Right, it's terrible@@betweenthevelvetlies

최성심 😅😅 0:39 😊​@@betweenthevelvetlies

I’m 2 months late to this! But the only things I think Guarma added was that 1. Dutch’s Tahiti plan never would have turned out well. And 2. Dutch killed an innocent and Arthur stood by and watched. Cornwall is a d bag, don’t get me wrong. But when Dutch pulls two revolvers on that unarmed d bag and sends him floating into the Louisiana Bay? Arthur came out of hiding with a much more timely but still emotive “wtf are we doing here”. Because of its new placement, it now is very close to the gator execution by Dutch on yet another unarmed d bag. None are an old woman, but combined we can see where the wind is blowing in Arthur’s perception. That’s why I moved cornwall’s death up, to capture that character development earlier like when Guarma asked for it. And for knowing Dutch’s Tahiti/island plan wouldn’t work out, the story teaches us that already

@@BrittonFilmmaker❤❤

I appreciated the game just fine with minimap on :)

​@@greyfivenine7005I hated the minimap thing, I prefer to follow the clues normally or open the map and mark the location, so I can better appreciate the elements of exploration and immersion that the game can offer

@@kevincaballero9295how do you know you’re going the right way then?

@@Sal-zs1ob I use the compass mode when I need to

@@Sal-zs1ob but I really wish they put the compass in the top of the screen like Elden Ring or AC Valhalla

I know right! And I also always thought it was one of the coolest missions in the game

It is THE definitive turning point. That is the point where it REALLY goes downhill and fast. Objectively one of the most important plot points.

@@bobkin611 Agreed

What??? He cut that out?

bro what. that's literally one of the most important parts of the story. it exposes dutch as the traitor he is to arthur and wraps up the eagle flies story.

That song always floats around in my head, what an amazing and ethereal scene

That's when I first started weeping. When the horse dies later was the last defense against a war or tears 😂

way more actually. half of the main story is cut from this movie (including entire sections like guarma and the epilogue) and then there's all the side missions too

Actually, in RDR2 is like 18+ hours of cutscenes.

​@@BloodRain23 that's nuts

still not more than mgs4 lmao@@BloodRain23

and adding most sections were real time gameplay like dialogues if those were cutscenes as long as the delivery id be additional 6hrs?9?

It would,but if they ever did I wouldn't want them to ruin it.

God I hate that damn bandolier it’s so awful lol. I get it has gameplay effects but it just does not look good. At least the epilogue with John Marston I did doesn’t have one. This edit is partly a frankentien’s monster of other people’s playthroughs as I myself didn’t have an existing save of the whole game. I got first person angles of some bits, got some missing exposition horse rides, and reshot some scenes that were at the wrong time of day. So the main skeleton piece I used was of this guy with a bandolier, but I was like, “well at least he’s wearing the right jacket and beard length” Then, when I went back to collect footage that was missing, glitched, or bad, I had to put on that cursed bandolier for consistency 🤣 Maybe one I day when I recovered from my recent injury I can sit down and record the entire thing start to finish with even his clothing having a bit of an arc to it. Would certainly take months though. Thanks for watching it! The weirdest decision I made was moving Cornwall’s chapter 6 scene up to chapter 4, because I felt like it accomplished almost everything Guarma did without needing Guarma. (Once I cut out the references to chapter 5 and 6 in that Cornwall sceen)

@@BrittonFilmmaker i'd love to watch arthur's clothes, hair and facial hair portray a sense of progression like you said! you're right though, it would take much more effort and time. still, you did a good job with this video. sorry to hear about your injury, and sorry you had to deal with that bandolier lol. get well soon :)

@@BrittonFilmmaker The bandolier does not have gameplay effects. Owning the bandolier unlocks the gameplay effects regardless of whether or not it's worn. This is in contrast to improved rifling and leather wraps, which only apply their bonuses when equipped.

