Resisting Putin's war: the women risking it all on the streets of Russia

  Переглядів 1,098,929

The Guardian

The Guardian

Рік тому

As they protest Putin's invasion of Ukraine, reactions are varied from passersby: some stop to whisper their gratitude, others castigate them as traitors. St Petersburg’s anti-war protesters want to send a message to those ‘who are still silent’
Subscribe to The Guardian on UKposts ► bit.ly/subscribegdn
‘I’m never going back’: the high-profile Russian defectors rejecting war ► www.theguardian.com/world/202...
The Guardian publishes independent journalism, made possible by supporters. Contribute to The Guardian today ► bit.ly/3biVfwh
Sign up to the Guardian's free new daily newsletter, First Edition ► theguardian.com/first-edition
Website ► www.theguardian.com
Facebook ► / theguardian
Twitter ► / guardian
Instagram ► / guardian
#Putin #RussiaWar #UkraineWar #NoWar #StopTheWar #Ukraine #Russia #Antiwar

КОМЕНТАРІ: 2 600
@theGuardian
@theGuardian Рік тому
‘I’m never going back’: the high-profile Russian defectors rejecting war ► www.theguardian.com/world/2022/may/25/im-never-going-back-the-high-profile-russian-defectors-rejecting-war
@mdsarwar6054
@mdsarwar6054 Рік тому
Thank you guys
@watchingthehawks355
@watchingthehawks355 Рік тому
This girl is naive, Europe and America hate Russians not just Putin, Putin was just opportune to solve the problems left by the collapse of USSR. Russia had been under attack by Western Europe for centuries,she's just been emotional.
@ShawnJonesHellion
@ShawnJonesHellion Рік тому
you wouldn't have to censor your media to exclude russia an the middle east etc if you were ever honest an not rigging elections. every word you say an video you stage is a lie by default to intelligent people
@sergiytokio7295
@sergiytokio7295 Рік тому
Every year on the last Sunday of May the capital celebrates Kyiv Day. This year the holiday fell on May 29. Officially, the year of Kyiv's foundation is considered to be 482. So in 2022 Kyiv will be 1540 years old. Volodymyrska Street is considered to be the oldest street in Kyiv, over 1000 years old.
@pavelshnaps2345
@pavelshnaps2345 Рік тому
The Guardian is becoming increasingly pro Telegraph, bojo the fluffy can't take the loss 😅where did you find these punks?))
@Gencoil
@Gencoil Рік тому
What really hurts is seeing someone get insulted and harassed with such harsh, hateful words just for wanting peace.
@ItsaRomeThingEverydayallday
@ItsaRomeThingEverydayallday Рік тому
Absolutely
@xgamerzxz
@xgamerzxz Рік тому
kinda what happened when we was at the middle east for no reason excpet over the lies that there were weapons' when there weren't.
@DanielBrongers
@DanielBrongers Рік тому
@@xgamerzxz While there were no evidence that there were weapons present in the middle east, there were also no evidence that there were NO such weapons either. Don't make conclusions for things if you don't have any proof to back you up...
@Xerex9999
@Xerex9999 Рік тому
@@DanielBrongers it's funny, u just did the same thing u told him not to do
@nicwilkin4743
@nicwilkin4743 Рік тому
If they only new the truth.
@GabrielSousa-ju1rv
@GabrielSousa-ju1rv Рік тому
The emotional reaction of young people to the activism of the old lady is astonishing. She was able to capture and channel the feeling traped inside the hearts of people passing by. A true artist in that sense. The most respect for the courage and braveness of these women.
@TheRatlord74
@TheRatlord74 Рік тому
Like young people everywhere, they have no clue what they are talking about. There were children when Ukraine launched its assault on russian speakers.
@xax8918
@xax8918 Рік тому
Amen
@johnminer1407
@johnminer1407 Рік тому
Old lady is a well known Russian artist.
@ShawnJonesHellion
@ShawnJonesHellion Рік тому
you wouldn't have to censor your media to exclude russia an the middle east etc if you were ever honest an not rigging elections an fabricating wars. every word you say an video you stage is a lie by default to intelligent people
@kxmalahov
@kxmalahov Рік тому
if I am Putin, I would put her to prison, but Putin is not Stalin, too soft in my eyes.....too much Democracy here!!!!
@anamelikeothers
@anamelikeothers Рік тому
Taking a stand when most are against you takes much bravery. These ladies have pure hearts.
@user-jp5bf1ce5x
@user-jp5bf1ce5x Рік тому
Most Russians are against the war, I say that as a Russian citizen. Most just don't have hope anymore, we tried to overthrow the government in 2010, 2012, 2014, etc. But it didn't work out. But I will do everything I can to get us united again.
@user-jp5bf1ce5x
@user-jp5bf1ce5x Рік тому
Most Russians are against the war, I say that as a Russian citizen. Most just don't have hope anymore, we tried to overthrow the government in 2010, 2012, 2014, etc. But it didn't work out. But I will do everything I can to get us united again.
@vitalijslebedevs1629
@vitalijslebedevs1629 Рік тому
@@user-jp5bf1ce5x I wanted to say something, but then i read your username..))) So this is not a reply. Just an expression of utter support for anyone on opposition, the only 'place' a healthy, intelligent brain can exist in that regime. I'd like to find some hronicles of 2008-2014 resistance or coup attempts, besides the poweful documentaries by Navalny. (I'm too lazy to write in my not-ideal russian right now). If you can drop a censured name for Telege or point me in the direction of independent coverage of russian efforts to change the powers, much appreciated. ⬜ Stay 💠Strong ⬜Inside!
@killay02
@killay02 Рік тому
настроены против них только те, кто сейчас в нестабильном эмоциональном состоянии, так как их братья/сыновья/мужья сейчас воюют с украинцами, и поэтому им кажется, что нельзя поддерживать украину, что они плохие. но никто в россии не хочет войны, все хотят мир
@anamelikeothers
@anamelikeothers Рік тому
How do you translate your username? I am learning Russian and can read it but i only understand 2 words.
@luv.xtina3216
@luv.xtina3216 Рік тому
As a Ukrainian, god this breaks my heart. I respect these people for standing up for what is right. I am in constant heartbreak for everyone.
@user-tm6pj5ry6z
@user-tm6pj5ry6z Рік тому
Піздєц, правда? 😢
@chrisb3189
@chrisb3189 Рік тому
Это наш "братский народ"...
