Military Trauma Surgeon Rates 10 Battle Wounds In Movies & TV | How Real Is It? | Insider
Переглядів 5,671,480
2 роки томуTrauma surgeon and Navy veteran Dr. Peter Rhee rates 10 battlefield medical scenes in movies and television for realism.
Dr. Rhee discusses the accuracy of medical war scenes in “Hacksaw Ridge” (2016), starring Andrew Garfield; “Three Kings” (1999), featuring Mark Wahlberg and George Clooney; “Saving Private Ryan” (1998), featuring Tom Hanks; and “Cherry” (2021) with Tom Holland. He also comments on the reality of bullet and grenade wounds in “Black Hawk Down” (2001), “Band of Brothers” (2001), and “M*A*S*H” (1973) and analyzes combat medical procedures in “The Outpost” (2020), “Our Girl” (2014), and “Combat Hospital” (2011).
Dr. Peter Rhee is a trauma surgeon and a veteran of the United States Navy, where he served for 24 years. He is currently the chief of acute care surgery and trauma at the Westchester Medical Center. He wrote the book "Trauma Red" about his experience as a trauma surgeon.
"Trauma Red" by Dr. Peter M. Rhee: www.simonandschuster.com/book...
MORE HOW REAL IS IT VIDEOS:
ER Doctor Rates 10 DIY Surgery Scenes In Movies & TV
• ER Doctor Rates 10 DIY...
Afghan War Veteran Rates 9 Afghanistan War Battles In Movies
• Afghan War Veteran Rat...
Urban-Warfare Expert Rates 11 Urban-Warfare Scenes In Movies And TV
• Urban-Warfare Expert R...
------------------------------------------------------
#BattleWounds #HowRealIsIt #Insider
Insider is great journalism about what passionate people actually want to know. That’s everything from news to food, celebrity to science, politics to sports and all the rest. It’s smart. It’s fearless. It’s fun. We push the boundaries of digital storytelling. Our mission is to inform and inspire.
Subscribe to our channel and visit us at: www.insider.com
Insider on Facebook: / insider
Insider on Instagram: / insider
Insider on Twitter: / thisisinsider
Insider on Snapchat: / 4020934530
Movies Insider on Snapchat: / 9616609930
Insider on TikTok: / insider
Military Trauma Surgeon Rates 10 Battle Wounds In Movies & TV | How Real Is It?
@TheSourestKraut 2 роки тому
Army Medic here, I love how this guy differentiated us grunt medics from surgeons. I get asked about random medical conditions all the time, my answer is always "I have no idea, my job is to keep air moving in your lungs, keep juice in your veins, and get the casualty to someone who can do this better than me!"
@luisprado7107 2 роки тому
No offense big dawg, but I'm a Medic too. Medics are expected to have clinical knowledge. Nowadays Medics need to be able to sit on a casualty for 36 hours and keep them alive. If all you know how to do is what CLS learn in a week. You're cutting yourself and your joes very short.
@TheSourestKraut 2 роки тому
@@luisprado7107 I completely agree! The name of the game in the modern battlefield with a near peer enemy is prolonged field care and nursing skills as well as TCCC. Just saying that many civilians view combat medics on the same level as surgeons, when they are a much higher echelon of care.
@IudiciumInfernalum 2 роки тому
@@TheSourestKraut Average civilian generally has little to know medical training as a reference point. If you do 'doctor stuff' you're as good as a doctor or a trauma surgeon to them. At least in their minds.
@ladywaffle2210 2 роки тому
"A doctor heals you. A medic just makes you more comfortable... as you die." -Doc, Red vs. Blue Jokes aside, I'm no doctor, but the first step in saving a person is keeping them alive for the time being. It doesn't matter if they're en route to the best hospital in the world if they bleed out on the way there.
@caaltaga 2 роки тому
Oh I see, I also had this belief that medics were full on doctors. It must like being an engineer and getting asked to fix wifi or a printer lol
@timbayley7196 Рік тому
"If it's not your heart and your major vessels, we can save you" is the most stone cold thing anyone has ever said. This guy is a beast.
@jeepersmcgee3466 Рік тому
is the brain a major vessel?
@wattsonsplug Рік тому
@@jeepersmcgee3466 bruh if you got shot in the brain do you think would die?
@PringlePowerr Рік тому
@@jeepersmcgee3466 you'd already be dead so you wouldn't be on any operating table?
@salsatheone Рік тому
@@jeepersmcgee3466 even major brain trauma can sometimes be saved, but rehabilitation is required still, it really depends.
@tj1934 Рік тому
@@jeepersmcgee3466 Im guessing major vessels refers to heart and large arteries and veins like aorta and pulmonary tubes
@pcbatl 2 роки тому
I've worked with Dr.Rhee in a level 1 trauma center in the States and can attest to what he saying. He's legit, professional, and efficient. He'll be in critical trauma situation and speaking to you just like this, calm and collect. I loved working with him and learned a lot.
@theuniongamer4552 Рік тому
I Didnt know you were a veteran Patrick! Thank you for you service!
@caseyb1346 Рік тому
@@theuniongamer4552 thanks now I'm imagining patrick in the military and...oh well that's just your average marine isn't it?
@DefgirRZawa Рік тому
@@caseyb1346 So Patrick did find the military in the end after the desaster of Squidwards "Restaurant"... Also thank you for your service, actual person behind Patrick^^
@breezyjr Рік тому
I didn't know Bikini Bottom had a Level 1 trauma center...
@DefgirRZawa Рік тому
@@breezyjr They have Spongebob Squarepants there. He is reason enough to have one^^
@WhiskeyN9 Рік тому
Holy crap!! I served with this guy at Camp Junction City in Ramadi, Iraq back in 2005-2006. Such a cool dude! I learned a LOT from him. That picture of him in the beginning of the video is when he was in the OR we had at JC and my friend Lauren is right behind him! So cool to see him again! This guy is legit!
@leo_mas_922 Рік тому
LoL sure
@moss8702 Рік тому
@@leo_mas_922 what makes his statement untrue?
@leo_mas_922 Рік тому
@@moss8702 I dined with Scarlett J. . What makes mine untrue?
@BloodTrinity Рік тому
@@leo_mas_922 Easy, because I dined with Scarlett J. So obviously you are lying.
@leo_mas_922 Рік тому
@@BloodTrinity Dayum
@blbelt2001 2 роки тому
I just want to say thank you to Dr. Rhee, he saved my cousin's life and is the reason he still has the use of his right leg.
@Trund27 Рік тому
That’s absolutely awesome!!!!
@Zayn-kg4bu Рік тому
Ehhh I have my doubt.
@periwinkle2486 Рік тому
@@Zayn-kg4bu you must have heard that a lot while growing up
@aaronwentaway Рік тому
source: just trust me
@mas7rreaper126 Рік тому
@@aaronwentaway there’s no reason to lie about it though???
@namegoeshere5432 2 роки тому
*Love how he explained what they would and wouldn't do in the military and civilian scenarios* Alot of people don't understand how tenacious it is to be a surgeon let alone one in an extremely high stress fast pace environment like the military. Very knowledgeable breakdowns. Thank you for your service.
@Theoryofcatsndogs 2 роки тому
If you are a military surgeon, it is very unlikely you will get sue. Also, their goal are save life in a very bad situation, recovery and quality of life usually push aside.
@dionisiuskusuma1462 2 роки тому
@@Theoryofcatsndogs they won't get sued due to Feres doctrine
@jamesloder8652 2 роки тому
Firstly, *a lot. Second of all, that's not at all how you use the word tenacious.
@namegoeshere5432 2 роки тому
@@jamesloder8652 Aw thanks for caring so much. Seems as though *A lot* of people understood my comment and I didn't need a tenacious hold on the English language to do so. 😁
@dmarti11235 2 роки тому
@@Theoryofcatsndogs Usually they'll do your emergent care and stabilise you in-theater, and then send you to Stuttgart or somewhere else out-of-theater for longer-term care and recovery.
