Saving Kids From Government Schools

  Переглядів 140,702

John Stossel

John Stossel

2 роки тому

It’s school choice week!
What's that? It's a week about giving parents and kids a choice of schools, so they aren't stuck in failing, government-run schools.
----
To make sure you see the new weekly video from Stossel TV, sign up here: www.johnstossel.com/#subscribe
----
At some of these alternatives, amazing things happen. I visited one school where the kids LIKE learning. Reading is "rockin' awesome," one kid tells me.
That school was created by Eva Moskowitz. Her “Success Academy" now runs 46 charter schools that teach more than 15,000 students. As a charter, she has more freedom to innovate.
Her school gets amazing results: 95% of kids pass the state math test, and 84% pass English. At government monopoly schools x and x pass.
Despite her success with kids, she receives nasty criticism.
Critics say that she only takes the best kids. But that's false. The kids are selected by random lottery.
Critics say she pushes difficult kids out of her school to increase her results. That's also false; her schools have a lower drop-out rate than public schools.
See the video above for more on what school choice can accomplish.

КОМЕНТАРІ: 1 300
@kkampy4052
@kkampy4052 2 роки тому
The biggest hurdle ironically is the teachers union. They are the biggest obstacle to quality education.
@goofyfoot2001
@goofyfoot2001 2 роки тому
Everything government is the biggest obstacle to everything.
@rupertsamborski5153
@rupertsamborski5153 2 роки тому
Bound to the democrat party
@robrobets7813
@robrobets7813 2 роки тому
True, and the over-bloated School Boards and Administrators that simply leech most of the Government Funding marked for "Education". The actual Public Schools get nickels on the dollar after Unions, School Boards and Administrators all get their cut. Baltimore is a prime example... Gets ever increasing Federal Budget every year, yet the Failing Schools in those Districts are as bad or worse than previous generations.
@rupertsamborski5153
@rupertsamborski5153 2 роки тому
Unsustainable pensions
@markekar6021
@markekar6021 2 роки тому
is that irony? its probably ironic that you think its irony. anyway, yea, of course the mob is in the way lol
@waynert69
@waynert69 2 роки тому
Heartbreaking that not all kids have this opportunity.
@whousa642
@whousa642 2 роки тому
Why heartbreaking? Done by WE THE PEOPLE
@spikes1529
@spikes1529 2 роки тому
If i want to be a teacher, it requires a lot of paperwork. I could be an electrical engineer and yet not able to become a teacher because i dont have classes in teaching...
@jameskearney4100
@jameskearney4100 2 роки тому
@@spikes1529 You took the wrong classes.
@Terminxman
@Terminxman 2 роки тому
They try to keep it that way, the teachers unions and bureaucrats with agendas don’t want kids out of the public system
@noobandfriends2420
@noobandfriends2420 2 роки тому
By design.
@tomhenschel1104
@tomhenschel1104 2 роки тому
“There is nothing wrong with the children, there is something wrong with the system”. Shout it from the mountaintop, Sister!
@jasoncarr5379
@jasoncarr5379 2 роки тому
Truth is truth!
@michaelharmon2389
@michaelharmon2389 2 роки тому
Oh no, that lets the asshole administrators and bureaucrats off the hook. The system is flawed, but the people running the system are the reason it stays flawed.
@monkeybitz7717
@monkeybitz7717 2 роки тому
And those parents who don't want their kids to be smarter than they are!
@dannygillmusic
@dannygillmusic 2 роки тому
Let's be real there's something wrong with the parents
@MP-ef9yo
@MP-ef9yo 2 роки тому
The problem is that charter schools have skewed data because they hand select students who are already performing well in school. If they had to educate students with learning diabilities or students from broken homes like public schools do, they wouldn't look so holier than thou
@Crazy-Chicken-Media
@Crazy-Chicken-Media 2 роки тому
Imagine not wanting your kids to have a good education...
@DoesThisWork888
@DoesThisWork888 2 роки тому
Good education is racisss!!
@cayakdawson2020
@cayakdawson2020 2 роки тому
As a teacher working in a public school. Saddly I don't have to imagine. We are less and less education, and more and more a daycare.
@danieltorrens4954
@danieltorrens4954 2 роки тому
Then stay home with them and teach them yourself! Then you will have nothing to complain about when your children grow up and hate you no matter what you do!
@Crazy-Chicken-Media
@Crazy-Chicken-Media 2 роки тому
@@danieltorrens4954 wow, there is a lot to unpack in that short comment... I take it you had bad parents? And there for equate homeschooling as a punishment instead of something better? It would be nice to see some discussion instead of I don't know what that comment was considered. So please get back to me and tell me why you "feel" this way.
@glennabate1708
@glennabate1708 2 роки тому
Schools should be run by non profit organizations not the government. Get the government out of our kids education.
@kathyalex778
@kathyalex778 2 роки тому
1:21 “Kids rise to your level of expectation” Absolutely, this is 100% true. This is why kids who come from families who value education and are involved in their kids’ learning will always perform phenomenally better than kids who come from families who don’t give a damn and aren’t good role models for the kids.
@zvipatent
@zvipatent 2 роки тому
Good point. Was true for me. When I was placed in advanced level classes without even being asked, I got serious. I was lucky
@chefgregarious
@chefgregarious 2 роки тому
Kids will meet low expectations as well. I hate seeing unruly kids and the parents are like, "oh he's just a kid". You get what you expect, generally.
@parrotshootist3004
@parrotshootist3004 2 роки тому
@@chefgregarious parents with 'covert Narcissistic' issues secretly project expectations of being less than or nothing. They then wonder why at least one kid under performs, depressed etc
@Zamkat013
@Zamkat013 2 роки тому
People underestimate kids so much.
@SovereignStatesman
@SovereignStatesman 2 роки тому
“Kids rise to your level of expectation” No, they rise to the level of their OPPORTUNITY. I was 8 years ahead of the class in 6th grade, so school always felt like a prison.
@zvipatent
@zvipatent 2 роки тому
I am impressed when the teacher calls her students "scholars". They will try to live up to this expectation
@TheOrangeRoad
@TheOrangeRoad 2 роки тому
Meh, thats just a participant trophy. I think its kinda stupid
@walterlowe7252
@walterlowe7252 2 роки тому
@@TheOrangeRoad they are scholars… they aren’t getting an award for participation… I’m confused by what you mean
@glasshalffull8625
@glasshalffull8625 2 роки тому
@@TheOrangeRoad They are budding scholars and looks like they deserve the title. Also, it’s part of molding them to think of themselves as someone who pursues academics. Similarly, When I coach baseball, I don’t say, “ Guys listen up.” I say, “team.” I’m molding a team every practice and these teachers are molding scholars.
@epauletshark3793
@epauletshark3793 2 роки тому
We have been doing a similar thing in the homeschool group I was in. It works well.
@blest5132
@blest5132 2 роки тому
it's a show for YOU, don't you understand this??? "all the world's a stage" propaganda 101, wake up.
@CM-mz3qy
@CM-mz3qy 2 роки тому
I teared up when I saw the parents in line wanting hope for their kids. And how sad they were when they didn’t get in
@bostonphotographer20
@bostonphotographer20 2 роки тому
And I was disgusted at that woman who was yelling about simply giving parents a choice where their kids go.