@-Danceordie-
@-Danceordie- Рік тому
Очень эмоциональный ролик, невозможно смотреть без слёз
@natalies753
@natalies753 Рік тому
Hoping you are safe over there! Slava Ukraini 💙💛
@user-ew8cf2bb9e
@user-ew8cf2bb9e Рік тому
Как украинец вы должны были выступать против нацистов' которые заполонили вашу страну!
@babakarzoomand8434
@babakarzoomand8434 Рік тому
I am from Iran, my Russian sisters. I am so proud of you.
@Missconduct044
@Missconduct044 Рік тому
Iranians are absolutely amazing people. You fight the wrongs of the world with power and love. ❤ from 🇺🇸
@chrisbrooks7387
@chrisbrooks7387 Рік тому
I truly hope you find freedom in your country.The people of Iran a great.I would love to visit one day.American
@marshallmintz7564
@marshallmintz7564 4 місяці тому
@@Missconduct044 Let me correct you "Iranian Woman" are amazingly courageous......with some men as well.
@johannesnicolaas
@johannesnicolaas 2 місяці тому
I have some Iranian friends, I think they are wonderful.
@sueouzounis9439
@sueouzounis9439 Рік тому
Sorry to the young lady who was abused. You are following your soul, bless you and keep strong.
@devinreis5811
@devinreis5811 Рік тому
The lady that cursed at her was fired from her job.
@AnimeWatcher107
@AnimeWatcher107 Рік тому
@@devinreis5811 where did you get this info? Can you send a link I want to read an article if there is one.
@marshallmintz7564
@marshallmintz7564 4 місяці тому
You always consider the source of insults.....in this case you had the insulter......a bitter old cow of a lady that saw no joy in life and wants everybody else to suffer as well VS. a beautiful young vibrant and smart lady who is just starting in life and wants peace and safety for her family.
@kristalkristal2506
@kristalkristal2506 Рік тому
Seeing these gentle and courageous, solitary women made me cry.
@Leadbelly.
@Leadbelly. 9 місяців тому
No misfortune humanly possible, could make me cry for an Ivan.
@kristalkristal2506
@kristalkristal2506 9 місяців тому
@@Leadbelly. If that's really true, it makes you worse than they are.
@retroconsole_
@retroconsole_ Рік тому
У меня разрывается сердце, когда я вижу, как моя страна и люди проходят через это. Русские и украинцы этого не заслуживают. Это братоубийство.
@igormelnichenko5161
@igormelnichenko5161 Рік тому
Це не братовбивча війна.
@Humangenerator
@Humangenerator Рік тому
@@igormelnichenko5161 да какая разница. Хоть братоубийственная, хоть с инопланетянами вообще. Эта война аморальна по своей сути, и никому не нужна кроме откровенных нелюдей-людоедов, которые в своём делирии видят явно искажённую картину мира.
@user-dh5we1ig5d
@user-dh5we1ig5d Рік тому
Корвалола попей , чтоб серце не разрывалось ! Напиши свою пургу , и предъяву пиши в США и Великобританию ! В 1917 году , в России тоже было братоубийство , благодаря этим же странам ! Пиши ЗЕЛЕНСКОМУ И ПАРАШЕНКО за чем они войну замутили , и поплачь им в жилетку !
@kimobrien.
@kimobrien. Рік тому
@@Humangenerator When I was young we protested America's criminal war in Vietnam and our protests help force an end as the soldiers did not want to keep fighting and two Presidents were forced from office. Lyndon Johnson announced he would not run for Persident again and Nixon resigned amid the massive watergate FBI secret police scandal.
@thedamntrain
@thedamntrain Рік тому
@@kimobrien. So where were all the sanctions against the United States for the war then?
@suna2317
@suna2317 Рік тому
That old woman gives me so much hope in humanity. There is much we can learn from not only art but wise people who have lived through these experiences before, so as not to repeat the same mistakes of history.
@HisameArtwork
@HisameArtwork Рік тому
ikr, and unvaxed ppl wanna kiss her. just give her money or a box of paint, don't endanger her life further, so selfish, they just want to touch her for publicity since the saw she was filmed.
@devinreis5811
@devinreis5811 Рік тому
She's tough as nails. Her granddaughter told BBC, "My grandma is tough. She's not scared of anything." She's a survivor of the siege of Leningrad.
@EsqueJon
@EsqueJon Рік тому
I agree. I would like to learn more about her, her-story, and her art.
@dna9838
@dna9838 Рік тому
Really emotional watching this. These women... Such courage. They are like lights shining in the darkness.
@gmf8171
@gmf8171 Рік тому
LOL what a load of BS
@1funkyflyguy
@1funkyflyguy Рік тому
@@gmf8171 Is that It? Is that all you've got?!!!
@gmf8171
@gmf8171 Рік тому
@@1funkyflyguy These women are simply emotionally immature, poorly educated, and incapable of critical thought. In other words, they're typical Liberals and should be ignored.
@Google_Does_Evil_Now
@Google_Does_Evil_Now Рік тому
They truly are brave and inspirational. The old lady is clever and understands her power.
@arek3866
@arek3866 Рік тому
Bravo and HONOR to ALL Resistance there!!!!
@charlesw9875
@charlesw9875 Рік тому
Given the penalty for this sort of thing is fifteen years of torture and humiliation in the gulag, these women show extraordinary bravery. As a fellow human being, I salute you all.
@mrsnegy6001
@mrsnegy6001 Рік тому
The young woman is a true hero! The old woman is intelligent, wise, brave, heroic, a symbol of the best we find in human beings. Unfortunately, there aren't many like her. HATS OFF TO BOTH!
@izzy4575
@izzy4575 Рік тому
You girls are heroes, the world is proud of you, you are saving the soul of Russia at your own personal risk. Спасибо. 💔🇺🇦
@pietroiannetta8539
@pietroiannetta8539 Рік тому
How can that woman use such terrible words against that young girl! One day she will understand, but it will be too late because the world will have been ruined and so many people will have died for no reason at all.
@yungskoota5016
@yungskoota5016 Рік тому
No they not
@ZaMonolith1986
@ZaMonolith1986 Рік тому
@@yungskoota5016 ill bet youre fun at parties
@devinreis5811
@devinreis5811 Рік тому
@@pietroiannetta8539 She got fired from her job over it.
