I feel bad for the ones who had to *stand* for *that long*

I could tell the girl was lying about her Uncle from the beginning. Mixing up ages, relationships, locations, etc.

The woman said she thinks it was winter then said she thinks it was during spring break...

The biggest tell that it was Dan was his reaction while standing at the back wall. He was definitely feeling worse the more he had to tell his story and listen to the other two lie.

The best part was the look on the private investigators face when the psychic gives her excuse

Dan looked very distressed while the others tell their stories, he was literally hugging himself for comfort

They give it away with the warning at the beginning.

The reason why the PI took so long is because he’s a professional and as a professional interrogator, you don’t need to think about things like how long it’s taking, the one and only goal is to find out the truth, wether it takes 10 minutes or 10 hours.

The woman was such a bad liar lol

100% thought it was Nate. His body language, story, and he got red while talking about it. He seemed so real, I feel betrayed lol

This woman is trying to trick a private investigator while laughing about her uncles "death" lol

The fact that the regular dude figured it out in a quarter of the time with half the questions...give that man a job 👏🏻 Edit: PLEASE omg I’m not being literal this is not to disrespect the PI or anything you don’t need to argue under this 😭

I like how the private investigator asked her how old she was when her uncle died at the beginning and then again later to make sure she had a straight story

Why are the other 2 just standing in the background. I feel uncomfortable.

Of course the psychic immediately blames someone else for why she guessed wrong

It was easy to guess when you looked at them standing in the back line. Dan was just staring out into space the whole time reliving the moment. Kind horrible tbh.

I knew it was Dan immediately because I was there! I couldn’t believe it when he started telling the story! If this is the same situation, which is HAS to be, the guy had been release from incarceration that day, robbed a gas station and then made his way to the turnpike. He did have a weapon and the police were called because he was aiming his gun at cars. We didn’t see the body, it must have been on the other side of the road, but it was a really sad situation and super scary to be in traffic.

“Hello! I’m a professional bullshitter and I’m here today to compete against...”

I feel like they could of cut this video a lot shorter? We’re listening to everyone’s stories over and over again,,

If she was really psychic, why would she even need to as questions?

You could really tell Nate is in Hollywood for acting, he was laying it on so thick 😂😂😂

Nate is a good actor tho he almost got me

I like how the PI is so frustrated whenever the psychic talks

The private investigator winked after they revealed it was dan telling the truth and I died.

Matthew only took 12 minutes and figured it out WHAAATT

17:16 Take a look at this frame and you'll figure out who's telling the truth. The topic of death clearly affects one person more than the other two.

I’m floored that the normal guy spent 12mins and was the only one who was sure and right

"Where are you from?" "Florida" Well this guy is from Florida so that's the end of the video, isn't it?

Nate's was kind of a story that happens a lot - runners find the bodies of homeless people. So gut wrenching.

That guy nate was good but he had a big tell, he kept blushing LOL his cheek kept getting redder and redder as he was talking

It’s very interesting to see the inconsistencies in their stories, and how they change the story slightly each time it’s told

as soon as the "psychic" asked their names, I was like "yeah, great job so far"

-Psychic was wrong- "Oh, it's only because I didn't get a good enough reaction of his girlfriend and didn't ask about the smell of the roof of the car and also where the sun was positioned that day" Yeah okay man.

everyone’s asking for ryan and shane but honestly this is some quality content

I love seeing a so called psychic losing to an actual detective AND some random guy

The "psychic" made me REALLY uncomfortable, like seriously, the dude can't cross his arms?

why wont y'all understand Shane and Ryan ONLY do unsolved if it doesn't say unsolved don't say you got your hopes up

So basically, a regular person like this could give you a good impression on who would be lying, but if you need to be absolutely sure, you need an investigator. ...also just don't hire psychics. You can hang with them but don't put important decisions on them.

The girl changed her story a couple of times and Nate’s didn’t make sense. He said the guy was missing for 2 days and yet his body was 5 minutes down the trail.

The lady is such a bad liar lmaoo

Wow, Dan was actually the one i didnt believe the most. 💀 i thought Nate was telling the truth.

It's a psychics job to lie to people.

The woman said “my dads sister” but then told the other guy, “my moms brother”

Imagine having the nerve to say “professional psychic”.

You forgot to put "psychic" in quotation marks.

the psychic giving her bs excuse 😂👌

The woman's story hit me hard because that's exactly how my cousin and I found our grandpa.

“PLOT TWIST!” *The “Psychic” is the REAL liar!*

gee the one relying on magic hoopla was wrong, go figure

The fact that Dan looks like Remus Lupin just makes me love him even more

Man, I thought it was Nate for sure. He seemed really believable as far as his details of interacting with the police. And Dan’s story seemed like he kept getting confused on if he was coming from or going to Miami. I was confused by it anyway.

I thought it was Dan because initially he said, "I haven't told this story to many people..." and I thought that was an extremely personal sort of disclaimer and a bit too clever for a liar. And then he said that, "They don't cover the body like you'd think they would," and I don't think someone trying to weave a believable story would not give such a casual/opinionated statement

Wait, where’s logan paul?

Definitely interesting to hear the discrepancies in the details after being told over and over.

Dan was the most calm, consistent and when the other two laughed, he didn't. surprised that the psychic got it wrong, even if they're scammers, they're supposed to be good at reading people to be successful "psychics"

I'm crying laughing at the fact that an average person knew better than a "psychic" lmaoooooooo that woman was basing this off nothing 😂

Raise ur hand if u dont care if its shane or ryan ur here to enjoy good content.

for those of you who expect content with shane and ryan: don't. there won't be more from them until a new season of buzzfeed unsolved is announced by buzzfeed and that'll be in like 4-6 months. (what i say MIGHT not be 100% correct, i speak from what i know of being a fan for over two years. wait for an actual announcement from buzzfeed.)

