India Today Conclave 2024: 'Secularism Is Dying in India' | The Conclave Debate

  Переглядів 190,796

India Today Conclave

India Today Conclave

Місяць тому

Is secularism dying in India? Do we need to redefine secular values in the country? Watch this fiery debate between panellists from across fields at India Today Conclave 2024
The India Today Conclave - India's premier thought forum - is entering its 21st year. Over the next two days, Conclave 2024 will bring together visionaries, leaders, and luminaries from across the globe under one roof to delve into the essence of 'Brand Bharat: An Assertive Nation in an Uncertain World'. Spanning over two decades, the conclave has established itself as a premier forum for dissecting the complexities of our times, stimulating intellectual debates, and seeding the ideas that shape our world.
#IndiaTodayConclave24 #indiatodayconclave #indiatoday #indiatodaylive #SaketGokale #Ashutosh#ShamaMohamed #ShehzadPoonawalla #HindolSengupta #ShehlaRashid #AryamaSundaram #SwapanDasgupta #DeepakVerma
SUBSCRIBE to India Today Conclave so you don't miss any session and make sure to enable Push Notifications, so you'll never miss a new video. All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!

КОМЕНТАРІ: 1 800
@DreamIAS-lc2ul
@DreamIAS-lc2ul Місяць тому
Shehzad rocks...
@user-mh2jp5wn1s
@user-mh2jp5wn1s Місяць тому
🤮
@user-py7qt5le4y
@user-py7qt5le4y Місяць тому
As always
@elborrador333
@elborrador333 Місяць тому
he is among top 3-5 political spokespeople across any party today
@gauravdey4163
@gauravdey4163 Місяць тому
He is Chona wala
@Jvmlpcvr
@Jvmlpcvr Місяць тому
मोदी अपने लिए वीडियो बनाने वालों को 2 लाख रुपए दे रहे हैं मोदी ने लोकतंत्र की हत्या कर दी
@tejaspb24
@tejaspb24 Місяць тому
Only Sai deepak was enough to debate for secularism is alive.
@tanaystudies
@tanaystudies Місяць тому
He'd Be Too Much For Them
@Mr_x957
@Mr_x957 Місяць тому
Machar marne ke liye kamaan kew laye?
@RoniDattaChoudhury
@RoniDattaChoudhury Місяць тому
Ya log sirf dharm ke name pe hi debate kar sakta hai . Kam ke nae per koi debate nehi kar sakta Issliye india ka press index itna kharab hai😡😡
@gyanibaba25
@gyanibaba25 Місяць тому
​@@RoniDattaChoudhurytu baat karna sandeshkhali me development ka
@RoniDattaChoudhury
@RoniDattaChoudhury Місяць тому
@@gyanibaba25 sale jail me chala gaya or bjp ke member jo wrestlers ke protest ke main waja tha o abhi bhi khula ghum raha hai or modi khula ghumkebhi manipur nehi jaraha. Kya andhbhakt hai be tera malik log case huya bolte hai but main jo culprits hai uska kya huya o nehi batata kya
@rajibbiswas1843
@rajibbiswas1843 Місяць тому
Shahzad .... You are too good for man ... All the best for flying career in politics .... India needs Indians like you in national politics
@satishdoddaballapurchandra9558
@satishdoddaballapurchandra9558 Місяць тому
3 comfortable minutes were appropriate for Mr. Shehzad Poonamwala to explain and expose the difference in secularism between Congress and BJP regimes.
@manojsharma5837
@manojsharma5837 Місяць тому
Shehzad and Sheila Rashid are the real winners for me
@bharatdave6288
@bharatdave6288 Місяць тому
Shezad and Ashutosh
@elborrador333
@elborrador333 Місяць тому
@@bharatdave6288Ashutosh is 1st place from the bottom 😂 😂 😂
@striker4072
@striker4072 Місяць тому
only lol 😅😅​@@elborrador333
@jaishks
@jaishks Місяць тому
@@elborrador333womp womp…
@ajitnadgouda6079
@ajitnadgouda6079 Місяць тому
@@bharatdave6288 Andhabhakta...
@ajitnadgouda6079
@ajitnadgouda6079 Місяць тому
According to Ashutosh a Rapist is secular but if someone asks him why did he rape, then the one who questions is communal.
@MrPeaceGuy54
@MrPeaceGuy54 Місяць тому
He never said or implied this, but distortions are all too common these days. This is the consequence of the विकृति that Mr Savarkar's ideology has brought.
@ajitnadgouda6079
@ajitnadgouda6079 Місяць тому
Ashutosh did say like this. While responding to a question he said, in earlier days Hindu Muslim riots even if Muslims killed or raped Hindus, nobody took names, but nowadays media is taking Muslim name. This means if Muslim rapes its ok. He is secular. But if media questions as to why did he rape, then they are communal. According to him even if Muslim does riots, he remains secular, but if media says he was the person who started riots, then media is communal. Understood now??​@@MrPeaceGuy54
@ajitnadgouda6079
@ajitnadgouda6079 Місяць тому
​@@MrPeaceGuy54Savarkar is not विकृत, but the Nehru family labeling him as anti-national and British agent is विकृत. Savarkar was a Hindu, but did not believe in rituals. He faced Kala Pani for 50 years. But still Nehru demeaned him, because Nehru was a Muslim and Sawarkar strongly opposed Muslims, because they killed Hindus. Therefore Nehru family is विकृत and not Sawarkar.