@quarryryde
@quarryryde Рік тому
Made me tear up especially for the young girl with the white roses as I can see what she is doing cries against her whole being yet she does it because she cannot do otherwise.
@michellesheaff3779
@michellesheaff3779 Рік тому
I'm consoling myself over the young blond woman by thinking forever more, she has been immortalized on film as a brave, caring, smart and dignified young lady, whereas the cheetah woman has forever revealed the rot within. We can plainly see what kind of Russian supports peace and what kind wants war.
@DavidCunningham65
@DavidCunningham65 Рік тому
me too!
@user-lr7lb2rj4l
@user-lr7lb2rj4l Рік тому
@@michellesheaff3779 а те кто поставляют оружие Киеву, они за мир или против? или они хотят уничтожения всех украинцев?
@lukas6610
@lukas6610 Рік тому
@@user-lr7lb2rj4l they help the ukrainians defend thier homes and freedom
@lukas6610
@lukas6610 Рік тому
@@user-lr7lb2rj4l russian soldiers dont have to fear about loosing their home or their family. the ukranians have to fight or they'll be taken away, thier property will be stolen and they will lose thier political rights just like you some people value democracy and freedom. You support this war while russia could just simply leave and all lives would be spared but no to much greed.
@biankaionescu496
@biankaionescu496 Рік тому
So emotional, I cried... I'm so sorry for all those ppl that are suffering because of the war. I'm happy to see that there are people that don't want war
@thomasdong3882
@thomasdong3882 Рік тому
Well if America don’t go down we will always gonna have war
@johnjones3079
@johnjones3079 Рік тому
Prayers and blessings to those brave women who stood their ground for the right thing. To the lady with the foul language, I find you heartless and without soul.
@johanvermeulen4081
@johanvermeulen4081 2 місяці тому
Мы все хотим мира, но не наши хозяева на Западе. Поэтому вы должны защищать себя сами. Начните с информирования себя. Просто идя по легкому пути (самодовольному тоже) и не изучая и не ища правду..... ЧИТАТЬ ДАЛЕЕ: ... это предательство всех остальных людей в вашей стране. Вот доказательство агрессии Запада: Список агрессии США после 1945 года: Bo = бомбардировки. RC = успешная смена режима. Rc = неудачная смена режима. Китай 1949 - начало 1960-х гг. Корея и Китай 1950-1953 гг. Албания 1949-53 гг. Сирия 1949 г. РЦ Греция 1949 г. РЦ Восточная Германия 1950-е гг. Куба 1952 RC Иран 1953 * RC Гватемала 1954 * RC Бо Коста-Рика середина 1950-х гг. Южный Вьетнам 1955 РЦ Сирия 1956-7 рк Египет 1957 рк Гаити 1957 РЦ Индонезия 1957-8 рк Бо Британская Гвиана 1953-64 * РЦ Куба 1959-1961 Бо Южная Корея 1960 г. РЦ Ирак 1963 * РЦ Северный Вьетнам 1945-73 рк Камбоджа 1955-70 * RC Лаос 1958 *, 1959 *, 1960 * RC RC RC RC Эквадор 1960-63 * РЦ Конго 1960 * РЦ Гватемала 1960 Бо Южный Вьетнам 1963 РЦ Гватемала 1963 РЦ Франция 1965 рк Бразилия 1962-64 * РЦ Доминиканская Республика 1963 * РЦ Куба 1959 по настоящее время рк Вьетнам 1961-1973 гг. Боливия 1964 * РЦ Конго 1964 Бо Лаос 1964-1973 Бо Индонезия 1965 * РЦ Заир 1965 RC Гана 1966 * РЦ Чили 1964-73 * РЦ Греция 1967 * RC Гватемала 1967- 1969 Бо Камбоджа 1969-1970 гг. Коста-Рика 1970-71 рк Камбоджа 1970 РЦ Боливия 1971 * РЦ Сальвадор 1972 РЦ Австралия 1973-75 * РЦ Чили 1973 РЦ Ангола 1975, 1980-е гг. Заир 1975 г. рк Португалия 1974-76 * РЦ Ямайка 1976-80 * РЦ Сейшельские острова 1979-81 рк Южная Корея 1979 РЦ Либерия 1980 РЦ Чад 1981-82 * РЦ Гренада 1983 * РЦ Южный Йемен 1982-84 рк Суринам 1982-84 рк Чад 1982 * РЦ Фиджи 1987 * РЦ Ливия 1980-е гг. Сальвадор 1980-е гг. Никарагуа 1980-е гг. Никарагуа 1981-90 * RC Гренада 1983 RC Bo Ливан 1983, 1984. Бо Ливия 1986 Бо Иран 1987 Бо Панама 1989 * RC Bo Болгария 1990 * RC Албания 1991 * РЦ Ирак 1991 г. РЦ Бо Афганистан 1980-е * РЦ Сомали 1993 г. рк Бо Босния 1994, 1995 гг. Судан 1998 г. Бо Афганистан 1998 г. Бо Югославия 1999-2000 * РЦ Бо Эквадор 2000 * РЦ Афганистан 2001 * RC Афганистан 2001-2014 Бо Венесуэла 2002 * RC Йемен 2002 Бо Ирак 2003 * РЦ Бо Ирак 2003 * RC Bo Гаити 2004 * РЦ Сомали 2007 - настоящее время РЦ Пакистан 2007 - настоящее время Бо Сомали 2007, 2008, 2011 Бо Гондурас 2009 РЦ Йемен 2009, 2011 Бо Ливия 2011* РЦ Бо Сирия 2012 г. РЦ Выполните свой долг: Скопируйте и перепостите. Это не выдумка, не фальшивка, это можно проверить. Это доказывает агрессию Запада. Пропагандистская война - это также война на истощение. Вы тоже должны продолжать бороться с их пропагандой. Помогите себе и своей стране: скопируйте и перепостите.
@maudieedwards9332
@maudieedwards9332 Рік тому
This made me cry l have the greatest respect for this lady and all the women who speak out against the war in Ukraine where lives on all sides are being torn away. To stand and face a barrage of abuse from that woman... and say nothing speaks volumes. I am with her and all woman who speak out. And the older lady who gives warnings of what war can do...she is a beacon of strength.