I love how the PI asked for specific details because you get traumatic experiences ingrained in your mind, probing for details missing or changed

What's interesting is that you could tell right away just by looking at them - there's one thing we do when we lie that we just don't realize,, and I don't think it's possible to just sort of abandon this behaviour without any special training. It's a thing we do subconsciously, a thing we just don't have control over without knowing. Just look at their eyes. When we tell lies, we tend to look *right and up* - it's where we look to visually construe things - same for the *right side* which is for all the auditory stuff. That's what the woman did the most - her eyes were twitching to the right side all the time; once you know it, it's really so obvious. However, and that's why I knew it had to be Dan from the beginning, if you look at the *left* upper side and the left side, that's when you recall and remember *true memories* . So next time you're unsure whether someone's telling the truth or not, just remember: Every direction we look in has a meaning.

Maybe at the end of each season, Ryan and Shane should announce that ending a season means there will be a season break, and how that means there won't be episodes, and that for algorithm* reasons, they have to keep uploading videos on this channel. And like, maybe that clip could be posted as its own video half way through the season break, to calm some people down. (* no offense meant to the producers of these, I'm sure you also have creative reasons and pressure-from-buzzfeed reasons, but the algorithm is why they need to be regularly posted on this specific channel)

Why start the video by telling us who's story was real? Completely ruins the fun of trying to figure it out myself.

She’s a “professional” psychic? So I guess she went to Hogwarts?

I get it right from the beginning when Dan start explaining his experience it felt real and his physical reaction as well helped me figure out that he was telling the truth, but I must say Nate was also a good liar but at some part It didn't seem right for me, and the girl I knew immediately she was lying because of the way she was telling the story.

"psychic" lol

Nate said he was on the way to a film set- made me think he's an actor and I was suspicious of him after that.

17:15 Dan didn't even laughed there while the other 2 did.

Thats not a real psychic. A real one doesn’t have to ask questions.

D'vaughn to the detective: "It was in Winter" D'vaughn to the physic: "It was um like spring break?"😁😄

Is it only me or Nate's story is more realistic? He's cute too. Haha. 😅

I feel so bad for the people in the back lol. please get them a chair 😂 they stood for so long

Psychic: Exists FBI Behavioural Science Unit: Am I joke to you?

I thought this was going to be one of those things where ALL three were telling the truth or something. :P

I could tell it was dan because of the way he kept his eyes down and talked with his hands like he was trying to visualize the event in his head.

I love how even I got it right and the psychic didn’t 😂

Nate’s cheeks got super red like he was nervous telling the story like it would have been a lie.

The psychic is already lying in general.

"bEsIdEs ThE DeAtH-" I love this guy.

If John spent 46 mins asking questions how come we only see seven minutes of it

With Nate you could really see the pain in his eyes and how uncomfortable he was. It’s sad that he lied but you can 𝕜𝕚𝕟𝕕𝕒 tell by how he’s listening to Dan tell the story he’s really interested. But his excessive blinking 𝕜𝕚𝕟𝕕𝕒 gave it away. But Nate said in a ditch then next to a tree IN THE SAME INTERVIEW.

Used to work at a nursing home, post-mortem care was part of the job description. 🤷‍♂️

So they're telling me that only one out of the three people has attended a funeral?

It’s interesting to see their lies develop and then become more comfortable in the extra details asked of them when telling the next person.

the vibe and body language of the people being questioned is completely different between the PI and the psychic's questioning

Seems like Shane and Ryan need their own channel.

Quoting the GREAT PATRICK JANE-"There is no such thing as psychics"

hey buzzfeed! just wanted to say this is an amazing video, and i would love more content like this! i’ve been waiting for y’all to capture me back in, and with hopefully more content like this, i’ll be sure to stay! i love the unsolved series but i think this would make a great series as well!

*_I'll try to figure it out myself_* After I saw the PI questions: It's definitely the guy with long hair he looks like the kind of guys to see death After I saw the psychic questions: The guy with brown jacket sound believable and didn't even laugh, The girl is definitely not her! After I saw the regular guy: It's definitely one of the guys , tho at 17:16 everyone laughed except the guy with the brown jacket/Short hair Idk i think its the brown jacket guy he looks genuinely affected by the death edit: Yaaayyy I did it !

Yessss so happy that John is back!

please do a video on haunted fort of Bhangardh (Rjasthan,India). People believe that this fort is really haunted but are the stories true or they are rumors.

Nate even remembered the rain detail. Damn thats affected him deeply i guess... 😕

This was so entertaining. Keep these kinds of ideas coming buzzfeed.

the moment i saw the physic shake their hands i knew it was over for her

i’m so glad that the psychic got it wrong omg

It's funny how the subjects are significantly more nervous with the psychic than with the pi

The wink by the PI at the end was amazing!! Love that guy

I hope they got paid for doing this cause I would not feel like standing in the background for that long

I feel like the psychic should write down who they think it is prior to questions and then after.

Guessed dan correctly too! It’s usually the uncommon and somewhat crazy stories that are real bc I find that the lie stories are always things that happen commonly in order to seem more real and have less details so they don’t mess up their story

I knew almost immediately. He was the only one confident in his story, and there were so many details that he was sure of. He didn't repeat, "I think," like the other ones, and the way he looked at everyone else during their interrogations vs how everyone else looked straight ahead. Also their body language throughout the entire thing, including the cadence of their voices. I don't know; there seemed to be so many tells.