I like it when karina is in a ponytail because the way she flips her hair during the chorus is so satisfying

Me thinking how a Main Vocalist so small could pull off those sharp moves without even trying like how is that possible Ningning? You gave me more reasons to go crazy for you.

Karina deserve being the center position. She is so charismatic and her aura is just overflowing. Icant stop looking at her!!

아니 스엠은 보컬교육윽 도대체 어떻게 시키길래 하나같이 다 잘하는거야 진짜?ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 아 웃기냐 왜케 사실 안 웃겨 미쳣어 실력 진짜;

에스파 실력보고 뽑은거 같은데 외모는 덤으로 얻은 느낌임 다들 엄청 칼군무에다가 빡신 안무인데도 이 정도 피치의 라이브를 소화한다는 건 엄청난 실력파라는 거... 당장 엠알제거만 들어도 타그룹보다 라이브 실력이 훨씬 뛰어난 걸 알 수 있음

i really can't take my eyes off ningning, she's slaying every part, she just goes harder and harder in every stage

Karina can be a leader,center,fotg,dancer,singer,rapper and beauty like a doll (visual). God what did you use making her queens and diamonds. She can do everything. And she is an ace. Wait there is one thing she can't do Being not perfect cause she is so perfect. Love you my anime girl.

의상 제일 좋았음 역대급ㅠㅠ 애들 편한거 입히니까 날라다니는 것 좀 보세요 세상 사람들... 우리 민정이도 다음에 저렇게 힙한 조거팬츠 입혀주세요💖 진짜 무대 하는게 신인 같지가 않음 너무 잘해...

Imagine being the main vocalist and can also dance like that. Ningning can relate. She’s too charismatic. Hope some people appreciate her more.

stan that 4 talented girl for a CLEAN SKIN

If you're still not convinced that they sang live here, well, please help us make aespa win and let them do encore.

Not pre record audio and they stable af. I'm a proud aespa stan

Giselle: 80% legs

Winter's presence is really something. I'm trying to look at every member but I ended up looking at just her

계속 보게되네 카리나 춤 선 진짜 예쁘다

I love all the girls, but i think we can see Ningning's improvement in every stage.

That smooth move by Winter at 2:05 !! Didn't even realise till I looked closer 😭 talented girls 🥺

Haters: Their debut is rushed. Aespa: *Sings perfectly live* *great choreo* *a whole bop* Say what now? U tried. NEXT

winter is the definition of being stunningly, beautiful, and talented

Winter you deserve everything queen. Aespa is perfect 💙

Winter is precious diamond 😍

KARINA ALL ROUNDER. VOCAL, DANCE AND RAP 💙

NingNing with that hairstyle is just on FIRE!

I love Winter very much, you won’t understand.

Ningning looks so good

Its unfair how Ningning can have the GOLDEN VOICE, KILLER CHARISMA, AND THE PERFECT VISUAL when she's just 18 ✊😔

why isn't anyone talking about Giselle? she's really pretty 🤍🤍

뭔가 윈터가 예뻐서 에스파는 나야 에스어쩌구가 ㅈ도 모르겟지만 반박못하게 묘하게 설득당함 그랬구나... 할미는... 이제야... 알겠다...너의 뜻...

IDK ABOUT Y'ALL BUT NINGNING ATE, SWALLOWED, AND CONQUERED HER HIGH NOTE!

Glad to finally see Ningning hit the high pitch on live!

이번 무대는 라이브 티가 나는데 예상외로 되게 잘해서 놀랐음ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 역시 스엠인건가....?

진짜 노래 춤 비주얼 빠지는거없네 진짜 완벽한무대였다 심지어 라이브가 이렇다니... 에스파안좋았는데 자꾸 좋아져ㅠㅠ 입덕각...

winter is so pretty no wonder she is a visual, but her vocal sounds very unique.