@rosc2022
@rosc2022 2 роки тому
Right? That one little guy in tears was just heartbreaking.
@cydra_infinity1423
@cydra_infinity1423 2 роки тому
Damn Communist institutions are a tragedy to America. I really wish these parasitic propagandist would have mercy on the vulnerable.
@bogusphone8000
@bogusphone8000 2 роки тому
"I will fight until my dying breath" to make sure my child has no greater opportunity than me.
@rosc2022
@rosc2022 2 роки тому
Believe it or not, a friend who taught in New Jersey schools, late 70's, had ongoing issues with, "if the education was good enough for me, it's good enough for my kid." That attitude sure doesn't help kids.
@johncrocker4209
@johncrocker4209 2 роки тому
My eldest daughter started in a charter. Transferring to public after 5th grade & was placed in advanced programs. Now she's on track to graduate 2 years earlier than her classmates. Her younger sister (born after the move) can't read or do simple mathematics at grade level. We found out during the shutdown. A hard way to find out public schools are not only under preforming but they are less likely to let parents know their children need help.
@c59997
@c59997 2 роки тому
They are also indoctrinating your kids
@purplepeopleeater5355
@purplepeopleeater5355 2 роки тому
My oldest couldn’t read “Cat in the Hat” at the end of 2nd grade. It was so bad! We pulled him out and started homeschooling because there were NO other options. He’s almost 19, in college, and set to graduate this fall. Best decision we’ve ever made!! I know it’s not for everyone but if you can sacrifice it pays off in the long run.
@ThePoliticalOrangeAngler
@ThePoliticalOrangeAngler 2 роки тому
Listen to some of the union teachers speak. They're illiterates teaching illiterately.
@ageofgaslightenment
@ageofgaslightenment 2 роки тому
If it takes a shutdown to find out your child is behind, I suppose a lack of parental involvement in their education is part of the issue.
@johncrocker4209
@johncrocker4209 2 роки тому
@@ageofgaslightenment I accept that I could have been more involved. I certainly am now. The difference is the charter school never hesitated to let us know when & where my child was having issues. Public school just acted like daycare & apparently didn't grade based on actual achievement or feel like encouraging engagement. So like a fool I trusted people with the title of teacher to "teach". Lesson learned.
@spldrong
@spldrong 2 роки тому
School choice is a real problem we should be dealing with instead of who is a "racist" or who said what 15 years ago
@rosc2022
@rosc2022 2 роки тому
Only as long as everyone remembers that school isn't daycare. I suspect that too many kids (and parents) transition from daycare to school without taking time to contemplate the very real difference. Kids really do have a job, learning, and I suspect very few are told explicitly that they do and what it is.
@thereligionofrationality8257
@thereligionofrationality8257 2 роки тому
"Kids rise to your level of expectation." Exactly! When did Western society forget this obvious truism?
@blkshp25
@blkshp25 2 роки тому
When victimhood began paying more
@MM3Soapgoblin
@MM3Soapgoblin 2 роки тому
No child left behind. All of the advanced placement programs in my district were scrapped to move the funding to special education during that time. I went from learning pre-calc in 5th grade to being a problem child in 6th grade and routinely accused of cheating because I didn't pay attention in class but still got ~100% on the tests. I even got suspended once because I wasn't showing work, told the teacher I was just doing it in my head, and my teacher said it was impossible, even he struggled doing it in his head. The administration said the only possibility was that I had cheated (even though they made me take a new, harder test, under supervision and still aced it). I wish I could find that teacher now, show him my PhD in physics, and tell him how he made me want to drop out of school. If it wasn't for my 7th grade math teacher that gave me separate assignments on the side to challenge me I would have tuned out completely. She was awesome but she got reprimanded by the same administrator for not having me follow the "approved 7th grade" curriculum.
@GlobalOutcast
@GlobalOutcast 2 роки тому
@@MM3Soapgoblin No childhood leftbehind: By making everyone equally braindead
@dawnmitchell11
@dawnmitchell11 2 роки тому
Kids DO rise (or sink) to your level of expectation. Absolutely true, EVERYTIME, EVERY kid!
@dawnmitchell11
@dawnmitchell11 2 роки тому
@@MM3Soapgoblin this makes me sad. I see this with my son in our district as well. They have some advanced programs, but in the last few years they have been starting to allow anyone who wants to participate be in them. It has caused the challenge level to drop significantly. I'm no expert in SPED issues, but I do believe some of the funding for SPED should be funded through medical department, not education. Many SPED students require physical medical or mental health medical intervention. We have an older son that has a learning disability that mimics dyslexia. I do believe if he had been referred to a medical professional, he would have been diagnosed much more quickly and received the kind of training and assistance he needed. But, the school said it was their job to test, etc. 🙄
@bidmcms3
@bidmcms3 2 роки тому
Doing the most important work a journalist can do. Spread the message far and wide folks!
@peppolobuondelmonte
@peppolobuondelmonte 2 роки тому
With a sense of humor to boot.
@richarddelaney9593
@richarddelaney9593 2 роки тому
Journalists are the problem.
@hearttoheart4me
@hearttoheart4me 2 роки тому
@@richarddelaney9593 Today's main stream media with their over inflated egos calling themselves journalists but only giving their opinions or what they are told, are the problem.
@SovereignStatesman
@SovereignStatesman 2 роки тому
Bullshit. All he does is WHINE about how terrrible government is, but says NOTHING about how elections are ultimatums implemented by the illegal "civil war."
@juniorvonclaire3576
@juniorvonclaire3576 2 роки тому
@@SovereignStatesman Bullshit. He’s in the PRIVATE SECTOR and owes YOU absolutely nothing! Don’t like it? Go become a journalist instead of just whining online. 🇺🇸👊🏻🗽
@rupertsamborski5153
@rupertsamborski5153 2 роки тому
I’ve been saying it for years: liberate education - defund the government run monopoly of public schools. We the people can educate ourselves better then the government
@07wrxtr1
@07wrxtr1 2 роки тому
They don’t want “educated” kids anymore as American workers cost more.
@tracybarhite1764
@tracybarhite1764 2 роки тому
The dumbing down of children in public schools has been happening for years.
@combativeThinker
@combativeThinker 2 роки тому
This is deliberate. The government wants ignorant slaves.
@metallord6960
@metallord6960 2 роки тому
Yeah but if kids grow up to be smart and, God forbid, capable of thinking for themselves, how will the politicians get the vote?
@andyiswonderful
@andyiswonderful 2 роки тому
@@combativeThinker No, the parents and ghetto culture are promoting ignorance within minority populations.
@iandaut9634
@iandaut9634 2 роки тому
As a parent of a first grader in a public school I was appalled at how low the expectations and quality of learning is. Now I am home schooling in addition and set for her to start at a charter school next semester with much better curriculum.
@lehbeltman
@lehbeltman 2 роки тому
years ago my daughter started at a private school for kindergarten and first grade. We couldn't afford it and sent her to public school starting in second grade. She had learned to write in cursive in 1st grade in private school. Her second grade public school teacher told her not to write in cursive because the other kids didn't know how yet and it would hurt their feelings. Public school in a nut shell, lower the top not raise the bottom.