@MrPeaceGuy54
@MrPeaceGuy54 Місяць тому
@@ajitnadgouda6079 That was equally applicable. The media usually used to say that there was violence between two communities, which was done to ensure that people unnecessarily did not develop prejudices towards someone. However, nowadays, the media is quite keen to take the name of some people. You can check how a reputable news agency like ANI shared fake news in its hurry to take the name of a particular person, and the same is true for media outlets like OpIndia. None of this implies that someone doing evil is secular or that they should not be questioned. However, their identity is not one-sided.
@MrPeaceGuy54
@MrPeaceGuy54 Місяць тому
@@ajitnadgouda6079 No, he did not spend 50 years in prison. He was released and confined to Ratnagiri. I do agree that he was once Veer, but the man who came out of prison (do keep in mind that he deliberately chose the path of violence, and there were others who chose to remain instead of writing six mercy petitions) had been corrupted morally and intellectually. His idea of a Hindu is almost entirely political. As an atheist, he obviously found little value in spirituality. All he did was to conveniently link nationality with a particular religion and then claim that there was another nation that had to be compelled to live in the same territory. Dr Ambedkar rightly called his position "illogical" and "dangerous" for the safety and security of India ('Pakistan, or, The Partition of India'). Mr Savarkar's divisive ideology contributed to the partition of India. While he was busy doing things like conspiring to assassinate the Mahatma, asking the Hindus to help the British during the second World War to crush the Quit India movement, people like Mahatma Gandhi and Pandit Nehru were in prison. Both of them willingly gave up lives of comfort and luxury. Mahatma Gandhi risked his own life to save people in Noakhali and Calcutta, and Pandit Nehru did the same in Delhi. However, Mr Savarkar was not there. Mr Savarkar's ideology will cause unimaginable damage to both Bharat and Sanatana Dharma. While people like Mahatma Gandhi and Pandit Nehru fought for the Vedāntic pluralism of Swami Vivekananda, Mr Savarkar did everything he could to undo it. Sadly, our so-called liberal opposition parties have reduced people like Pandit Nehru and Mahatma Gandhi to mere statues. Their ideas have been neglected in favour of appeasement, corruption, and an unending thirst for power. Mrs Gandhi started all of this, and the rot has not been fixed yet. Nevertheless, it remains my conviction that Mr Savarkar is India's (and Hinduism's) most dangerous विकृति. If we don't wake up, then we will pay a heavy price (if people openly praising Mr Godse, a centuries-old place of worship being demolished in Delhi, young children being encouraged to say hateful things, an RPF constable specifically targeting some people, some immoral individuals being garlanded, and a man in Haridwar openly calling for harming others not being punished for years is not enough). This does not mean that we can ignore the other side. Abrahamic religions do need reforms. But we will not do anything meaningful by becoming what we once opposed. Kabir, Maulana Madani (whose descendant recently spoke about the unity of Allah and Om), Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan, Raskhan, and Maulana Azad also existed. May you have a good day!
@bindusingh9722
@bindusingh9722 Місяць тому
I proud of Sahjad Punawala,aapne sequelar ke surmaon ko dho dala.jai Hind.
@Fitsapiens007
@Fitsapiens007 Місяць тому
Thats how all debates should be well managed and no shouting or cross talking.
@indiasane9420
@indiasane9420 Місяць тому
Shehzad Poonawala stole the show !! He has to be the winner.
@ratanbhattacharjee7233
@ratanbhattacharjee7233 Місяць тому
Godi media ki kamai ki tareef karo Jhuth bolke paisa banata hai.
@abrakidabra
@abrakidabra Місяць тому
​@@ratanbhattacharjee7233kaunsa jhoot?
@SrcTrustMeBro
@SrcTrustMeBro Місяць тому
@@ratanbhattacharjee7233tereko G maartha hai raat ko abdul
@Sam-wt7bn
@Sam-wt7bn Місяць тому
​@@ratanbhattacharjee7233bro you are ostrich 😂😂😂
@sarvajanhitaay
@sarvajanhitaay Місяць тому
Shehzad was good in first part. But I think it would have been better to come up with stats to show it is actually secularism is flourishing in India.
@cherry316316
@cherry316316 Місяць тому
Why do they forget about Buddhism, Jainism, Christian, Sikh etc in religion? Only if one community don't get appeasement then secularism is dead
@induchopra3014
@induchopra3014 Місяць тому
Joke. They are minority by choice. They chose partition. They chose to be jihadis where more. They chose to leave. Noone pushed them out. Just having Muslims in every seat is not secularism We want meritocracy. We want equality, no appeasement. Only meritocracy should rule. Hindus are forced to celebrate all festivals. Do muskims celebrate diwali,holi? Thats secularism. Do muslims say they are Indians first? No. Do muskims respect idols? Hindus say Allah. Will they say bhagwan? Noone can claim any rights on basis of religion. That is secularism. Has anyone heard Owaissi ask hindu voters right of his constituency. He only talks of muslims Muslims. Thats communal. He is communal. No hindu demands rights for being hindu
@rajatsingh1375
@rajatsingh1375 Місяць тому
Perfectly said
@sm8315
@sm8315 Місяць тому
India has been designated as the most dangerous place for Christian’s with the mass slaughter of Christians in manipur. Don’t forget how Sikhs are labeled khalistanis
@tarunvarshney
@tarunvarshney Місяць тому
According to Indian constitution, Buddhism, Sikh and Jainism are considered Hindu already.