@wladimirnowak8797
@wladimirnowak8797 Рік тому
where they were during many ears of Bandersztat leaded genocide against Donbass ? ! They promoters of genocide !Kak zhywut strany w Sojuznim SNG , i kak wse tridtsatj let iz Ukrainy, liogszej pod sataninskij kolonialjnyj Zapad , sdelali nishenku a potom i sataninskij Bandersztat - Kliniku bujno pomeszannych s psihopatijej i suicydnymi pozywami w masztabe wsej strany. Tak kto zhe zhywiot i razwiwajetsa i myslit konstruktiwno a kto podyhajet bo zbozhewilliau niczyczym bezumets ?
@marinaivashuk6730
@marinaivashuk6730 Рік тому
This is a specially selected lady who is constantly standing, she is bought in order to then put on the Internet.
@mariegreen8763
@mariegreen8763 Рік тому
I am crying... Iam. Russian
@MsJellyBellyLove
@MsJellyBellyLove Рік тому
It brought tears to my normally stoic eyes as well.
@Bozewani
@Bozewani Рік тому
i am also russian and I am opposed to the war If putin runs in 2024 I am not voting for him i amvoting fora just russia
@harperwelch5147
@harperwelch5147 Рік тому
This reminds me of my teenage youth blocking the freeway through Seattle with protests against the Vietnam War. We knew the government was lying. We knew there was no justifiable reason for us to be there. All we could do was protest. These poor folks can’t even do that without risking arrest and prison.
@ItsaRomeThingEverydayallday
@ItsaRomeThingEverydayallday Рік тому
My dad served in the Navy during Vietnam. My grandfather served during ww2. Freedom is not free. And hats of to all our service men & women. Thank you for your bravery and for protecting our nation and the world from the tyranny of of the oppressive dictators that caused the conflicts of war. Godspeed
@Whistlewalk
@Whistlewalk Рік тому
And without risking their very lives.
@carl5438
@carl5438 Рік тому
My thought exactly. Stole Muhamad Ali's prime years because he said he's not fighting/killing people who had not called him the N word.
@bigstuff52
@bigstuff52 Рік тому
@@ItsaRomeThingEverydayallday You ought to try being in the military out there protecting our so called freedom and democracy...The USA hasn't been in a legitimate war since WW2...All the people that died for some "old" guys wet dream of what the world should be like..The USA is a dying empire but unfortunately as it dies,a lot of people are going to get hurt..
@zollyy
@zollyy Рік тому
Blocking a freeway doesn't do anything except make regular folks hate you. Your protest was pointless.
@mikep7477
@mikep7477 Рік тому
Thank you for showing the world that there are still proud and fearless people in Russia.
@axe0144
@axe0144 Рік тому
These women are strong, courageous and with people like these women is where positive change can take root. I'm Canadian, but my family is from Ukraine and I call these brave women friends!
@cmarq817
@cmarq817 Рік тому
In awe of these women’s courage. 👏👏👏
@marshuswp3325
@marshuswp3325 Рік тому
We all are!💙💛
@tanioraaura1274
@tanioraaura1274 Рік тому
Agree [absolutely courageous]
@joeyslush
@joeyslush Рік тому
Respect to these women. Stay strong and l hope you’re going to be safe and soon be able to lead a normal life again.
@beesmonk
@beesmonk Рік тому
normal life? is there such a thing?
@limbostratus
@limbostratus Рік тому
​@@beesmonk I guess he means watching east Ukraine getting bombed into oblivion
@aleksandarmitrovic5556
@aleksandarmitrovic5556 Рік тому
Yeah b.... When you go in war then is democracy. 1000 years west steal from this world. Now is over baby👍
@adam.maqavoy
@adam.maqavoy Рік тому
So Hard To Watch this ~ Have a Friend (LDR) In *St Petersburg, Russia*
@bananaspiel1850
@bananaspiel1850 Рік тому
Aren’t they amazing!! Very touching.
@luvmydababy
@luvmydababy Рік тому
I love the blonde haired girl in black with the flowers.I'm an American man that has always stood up for what I believe in even when it was going against the crowd.I admire her bravery and pray for her safety.SENDING LOVE FROM THE U.S.A.
@bobsullivan5714
@bobsullivan5714 Рік тому
Yeah, that nasty old blister was thinking about giving her a beatdown. But, she stood her ground anyway........... Yeah, SENDING LOVE FROM THE U.S.A.
@danieltheal
@danieltheal Рік тому
The woman in the leopard coat was appalling. She was so hateful and full of negativity. Hats off to the brave women demonstrating for peace. We need peace now and always. Violence is wrong.
@abdel-qadeercoubadja4750
@abdel-qadeercoubadja4750 Рік тому
Gotta call a spade a spade.
@Greg-yu4ij
@Greg-yu4ij Рік тому
The old lady is awesome. You can’t arrest grandma because she doesn’t fear jail and it will only get her children involved.
@snowdogthewolf
@snowdogthewolf Рік тому
Their bravery is astounding! However, I worry for their safety.
@davidrubel441
@davidrubel441 Рік тому
Why? This is not Europe, where they put you in jail for supporting Russia.
@devinreis5811
@devinreis5811 Рік тому
Police are afraid to arrest the elderly lady that survived the siege of Leningrad. All she has to do is tell her story and they'll leave her alone.
@29evolution
@29evolution Рік тому
Respect to these brave women. 🙏
@northernlife231
@northernlife231 Рік тому
What an incredibly brave old woman. Nothing to loose except her dignity which the Regime has already taken from its people. God Bless her.
@maximpopov8651
@maximpopov8651 Рік тому
Stop the madness, stop the war... Peace Love and Freedom ☮️
@trishameenaghan8009
@trishameenaghan8009 Рік тому
The older abusive woman name-calling, insulting and demeaning this peacefully protesting brave young woman... tells you ALL you need to know about the cruel oppressive Russian society! 😪
@paulgibbon5991
@paulgibbon5991 Рік тому
@@crhu319 Botski reported.
@nicki7327
@nicki7327 Рік тому
@@crhu319 Russians belong in Russia, not Ukraine.
@virginiaserranovalencia8082
@virginiaserranovalencia8082 Рік тому
@@paulgibbon5991 ANYoNe WhO DiSsaGrEes mUSt bE a bOT!
@louiekiwi
@louiekiwi Рік тому
@@virginiaserranovalencia8082 Liberals are like that. There's no nuance or critical thinking, just total ideological compliance.
