Hey all! If you haven’t seen my community post, I plan on doing a MASSIVE 31 SKIN GIVEAWAY, if I get 50k subs by Nov 25!!! Let’s make it happen

In the defence of Surge His upgrading mechanic is really unique enough to be legendary. He is the only one to do this after all. Lou should have been a legendary, but he is so unpopular that mythic make him a bit more enticing because it is easier to get.

leon should be legendary

Belle as legendary got me really confused

Belle: I can mark people with my super! R-T: I can do it with my main attack! Supercell: I don’t see a problem here

Idk about the other cromatics but surge and cordelious should be legendary..they both have special abilities surge have different stages and cordelious has his own different world (realm)

Gale should be a super rare, Lou is good as a epic, Belle is just made for that red background, and if Amber can be a legendary, then so can R-T.

Can we just appreciate that he changed the brawlers name's color to match the rarity, and random when he didnt reveal it yet.

fun fact: if Surge was released as a legendary, this would mean we would have 2 legendaries in less than 3 months (surge season 2 and Amber on season 3)

I feel like this creates an imbalance between the rarities with these changes, because now there will be significantly more epics and Mythics.

What was bro smoking thinking belle should be a legendary

Surge as a legendary is right, a mechanic every time you use the super, you get a new mechanic that makes you stronger, which makes complete sense to be legendary mainly because it is an extremely unique mechanic, Belle doesn't have much alone it has the form of damage and the super is very basic, Lou is ok, due to the freezing mechanic but many other brawlers have this mechanic, while Surge has an extremely unique and creative mechanic, he really deserved to be a legendary

"Belle's marking mechanic is super unique so she deserves legendary "R-t should be mythic" Logik

Ash is so unique in my opinion, I have no idea why he has the same rarity as Pearl, Gale and Maisie which have basic mechanics. The same goes for Sam.

I think Frank mentioned in a post one time that Legendaries aren't determined by how "unique" they are, the most unique brawlers are of the Epic and Mythic Tier, but of how challenging they can be against new players who start the game.

As a surge main, i think he is at the right place with rarity

I heavily disagree with Surge, Belle and Lou placements. Surge is one of the most unique brawlers in the game, while lots of brawlers have different stances and modes that almost make them completely different characters (Sam, Meg, Bonnie, R-T) Surge is the only character that upgrades his own abilities and the way you play changes with each one of them. The more upgrades you have, the better you perform, but also it gets riskier since you may lose it all in one death. His super, aside from this upgrading, also doubles as a mobility and assassination tool. As much as Surge sucks in the meta rn, he's undoubtedly one of the most unique chromatics. Lou, on the other hand, is just average. His super is pretty gimmicky and is definitely the ultimate control tool, but it's only unique tool is the ice sliding and that's just enough to be a mythic. His brain freeze mechanic is cool too, but it's just a stun, a lot of brawlers can stun without a meter, and if Ash, who also has a unique meter with properties, is an epic, then Lou isn't legendary material, not even close. Belle is one of the most epic-tier brawlers in my opinion, I'd have to twist my whole view of reality to see her as legendary. Her bouncy attack is ripped straight out from Jessie, who can also hit many times with her attack, and her super is just a defense debuff, a permanent one! But R-T can do pretty much the same thing in a support-y way and he's mythic. She's just that, a sniper with a little gimmick, the same as Piper, Bea and Mandy, and they're all epic.

surge legendary all the way ! most iconic chromatic out there

Spike has a mastery title called “one of a kind” I think that is why when you always said ‘one of a kind’, a Spike pin came out 😂

If cordelious isn’t a legendary then something ain’t right

Ive seen a redditor say belle should be super rare, and i agree, she's so basic

I still think they should have done a community post before they hand picked the rarities by themselves, since if the community said surge should be a legendary no one would be mad since they voted that, but since we got this out of nowhere it's definitely going to raise some eye brows.

I am so happy that i am not the only one who thinks that sam should be a legendary, he is my favorite tank, he is so many cool features and i love it

This is a good list although i think the brawlers you chose to be legendary you based all on how different their mechanics are, and i think that legendaries aren’t only about how different their mechanics are, but also about how fun they are, when i look at the ledendaries, they really have creative mechanics, but they are the funniest characters in the game overall, for example, spike is pretty simple, he shots a ball that splits, and creates a slow area in his super, it is simple as an epic brawlers, but it is so fun to play that he is a legendary, and lou and sam really are different, but most players don’t like to play then THAT much. Surge has a quite mythic complexity, but he is so fun to play that he feels like a legendary. And belle, for me, has nothing to do with the legendary rarity, you use her main attack as a normal sniper shot, and you just you use her super on the one enemy w the highest health