@vitaly6312
@vitaly6312 2 роки тому
I was born in Russia and went to first grade there before moving to the US. We learned long division by the end of 1st grade. I wasn’t challenged in the US in math until I went to middle school.
@Bookworm51485
@Bookworm51485 2 роки тому
I work in a school. It's almost embarrassing how little is expected from these kids... Showing up is pretty much all they seem to expect
@newsnowadirondacksredux360
@newsnowadirondacksredux360 2 роки тому
This panics the Public School Unions.
@matthewbyrd2329
@matthewbyrd2329 2 роки тому
America's downfall began with these phrases: "You're special" "We don't keep score" "Everyone gets a trophy"
@metallord6960
@metallord6960 2 роки тому
And for the icing on the shit-cake, "No child left behind".
@georgetang6157
@georgetang6157 2 роки тому
Also with a few abusive teachers refusing to help students succeed in their classes. They wouldn't care even if you work your ass off and still couldn't do well.
@anastasiab9506
@anastasiab9506 2 роки тому
yes, and now we are at a point where "we can't fail you if you can't read english because that would be racist"
@JohnDoe-xf2ke
@JohnDoe-xf2ke 2 роки тому
No, it began with the establishment of the Federal Reserve & adoption of fiat currency. Once the US currency was controlled by a private cartel of bankers, they were able to devalue our wealth by printing money and giving it to their friends. Creating dollars from thin air lets them manipulate society in a million ways.
@WackadoodleMalarkey
@WackadoodleMalarkey 2 роки тому
You'll own nothing and be happy
@mr-fh2be
@mr-fh2be 2 роки тому
I was home schooled as a high schooler. This was in the mid to late 90's. Had to sit with the books every day and do the actual work solo. No online classes at all. Family member took the answer and solutions books in math from me. Really made me buckle down and solve the problems. So yes, parents should have the choice to do whats best for their children. That is a God given right and responsibility upon them!
@honkhonk8009
@honkhonk8009 2 роки тому
Every Asian kid does that aswell. We all go to schools, but the moment we come home, we learn at our own pace. School is more like a glorified daycare, and home and Kahn Academy/kumon is our real teachers. Sad that rich white liberals dont understand this basic aspect of education.
@elaishh3533
@elaishh3533 2 роки тому
Great video! Who would of thought encouraging kids to reach their potential would have better success then telling them they are victims.
@jeffklaubo3168
@jeffklaubo3168 2 роки тому
They are victims though... victims of the school system speaking on their behalf
@haroldb1856
@haroldb1856 2 роки тому
They tell some children that they are victims, but they also slander and villify certain children, like children of military families, as oppressors.
@NotEvenDeathCanSaveU
@NotEvenDeathCanSaveU 2 роки тому
"You are a victim, thats why you're so uneducated my child.. Trump did this" :DD
@catmandenny
@catmandenny 2 роки тому
Charter school help students learn how to think, not what to think.
@thevolatilitywhisperer7616
@thevolatilitywhisperer7616 2 роки тому
Putting my son in charter school is one of the best decisions I've made. My oldest went to public (grown now) my youngest started last yr and the quality of education isn't comparable. Our school is amazing!!!
@doughaug
@doughaug 2 роки тому
I was lucky enough to hear a government official from Finland talk about how they achieve good results, and the most important thing I got out of it is that there is an expectation of excellence from the students, the teachers and the parents. If we expect a fifty percent failure rate, that is what we will most likely get.
@MrZoomah
@MrZoomah 2 роки тому
Funny thing is. Those experts for Finland would be 100% against charter schools. I was reading a report written by one into Australia's education system, which went from top 5 to... far down.. in 20 years. What happened over the last 20 years? Standardised testing, publicly funding private education and creating 'independent public schools' aka charter schools. So why are we falling? Why are charter schools and why is subsidizing private education bad? It encourages segregation. In Australia parents who can afford to drive their kids can remove their kids from 'bad' schools or pay for their kids to be in schools that are highly funded. Why is that bad? When schools reach the threshold of 50% disadvantaged kids it becomes very hard to lift up kids due to lack of role models and behaviour issues. In Finland there are no charter schools. There are no private schools. You have public schools and you send your kid to the closest one. There is no shopping around. The problem is that education is run by politicians. If experts ran it we could scrap half the non-sense and follow what science says works. My foster kid is in public school. His old public school had 2 nominated teachers of the year and principal of the year but it had over 60% disadvantaged kids. He is now at very boring school but in which maybe 10% are low socio economic. He has so many issues and he easily the most disadvantages, and worst behaved, kid in the school. He has come further in 1 year than he did in the first 3 years of school. Why? Because he looks at his peers and measures his behaviours and academics against them. He has raised his own standards.
@sjoerdderks4731
@sjoerdderks4731 2 роки тому
what the finland schools and charter schools have in common is that they are aware that they teaching children, each with an diffrent technique to keep the kids interested
@robgibbs216
@robgibbs216 2 роки тому
This is one of the BEST videos I have seen in a LONG time on any channel! Great job! 💪
@SyntagmaStation
@SyntagmaStation 2 роки тому
John Stossel is an American treasure. He has been at the top of his profession since the early 1980s and he’s just getting better and better as he gets older. His devil’s advocate interviewing style (using typical pushback points to elicit a response) is something no one else does, and it’s just masterful.
@dmichael1172
@dmichael1172 2 роки тому
And he doesn't take sides,which so many so called journalists do now.
@sschuyler1
@sschuyler1 2 роки тому
Thomas Sowell wrote a very good book last year called, "Charter Schools and their Enemies". Success Academy was one of the charter schools profiled, but as he pointed out, not all charters performed as well.
@MP-ef9yo
@MP-ef9yo 2 роки тому
That's because some charter only accept students who are already perfoming well in school. They don't need to catch students up who are behind. Especially since teachers at charter schools do not need teaching degrees or licenses. The charters who actually try do it right and accept both higher and lower performing students perform even worse than public schools because they have less experienced teachers
@yukihirasouma4691
@yukihirasouma4691 2 роки тому
@@MP-ef9yo did you even watch the video or read the description. Lol
@MP-ef9yo
@MP-ef9yo 2 роки тому
@@yukihirasouma4691 Have you ever worked in a charter school like I have? Lol
@litigioussociety4249
@litigioussociety4249 2 роки тому
I feel bad for that kid who's mom was against charter schools. That's like being opposed to a scholarship or internship for your child.
@dawnmitchell11
@dawnmitchell11 2 роки тому
The look on the little boy's face who was standing next to her was quites telling and sad.
@andrewfreeman88
@andrewfreeman88 2 роки тому
You could see and feel the angry in her eyes and voice. Her poor kid was taught rage and angry at that moment.
@JasonAdank
@JasonAdank 2 роки тому
yeah, the little kids reaction was heartbreaking. He intuitively knew his mom was off her rocker. sux being sabotaged by your own parents.
@MP-ef9yo
@MP-ef9yo 2 роки тому
Charter schools only accept students who are already performing high in school. They take funding away from public schools who service kids with learning disabilities who charter schools feel are not worth their time or effort
@litigioussociety4249
@litigioussociety4249 2 роки тому
@@MP-ef9yo Did you not watch the video? One, many charter schools have lotteries for any kid who qualifies. Two, if public school was gone, then private education would offer more opportunities for kids with disabilities, and in fact they already do in cities that don't tax their residents so much that the residents don't want to engage in private charity.
