How Does Lobbying REALLY Work?

  Переглядів 25,887

Above The Noise

Above The Noise

День тому

Are lobbyists really as bad as their reputation?
Is the Electoral College Killing the Democratic Process? • Is The Electoral Colle...
SUBSCRIBE so you never miss a video!
bit.ly/3tNKzhV
And follow us on Instagram and Twitter!
/ abovethenoi. .
/ atn_pbs
**What are lobbyists?
Lobbyists get paid to try to convince lawmakers to adopt or oppose policies on behalf of their clients. There are thousands of different groups that have lobbyists either working directly for them or hiring lobbyists from lobbying firms. And these groups can range from big corporations and trade associations to public interest nonprofits.
**Are lobbyists bad?
Lobbying itself is generally thought of as a fundamental right guaranteed by the first amendment in the constitution as the right to petition the government for a redress of grievances. At its core, lobbying is just a way for citizens to engage with lawmakers on issues that are important to them. Most of the critiques around lobbying have to do with how money is involved. It’s really expensive to run a political campaign, and one way that lobbyists can get facetime to talk to politicians is to throw big fundraisers for them, and lobbyists themselves can actually donate to political campaigns. And most of the biggest spenders on lobbying represent business interests. This raises equity issues about what types of organizations can afford to hire lobbyists and ultimately whose voices influence policy.
**How does lobbying work?
A lot of lobbying is building relationships with politicians and finding out who has the interest and power to help with your cause. And money isn’t the only currency in lobbying, politicians also pay attention to how many people are calling their offices and care about an issue, how many people are sending emails or writing notes about an issue. Getting facetime with politicians and their trusted advisors is extremely important when it comes to lobbying,
*Do lobbyists for non-corporate causes ever win?
Yes, even though corporate interests outspend public interest groups- lobbying can still work to bring about change that isn’t necessarily pro-business. For example, The Nature Conservancy, an environmental nonprofit successfully lobbied for congress to permanently fund the Land and Water Conservation Fund, which is a pot of money reserved for conservation efforts to offset environmental damages caused by the oil and gas industry.
SELECTED SOURCES
Lobbying (The National Museum of American History)
americanhistory.si.edu/democr...
How Corporate Lobbyists Conquered American Democracy (The Atlantic)
www.theatlantic.com/business/...
Gold-Level Clubs for Lobbyists (Politico)
www.politico.com/news/2022/08...
Top Spenders on Lobbying 2021 (Open Secrets)
www.opensecrets.org/federal-l...
Midterm Election Spending (Open Secrets)
www.opensecrets.org/news/2022...
Big Pharma Went All In to Kill Drug Price Negotiations (Kaiser Health News)
khn.org/news/article/big-phar...
Testing Theories of American Politics
scholar.princeton.edu/sites/d...
Fighting Special Interest Lobbyists Power Over Public Policy (Center for American Progress)
www.americanprogress.org/arti...
About KQED
KQED serves the people of Northern California with a public-supported alternative to commercial media. An NPR and PBS member station based in San Francisco, KQED is home to one of the most listened-to public radio stations in the nation, one of the highest-rated public television services, and an award-winning education program helping students and educators thrive in 21st-century classrooms.
Funding for KQED’s education services is provided by the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, the Koret Foundation, the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, the AT&T Foundation, the Crescent Porter Hale Foundation, the Silver Giving Foundation, Campaign 21 donors, and members of KQED.
CHAPTERS
0:00 Intro
0:56 What are lobbyists?
1:47 Lobbyists and money
2:32 Lobbyists for businesses
4:50 Environmental lobbying
7:50 Conclusion
#lobbying #lobbyists explained

КОМЕНТАРІ: 67
@AboveTheNoise
@AboveTheNoise Рік тому
If you could lobby for any law to get passed, what would it be…and how would you work your strategy?
@thomasr.jackson2940
@thomasr.jackson2940 Рік тому
For election reform. Remove the arbitrary cap on the number of Congressional representatives, bring the ratio of people to reps from 750k to 1 down to 50k to one, and possibly eliminate geographic districting, and, using the 14th amendment, link state apportionment to voter participation rates.
@miroslavhoudek7085
@miroslavhoudek7085 Рік тому
If people stopped saying "let's evict the lobbyists out of Washington" and start saying "let's put our lobbyists into Washington" :-) Why it's so difficult for people to organise, right? So much to be gained from organised labour - and from organised politics as well.
