It sounds like Minority Report is becoming more fact than fiction.

Tom Cruise didn’t have a good time with predictive policing in Minority Report

It is never okay. You cannot charge someone for a crime that has never occurred on the presumption of it being committed.

I believe there is two important questions to adress: 1) radicalisation throught online activities increased in the past years, leading authorities to develop ways to monitor what is going on online in hope of helping to prevent crimes that frightened people. 2) the second big question is about the scientific validity of the predictions based on data collected online. These tools, with incorrect input data, or incorrect auto-confirmation loops, can become "Weapons of math destruction" (see Cathy O'Neil's book). To disregard the technology seems as premature as considering it as reliable as the truth. Maybe we should think about mecanisms that can be put in place to balance the potential adverse effects of those technologies. There is still the future of the world ahead of us that needs to be designed and adjusted to fit our democratic values and laws...

I Wish this story included interviews with the victims that Damian robbed. That might put this into a broader perspective.

Let`s say: One of my friend took my phone and committed crime on my account or hackers stole my id and use it on behalf me online. How would police know? That`s absolutely insufficient system, could cause misinterpretation.

That's RL Minority Report. We, the populace, are so very screwed if we don't unite against stuff like this. And given the fact that 90% of humanity has been rendered completely inert and docile...we're screwed beyond measure.

The mother is so wise and insightful. She clearly somes up the whole documentary in a few words.

"Life altering consequences" Do you mean for the criminals or their victims?

How could it ever be used the wrong way? Don't think about it though, they'll have a machine for thought crime too.

It's just a nightmare for free and adequate people. "1984" or even worse. I dream about a free world without total surveillance, tracing and with a possibility to pay with Bitcoins everywhere. I live in the Netherlands now, and I'm extremely ashamed that this system works in Amsterdam. It'll target mostly minorities. The Amsterdam police department is awful.

Right, while the 'big guys' commit crime with impunity, exemption. Get it?

Really efficient and accurate documentary! Great work!

The real question? Does predictive policing reduce the likelihood that those likeliest to commit crimes will ultimately be saved from imprisonment for committing crimes?

"Should the machine have the last word?" ... well, if the answer is supposed to be no, who does have the last word? The same people (local police) that managed to teach an algorithm how to be racist by learning from their behaviour? Sounds like the problem is a bit greater and algorithms are just a new kind of a prof that something is wrong.

You don't need a computer to tell you. You just look at how extensive their criminal record is.

Love the program! Are you guys able to do another episode on the opposite side? Like how to use big data to passively address crime and poverty if it is being used for that at all?

The cops, the government, the reporters, the people interviewed, this video... you all miss the biggest point. If the computer can predict which conditions lead to crime we just could, you know, CHANGE THEM?! How about preventing people from becoming criminals, instead of focusing on policing every potential criminal?

the more social media presence you have the more information they have to determine ur paters to determine your behavior

Psycho-Pass called it! There's a whole show set in a dystopian future where this is the standard, check it out!

Somebody's been watching too much Minority Report the movie.

The penalties that come with a program like this . I think would push people into a kind of self fulfilling prophecy

I think they are asking the wrong question. The real question is whether the police should be able to target known criminals for increased monitoring. A lot of the time if there's a string of crimes the police know who likely did it and who to ask for their locations. They know where they live and who their friends are. Most crime is by recidivist criminals, you don't need a computer to remind you of that. Whether the software exists or not the police "know the locals". Like the software they make mistakes, police are frequently prejudiced, police will never leave some people alone even if they have never committed a crime. Software on the other hand will remove someone from the list who was previously marked as a criminal or potential criminal if they change their ways or don't commit crimes. Not all juvenile delinquents grow up to be criminals. Perhaps we should be working on software to do this and making sure it works well. It's quite the damning statement, but maybe we can trust the software more than the police. Software can modified, tuned and trained. Police on the other hand have had the same problems for hundreds of years and little seems to be changing.

I was asked once a few questions by the Danish Police due to racial profiling, and I had no problem with that - why should I, I have nothing to hide. The police did their job in keeping their country save and I asked in return how to get to the city quickly and it was a passive conversation. People are just too spoiled and weak nowadays and get emotionally frustrated for little to no reason.