@hollywoodbb 2 роки тому
I was an EMT for under a year and years later I still have trouble with some of the things I’ve seen. I can’t imagine 25 years in the field. Bless this man, he’s unwavering.
@JohanN4664 Рік тому
Was it really that bad ? I always wanted to be an emt but didn’t know if I could handle it
@mandowarrior123 Рік тому
You have to be a sociopath or psychopath to cope with it mentally, but that is why those kinds of people can be heroes, and why there is a certain degree of tolerance for it in the armed forces.
@hollywoodbb Рік тому
@@JohanN4664 yes. It depends on each person and their experience in the field, as well as how it affects you. For me, I never had trouble in the moment, I just locked in and went into robot mode no matter how fucked it got. But when the adrenaline wears off and time goes by, it can seep in. I have trouble sleeping because of the night terrors I have. Know what you’re signing up for.
@user-th6ty2ln6x Рік тому
@@hollywoodbb Hey, what bothers you the most? What surprised you/missed your expactations when starting career, and did you look into it before, prepare yourself? I'm trying to grasp what is the load in this job.
@darbyheavey406 Рік тому
You were in the wrong field- it’s not for everyone. 10 years in a trauma center in North Philly was enough for me but the schedule was the worse.
@DrJSurgeon Рік тому
I was a surgery resident of Dr Rhee at University of Arizona. This man speaks surgical knowledge worth chapters in few words. Still recall cases I managed in the trauma bay with Dr Rhee and what he taught me. One particularly, a patient transferred from Mexico result of cartel shooting. Everyone was worried about the situation, Dr Rhee came in calmly and made everyone focus on the real problem, patient's life.
@mufasaiam7794 2 роки тому
It's so cool how calm he is talking about stuff that would make most people pass out if they see it
@roymarshall_ 2 роки тому
Thats an experienced professional right there, exactly the guy I would want working on me if I was badly wounded
@theflyingdutchguy9870 2 роки тому
its not making most people pass out when they see that stuff. some people do. but it ofcourse depends. i used to have someone in ckass as a kid who would go down seeing a vew drops of blood😅. but most people keep it together unless there is some crazy stuff going on. and the smell of blood probably does not help😂
@theflyingdutchguy9870 2 роки тому
when i see or feel something very painfull. i usually start laughing while crying and its weird. but i guess it helps me deal with it. kinda funny
@eyelessjack3406 2 роки тому
@@theflyingdutchguy9870 we get it you're a cool guy.🙄
@theflyingdutchguy9870 2 роки тому
@@eyelessjack3406 you really think so? or do people have weaker stomaches than i realised
@delancyj67 2 роки тому
The best part of his interview is that he is conversant with historical aspects of treating battle wounds. Types of wounds and how they were treated in Vietnam, WWII, and Iran has made this one of my favourite expert interviews.
@eocall2 2 роки тому
Agree 100%
@Leadfoot_P71 2 роки тому
Iran?
@sErgEantaEgis12 2 роки тому
@@Leadfoot_P71 I assume they meant Iraq but had a slip.
@BalkanRedneck 2 роки тому
@@Leadfoot_P71 he's just predicting the future.
@AlexSDU 2 роки тому
@@BalkanRedneck Or maybe he recalled the failed US hostages rescue mission in Iran.
@Flyboy207 Рік тому
I'm glad they included M*A*S*H in here. I have a little bit of medical experience in the civilian world but I can't imagine what it's like in combat. The line from M*A*S*H that always sticks with me is: "Rule number 1 in war, is that young men die. Rule number 2 is, doctors can't change rule number 1."
@cavscout6b Рік тому
One of the very few serious and educational moments from Henry Blake.
@mjp152 18 днів тому
One of the best series ever made.
@lordcrawfish4373 Рік тому
If anyone was curious, this doctor is 100% legit, in the military's TCCC training there is a video of him helping perform a cricothyroidotomy on a patient in the middle east.
@seasonedbeefs Рік тому
Had to Google that
@seasonedbeefs Рік тому
Thought it was Jurassic
@johnwick7175 Рік тому
i'm struggling to even pronounce that
@samaraisnt Рік тому
I hate the internet. Why are we ONLY questioning the legitimacy of this expert, but not literally every other? Isn't stolen valor literally a crime? Y'all are trash bags, examine why this man isn't credible but every other expert from accents to chef is so legit. Those other things aren't illegal to lie about and you can literally see photo evidence of him, in combat hospitals.
@notjason6595 Рік тому
@@samaraisntMaybe he probably saw that video and recognized him,no need to be so down.
@CrippledMerc 2 роки тому
You should bring him back for more because he’s excellent at this. I could listen to him for hours. I like seeing the contrast between a civilian doctor and a military one, and the differences in how they do their work. It’s fascinating! I’m sure he’s got tons of crazy stories he could share. I’d like to see him react to more medical scenes even if they aren’t military related. You could have him check out self administered or improvised medical care from movies and TV. Things like someone treating their own gunshot or knife wound like the Javier Bardem one in No Country For Old Men. I think there was also a similar scene in the movie Shooter with Mark Wahlberg if I’m not mistaken. Stuff like that though would be interesting as well and I’d like to hear his professional take on improvised medical care.
@paulchambers360 2 роки тому
Truly excellent interviewee
@leonprowse5806 2 роки тому
Crossbow bolt scene from Blue Ruin
@genola 2 роки тому
Paul Bettany’s character from Master and Commander
@dmc_9894 2 роки тому
Agree
@ZedsDeadZD 2 роки тому
Mark wahlberg in Lone survivor would be awesome. Lots of wounds you probably wouldnt survive. They even joke about getting shot in the head. Would love to see it.
@Ray-gl2vr 2 роки тому
I was a combat medic in Iraq and Afghanistan, totally agree with everything he said. I had the honour of observing the trauma surgeons in Camp Bastion and these guys worked miracles, they saved the lives of people who simply shouldn't be alive today. I treated and medevaced a guy with quadruple limb amputations, I was shocked he was still alive when we got him on the MERT. I'm still shocked he is still alive today thanks to these guys.
@Dr_V 2 роки тому
Hello dear colleague, I need a bit of advice if you please. I'm trying to put together some field trauma kits for sending into Ukraine, but I'm just a radiologist so my knowledge in this is rather limited. Here's a brief list of what I've gathered, please tell me if I'm missing anything important: sterile gauze bandages, gauze wrap, band-aids, steri strips, sterile gloves, tape, scissors, tourniquet, disinfectant (PVP-I), local anesthetic (lidocaine), syringes, local anti-inflammatory (Rivanol), oral anti-inflammatory (Paracetamol), wide spectrum antibiotic (Amoxiclav). I'm buying these over the counter, so I can't get sterile suture kits, stronger anesthetics or IV antibiotics.
@Ray-gl2vr 2 роки тому
@@Dr_V hi, it depends on the purpose. I assume if you really mean trauma kit then it's for a combat medic type deal. In that case drop the band aids, steri strips, all the drugs other than the antibiotics and the pink and fluffy wound cleaning stuff. Trauma kits deal with mostly bleeding, so all you really need are bandages, gauze, tourniquet, gloves, mask and bag, tuff cut scissors and permanent marker. I would say for 90% of casualties I saw would just need those items. Things like wound cleaning or small wounds can be dealt with at an aid station or hospital, a trauma kit is for saving lives so it should just be stuffed full of thing designed to do just that. If you wanted to create a more general first aid kit then what you listed would be fine.