@pushpeh57
@pushpeh57 Місяць тому
Par buddhist aur jain to hindu hai na
@rahilsanjayjain601
@rahilsanjayjain601 Місяць тому
Shehzaad and sheila killed it with their arguments....❤
@prakashindorkar4255
@prakashindorkar4255 Місяць тому
Shahjad what you said is “ Full of Sense, Meaning and Touches the Heart of entire Masses of our country. At par it’s all an Excellent. Jaihind, Jai-BHARAT 🇮🇳🌺🌺🌺🙏
@user-mz1mm2gk4d
@user-mz1mm2gk4d Місяць тому
The TMC spokesperson should be ashamed of putting allegations against BJP when his party TMC does all that in Bengal !
@aayushhh95
@aayushhh95 Місяць тому
He was the easiest of the lot. All of his points could be proven wrong by simple facts and concepts. He never seemed competent to hold up on his arguments even for a minute
@shubhankarhalder9044
@shubhankarhalder9044 Місяць тому
We ashamed as a bengali
@gauravdey4163
@gauravdey4163 Місяць тому
Bjp should be ashamed for what they are doing in Manipur
@gauravdey4163
@gauravdey4163 Місяць тому
@@shubhankarhalder9044 you should be ashamed for Manipur
@gauravdey4163
@gauravdey4163 Місяць тому
What tmc is doing bjp anti bengali party doing nothing drama
@BESMARTER-il4kn
@BESMARTER-il4kn Місяць тому
WHO IS SHEHZAD??? HE SPEAKS THE TRUTH INDIA ADMIRES HIM, THE AUDIANCE CLAP THEIR HANDS FOR HIM WE ARE SHARING M SHEHZAD'S TESTIMONY WITH EUROPEAN PROFESSORS
@fuse8354
@fuse8354 Місяць тому
National spokesperson of bjp
@BESMARTER-il4kn
@BESMARTER-il4kn Місяць тому
@@fuse8354 THANKS we appreciate his clear and frank account
@user-xp5by3jd9g
@user-xp5by3jd9g Місяць тому
When Bharat is intact and united, we have a Bharat Jodo yatra. Similarly, when Bharat is secular by its nature, some people think it is their duty to make it secular.
@BHALAMAN
@BHALAMAN Місяць тому
When they are in minority they ask for secularism. Majority me aate hi Islamic mulk chahiye. Secularism will be alive till Hindu is in majority.
@ankitkaran_
@ankitkaran_ Місяць тому
Shehzad Poonawala is the best debater❤
@gauravdey4163
@gauravdey4163 Місяць тому
He is choona wala
@SaritaSingh-oy8vp
@SaritaSingh-oy8vp Місяць тому
He has brains
@manzoorahmadlone6552
@manzoorahmadlone6552 Місяць тому
A Stooge
@KB-ci4hg
@KB-ci4hg 27 днів тому
​@@manzoorahmadlone6552behead him or what???
@aniketsharma9388
@aniketsharma9388 Місяць тому
Without lust islam dust 😂😂😂
@aniketsharma9388
@aniketsharma9388 Місяць тому
@@faultlines3399 54 year old Mohammed rap^d 6 year old Ayesha #exmuslim sahil youtube Chanel
@aniketsharma9388
@aniketsharma9388 Місяць тому
@@faultlines3399 6 saal ki bachchi se 🤡🤡🤡 #exmuslim sahil
@jaishks
@jaishks Місяць тому
@@faultlines3399what hard evidence you have that God actually spoke to Muhammad? 😂 flying donkey?
@yourstrulytk12
@yourstrulytk12 Місяць тому
​@@faultlines3399 ?
@nicolasflamel3489
@nicolasflamel3489 Місяць тому
@@faultlines3399 hinduism precedes ram by thousands of years. pisslam started with popat
@malladidattatreya9492
@malladidattatreya9492 Місяць тому
Its a fact that secularism is alive.
@santoshkarekar9357
@santoshkarekar9357 Місяць тому
Wow what a selection of panel members to defend the point secularism is not dying in Bharat 🇮🇳
@PrateekUmrao-dm5dy
@PrateekUmrao-dm5dy Місяць тому
Seculism is dying when temple is pay jajiya kar, secularism is dying because 60 percent no. Those who are IAS but have to get 80% are not IAS. Secularism is dying because some government is giving quota based on religion. Secularism is dying because some party is saying that first right on this country is of the Muslim
@BharathiFromSouth
@BharathiFromSouth Місяць тому
#FreeHinduTemples
@saratsaratchandran3085
@saratsaratchandran3085 Місяць тому
👍👏🏼👏🏼💐‼️
@imanand11
@imanand11 Місяць тому
Which party is saying that? Bro its 2024 not 1947.
@Karthikeyansundar-rl5ym
@Karthikeyansundar-rl5ym Місяць тому
@@imanand11Are you uneducated… Go and at least do a simple google search, it was said by our ex-prime minister Mr. Manmohan Singh..
@imanand11
@imanand11 Місяць тому
@@Karthikeyansundar-rl5ym I dont edorse quota in religion and caste... The current form of Wuota itself is injustice.
@rajv9921
@rajv9921 Місяць тому
Secularism had died in India, when Congress brought in WAQF board act. Secularism had died in the country when to allow a procession doesnt let durga puja to be conducted. Secularism had died in the country when the country allow Rohingya refugees in the country and use them as vote banks. Secularism had died in the country when Bangladeshi muslims are allowed to settle in country and use them as vote banks.
