it looks like I am the only one that prefers Ren with short hair. He looks so beautiful in this MV😍😍

Idk where the original comment went but there’s a deep theory and story behind this MV: Ren throws up a flower and shows his abs because he’s tired of people calling him a flower or pretty boy. He wants to show that he can be manly and sexy too. Also symbolism of hanahaki disease, the feeling of a one-sided love throwing up flowers. Because no matter how much they love their fans and work hard, they’re not getting it back. JR chases after the fish representing how they’re been so close to chasing fame but never get it. He then eats it to represent a rebirth (their album title) Baekho rips the old boring wallpaper to reveal a prettier more interesting one to represent how in the past he’s never been considered one of the handsomest in Nu’est and wants to show that behind his looks, on the inside he is beautiful (don’t worry baby you’re gorgeous) Aron is seen looking out a closed window representing his longing for America or how much he misses his family and life over in the states. Minhyun is supposed to represent the sacrifices and hardships of Nu’est. Suicide with the bathtub for how much they’ve wanted to give up. And tattooing his own arm to show that no matter what Nu’est is forever. At the end they’re all seen happy jumping with fireworks to represent how they’ve achieved the image they’ve wanted to portray. Goodbye bye is also kind of saying bye to their old selves in the comeback. When I found this out I cried. Hope y’all enjoy and give them lots of love!!!! They deserve it. Nu’est fighting ❤️

my online best friend sent me this song before he commited suicide. he is half korean so whenever hes sad, he can only express himself in korean. im now staring blankly at the screen and crying while this song is playing. i love you kyong, thank you for everything.

Such a good song by Nu'est. They leave good music and disband in good way. No scandal and no bad thing happen in this 10 years. May they success in life and career.

Nuest was the first group that got me into Kpop. I remember my friend showing me their debut, and I thought they were going to be huge. Sad to see talent go unrecognized.

I love nu'est but it's so hard bc it's almost like whoever owns pledis forgets they exist and are signed with them.... 😳

This is the theory of this MV: Ren throws up a flower and shows his abs because he’s tired of people calling him a flower or pretty boy. He wants to show that he can be manly and sexy too. JR chases after the fish representing how they’re been so close to chasing fame but never get it. He then eats it to represent a rebirth (their album title) Baekho rips the old boring wallpaper to reveal a prettier more interesting one to represent how in the past he’s never been considered one of the handsomest in Nu’est and wants to show that behind his looks, on the inside he is beautiful (don’t worry baby you’re gorgeous) Aron is seen looking out a closed window representing his longing for America or how much he misses his family and life over in the states. Minhyun is supposed to represent the sacrifices and hardships of Nu’est. Suicide with the bathtub for how much they’ve wanted to give up. And tattooing his own arm to show that no matter what Nu’est is forever. At the end they’re all seen happy jumping with fireworks to represent how they’ve achieved the image they’ve wanted to portray. Goodbye bye is also kind of saying bye to their old selves in the comeback. I have copied this from another person here in the comment section. I just want to preserve this theory here so that anyone coming late can see it. I love you NU'EST.

NU'EST DON'T HAVE BAD SONGS

Ren's too handsome in this ;-;

Who else came here after watching their newest MV?

The only reason why they've been so underappreciated before pd101 was all because of Pledis incompetent. They got everything to be a top notch group the debut song were great, their concept were one of a kind and unique but because of Pledis were so incompetent they've been slept over. I'm glad they got the attention and recognition but i hope that Pledis didn't fucked them up again

Everyone heard at least one NU’EST song in their life, but they don’t know the title. Guys we are the lucky ones :D my life is not a failure because I am a Love

Hanahaki disease (하나하키병 in korean) is a fictional disease where the victim coughs up flower petals when they suffer from one-sided love. I love the story behind this fictional disease

people sleep differently, i sleep on my left side, my dad sleeps on his back and south korea sLEEPS ON NU'EST

