Q1 - Why is 'Leaves from the vine' sadder than Aang's discovery of the air nomads' fate, according to a 2022Jun poll? (In-universe reasons only.) They don't even use the g word to describe what happened to the air nomads. Cowards. Q2 'Leaves from the vines' is about a war criminal crying over another war criminal. How's it sad BEFORE Iroh fully defects? But even after Iroh defects, I don't see how it's sadder than Aang's reaction to air nomads. Or maybe the writing was bad because it's a kids' show which doesn't really dwell much on the g word. Idk. Notes: 1 Change 'war criminal' to 'unjust war aggressor' if need be. 2 Imagine you had relatives who met fates similar to the air nomads', but people were crying over leaves from the vine. Eg Uyghur, Cambodia, Rohingya, et al. More info: - p1w4Rr-XW

Zuko is Israel, while Sokka is Hamas. ATLA netflix S01E01 - I noticed something: - Zuko is like Israel because Zuko accepts a 1v1 fight to reduce civilian casualties. - But Sokka like Hamas / Palestine is a war criminal (just like in the original with the false flag on the hot air balloon) by using children as soldiers and human shields by putting them in the front lines namely at the gates of the southern water tribe. Lol. What do you think? More info: - p1w4Rr-XW

In don’t think Gyatso wasn’t there was because if he stayed Aang would stay.

Agreed. He said what he needed to.

I think he only stayed to encourage Aang to let go of his guilt

Reincarnation isn't real, resurrection is!!

@@user-uq7jm4ix1n Oh yeah? Tell that to the Avatar

And until he told him what he needed to know. That he should not blame himself.

I liked it. Very emotional. But does this fit the story? What is so tragic about Aang is he never got closure. His whole race of people were just completely massacred literally a century ago, yet Aang feels responsible. He has to get over it. That feels more realistic. Solving this conflict by just letting Aang talk to Gyatso I feel like completely removes that void Aang has that is pushing him forward. It's sorta makes his character weaker emotionally because he doesn't get over it himself

Well, it's true. If anything, Aang running away was the best decision he ever made.

@@TANMAN84 it does fit the story, because aang is able to later on master the avatar state by having to get over the guilt of his tragic past which will happen much later.

​@@TANMAN84bruh hes an avatar he could meet spirits

Me too. This was wonderful.

And also best friend in Aang’s previous life

A great way to describe it, I love this❤

And (in Aang's case) reincarnated friends. Remember Gyatso was friends with Roku when he was training in Airbending

Amen

And Toph is still the Avatar's mentor after Aang passed away.

@@tristanlau1213also katara

The air normal not totally extinct , still have people escape outside to born the descendant But since the culture about airbender no longer exist Descendant of the survival can’t awaken the bending abilty to using it anymore

I 100% agree! People keep blaming him for the war because he ran away like a coward and didn’t fight back “when they needed him the most”. Aang is a child! The Avatar isn’t revealed until they turn 16, when they’re a bit more mature, but Aang is 12. He only learned about this a few hours before the invasion and found out he was going to be sent away from his mentor/guardian/friend to start learning the other bendings. Being told he has to save the world is a lot of pressure on a kid, of course he’s going to be scared! He didn’t even run away. He was just going out to clear his head for a bit and was going to return home as soon as he saw how bad the storm was. The iceberg was an accident. Someone finally telling him that none of this is his fault, that he wouldn’t have survived if he had stayed with them really helped him I think. It was something he needed to hear because it was true. Yeah, he’s a powerful air bender, but so were the other masters and they fell.

@@PuccaLover15 to be fair The air normad fail because they refuse killing Even gyatso only choose killing at the final moment That how and why they fail They stick to their culture which lead to their dead

@@vietcuongnguyenle8530 mhm after watching the live action I got more aware of the effect of what Sozin did. No matter how many generations we go into the future, the airnation will never become something close to what it was.

​@joris5429 If it's any consolation; The Air Nomads are thriving again by the time of Korra and Sozin is hopefully burning in hell

Amazing comment.

Not many thought it was bad. It captured the heart of the Original but made adjustments that were better suited for the now adult fanbase.

I'm upset with how Netflix handled the story. But this, I was crying on the inside. And they handle "Leaves On The Vine" just right, there's gonna be a lot of people balling their eyes out

Lol bad. Au contraire better than the original. Just like the Aladdin movie.

​@@tempestates13 Q1 - Why is 'Leaves from the vine' sadder than Aang's discovery of the air nomads' fate, according to a 2022Jun poll? (In-universe reasons only.) They don't even use the g word to describe what happened to the air nomads. Cowards. Q2 'Leaves from the vines' is about a war criminal crying over another war criminal. How's it sad BEFORE Iroh fully defects? But even after Iroh defects, I don't see how it's sadder than Aang's reaction to air nomads. Or maybe the writing was bad because it's a kids' show which doesn't really dwell much on the g word. Idk. Notes: 1 Change 'war criminal' to 'unjust war aggressor' if need be. 2 Imagine you had relatives who met fates similar to the air nomads', but people were crying over leaves from the vine. Eg Uyghur, Cambodia, Rohingya, et al. More info: - p1w4Rr-XW

@@nicbentulan very well thought out analysis mate.

This and the 41st division bowing to Zuko were the two scenes that made me cry. 🥺🥺🥺🥺

Well Iroh left his body and his soul went into the spirit world and i love the video of him and zuko visit him in the spirit world and they play pie so and it’s funny

I think this part is already shown in the animated series, the flashback episode during the time Aang and the gang embraced the storm

There's only one way to keep it straight.

Always remember who you are.

They have to cut it, otherwise UKposts's copyright algorithm will take it down

@@XandarYTOh yes I understand. I do know that applies to most movies. But I have seen small scenes from movies on UKposts before. That's why I found it odd that the uploader did that here

He may activate the avatar state but at the same time the comets enhanced the firebenders. He may be a 1kid army but he up against severals adults who let's say about 1 with 10 men strength. He'll still be outnumbered and also with other monks at near the area could probably distracted him. Just as he could be calm down out of the avatar state when katara calls him concernly in the animated series.

Exactly bro

The Moon/Spirit Oasis in the North Pole

He meditated

This wasn’t an illusion. Gyatso moved beyond the shadows and stayed in the Spirit World before moving on. It’s implied he stayed in the Spirit World to one day reunite with Aang to relieve him of the guilt he feels for abandoning the Air Temple. When Aang returns, Gyatso finally moves on, and emotionally, so does Aang.