@Zakir-Raza
@Zakir-Raza Місяць тому
What About So called RSS which is terrorist organisation!!!
@Zakir-Raza
@Zakir-Raza Місяць тому
What about your so called RSS that is terrorist organisation ...
@user-bb4qt8xo4u
@user-bb4qt8xo4u Місяць тому
Thanks Sure,🙏🙇 Fir your Super Comment. 🙏🙏 ❤🇮🇳🇮🇳🚩" OUR NATION'S DEVELOPMENT, & SAFETY & SECURITY, IS OUR EACH CITIZEN'S FIRST PRIORITY, FIR OUR FUTURE YOUNGER CHILDREN'S LIFE PROSPERITY. 🙏🙏❤🇮🇳🇮🇳" OUR NATION FIRST☝
@t.sudarsanpatro4883
@t.sudarsanpatro4883 Місяць тому
I agree.
@supermanku2852
@supermanku2852 Місяць тому
I agree
@kprajendran-oz9bc
@kprajendran-oz9bc Місяць тому
Earlier the "appeasement secularism" ends, the better. Let equality prevail
@venkatavendidandi207
@venkatavendidandi207 Місяць тому
"Is Bharath Maatha Ki Jai" is unsecular? What type of mentality is this?
@ashokbraroo8845
@ashokbraroo8845 Місяць тому
M. Hindu virodhi mansikta is ur secularism. Congress gives 100crores /200cr to church and mosques and taxes temples with 10%tax is ur secularism. Shame on all of you. ❤
@induchopra3014
@induchopra3014 Місяць тому
Temple money Temple gold is nations wealth. Taken by govt. Used for all citizens. But masjid money is not for all. Which govt has touched it. Which govt has taken money from masjids? How much money comes from church? How much money comes from gurdwara?
@mayankindian3750
@mayankindian3750 Місяць тому
​@@induchopra3014 to church or masjid ko kyu de rahe hai 😡🤬😠 baap ka maal hai
@devendrapandey6047
@devendrapandey6047 Місяць тому
Shehzad bhai is on fire, as always.
@bharatdave6288
@bharatdave6288 Місяць тому
He is always logical
@rahulpathania8846
@rahulpathania8846 Місяць тому
Missing Sai Deepak 😂😂😂😂😂
@vgkashyap6680
@vgkashyap6680 Місяць тому
What is secularism in INDIA ? A secular is such a citizen who openly barks against the Hinduism and comment about the Hindu culture , unfollows the Hindu tradition and finally say Hindu laws are unrealistic 😊 and in spite of being non prosecuted for unwarranted talks, concludes there is no secularism in the country …
@nationalistsanghi5897
@nationalistsanghi5897 Місяць тому
Tax imposed on temple but not on mosque and churches , temple adminstered by state but mosque and church not....is is secularism? In which secular country WAQF ACT , minority commision used to he happen...minority reservation is the identity of secular state?
@Avant-garde1611
@Avant-garde1611 Місяць тому
Utopian genre of secularism goinn on..still some complaining about it
@Biztalkcontrolcenter
@Biztalkcontrolcenter Місяць тому
C🎉🎉perfect
@thiruvetti
@thiruvetti Місяць тому
Their only reply will be Brahmin patriarchy or Andhbhakt and running away. No Liberandu will have answers to your slapping questions.
@unknown00808
@unknown00808 Місяць тому
Did u ever see PM inaugurate mosque or church, but he did for ram madir , so securlism don't apply there
@yourstrulytk12
@yourstrulytk12 Місяць тому
​@@unknown00808 I don't know... Is a non Muslim allowed to inaugurate a mosque? (Curious. Not trying to prove a point.)
@DreamIAS-lc2ul
@DreamIAS-lc2ul Місяць тому
Now I perfectly came to know that..nationalist or proud hindu people are more educated and speak on fact rather these leftist or sickular....there is no logic no fact in ashutosh , riju arguments.....now we more convinced that bjp is doing much better for this country and now the true philosophy of secularism is realizing in India...
@arthuranydonuts923
@arthuranydonuts923 Місяць тому
LeLis can't debate, they can only say Andhbhakt when someone calls them out and feel proud of their stupidity.
@Avant-garde1611
@Avant-garde1611 Місяць тому
Truly 💯
@gauravdey4163
@gauravdey4163 Місяць тому
We don't need this we have our bengali nationalism
@mayankjhunjhunwala2625
@mayankjhunjhunwala2625 Місяць тому
​@@gauravdey4163😂
@mmsdesigners8463
@mmsdesigners8463 Місяць тому
Then Brother say Abki bar 400 par 😊🔥
@straightpoint6419
@straightpoint6419 Місяць тому
Even Seila Rashid is supporter of Modi present, what do you need in the name od secularism?
@asutosh413
@asutosh413 Місяць тому
Bengal is the most communal place in India today .
@atokimruk937
@atokimruk937 Місяць тому
Bengal = Bhikaris
@cosmoshercules8436
@cosmoshercules8436 Місяць тому
There's one more state in the South.
@gauravdey4163
@gauravdey4163 Місяць тому
@@atokimruk937 up bihar cow belts is bimaru bikhari producing population
@niceboy9806
@niceboy9806 Місяць тому
@@gauravdey4163 did Momtaz bano kept her ROZA today?