Miss this era so much😢😢😢😢 Shinhwa, Super Junior, TVXQ, SS501, U-kiss, Mblaq, 2PM, Bigbang, Shinee, Infinite, ZE:A, BTOB, B1A4, Got7, EXO, NUEST, Teen Top, BoA, Wonder Girls, Girls Generation, KARA, 2NE1, F(X), Miss A, After School, 4Minute, Sistar, Apink

Ren in this video has otherworldly beauty, he seems ethereal, unreal

ANYONE STILL WATCHING IN 2016? ;) ..this song slayss and so does the video and OMFG REN U ARE SUCH A HOTTIE

I'm not a fan of NU'EST but seeing them on the stage of Produce 101 S2 made me sad (esp. when kahi cried). I have known them for having Unique music videos (in a good way) and they are all Talented, the five of them. I just discovered that the 4 members are participating on the survival show and I hope everyone will support them and they already said that they're desperate and that it maybe their last chance to be on a boy group. Please support them all the way!

Ren 😳I want this look again

The fact that it was 8 years ago I can't believe it ever I miss you guys Take good care of yourself When K-Pop was fine it was the best not now it's full of scandals and insults

Okay I will explain this Mv for those who cant(from my Pov) Its a break up song, and its a very artlike music video * when Jr ate the fish: He wanted to die but intead of pills, theres a fish * So later Ren its on the toilet(All members are like one person) and instead of vomit it was flowers * A rose was burning...its meaning is love coming to and end pretty fast * Members were falling...its meaning is he trusted his way even when he didnt know what the results would be * Members are angry...mostly because of frustation of cant forget about her * Then they realize they can move on, and to show they over her...they all jump(Symbolism) * they scream but intead of sound...theres fireworks....like saying I am now happy that its over *Finally There was an incepcion reference when he falls to wake up..and realizing that it was a dream(ofc the break up part was true, only the symbolisms werent) *The title was double meaning : GoodBye= I hope ur happy //// and Bye= I forget about you

I'm probably the only who prefer Ren with his blond long hair ♡

I'm so sad, because learn about you so late. My favorite song of you is "annyeonghaseyo" - "Hello" ❤

I want NU’EST reunited, at least in a meeting or in a collab ❤❤❤ even of that I’m so happy for their evolution as artists that they are doing great as a solo artist, it’s beautiful to be part of them since 2012 and see their evolution.

2:50 The wall felt Minhyun's high note coming, so it cracked in advance.

FREAKIN REN AND HIS SHORT HAIR HDLCIGECIGEICG I STILL CANT GET OVER IT. HE DESTROYED ME CLWLWIEDW

They predicted this before and it's literally goodbye for real 😢

Anyone else come to say goodbye after the disbanding announcement?

So...Who's on here streaming Nu'est videos after the end pf Produce 101? I am so salty right now.

The flower in Ren's mouth reminds me of a fanmade concept called Hanahaki disease. Where the person with one sided lobe starts vomiting flower petals. It can only be healed with the person liking them back. P.s Ren's hairstyle here is just simply amazing

𝐍𝐔'𝐄𝐒𝐓 𝐝𝐞𝐛𝐮𝐭 𝟗𝐭𝐡 𝐚𝐧𝐧𝐢𝐯𝐞𝐫𝐬𝐚𝐫𝐲 Show time, Nu'est time

14,143!!! Anyone listening to this wonderful song in late 2020 ???

Jr, I think you should cook the fish first before you eat it

REN REALLY LOOKS LIKE LUHAN HERE IM CRYING A LITTLE WHAT

I can't move on knowing that this masterpiece was not recognized.

I am saying goodbye to my old self, i am reborn again and found my true colours.💞

its 2016 and im still not bored of this

The song is so underrated .. Sold so little , no wins , little views. Yet their best track for me . Freaking underrated like Nuest...