@flashkills 2 роки тому
@@Dr_V Im not a licensed medical professional but I was an infantryman with actual casualty field care experience and training. Most tactical combat casualty care at least for first-line care revolves around a IFAK (individual first aid kit) primary items that you want to include in a IFAK are T triple C certified tourniquets such as a CAT tourniquet or a SOF-T tourniquets. Pressure dressings also known as Israeli dressings as well as Hemostatic agents or such as Celox or Combat Gauze as it is infused with the hemostat already. This will cover most injury’s involving hemorrhaging to the extremities and is the #1 killer on battlefields. you can also include items such as occlusive dressing or chest seals as well as decompression needles to treat tension pneumothorax but I would only recommend these items to trained individuals as it involves shoving a 14gauge catheter in to someone’s lung so yea. Other items are NPA’s (Nasopharyngeal Airway) for airway, gloves, surgical tape and compress gauze. Also, trauma sheers and sharpies are a MUST trust me. This will help sustain the casualty until they can get to high medical care. Hope this helps
@Dr_V 2 роки тому
Thank you. As a civilian MD I don't have access to military medical equipment, but I'll ask around for some hemostat infused dressings. The band-aids I mentioned aren't the little pink "finger scratch" type, but the kind made for post-operative wound dressing (large, thick and infused with a contact antiseptic), should be at least somewhat useful.
@flashkills 2 роки тому
@@Dr_V Hemostat dressings can be purchased online and is available to the civilian market as well as every thing mentioned above you can even buy prefilled IFAK's. Just google Quikclot and you'll see. They are just one of the many producers. The difference be tween the civilian and military is 1. the military ones are vacumed packed for storage and size. and 2. the military ones have a strip the runs thru the entire length of the gauze so sergionz can X-ray it and see if any is still inside the patient before or after they suture them. Both can be purchased online.
@metroidhunter965 2 роки тому
From what I understand, _Hacksaw Ridge_ is an accurate recreation of Desmond Doss’s service during WWII. He was a Seventh Day Adventist and refused to carry a weapon due to his religious beliefs, thus becoming a medic. He saved anywhere from 50-100 men in the Battle of Okinawa and received a Medal of Honor for that service.
@kentinson1670 2 роки тому
Still blows my mind that this guy was real and managed to survive that ordeal without a gun
@airmagebobby7269 Рік тому
@@kentinson1670 I think it's pretty remarkable that he did too, but just a thought. Would his odds actually be any better with a gun? A carbine won't stop you from getting shot. The only time it might is if you're unfortunate enough to be right next to an enemy combatant which is rarer than it sounds.
@jakelee7083 Рік тому
@@airmagebobby7269 Well in a battlefield like the ridge, yeah it would. There were multiple times Desmond would have died had it not been for his comrades who saved his life by shooting the enemy. Sometimes while he was trying to save their lives.
@J03_M4m4 Рік тому
Wasn't he one of the first (if not the first) conscientious objectors to recieve Medal of Honour? I saw Hacksaw Ridge a good while ago and can't remember that bit well
@Eggy79 Рік тому
@@jakelee7083 yeah so he really shouldn't be applauded then. His superstitious beliefs put everyone around him in more danger and he still needed those guns he hated to do his "heroism"
@tony.h321 Рік тому
14:52 His little smile, as if he's thinking "Oh yeah, I've done this." like its a fond memory. This man clearly has balls of steel.
@lucklesspanther1929 2 роки тому
This guy is amazing, can we get more of him? Could literally listen for hours
@Trund27 2 роки тому
I second this!!!
@crimsoncrusader4829 2 роки тому
Yeah, I also love how he would get into the evolution of field trauma like the historical use of morphine or IV
@ufc990 2 роки тому
@@crimsoncrusader4829 The real interesting stuff is pre morphine, them good old barber surgen days
@untilvalhalla7854 2 роки тому
I absolutely agree. He would be great for a history of military medicine thing. I had the privilege of working with men and women like this for a long time. I was always humbled and amazed by them and wouldn’t trade it for the anything.
@ryannoneofyourbusiness9692 2 роки тому
He died in the new war
@lazyidiotofthemonth 2 роки тому
In that episode of Band of Brothers the two Medics actually spent the first 15 minutes(2 real world days) going from aid station to aid station asking for plasma, morphine, bandages, and scissors.
@pasta-and-heroin 2 роки тому
Thats one of my fav parts of the book
@saintroddy 2 роки тому
"Hinkel, ist das du? Hinkel?!"
@mikesullivan3264 2 роки тому
@@pasta-and-heroin 1
@clardergrarder4991 2 роки тому
Thats me in foxhole
@lachg1714 2 роки тому
Yes at Bastogne.
@ColterBrog Рік тому
I think what struck me is when he was talking about how much “fun” he had… with a subtle sound of joy in his voice. I found it strange that someone would find happiness in such a situation- working on the wounded, sometimes horribly so, and the dying. As I considered it more, though… if I was a patient, that’s exactly who I’d want helping me. Someone with a passion and excitement for his craft. He loves helping people so much he doesn’t even see the horror before him, only the opportunity to do good.
@Mate_Antal_Zoltan Рік тому
honestly, I was put off by it too, but then I remembered that saving lives probably should be fun now if a combat veteran said killing people was fun, I wouldn't think they were normal
@annieseaside Рік тому
Possibly he was referring to the Camaraderie in Combat theaters that has no equivalent, rather than the carnage.
@joshknix1866 Рік тому
@@Mate_Antal_Zoltan there are plenty of combat vets that enjoyed killing people. It’s really not that rare. They aren’t normal, normal people don’t kill people for a living. Normal people don’t go through special operations selections.
@fleetskipper1810 7 місяців тому
I suspect he was remembering the thrill of working closely with other people who had the same goal. Unfortunately, that doesn’t happen nearly often enough in civilian life.
@52000rightwing 2 роки тому
This guy is a real hero. I’m willing to bet the number of lives he has saved will fill up a stadium or two. Awesome.
@kinagrill Рік тому
No one's born a hero or choose to become one. They are MADE a hero by others. :)
@ikapatino3214 2 роки тому
The fact that this guy doesn't have the thousand yard stare and still smiles is amazing to me I bet you he's seen some stuff.
@stayhungry1503 2 роки тому
he told us about some of it. seeing a six year old girl with a big piece of shrapnel sticking out of her neck for example. and a lot of civilians with burns.
@Rudyelf1 2 роки тому
That is the worrisome part. Think Robin Williams and his depression. I had my wife’s family be surprised when they realize I am a combat grunt. “But you don’t seem like a Marine.” Probably because I am always being silly and entertaining kids. Then there are nights when I remember the acts of violence I committed, or my dead or injured friends, and I get bummed out.
@sErgEantaEgis12 2 роки тому
@@Rudyelf1 It means you're still a human and you still have a conscience.
@GraceLJW 2 роки тому
I've heard from some of my veteran friends that the medics usually are the ones who come out most mentally ok from horrible experiences. I'm guessing it's because they're the ones actively doing something that is natural to our human wiring when helping advance the combat mission. Trying to keep people in your group alive and well is instinctive and can override fear. Seeing people get wounded around you and not being able to help except to hopefully keep the enemy off of them probably isn't quite as aligned with what our brains can handle.
@scythelord 2 роки тому
@@GraceLJW Actually human brains can handle death pretty well, its just that modern life ensures we don't have to deal with it enough that we actually get used to it. It affects us greatly because of that. Most of us can't even stomach seeing the livestock we eat die in front of us because we don't do it ourselves anymore.
@JackKirbyFan 2 роки тому
Talk about a man who's tough as nails. This is the guy that's a hero in my book. Understated and courageous without bragging about it. Incredible person.
@aaronkonstantine2794 2 роки тому
💯
@paintballplayer700 2 роки тому
My man rocking a $50,000 Royal Oak, not 100% understated. :-D
@apolloclasp2326 2 роки тому
@@paintballplayer700 his watch?
