0:00 - Strawberry Conman 3:11 - Killer Prostitute 9:57 - Arm Amputation 13:43 - Horse Kicks And Kills Its Owner 14:16 - Ku Klux Klan Meeting 16:10 - Peeping Toms 17:18 - Chelonian Suicide Jump 18:36 - Finding Tucker 21:04 - Prisoners Kill Lawmen 21:57 - Kidnapped Boy

I love the addition of John yelling "CHELONIA!" if he jumps with them.

The Killer Prostitute one is pretty wild honestly. I never knew you could straight up walk the body to the sheriff office and report her and get her executed. Didn’t think she was a serial killer either. But I guess that makes the fact that she tries to kill you with no hesitation if you deny helping her make a whole lot more sense😂

20:39 Arthur: *watches a man mourn his dead friend and get torn apart by a grizzly bear seconds later* Also Arthur: *lights cigar and continues to watch*

Abigail: Worried that John will die in a gunfight while bounty hunting or tracking down Micah John: *CHELONIA!*

I didn’t know you could jump and scream, “Chelonia!” as well. That’s hilarious! I want to hear Arthur do it too...

Fun fact for you: You can see the hanging of the amputee from Number 8 in Saint Denis at some point in the future. He killed a woman who was mocking his injury or "disfigurement" as the lawman puts it. God, I love this fucking game so much.

13:43 there's actually good ending in this situation. You just gotta scare the horse by riding next to it at high speed. The owner asks you to catch it, you catch the horse, come back with it to the owner and he just rides away on it.

20:37 Athur: sees bear attack someone Also arthur: *smokes cigar and drink alchohol.

I never got the killer prostitute event, but I straight up ran into her execution outside Valentine. I didn’t know a thing about her but she sounded honest to me when she tried to defend herself before being hung, so I killed everyone and saved her. Had to pay a 150$ bounty just to find out now that she was guilty the whole time. Damn.

The horse killing it's owner scared the living shit out of me the first time

Almost three years, guys, and this game still suprises me. What a Masterpiece.

18:28 Alright Rockstar, you got me there.

Fun fact about the killer prostitute if you do this event as John he writes a journal entry about it where he asks himself why he helped her before commenting that she reminds him of Abigale before she joined the gang

2:09 the threat "eat shit and die" has never been more appropriate😂

18:25 proves rockstars the best game studio ever, obv they had some players jump and went the extra mile to add the dialogue if they jump xD

When that con man popped back up from the outhouse and spit out the shit-water, I gagged. Probably one of the most disgusting scenes ever.

18:28 CHELONIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!

It's crazy to think how big this game actually is. The prostitute had like 5 different story lines and Rockstar made dialogue for every scenario but because you only get to play one version of the story you forget how much of the game there actually is in the background.

13:43 This was one of the first random events I encountered in the game, and I thought it was the craziest thing I had ever seen. How little I knew back then...

9:58 are we not going to talk about how massive that horse is????

20:40 wtf dude ahahaha i don't know if this was badass af or the worst thing i've ever seen

18:30 I did NOT see that coming! 😂 I actually laughed out loud.

From all my time of playing this game i never knew you could turn the proustite into the sheriff. I would have done this if i knew because that sheriff is actually one of my favorite characters. So much depth for a side character.

14:16 For the first Klu Klux Klan meeting I stole one of the horses, and I had an entire army chasing after me 😂

2:16 this wins the "Most Fucked-Up Way To Die Award."

The last one is really sad, and the worst is that in real world are hundreds of similar cases.

Imagine dying by drowning in shit-😭😭

I think the finding Tucker one is probably one of the saddest side stories you can find in the game

Arm amputation was one of my favourites, its a way the game shows you the existence of saint denies if you haven't explored it already

Kinda late to the party, but I found out at 13:43 that you can just not intervene and the horse will run off and you can lasso it and bring it back to it's owner for honor.

Im sorry for the guy that got eaten by bear at finding Tucker he was just trying to find his friend

anyone else cry at the end of the game?

The chilonia one was awesome I never would have thought to follow them off the cliff or expected John or Arthur to shout that out while doing it that's great

Hunter: Being brutally murdered by a bear Arthur: I feel like i need to take a smoke Hunter: Is being torn apart by a bear Arthur: I'm a little parched, let me drink some Kentucky Bourbon Hunter: Is being eaten alive by a bear Arthur: Ooh, what a nice hat i found!

I remember when I did the one where you take the guy to get his arm amputated ,my horse was dead ,but I wasn’t gonna let him die ,so I walked all the way from lagras to saint denis to save his life

10:00 holy shit look how big Arthur's horse is compared to the other one o.O I also like how in the bear attack he's like "a cigar, in remembrance of this tragedy. And pour a shot for my homie."

I’ve played this game for over two years, and didn’t know about the Chelonian suicide jumps! Awesome, thanks! 👍🏻

10:00 why is that horse so big 😭😂😂

Some of these events have even more outcome or variants , for example If you help killer prostitute she will kill another guy in few days after and will ask for your help again Guy you help with his infected arm will be executed few day after for killing girl. You can save that guy getting kicked by his horse by interacting with him in different way (then you can help him with his run away horse) Kkk will try to make another meeting spot and two of them will get crushed by wooden cross xD And finally peeping toms , you can find them in different towns like Strawberry where if you look in the window , lady will try to shoot you with shotgun

20:39 that’s not supposed to be happening where did the bear come from? Od hang fen farm 😂

Fun fact: if you mislead the guy trying to drown the conman the conman will thank you then fall into the toilet and drown

24:24 the honor system in this game is so stupid sometimes. You lose honor for telling on the conman? It's not my fault that the dude decided to drown him in shit.