8K 대박... .실물영접하는기분이다

Ningning is the best girl~~ rooting for youu

오늘 음방 보며 음 살짝씩 빗나가는 거 보며 라이브 진짜 맞는 거 같더라... 몇달전 바로 결성됐다는 루머 깨부수는 라이브👍🏻

Im gonna talk about this again. Giselle’s hairstyle today is perfect, it suits her so much! And look, she is 80% legssssss!

Ningning’s voice has never failed to amaze me

Ningning stage presence is no joke omg, i can't take off my eyes of her.

My bias 1 ningning 🦋 2 winter ⭐️ 3 karina ❤️ 4 giselle 🌙

겨울이 언니 역시 미쳤네... 유영진 첫째 딸 맞나 봐.. 저걸 라이브로 하다니... 언니 사랑해...

SM is so cruel for letting them eat CDs for breakfast

this is a live performance. they are very good. their voice is stable and the dance is powerful. I also really like today's clothes and beauty. Winter's voice is very stable, ningning with its very stable high notes, stable karina dance, and also deep giselle voice that is stable and her interesting swag style. Really like Aespa's appearance today.

카리나 포니테일한거 ㅈㄴ잘했다 고개돌릴때 넘 이쁨ㅠㅠㅠ 사랑해 ㅠㅠ

라이브 지린다,,,,윈터 음색 너무 좋아 ㅜㅠ 넘 예뻐,,,,생머리가 찰떡 진심;;;;🤍

It's so cute that people are having a hard time identifying if it's live or not. Why? Coz they're talented ♥️ I stan the right queens 👑😭

I'm glad to see that the backup dancer have a cover in her knee for the moment when Ningning place her feet on her. It shows that they are taking care of there staff, and I'm sure that Ningning feels at ease knowing she is not hurting anybody when dancing. Good job 🙂👍

how are they only a rookie group? they’re setting the standards very high! i love them sm

giselle wearing that high waisted leggings hugging her figure COME THROUGH MISS JAPAN

겨울이 오늘 라이브랑 표정이랑 복근이랑 다 미쳤다

초반에 논란 엄청 많아서 안좋아했는데 보면 볼수록 진짜 호감이다 특히 윈터랑 닝닝... 논란 사실만 아니면 진짜 대성할듯

sm never fails to amaze us when it comes to vocals,aespa said:"our mics are on"

닝닝이 뭐야 매직으로 머리 피니까 더 이뻐졌어ㅠㅠ 확신의 고양이상이다 증말~유지민 머리 뭔데 좋다고 안무영상 머리 좋다🥰윈터는 안정성이 오우~~^^ 지구젤리도 옷에 리본 귀엽다구~~~**

피치가 이게 춤추면서 가능해? 음정정확도나 힘들텐데 끝음처리 안날리는거나 라이브아닌줄 진짜 그정도로 대박이네 이거 라이브면.. ㅇㅏ직도의심중 그정도로잘해서 개개인 노래실력을떠나서 걸그룹이 갖춰야할 춤추면서 호흡조절이나 음정정확도 같은게 완벽한건 칭찬받아마땅한듯

라이브 완전 오지는데..? 스엠빠 실력파인건 어디인가 + 생라는 아니여도 이정도면 잘하는거죠 싸우지들마시죵

Karina is exceptionally beautiful

NingNing a vocal powerhouse!!! So proud of u baby!!!!

윈터야 CD 먹었음???? ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 넌 정말 최고이에...

watching karina is so addictive

역시 스엠은 스엠이구나 데뷔한지 한 달도 안 됐는데 개잘해 진짜... 나 얘들 논란이 너무 커서 별로 안 좋아했었는데 점점 좋아짐 어떡하지 ㅜㅜ

괜히 sm이 아니다... 라이브 개오져

아야야야야야 파트 데뷔 무대 보다 더 빡쌔진거같은 ...