@techenjoyer_cool
@techenjoyer_cool Рік тому
@@virginiaserranovalencia8082 the start of your name really does describe your personality
@jaylm4112
@jaylm4112 Рік тому
I thank with all my heart the Russian that were kind to this old wise women... More Americans and Russians need to be like this older women thank you to the Russians who treated her with respect thank you so much.. Thank you to the cops for not forcing her
@canaryinacoalmine7267
@canaryinacoalmine7267 Рік тому
Us Americans supported our wars in Afghanistan and Iraq and other countries in the Middle East. We didnt cause our government to have a coup. These wars were unjust as the Ukrainian war. Its upsets me that Americans are so judgmental about Russian people, when we allowed the same thing to happen.
@kazmroz8948
@kazmroz8948 Рік тому
@@canaryinacoalmine7267 Judgemental against Putin, not Russians.
@sands7779
@sands7779 Рік тому
@@canaryinacoalmine7267 there were lots of protests against Iraq and some journalists disagreeing. I think most people understand the repressive laws the Russians live under. I do think people should make an effort to investigate for themselves.
@canaryinacoalmine7267
@canaryinacoalmine7267 Рік тому
@@sands7779 Just stop! We didnt overthrow Bush. Hundreds of thousands of people are dead because of the wars we started for NO reason. You are delusional.
@karinjohansson7262
@karinjohansson7262 Рік тому
Those cops should be for the people, not against the people. Also militaries should be for the people, not insulting thrm!
@yukimatsukawa6770
@yukimatsukawa6770 Рік тому
本当に勇敢な人だ!僕はこれからの人生、絶対にこの人達を忘れる事はない 本当に尊敬します。 あなた達のようなロシア人がいる事に感謝します。
@futureprogrammer7084
@futureprogrammer7084 Рік тому
The real heroes aren't the ones with intercontinental ballistic missiles but those with a big heart. ❤️
@liezelhaupt7172
@liezelhaupt7172 Рік тому
My heart goes out to these young people who have to fight for a better future in silence.🤗❤
@tanioraaura1274
@tanioraaura1274 Рік тому
Silence only hides the truth And so the historical events become a recorded confidential file well into the future Thank you for your comment.
@rohan8973
@rohan8973 Рік тому
Support to the brave women who are against this barbaric war, love from India.
@no-oneinparticular7264
@no-oneinparticular7264 Рік тому
Wow, I usually read pro Russian comments from India!!. At last, someone who thinks for him or herself, slava Ukraini 🇺🇦
@thenormalonebenutzer9911
@thenormalonebenutzer9911 Рік тому
There are Indians, who dont support the war??? Nice. Gives some hope.
@sands7779
@sands7779 Рік тому
@@no-oneinparticular7264 do not judge Indian people by the comments from trolls or people saying western nations are hypocritical, which they often are, or trying to rationalise their neutral position as there are justifiable arguments there. Many Indian people support their official neutral position while having sympathy for the fact that Russia is trying to colonise Ukraine.
@paulgibbon5991
@paulgibbon5991 Рік тому
@@no-oneinparticular7264 No, you read pro-Russian comments with an Indian name attached to a Moscow botski.
@shylanambiar4316
@shylanambiar4316 Рік тому
Many Indians support Ukraine. The ones making pro-Russia comments are right-wingers or Russbots.
@poskeegget8043
@poskeegget8043 Рік тому
This is bravery. People desperately fighting in their own way to make their home a better place.
@quite1enough
@quite1enough Рік тому
I live there and you managed to capture the current state and mood of Saint Petersburg really well
@pyabs2234
@pyabs2234 Рік тому
I love that old lady, she really touched my heart.
@oddrunhaland
@oddrunhaland Рік тому
Wonderful people - so intelligent. The old lady has become a symbol of democracy. We must stand by people like her. We must not give up on Ukraine because if we do we will give up on democracy and freedom. Then people in the West will be like Russians - oppressed slaves.
@user-kv3lp5gc8i
@user-kv3lp5gc8i Рік тому
Democracy and freedom for Iraq, Afganistan, libia, syria,other and now Ukrain well job....
@mrsbelcher
@mrsbelcher Рік тому
@@user-kv3lp5gc8i Oh PLEASE give us a f*cking break with all the stories about the past and start working on your own part for making a better future for everyone. Just because some corrupt politicians made very wrong decisions in other countries, you have no right to be evil yourself. There are Ukrainians AND Russians dying right now!!
@apotato1529
@apotato1529 Рік тому
@@user-kv3lp5gc8i We can go back further. Don't forget, Russia was in "The West" and enslaved the Aleut before finally getting repelled by the Tlingit Nations and alliances in the 1800's. The problem with "The West" is that it's complicated. The problems with those examples, was "Russia".
@genespell4340
@genespell4340 Рік тому
@@user-kv3lp5gc8i if people want democracy in their countries, they need to remove the dictators and their associates instead of trying to fight the armies that are controlled by the dictators.
@bulentmert9951
@bulentmert9951 Рік тому
@@user-kv3lp5gc8i Iraq is free, Afganistan was free, libya and syria wants to free. None of their land was occupied by orcs destroying the whole infrastructure and bombing cities to ashes. Anything else Russia Troll?
@mariegreen8763
@mariegreen8763 Рік тому
Very brave young woman, be strong and don't give up.. Stay strong...please, we need such wonderful people.. Thank you for being such a brave and honest...
@leanne4333
@leanne4333 Рік тому
What an incredibly brave woman, brought tears to my eyes 💚
@muzungufiacre7314
@muzungufiacre7314 Рік тому
ALWAYS WOMEN ARE THE RIGHTS OF THE WORLD. PLZ GIVE ME YOUR CONTACT I HAVE QUESTION TO TALK
@Derapplecraze
@Derapplecraze Рік тому
These women are incredible more people in Russia need to do this
@qwertyasdfgh100
@qwertyasdfgh100 Рік тому
Скажите это США!
@draka1051
@draka1051 Рік тому
Do it in USA
@plotoyadnaya_rossiyanka
@plotoyadnaya_rossiyanka Рік тому
Easy to say, hard to do. Those women are heroes, but most of people are not, and despite being against this war they have to sacrifice their desire to stand against the government for their safety and “freedom” (being outside of prison is the best freedom you can have in Russia).
@kwaru1
@kwaru1 Рік тому
The elderly lady. Her courage is so inspiring. I teared up:)
@joannmarie61
@joannmarie61 Рік тому
I too was moved to tears watching these brave women. Elena Osipova (the artist) said "The slaves create the tyrants." Wise words that we should remember here in the US.