@missfuneralsong 2 роки тому
Personally would love to see Dr. Rhee's comments on more scenes from MASH. I've heard the show's accuracy remarked on a few times before, which to me seems really notable considering how old the show is and the fact that it's (ostensibly) a comedy. I think his perspective on some of the really memorable scenes and how field medicine has changed between then and now would be super interesting to watch.
@Aeternus75 Рік тому
If I’m not mistaken they used real veteran stories and reports to make quite a few of those scenes. It does explain why it has an inexplicable weight to it a lot of movie scenes don’t seem to have.
@rdfox76 Рік тому
@@Aeternus75 There's also one of the most effective little rules they had. Because it was a comedy, CBS required them to use a laugh track (because apparently TV executives thought people wouldn't know to laugh at the jokes without prompting). However, the producers put an ironclad rule into place that they even fought CBS's executives over (and *won*): There was to be *no* laugh track in the ER scenes. Even when someone cracked a joke in the ER, there wouldn't be any laughter except possibly from the other people present in the scene. The lack of laughtrack (and score!) in the ER gave it an emotional weight because you could subconsciously *feel* that they were missing.
@FordRangerClassics Рік тому
@@rdfox76 I hate laugh tracks. (Big bang theory will always stick out as particularly guilty lol)
@di0__0ib Рік тому
@@rdfox76 great thing about the DVD release of the show is there's an alternate audio track for all of the episodes with no laugh track it adds SO MUCH WEIGHT to what's happening and what's being said it's the only way to watch it for me now I grew up with the laugh track glad to have it this way now
@cavscout6b Рік тому
M*A*S*H had Walter Dishell M.D. as an advisor. He used period articles and texts as a basis or limitation for what was feasible during the Korean War.
@NoName5589 Рік тому
Dr. Peter Rhee is one of the best guest speakers I've seen on this channel. He's got the knowledge, the stories, and the charisma. He's awesome
@jimbopaleomedic858 2 роки тому
I had the privilege of working with Dr. Rhee in Tucson when I worked in the field as a medic as well as in the Emergency/Trauma department. He is the consummate professional, very knowledgeable yet down to earth and absolutely unflappable.
@26b47 2 роки тому
You know, you’re about 3rd guy in the comments to bring up working with him in Tucson, you might know some of these people.
@jimbopaleomedic858 2 роки тому
@@DJgoon12 ER Paramedic
@christopherbronson3275 Рік тому
Tucson? Arizona? Neat! I'm from there
@azraelf.6287 2 роки тому
Regarding the bare hands. I went through CLS training when I was in the Army. Basically slightly advanced first aid. I'll always remember one of our instructors told us if we have gloves in our kit, use them, if not, don't worry about it: 'I can fix an infection later, just get them to me. I can't fix dead.'
@kevincass9917 2 роки тому
What a way to remember that.
@repunklican1181 Рік тому
Same concept with packing wounds with dirt or using dirty rags to stop bleeding
@CombatIneffective Рік тому
CLS huh? How bad did you wanna stick someone to give them an IV for being a heat casualty?
@azraelf.6287 Рік тому
@@CombatIneffective never had to outside of class, and that was honestly my least favorite part of class. My unit told me I had to go so they could hit their numbers, or I wouldn't have taken the training. I just wasn't a fan of needles. But I got both required sticks on the first try. By the time my re-cert came around CLS's were no longer able to do IVs.
@nopeuhhuhh3662 Рік тому
Haaaa, I remember my CLS training too. Pressure bandages and tourrnequets...outside of that, getem to a medic
@salg760g5 Рік тому
I absolutely admire a surgeon who has so much experience repairing traumatic wounds and saving lives. It just leaves me speechless and humbles me...makes me realize I should of learned more in life by now...
@devindalton4688 Рік тому
Not everyone can do everything all the time. You'll find your way, just try to enjoy the path there and keep working as hard as you need to while you do.
@lwkee7143 Рік тому
Never too late to learn more 💪🤓
@oldcop18 Рік тому
I served in Nam as a Navy Corpsman w/the Marines in 1966 & saw a lot of trauma. This doctor is spot on w/his observations
@bradbiggs4283 2 роки тому
"If it's not your in your heart or major vessels, I bet I can save ya..." I believe him. I really do.
@andrewmoore7014 2 роки тому
The thing about putting on a tourniquet being painful reminded me of when I took a trauma medicine class at my local gun club. The instructor showed us a video of a soldier whose leg had been blown off and his comrades applied a tourniquet. The wounded soldier kept trying to pull it off because it was more painful than the injury and had people screaming at him to leave it alone. It saved his life, but imagine how much it must have hurt!
@yeetstreet3240 2 роки тому
Was on a call for an accidental discharge to the lower leg. Guy had lost a lot of blood before we got there and was still bleeding heavily. Tibia blown out in at least one spot. Lots of reasons for him to be in lots of pain. He was p calm and moderately distressed. Tourniquet went on and within a few minutes he was howling.
@trouserarmadillo8616 2 роки тому
In the Marine Combat Lifesaver Course tourniquets were huge. If you have a leg wound, I’m standing on your leg to brace you and tighten as hard as I can. Mark em and keep it movin. Plus, a man can still fight with a tourniquet on.
@jeffm5991 2 роки тому
In the military, that's called being "in the black". Because of his injuries he was probably not fully aware of his surroundings and probably wasn't hearing what everyone was saying and didn't know what he was doing.
@trouserarmadillo8616 2 роки тому
@@jeffm5991 nailed it!!
@sbreheny 2 роки тому
I suspect that a lot of the pain from tourniquets comes from the combined effect of the wound and the tourniquet. I took a trauma medical class and part of the class was for us to actually put a tourniquet on ourselves (one arm, then one leg) and on someone else (one arm, one leg) and the teacher would come around each time and verify that there was no distal pulse. It hurt a fair amount but not the most painful thing I've experienced by a long shot and the other people seemed to have the same experience. Now, granted, we never left them on for more than about 2 minutes so maybe it gets much more painful with time.
@mango8918 Рік тому
To all those who have served as a combat physician, physician's assistant, nurse, medic and trauma center staff, please accept my heartfelt thanks and bless you for work you do (did). If Dr Rhee is an example of who staffs our trauma centers, we are in the very best hands!
@matthewjaredcox9753 10 місяців тому
No thanks for the millions of other service members? Just the medical staff?
@oliveradams1270 10 місяців тому
Amen to that
@kcgunesq 11 місяців тому
This doc is one of the coolest people I've ever seen. People like him are who should be our kids role models, not a bunch of criminal athletes.
@nateakabravo-one5035 2 роки тому
Dr. Rhee is an amazing doc that I have had the luck to have learned from so I can provide quality trauma care to my community as an EMT. He knows his stuff and has plenty of stories to share and overall a very down to earth guy! Glad to see he hasn't changed since he left from Tucson, AZ
@kyleb9719 2 роки тому
Very cool! Great job helping your community, hope for plenty of success, luck and safety for you and your partner.
@franksmith7247 2 роки тому
I'm always in such awe of the composure under pressure of such professionals like Dr. Rhee and yourself. I suppose it's as easy as "Someone's got to do it. And it doesn't serve the patient being frantic"
@wheredamoon 2 роки тому
Oh right! I knew I knew him from somewhere. I've seen him lecture at the Trauma ACS Conference in Vegas. Great guy.
@DJgoon12 2 роки тому
You're an EMT and you think you can give him a stamp of approval?
@aprayingatheist2378 2 роки тому
@@DJgoon12 you better watch your mouth when you're talking to Bravo-One
@hellothere9167 2 роки тому
Fun fact: On making of Hacksaw Ridge, the actions that Desmond Doss did felt superhuman to the director and they actually stopped his story short to make it more believable
@sararadley5702 2 роки тому
Glad they did the film did such a great job, it’s so staggering to think of what Desmond did
@hannahhester8376 2 роки тому
Right??
