here because of Baby Reindeer

Thumbs up if Baby Reindeer brought you here.

Don't be sad that there is only one Beegee remaining. Rather be happy that you got the chance to know them and got to listen to their amazing music.

This song has been playing in my head for last few days after watching Baby Reindeer. I never realized til now how profoundly sad this song is.

As a 53 year old man that never caught on to the Bee Gees until two months ago. My goodness. This performance reduces me to tears

No Robin... the joke was never on you. Thru' the years you made us happy, you made us smile with your beautiful voice. The day you died.. the world cried. The joke was on us.

Robin was such a sweetheart. The best voice of the group. He sang from his heart. God I miss him. ❤

A beautiful song that conveys so many feelings dealing with life’s choices, regrets, losses, pains, confusion, disillusionment. Mr. Robin sings it with such sincerity and love, that it actually ministers to hurting souls and brings comfort thru relating to our common plight as human beings.

Robin Gibb truly had the voice of an angel, and I really love this song!

My husband and I attended this show. Robin’s beautiful song/voice made me cry. All 3 of Barry’s brother’s are gone, but their music will live on. ❤️💜❤️💜❤️

I love the respect Barry showed by turning his back to the audience giving Robin the chance to be front and center. Which was rightly owed. R.I.P Andy, Maurice and Robin ❤️

I miss Maurice, Robin and Andy… all legends in their own right! Thinking of you Barry! Some of us still struggle to believe too! ❤

There will never be another voice like Robin Gibbs. Never

Rest In Perfect Peace Robin... the world is now a joke... still Loving your voice in 2021.....

Meu Deus ... ouvindo essa musica , paro e penso .... " Será que os outros que a ouvem também se identificam ? " ... Incrível , é tipo uma revelação . Extraordinário !

An absolute masterpiece, robin. You and this song belong in the music hall of fame. Barry, you make sure that happens. Don't stop until it becomes so. Let's put it to a vote. Hands down, this song is unmatched in performance and songwriting. Robin certainly deserves this long, overdo recognition. Such an immense talent. And it all came so naturally to him. 😢 Rip

It's not the song it's the voice that breaks your heart . RIP Robin great singer

Note how Barry turns his back to the audience to Give Robin the full audience attention,,,he's a great Brother

Robin truly had the best voice of the group . He was the most under appreciated of all.

I have been listening to you all since you started singing. I’m 69 now and I’m still listening!! ❤❤

A beautiful man with a beautiful voice. He is missed so much!

I wonder if Barry still listens to all these tracks. Especially ones like this. He said he misses them everyday If I was him, I'd cry a river.

The voice of that man... Could make the biggest baddest cry like a baby

Wenn ich die Musik höre, kommen mir die Tränen. Robin Ruhe in Frieden.

In all honesty this man right here is one of the most UNDERRATED GREATEST MALE VOCALIST EVER

Listening to Robin's voice takes me to another dimension. I always reflect on my childhood days with these songs, truly magnificent.

Will never forget the first time I heard this song, I was a young teen and my mom had bought me a 5 album set, basically the British invasion, the song moved me then, and still does, the song had so much hurt in it!

Belíssima música. Sua letra, seu sentido, sua melodia, interpretada por uma bela voz.

There is no comparable voice (then or now) to Robin's soulful vibrato. He was able to convey more emotion in a single song than most musicians can wish for in a lifetime.

It not about the Scale, pitch, song, Rhythm, music, beats, words, singer, etc etc.. Its all about the Feelings it might arise in YOU !!! Lovely song

Miss you Robin 😔 but thank you for sharing your beautiful voices and songs 🎵 Bee Gees forever ❤❤

No other singer can this song better sing than Robin Hugh Gibb i love him so and i miss him .......almost every day i think on Robin and his brothers💘💝💖💗💓💞💕🧡❤‍🩹💔💔💔

I can listen to his voice day after day . Loved them in my teens and still love them to this day. Over 50 years have passed.

In a 1,000 years people will be still listening to this song.

Robin's voice was so amazing!

Awesome! I never was a big Bee Gee's Fan, but as I mature I become more open to different talents and find myself listening for the special talents like Robin Gibb and I am amazed by his voice.

Big Bee Gees fan all my life. Didn't get Robin's voice till I heard this song. I now love it for all its magnificence and vulnerability. Great rendition!

His natural vibrato voice is pure genius. A most unique voice which is hard to imitate.