@Tristaneus
@Tristaneus Рік тому
Oh boy, I just saw the bravery of Mrs. Osipova and think to myself: I want to hug this grandma so much! and then came this part 6:26, and I had the same feeling of respect of the young woman to her Mrs. Osipova, so emotional... man I think I got something on my eye…
@mikeneill6813
@mikeneill6813 6 місяців тому
Strange that. I think I did too.
@realitate666
@realitate666 Рік тому
I'm so disgusted by the first scene, she can say all those words and walk away but those who are actually doing something right are being jailed... I feel sorry for all the people who are against the war, but can't raise their voices...
@realitate666
@realitate666 Рік тому
@@Alex-lb4qw why so many people are scared to talk then?
@MariaMoz
@MariaMoz Рік тому
@@Alex-lb4qw No one's in jail?? I'd love to live in your reality.
@karinjohansson7262
@karinjohansson7262 Рік тому
@@Alex-lb4qw many has been put in jail, also people have had to flee the country because they wants peace.
@karinjohansson7262
@karinjohansson7262 Рік тому
@@Alex-lb4qw they are afraid to speak. Stop lying to yourself and others. So many videos here in UKposts that prove otherwise than you say. You have sold your soul to the Devil.
@karinjohansson7262
@karinjohansson7262 Рік тому
@@MariaMoz he is a troll. Check out his channel.
@JG-mv5qn
@JG-mv5qn Рік тому
These women have incredible courage, the present and future will be proud of you.
@poo2764
@poo2764 Рік тому
She get the prize of a night with Putin, what a horrible woman the way she spoke to that young woman absolutely disgusting.
@IvanIvanov-tb7fq
@IvanIvanov-tb7fq Рік тому
yes, it looked rude, but the woman told her the honest truth...
@miltonolley121
@miltonolley121 Рік тому
What a brave elderly lady. Such a special person at this time in the world. I admire all these women. Stay strong.
@debbiewatts8665
@debbiewatts8665 Рік тому
Please know what you are doing is beautiful. If someone calls you a bad name, it means you are making a difference in the world. Your voice is being heard around the world. sending love from AUSTRALIA xx
@polishnorwegianandspanish9145
@polishnorwegianandspanish9145 Рік тому
Tell this beautiful, honest lady that she is welcome in Poland anytime. She is amazing and deserves to have a peaceful retirement. Anytime she would like to, she is welcome in my home.
@ansmehota8976
@ansmehota8976 Рік тому
Hey
@ghjorhyliuybn168
@ghjorhyliuybn168 Рік тому
​@@Knjaz-opium Привет из России. не падай духом. В эти сложные времена держись близких людей, друзей и все будет хорошо.. Знай что большинство россиян - против войны. Да и я стараюсь по возможности разговаривать с людьми, которые верят пропаганде (в нациков и биолаборатории) что б их переубедить. Держись там мужик!
@ghjorhyliuybn168
@ghjorhyliuybn168 Рік тому
@@Knjaz-opium Та если б не вся эта политика, я уверен и русофобов бы почти не было. А так СМИ И политика пытаются рассорить два по сути братских народа. Ну а Пу так совсем решил пойти освобождать людей от домов, жизней и того, что им дорого. Я даже более чем уверен что он же и причастен к тем 8-ми годам о которых любят говорить те, кто слушают пропаганду. Вообще все сложно. Но главное быть человеком. А политики - это не люди ) это зло. Причем почти все.
@ghjorhyliuybn168
@ghjorhyliuybn168 Рік тому
@@Knjaz-opium Да, согласен, тошно уже от этой политики. Они принимают решения, выгодные лишь для себя и возможно для какой-то группы людей из их окружения. А то что будет с народом - их не волнует. Такое ощущение что Пу живет в своем каком-то мирке. В итоге десятки тысяч людей с обоих сторон прожигают молодость на войне, которой быть не должно вовсе ... Вообщем адекватные россияне за вас. Береги себя, следи за здоровьем, пытайся пить побольше воды С ув. Илья из Краснодара. Искренне надеюсь что весь этот абсурд скоро кончится. Но следы от этого будут еще десятки лет.
@marias5088
@marias5088 Рік тому
@@ghjorhyliuybn168 Мы не верим в нациков, мы их на видео видели, когда они выходили из Азовстали, а Вы решили видео не смотреть и просто поверить иностранным СМИ? Да, большинство россиян против войны, но не против войны с нацистами.
@ryanelli9841
@ryanelli9841 7 місяців тому
I was crying watching these women especially the old lady(artist) who stand in the public where lots of people recognized her and show her their support.😢😢
@sophietrethewey373
@sophietrethewey373 Рік тому
This really made me cry, very moving, great women, heroes
@ShizukaOG
@ShizukaOG Рік тому
*They even got Karen in Russia.*
@Juarzed
@Juarzed Рік тому
karens everywhere
@ShizukaOG
@ShizukaOG Рік тому
@@Juarzed *A country where you least Expected.*
@e.thomas8722
@e.thomas8722 Рік тому
WOW THAT WAS SO POWERFUL.. I COMMEND THE PROTESTERS.. THE BRAVE ARTIST..ALL THOSE WOMEN ARE BRAVE.. THEY ARE RIGHT..RUSSIA IS NOT PUTIN
@dagreatstoney.5869
@dagreatstoney.5869 Рік тому
Heartbreaking, heartwarming at the same time, beautiful brave people 😢
@alf3707
@alf3707 Рік тому
That old lady has "balls" to do the right thing. For her as an elderly it's already very difficult to live cus of the low salary and what her family went through during WWII.But she's still keeping up against the evil. YOU GO GRANDMA
@lunacy3
@lunacy3 Рік тому
Respect to all of these women, truly❤️
@markokuk327
@markokuk327 Рік тому
This video makes me emotional. Yes, we all need peace to prevale.
@delesprie86
@delesprie86 Рік тому
Brave women!!!! We love you and support your cause. We honor you!!! Thank you😢😢😢. We need more people like you, you are counted as a hero too.
@rainieresguerra4780
@rainieresguerra4780 Рік тому
The old lady is really really brave. I bow to your courage in expressing your beliefs. Godbless. 🙏🙏🙏
@Diegogr08
@Diegogr08 Рік тому
All my respect, admiration and support to these brave Russian women who represent the best of the Russian people, who represent the best of humanity. From Spain, thanks to The Guardian for this great video document. 👏👏👏👏👏👏
@ejs7861
@ejs7861 Рік тому
Hello... How about Cataluna independence and their freedom.... Many people got jailed for protest....
