This song reminds me of a memory that was never made.

‘GUESS IM CAUGHT IN THE MIDDLE OF IT’ at exactly the middle of the song 2:16 GENIUSSSS

Devastating. Finneas and Billie have said they're not making anymore like this because this wasn't well received. Such a shame cause this song is incredible.

I dont get why people hate this song, I ABSOLUTELY LOVE IT

Honestly, this is one of the best Billie’s song but also one of the most underrated

This is such an underrated song

Unpopular opinion: this is better than badguy.

This song is criminally underrated

The auto tune is used only for effects because she’s “dead” in the song. She doesn’t need that, her voice is amazingly beautiful okay people????

It’s Billie’s year 2019!

Billie's voice is so relaxing...

I'm a 40 year old Marine Corps veteran who quiet despises current pop and rap, but I've got to give credit where credit is due, this song caught me off guard. Has a feel to it that I can't describe, but it's unique, my hats off to you Billie.

Obviously Billie doesnt need autotune yall need to realize the artistic view of why she used it

Everyone saying its auto tune...it isnt lmao. Its called a vocoder. Its used on purpose to modify the voice and make it sound more robotic

She's such a queen. she literally don't have any bad song.

ALMOST 4 YEARS LATER AND STILL ONE OF MY ALL TIME FAVORITES

I NEED AN ACOUSTIC VERSION OF THIS

This song weirdly makes me feel like I had a past life

Finneas is fkin insanely good at making perfect melodies every single time

Literally my favorite song.

Her voice always puts me in some kind of mood.

Billie at 17: famous, successful and so damn perfect Me at 17: not died yet

HER BEST SONG UGHHH I ALWAYS COME BACK TO THIS

I'm obsessed with this song. The fact it really sounds like you're underwater, it's beautiful and so underrated. It's also dredging up the emotions from Roma, I saw it twice and it was so good.

I'm scared of how good she is...

*Have you noticed that when she sings: "In the middle of it" at **2:16** is in fact in the middle of the whole fucking song???????*

Came from resident evil. It fit so perfectly. Added a whole different perspective to the mood. Absolutely nuts.

This is 2022 and I still listen this masterpiece. This song is so underrated, one of the best songs exists in this universe. I still remember 3 years ago when I had lowest time in my life, this song came to me. I listen it almost everyday, and somehow I felt alive. I hope Billie can realize how good this song is bcs it is

*This song is Deeper than her* *other songs I hope I don't* *Drown*

Here’s the lyrics if you want them😂 When I was older I was a sailor On an open sea But now I’m underwater And my skin is paler Than it should ever be Mhm I’m on my back again Dreaming of a time and place Where you and I remain the best of friends Even after all this ends Can we pretend? I’m on my- I’m on my back again It seems more and more Like all we ever do is see How far it bends Before it breaks in half and then We bend it back again Guess I got caught in the middle of it Yes I’ve been taught, got a little of it In my blood, in my blood Memories burn like a forest fire Heavy rain turns any funeral pyre Tonight, in the flood When I was older I was a sailor On an open sea But now I’m underwater And my skin is paler Than it should ever be I’m watching movies back to back In black and white, I never Seen everybody do it like I do it any better Then going over you, I’m overdue for no endeavors Nobody lonely like I’m lonely and I don’t know whether You’d really like it in the limelight You’d sympathize with all the bad guys I’m still a victim on my own right But I’m the villain in my own eyes When I was older I was a sailor On an open sea (Edited because I messed a part up)

Most underrated song ever

I’ve listened to this song many times, but each time I hear something hadn’t noticed before. This song is layered and haunting. It truly is an amazing song. So rich and hypnotic. Absolutely beautiful.

(in my opinion) when I was older, come out and play, party favor, 8, lyin to ya and ilomilo are her most underrated songs

i love how smooth and gentle she sounds. Its so unbelievable.

This song is criminally underrated Billie Eilish is so dope. I can't stop watching this track again and again. I am sure she will be #1 soon due to 💖a u t h e n t I c v i e w s 💖

This is billie's most underrated song, and in my opinion it's also one of billie's best!😟

I’m amazed of how deep her songs really are like omg i can feel that.....

this is the most underrated song by billie eilish there is

This song is sooo slept on

I love everything she sings. Her lyrics are fucking incredible. When I was older is the best song she’s got out there at the moment. It’s deep no pun intended.

haven’t even listened to it yet and i already know i love it

The lyrics...the whole feeling the music gives you in the beggining as if you're slowly getting dragged into the abyss that is the ocean...the contrast between her gasping for air trying to survive and singing in that robotic dead tone... Wow Billie and Finneas... You've outdone yourselves this time, im crying like a little bitch and i havent even watched the movie but now i for sure will!And i bet it will crush my soul just like this song did.

If you still listening this music in 2022, you're a legend.

When she says the line "guess I got caught in the middle of it" she pronounces the word *middle* at 2:16 which is exactly the middle of the song

Billie doesn’t need autotune. *Autotune needs Billie.*

Billie and Finneas never ever made a mistake, wtf? This is superb

this is so criminally underrated.

she literally can’t make a bad song

this was insane i felt like i was in a trance the whole time-

this song hits me different, and i can't explain

This song makes me feel weirdly good vibes.

"I'm still a victim in my own right/but I'm the villain in my own eyes." *sobs in the corner for 67 hours*

Such a beautiful and hypnotic melody

1:49 and 2:40 give me chills every time... one of her most underrated songs imo

I'm drawn to the dark yet beautiful melodic undertones.