@williamflummer3240 2 роки тому
Gibson said that if they would included everything he did, the audience would not have accepted it and thought it was unrealistic.
@zacharyramsli8002 2 роки тому
Yeah go look up the citations for his actions at hacksaw - it really is unbelievable.
@B0BBARKER444 2 роки тому
Honestly got to say I'm not a huge fan of that movie. Really respect what Doss did, he's a hero. But the movie just felt hokey to me. Idk
@187btokes Рік тому
Fellow vet here, and I have the utmost respect for the medics and trauma surgeons... Their job is intense and brutal
@victorfield4607 Рік тому
Dr Rhee words cannot express how much I admire you - thank you for telling the truth about the difficulty and pressure battlefield medics and surgeons work under - I was treated as a child by surgeons who did service in WWII and they were effective and inspired confidence in a way that your average doctors simply can't do nowadays - thank you for your great work.
@paulmorris6177 2 роки тому
As a medic in Iraq, I will 100% agree with the Col. We stopped using IVs all together on my last tour in 2008. We were hit by a RKG3 in Tikrit. One soldier had a piece of shrapnel in his back (another had wounds to his upper arm). I treated him until we got back to our COB and handed him over to the docs there. ABCs (airway, breathing, circulation) will save lives every time.
@patrickmcglonejr8163 2 роки тому
We are even taught ABC in the arborist trade.. I truly think its something that should be taught in High School
@JustinsAdventure 2 роки тому
ABCs are out dated, last I heard they’re running P-MARCH-P.
@Alsatiagent 2 роки тому
@@patrickmcglonejr8163 That was the first thing that popped into my head when I I took my first CPR course twenty years ago. Virtually anyone can do it.
@joshuafranz7846 2 роки тому
@@JustinsAdventure you’re not wrong, but it’s essentially the same thing. ABC will still work
@Vinny86100 2 роки тому
Oh man MARCH completely forgot about that, yeah that got bought into my 2nd tour to Afghan in 2010. That and learning cannulas and bone drilling. Amazing stuff, that I later learnt we shouldn’t have been taught.
@goremonoja 2 роки тому
I did a first aid course for major trauma once, the guy was called Simmy and he was a former army trauma surgeon turned civilian paramedic and first aid instructor...He told us that a tourniquet when fully applied is known to hurt more than an emergency amputation! He also shared a short but profound story about his time in Afghanistan and it went like this...One day after a very nasty contact or IED ambush, he and his colleagues dealt with all the human casualties at hand. Once they deemed the scene secure they then noticed a local stray dog that seemed injured so he and his 2 colleagues went to try to give it aid. The next thing he remembers is waking up in a hospital in the UK 6 months later...turns out the enemy had stitched an IED into a stray dog as a secondary ambush and both the medics to his left and right were sadly killed instantly. Simmy was nearing the end of his service career and his wife said she would leave him if he went back lol(fair one) so he got his discharge but has continued saving lives directly and indirectly ever since...What a lad!
@hahaimasian 2 роки тому
I had a friend that served in Afghanistan, he said they gotta shoot any living creature coming to their camp. They always make sure they are dead and taken care off for the same reason of enemies planting bombs in them. He said his role is the baiter, he carries flash rounds with him.
@ADAPTATION7 2 роки тому
That is sick, sick, sick. In order to do this to an animal, you have to be even worse than an animal.
@ikapatino3214 2 роки тому
Yeah fuc the dogs man ,in that instance.
@I___Am 2 роки тому
@@ADAPTATION7 Well, to do something cruel like planting ied to other human already made them worse than animal. 😅
@Jarhead64 2 роки тому
@@I___Am the movie Hurt Locker did show the enemy trying to put IEDs in humans.
@ZiggyHernandez Рік тому
My grandfather was a medic in WWII and he told me a lot of the same things when we watched Saving Private Ryan together. I never understood what he had seen until then. Respect these people, they have faced things we can’t imagine.
@Machtyn Рік тому
M.A.S.H. for being a comedy, took things for real and seriously when it mattered. Great show.
@bradhaines3142 Рік тому
last 3 seasons just sucked
@sc666666 Рік тому
a bit heavy on the alcoholism
@samuelhowie4543 Рік тому
Remember another scene when Potter was the surgeon about a guy having a piece of bone blown into his body from another casualty.
@CyanideGirl94 Рік тому
@@bradhaines3142 Nah
@unluckytourist 2 роки тому
That wound in Black Hawk Down is what led to them developing Quick Clot, which saved a lot of lives in the wars in Afghanistan/Iraq. Also bizarre fact - The Delta Force Operator called "Hoot" in the movie became a pharmacist after he left the military because the incident led him to becoming interested in medical care.
@casedistorted 2 роки тому
yeah sounds like my mothers ex husbands dad who was in WW2 (somehow he's still alive) and he was a medic in WW2, got captured by the Nazis for a time but when he survived the war he opened his own pharmacy company in Wisconsin here. Made a killing of a living that's for sure.
@matts5247 2 роки тому
How is a pharmacy medical care? It’s retail. And what is quick clot? Bc I know sulfa powder was in use way before the 90s. I know they had it by WWII at the latest and it’s function was to cause blood to quickly clot to prevent fatal blood loss. Is quick clot just like a more modern version of that or something? I’m just curious since I haven’t heard of it. On a side note, one of my best friends growing up had a parent who was a doctor and came up with a product was some kind of patch that could be put on extreme wounds and it would allow it to start healing out in the field. I know they had signed a contract with the military to sell it to them but there was a bunch of legal shananigans that I’d rather not go into. But I though that was really cool. Although I don’t think my buddies family member’s company ended up going to market with it. But I’m sure a product with the same technology is used by the military these days.
@casedistorted 2 роки тому
@@matts5247 "QuikClot is a brand of hemostatic dressing, wound dressing that contains an agent that promotes blood clotting." Omg another description lol "Control bleeding with QuikClot® hemostatic gauze, which acts on contact to stop bleeding five times faster. The gauze is impregnated with kaolin, a mineral that accelerates your body's natural clotting process." I have never used it but I've heard of it as a former EMT, it's a pretty cool invention so it knocks out two birds with one stone. Essentially instead of spilling sulfa powder everywhere you just use a nice sterile bandage wound dressing that also helps to clot up the blood at the same time. Quite ingenious, though I don't know how much I want to impregnate someone while trying to save their life LOL
@fdota 2 роки тому
I wouldn't call pharmacy retail. I mean, it has elements of retail (especially if you work in the community setting), but pharmacists also work in hospitals and are thoroughly involved in patient care.
@erikawhelan4673 2 роки тому
@@matts5247 becoming a pharmacist is not necessarily the same thing as opening a pharmacy. Pharmacists are medical professionals who specialize in the effects of medicine on the human body.
@artvandelay6306 2 роки тому
You don't really hear much about medical units, but these men and woman are absolutely deserving of more praise and recognition.
@ray8776 2 роки тому
Agreed. What they do is deserving of praise and recognition, but why they do it for isnt. War still exists because we dont actually take account how terrible it is because we look into the bigger picture.
@ttoddh1 Рік тому
I enjoyed this discussion more than any other you have ever done. I admire his no-nonsense reporting and comparing. Good job.
@tonysandoval3799 Рік тому
Imagine the lives this man saved, a lot of generations will continue because of this hero
@shiwashere 2 роки тому
When he points out that medics would be shot while tended to the wounded to add to the casualties is scary but incredibly accurate. My father went on a peacekeeping mission and they were actually told not to respond in a sniper situation and to take cover first because going out to be a first responder was a death sentence if you're running out in the open
@chemistryofquestionablequa6252 2 роки тому
The first priority is to remove the threat. Then you can worry about aid.