@saeedabasilobbyist
@saeedabasilobbyist Рік тому
Me also introducing a global positive style of Lobbying in professional way rather than a kickback or bribery style
@air.internetH2O
@air.internetH2O Рік тому
this video really good
@baddoomguy1986
@baddoomguy1986 8 місяців тому
I'd lobby to ban lobbying.
@MandoMTL
@MandoMTL 8 місяців тому
Lobbying, Bribery... Potato, Potatoe...
@Haseri8
@Haseri8 Рік тому
You can hire a lobbyist to negotiate a raise, it's called a union
@ruan13o
@ruan13o Рік тому
Surely the most obvious improvement would be to ban lobbyists from doing any work that could benefit politicians and government officials. So that includes fundraisers but also any gifts, holidays, favours for family members, offers for future jobs etc.
@AboveTheNoise
@AboveTheNoise Рік тому
Thanks for watching and weighing in!
@miroslavhoudek7085
@miroslavhoudek7085 Рік тому
The thing is, can you even enforce it? I agree with you that forbidding it would be a signal. But ultimately there could be Big Tobacco Lobbyist and Big Tobacco Fundraiser and both these guys will claim to be independent (and protected by free speech). But when the politician help the Lobbyist, the Fundraiser will help the politician.
@ruan13o
@ruan13o Рік тому
@@miroslavhoudek7085 I agree it's tricky but I also feel like we have to try. Our democracy is increasingly run by big corporations who often act against the interests of citizens. Often shortening our lives and causing us harm. We surely can't just shrug our shoulders and give up.
@ImHeadshotSniper
@ImHeadshotSniper Рік тому
@@miroslavhoudek7085 i'd be hopeful that a just society could do some investigation into groups that try to legally evade their real purpose. it is just baffling to me though that money could at all affect the judgement of legal decisions when money is completely irrelevant to the argument of the decisions themselves.. the only people concerned about the relevance of the money in legal decisions are the lawyers and the judges, which is literally a scam of money, and justice.
@miroslavhoudek7085
@miroslavhoudek7085 Рік тому
@@ruan13o oh no, I agree. But markets are a real thing and you can't prevent corporations from 1) having money and 2) finding a way to spend it in their interest. You can't so simply outlaw it because they can always hire the smartest people to avoid the laws, bend the laws, find loopholes in them. My humble (truly humble) opinion is that solution is not some active minority - like you and me - somehow making a law (or two) that will fix the world. The only true solid permanent solution is majority of citizens becoming aware and active and they will 1) spend their own money to have lobbyist work for us. And we are so much more powerful than corporations can ever dream of. Because we have money but we also 2) have legs to walk to the points of power in large numbers and voice our opinions - and notably 3) we also have all the votes. Also also 4) corporations are owned by some of us through direct stock ownership or through hedge funds that should listen to what we want. Not take our money and go on a power trip with them. There's a saying that people have the government they deserve. If people are willing to bow their heads or get manipulated, they will get what they deserve. And you can't really legislate your way out of it ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ People have to start pulling their weights, spend their money, do the learning etc.
@Nonz.M
@Nonz.M 2 місяці тому
This video was a good reminder that the voice of the people has very little influence on the laws that get passed.
@protennis365
@protennis365 Місяць тому
So you are against union workers.
@chuco915C
@chuco915C 20 днів тому
@@protennis365I’m against us citizens having little influence on the laws we can pass.
@PrayForMariMariEmmanuel
@PrayForMariMariEmmanuel 8 днів тому
​@chuco915C we should have an official group of government whose job it is to take law requests and submit those requests in an official manner and then the people vote on those ideas in a public and governmental forum. The most popular ones get passed on to legislators. The people who submit the requests should get paid a fixed salary by the government. The people who come in to voice their ideas should pay a small service fee (like $10) to submit an idea and that money goes back to the government as taxes.
@chuco915C
@chuco915C 8 днів тому
@@PrayForMariMariEmmanuel good start.