@@BrittonFilmmakeryikes you ok what happened?? 😢

​@@BrittonFilmmakerI think it's a great idea to basically record your own playthrough (maybe a 100% one that includes all revelant sidequests/smaller open world moments?) and stitch together everything like others are saying! If you don't do it I'm seriously considering it myself. I have a bunch of older relatives who love Westerns and to me this concept looks like a perfect way to help bring older folks into looking at videogames in a different light. Like as if it helps bridge the generational gap in a way. A genuine public service.

It's on my channel. A 5 part series gameplay edited so you can enjoy the story.

@@Escape_is_keybig dubs

​@@Escape_is_keyI checked it out, pretty cool! New sub

play the game, my guy! You yourself can create an episodic adventure by playing through the game in little episode-length increments lol

I like that idea. Even this cut version is still 4 hours, which is kind of a lot to ask if you're showing it to someone who's never played or isn't into video games. Perhaps each in-game chapter could be like its own mini season with 3-6 episodes 30-40 minutes each? You'd certainly have to play around with the exact structure, but there is certainly enough content to do it that way, especially when you include all the free roaming dialogue, side missions, and even adding in some shots of free roam activities as filler; Could even dub in Arthur's journal narration during the latter parts. This is something I have wanted to do ever since R* released that RDR1 short film on the Xbox store as a free DLC/"Extra". I believe the hardest part though is getting the timing of the day/night cycle correct (some missions, like the bar fight, are clearly meant to be done at night; others become much more emotional during sunrise/sunset or when it's raining etc. Like "Who Is Not Without Sin?" the mission where you find the reverend playing cards while he's absolutely wasted, for example - that missions hits better when you start it at ~6AM on a clear day), and also figuring out a nice canonical way of ordering the side missions/adjacent missions so that the transitions aren't too jarring. I actually have a notebook somewhere in which I started writing down notes for RDR1 on each mission describing what order to play them in, what time of day and/or weather patterns were best for each one, how many days should be in-between each mission, some side activities to do as filler in the days between, etc. Never got around to actually filming and editing, but just following those notes up until the point you meet the Armadillo marshall felt like I was literally playing a movie - especially your introduction to Armadillo, when the game truly let's you off the proverbial hook of story establishment into true free-roam. Renting a room in the saloon and buying some supplies from HERBERT MOON and hunting for pelts for a couple days before returning to Bonnie - it felt so fluid I almost forgot that it was in fact an open world game. Honestly if someone from HBO or something hits up R* and puts together a multi-season live action show covering the entirety of RDR1 and 2, I would probably never go outside again lol, it's just crazy to me to think that nobody has ever tapped into what would without a doubt be a huge cash cow for whomever decides to make it. I do however have a sneaking suspicion that Rockstar's legal team is to blame for that, though.

Playing this is a game like that before seeing any video spoilers was one awesome experience. Best gaming experience of my life.

I was so sad that gaurma was skipped because im watching this with my dad because he won’t play video games

The game is the movie .

no matter how well they adapt the story it would always disappoint people who played the game. theres just so much extra flavor that really shines when youre in control, i dont think you could possibly translate that to tv and definitely not a single 2 hour movie.

WE MAKE A LOT OF NOISE, A LOT OF MONEY, AND WE GET THE HELL OUT OF HERE. FAITH, GENTLEMEN. FAITH.

ONE LAST BIG SCORE!

MR PEARSON, MRS GREMSHAW

I'd be nice if people weren't still saying this as if it hasn't been said a million times for the past 4 years. Where's originality gone?

@@YodatheHobbit erm.. that's not a line in the game..

Arthur loves horses so I’d imagine to him it’s like eating a person. You just don’t do it.