A real tear jerker

I heard this song after Massachusetts (1967) and I was in love with the Bee Gees. This song and Massachusetts will always hold a special place in my heart. Can never go wrong with anything this group ever sang ❣❣❣

The joke was on us. RIP one of the greatest singers of all time

I started a joke Which started the whole world crying But I didn't see That the joke was on me, oh no I started to cry Which started the whole world laughing Oh, if I'd only seen That the joke was on me I looked at the skies Running my hands over my eyes And I fell out of bed Hurting my head from things that I'd said 'Til I finally died Which started the whole world living Oh, if I'd only seen That the joke was on me I looked at the skies Running my hands over my eyes And I fell out of bed Hurting my head from things that I'd said 'Til I finally died Which started the whole world living Oh, if I'd only seen, oh yeah That the joke was on me, oh no That the joke was on me Oh, no, no, no

This song. Always. Forever. Wow. What's particularly beautiful about this video is they've grown up -- no antics on stage, no trying to steal the spotlight from the one singing. Just 3 men making beautiful music together on stage.

Its amazing that each brother individually was so amazingly unique but when they came together it made the best harmony ever

My Dad's favorite song. He passed away last year and today is his first year death anniversary. Miss him so much.

Crying my eyes out. This is a song that touches me deeply. Bee Gees Forever!

Yo conocí a los beegees por mi papá, le encantaban todas sus canciones pero no hay otra canción cómo "I started a joker" que le llegaba al alma, y hace unos dias falleció y como su último deseó pidió que en su sepultura se le pusiera está canción y así fue...🕊️✨

"And I fell out of bed hurting my head from things that I said" -- that lyrics just gets me every time I listen to it.

There has never been a voice like Robin's. So appreciated by fans and very much loved and missed...

The tone of Robins voice especially in this song is so beautiful it always brings me to tears...🌹

Alguém do Brasil ouvindo 2024??🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷

No fui de esa época, pero al escucharlos me llaman mucho la atención su talento, y la voz de Robin Gibb me fascina❤

The best song and voice! That's the way to expres your feelings. Robin, thank you for that! Rest in peace, we won't forget you!!!

I love the way Barry turns away and lets the entire spotlight highlight just how great Robin was.

What a beautiful voice Robin has, what a blessing to us all in Australia, that we had the beegees here for a little while at least while they were kids, but Robins beautiful voice will live on with me, a really great memory and a great song, wow.

This wonderful song, has been a hit, since 1967 !😂💜💫✨

My dad pass 2 days ago, this is his favorite song. He always play this song when he drives with me and my sister. Oh Dad, I never say how much I love you. Hope he will get the best in his next life. Love you daddy.

The voice from Robin Gibbs when singing this beautiful song was indeed came from his heart, full of sadness. Life is so short.

Te ne sei andato ma la tua musica rimane fino alla fine dei tempi ✳️🎶👍Grazie caro Robin ovunque tu sia 🙏 Meravigliosa canzone e prestazione, così come il fantastico video 🤳 Complimenti e Applausi 👏👏 Ciao 🇮🇹✔️🤗

Oh, what can said about dear robin? Of course, the voice of an angel that turns you inside out, and like his brother, barry once said, 'no one sings like you", rob. That sums it up for me, and of course, the emotion and 'trance-like state' he puts you in with his god-given vocals. Truly magical. Definitely 'hall' worthy. An unforgettable piece of music by the master, robin gibb. "I started a joke". Upon hearing the first few bars, you know the 'magic' is beginning, and so it goes, and everything is right in the world for the next few minutes. Thank you, robin. Your 'famous" and we're grateful.

I never, never get tired of listening to their amazing music. I'm here in November 2020 to escape the madness engulfing our country at this sad and scary time.

This is the BEE GEES' song I like the most. ROBIN sang it so beautifully and the lyrics ( he compsed the song and wrote the lyrics are so soul wrenching ! He was a beautiful Human Being. R.I.P..

Três horas da manhã e estou ouvindo Bee Gees. Inesquecíveis, um misto de sentimentos.

*A VONTADE DE CHORAR É TÃO GRANDE QND OUÇO ESSA MÚSICA.* *LINDA DEMAIS, GRANDE ROBIN GIBB, NO VOCAL, VOZ INCOMPARÁVEL, UMA PENA TERMOS PERDIDO ELE EM 2012, DESCANSE EM PAZ.* 🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾 Jota Soares, Aracaju/Se

This song so meaningful to me as a youngster back in the 1960's. 2022 now and I'm an old man and this song more meaningful than ever. Music is Life!

Feel so lucky to have grown old with these guys never get tired of listening to the bee gees

His vibrato is everything. ❤

BR 2023 🇧🇷 ESTAMOS EM TODOS OS LUGARES PRINCIPALMENTE NOS MELHORES ASSIM COMO ESTE ❤

Beautiful to hear Robin's voice, so gorgeous and heartfelt. Timeless. ❤️

It's amazing how they wrote their own songs and turned them into international hits, which artist from today does that? no one. The Bee Gees were not only amazing singers, but truly artists that knew how to convey feelings through their lyrics and wonderful vocals

What a voice

What a wonderfoul voice!!