@TheVagolfer
@TheVagolfer 2 роки тому
There is nothing the government does better than the private sector - Mail delivery, utilities, the military, space exploration, etc., etc. And yes, even schools. The private sector always does it better, faster and cheaper.
@1mropz1
@1mropz1 2 роки тому
I'm really grateful my kids have been able to attend k-6 and 6-12 charter schools in Arizona. The charters schools were A rated and public schools were D or F rated, but there's a happy twist here. The competition forced the public schools to step up their academic efforts and a few years later they are now an A or B rated school. Reasonable people might call that a win-win situation, but it seems many in big cities want no part in a competitive academic milieu. What might that situation be called?
@bryanboone7363
@bryanboone7363 2 роки тому
A friend of mine takes her kids to Basis and UHS in AZ and they are 10 times more educated than any other kld I know.
@1010cryptosonny
@1010cryptosonny 2 роки тому
@Charles Larkin I would suggest Basis Chandler and ACP (Arizona College Prep) in Chandler, AZ are good schools.
@chuckhanshaw1638
@chuckhanshaw1638 2 роки тому
Patriot....A person who vigorously supports their country and is prepared to defend it against enemies or detractors... A true Patriot will defend his country FROM its government. Thomas Jefferson
@SyntheToonz
@SyntheToonz 2 роки тому
My teen-age daughter goes to a Charter school. It is A-M-A-Z-I-N-G the level of resources that the school can have when it doesn't have to pay for useless bureaucrats. We were sending her to private schools costing an arm and a leg and the resources there were not as good as the Charter school. The art and science departments in the Charter school are phenomenal. The school has a greenhouse for biology. My kid is on a medical path where her afternoon is dedicated to classes related to the health care industry and her school uniform is medical scrubs. For this the school has a mock medical office and procedure rooms and dummies for test procedures. When my daughter graduates she will have certification qualifying her for a job in a doctor's office BEFORE she goes to college.
@Matt-dk3wl
@Matt-dk3wl 2 роки тому
Vocational schools are like this too. The one I went to in the 90's had Automotive, Carpentry, Plumbing, Metal Fab, Electrical, Electronics, Computer Science, Civil Engineering, and a bunch I'm forgetting. Each had fantastic shops that were well funded and even had corporate sponsorships. e.g Toyota and Automotive, Carpentry with some local builders, etc. That's what high school needs to be. What are kids in regular high schools capable of? Nothing at all.
@scottbarnett3566
@scottbarnett3566 Рік тому
Wow. Where is this?
@SyntheToonz
@SyntheToonz Рік тому
@@scottbarnett3566 The Villages Charter High School in FL..... My kid graduated this year and just started at FAU .
@scottbarnett3566
@scottbarnett3566 Рік тому
@@SyntheToonz thank you!
@perfect1087
@perfect1087 2 роки тому
Every child should get this opportunity. Public schools are the worst. In Nevada they don't have grades lower than 50% because of feelings. My kid didn't take a test and got a 50% on it. It was impossible to explain to him that he didn't get 50% right. He didn't get any answers right. And this was a math test.
@MP-ef9yo
@MP-ef9yo 2 роки тому
Why didn't he take the test? You shouldnt be bragging that your kid bombed a test. This just calls your parenting into question more than anything
@BB-cf9gx
@BB-cf9gx 2 роки тому
An additional contributing factor to the student success is parental love and attention. The parents had to struggle to get their children in to the school.
@AarmOZ84
@AarmOZ84 2 роки тому
I agree that is a factor that shouldn't be ignored.
@MP-ef9yo
@MP-ef9yo 2 роки тому
Exactly! And public schools are tasked with educating students who do not have such devoted parents and must work 10x harder to get those students where they need to be. Charter schools are not outperforming public schools, they just have an easier job
@tpoz48
@tpoz48 2 роки тому
Anything the government touches (including public education) is sub-par compared to the private sector.
@Gandoff2000
@Gandoff2000 2 роки тому
Transform ALL public schools to charter schools. The schools are supposed to be working for the parents not the government.
@romulasex1717
@romulasex1717 2 роки тому
The government owns the children, not the parents
@Gandoff2000
@Gandoff2000 2 роки тому
@@romulasex1717 That is the belief of all communist and that is why communism is the new slavery. Owning people is slavery.
@GlobalOutcast
@GlobalOutcast 2 роки тому
@@romulasex1717 The government doesnt own shit buddy everything they "own" is stolen from its citizens.
@romulasex1717
@romulasex1717 2 роки тому
@@GlobalOutcast tell that cps when they're taking your children away for wrong think.
@combativeThinker
@combativeThinker 2 роки тому
@@romulasex1717 I’d put them in a fucking body bag.
@jacknitro9163
@jacknitro9163 2 роки тому
I am a charter high school school teacher and even though we have our faults, we are 100 times better off than our public school counterparts.
@freyawildesciencefictionau8156
@freyawildesciencefictionau8156 2 роки тому
“Self-education is, I firmly believe, the only kind of education there is.” ― Isaac Asimov The only answer is to get rid of compulsory ed. Put education completely on the free market.
@aquilesriffo
@aquilesriffo 2 роки тому
bad idea for children. Also if you noticed adults already have self-education as they choose to go college or not
@Delosian
@Delosian 2 роки тому
I am somewhat surprised that we haven't 'gamified' education at this stage of our technological development. Every child should get a tablet / iPad that comes pre-loaded with Math, English and Science courses that get steadily more complex.
@nutbastard
@nutbastard 2 роки тому
I think both structured education and autodidactic learning are important. The larger problem is that children are given little choice in what they learn. 90% of my schooling was a waste of time. The only valuable classes I ever took were Math, Science, and Metal Shop. I'll include French ASL as well because learning a second language is just plain cool. The rest of the useful things I ever learned, I learned on my own because I was interested. I'd have given anything to drop History and English and spend as much time as possible in Metal Shop and Wood Shop. I was going to read books anyway, and I don't think anything other than basic history is important for kids. You can't really understand history at that age, or appreciate why it's important to know. This is especially true when it's all about memorizing people and dates. Broad strokes are all kids need, and it always jumped around in time, giving no coherence to the story of mankind. You know what they didn't teach us in the 90's? Vietnam. Korea. Nixon. McCarthy. And don't get me started on the nonsense they taught us about Egypt, Columbus, or Native Americans.
@aquilesriffo
@aquilesriffo 2 роки тому
@@Delosian bad idea because they will expect a reward.
@tihspidtherekciltilc5469
@tihspidtherekciltilc5469 2 роки тому
@@aquilesriffo Can you expand on what you meant by going to college or not?
@maltava4534
@maltava4534 2 роки тому
Having a longer school day that aligns with common work hours would actually alleviate a lot of stress on the family because the parents would need to arrange for after school day care. Single parents wouldn't have to worry about arranging for transportation or leaving kids alone for hours after school. Groups of single parent kids left on their own after school is where gangs recruit.