@gyanibaba25
@gyanibaba25 Місяць тому
​@@gauravdey4163look at the U.P where bjp is ruling specialy the great monk...and Bihar is not a cow belt it is totally controlled by lallua corrupt and mullas
@shails98
@shails98 Місяць тому
It is because of Hindus that we can talk about secularism in India otherwise which other religion allows this much liberty.
@shubhankarhalder9044
@shubhankarhalder9044 Місяць тому
My dirty mind thoughts about 57 Muslim countries and their secularism 🤣🤣🤣
@MohdRiyaz-wp7us
@MohdRiyaz-wp7us Місяць тому
I thought it was the constitution of India..
@funfactz5605
@funfactz5605 Місяць тому
​@@MohdRiyaz-wp7usDo you know the history of constitution? You think Muslims were allowed in India after partition because of constitution?You think Pakistan was formed because of constitution? Are you delusional?
@MohdRiyaz-wp7us
@MohdRiyaz-wp7us Місяць тому
@@funfactz5605 Bro chill..I was just talking about this debate..
@ps93747
@ps93747 Місяць тому
​@@MohdRiyaz-wp7usconvert detected opinion rejected!
@madhusudanarao5252
@madhusudanarao5252 Місяць тому
The title (Secularism is dying in India) itself is prejudicial. How can they form that opinion before beginning of the debate? Who are they to decide that the Secularism is dying? The title should be 'Status of Secularism India'
@nepurohit8951
@nepurohit8951 Місяць тому
जय 🙏श्रीराम
@nationalistsanghi5897
@nationalistsanghi5897 Місяць тому
इस debate को shehzad, शेहला rasheed ने जीत लिया...fact और logic पर बात रखी...जबकि कोंग्रेसी ने सिर्फ bla बला कुछ भी...
@sumantkumar7079
@sumantkumar7079 Місяць тому
ticket chahiye 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@ss74blr
@ss74blr Місяць тому
Shehla Rashid? Read her tweets on Mother Sita and Lord Rama! It is beyond disgusting comments that she made. Now for political ambitions she is acting secular! The snake!
@mmsdesigners8463
@mmsdesigners8463 Місяць тому
I'm totally agree with you 👍
@rahooblack
@rahooblack Місяць тому
​@@sumantkumar7079Haan, de
@user-mz1mm2gk4d
@user-mz1mm2gk4d Місяць тому
This Ashutosh guy is a big joke. There is something terribly wrong with his thought process that he thinks everything is wrong. He generalises events perpetrated by small fringe elements and this is very dangerous.
@pichumanisankar2617
@pichumanisankar2617 Місяць тому
He is extremely prejudiced and always on an one way street and this speaks volumes for his cussed attitude and we can hardly call him a political analyst.
@chanakyabharat756
@chanakyabharat756 Місяць тому
There are crores of such people😂😂
@riteshattam620
@riteshattam620 Місяць тому
😂😂
@rajaramakutty9088
@rajaramakutty9088 Місяць тому
Even Delhi mayor Kejriwal couldn't stand Ashutosh, kicked him out of AAP😂😂
@VK-md7jm
@VK-md7jm Місяць тому
@@chanakyabharat756 Spot on. Those who are sleeping need to be woken up. They most likely suffer from inferiority mindset. They will never answer: If Hindus are no more a majority, will India still be secular??? They need to answer: There are 57 muslim countries that follow Islamic laws, there is 1 country for Jews, there are 117 countries that lean Christian. Hindus have NONE. Why????
@sunithaacharya4340
@sunithaacharya4340 Місяць тому
Ashutosh should speak about the atrocities perpetrated on Hindu women by a certain Shah Jahan and how the secular TMC defended him. This is secularism for Ashutosh.
@user-le3ir7dv4v
@user-le3ir7dv4v Місяць тому
2014 से पहले सेक्यूलरिज्म का मतलब था मुसलमानों का तुष्टीकरण,उसको देश के संसाधनों पर पहला हकदार मानना...2014 के बाद सेक्यूलरिज्म का मतलब देश के संसाधनों, सरकार की योजनाओं पर हिंदूओं,मुसलमानों,सिक्खों,ईसाईयों,पारशियों सबका बराबर हक...अर्थात सबका संतुष्टीकरण जय रामजी
@nagendarbabu111
@nagendarbabu111 Місяць тому
Why don't the Ashutosh and company discuss Kashmir , Kerala, Bengal killings
@rathivarma9649
@rathivarma9649 Місяць тому
They won’t , because they cannot face truth, the bitter truth. The film Kerala story and Kashmir files threw some light on the peaceful community activities in these states. 3 or 300 doesn’t make much difference ,when innocents become victims of treachery . Only the parents of victim dies , but for the doers it is Jihad in the name of religion. Shama Muhammed though being from Kerala fails to see eye to eye , because religion comes first for them and not innocent girls cheated and thrown into gutter.
@vishnushabaraya2489
@vishnushabaraya2489 Місяць тому
Secularism is dying only for india today
@atulkumar-pr4yo
@atulkumar-pr4yo Місяць тому
What is secularism? Will u please define?😂
@EvolveYourBrain
@EvolveYourBrain Місяць тому
If secularism is dying it’s only because the tolerant are tired of appeasement of the intolerants.
@gyanibaba25
@gyanibaba25 Місяць тому
​@@atulkumar-pr4yosecularism is majority ko chutiya bnao
@palaksdarji
@palaksdarji Місяць тому
Sahi kaha bhai, Rahul doesn't seem to be very happy with the result. 😂😂
@anantnarayan7070
@anantnarayan7070 Місяць тому
India was ruled by Muslim invaders for more than 500 plus years. The Cristian invaders for more than 200 years. was the secularism not dying/dead then? We had one party Congress rule after independence for nearly 50 plus years. Was Dictator/autocratic rule was never felt then? the most misunderstood word is secularism and only request the speakers to define Secularism.