I won't lie I'm sad and I'll miss NU'EST so much. But I understand and respect your decision. Thank you so much Aron, JR, Baekho, Minhyun & Ren for all your hard work to always give us good music and beautiful performances. Thank you so much for all the happiness, fun, energy, strength and courage you gave to us these past ten years. I'm so happy and grateful to be a ㄴㅇㅅㅌ and I'll always keep loving and supporting each of you. I wish you to stay healthy, to be happy and to realize all your dreams, you really deserve it guys. 💗🇫🇷

Because despite everything NU'EST is and will be an iconic group in the kpop industry, even if they are no longer together, I will support their career separately.

One of the most underrated songs of 2014.

I dont understant why this song wasnt popular?!!! its like so high quality and yassss kry kry

missing nuest more after watching that hybe picnic day. hoping the boys will find their own happiness and success in this life. will forever be ㄴㅇㅅㅌ 🫶🏻

Who still comes here to listen to this

I honestly am not a fan of NUEST, I am ELF. But between fandoms we have to unite to support them, perhaps we would like this to happen to our Favs? We have to vote for NUEST in produce 101

OMFG WTF REN LOOKS LIKE LUHAN/SEHUN 0.0 WHATTTTT

Ren is so handsome . His hair style is so omg awesome I hope he will use that hair style again :)

Anyone else here to relive the memories?

*AFTER YEARS, I JUST REALIZED REN HAVE HANAHAKI DISEASE HERE*

i absolutely love how Ren looks here T.T he should drop the long blonde looks and keep it dark, he's stunning! :D

NU'EST are visual group

6 years, it's been a long time...

Everybody is talking about Ren and "the guy who eats the fish" (JR.) but... HAVE YOU SEEN MINHYUN? HE LOOKS SO GODDAMN HOT!!!.

There are so many "break up," "I can't live without you" and "I can't forget you" songs and this one is no exception. But Nu'est's song and MV pops out to me in so many ways. The members look like they've matured and don't look and sound like rookies anymore (They are very handsome men). The symbolism in this MV is pretty interesting with the flower and fish. The beat and the dub-step towards the end is awesome and the lyrics are so meaningful which I love. It's catchy too and I can replay it so many times like all other Nu'est songs. Though I admit their latest songs haven't really exceeded their "Face" song, I'm still a fan and I love this song. They are talented and I'll keep supporting them. But seriously these guys need so much more attention. They have huge potential.

Seeing Minhyun in Alchemy of Souls brought me back here. I thought he looked really familiar as soon as I saw him in the series. I miss 3rd gen kpop :

It's really good bye 😢

I don't understand how NU'EST can't be popular like the other boy band . They have good song very much . Just weird .

I can't believe I didn't recognize Ren when I first listened to this!

We need to make this song viral again like sleep talking. Ren hair and features omg . Seriously .

2021? I'm watching

This is one of the best songs NUESTs have but it's so fucking underrated i hate everyone

To think a legendary group is now on produce 101 hurts

Goodbye baby goodbye baby because I'm in trouble! But let me say i got you on my mind i got you on my mind

Who's here in 2021? Happy 9th anniversary to Nu'est

When i first saw the guy grabbing for the fish: "Ha hes probably gonna eat it..that would be funny" When he ate it: " WTF"

Well this was just intense from start to finish.. First Off ABS... You've been holding out on us all this time Ren and the Hair Cut looks fresh... 2nd Did Jr. really just eat that fish... man Jr. if you wanted fish I could have made dinner for two with Fish as the main course.. lol.jk 3rd Baekho that hair color tho... and I'm lovin you redecorating the place in the Video the 2nd layer of wall paper is Definitely a better look, 4th Minhyun boo boo don't give yourself tattoos when you're angry you gon regret it later, also don't fall back in to the Bath Tub like that you might hurt your handsome self... And last but definitely not least My Main Squeeze Aron... You done had fireworks coming out your mouth, now that's determination and fitting since your raps are like FIRE!! lol... ALL in ALL in case you haven't noticed I enjoyed the MV and the Song NUEST FIGHTING!!!