@FuddlyDud
@FuddlyDud 2 роки тому
So true! I’d recommend doing away with summer break. No job gives you 3 months off annually, so why train children to expect that? Maybe school has more shorter breaks and more trips/games, but the long vacation shouldn’t exist if the goal is to prepare them for working as an adult! :)
@maltava4534
@maltava4534 2 роки тому
@@FuddlyDud I like the year around school year where different groups of kids have different weeks off spread out throughout the year. It gives various seasonal options for vacations and breaks up the monotony. Moreover this also helps with daycare cost for the family and stability for the daycares themselves. When you spread out the demand the prices will be lower and with a consistent number of children the daycares are more stable. The staffing can be fulltime instead of seasonal part time which means better employees. Instead we have boom and bust cycles with daycares and tons of staffing issues. Most of the positions end up part time and are hired quickly which leads to garbage people watching kids.
@rosc2022
@rosc2022 2 роки тому
Only as long as everyone remembers that school isn't daycare. I suspect that too many kids (and parents) transition from daycare to school without taking time to contemplate the very real difference. Kids really do have a job, learning, and I suspect very few are told explicitly that they do and what it is.
@FuddlyDud
@FuddlyDud 2 роки тому
@@maltava4534 Totally true on the varying vacations, better daycare hours, etc.! Bingo on the boom and bust cycles. We need to better serve everyone involved with more consistency AND properly prepare children for adulthood!
@FuddlyDud
@FuddlyDud 2 роки тому
@@rosc2022 VERY good point! The goal is learning/training for adulthood and most kids don't realize this growing up. :/ However, in charter and private schools, the norm is learning and the goal is performing well. :)
@raymanforever
@raymanforever 2 роки тому
As a public school educator, my number 1 predictor of success is how involved are parents at home. The biggest boon that the children of charter or private schools have is not the school itself, but the home environment that care enough to know what goes on in those schools. Grade reports are sent home ever 3 or so weeks, so we do our due diligence to inform parents how their kids are doing, the kids who have consequences at home are constantly trying to strive and improve, the kids who don't, we are lucky if they show up to school at all. Are there situations and schools that don't communicate, of course, but a school can never or should ever be a replacement for family.
@Individual_Lives_Matter
@Individual_Lives_Matter 2 роки тому
While most of what you’re saying is true, the government’s involvement in schools has led to nothing but bloated bureaucracy, inefficiency, corruption (ideological and financial) and miserable outcomes for students. We would have been far better off keeping schools private with some sort of public option that would be akin to a social welfare program and a last resort.
@Individual_Lives_Matter
@Individual_Lives_Matter 2 роки тому
What she said about games is huge. My 8 year old hated school after kindergarten. She said it’s not fun anymore. That’s huge. Government schools are not responsive overall, some teachers are but the public school systems are these huge unwieldy beasts that just can’t cope with change and can’t really meet students where they are.
@VincentWeisTheThird
@VincentWeisTheThird 2 роки тому
The reason I don't buy this argument is that, if it was true, then it could be tested by merely comparing outcomes for students who participate in interdistrict enrollment to students in charters, since presumably both sets of parents are involved in the students wellbeing. Demonstrating statistically that parents are less involved in some schools over others is hard, but it is possible to get some sense of that. Similarly, I find it questionable that the parents enrolling students in charters are consistently more involved or provide a greater home environment. Given that demographically, charters disproportionately enroll students who are poor or near poor, and part of racial minority groups, than the public schools, I find this claim dubious. So poor black students failing in public schools simply have bad home environments, but the same students going to charters, sometimes even in the same building as the public schools, they magically have a better home environment? If these parents are so much more involved, and that's what drives test scores up, why choose the charters in the first place? At what point do we admit that parents look at and care about the curriculum differences? Even if you were right, would it not be desirable to have that separation so that students capable of going at an increased pace were not stymied by students with a slower pace of learning and less support at home?
@the_other_seto_kaiba
@the_other_seto_kaiba 2 роки тому
This is TRUE POWER. Those Kids and EVERY KID knows.
@rebchizelbeak5392
@rebchizelbeak5392 2 роки тому
That mother was so upset that a better school was trying to move in. That is what a cult looks like.
@gjergjibullari
@gjergjibullari 2 роки тому
God bless Eva for her work
@SimonASNG
@SimonASNG 2 роки тому
When having discussions with my lefty friends, this is the easiest one to get them to concede on. They always start out so opposed to anything but public schools and talking about how charters charge more per student and drain money from the schools, and it is so easy to show them it isn't true. In fact, per student capita, every student that leaves the public school system leaves more money and space behind for the other students. If their argument is that charter schools are racist (isn't everything these days), I show them the lines of black people (I live in Detroit) begging to get in and ask them why they think those parents want their students to go to charter schools and if it is really OK to tell them that they need to be stuck in the bad government schools that cost more and don't educate? It seems pretty racist if you don't think black people are smart enough to choose the school for their kids. Do they not want black people to get a good education? Easy win for any debate because it is so clear cut. The only people with a good reason to be opposed to charters are directly paid by the teachers union, and that includes politicians.
@honkhonk8009
@honkhonk8009 2 роки тому
The fact that Charter schools get more money from students, should be a case to actually support charter schools. Its clear that the US Government would rather spend $2 trillion on afghanistan, than our own countries education. Its up to ourselves to pay for our education, or atleast integrate that pay with our welfare state
@nutbastard
@nutbastard 2 роки тому
It's been my experience that leftists are deeply subconsciously racist and really do think black people are inferior and need assistance with everything. Which is how we ended up with affirmative action / quota hires. Meanwhile, Asians are losing opportunities because they're overrepresented in colleges. SAT scores required for admission are literally adjusted by race. If that isn't racist, I don't know what is. Don't get me wrong, there is no dearth of right-leaning racists either, but at least they have the decency to be up front about their ignorance.
@johnw4227
@johnw4227 2 роки тому
these kids have involved parents that actually care about education and their well being. That's huge when you're trying to do more with less.
@chrisaustin9949
@chrisaustin9949 2 роки тому
It's easy when you only have to teach the 5% of the kids that get the best teachers and the most focus. The only thing new here is calling that "Charter schools".
@MP-ef9yo
@MP-ef9yo 2 роки тому
Exactly and public schools are the ones tasked with educating kids without a strong support system at home and this guy wants to say that they are "failing" when they just have a job that is 10x harder
@johnw4227
@johnw4227 2 роки тому
@@chrisaustin9949 Charter schools do not get the best teachers necessarily. Public schools have a much higher budget, attracting the more experienced teachers to higher pay. public schools also have a more diverse curriculum. The opportunity for an excellent education exists in both. That being said, I believe that neither is a perfect fit for every child. The key to a good education is parental involvement.
@stevegarcia9098
@stevegarcia9098 2 роки тому
that young black girl at the beginning, her cultural environment is already teaching her bad english. her, "it don't matter", says a lot about her home environment.
@Zamkat013
@Zamkat013 2 роки тому
It's so bizarre to see those other teachers that are supposed to be children's advocates so vehemently opposing a school that gets great results with proven teaching methods.
@denisegaylord382
@denisegaylord382 2 роки тому
I think that the reason teachers fight this is because they would have to actually do work and have responsibility for meeting higher standards. Most teachers I see balking at charter schools are ones that see educating our children to be a cushy job that they will get paid regardless of outcomes. Their union will protect them, and their retirement. It's sad.
