That mistake was like god saying let me help you with that 🤣🤣

Best musical mistake ever lol

you're not wrong if that is what it does with your heart

Ripping (off) Yarn!

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus ?

@@ShalomMulenga It's really nice. You had involvement in its creation? You're probably doing the narration, yeah?

Mistakes happen, but they distort the original idea. In the future that piece of music might be performed by a death metal band and people think it's just some traditional lullaby from the year 1984.

​@@ariseaman390 you underestimate (Death) Metal. Especially in Scandinavia many Metal bands are formed by musicians who studied music at the university. There is no modern music that is more complex than Metal (apart from "modern" classical music of course). Music is the language of emotions and in this song the high C is nothing else. But how can you express rage, anger or even hatred with a choir? This is the gap harmonic music cannot fill and where Metal has to be.

I like your thinking 🤔👍

Crap you beat me to it lol

i prefer master oogway

RIP Bob Ross... Even my pre-teen children love him...

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

Sweetest comment ever. 🙏🏽

I hope it went well!

May I ask: have you been singing it in Latin?

I think it sounds much better with the Prerigrinus rather than Mode ij.

Magic doesn't exist. Grow up.

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

The James Macmillan version is my favorite. Look up the version by the ORA singers. PERFECT blend. Absolutely perfect 😭😭

yeah dawg, it slaps da bass!!

​@@Frankybeanselevators weak.

Somehow “slaps” comes nowhere close to the majesty of this music.

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

Except for the soprano's scoop and pitch issues in the third version.

The tenor soloist was under pitch on his first two plainchants. I’m also not a fan of the conductor’s gestures/conducting technique

@@danielhughes441 I think they added the solos from a different take. The 4-part choir would have come in on the lower pitch they had been presented with if the performance was continuous, but they were instantly in tune with each other and matched the previous choir. Also, no conductor is necessary for this.

Its not as good as it sounds...

Absolutely!

Is she a contralto?

Helen Charleston it is. Glorious

A really warm voice! I have a special care about (the almost forgotten) Alto voice.

@@richardrobb9016 A lovely rendition of hers in a lighter mood, here with Trinity College ukposts.info/have/v-deo/nZV8Za6aa2dptGg.html

it's rather beautiful isn't it. thanks for watching

i think the actual sistine chapel choir had made a recording of the original piece which was recorded in the sistine chapel .

I wholeheartedly agree.

I hope you do a recording too - your work is beautiful. The original tells more closely to the meaning of the Psalm itself too but all are exquisite.

@@atlinc.s6525 Al though the Sistine Chapel Choir of the late 20th and 21st centuries doesn't bear much resemblance to the one of the 16th and 17th centuries.

The human voice is the only instrument created by God, not by Man, making it the highest instrument of them all.

@@creightonstarbuck2000 dude...best comment ever

God's greatest instrument.

@@drlrwilsings By your logic, god also made heavenly farting.

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

😂❤

😘

It would be really nice to have a full recording of the 2nd version from beginning to end. That seems the version most suitable for a concert, but what I like about the original version is that it can be sung by ordinary people in an actual liturgy!

@@c_era_una_volta😅😅ii😅ii

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

Bob Ross, 😆

Nah, it’s a terrible mistake. If you want to hear that high C just transpose the original score up a fourth, but don’t mess with the composers work.

Funnily enough, it's more like evolution. A random mutation / fault that proved to be more fit to survive than its ancestors.

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

@@torsteinnordstrand170 You're ignoring the selection mechanism. Plenty of random things happen but they don't get selected randomly.

@@ShalomMulenga Man, I didn't even realize this song is psalm 50(51). Brings a tear to my eye

@@Cyrus_II Not sure what you mean, it was clearly selected for. Just as Jeff Buckley's rendition of Hallelujah has made us forget Cohen's original.