Predictive Policing isn't just used against past muggers. Its used on people who've lost civil cases. Most likely, those losses will happen, because they're low income and can't afford to hire a lawyer to defend them in court.

Minority Report is not a sci-fi movie anymore

Wow, almost like we should not let mass surveillance and the state get too out of hand?

Problem is using it to punishe the people. Don't give it to police Give it to the social workers.

U.S policing budget $ 123 Billion ........Britain's Defence Budget $ 68 Billion ...........WHY ??????

This is just another way to control people and carry out discrimation.

The potential of misuse is there and large - programs are programed by people who should follow science but may follow instructions from people in power. Therefore, opposition and government uncomfortable people can be 'observed' with a somehow legal system - by the outside view. Other countries use it as well. Transparency?

Doesn't seem right that his brother, who had not been convicted of a crime would be subject to this. It did, however, seem to work well with the 2-time violent criminal.

Sounds like Pasco county, Florida

You have 20 seconds to comply.

No crimes here. I am. Tqrget. Doing NOTHING. No record. My community is monitoring everywhere.

Person of Interest.

Sooo, how about a study: generate the lists. Randomly select half. Treat the selected half like proposed (increased police surveillance etc.). Treat the other half as not on the list. After some time, compare the two groups. Did the social programs help or did they commit more crime?

Man, such bad data from ridiculous data collection. Calling it all "historically embedded" is giving a high-brow error status it simply doesn't deserve. I'm not in principle against the preventive intent of predictive programming, but it's like the ol' saying: Garbage in, garbage out. And then, to not even examine its effectiveness ....

Start with the cops and politicians!!

I remember watching this movie…

Guilty until proven innocent

Wow! Watch_Dogs in real life! What was the message of that game again? Oh never mind, it must have been a manual just like 1984.

Gangstalking

Problem is, is that the program is done by humans and the folks programming it will still have prejudice!

Great idea! I'm a software engineer, how can I contribute?

As you are programmed with the AlphaBet' like a computer, the System can foreCAST your REaction to certain Events like the PlANDEMonIC

I wager that reoffenders may reoffend.

They should do one to surveil police brutality

I will guarantee I'm predicted to do everything bad. Soon, It'll be that i breathe and that just cannot go unpunished.

Predictive policing, utilizing statistical data, especially race or ethnicity, sex, age, poverty and history, will reduce crime dramatically. The loop where certain ethnicities, or statistical groups get overlabeled from predicting policing focusing on their neighborhoods, is a short term unfair affect. If a wrong neighborhood gets focused on, or overfocused, this will get reflected in future statistics. Their crime rate will drop, other neighborhoods will rise, overlabeling them. The point of view of a victim is not presented. Point of view of worrying families with vulnerable loved ones is not presented. Did Amsterdam's crime rate drop dramatically after the program, not presented. They did mention, he got off the system but at the very end, not when they introduced the concept. Most undecided to be influenced by this report probably already formed their opinion and unlikely to change it, despite the last part. Report does mention, predictive policing, can be a mask to implement a different program designed to control dissent. Predictive policing, is a double edged policy. It works, in my opinion, however, is it worth it regarding side consequences it will have, is the question. Predictive policing makes society less forgiving, more reactive and self-centered, for better or worse, this will affect other policies, but it does dramatically reduce crime. The victim, especially of violence, usually will have dramatically different opinion on this than the perpetrator, while everyone else, wont know everything about the situation, the most important part, the experience of it. Maybe victim's experience is much worse than people who never were victims might think. Maybe perpetrator feels especially unfair being labeled. The report was biased, and misleading in my opinion, it presents predictive policing to appear not to work, it does. NYC and other areas got clean from similar policies in the past, and now without them, crime rate is much higher, some areas near anarchy, held together by social welfare, mainly caused by people of same ethnicity, sex, poverty level and history. Regardless, i doubt one knows enough to make a right choice on the topic, so this becomes an ideological issue. I say no, but only for that reason, not because i think it is unfair, or doesnt work.

This is LITERALLY The Minority Report

9:20 I swear I said the same thing in a comment before I heard this lady say the same thing

Terrifying concepts like this is why media like Psycho-Pass is made

So Psycho Pass is now real...