@Mr.Rogers91
@Mr.Rogers91 2 роки тому
Kids rise to your level of expectation. Yeah public schools expectations are zero.
@dawnmitchell11
@dawnmitchell11 2 роки тому
True story!! I did substitute teaching for 3 years. There are some exceptions, but mostly true! The classrooms that had the fewest problems were teachers that clearly had high standards and expectations, didn't put up with anything, but were also encouraging/cheerleaders for the students. The students would say the teacher was "strict and makes us work hard". When I asked if the teacher was mean, they would say no, actually nice rather.
@rosc2022
@rosc2022 2 роки тому
Let's hope it isn't that bad.
@Mr.Rogers91
@Mr.Rogers91 2 роки тому
@Ros C I would argue its less then zero since they teach SJW crap
@Mr.Rogers91
@Mr.Rogers91 2 роки тому
@Dawn Mitchell yeah I'm 30 years old and I remember no child left behind policy being implemented while I was in school. Kids that barely came yo school would just be pushed along
@HeadCoachKev
@HeadCoachKev 2 роки тому
our Universities are overrated
@big1boston
@big1boston 2 роки тому
Occult science is the science of sciences. The learning of everything...
@TheCarnivoreSoprano
@TheCarnivoreSoprano 2 роки тому
Very
@iloveschicken6527
@iloveschicken6527 2 роки тому
Fun fact.. Strippers, bartenders and drug dealers , celebrities and pro sports players make more money than some doctors ... without student debt! See the problem here? Of course they are overrated.
@HeadCoachKev
@HeadCoachKev 2 роки тому
@@iloveschicken6527 LMAO🤣
@iloveschicken6527
@iloveschicken6527 2 роки тому
@@HeadCoachKev Its most certainly fact my friend. 😎
@Marlene-db4ob
@Marlene-db4ob 2 роки тому
Public schools are more like a daycare than a school.
@mr5039
@mr5039 2 роки тому
If any of the kids in this video see this, keep doing what you’re doing!!! I know I don’t know you, and you don’t know me but still I sit here proud!!
@TheBlackJester
@TheBlackJester 2 роки тому
It is still a public school where state funding directed to the School, as opposed to a voucher that follows the child to schools.
@sterling3159
@sterling3159 2 роки тому
As a public high school educator, I approve this message.
@isaiahcallahan1701
@isaiahcallahan1701 2 роки тому
The freedom that I have teaching in a private school vs a public one is amazing. Best decision I ever made was switching over.
@dl2839
@dl2839 2 роки тому
Public Schools are fundamentally broken, I believe they should be completely Abolished.
@lucidzfl
@lucidzfl 2 роки тому
brought tears to my eyes. just got my kid into a kindergarten stem charter. IT. IS. AMAZING! These things are wonderful!
@iammrbeat
@iammrbeat 2 роки тому
You sound like a wonderful parent. Charter school parents generally care deeply for their children's education.
@allen_p
@allen_p 2 роки тому
I support school choice, but there have been some horribly corrupt and badly run charter schools in Texas. It's not all roses. Proper oversight is essential.
@Razor-gx2dq
@Razor-gx2dq 2 роки тому
Similar in GA, there was a charter school here so bad that people were begging to leave and go back to regular public schools.
@stevebabiak6997
@stevebabiak6997 2 роки тому
Face it, there are going to be bad apples all over. The key thing is that if one of these schools does not live up to at least the level of the public schools, they will lose attendance - and too much lost attendance will lead to closing the doors. Bad schools closing down is only possible in this kind of free market. And bad schools closing down is a good thing in the end.
@donnguyen3795
@donnguyen3795 2 роки тому
More choice will help parents get rid of bad school, regardless of public or charter
@honkhonk8009
@honkhonk8009 2 роки тому
True. Whats good though, is those bad charter schools can actually go out of business, and dont have to deal with unions
@p52893
@p52893 2 роки тому
It’s not about Teaching but all about Control. Leave them kids alone!
@dianasasina9328
@dianasasina9328 2 роки тому
Thank You , Eva !!! For ALL Your Hard Work , Your Intelligence And Your CARE FOR AND ABOUT OUR CHILDREN AND THEIR EDUCATION ..... THANK YOU !!!!!
@carlosarana1589
@carlosarana1589 2 роки тому
I went from being a year behind and failing my junior year in high school, to graduating 6 months early my senior year by switching to a charter school.
@WhyHandleYouTube
@WhyHandleYouTube 2 роки тому
There is no business like government business.
@NekoBoyOfficial
@NekoBoyOfficial 2 роки тому
Honesty like this is why I love Stossel. He even acknowledges bad charter schools.
@dustintacohands1107
@dustintacohands1107 2 роки тому
Love seeing these kids happy to learn I like the vibe from teacher kids and classsroom good job y’all best if luck to you
@Mike-123
@Mike-123 2 роки тому
I felt bad for that kid who cried because he didn't make it in on the lottery. Losing that lottery is a really big loss in his own individual life.
@MP-ef9yo
@MP-ef9yo 2 роки тому
Many charter school "lotteries" only accept students who already perform well in school. They don't accept students with learning diabilities who they feel are not worth their time or energy. That is the truly sad part
@DanJohnsonAffordableAviation
@DanJohnsonAffordableAviation 2 роки тому
The little kid crying that he didn’t get in was a heartbreaker. We must have more of these! I like all your shows, John, but this one really hit a mark. Well done!
@Joshpower57
@Joshpower57 2 роки тому
Gotta love loud screaming parents that are scaring their kids in order to destroy education... This is the kind of stuff I wish was made fun of, but it won't be
@iLikeCrabrangoons
@iLikeCrabrangoons 2 роки тому
I love what you're doing here. Keep up the good work, great video. Its really heart warming to see all the people that want to ensure a better life for their kids with a strong education.
@pots2306
@pots2306 2 роки тому
As a retired public secondary teacher and administrator, I have always favored charter schools. Some are lousy, but the successful ones should be funded and expanded. The only thing standing in the way is the teacher unions (NEA, AFT). The unions represent the interests of the teachers, not the students. And funding for public schools means nothing when it all goes to salaries and bad teachers cannot be fired.
@pots2306
@pots2306 2 роки тому
@Charles Larkin I was in Los Angeles. It’s all about politics...raising money for the Dems. I understand that unions in the middle of the country are much less powerful, if they exist at all.
@burntsider8457
@burntsider8457 2 роки тому
Gives me a little hope for the future of the country. The unrestrained anger displayed in anti-charter rallies dampens much of that hope.
@skippylippy547
@skippylippy547 2 роки тому
When people are given CHOICES, people succeed. 👍
@tropictom5996
@tropictom5996 2 роки тому
Become involved. Run for school board or, if you can afford it, consider becoming a teacher. I’m retired military, 53, and about to finish my degree. Imagine what an older person has to offer to students. Imagine what a wave of older people could do.
@rosc2022
@rosc2022 2 роки тому
You will put all of your leadership training and experience to use as a teacher.
@andrewfreeman88
@andrewfreeman88 2 роки тому
They don't want older people with experience. They want young naive minds, that they can control and brainwash to fit their narrative.