@justiceforall2054
@justiceforall2054 Рік тому
Serving Putin war is bad for russian people
@GeekyC
@GeekyC Рік тому
@@Knjaz-opium Sending you love from the UK .. Prayers arent much but ive been lighting a candle pretty much everyday for you all and keeping up with your news since the second day
@shah-zj1tt
@shah-zj1tt Рік тому
@@GeekyC Let me help you, my friend, I am translating, especially for you, the nickname of this person. @✴️ΟͲҔϷΟС ΟҔΨξСͲΒΑ✴️ -"The dregs of society". This is an absolutely accurate translation, I did not add anything from myself.
@kacodemonio
@kacodemonio Рік тому
@@ejs7861 Ehem . . . No.
@mrsmirnoff8715
@mrsmirnoff8715 Рік тому
The true patriots of Russia.
@hamilthamilton3251
@hamilthamilton3251 Рік тому
Да та женщина настоящий патриот)
@cristinaguevara5201
@cristinaguevara5201 Рік тому
Admiration and respect for this old lady and the young woman.Doing the right thing….🇺🇦glory to Ukraine .Peace ✌🏻❤
@Iquey
@Iquey Рік тому
We as Americans should all hope to be at least half as brave as the elderly woman with the sign by herself (as well as the young woman with the pale roses who stood have her were life ahead of her). I'm afraid we might need courage like that soon.
@danims7329
@danims7329 Рік тому
Very beautiful video, with some very touching moments. It's just so heartbreaking to see these brave women's protests have so little support from other people on the streets.
@JoeVideoed
@JoeVideoed Рік тому
It seemed for the older artists, at least some of the younger people were nice & supportive. There just needs to be more.
@brianharris1813
@brianharris1813 Рік тому
The voice of sanity from these brave women. There is so much fear in people though and suppression to talk openly🇺🇦🕊🇺🇦🕊🇺🇦
@timtrewyn453
@timtrewyn453 Рік тому
I thought I saw a lot of cautious support. Even the cops figured out the elder woman's act was not worth making into a public scene.
@jorgegonzalez-larramendi5491
@jorgegonzalez-larramendi5491 Рік тому
@@moomoocowsly and the vietnam madness: most of us boomers are/were decent and fair.. and we knew back in the 1960s that the hydrocarbons are obsolete evil.. we tried..
@herekitty791
@herekitty791 Рік тому
'Brave Russian moms who encouraged their 18 year old boys to fight in Ukraine 🤡
@CanComp
@CanComp Рік тому
The old lady is smart, cause she knows about the war back then and actually sees her country transforming, into what her dad probably once fought against.
@nomiki8436
@nomiki8436 Рік тому
All my respect, love and strength to these three wonderful women. Bless you.
@christopherschmidt1469
@christopherschmidt1469 Рік тому
She survived the siege of Leningrad in World War II. She's a hero and objects to the government's role in the war and the heads of state who make everyone's lives more difficult. If only we could all be as brave as she is now. What a wonderful woman.
@daniellecherdak6898
@daniellecherdak6898 Рік тому
Brave women. I wish I lived my life with even a fraction of that.
@pavelshnaps2345
@pavelshnaps2345 Рік тому
Brave? Emotionally unstable, politically uneducated, personally motivated. Brave are the boys on the very ground kicking away NATO proxies, fighting street after street.
@pavelshnaps2345
@pavelshnaps2345 Рік тому
You are a troll, you've created your profile on the 20 of may, specially for provocative statements.
@MrJdsenior
@MrJdsenior Рік тому
@@pavelshnaps2345 You are a troll, Danielle's statement had literally zero provocation in it. And who cares when she first hit YT?
@thankstrek5759
@thankstrek5759 Рік тому
Praise to these ladies of different generations,this brings some warmth to a repressed society
@frankieclayton9303
@frankieclayton9303 Рік тому
This older woman is so strong brave a beautiful blessing for standing up for what is right
@piotrdundziak6665
@piotrdundziak6665 Рік тому
Szacunek dla pani Eleny 👏💪👍🇵🇱🤝🇺🇦🤞✌
@rayofthesun7239
@rayofthesun7239 Рік тому
My heart ate w/them,the old lady and the woman w/ white flowers,she is called harsh words but the lady who confronted her fitted to the words she threw upon her...disgusting stinky mouth.
@petemoss8625
@petemoss8625 Рік тому
Brave women, We salute you, and thankyou, your peaceful protest is not in vain.
@volna880
@volna880 Рік тому
That makes me cry. I’m so sorry. Bravest women. Thank you.
@Trener_Artem
@Trener_Artem Рік тому
They are not "risking it all". They are risking dozen thousands of rubles fine. Unlike Ukraine, people dont get shot in the head here for speaking what they want to.
@lordarchibald3691
@lordarchibald3691 Рік тому
Правильно говоришь, клоунаду устроили ещё и говорят "тюрьма", хотя за такое нарушение предусматривается максимум административка. Особенно это забавно, вспоминая случай с Марией Овсянниковой, которой просто выписали штраф хД
@gabklein1
@gabklein1 Рік тому
Russia is not Putin. I see you with love, fellow humans.
@sands7779
@sands7779 Рік тому
my favourite comment- it is convenient to lump people into stereotypes and this video shows some of the variety
@stanbigdabigda411
@stanbigdabigda411 Рік тому
More Russians should PROVE that Russia is not Putin...
@user-yj7um6hv1d
@user-yj7um6hv1d Рік тому
Thanks, lieutenant obvious! We know that we're not Putin.
@alkazeicer9616
@alkazeicer9616 Рік тому
it is so warm feeling to see this granny standing up for peace.. It looks like smart people treated like they are handicapped..
@mrsfrosja
@mrsfrosja Рік тому
So much respect for Elena Osipova
@iandale8762
@iandale8762 Рік тому
What a courageous young woman, standing up to the witch!
@CCitis
@CCitis Рік тому
Three beautiful women, three beautiful souls. We stand with you, and we know there are many who do not support Putins regime.
@bravestbullfighter
@bravestbullfighter Рік тому
Respect to the freedom fighters. You will be remembered in future history books.