@sErgEantaEgis12 2 роки тому
There's virtually no military benefit to shooting medics, it takes a special kind of monster to shoot medics.
@bramgierkink7485 Рік тому
Isnt there some sort of law that u cant shoot medics when they're helping someone?
@shiwashere Рік тому
@@bramgierkink7485 technically but its not like people still won't :/
@bramgierkink7485 Рік тому
@@shiwashere Maybe if we ask them nicely :)
@kyleb9719 2 роки тому
Tourniquet time written on the face is fascinating. Makes perfect sense but had no idea they did that. Hope for more military surgeon videos.
@texdoc89 2 роки тому
I would always keep a sharpie or something to be able to write somewhere on the patient lol. Once blood starts pouring it makes it way more difficult to be to write tourniquet time and if they got morphine, we were actually still being issued morphine in 2012 in Afghanistan.
@rasmusn.e.m1064 2 роки тому
Yeah, it's one of those very good ideas that you don't think about because we are taught to think about tools as only applicable to a specific inanimate medium, which human faces aren't, but they can used that way.
@rasmusn.e.m1064 2 роки тому
Yeah, it's one of those very good ideas that you don't think about because we are taught to think about tools as only applicable to a specific inanimate medium, and humans aren't inanimate.
@jasoninflagstaff 2 роки тому
They taught us in boot camp to write it in blood,if we didn't have anything else. The dr. says after 2 hours,the limb is dead. What he didn't say,or maybe he kinda did,is if it's not dead and you haphazardly loosen the tourniquet,the victim will bleed out much faster. Always write "T" and time on the victim's forehead.
@rc1411 2 роки тому
Yes, but why did she put what looked like a 'M' on him ? What does that mean?
@SpartanUruk Рік тому
This was one of the most enjoyable videos yet, his vast amount of knowledge and experience is incredible to listen to, makes me want to learn more and gives me alot of respect for his professionalism and skill on how to explain things for the casual viewer.
@ginge5253 Рік тому
I don't watch many videos like this, but it makes me realise guys like this doctor (and any front line military personal frankly) are just made from totally different stuff to most of us. I worked in engineering for quite a while and I've seen a few bad accidents, saw a guy crush his fingers in a machine, and a guy drill through his hand on a piller drill. I didn't really freak out or anything but it's stayed with me. But... I couldn't even imagine trying to save someone from bleeding out with an arm/leg blown off all whilst rounds and are whizzing past me and bombs are going off. Just a level of dedication and bravery that is truly astonishing. Also the line about enemy snipers picking off medics to cause maximum casualties was extremely chilling. It makes perfect sense when your goal is to destroy your enemy, but to hear it spoken so matter of factly by a man who would have witnessed it is very disturbing.
@erickzuniga3113 2 роки тому
I remember I had someone with their intestines spilling out. He was screaming and trying to hold them, but that caused him to bleed even more and might have caused a puncture. I covered him up with a AB pad and .9, and remember yelling at him to stop screaming and not grab them. I feel so terrible that I yelled at that man for reacting completely normal. The man wanted comfort and his family, and I yelled at him. I hope he's ok, and I hope someday he and God can forgive me.
@tacticalpossum7090 2 роки тому
Yeah it really sucks yelling at people when they're in pain and just doing the only thing their brain can comprehend. Bringing them back is hard
@AD-ji9ci 2 роки тому
Sounds like you had good intentions. May God bless you.
@ashleyhoerner5280 2 роки тому
in a high-panic, high-stress situation like that, i can imagine it’s impossible not to yell when you’re trying to save their life. you shouldnt feel guilty, what you were doing was out of necessity and for the good of the patient, dont feel guilty God understands :)
@kylegardner9240 2 роки тому
Don't worry if he forgives you, you saved his life. what really matters is if you would be able to accept his forgiveness, and forgive yourself.
@christopherbauer9991 Рік тому
Sounds like you did your best in a very bad situation.
@evankrakovitz6136 2 роки тому
I am a surgeon and I can tell you Dr Rhee is the real deal. He is also a tough grader which is also a surgical trait.
@cleverusername9369 2 роки тому
I'm glad to know that surgeons have very high standards lol that's reassuring!👍
@jasonlang9074 2 роки тому
@@cleverusername9369 😂😂😂
@TheNaturalGamer1 2 роки тому
Surgeons are jerks
@dash4800 2 роки тому
i would imagine you would have to be basically perfect to pass as a surgeon. Its not like you get partial credit for medical care.
@ellvee4262 2 роки тому
@@TheNaturalGamer1 Sure, whatever you say troll, you do realise this tactic for attention is way past its sell by date don't you? Better hurry I think your village is missing you 🤡
@carlinianam0s 2 роки тому
Listening to him talk about what blood is made of reminded me that I haven't donated blood in a while, so I made an appointment for three days from now. Thank you for the reminder 🙏🏻
@tenaciousg4340 Рік тому
This is the best 'Expert Rates' vid out there. Great surgeon, great analysis, and great instructor. Thank you for your service
@Maazzzo 2 роки тому
SO HAPPY TO SEE M*A*S*H GETTING SOME LOVE. Love this series, Peter was really cool. More, please!
@SamuelBernofsky 2 роки тому
Agreeded. I watch years of mash reruns as a kid but had no idea it was this accurate.
@imadeanaccounttocomment7800 2 роки тому
@@SamuelBernofsky it’s accurate to the point that the medical techniques used were also dated to that period, however they are more accurate on representing military bureaucracy than the medical aspect.
@trirain146 2 роки тому
I'm really pleased they did MASH. MASH is kinda all the time in our TV ;). Since the year 1994 (not US) and has really ingenious dubbing and without the artificial laugh
@whiskeygolf2054 2 роки тому
MASH is just the best.
@Nieghorn 2 роки тому
I remember a documentary saying they often asked vet med staff for ideas or they'd recommend things. Incredible series!
@embroiderart6131 2 роки тому
With the MASH one, I'm not surprised at the accuracy. I have heard over the years that the MASH writers and consulting doctor actually went through military medical records and veterans' stories on the types of injuries received/seen during the Korean War and incorporated them into the scripts.
@maskcollector6949 2 роки тому
That makes a ton of sense because it always had some sense of weight to the scenarios. I always grew up watching M.A.S.H. on my worst sick days as a kid (a lot), always made me feel better.
@francescodarcangeli4197 2 роки тому
Love the mix of "war story/expert report" style and his laid-back way of talking. Thank him and every other serviceman/woman posting here for their service.
@ronrobertson59 Рік тому
I was a police officer in a high crime area and I saw a ton of gun shot and stabbing wounds way more than I ever saw in the Army over my career. Bullets do strange things sometimes.
@theoutlook55 Рік тому
Dang, I can believe that, especially if a person start during a relatively peaceful time.
@The_Custos Рік тому
My delightful town, a drunk almost got his head taken off with a broken bottle. Ambos couldn't do anything. High crime areas are wild, and the police were very good at fighting back to back.
@kwill6518 2 роки тому
As a former Hospital Corpsman, I really loved seeing this! I was blessed to be stationed with the Marines and I was required to do this training. I learned SO many life saving and life changing skills.
@fmfdocbotl4358 2 роки тому
Rah
@db336 Рік тому
Oorah Doc!
@jamesb.2064 Рік тому
Ditto
@oliveradams1270 10 місяців тому
Thankyou for your service
@uwu_commrade1682 2 роки тому
Man listening to him explain and talk about things he's done and stories he actually has info on is enough to make your heart feel heavy for the troops. Thank you to all those who serve
@alicelong3613 2 роки тому
Go join. Your words are empty
@timb9363 2 роки тому
@@alicelong3613 lolol, I agree with the other guy’s comment. You’re an embarrassment
@mcpepp3603 Рік тому
@@alicelong3613 Did you serve?