"For Chelonia!!!" I love that Rockstar anticipated players jumping off the cliff.

18:25 i love how they actually have a voiceline for this

I love how nobody cares about the giant ass horse Arthur is riding.

My favourite thing in rdr2 is the random events they are so good and creative

I love how John also shouts Chelonia

Fun fact... everyone can't be First....

5:49 i love how malloy all of a sudden stared walking like he was a player

I had a hilarious encounter with a hunter, I believe he was. It takes place (at least it was when I encountered him) when you meet with the Natives and there's a camp close to where the soldiers stole the fragments. After I killed them, the camp is still there, and some hunter guy took it over. He talked about some cougar or panther near St Denis. After he recognized me, he got on his horse and tried to flee, but he ran into the tent right next to the fire. His horse died and landed on the fire, and he was stuck and kept running into the tent next to his dead horse. The horse caught on fire, and since he was do close, he caught on fire too. I kept laughing my ass off for a few minutes. I wish I had that recorded.

When I did the first one, I was expecting Nigel Westdickens to be the conman

I was screaming the whole time shoot the bear lmao

The horse killing it's owner sometimes doesn't kill him, and turns into a fetch quest fyi.

11:17 why is your horse so big

18:28 was pretty good, caught me off gaurd

What’s funny is that saving the conman from the angry man in Strawberry actually increases your honor, which presumes that the guy was not actually that good of a man

20:41 Guy:Geting Killed by a bear Arthur:Pulls out cigarette and just watches Arthur again:Takes Out whiskey/beer and just takes his hat

The Valentine Peeping Toms surprised me cause I had a similar encounter in strawberry but it was to watch a woman undress and I think it gave me a disturbing the peace bounty

20:34 was the most funniest and most disrespectful thing I've ever seen lmaoo

Man i’ve played this game 3 times, on my 4th play through after a trip to Utah this summer rekindled the western spirit. Just realized on this play through, if you race the man with the new horse 3-4 times, he will shoot his horse in the head after losing and your horse will gain a permanent increase to speed. I used the tamed white arabian too. Damn thing went into warp drive after level 4 bonding and got that 3-4th win

LOL Marston "chelonia!!!"

I had no idea you could take the body to the sheriff lol

Strawberry Conman 18 something - 19 something Drowned in crap while escaping a man with a small winkle

To be honest the kidnap boy it’s pretty sad especially when you Looted him

This game just blows everybody’s mind , how above and beyond , how alive and realistic everything is . It’s literally reality in a game . I can’t imagine gta 6

I ran into the KKK twice (in the same playthrough, within thirty minutes of each other) and both times I simply tossed a stick of dynamite into the middle of them and killed them all. The first time I missed a guy, so guess who was being dragged behind my horse when I find the second meeting?

I love how Arthur just casually has a drink and a smoke while dude gets torn up by a bear.

When I heard the house building theme I knew it was gonna be lit.

20:50 Well, this is your life, save yourself. oh nice hat

I love your videos so much my whole page is covered with your videos even though I don’t have a console I still watch you your videos are amazing keep up the good work

3:46 why did you Switch to first person 😃

Red Dead redemption 2 is better than GTA V

Question: is the arm amputation available after chapter 4? I spent most of chapter 6 trying to get it for max honour for arthur

18:30 😂 I laughed 😂

In arm amputation,WHY YOUR HORSE SO GIANT?!

21:03 look at how small Arthur's horse is.

Never seen such respect for details since far cry 2.

8:28 I love how Arthur mutters his own opinion to himself. Because he doesn’t want to actually say it to their face lol

I've seen the horse kill its owner about 3 or 4 times in my current playthrough

3:48 bro i know you aint that down bad right?? 😭

Damn, that conman in the shithole killed me.

I love how Arthur just lights a cigar as the dude gets mauled 2ft away.

I played this game to the end at launch and can defo say it’s in the top 5 games I’ve ever played, I really wanna play it again but the backlog is hugeeee

18:25 😂😂 CHELONIA !

Only video in this channel that aint cringe

I love how your horse is also called “my horse” too

😂😂 I love the chelonia one and the bear attack! That exactly how I play Rdr2 too 😂

10:06 that horse is hilarious

I didn't kill the gunsmith, i did knock him out though and returned a few days later, got a bit of intresting dialouge.

An additional thing to note for the guy who gets his arm amputated: If you come back to saint denis a few days later, you'll see him about to get hanged for killing his girl after she rejected him (presumably for losing his arm) Been a while since i seen that encounter, but i think you have the choice to help him again by freeing him or you can just watch the hanging.

The Strawberry Conman one felt like a fever dream-

Went to do the arm amputation one and was cut off by a cart. Knocked us both off the horse. He died and I became wanted.

13:23 The amputate one impresses me a whole damn lot

i like how when the bear attacks the man in the tucker quest arthur just takes out a cigar like it was all planed

13:53 Looks like someone pushed the wrong button to ride again.

2:48 I wonder if you were able to convince him with dialogue not to murder the guy?

you smoking and drinking infront of that hunter getting ripped to shreds got me so hard😂😂😂

Dude you crack me up!

14:30 I got that occurence as Arthur I remember they did catch on fire and most ran away and one of them tried to kill me but I threw him off the cliff lol😂🤣 Fun fact:when you go in fire the temperature increase to the fires heat