How can Billie leave us MoRe AnD mOrE sHoOk with every new song she releases?!?!?!?!

i can really see this in scary movie, it give such an intense vibe!!

The perfect mix of chaos and serenity in their pristine forms. Beautiful.

Cant wait to hear more like this...

imagine the music video for this-

Anyone Else On A Billie Eilish Marathon? 🙋🏽‍♀️💕

this song did not get the recognition it deserves oml

this is one of Billie's most underrated songs, damn it's beautiful as long as no one doesn't calculate it

When I was older I was a sailor On an open sea But now I'm underwater And my skin is paler Than it should ever be I'm on my back again Dreaming of a time and place Where you and I remain the best of friends Even after all this ends Can we pretend? I'm on my, I'm on my back again It seems more and more Like all we ever do is see How far it bends Before it breaks in half and then We bend it back again Guess I got caught in the middle of it Yes I've been taught, got a little of it In my blood, in my blood Memories burn like a forest fire Heavy rain turns any funeral pyre to mud In the flood When I was older I was a sailor On an open sea But now I'm underwater And my skin is paler Than it should ever be I'm watching movies back to back In black and white, I never Seen anybody do it like I do it any better Then going over you, I'm overdue for no endeavors Nobody lonely like I'm lonely and I don't know whether You'd really like it in the limelight You'd sympathize with all the bad guys I'm still a victim in my own right But I'm the villain in my own eyes When I was older I was a sailor On an open sea

Who’s here before 1 million?

Billie is the bundle of talent

shes really good at writing lyrics i can easily understand and its so deep

0:00-1:24 Sounds like a siren trying to lure you to the water to kill you.

Billie here to snatch the spiders out of our homes again.

this is insanely underrated.

the end though , gurl shes so good i can’t 😩✋

*_how does she make everything so beautiful like wHaT tHe hEcK_*

WHO’S HERE BEFORE A MILLION VIEWS? 🖤🖤

This song is so underrated.

I loved this in resident evil...

*Hey beautiful people that scrolling thru comment I sent you my blessing and wish you great year!😃❤*

To all those who think she overdid the "autotune": it was to make the effect of her drowning, like the sound of your voice underwater AND IT'S MFING SICK

This song is criminally underrated 😭 listening to this song for the first time felt so magical, my mind was blown away

his songs calm me too much from depression and anxiety why am I sick of this shitty world 🙂

She voice was asmr, so deep, dark, and hypnotized anyone who listened

Guys, the “autotune” thing is just an effect to make her voice sound broken. Singers like Tyler Joseph from tøp have used this artistic resource and people don’t seem to understand it :(

2022 here loving this still !!!!! Why is this song not getting attention?

I want you all to step into my shoes for a minute. Imagine yourself as a huge Billie Eilish fan (I’m sure that part is easy if you’re reading this). You’ve heard when we all fall asleep where do we go probably 100+ times. One of your favorite songs of all time is ilomilo. That was my initial intro to her and I backtracked to don’t smile at me which I’ve also listened to plenty of times, as well as standalone tracks like Lovely and No Time to Die. Spotify in 2020 says I’m in the top 1% of all listeners of Billie Eilish. 2021 rolls around and I listen to happier than ever obsessively. Such an incredible album. Now imagine all of this time as what you can see I’m a pretty fairly obsessed fanboy that I have NEVER HEARD THIS SONG. What?! I was just shuffling all Billie Eilish music when I went to bed and woke up in the middle of the night and this song is playing. I had NEVER HEARD IT and even Shazam’d it thinking, in my half asleep stupor, is this a different artist? Baffling, cause I’ve seen -so many- videos of her live performances yet somehow never encountered this song. What a haunting, chilling song. I feel ashamed a little that this somehow passed me by. Yet I feel privileged AF that I get to experience a new Billie Eilish song today, august 15 2021. I know some fans will be appalled that I JUST heard this. But true fans that read this full story and put themselves in my shoes might just shed a tear at how lucky I am to experience this gem at such an unforeseen moment.

OMG I WISH THERE WAS A MUSIC VIDEO FOR THIS

HAPPY BDAY WIWO💛💛💛💛💛💛💛💛💛

the most underrated and beautiful song.

1.she came 2.she sang 3.she conquered 👑🖤 this song is so hypnotising😍

Why isnt anyone talking about her sick rap verse?

Summer's about to end and I wish you guys a great new year, full of productivity, success and happiness ❤️

I love Billie she's such a talented QUEEENNNNNN

When the song stopped and was silent for a moment Me: wtf is wrong w my wifi Billie: dreaming of a time-

who's here before 87 billion?

This song gives me chills but like in a good way yk what I mean it feels almost unreal

this has always been my fave billie song

Wig? Flown. Acne? Cleared. Tears? In my eyes. My love and appreciation? Coming at you. Hotel? Trivago.

Saw someone complaining about autotune? OKay so Billie doesn't use it, the point of this song was saying she was under water, or drowning. So autotune was used to make her sound like she was underwater, just to clarify ^^. (Also please don't start a war in the replies.)

Resident Evil sent me here. Great song!

I just want her and Finneas to do whatever they want always and I'M HERE FOR IT. ✨🎶🎧😌

This song scares me for some reason. But I still love her.

Me: "When I was older" English teachers: **Cries loudly** My Asian parents: When you are older you will be a doctor