same

Druid? Gregorio Allegri was a Roman Catholic Priest. Stop confusing yourself and robbing the Holy Trinity of their Glory! Their aim is to inspire love of God by sending Sanctifying music into the world. Their purpose again is to raise a soul to God! No doubt you are an admirer also of Mozart? Mozart was not the silly wretch they portrayed him as being in the film. Having read his unedited letters, he was revealed to be what would be classed today as a most Conservative Prudish person, a devout Roman Catholic (like Allegri) who served God and led people to God with his inspired music. In many letters Mozart speaks of Christ. "Christ willing I'll see you later" "If it is God's Will I will do so" etc...In one letter that Mozart wrote to a friend, he revealed that during the space of time that he sat at Table eating his dinner, he became distracted from his table guests, upon hearing music as though already composed playing in his head. All that was needed was for him to write it down. No doubt you would interpret him as being a warlock, Druid, or heathen - (all known to be Satanic types who are NOT of the pure, just God. Mozart, however, did not despise the virtue and innocence of Christ, and he recognised His virtue and innocence within His gift of Music. He therefore gave full credit to God. He said the music came from Heaven so that he could bring glory to God as souls marvelled at his accomplishments. Mozart also once said "I trust NO man who does not love Christ." As a Composer myself I know that what he said was true. Whether the music is dreamed, heard consciously playing outside yourself, or even played in your soul so you are unaware that it is indeed a gift from outside you - the author of ALL Sacred, spiritual beautiful music is Our Lord. Who hopes we will rush to worship Him as we hear it being performed. His aim is realised. MANY souls are brought to Christ listening to the music that He gave the Composers who LOVED Him. Other RC Priest Composers are Palestrina, Vivaldi, Tomas Luis de Victoria Monteverdi, - other Catholic Composers include, Pergolesi, Elgar, and of course, William Byrd and Thomas Tallis.

@@smc3735 “Druid” was a typo! I intended to type “period” and it auto-corrected. Not sure where you got your interpretation of my comment from though. Actuslly personally Mozart is among my least favorite composers. Also, as a composer, I appreciate and tolerate all religions and the music they have inspired, as well as the music they haven’t, and as such, respect that Allegri may have come from a similar spiritual background to yourself!

Damn, you are gorgeous !

That one is called lamentations

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

@@chubbs-thechubbyninja4719 thanks

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

The singers are uncredited individually, but I think that's Helen Charlston as the contralto (formerly of Trinity College Cambridge). Yes, an awesome talent.

SAME! But i do think the c makes it so very gaudy.

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

Roy Goodman became an excellent violinist, especially in Baroque and early Classical music.

Me too

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

Quit spamming our page

For another, try the one in Nigel Short's Tenebrea Choir. The one I'm speaking of specifically is in the antiphonal choir, I put you in about 10 seconds before that stratospheric note. It's the same piece, BTW. ukposts.info/have/v-deo/gGOnbaulp56XymQ.html

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

I *loathe* that 9:42 with a passion, I have to say.

@@chrismoule7242 maybe I'm uncultured but that whole part from 9:42 to 10:11 (especially at 10:05) just sounded super pitchy and off to me?? I guess it was meant to sound that way but the blond singer sounded off key to me and it threw me off. But maybe I'm just super used to the original lol

@@ghastlycandle I love the dissonance in that part. It's not off-key, it's just a chromatic note (or borrowed?) I'm assuming. It darkens it a bit. Love it

Grinch-like, my soul grew three times its size the first time I heard that 12:10 sound (and every time since!)

real. a full 15 min version of it would be incredible

Now that’s a lot of damage

Same, my guy -- and yet, here we are, just as magnificent as that "mistake" of a note.

Well, you can appreciate heavenly music so you can't be all that bad 😊.

They made a mistake they think but all they did was miss the largest opportunity of their life's, raising a child. God makes no mistakes child but humans on the other hand blinded by our ambitions stumble by the second. You are loved but we all have a struggle to face. Hold fast and elevate your struggle for the holy souls of purgatory.

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus

to me, the high C is what makes it, I just saw it a few days ago and let me tell you, it was an experience

@@fredgarv79 thats me right now having an experience. The Hi C version just blows me away

You hit the nail on the head..." hauntingly beautiful and reflective". I can definitely picture it during Tenebrae Services.

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus ?

Glad you enjoyed!

And very familiar. We use it among others.

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus

Right ? Such a great mistake !

Thanks Frances!

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

Yep Psalm 51 is the “big” one

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus

You’re welcome to come to the Catholic church any time

Thanks for the feedback Barbara! Noted!

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

Indeed. I only hope this is the song I hear as I enter heaven. Glorious!

Amen

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus ?

Another favorite of mine, and Voces 8, among others.

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

A blessed Easter to you too.

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version of Miserere mei Deus

ukposts.info/have/v-deo/f4aBnq6PhbBjxpc.html what do you think about this version

I agree! It befits Holy Week. And the tonus peregrinus is haunting.