I’ll be honest the reason why I would agree with supercell more on this is because there basing it more on the brawlers power than uniqueness and either way most brawlers blend together like belles and rts mark, Otis and Cornelius silence so i makes sense to lower down some people’s rarity raise others

When i saw Cordy I thought "Damn Supercell really giving us that really cool brawler and it's not even legendary?!?" Cordelius honestly deserves the legendary status more than actual legendaries such as Amber

Lou should be legendary

You forgot to mention the fact that if two cordelius-es bring two people, each in the shadow realm in the same time, they can see each other there. It’s a super cool underrated mechanic of his!!

I wish they let the community vote for what the rarity should be. They could have asked for the 2 that they think should be legendary and then picked the 2 most popular voted ones and then did that for the other rarities.

I'm a Buster main and I think Epic is just fine for him, I mean his super is just a shield.

Im a Sam main and I actually think that Sam should be mythic rather than an epic as he is unique and also red background suits him

We need more super rares

I was waiting for someone to finally say sam should be legendary because thats how it should be!

Colette's super is very unique and her percentage attacks are very cool. She provides a new playstyle, and is heavily underrated for new players.

I commented this on a 2 months old video about "The chromatics problem": ,,I think they will buff the Star Road system and put the Chromatic brawlers in diffrent rarities. My prediction: GALE: Epic SURGE: Mythic COLETTE: Epic LOU: Mythic COLONEL RUFFS: Mythic BELLE: Mythic BUZZ: Epic ASH: Epic LOLA: Mythic FANG: Epic EVE: Epic JANET: Legendary OTIS: Mythic SAM: Epic BUSTER: Epic MANDY: Epic R-T: Mythic MAISIE: Epic CORDELIUS: Legendary PEARL: Epic Yes Janet and Cordelius aren't that strong now bu their mechanics are unique compared to the others so with a little buff/rework they would deserve the Legendary Rarity." CHARLIE wasn't announced and PEARL season just started. Tbh I was convinced CHARLIE will be a Mythic anyway.

Are we all gonna talk about all the snipes Jimbo had with Mandy. Even tho they were bots it was still cool

0:55 anyone saw him playing against emotional damage?! (maybe Lex???)

I honestly feel like Collette should’ve been mythic because her attack is just SO unique-there’s no other brawler that does damage like that

Ngl i think edgar should be epic. Also: why did no one wish that jimbo will never hate on mortis?😭

Yes Leon should be obisiouly legendary,I remember buying his brawl pass and getting his tier 70 skin! Best chromatic.

In my opinion, mythic rarity is pretty suitable for Buster. He is a ranged tank, he has a unique Super trait, a completely broken Gadget and a pretty unique Super.

I suppose that after the chromatic rarity getting removed,the ppl who got an epic brawl pass (epic brawl pass means the chromatic brawlers that are goona be epic) they spent 169 which is the cost of epic brawlers while who got mythic brawl pass they spent 169 while the mythic rarity cost 349 for each brawler, means they got free 180 gems (349-169) and who got Surge or Cordelious they spent 169 aswell, so free 530 gems (699-169),that means for example: i got Maisie and spent 169 gems which is great because i got free skin with pins and free 925 credits while mythic ones has free 180 gems + free skin with cosmetics and 1900 credits, for the legendary brawl passes ( Surge and Corde.) they got free 530 gems as well as skin and cosmetics which kinda unfair like i if i knew that this is gonna happen i would've bought Cordelious or a mythic brawl pass. you gonna say: "well, you can get it by chroma creadits before 2024",which is true but this is the last brawl pass that give 500 chroma creadits and since they'll be 12 brawlers per year its impossible. if i knew i would've picked the legendaries first then all mythics then choose epics from most fun to least fun however, i lack of 2 mythics which i really could've picked them first plus there's others who lack 2 to 6 mythics and its extreamly hard to get them, it needs time and patience. its unfair

Honestly, i am tired of how many there are legendaries (and you multiplied their amount by 2), epic and mythic. Rare and super rare are the smallest rarities. Like, in BS legendaries more than rares. That's why i was so happy when they added Gas, not because i could faster obtain new brawlers, but because it will be more accessible for new players

still dont get why R-T cant hover over water in his super form😭

Y’all, use you chroma credits on the brawlers that will become mythic or legendary. Little boost in progression lol.