@MQXM001 Рік тому
@@alicelong3613 Go play in traffic
@joshsallee3936 Рік тому
I was always taught tourniquet and get back into the fight. Appreciate the guys like this. I sent plenty that way and when I see them now I have no words. Guys like this helped my friends live. Plus I love you doc! That corspman could've done anything like this guy in my mind!
@jameyteasley3555 Рік тому
Huh??
@dorfo1312 2 роки тому
09:45 "And it was just a ton of fun being out there helping out the troops" The definition of FUN can be very wierd sometimes.
@tigerjonn 2 роки тому
The surgeon who saved my mom's life was also a previous US Army surgeon who had significant experience on the battlefield. I couldn't be more relieved to get a surgeon who performed trauma surgeries on the battlefield.... I knew that this guy knew and understood pressure and performing on my mom would be a walk in the park for a experienced guy like that... Thanks Dr. Kim.... He was also Korean American like Dr. Rhee... I know the famous Korean American Navy Seal, Harvard Medical Doctor, and now Astronaut Johnny Kim was also a medic in the Seals.... Is that coincidence or a lot of military medics and battlefield surgeons Korean Americans..?
@jamesw1313 2 роки тому
Korean parents are notoriously strict, very very strict when it comes to the grades of their children. Actually it is most Asian parents like that. That’s what makes certain groups of people successful and others not successful. Two parents in a home that stress education will have a child that lives above the poverty line 95% of the time. That’s the answer to poverty in this country 1 don’t have a child before 18 2 have a two parent home 3 have both parents be involved in the child’s education If those three things happen, poverty will be ended in any society within one generation. That’s it, that’s all it takes.
@SKoreanKimchi 2 роки тому
I think it’s why South Korea went from being the second poorest country in the world to a country with a bigger economy than Russia in a generation despite its much smaller population and lack of natural resources….
@angelachouinard4581 2 роки тому
@@jamesw1313 You are spot on. I lived in Korea and tutored a lot of Korean kids there and in the States. The parents work hard and the kids are expected to as well. I even had parents as students, they wanted their English to be better to help their kids. My dentist now is Korean and he's overcome a lot of poor past work and is the absolute best.
@wheredamoon 2 роки тому
South Korea only exists because the US came and helped fight the communists. There is/should be a strong sense of gratitude and duty toward the American military for every SK and KAm citizen that fully grasps what happened in Korea in the 50s... It's why I would like to join if I can.
@nongo9508 2 роки тому
@@jamesw1313 yeeea Johnny Kim’s story goes against the grain of your stereotype
@nathangarrett4004 2 роки тому
I remember Dr. Rhee being the doctor fielding questions in a press conference after Congresswoman Giffords was shot, and thinking that this man was going to give her the best shot to survive possible. Heroic.
@lost4468yt Рік тому
Wow I have so much respect for a medical professional who keeps with the times and is more than willing to change with the evidence. There's far far too much dogma in medicine unfortunately, so many ignorant doctors who choose "well that's how we did it in my day" over what the actual data is saying. Huge amounts of respect to Dr. Peter Rhee for understanding that medicine is changing all the time, and that in the grand scheme of things we still know very little. It's people like you who actually push it forward, rather than arrogant GP's who think change is doom.
@albertlitts2191 Рік тому
This has become one of my favorite channels lately,great job on the content and great people you guys get on here. And thank you for your service sir.
@robm2362 2 роки тому
Dr. Rhee is a Ramadi legend. Smartest man on the whole base by far.
@ymatT601 2 роки тому
Boy the PTSD I’d have if I had this man’s job.
@michaellim4165 2 роки тому
Former medic, I deal with this everyday after i got out. It has gotten better over the years, however, it never fully goes away.
@ymatT601 2 роки тому
@@michaellim4165 Man the sight of blood and certain kinds of injuries makes my blood go cold, does that happen in real life?
@mpk6664 2 роки тому
I'm sure there are stories he'll never tell. Seeing dead children is a universal one for most people.
@BigSkyCurmudgeon 2 роки тому
my family doctor when i was young was a meatball Navy surgeon on Guadalcanal. 1943...in late 60s his Midwest general medicine/surgeon life would be interupted whenever would drive near a summer time road killed animal. that bloated smashed stench brought the poor man back to his combat days in the south Pacific islands.
@SSgtCalebP 2 роки тому
I did 9 months with an FST in Afghanistan and saw about 50 battlefield casualties, mostly ANA guys. Never lost a moment of sleep, no PTSD, I loved my job and could hit drinking coffee ☕️ and snacking right after we dealt with double amputees or a GSW to the testicles. Some of it you can be desensitized to, but the reaction is very individual. By contrast I’ve got buddies with bad PTSD from dead bodies who dealt with more trauma than me, and I’ve seen experienced EMTs freak out with bad trauma.
@jasonlavelle3293 2 роки тому
Really enjoyed watching this video, wish it was longer. I love how you went into detail with everything. Great content 👌
@marifazekas5650 Рік тому
He was phenomenal, I could listen to him talk for hours. Would love more videos with him
@bakedAK85 2 роки тому
My dad was a medic/x-ray tech in Vietnam. Told me about the time he helped operate on an ARVN soldier who had a live mortar round in his chest. Surrounded the helipad with sandbags and extracted right there.
@erinjackson6243 2 роки тому
Damn, nerves of steel right there. Did the wounded guy survive that? I'd think a mortar round would leave a pretty significant hole.
@bakedAK85 2 роки тому
@@erinjackson6243 lol! Dad said he was shakin like a leaf. His buddies told him it looked like was trying to run away standing still. The guy did survive btw.
@johneynon7121 2 роки тому
I worked Er/Triage in Vietnam as a Corpsman when a marine came in with a M79 round down his throat. One doctor was able to removei t I saw the X-ray
@johneynon7121 2 роки тому
Of the soilder with the morter round along his side as you mentioned
@justinhackstadt6677 2 роки тому
My father was a field medic that served 3 tours in Vietnam. He's seen things that humanity wasn't supposed to witness. He finally was laid to rest in 2016. 😓
@papillonvu 2 роки тому
May your father rest In peace. He must’ve saved a lot of lives.
@warrencartright5712 Рік тому
Ya, he did, I joined the Tonkin Gulf Boat Club in sixty-nine, so I did not see any land action.
@josephlafrance334 Рік тому
My uncle was a Medic in Vietnam and he was hit in the forehead luckly he's still with us.
@josephlafrance334 Рік тому
@@papillonvu Amen to that ,I was treated by a medic in Iraq and he happened to be from the same town as me . they are angels as far as I'm concerned.
@MeanBeanComedy Рік тому
I hope he's in peace. ✝️🙏🏻
@niofo7713 Рік тому
i'm so glad that you included mash in the list. it was one of those shows that made me become a doctor. i'm not a surgeon, but can attest a lot about the climate of the show, with a lot of dark things happening you kinda get desensitized and humor is one way of dealing with the stress. there is talk going on the doctors' or nurses' office that really shouldn't be repeated outside, but it does make for an absurd/dark comedy, esp when you have to deal with some impossible or ridiculous situations. but never in front of a conscious patient or their family
@TexanAmerican Рік тому
I want more of this guy. Amazing descriptions, to the point, well thought out. I've worked trauma (civilian) for many years as a respiratory therapist and part of the resuscitation team, I could watch him all day.
@aidanrogers4438 2 роки тому
2:39 Know of this drug, Yoda does.
@TPLuo 2 роки тому
It's heart melting to see Dr Rhee getting emotional. This is how most of health care workers feels at times. Thank you for your service.
@mjrchapin Рік тому
Wonderful presentation, clear and concise. Thank you for you service, Dr. Rhee and for sharing your experiences!
@Liquid_Alchemy Рік тому
God bless you Dr. Rhee. It was an honor watching this episode. Thank you for your service.