@wladimirnowak8797
@wladimirnowak8797 Рік тому
where they were during many ears of Bandersztat leaded genocide against Donbass ? ! They promoters of genocide !Kak zhywut strany w Sojuznim SNG , i kak wse tridtsatj let iz Ukrainy, liogszej pod sataninskij kolonialjnyj Zapad , sdelali nishenku a potom i sataninskij Bandersztat - Kliniku bujno pomeszannych s psihopatijej i suicydnymi pozywami w masztabe wsej strany. Tak kto zhe zhywiot i razwiwajetsa i myslit konstruktiwno a kto podyhajet bo zbozhewilliau niczyczym bezumets ?
@user-bc3pv6dx8k
@user-bc3pv6dx8k Рік тому
Кого будут помнить??? Бабусю, или эту девочку, которая через полгода вообще забудет,что снималась в кино!?))))))))
@senatornikoloz6987
@senatornikoloz6987 Рік тому
@@user-bc3pv6dx8k Ага, я ещё не понимаю как люди в это верят.
@user-bc3pv6dx8k
@user-bc3pv6dx8k Рік тому
@@senatornikoloz6987 Верят и даже очень.Это видео мне прислал знакомый из Канады! Уверен, блин прям очень,что так оно и есть!
@svetiks100
@svetiks100 Рік тому
This was so hard to watch. These incredible women are an amazing inspirations to all for freedom. My heart was just feeling their true desire for peace. The older woman is very touching and so deep.
@enriquegarcia2612
@enriquegarcia2612 Рік тому
That reminds me once during the Falkland war a student was evicted from the university refectory because expressing her feelings against that war. It happens everywhere.
@tessatandler393
@tessatandler393 Рік тому
What brave courageous human beings...an example to us all
@EvaLieblich
@EvaLieblich Рік тому
I had to cry most of the time... Thank you so much to this woman! And thank you to all people that work for freedom!! For a world in peace
@davidsartin5708
@davidsartin5708 Рік тому
Bravo, young lady,(grandmother). I admire your paintings and dedication to peace. Thank you.
@megamediker
@megamediker Рік тому
Outstanding, thank you for delivering this vital insight, Roland from good old Germany
@danielcruz5206
@danielcruz5206 Рік тому
Kudos to these women for standing up against Putin and his regime.
@ice9594
@ice9594 Рік тому
Putin isn’t the enemy. Look in your own back yard.
@cann0708
@cann0708 Рік тому
@@ice9594 I'm pretty sure most world leaders are our enemies, Putin included
@Titaniumjake1472
@Titaniumjake1472 Рік тому
@@ice9594 no putin is the enemy how bout you open your effin eyes
@werwer5339
@werwer5339 Рік тому
@@ice9594 Putin is the enemy. Look in your own back yard. I fixed it for you.
@imaginemetoo
@imaginemetoo Рік тому
Putin is not Russia! Putin's wealth is Russia's!
@yo2trader539
@yo2trader539 Рік тому
Brave people exist everywhere. Appearances are so deceiving.
@robertn314
@robertn314 Рік тому
Pretty sad These people are walking a fine line Prayers for people
@MrYablochnik
@MrYablochnik Рік тому
Thank you, The Guardian, for this touching video! In my opinion, it is very important that as many people in the world as possible know that not everyone in my country supports Putin's unprovoked and unjustifiable war against Ukraine and that there are quite a few people who have taken a firm stand against it. At least in their minds, as not everyone is brave enough to protest openly for fear of a jail sentence. And I am especially proud of those who don't fear! It is thanks to them that we will be able to build, once Putin's regime collapses, a new democratic Russia of the future!
@chepteneala696
@chepteneala696 Рік тому
За новую демократическую Россию будущего!
@MrYablochnik
@MrYablochnik Рік тому
@@chepteneala696 И это будущее обязательно наступит! Перефразируя Маяковского, "когда такие люди у нас в России есть!"
@1kchallengezerovideo805
@1kchallengezerovideo805 Рік тому
Even I feel like crying 😭 hope this war end soon and their be peace among Russia and Ukraine..
@symek2033
@symek2033 Рік тому
With Putin at the helm there will NEVER be peace or his old cronies which back Putin🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬 A whole new Government is needed with progressive thinking people & younger educated persons as Navalyn who was locked up by Putin for wanting a None Currupt Government ‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️
@IrenESorius
@IrenESorius Рік тому
Eternal glory to those who stands up against tyranny,, 🇸🇪💖🇺🇦
@cheebacheeo5876
@cheebacheeo5876 Рік тому
Sic Semper Tyrannis...
@GalacticNovaOverlord
@GalacticNovaOverlord Рік тому
Then that must mean everyone who stands up against the tyranny of the west must have eternal glory eh? Stop being puppets for this fight of two great evils
@user-ll8wy6ws4r
@user-ll8wy6ws4r Рік тому
These are my russian heros, russian brothers and sisters ❤️🙏
@annborges9088
@annborges9088 Рік тому
I am in awe of the bravery of these women. I wonder if I would be as brave, given the same circumstances and choices.
@JackBQuick79
@JackBQuick79 Рік тому
The bravery and tenacity of that sweet lady is inspiration to me here in Michigan. I hope everything works out in her favor.
@SUPREMEdiver33
@SUPREMEdiver33 Рік тому
They're so brave I couldn't do what they're doing
@CyarleyBlack
@CyarleyBlack Рік тому
She doesn't risk at all. It's legal and free in Russia to perform peaceful protests. She has her opinion, but also she want's to be popular, that's it. Stop believing in stereotypes and feed narcissism. With all the best wishes and love from Russia.
What Russians Think About Leaving Russia Now | Easy Russian 55
12:20
Easy Russian
Переглядів 126 тис.
одни дома // EVA mash @TweetvilleCartoon
01:00
EVA mash
Переглядів 4,4 млн
Who are Just Stop Oil? Where the controversial climate protesters began
16:41
Russian girls about feminism, dating and splitting bills
14:15
Eli from Russia
Переглядів 1,2 млн
Russian police arrest man holding up blank sheet of paper
2:30
Global News
Переглядів 1,1 млн
'A fragile monster': Author describes Putin's character
10:48
What Ukraine needs to defeat Russia - Expert explains
25:47
Channel 4 News
Переглядів 313 тис.
What Do the Chinese Think of Russia? | Street Interview
17:20
Asian Boss
Переглядів 2,9 млн