There is only 2 thing i dont understand why Lou=Understandeble Surge=Idk but ok But BELLE a LEGENDARY!!? The mark only causes the opponent to receive more damage,and the basic attack is literally Jessie's one but slower and can hit more than 1 time Sam, i just see him kinda basic, rosa+primo atack, the super could make him a mithyc but a ¡¿legendary!? NO HATE

honestly pretty good takes but i think that surge deserves legendary i might be biased because i love playing surge but like chester got legendary bc he can change his attack and super, surge also has the ability to change his attack, and move speed, and his attack changes much more than chesters also ruffs should be leg, ruffs is so unique hes a jack of all trades kinda character with an extra unique edge that makes him viable everywhere honestly i rarely play ruffs but hes just so cool i automatically respect the ruffs title

I totally agree with sam ! I think he‘s very unique and cool!

The spike be like:THATS MY TITLE!! Then the spike:I give up😓

Belle should be superrare bruh such a boring brawler

Perhaps when the chromatic rarities are removed, the developers will make a balance change and there will change the powers of the former chromatic characters and some will become worthy of being legendary and some will worsen

Tap sometimes on the star park(on the desk) after taping on camera to get some hidden footage... It also confirms the boy is leon

I think otis and charlie should also be legendaries cuz the mute ability is one of the strongest abilities in the game right now.

Nahh I think ash should be a mythic, and surge a legendary, just too many things going on with surge, split attack, upgrade as you mentioned, and he can jump up into the air and over walls giving a short span of invincibility, but I guess we’ll just have to see in the future.

As a Fang main, I would like to say that he is fit to be a mythic, if not a legendary. Hear me out. Like you mentioned, he can throw his shoe if he misses, and that shoe charges his super the SAME AMOUNT as his regular attack. Secondly, he has an extremely unique super with chaining and teamwiping abilities. It can chain onto upto 4 targets and does absurd damage. Third, his kit is very unique. His gadget (ignore corn-fu) Roundhouse Kick fits perfectly with his kick and is a 360 stun to anyone who gets caught in its range. And BOTH his Star Powers are completely unique. Fresh Kicks (the superior one) INSTANTLY recharges his super if it kills someone. NO OTHER BRAWLER has a star power or gadget that has even somewhat of a similarity to this. Divine Soles is also pretty one of a kind. Every 3 seconds, he gets a shield that consumes damage, NO MATTER WHAT. Now, you may think that most of my reasons rely on Fangs SPs and gadget, but if it werent for Cordelius' gadgets and star powers, i highly doubt he would be placed as Legendary. Epic brawlers are for the most part extremely simple and dont have too many cool mechanics. Which is why I think Fang deserves high mythic or even legendary.

What i only understand of this future update: Buy Surge and Cordelius as fast as you can. Its not the same 500 chromatic credits than 3800 credits!

Should’ve made some super rare

Ngl Belle should at least be a Mythic. She has the marking ability that R-T has, her attack deals good damage, and it forces teams to be apart most of the time. I agree witv Lou and Sam legendary tho I wonder if brawl stars will change some of the "chromatic" rarities again in the future

1:47 This took me completely by surprise! I was like "Here we go 😒", expenting you to say that she is perfectly ranked as an epic, or even to be a super rare. I must have underestimated your vast culture my intelectual fellow! As a Belle enjoyer, I am proudly shaking your hand🤝 You, my man, gained my (a rendom person's) respect! 3:47 I think more controversial is Belle as a legendary brawler 😂 As a Gold Arm Gang enjoyer, once again, I agree with you. 5:42 I like where this is going. As a Gold Arm Gang enjoyer, but not for Pearl, your ranking is just right. I trusted you'll not give it higher ranking 🤝

I think belle and Sam should be mythic, other than that your rankings are perfect!

I think the thing pushing fang to mythic is his skill cap

Never rate again

The fact you gave 4 brawl’s legend that is insane

You earned your place as my fav youtuber. Belle is my fav brawler and I also think that she should be legendary!

Did he forget that fangs super can bounce

As a Sam enjoyer I would love Sam to be a legendary

Collette needs to he atleast mythic. Even thogi hshe was released years ago no other brawler shares the way she damages players and inly a few gadgets or star powers does percentage based damage. Id say legendary just for the fact nobody shares the damage type.

What would really make Surge a Legendary? Would be giving him his “Teleportation” back. It was something that made me fall in love with him. It was something that made him who he was as a Brawler.

No way Belle and Sam should be Legendary, or Buster Epic.

Eve should be legendary. The ability to walk over water is so much more interesting than Meg or Amber to me.

the fact that he rated r-t as a mythic and belle as a legendary is so confusing to me like r-ts main attack is literally a bit nerfed belles super

Can we see what rarity they turn to before the update when youtuber play the dev build?