@differnet 2 роки тому
Thank you Dr Rhee for being there for soldiers. Knowing that such competent people cared for our people is a real comfort.
@russell28533 2 роки тому
As a prior service Marine, thanks Doc for all of the hard work and for being there when we needed you the most.
@LyssaFeniceNotturna Рік тому
What a truly impressive, genuine, articulate, intelligent, and inspiring Man. To dedicate 24 years of your life to saving the lives of the members of our military, to spend that time in combat zones, to do so knowing the risk to one’s own life, and come home and continue to save lives, educate medical professionals and students, and dedicate the remainder of his life to improving the lives of others, saving lives, and improving the medical field with such poise and a happiness that he radiates inspires me to want to live a bigger life and do something to better the lives of others. We need to show the younger generation and our children more examples of people like this in schools, the media, social media instead of the Hollywood nonsense, political agendas, and promotion of self absorption and profound laziness and the belief that mediocrity and handouts are something to be celebrated.
@martinswiney2192 2 роки тому
Wow. Just so relieved to know our armed forces have access to doctors like this. I am just a machinist with no military service. Not serving was biggest mistake of my life. I am so glad we have the men and women capable of doing these tough jobs so I can run a lathe in a free country. Thank you all.
@N17C1 2 роки тому
We are so lucky to have people like this surgeon who work tirelessly to reduce fatalities. And their work will benefit all fields of surgery and medical care.
@246kisses 2 роки тому
I 100 percent agree! I couldn’t imagine seeing the things he’s seen and had to experience
@batticusmanacleas510 2 роки тому
Wow. The knowledge he has of war medicine and history, coupled with his extremely effective articulation, makes this probably the most entertaining expert I've seen on this channel.
@balisong46 2 роки тому
I was a 68W (line medic) with the Infantry in Iraq and Afghanistan and we get accolades, but we all know these guys like Doc Rhee are the real GOATs
@yellowtailhunter 2 роки тому
Great video, we need more of that surgeon! We always had a considerable amount of medical training while training for and partaking in commercial diving but that was mainly focused on barotrauma. I've been to the ER enough times in my life that I'm at the point that this kind of thing just fascinates me.
@EzraB123 2 роки тому
I was a Corpsman with 1/5 and 2/4 (Marine infantry) would have loved to work for this brilliant man. Btw I loved "The Outpost." Just the way grunts talk to each other, the culture, they hit the nail on the head. Great movie.
@alexkalish8288 2 роки тому
Great video with a hero. In the old days in Viet Nam , I was a infantry officer - I had more than one chopper come down to pick up casualties when we were under fire. I was reluctant to call a medivac but they always came no matter what. Those chopper pilots were the bravest of the brave - they immediately became the target. Those are the decisions that haunt you forever - as they didn't always get back.
@mandowarrior123 Рік тому
In Britain, this is the duty our prince volunteered for in service (sea king, so among other duties). It was the epstein one though. They always came because their job wasn't to survive or save lives but to preserve your hope, that someone will always be there for you and your comrades. Complete confidence they can fly so well they can dodge bullets helped. You really shouldn't get bogged down thinking about numbers, or misfortune, when you made sure you had the back of your men. They trusted you to take risks for them, and risks don't always pay off. It isn't possible to account for the lives you theoretically saved and you'll always feel responsible for those lost under your care. You don't need to regret choosing between two bad options. The most important thing to do is to make one. Its for the pencil pushers to do the statistics and set doctrine.
@uuzoo Рік тому
This is an outstanding video! I like how he explains things thoroughly. Thank you very much.
@mollyb.7834 Рік тому
This guy is 100% chill! And sharing tons of knowledge. Absolute hero
@xx2xxCoolioxx2xx 2 роки тому
I loved how he explained the medics side as well. As someone who worked that job he really did great with showing the importance of the first aid care people and then guys like him, the surgeons.
@velonicatgmaildotcom 2 роки тому
I'm so thankful for Americans like this man! Confronting blood and guts! Thanks for your Service, Sir!
@noahdoss1967 2 роки тому
Andrew Garfield's character in Hacksaw Ridge is actually related to me! I found it really startling to hear him put to words a lot of what we've been taught in my family as just the way you're supposed to comport yourself throughout life.
@himeshoney Рік тому
If you are rly related to him... God bless your relative, Desmond Doss, for his service in the military 🙏🏻🙏🏻
@blarghinatelazer9394 Рік тому
I have the utmost respect for your (I would assume) twice-great grandfather. Interesting to hear just how much his philosophy has been passed through your family.
@rotyler2177 Рік тому
Desmond is related to you? That's awesome.
@Henry-yf2np Рік тому
Last name checks out
@joeb1den114 Рік тому
You and your family are cowards just like him?! Wow that’s so neat!
@OldFellaDave Рік тому
Brilliant review. I think I could watch/hear him break down more scenes, or just tell us his stories, for hours more. Interesting to see that MASH, a show that ended 40 years ago, still rates so highly for accuracy. Still one of the best TV shows ever made.
@CyanideGirl94 Рік тому
Full agree. It has always been my personal favorite tv shows, and I wasn't even alive during its original run, lol. It had a huge impact on me during my most formative years.
@MaMastoast 2 роки тому
There's something about that fact that you have two people shoot eachother, then bring them both to the same place to get treated that is incredibly telling about how dumb a lot of the death and suffering in war is
@triciagrant2315 2 роки тому
Happens all the time in a level 1 trauma center.
@gulc 2 роки тому
@@triciagrant2315 Happens a lot in Chicago as well.
@triciagrant2315 2 роки тому
@@gulc I'll bet that happens at any hospital in Chicago.
@scythelord 2 роки тому
Same exact thing could be said of a police officer and a suspect being brought to the same hospital after a shootout. Same justifications, but fewer would call it dumb. War will always exist, saving everyone that can be saved is just what you do.
@MaMastoast 2 роки тому
@@scythelord The two situations are not similar. In the case of two countries at war, we have two governments spending huge amounts of resources to kill eachother's soldiers, only to turn around and spend another another huge amount of resources to try and save the lives of the people they just tried to kill. In the case of the cop vs the criminal, the two parties rarely actively try to get into a shootout and the the criminal is not likely to go out of their way to save the cop.. It's a situation of a power structure subduing a criminal, making it an entirely different dynamic.
@kevinmreams 2 роки тому
As a former combat medic (still active, just changed MOS) it was cool to watch this and have pretty much the same reaction to the scenes.
@Pugrug. 2 роки тому
Same here, great minds think alike.
@B1GK1NG Рік тому
Thank you for your service Dr. Rhee. Love the review of Hacksaw Ridge
@yhau1309 Рік тому
Doc Rhee is very informational; he even explained what is right or wrong. I learned a lot. Thank you
@emmetthowell9265 2 роки тому
When I was in high school I had a nursing class and we were learning basic first aid, they actually made each of us have a properly applied tourniquet to feel just how much pressure you should be putting, because sometimes if you know what is feels like to be done properly you know how to do the same to others. We did have to sign a form saying the school had no liability if the tourniquets hurt us, but the students werent allowed to do them on each other.
@kylieroth2326 2 роки тому
I appreciate him speaking about the bilateral amputation. My uncle stepped on a landmine and became a double amputee so hearing this and not needing to ask my uncle and bring up memories is interesting to me.
@CannibalCarp Рік тому
Thank you for your service. The knowledge you provided was amazing. Respects.
@miSc_dk Рік тому
I cannot find proper words of appriciation for these people, surgeons and medics in/outfield. Bless you
Insider
Переглядів 1,8 млн
Алексей Навальный
Переглядів 4,2 млн
Insider
Переглядів 10 млн
Insider
Переглядів 463 тис.
Insider
Переглядів 9 млн
Insider
Переглядів 2,2 млн
Insider
Переглядів 3,2 млн