@boringlife7745
@boringlife7745 Місяць тому
Why only India was forced to become secular?
@dharamwwe
@dharamwwe Місяць тому
Shahzad is one of the finest speakers and staunch nationalist
@ddb0831
@ddb0831 Місяць тому
👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏
@arungokulvs
@arungokulvs Місяць тому
Shehla, Shehzad & Sengupta totally decimated the "Secularism is dying gang".
@dantalasubhash8019
@dantalasubhash8019 Місяць тому
Secularism is not dying anyway.Only pseudo secularism is dying because nowadays common people are awakened and thinking in a good direction and moving in the society for the development and maintaining good relation among the people irrespective of caste and religion.
@nabaneetasinha2863
@nabaneetasinha2863 Місяць тому
For Riju Datta…my question is Why Mamata Banerjee inaugarates no of Durga Puja pandals during Durga puja…
@qf8822
@qf8822 Місяць тому
The word Secularism should be removed from constitution by Members of Parliament
@ashishdhiwar6226
@ashishdhiwar6226 Місяць тому
why
@k45rt789jh
@k45rt789jh Місяць тому
Why not
@ashishdhiwar6226
@ashishdhiwar6226 Місяць тому
@@k45rt789jh he should answer first as he wants to remove something that is already included in constitution. So.. why remove the word secularism? You want the nation to include only one religion?
@raghvendrasingh9675
@raghvendrasingh9675 Місяць тому
@@ashishdhiwar6226 'secular' term was not present in Original Constitution. It was added during Emergency by 42nd CAA. Similar is the word "socialist'. These are token terms for appeasement, nothing else. If you read Fundamental Rights, DPSPs - you will realize our Constitution already has the essence of being secular and socialist. Also, Originally, certain segments of Constitutional provisions were meant for that purpose -- that too socialist tendencies were in DPSPs, left to govt to implement when appropriate. Forcefully putting them in Preamble is a desperate vote catching attempt. The illusion these terms have created is astounding. Numerous Religion-specific laws have been created and their existence justified by holding these terms to ransom. Wakf Act, Places of Worship Act, Muslim Personal Law and so on. Today distortion has exceeded so much that 'secularism' is loosely translated as of Muslim nature, due to un-counted appeasements.
@prasanna3378
@prasanna3378 Місяць тому
​@@raghvendrasingh9675 *Denounce the "infallibility" of ALL Scriptures, necessarily including Quran and Bible, and GuruGranth, Tripitak, Smritis, and everything else, and be real Secular.* *Liberalism : "It pays to keep an open mind, but not so open that your brain falls off." -Carl Sagan* *Even those who believe in GodS are just fine, but those who believe in Books are Dangerous.* *Speak up about Islam. If Liberals addressed Religion of Terror then this day wouldn't had come. Follow Ex-Muslim movement.* *There's no "First Human" in the path of Evolution, ever.* *No Adam, no Noah, no Manu ever existed.* *All Creation stories are false.* *All Religions are false. All Prophets are Frauds.* *All Book bound Religions are false. All books have been disproved by Science.* *Science is the ONLY Truth we Know.* *Follow only Science and Humanism.* *Forget all religious teachings. They're false, all of them.* *"It's called Faith cause it's not Knowledge."* *-Christopher Hitchens* *"There's ONLY one World. The Natural World. And no Super-Natural."* *-Sean Carroll, Poetic Naturalism* *Stay away from Naxal Fraud-Ambedkarite fraud-Islamo-Buddhists Conversion Racket. **#BandeMataram* *These poor people, who are so fond of religion, they don't understand that it's the religion, the very religion they're defending, it's that religion that kills people.* *All Humanists are friends of all humanists. Sanatani, Sikh, Christian, Musalman these all are hoax. All these religions and religious identities are fabricated. Find the human in you, and in the other person, even if it's Kaffir or Musalman.* *Leave Religion, accept Humanism. Don't be a Musalman, be a Human.*
@Mrbombastic614
@Mrbombastic614 Місяць тому
Bro Sai Deepak and Ranganath sir would have demolished tmc and Ashutosh
@chanakyabharat756
@chanakyabharat756 Місяць тому
Sai ok but Ranganath is bluff
@ss74blr
@ss74blr Місяць тому
Why shoot a brahmastra on a sparrow?
@rajkumarkaul8028
@rajkumarkaul8028 Місяць тому
Captains for the finals😅
@jayaduttabhoumik784
@jayaduttabhoumik784 28 днів тому
​@@chanakyabharat756 How is he a bluff, please elaborate...🤔🤔
@prem2179
@prem2179 Місяць тому
Mr BLIND Ashutosh.. Junior Pappu.. .. cant you see the same done with Hindus??!!!!