No way you think that Belle should have been a Legendary 💀 she's Super Rare to Epic at best

I agree sam should be a legendary

If surge have the tp gadget right now it would have make more sense but as of now surge is very hard to play bc he have a higer skill ceiling i think a little buff to both of his gadget would help

honestly, they probably made surge a legendary just because of how popular he is. same for fang im gonna assume

I would love mandy as a mythic She has Nothing unique but her super whole Map Longest Range One shot many Brawlers Is too good Ik she is better as Epic but Mythic for her is great

I completely agree on all these options, except belle... Belle is just not interesting, her main attack is basically a jessie attack but a little better, and her super is just a mark... I dont get why you make rt mythic and belle a legendary, she just doesn't deserve it! Maybe a mythic would be possible but I'd give it an epic... She doesn't feel nearly close to a legendary, mostly when i play a legendary brawler i just have that feeling like "yeah, this is legendary", and Cordelius really succeeds in that, even surge does! But belle? Nah, no flipping way

Im crying im back from a 9 month break from brawl stars and went back to the game in december 10, Just to see myself get more grinding cuz of surge and cordelius…… I have only the chromatics gale,fang,buster,Lou,janet,and colette

I think brawl stars dev will probably buff and nerf chromatics

My former chromatic brawlers (some of them I can't explain) Gale = Super rare (because his trio end with different rarity) Surge = Mythic (at least make it easier) Colette = unchanged Lou = unchanged Ruffs = Epic (Cuz it's too much support for Mythic brawlers) Belle = Super rare Buzz = unchanged Ash = Mythic Lola = unchanged Fang = Legendary EVE = Epic Janet = Legendary (she's worthless) Otis = Legendary Sam = Super rare Buster = unchanged (Mythic brawlers so long don't have tank) Mandy = super Rare RT = Epic Maisie = unchanged Cordelius = unchanged Pearl = Super rare Charlie = Epic

My rating: Epic:gale,surge,collete,ash,fang,otis,buster,mandy,maisie,pearl Mythic:ruffs,belle,buzz,lola,eve,janet,charlie Legendary:lou,sam,R-T,cordelius

I think surge might get buffed becoming legendary while in like b/c tier idk if less after his gadget nerfs might make him a brawler that will be buffed soon

1:03 SPIKE CAN TALK🤯🤯🤯🤯😲😲😮😮😳🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿🗿

I liked my own comment

Otis is the only brawler that can apply an effect to an invincible brawler

1:05 Spike doesn't even talk-

Sam should be a Legendary. They made Otis Mythic, but Sam Epic. Like what?!

Most of them should be epic

If you ask me bell is a super rare brawler for me she has the most basic layout you can think of

I know this isn't a bugs comment video but, I found out that apparently you can use belle's super on 2 brawlers at same time but only works when it's a cordelious and a random brawler (it just happened in a match rn) when cordelious goes to his dimension having belle's mark then when you mark another brawler while cordelious is about to come out of his dimension and you can see that because of it both brawlers still got the mark(if you want full explanation please reply with something random)

I think Lola deserves at least Mythic. Due to her Ego. That thing and Lola together could get any living being dead in mere seconds. And... Never leave anyone who knows how to play Lola near a heist

An Ash main speaking here, I believe Ash should be a Mythic rarity rather than an epic. He is not only a complicated brawler to play for some people, but also you’ll be rewarded if you know how to play him by dominating anything in his path (except for his few counters though). And Ash looks way better with a red background with the combination of his blue armor.

Epic: Gale, Collete, Ash, Lola, Fang, Otis, Buster, Mandy, Maisie, Pearl Mythic: Surge, Ruffs, Buzz, Eve, Janet, R-T, Charlie, Legendary: Lou, Belle, Sam, Cordelius

"I feel like hes so one of a kind-" Spike: I hate my life...

I think Fang deserves the mythic spot that supercell gives cuz his main attack reaches further and you can wipe an entire team on your own with his super

Mandy should be mythic (my opinion) she has the highest range of all the brawler. Does high damage.Her Super burst through walls.

Sam as a Legendary is perfect! I don't know what supercell was thinking.

There are few brawlers that i am disagree with, but its fine tier list

The thing about the rarities is that its not about skill cap, which is how you are rating them, but its about the uniqueness and how easy it is to fully understand the abilities and functions of the brawlers. Also, the rarities are based on how they are currently in game, not taking into account previous forms of the brawler that were maybe simpler at some point.