I seriously feel Robin’s emotions here, so sad😢2021 still loving this song

Robin's voice brings on tears...RIP sweet soul...you are terribly missed and still loved.

Beautiful song, beautiful voice, and a beautiful soul.

No Robin the joke was never on you.through the years you made us happy you made us smile with your great voice the day you died the world cried.the joke was on us.

Robin's voice was sublime. This is my favourite Bee Gees song, however, they were , as a group second to none.

5-20-2016 'til I finally died which started the whole world living'. 4 years ago today and we still mourn your loss, dear Robin.....you are loved by so many....always.

The only singer in the world who did this song justice. A song the each individual will interpret they're own individual way.

I started a war, that started a war .... that made the whole world cry if I only saw that the joke was on me. I ignited a conflict, kindling flames across gaza, Where laughter once echoed, now only the sounds of strife. In my hands, a spark, that set the world alight, But in its glow, I see the error of my ways. The battles I began, a chorus of discord ringing, Underneath the stars, once bright, now dim with sorrow. In the echoes of the night, I hear the cries for peace, A plea for harmony, in a world torn by my hands. I wish for a return, to days of gentle whispers, Where swords turn to plowshares, and hearts are mended whole. In the quiet after the storm, let there be a solemn vow, For peace to reign supreme, in a world once lost to fight

The voice of an Angel. He still makes me cry....... there will never be another Robin Gibb.

To the 8k+ who disliked this song, i guess jokes on them. The Bee Gees are one of the BEST singers/songwriters that ever lived!

the best band bee gees ❤❤❤

No me canso de decir que es la versión inigualable de una canción entonada con sentimiento, nadie la ha podido igualar, menos superar 💖🥰🇨🇴

The BEST rendition of this. This performance was the first time I'd heard it, and it just sounded so sad and painful and tragic, like only some experienced adults could know. I can picture someone standing outside late at night drenched during a downpouring rain, just standing there, looking straight up, with hot tears running down their face just as fast as the cold rain is. The truth is that I watched this performance on TV with my dad as an adult. He loved this song. My parents got divorced when I was little and it kind of destroyed him. I remember one late night with him sitting on a kitchen chair wearing his black leather suit jacket, his hair still wet combed back from a shower, and all of his clothes in a black trash bag on the floor next to him, with his eyes looking at mine trying to explain to me why his was leaving, with tears running down his face. I was 4 so I was confused. Then when I watched this with him so many years later, I realized how he felt way back then when he listened to it. Then I saw his face that night that we saw this; I felt his pain, *even though he was smiling while he watched it*. We were both very sentimental people. And one of the biggest things that we both loved that we had in common is that we both LOVED the Bee Gees. No one else we have ever known will ever get that. He never remarried again. He's gone now. And unfortunately, I now as a mature adult have gotten to experience something like that personally for myself. It's just life. Robin did a beautiful job at portraying beautiful tragedy. And ironically, *it makes me smile too* .

Robin has a voice like an angel.

Awesome voice awesome song.

Essa música, como tantas outras, atravessam épocas e desbanca toda musicalidade da atualidade.

How MUCH can we love Robin?? Every year our hearts expand more to receive the love he gave the world. Love you Robin.

How can any one give this Man a thumbs down all he ever did was to bring a little joy to this world

Ôh mano vc canta demais... Jamais esquecerei está canção! Obrigada por esse hino!

A década de 80 nos brindou com canções únicas e memoráveis, marcadas por sintetizadores cativantes, batidas envolventes e letras apaixonadas. Os artistas dessa época ousaram experimentar e inovar, criando hinos atemporais que continuam a nos emocionar. Essa era musical nos transporta para um universo de nostalgia e emoção, lembrando-nos do poder duradouro da música em contar histórias e tocar nossas almas.

Such a unique voice, doubt there will ever be anything like it again. Beautiful!

Best of the voices of Bee Gees. Robin's voice is unmistakable.

It is 2023 and I wish so much tbat Robin knew how meaningful that song was to me. RIP Robin, please know how much you mean to me and countless others. ♥️

What a man, what a voice, what a song, what a feeling, what a time than he created this song ... So sad, this time will never come back, but so happy that I've lived in this time.

I can’t find any one can replace them after so many years, I would say thy are even much better than Beatles (in my opinion)

Beautiful voice Robin. God bless you. R.I.P.

I love him❤

What a beautiful voice he had. Sorry fans not get to enjoy and such a lost to his family. Rip robin❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