@tropictom5996
@tropictom5996 2 роки тому
@@andrewfreeman88 In my community we are short 300 teachers. They’ll hire me or I’ll sue them into oblivion.
@andrewfreeman88
@andrewfreeman88 2 роки тому
@@tropictom5996 Are you talking about a community in Thailand or the US. The thumbnail is throwing me off.
@tropictom5996
@tropictom5996 2 роки тому
@@andrewfreeman88 United States. My local school district is 300 teachers short.
@arnoldpaine6143
@arnoldpaine6143 2 роки тому
My grandson lives in New Jersey and attends a public school where they recently had midterms. The school had therapy dogs in the room for anyone who felt too stressed out by having to take a midterm test.
@stevebabiak6997
@stevebabiak6997 2 роки тому
How to ace your test: go pet a dog. Just keep those dogs away from the homework. Oh wait … I forgot, there’s no homework for the dogs to chew up.
@cowthedestroyer
@cowthedestroyer 2 роки тому
We got the same here I work for a school district and most of the schools have dogs for that same reason. Me personally I think they don't belong there but it is nice when I visit each school everyday to pay them on the head and move on.
@rosc2022
@rosc2022 2 роки тому
OMG, are you kidding me? Where is the line separating that the school is for the students and the school is there for the adults? I wonder that every time I hear about a "tragedy" and counselors come in from all over district to "provide support." Who is this for?
@tcbobb1613
@tcbobb1613 2 роки тому
For your Work do you have to take any tests?
@arnoldpaine6143
@arnoldpaine6143 2 роки тому
@@tcbobb1613 Where I work we on't have to take tests but we do have to take approximately 40 hours a year of diversity, equity and inclusion classes.
@stephpears4012
@stephpears4012 2 роки тому
Love your work John. One of the last remaining honest investigative journalist. Real journalist not like some of the talking heads of legacy Media that call themselves journalist.
@KimCookTV
@KimCookTV 2 роки тому
정말 안타까운이 가득합니다❤ 영상 고마워요 😄💕💛😊
@brycehedstrom374
@brycehedstrom374 2 роки тому
We can be confident that the child who said freedom is, "everyone has a different life so they can do what they want," will surely have had that dangerous notion stomped out of him by now.
@figoff2173
@figoff2173 2 роки тому
Good morning John
@123MineMan321
@123MineMan321 2 роки тому
morning
@shiny_duck
@shiny_duck 2 роки тому
Good morning, monday morning...
@madsatyr
@madsatyr 2 роки тому
Thank God for you John Stossel.
@kinglogic2091
@kinglogic2091 2 роки тому
Number one reason charter schools are better than public, someone cares! A parent, a gaurdian, a concerned citizen, someone is caring enough about the child's education to do something!
@jameservin1333
@jameservin1333 2 роки тому
Wow, this is incredible! This shows us that education can be improved. These school unions are garbage.
@Rajaat99
@Rajaat99 2 роки тому
If you can get your kid out of public schools, please do so. Other options: Homeschool, Charter school, or private school.
@jamiemitchell9733
@jamiemitchell9733 2 роки тому
The Youngs Turds "correspondent" lol
@Ggdivhjkjl
@Ggdivhjkjl Рік тому
Agreed that young people rise to the level expected of them but such a long day seperated from their families still seems tough.
@Marcus-kz7rw
@Marcus-kz7rw 2 роки тому
This video gives hope to the future.
@loviatar9
@loviatar9 2 роки тому
Give parents Choice!! Charter schools are the way forward. Even if it's groups of parents who get together in a community taking turns doing homeschooling. Public education has become indoctrination, not learning.
@quantumfrost9467
@quantumfrost9467 2 роки тому
Even in Australia if you compare private to public, private out performs
@sjhanksaz
@sjhanksaz 2 роки тому
Glad we live in AZ and we can choose charter schools here. Sent two of our kids to one ant it was great
@camrsr5463
@camrsr5463 2 роки тому
I would like to hear more interviews form older kids grades 5-8 and 9-12. I would also like to hear testimony from college grads about the charter system and how it impacted their life.
@OkieLou67
@OkieLou67 2 роки тому
My 3 kids went to a charter school, one in elementary, one in middle & one in high school. They all loved it. My kindergartener learned how to write in cursive before printing. I was truly amazed at how well that school was run(and the kids were so well behaved). Then we moved to another state with no nearby charter, so public was the only option- and it went downhill from there. They got an education, yes, but a better one? I doubt it. There was also a lot of drama with the public schools. Parents don’t want to help. People don’t seem to care about the kids as much. Teachers don’t have time to care- they have state test requirements to meet, so that’s all they can focus on. It’s sad.
@nickdavis8652
@nickdavis8652 2 роки тому
Waiting for superman, is an excellent documentary that follows families desperately hoping to win the school lottery to get their kids out of public schools and into charters.
@Miranda-zq7eh
@Miranda-zq7eh 2 роки тому
My kids went to a Charter school in New Mexico and their education was far superior to what they were getting in the public schools
@honkhonk8009
@honkhonk8009 2 роки тому
The funny part is that charter schools always have a higher drug use rate than their public counterparts. Its funny how that charter schools have these problems, but still vastly outperform their counterparts.
@heatherp4811
@heatherp4811 2 роки тому
Wow...keep growing Eva. You are an inspiration.
@palaceofwisdom9448
@palaceofwisdom9448 2 роки тому
If charters were so terrible, parents would be pulling their kids out and sending them back to the public system. I defy these union teachers to show us any sign of that happening.
@MP-ef9yo
@MP-ef9yo 2 роки тому
The issue is that charter schools only accept students who are already perfoming well in school. They leave behind any student who has a learning disability. Thus they take all the best students and exploit them for their test scores. Public schools are left with all the lower performing students and must work 10x harder to get them where they need to be. That is the problem with the system.
@palaceofwisdom9448
@palaceofwisdom9448 2 роки тому
@@MP-ef9yo If that were true, it would logically follow that students would not improve their performance in charter schools because they were already doing well. Again, show me the parents who say as much. For that matter, if a student is doing well in a public school, why would their parents even want to move them at all? Taking a child away from their friends to a new school is not done lightly. Plus you ignored that the students are chosen by lottery and thus the poaching you describe can't happen. There's also the fact that magnet schools have been around for generations and the union teachers haven't done any similar screaming about it because those schools are filled with union teachers too. You also seem to be implying that most or all poor performing students have a learning disability, and I don't see anyone presenting evidence of that. This is just a litany of excuses for a pool of teachers who have proved at every turn that they care nothing about their students; they literally want to phone it in.
@MP-ef9yo
@MP-ef9yo 2 роки тому
@@palaceofwisdom9448 Parents move their kids because they don't want them to be around all the lower-performing kids. They feel as if they would be bad influences, which can be somewhat understandable, but those kids have a right to an education too. I did not imply that at all. If that is what you took from it, that is your own personal bias. Those lotteries are not blind. They are heavily screened.
@victorsullivan7238
@victorsullivan7238 2 роки тому
I fully support charter schools but I don't think there's anything you could do to make 8 year old me participate in school from 7:45 to 4:30
@samuelhowie4543
@samuelhowie4543 2 роки тому
But if you're engaged then you don't realize how much time you spend there. There are a lot of kids that go to public schools then go to after school programs and that is just as long as this charter school hours.