무대 의상이 완벽한 무대네요. 거기다 뮤직뱅크 쩌는 직캠 화질까지...이것은 최상의 조합입니다. 이 모든걸 가능하게 한건 에스파 덕분입니다. 이것은 감히 완벽한 영상이라고 불러도 손색이 없습니다.

can’t take my eyes off Karina main dancer

Ningning's vocals ❤

2:29초 닝닝이 고음불르면서 고개 탁 꺽는데도 고음 쭉쭉 올라가네 진짜 대박이다 닝닝사랑해😍

I’ve pretty much watched everything Aespa at this point. I’m in love with Karina, and Ningning pants, they look so good.

come on, they are one of the biggest groups in 4th generation and in kpop industry for some reason!! QUEENS!!!!

shoes really does a big effect in their dance. you can see how powerfull they dance in this boot and in the high heels. they dance more powerful so stop hating and say the girls are lazy. go wear high heels and dance urself. u know how hard it is.

진짜 보면볼수록 매력 쩐다... 과거 논란은 진짜 아쉽긴하다.. 그거만 아니었어도 ㄷㅓ 긍정적으로 주목받았을텐데 갓데뷔했는데 전혀 신인같지가 않음... 멤버들 조합도 좋고 각자 개성이 뚜렷한데 잘 어우러짐 ㅜㅜ 잘한다 기대되는 그룹이네용

It's live but accompanied by back vocals. You can hear a little voice crack from Ningning and the others. Their voices are steady

라이브 미쳤나봐 진짜 천재아이돌

Winter looks amazing here.she slays her part and sound so stable.ACE material

sooooooooooo lovely💛

김겨울 라이브 개잘해 ••

자꾸만 듣고 싶은 노래 카리나 완전잘함

That's on 30% prerecord and 70% live singing!! These girls slay hard!!

Winter’s voice before Ningning’s amazing high note almost cracked. But she pulled it off amazingly. This is live, haters. You could never.

Yeokshii uri SM maknae group, AESPA~♡ Stable vocals + clean movements in dance + energic performance. I can see their confidence is increasing, more than their previous stages!

에셈이 일냈다...이런 신인을 내다니ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 진짜 왤케 잘하냐

The reason they are able to sing so stable bcuz probably they get to use their real voice to sing compared to other gg that use high pitch voice or other tone to fit their song. You could hear how solid and full their voices are compared to other gg

Karina💜

아니 라이브 이 정도면 역대급 아닌가..? 쉬운 노래도 아니고 안무 다하고.. 신인인데 짱이다. 진짜👏

ningning vocal woowww love this and girls too

I have a new bias now, it's karina's hair👁👄👁

데뷔무대 구두 신고 한것보다 훨씬 에너지 있고 좋아요👍

이 노래가 뭐가 그렇게 중독성 있다고 조회수가 이렇게 높은 거 아 야↗️ 야➡️야↗️ 야 ↘️야야~

무심코 지나가는 길에 이 댓글을 보셨다면 여러분들은 모든 일이 다 잘풀리고 좋은 일만 있을 겁니다 부정적인 생각들보다는 긍정적인 생각들을 많이 하는 하루가 되길 바라요😃

이거 라이브인데 애들이 넘잘해ㅠㅠㅠ 뭐야ㅠㅠㅠ

울스파 라이브도 잘하고 퍼포도 완벽해

it's beautiful to see how karina smiles at the members during the choreography

their shoes make a big difference. with heels it little bit hard when they hit the moves, but with boots? THEY ATE THIS CHOREO

ㅇㄴ 라이브임?? 개오지는데? 스엠은 스엠이구나...

I love aespa as well as blackpink real beauty in skin and voice.

윈터 진짜 어쩜 저리 이쁘니......

IS IT JUST ME THAT I LIKE THIS OUTFIT BETTER THAN THEIR OTHER OUTFITS?

이 노래 들으면 신나~.~ 춤도 맘에들고 노래도 잘하냉

0:36 I'm so surprised with Winter's vocal

Winter you are my Queen

SM really knows how to form their groups. Ningning and Winter both have a pitchy voice that's why they put Karina and Giselle who have low voices to balance it out. It's also amazing they can all dance pretty good too and I do appreciate that instead of adding a distinct main dancer that'll stand out in the group they decided to stick into 4 members and make the best dancer out of them, the main dancer. The intention is to show people that this is what a group should prioritize.