@user-bb4qt8xo4u
@user-bb4qt8xo4u Місяць тому
THANKS,🙏🙇TO, " INDIA TODAY CONCLAVE " FOR GIVING SUCH A GREAT DEBATE . ❤❤ 🇮🇳🇮🇳🐯🦁🇮🇳🇮🇳🕉🕉🚩🚩" OUR SANATANI NATION'S, DEVELOPMENT, & SAFETY & SECURITY " IS OUR FIRST PRIORITY ,& OUR EACH CITIZEN'S FIRST RESPONSIBILITY, FOR OUR FUTURE YOUNGER CHILDREN'S LIFE PROSPERITY. " SANATANI HINDU RASHTRA ( BHARAT ) IS THE ONLY ONE COUNTRY , " SAVE OUR HINDU RASHTRA , FROM " TERRORIST " & MAFIA'S ,. " THIS IS MY REQUEST🙏😊 TO, , ALL " PATRIOTIC " CITIZEN'S OF " BHARAT." ( INDIA )🇮🇳❤🇮🇳🙏
@nandakishore2497
@nandakishore2497 Місяць тому
So many Rahuls are in Support for Secularism😂😂😂😂
@Sahilk503
@Sahilk503 Місяць тому
All Opposition Debater Vs Shehjad. Shehjad just Nailed everyone.
@manzoorahmadlone6552
@manzoorahmadlone6552 Місяць тому
It is not about a good or a bad debate .It is about fluency of the language one speaks and the political hypocracy
@siddharthanvarier3342
@siddharthanvarier3342 19 днів тому
Secularism is not just about providing lawful succour to victims, but goes far, far ahead of GUARANTEEING secularism to each and every Indian, irrespective of their religious affinities The Rock of Gibraltor could be nudged but never DISLODGED
@sarvajanhitaay
@sarvajanhitaay Місяць тому
15:18 it is true Godse was a patriot. Nobody can raise question about that. And he wasn't a terrorist but at max a murderer.
@M.k_khan
@M.k_khan 20 днів тому
Godse was a terrorist. This is known to Everyone, nothing new.
@tollirengen8493
@tollirengen8493 26 днів тому
Not to forget!..secularism in fact not dying in INDIA which means still the citizens of India wants to remains the same democracy ideology...So no one or no political party members can change the constitution of India by the undemocratic and unreligious ideologies.As far as the majority votes of secularism is concerns as in the debates show at the conclave,we are proud to be Indians always. Long live secularism INDIA!!...🎉🎉 0:56
@anuragdixit7
@anuragdixit7 Місяць тому
I am very impressed by sehzad's body language,every time when other guest came he stood showing respect or even after they debated,these small gestures shows his hardwork and how much these small manners are imbibed in his personality.😊
@gkshorts8690
@gkshorts8690 Місяць тому
Shehzad ko sunne ke liye aaya tha main
@sreeramtirumala8076
@sreeramtirumala8076 Місяць тому
My question to congress debator. entire parliaments of World have prayers of Sanatan Dharm books whether it's US,uk Germany, middle East, Australia....
@shikharsarswat1609
@shikharsarswat1609 Місяць тому
Shehla Rashid shora ,always loved to listen her whether this side of that ! I wonder how she has been disappeared from National politics aura
@user-vg9ml3ug1g
@user-vg9ml3ug1g Місяць тому
I blame Nehru for today's situation.... What we are as a hindu🕉️
@KSH132
@KSH132 Місяць тому
Secularism is not dying but definitely muslim appeasement nd vote bank politics dying
@user-bu1ih3vn5y
@user-bu1ih3vn5y Місяць тому
Sai deepak supposed to be there ,, then you would know this term Secularism invented from where and inserted in india,, this is word used by church
@Avant-garde1611
@Avant-garde1611 Місяць тому
Yupp he would have raised the bar of this debate really highh
@krishna3311
@krishna3311 Місяць тому
I think before that debate it should have been defined as to what is secularism. Does secularism mean all relgions are equal or is it that some of them should be given special status because the people who follow are considered backward? Is not giving special status based on religion against the very concept of secularism? How can some religions be granted special status over the majority religion? The parties who have done that have actually redefined secularism in their own way and have actually strayed away from the path of secularism......
@KNBasu
@KNBasu 3 дні тому
Whereas any Government's achievements must be highlighted, their failures must also be discussed and questioned. Governments are elected by people and they are accountable. Governments must not bulldoze, rather find consensus in decision making. The mainstream media is not questioning the government for their failures and instead questioning the opposition who have already been ousted by the electorate for their misdeeds. That's the irony.
@devopriyomukerjee7892
@devopriyomukerjee7892 Місяць тому
Hindol and Shehzad by far the best debaters by a long distance…congress spokesperson needs a lot of practice.
@ankushyadav6814
@ankushyadav6814 Місяць тому
It's not about good or bad debaters when you don't have anything truth to say.
@Sahilk503
@Sahilk503 Місяць тому
Shehjad and Shehla has won the Debate. Opposition has not a single good debater.
@karthikb5
@karthikb5 Місяць тому
Good debate. Kudos to all participants
@saratsaratchandran3085
@saratsaratchandran3085 Місяць тому
Secularism was truly never there even when they expediently inserted the word in the constitution. Even today the Governments are involved in running the temples Haj pilgrimage Kumbhamela etc! So the debate is a lead balloon! But Bharat was always pleural and will remain so, so long the Dharmic population remains as majority!
@rachurisuresh1014
@rachurisuresh1014 Місяць тому
If u think secularism is dying ,this debate will not occur
@vasudevantk3433
@vasudevantk3433 Місяць тому
Wow Shehzad wow👍🏻👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
@nits143cal
@nits143cal Місяць тому
they are complaining because the govt is doing its job & their power & grip over their people is dying...divide & rule not working anymore...no more empty words we want action
@designernidhi132
@designernidhi132 Місяць тому
Bjp ko log muslim virodhi khte h or bjp ke liye 2 muslim hi khade h jo usko is debate me support kr rhe h yhi h sbka sath sabka vikash sbka viswas
@smiritigoswamiclass-5.398
@smiritigoswamiclass-5.398 Місяць тому
We are always with neutral and intellectual media.❤😂🎉.