🤘Thank you "JR", "Aaron", "Ren", "Baekho", and "Minhyun" for putting all their talents into the best for NU'EST. Throughout the past 10 years🥰

2020, Love Nuest

when ren vomited flowers, I honestly only thought of hanahaki syndrome, which is a fictional disease where flowers grow on the back of someone's throat, and they slowly die, either choking on the petals when coughing it up, or the hanahaki flower's roots spread to vital organs. hanahaki happens when the person they love doesn't love them back, so they literally die of love just an interesting bit of information

Lolz, who would have thought that a pretty guy like Ren would have abs? O.O and by the way, his hair fits him well… By some angle, he Ren looks like EXO's Luhan O.O

im still here.

Loves let's go to next mv action after that bet bet

i'm sorry but hwang minhyun is so hot i can't handle this he is literally the whole package i can't breathe

i think this song is so good but it is so underrated

Let's for 20 million

14,159!!! unsurpassed song!

Reading this made me sad x.x "The LOVEs are very aware that NU’EST is not doing as well they used to. All LOVEs understand that the significance of the word “rebirth” isn’t just literal, that there is a metaphorical resonance to NU’EST themselves. This comeback is about them getting back in the game, re-establishing themselves and acquiring the popularity they lost. They are extremely nervous about this comeback, because they are aware that this is potentially their last chance to prove themselves as worthy competitors to other popular groups." This song is so good; please help them get the success they deserve :)

OMG Ren without his blond hair makes him look kinda like Levi, if u know wat im talking about... from Attack on titan

**I can Overcome**

Nostalgia

choi minki could step on me and i’d honestly thank him, like damn. what a guy

nuest have so many good songs and they have like five beautiful visuals??? , why are they being sleep on??

14,030!!! Baekho's hair color was gorgeous on him !!!!

Still listening to her in 2021!! I will love you forever!!!!!!!!!

Okay NU'EST killed it. They also killed me. They look so prefect but Baekho's hair has gotta to go. That hair is not doing it for him. He would look so much better with black or ash blond hair. Come one stylists get it together. Apart from Baekho's hair everyone looks so unf. Baekho's body is just woah and his thighs dayum boy you is thick. Ren my pretty boy he's turned so manly but also pretty. JR he looks so good with that blond hair my kimchi dang. Okay Minhyun as soon as I saw his trifling face he killed me. He looks so much like Park Seo Joon like his twin brother. And Aaron im sad he didn't get as much lines and I really want the stylists to do something about his hair it looks good but hes had that hair since like debut. And that song ughhgghg its a NU'EST feel type kinda song and its amazing. Can't wait for the live performance. And also dance practice version. Ughgghhghghggh

They even didn't show aron in this mv

Still here

14,151!!! I love this song and even more when I listen to it

Me: 1: *dies seeing Rens ABS* 2: *gets alive again bc needs the daily doze of Nu'est* 3: *REPEAT*

NU'EST ❤ Oh. My. God. Ren is so different!~...*in a good way ^^* But I'm more used to his old look -even though he's prettier than me xD-

And let me say Good bye bye baby good bye babe

I love you JR ARON BAEKHO MINHYUN and REN ♡

NU'EST Members: 0:19 Minhyun (Singer) 1:18 1:26 Aron (Singer and rapper) 0:32 Ren (Maknae and singer) 1:36 JR (Leader and main rapper) 2:00 Baekho (Singer) Fandom name: L.O.V.E. (ㄴㅇㅅㅌ)

NU'EST 2019 comeback

Good bye bye baby

Loves please support NU'EST final Comeback on March 15!!!!!

ren is look more handome with his black short hair he looks more manly !! agree???

Three years and I can't believe my kids have gotten zero recognition. I'm a proud Carat, but I truly believe SVT have amazing superiors to look up to in their agency. NU'EST will recover, I won't accept anything else instead.

minhyun's hair in here is so superior :')

2024❤ it’s been 13 years with them singing in my ear.