@connecticutaggie
@connecticutaggie Рік тому
Myles, great video. I loved how you informed without painting an overly simplistic view. Insight about about Lobbyists can come from a similar to another job that is often villainized - Medical Sales Reps. Though Medical Sales Reps can (at times) use inappropriate means to influence a sale, they also provide information, training, and support that doctors need to be successful. I am sure when you go to your doctor I am sure you want them to provide you with the best treatment but so much has changed since they left medical school and even medical school can't train them on everything. That is often where a Medical Sales Rep comes in - he is an expert on the medicines he represents and can help a doctor understand what they are and where they can be used so he can make the best decision for you. The best Lobbyists can do the same thing for a Congressman. Congressmen can't be an expert on everything and the public almost certainly is not. Issues are complex and if he only listened to superficial he could very easily sponsor a bill that sounded great on the surface but actually was disastrous for his constituents.
@dramonmaster222
@dramonmaster222 Рік тому
Thanks for making this video and making politics more fun to learn.
@AboveTheNoise
@AboveTheNoise Рік тому
YAY! Glad you liked it!
@monstar5746
@monstar5746 Рік тому
What's the difference between lobbying and corruption?
@TheseWordsTouch
@TheseWordsTouch Місяць тому
Lobbying is legalized bribery as soon as money is involved. I wish politicians would just do their job and make informed decisions with any information provided to them.
@sullivannix4509
@sullivannix4509 6 місяців тому
Loved the video! Very high quality and informative.
@ForcesOfFreedomAndFascism
@ForcesOfFreedomAndFascism 6 місяців тому
"It's incredibly expensive to run for office," but with free internet and social media, wouldn't it be easy to publicize your platform? The cost of expensive 30-second TV ads, where you learn nothing about the candidate except a catchphrase or a smear of the opposing politician, seems ineffectual.
@PunkHerr
@PunkHerr Рік тому
The downside of lobbying is that people with money/power always have longer breath and more opportunities. But let's say we keep lobbying, what could help? For example like back in Greek to get random politicians. This way you start from 0 every time a new election happens so that you cannot take one politician and hope (or even help) that they stay for years and work for your interests. Through the randomness you don't have to fight (and loose ressources on that) for reelection.
@indiealaska
@indiealaska Рік тому
Learned a lot from this one! Thank you!
@AboveTheNoise
@AboveTheNoise Рік тому
Thanks for watching, @Indie Alaska!
@robotbutterflies
@robotbutterflies Рік тому
I was actually paying close attention to US ARK not long ago. There was some points in an upcoming bill that would make it very difficult to own or sell exotic pets. As a person who keeps Tarantulas, I had a vested interest on how it played out.
@DavidBeddard
@DavidBeddard Рік тому
Lobbyist to negotiate a raise? It's called a union, Myles!
@sylvesteruchia5263
@sylvesteruchia5263 3 місяці тому
"Even reptiles have lobbyists" Mark Zuckerberg : " how else are we supposed to get heard ?"
@user-yj8ly4gv4q
@user-yj8ly4gv4q 3 місяці тому
At this point I am looking for my new client but so many companies are so frustrating. So if you know a company looking for a lobbyist I am your guy. I am here in Washington D.C.
@rsaunders57
@rsaunders57 Рік тому
Good for Legislators + Good for Lobbyists = Not Good for Everybody Else. With the legislative branch writing thousand-page bills, somebody has to actually do the work of writing down the specifics.
@AboveTheNoise
@AboveTheNoise Рік тому
In some cases, particularly at local and state level lawmaking, lobbyists actually help write the bills: www.usatoday.com/pages/interactives/asbestos-sharia-law-model-bills-lobbyists-special-interests-influence-state-laws/
@saeedabasilobbyist
@saeedabasilobbyist Рік тому
Great info buddy, liked the way you presented.. Me also introducing a global positive style of Lobbying in professional way rather than a kickback or bribery style
@miriamrosemary9110
@miriamrosemary9110 Рік тому
Informative and educational. Thanks for making this!
@AboveTheNoise
@AboveTheNoise Рік тому
Thanks for watching!!
@mayaispunk
@mayaispunk 3 місяці тому
This was really great and simple to understand :D 👍🏽
@AboveTheNoise
@AboveTheNoise 2 місяці тому
Thank you!
@user-kg5kc5ju2n
@user-kg5kc5ju2n 5 місяців тому
I'd be perfect for my company's brand. Not going to name our company here, (top 5 tech company).. but sadly don't know how to apply to a position like that.. Thank you for the info
@lbjcb5
@lbjcb5 Рік тому
Great video!!
@gizmobowen
@gizmobowen Рік тому
I would lobby that all veterans would get veteran's day off as a holiday, regardless of their company's policy. As a veteran, I've had to work most veteran's days while my wife, who works for a federal contractor and is not a veteran gets the day off. That's the bill I'd like to see passed.