@tusharparikh4322
@tusharparikh4322 Місяць тому
Great job Ponawala! Thank you from bottom of my heart to clarify what Secularism really means; it is not the appeasement but equal opportunities for every one.
@swastideep207
@swastideep207 Місяць тому
sehzad wins the days thats it
@viveksinghal8149
@viveksinghal8149 Місяць тому
It was the fascinating debate result of the debate reflects the mood of the Nation
@vyasakaveendra7510
@vyasakaveendra7510 Місяць тому
Poonawala stole the show. Asserting truth.
@shubhanag
@shubhanag Місяць тому
Yay!! shehzaaad!!!!❤
@jaip8442
@jaip8442 Місяць тому
Exactly
@dashavanchikkagudda4192
@dashavanchikkagudda4192 Місяць тому
Poonawalla beautiful speak
@mashah57
@mashah57 Місяць тому
Should have 2 rounds of voting one before and one after the debate, to analyse as to who influenced the audience to change the opinion.
@shubhamchavhan444
@shubhamchavhan444 Місяць тому
आनंद रंगनाथन Sir को बहुत miss किया। ओ होते तो मजा आ जाता 🎉🎉
@PhotonShower
@PhotonShower Місяць тому
Shama.mohammmed..lol..she was thrashed in kerala by congress itself..she asked why women are thrashed in congress and the openly said she is a nobody in congress..hahahah
@ritwijayushmaan1834
@ritwijayushmaan1834 Місяць тому
Bravo! India Today is certainly setting standards for debate.
@paramjitsinghb1
@paramjitsinghb1 Місяць тому
Having a debate on the subject itself highlights if it's dying or already dead.
@manvisingh5598
@manvisingh5598 Місяць тому
Shocking is Sheila Rashid speaking in favour of secularism is not dying in India.
@VedicKausik
@VedicKausik Місяць тому
Debate is the culture of Bharat, thanks for organizing it.
@urmilladevikumar4716
@urmilladevikumar4716 Місяць тому
Shama is taking out her personal anger😅😅😅😅😅
@SuperUhdam
@SuperUhdam Місяць тому
When secularism is spoken about we think , politics and religion. We should include business. So the definition of secularism revolves around three pillars: religion, politics and business 😊
@RamachandraMaruth
@RamachandraMaruth Місяць тому
Excellent Debate! So well structured
@mukulpal8875
@mukulpal8875 Місяць тому
Hinduism is polytheistic-pluralistic -religion ,culture and civilization from 1000s of years we have given refuge to Parsi ,Shia Muslim ,jew ,polish christian and many more and defeated two intolerant and hateful bullies and colonizer's and we still remain Hindu rastra.
@mayankindian3750
@mayankindian3750 Місяць тому
Yes 💪✊😌🥰🇮🇳✊❤️🕉️
@JainShalinee-om4fn
@JainShalinee-om4fn Місяць тому
Shehzad wow wow just wow👏👏
@lalithasatish8344
@lalithasatish8344 Місяць тому
What did the governments before Modi did to minorities…? Did they encourage them in getting education and jobs …? During their 70 years of rule….if yes now the question would not arise….the rulers wanted to keep all the problems connected with majority and minority to encash those problems during elections…..for example ram mandir issue….why the rulers of that time did not think of solving these problems….so one cannot brag themselves just by siding with minority in only in words and not in actions…..what my sincere feeling is …religion should be confined only to inside of one’s house….once ur out of the house no religion only nationalism which takes forward our country
@SoniSingh-fl8cf
@SoniSingh-fl8cf Місяць тому
Jai Shree Ram 🙏🙏 Jai Jai Shree Ram 🙏🙏
@siddharthanvarier3342
@siddharthanvarier3342 19 днів тому
Before getting into the nitty-gritty of the topic, it is needed to understand it in its right perspective. Secularism is very much ALIVE and KICKING in this country. SHOULD THE INDIA ALLIANCE COME BACK TO POWER, this would be reinforced into its FULL POTENTIAL
@deepeshsao1008
@deepeshsao1008 Місяць тому
You can clearly see the difference as to who is reading from the paper who has the intellectual badwidth to speak up his/her mind. Shshzad did as no one else. 👏
@tusharparikh4322
@tusharparikh4322 Місяць тому
What do they say about Sar Tan Se Juda?
@atokimruk937
@atokimruk937 Місяць тому
That is very secular
@sachindubey788
@sachindubey788 Місяць тому
The worrying fact is these liberals speakers made the debate about Muslim vs Hindu ( left all other religions) rather than talking abt secularism as whole. There are crimes against Hindu and other communities too but they neglected it.
@p.haring-das3520
@p.haring-das3520 28 днів тому
Secularism was one sided before 2014 now all religions and Indian learned to live together in harmony, maybe under the strong governance.
Eurovision Song Contest 2024: First Semi-Final (Live Stream) | Malmö 2024 🇸🇪
2:23:45
Kitten has a slime in her diaper?! 🙀 #cat #kitten #cute
00:28
Eurovision Song Contest 2024: First Semi-Final (Live Stream) | Malmö 2024 🇸🇪
2:23:45