has a super that can revive not only himself but the teammates too

I remember when they had to nerf extra life around 4 or 5 times even giving you no invincibility and no ammo

love your videos carnage! what's your outro music called?

I think that spirit slap could be more useful if it would increase damage by for example 30% for 5 seconds after pulling an enemy to Gene's. What you guys think?

When swan song released, it was actually good. I remember using it because there was no insane stat padding, so 1000 hp was 2/3rds of a brawlers health.

I think the version 2 was ok for gene if it was a like 3 second duras AFTER and while the super is active this would make him better at killing tanks but I think if that was the case it should be 200 plus damage max

3:02 Actually Tick's backup mine was replaced because his second gadget did everything that the first one do better. First one: dash and a single mine. Second one: 50% shield, 1000 damage and knockback.

You missed Brock's Star Power, it set the floor on fire, but now it's changed to "Super contains 33% more rockets"

2:00 miss honey coat,favorite star power in the game also surge teleport fun asf

7:20 Back in the day 1000hp was a lot of hp It was normal for some brawlers to have way less than 1000hp Then they buffed every stat a lot

doug on his way to dig up the extra life star power and make it his super:

I loved ticks backup mine. I remember making so many plays with it

By the way You forgot about about Darryl rework His first star power was put as baseline and then nerfed And they gave him a new star power that gives him shield after rolling And the second star power used to give instantly 3 amo after using super And now the second star power doubles the reload speed

Damn i never played in those times but 8 bits sp looked op, would like to use it

1:00 It was replaced by Doug's super

To be honest, Bea really needs honey coat back according to current circumstances. She is helpless in showdown nowadays.

Honestly they should've changed Mr. P's Revolving Door SP, because when it first released the name made sense spawning porters faster, but now, what does a revolving door have to do with a beefed up porter? It shouldn't be a version 2, but an entirely new SP

Honey Coat was the OG 1HP clutch

Swan song has a very cool idea mayby in the future they should make s brawler thats passive is related to its death like after you die heal teammates by more than 1000health Deal damage to enemies knock back enemies stun what ever you can imagine

Watching this reminds me of Colt's silver bullet in solo showdown in maker maps when you still could get trophies from it😏

If they bring back the extra life then it would be balanced bcz u remember if u die u loose 2 ammo but this will probably give 8 bit an advantage bcz of the 1st gadget

about swan song In BS Beta, health and damage used to be way lower but they were increased on release, it was probably still bad but 1000 health then was way more than it is now

3:04 i remember this it left a 1 mine behind him it was uslees i only used it to escape

I remember when my dad got confused why 8-bit's super power "Extra Life" wasnt there when he checked it

A gadget that I think should be replaced is Bo's totem. It has caused way to much trouble with the multiple game breaking cheese it created. Besides, I can already come up with a gadget for him: Mountain treat: Bo will drop a mine that deals 40% less damage where he's standing

Not a rework but a kind of useful buff: I would love to see that if you play Surge and use his gadget which levels you up for a short time, that you can reach (and only with the gadget and Surge is on 4th level) a 5th level for that amount of time when it's active. Would be great I guess and you could still use the gadget at his 4th level :)

Supercell trying to get Da Capo right be like Why didn't they just make it 700 after 600? 💀

Swan song exist in the beta, when the most tankies brawlers has 1200 life points to up, literaly is super op if you think about it

Every randumb using Mine Mania after reworked Tick's Backup Mine and nerf to Last Hurrah gadget on Tick Idk why people is using Mine Mania even in brawl ball Last Hurrah is BY FAR the better gadget for Tick

7:27 back then, all brawlers had less ho and dmg (like 300 hp) so it was a good star power with any tank

It's funny how in da capo's rework they skipped 700 hp but it ended up being the right one

There was Carl’s SP where he could break walls with it. Idk if it was a SP, but I remember something similar

2:22 I really hate this excuse cuz you can say the same for emz plus some brawlers have useless second gadget too

I miss surge's teleport, because of it he was the first brawler i liked

another removed sp is gale's second wind it gave a short speed boost for any teammate caught in his super

I really liked tick's dashing gadget since it was useful to run away

If my memory is correct about ''Swan Song'' 1000 healing was a good amount of healing before Supercell increased HP and DMG of the brawlers i think is was in beta

Where my second wind homies at?

Hahahaha In Line is in this roster now!

there should be a game called Brawl Stars Power Overload where(if you have supercell ID) have your original account but it’s the brawlers before their nerfs like when they were op

Doug did 8-bit dirty with his extra life as a super

Did this video get turned into a member only video?

Didnt Poco had a StarPower that made his super go in a circle 360 instead of a cone shape radius? I believe it was when it was horizontal playstyle

Btw mortis had the dash startpower reworked twice or atleats once i think.

@CarnageGameYT Here is a video idea: Top 5 (might be more) Brawlers who's avatar (Not exactly avatar) got reworked (Example: Penny, Jessie, Pam, Daryl), its not a good idea but at least u have somsthing to make!

Good vedio but , me who looking for the star power in work on the brawlstars vedio running background still no evidence

La estelar de 8bit era MUY buena. En todos los modos de juego era medio basofia en realidad, pero en Sup. Solo era rotisima

Squeaks star power that makes his super deal more damage got removed. It now makes his ATTACK deal more damage.

I remember that the Bea star power never worked for me and I would not use it

Big nostalgia😢

I started playing Brawl stars very soon after release, so I knew about swan song :)

We need to know Poco's Swan Song was a Star Power that was deleated BEFORE Brawl Stars's global launch, where damage and health numbers were way low compared with today. It was the first ever reworked thing in the game!

Extra life was the best sp at those years but sam beat him RIP Extra Life

7:24 Obviously the star power was still trash, but back them 1000 healing was actually a lot, because the hp and damage scaling was very different.

Wait.. The map you play at the first It looks like i have played that map🤨

I honestly loved using Tin Can in brawl ball, especially on penalty kick

Honestly, as crazy as it sounds, I would be fine with Extra Life returning, as long as it cost your Super (in inventory). It would at least give some additional use to his Super, other than just for damage, and it would be really obvious because of the radius. It would still spawn with one ammo.

+ gale jump plate was rewirked from basic jump plate to gold plate

Wait, when did spirit slap get changed to deal 1k flat? I haven't even considered using it in so long I thought it was still the 300 damage buff with charged super 💀

the poco starpower in these age heal the same think like primo . But al the brawlers deals a los damagr

Swan song healing wasnt bad, remember avarage ho and damage of brawlers was much lower, and swan song was just during the early beta.

Just realize how similar old 8-Bit SP and Doug's Super

But still for tick's gadget, I think that is really good because right now 6 mines is very useless

I like how CG shot on beat as surge at 2:25

I think extra life could exist, but it should be 8 bits 2nd gadget and should bring him back with half hp, also only have 2 uses

doug can self revive now, how amazing :)

01:00 basically 8-bit star power got removed BUT doug exists

6:54 Oh boy, I know this one! I literally wanted just buff of this star power, but… uh

What about brock's first starpower and Carl's first gadget?

Wasn't Brock's fire thing a star power back then? You know when the rocket leaves fire on the ground

4:35 I didn't knew it got reworked

Welp now we can add rt in line to this list

The first dude with the coffee is his fault for holding it like that

The tick gadget was just a gadget used for cheese back in the days

O back in the day i woud use pat on the back and pop of healing my temates and pulling in the enemy gem carier all same super