“I’m afraid” 😢

wubby fan?

for real. it makes me want to go back in time to these times, despite how eerie the game makes it seem

@@ADHDDistracts Fr

Always bro it’s where I start tearing up before Arthur’s death, I always tell myself Ight not crying this time( my 3rd PT) get a little choked up on Arthur’s final ride with that’s the way it is playing on high honor then the horse scene my eyes get watery cause the horse that died was BUELL😭 I admit I like how you can save him for John after but man just completing the quest with Arthur felt so much more satisfying and right like out of all the negative in Arthur’s life at that point Hamish brought out some light and gave Arthur some peace away from the madness. Then I’m just pretty much crying a river with the final interaction with John “you’re my brother”

​@EternalNightingale please learn what full stops are 😂

You could still do it. No matter what, your film would be slightly different, and I personally like to watch many different versions of the same thing to get a good feel for it.

you could add gurma since that's not in this video and it's pretty important

I don't think it would be possible to turn this into a movie or a show. There's too much and it'll seem like 99% of it was lost. The characters, the interactions, the dialogue, the missions.... No way. Let's just enjoy the game... over and over and over again. I'm on my 3rd playthrough and taking my time. I've been in Chapter 2 since October. Couldn't progress because of Downes but found a way to skip it and other missions opened up. But now... my only option is Downes again. I'll just ride a bit more and collect more money. Almost at $20,000 just finding treasures, roaming, and killing bounty hunters. Might be my first low honor game.

Whoa!! I just looked up RedM and had no idea. I'm an instant fan, can't wait to try it

What is RedM really? Is it roleplaying? I only did a quick google search. Did you still have to buy the game? And how have you not played the game? That’s mad. 🤯

RedM is a Mod for Red Dead 2, it wont get you banned and will unlock roleplay servers@@hellomimibanana

@@hellomimibanana It's like FIveM (GTA 5's first original counterpart for creating, browsing and joining custom/RP player run servers) except it isn't as maintained as well, is vastly less popular and unfortunately it seems like the only active servers are super serious lightly populated RP communities that have steep requirements like time commitments and voice auditions. Really wish there were more "fun" less serious active servers to play around in, FiveM has plenty of those though.

What are you doing here? 😂

so an entire playthrough with no commentary? thats already on youtube buddy...

That's not what he suggested and you're being condescending and rude​@@notgonnaknowtillthen3192

@@notgonnaknowtillthen3192 They never said they had to include EVERYTHING, all they said was to include more gang dialogue. Atleast in the first chapters, you cutting around everywhere. One minute arthur is in camp, the next minute hes buying a horse, then not even 12 seconds later hes in a bar beating people up.

⁠@@Wumbonington Exactly. Not just that but key moments in the story were left on the cutting room floor. The money lending mission where Arthur beats Downes and subsequently exposes himself to TB is missing, as is the part where Dutch turns his back on Arthur when he’s about to be killed by the army at the oil fields. The conversation between Arthur and John about Dutch maybe being this way the whole time after they blow Bacchus bridge isn’t there either. Those are pivotal moments in the story and they’re just *gone.* This is less of a ‘seamless movie’ and more just a collection of cutscenes from the game.

Same. It’s a story that I know my dad would love and would resonate with him. I’ve been trying to share it with him, but he refuses to spend time on video games, despite the fact that he’s a huge buff for action/adventure movies. Hoping he gives the movie version a chance

100% they need to experience this game in some capacity

Especially when it’s buell :(

Hosea's death is definitely in this, during the bank robbery. And the video I posted right after this one is RDR1 with RDR2's epilogue as a movie!

@@BrittonFilmmakerohhhh sorry man, I made this comment at the time when Arthur and Dutch and Micah met up at annesburg and I must have just assumed your cut it. Sorry man

Yeah, he forgot it 🫤 Maybe it wasn't important lol

Thanks! Here’s my Halo edit: ukposts.info/have/v-deo/paaCZ3pwrniosGQ.htmlsi=dxL1oZwHu1ZnOggw I’m a big fan of it how it came out, those Halo 2 Anniversary cutscenes are unbelievable