@chef_moquin9535
@chef_moquin9535 2 роки тому
lol for real and then saying "china and India are not worried about length of school" is that really who we want to be comparing ourselves to?
@chef_moquin9535
@chef_moquin9535 2 роки тому
@@AnmolSinghJaggi65 lol I guess she isn't wrong then that India isn't worried when school ends since they end at 2 lol
@aaaaaeiou
@aaaaaeiou 2 роки тому
Public shcools are like HMO's. Centralized funding does not guarantee success for the student/patient. The funding only guarantees support of the facility.
@rosc2022
@rosc2022 2 роки тому
Kids like succeeding.....and that's where their self-esteem comes from, not empty affirmations and participation trophies.
@phantommaggotxxx
@phantommaggotxxx 2 роки тому
Wish I had that option around here... the school my daughter goes to is fucking pathetic and the only choice I have otherwise is religious school, which is equally evil... Why would anyone not want a charter school.. it's insane.
@johnpatrick1588
@johnpatrick1588 2 роки тому
School competition is good for all. Except for many mandated socialized government schools.
@benjaminramsey4695
@benjaminramsey4695 2 роки тому
TRUTH! Thank you for this.
@lawtonsegler1923
@lawtonsegler1923 2 роки тому
Please please please keep revealing the truth. School choice is the biggest issue of our time.
@johnpatrick1588
@johnpatrick1588 2 роки тому
A kid says "it don't matter" in a classroom in a story about learning and education.
@wholelottalight
@wholelottalight 2 роки тому
What of it? You may note that she is young. Very young. One might even say that she is just starting her education. She was speaking like her family speaks. That tells us of her background, not of the success of the school. She has much to learn. And much to unlearn.
@wholelottalight
@wholelottalight 2 роки тому
@YernthonTV What is your problem? Go get help. I know america also has the worst healthcare system in the world, but seriously... you need mental help.
@silent_stalker3687
@silent_stalker3687 2 роки тому
How to save kids from public school? I think the question is should be: why are parents fighting to demand their kids go to school with CRT, DEI, and so on. It’s like they’re fighting to send them to Epstein island if he had popcorn on a pier with a welcome sign. Just… don’t send them there? Go anywhere else that actually doesn’t do those things?
@usaintltrade
@usaintltrade 2 роки тому
PROTECT THE CHILDREN AT ALL COST
@ten-ms3bj
@ten-ms3bj 2 роки тому
“Government knows best” -Government
@Matt-dk3wl
@Matt-dk3wl 2 роки тому
"We lose 10 percent of families a year"... Yeah, that's your super power right there. Only about 10% of kids are really terrible in school. If I could magic wand away 10% of the kids in public school they'd be a lot better too. Also, opting into a lottery in the first place shows the parents who are signing up value education. How many crack head parents are trying to opt their kids into private schools? I'm not saying that private schools are better/worse or any of that, just pointing out that they are not saddled with crap kids and families like the public schools are.
@mariamakebbeh
@mariamakebbeh 2 роки тому
This right here!!! If public schools were able to get rid of non performing students and get more funding, I'm pretty sure their numbers would go up too. Let's be honest Charters schools and public schools can't be compared. They don't have the same resources, the same parents, or the same type of children. It's not that simple.
@VincentWeisTheThird
@VincentWeisTheThird 2 роки тому
They point out that the retention rate in the public schools is doubly worse that of the charters. By your logic, one must also logically conclude that the public schools are driving out more of their worst students, and their scores would also go up. Similarly, if it's just about selection, you'd expect the scores of students participating in interdistrict enrollment to have comparable scores to the charters, since presumably those parents are also going out of their way, and more invested, which you would expect to manifest in scores across demographics groups most likely to participate in interdistrict enrollment. And yet, enrollment characteristics of both charters and interdistrict skew more towards the poor and near poor, according the NCES. They're less likely to have a racial majority than public schools, and more likely to have black or Hispanic majorities. So it's hard for me to see where that selection is taking place. It would appear to be the opposite, that those who would otherwise be "disadvantaged" are disproportionately leveraging that opportunity to become "advantaged", regardless of starting point and initial investment.
@VincentWeisTheThird
@VincentWeisTheThird 2 роки тому
@@mariamakebbeh Thats true. The charters enroll more racial minorities, particularly black and Hispanic, and enroll less wealthy students in favor of near poor and poor students. The wealthy go to public schools, presumably leveraging additional resources as many AP students do, or private schools. So, you're certainly right that they can't be easily compared, since the charters have a more difficult task. And yet, when compared, they fare quite well. Funny that.
@Matt-dk3wl
@Matt-dk3wl 2 роки тому
@@VincentWeisTheThird If you get rid of 10% of the charter school kids they go into public school I assume? If you get rid of 20% of public school kids... What does that even mean? Where do they go? Back into a different public school? Is this the drop out rate? Point is, if you can get a bunch of kids sitting on the floor all happy to be there you're in a much better spot. Removing the kids who aren't like that is how you get a whole class full of superstars. My own kids classes are just like this too, a handful of disruptive kids ruin everything. It's plainly obvious. Some countries have whole other schools for trouble makers. A friend of mine grew up in a place where kids that didn't tow the line went to 'Brown School'... A special school for all the kids who wouldn't sit and behave. Sounds like a great idea to me honestly... (Edit a short time later) In fact, maybe this is the real solution,, Instead of charter schools we just prune the bad kids out of the public school system entirely. Call them something nice for the woke mob and it'll probably fly. "Centers of Excellence" Works in the corporate world...
Students Finally Winning The School Choice Fight
7:27
John Stossel
Переглядів 254 тис.
Classic Stossel: Stupid in America
7:57
John Stossel
Переглядів 805 тис.
Help Herobrine Escape From Spike
00:28
Garri Creative
Переглядів 47 млн
ISSEI funny story 😂😂😂Strange World 🌏 Green
00:27
ISSEI / いっせい
Переглядів 63 млн
ВИРУСНЫЕ ВИДЕО / Виноградинка 😅
00:34
Светлый Voiceover
Переглядів 5 млн
Let Charter Schools Teach
6:28
John Stossel
Переглядів 160 тис.
How Rent Control Hurts Renters
6:45
John Stossel
Переглядів 228 тис.
Government Run Schools Crush Innovation
6:03
John Stossel
Переглядів 126 тис.
My Phone: A Privacy Expert Doesn’t Like What She Finds
10:33
John Stossel
Переглядів 837 тис.
Solving Student Debt
5:47
John Stossel
Переглядів 475 тис.
STOSSEL: Why School Choice is the Right Choice
5:19
John Stossel
Переглядів 57 тис.
Woke Colleges vs Testing
5:19
John Stossel
Переглядів 433 тис.
The Full Charles Murray: Race and IQ, Government Welfare, and Crime
1:01:12
Even Greenpeace Says “Most Plastic Simply Cannot Be Recycled.”
7:13
John Stossel
Переглядів 907 тис.
Stossel: Let Charter Schools Teach
6:17
ReasonTV
Переглядів 69 тис.
Help Herobrine Escape From Spike
00:28
Garri Creative
Переглядів 47 млн