@8eight104
@8eight104 11 місяців тому
The Green Weenie will still find you, even after you're snug and asleep under a DD214 blanket
@AKLostbutFound
@AKLostbutFound 11 місяців тому
I say we take it a step further and make it so that all veterans never have to work a day again in their life. Why is risking one’s life not reason enough to be taken care of? 🤷 You deserve better 🙌
@jameltaylor4241
@jameltaylor4241 Місяць тому
Big Green is a lobby too. Where's the Food Service Workers lobby, Parents lobby, Child Safety Lobby, I'll bet there's a general "black" lobby, but that needs to be cut up, what about a Millenial Lobby?
@godsmosthated
@godsmosthated Рік тому
So sad how this has been happening for forever
@nitochi3
@nitochi3 15 днів тому
How do you become a lobbyist?
@Butwhoisthedreamer
@Butwhoisthedreamer 6 місяців тому
Great video! Earned a sub
@AboveTheNoise
@AboveTheNoise 6 місяців тому
Yay! Thanks!
@zeekay3205
@zeekay3205 6 місяців тому
Corporatism.
@centurio34
@centurio34 10 місяців тому
Lobbying isn’t as lucrative as it sounds - for every registered lobbyist in DC that’s at least doing okay, there’s another working for a smaller organization who’s barely making a livable wage. A big reason why is supply and demand - there are a lot more qualified people interested in government relations and public policy jobs than there are jobs available. Source: I’m a lobbyist.
@larrypowers2515
@larrypowers2515 Рік тому
4 Day work week? Done that. I hate working 13 to 14 hour days just so I can have 3 off. No thanks.
@air.internetH2O
@air.internetH2O Рік тому
very nice videos
@ramaalazzeh7382
@ramaalazzeh7382 5 місяців тому
wheres IPAC
@gozimusable1
@gozimusable1 3 місяці тому
Doesnt Google and Facebook own the highest amount of lobbyists?
@AnthonyCelata
@AnthonyCelata 8 місяців тому
What I didn't understand was the line "I don't have any political currency, I'm not up for reelection" Why would somebody who's term is up looking for votes have political currency? I would think someone with political currency would be someone who is head of a committee or has decision making authority. If you where to say that the guy who is up for reelection has political currency because he needs the votes and thus is willing to push a bill the voters want, then the political currency would be the willingness of a member to push a law. I'm missing something here, who can put their two cents in?
@sergeigen1
@sergeigen1 Рік тому
its all about the money baby
@aarone9000
@aarone9000 6 місяців тому
Clearly, it isn't about; "we the people"!
@brokenrecord3523
@brokenrecord3523 Місяць тому
95/100 represent big business and you focused on The Nature Conservancy? I see what's going on here too.
@qmenn88
@qmenn88 2 місяці тому
This sound like corruption with ekstra steps. Even if there sound good some times. :/
@gaBehcuoDsuoitneterP
@gaBehcuoDsuoitneterP 3 місяці тому
Great video!
Лизка заплакала смотря видео котиков🙀😭
00:33
Level 1 to 100 Mystery Buttons
00:46
A4
Переглядів 5 млн
Liberal Hypocrisy is Fueling American Inequality. Here’s How. | NYT Opinion
14:21
Are Parasocial Relationships Healthy...or Harmful?
7:22
Above The Noise
Переглядів 9 тис.
Noam Chomsky full length interview: Who rules the world now?
17:14
Channel 4 News
Переглядів 5 млн
The US-Israel relationship explained | Start Here
12:07
Al Jazeera English
Переглядів 775 тис.
This Is How To Hire Your Own D.C. Lobbyist
5:42
VICE News
Переглядів 106 тис.
What REALLY Happens To Our Old Electronics?
10:35
Above The Noise
Переглядів 8 тис.
Is Autism A Disorder Or A Difference To Be Celebrated?
10:33
Above The Noise
Переглядів 11 тис.
Mind Control: How Apps Use Design Tricks To Hook You
8:18
Above The Noise
Переглядів 13 тис.
Which Groups Spend The Most On Lobbying?
2:07
WCCO - CBS Minnesota
Переглядів 4,1 тис.
The US Elections Explained: Lobbying
6:47
LSE
Переглядів 17 тис.
Лизка заплакала смотря видео котиков🙀😭
00:33