What data is used in predictive policing?

Eagle eye is here

33:222 I like it. This is good. I am no man

"Minority Report" ...........

Welcome Big Brother! 🤣

Lifetime harassment for their spouses too.

They know if they have a history of domestic abuse yet they probably don't do anything about it and just hope they grow up healthy

It's not a problem to use technology to prevent crime. This is not like "minority report". The problem is that prison and other punishments do not prevent reoffending. So, once someone is in the system, they are marked, often for life. Only early intervention at home, in schools can stop a fall into criminality. Rehabilitation is important, but rarely implemented well in our society.

It's a scapegoat for the justice system. Spikes in crime lead to "Tough on crime" policies which in turn lead to discriminatory practices etc... & on & on.(On going cycle) The police & lower courts can say: " It's the data's fault" "The cold calculus of the machine doesn't lie or choose sides" When in fact it all comes down to a much larger issue of class discrimination. More the economic cast system gap widens the more disenfranchised less privileged people become. And more desperate The irony is that everyone contributes to it. By purchasing that giant T.V. & season pass for your favorite team or movie series your in fact putting money in the hands that want to maintain the status quo. Escapism is big business (One example of how we vote w/our wallets)

Whats is this pre probation?

Minority Report, go and watch...

Ultimate form of profiling.....

Hmm good way of serial killers to avoid the law. This if flawed

Seems like a terrible idea. A computer program is written by people and those people might have biases. The computer is going to have the same bias as the people who wrote the software. It also raises privacy concerns, is this software used with or without a warrant? These lawmakers so proud of their machine. How long before said machine accuses them of a crime?

Minority Report is no longer just a movie

Minority Report. Watch that movie.

Any person resisting these arrests should be immune to charges under self defense, any cop using force under these arrsts is by default guilty aka only penalty face as gilt is estabished by action. 100% fair for both sides........KILL a cop that arrst you becuse a predction and you ALWAYS go free, if a cop uses any level of force to arrset someon on a prediction then the op is by default guilty of mutlple flonies while armed and must server a minimum of 30years in prion, and any treial is a summry and public one only telling the cop that now you go to derve in prion for 30 yrs becuse of your actions...that is fair for both sides, and i no way whatsoever unfair on the individual officer

psycho pass vibes

Minority Report

This is a perfect example of when a criminal makes himself a victim when the criminal is paying the consequences of his actions. Don't break the law so that you will not be a suspect. If you want to start over and begin a new life, receive Jesus Christ as your personal Lord and Savior and your past will be erased and forgotten forever by God being washed by the blood of the Lamb, Jesus Christ. John 14:6 Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me. John 8:36 If the Son therefore shall make you free, ye shall be free indeed.

OH WELL KRAMER

great now we'll get prosecuted for pre-crimes

I love it. Evil people, wrong doers will be always there. You cannot prevent them from being born. We need to improve our system to prevent evil people from doing harm to the innocent. I have nothing to hide and my intentions are good. I am fot it. Waiting for better results.

Computers understand how karma works. That's how they know more

Ok, nice. So all I have to do is pay to future-seeing cop the fine for my future murders and ill be ok. Its as if nothing changed at all!! NNNNIIIIICCEEEEE...

i m sure a criminal, if they keep track of my search keywords... lol

⌛📡 OLD NEWS! ⏳

Round up the usual suspects.

Old people with too much free time

Remember, laws are written by the rich.

This is a documentary mostly produced in the Netherlands i see. Its true most criminals are revolving door criminals. Nothing wrong with some smart policing. Watch a episode of ''opsporing verzocht'' and you will get a good insight on where in which hives criminality thrives. Just saying..... I am dutch and not racist.

Gangstalking.

what could possibly go wrong...LOL people suck

Lol. Are they going to predict when influential people are going to commit crimes, or just us peons?

America lol

I may be in the minority but I kinda like where this is going... Don’t like my opinion?? report me then.

Lol. The new phase of authoritarianism.

Even with the current dip , I'm so excited I've built my portfolio to $50,560 from my weekly trade. I'm having my fourth withdrawal in 10 business days

terminator

mInOrItY rEpOrT