sometimes its okay to come here and cry. its comforting. i love you so much shinee.

Its the fact the fans were completely silent and they didn't scream or cheer like usual concerts they claped which is so respectful ❤

It's 2023 Jjong. We still remember you, love you, miss you

Jonghyunaaa. Its already 2024 now. Well, we still love and missing you. After all this years, is it okay if I am still crying? I hope u dont angry if i do that. I am okay now, I already fine. Jonghyunaa, like 2 years ago, I found a new boy. He is from astro, his name is moonbin. He is really charming and talented! But last year, he pass. He is sick and I couldnt save him :( Jonghyunaa, our bling bling jonghyunaa, u already became the brightest star up there right? Then can u company my moon too? I hope you two can accompany each other there. Oh! I almost forgot Today, shinee held a shinee world concert at tokyo! But still without our dubu leader onew, u still watching him right? Shinee did great tonight! Jonghyunaaa, thank you 🩵

This is the first and only time you see SHINee singing this song, and it will forever bring me to tears, no matter how many times I watch it.

As soon as I hear Jonghyun singing the tears start . This is a really emotional song doesn't matter how many times I hear it I get emotional. This is the only song that can make me cry every time. I hope you find peace in the next life Jonghyun.🌹

The amount of internal strength that is required for the four of them to perform this, I can't begin to express. Not every Jonghyun ritual they do is for other people, but this, this one, they did it for Shawols. And for that I will love them for 1000 years.

It's March 2024, it's 4:39 A.M and here I am listening to the only music that can calm me down. Spring is almost here and everything will pass... I hope so...

I'm just a baby shawol. I never knew SHINee when Jonghyun was alive. I wish I had, but unfortunately I didn't discover kpop until very recently. The boys were so strong to keep pushing on. It must've been so rough and I commend them for giving this beautiful performance so close to Jonghyun's death. It's hard not to get emotional during this song. Every time Minho looks at the empty mic. Key singing with tears welling up in his eyes. When Onew breaks down putting the rose on his mic stand. I totally lose it at 4:11. It's such a beautiful and touching performance...one that I'm sure Jonghyun would be proud of. He may be gone from this earthly plane, but his spirit lives on in his brothers. RIP Jonghyun. You did well.

Moonbin’s passing brought me back here😭

What really got me was they didn't just put up any mic in the center. At 1:17, you can see the mic has a red band at the base. Each member has their own distinct color on their mics. Red IS Jonghyun's mic. They still prepped his mic for him, even though they already knew he wouldn't be there ......💔

English Translation: If I hadn't met you yet What would I have been doing now ? Not even knowing the meaning of love Where would I have strayed ? No words to describe My surging emotions But you, we understand each other Always here, always will I offer you all my love And endless gratitude I swear on the stars that fall from your eyes I'll be with you forever I'll be with you I'll be with you Chasing my endless dream Never stop to take a step forward Never stopping, I took the first step Believing only in your smile Before I knew it, I found myself in this place A view unattainable on my own (Watch it pass me by) 手にできないものを (won′t let go) Together with you (Together with you) I can find it (I promise you) Let's go on searching for it forever I offer you all my love And endless gratitude I swear on the stars that fall from your eyes I'll be with you forever I'll be with you I'll be with you I'll never forget this day with you No matter what the future holds It's this love that makes me Even stronger I offer you all my love And endless gratitude I swear on the stars that fall from your eyes I'll be with you forever I'll be with you I'll be with you Forever

2024 To everyone who comes back here hoping not to shed a tear - it’s okay to cry. You are not the only one

It's 2024 I'm still here, I will always miss you Jjong. You did things for me that even you didn't know, you saved me I'm sorry for the way the world hurt you.

Onew: Singing through clenched fists Minho: Looking for his Jonghyun Taemin: Singing for his hyung Key: Removed all his jewelry except for the ring Jonghyun gave him for his birthday

Who misses jonghyun in the year 2024😭😭😭❤️

Today, we lost one of our angel again, Moonbin :( Jonghyun & Bin, may ur soul rest in peace 🤍

Being a Shawol & Aroha has been heartbreaking 💔 RIP Jonghyun & Moonbin,always in my heart 💎💜

This was my first time seeing this, and OMG. When Jonghyun's voice came on and Minho stared at the mic trying to keep the tears in. Than Jinki sang his part and started crying. At the end Jinki broke down. Key tried to hold it in, but could not. That all was "Heart-tugging" right there from beginning to end 😭😭😭😭😭 You all were so brave for singing this song for him, and for holding in your tears until you got off the stage.

Im not a fan but It's my 2nd time watching this And in crying harder than the last time I just can't stop

The sad and longing eyes of minho when looking at the rose is so heartbreaking until now.. no metter how many years may passed when I watch this I cant help but crying inside..

He’s still singing with them from somewhere far away and will always be with them😭 we love u JONGHYUN ❤😢

We forever love and miss you Jonghyun. SHINee is 5❤

5 years later, still one of the best groups in history. SHINee has been and forever will be 5. Jonghyun is proud, I know he is! 💜💜

i don’t know shinee well, i came into the kpop scene very late back in 2021 and after learning what happened to jonghyun i came here. this was a beautiful performance and such a beautiful tribute. i cried. i’m so sorry to shinee members and everyone who was affected by his loss, i hope you know you are not alone and you will never be. this isn’t the end i promise. thank you shinee for performing depsite how painful this must have been

After years I‘m still not over it. I remember the day the news of his passing reached me and it was almost ridiculous how devastated and sad I was. I cried a lot that day as if I lost someone dear to me, like a family member or anything alike and I felt stupid for it. Years later I still regularly watch this video or other sad and happy videos of my boys, of Jonghyun and cry. I‘m so proud of my boys, of everything they achieved and for how well they managed to handle this tragedy, together as a unit and individual. The ways they show their emotions, their sadness but also manage to find positive words, healing words, dedicate a song to him. I‘m just so proud of their journey. Even tough I know that people outside of our „SHINee and Kpop bubble“ will probably never understand why so many of us still post underneath Jonghyun‘s instagram pictures or why we still cry about it but I just love these boys with all my heart and I know I‘m not the only one. They were a part of me during my teen years where I was lonely, without friends and insecure, they were always by my side back then and gave me so much strength, made my days better. I‘m almost 26 now and even if life got in between and I‘m not so active in following every song that comes from my favorite kpop groups or don‘t collect their albums anymore I still love you, SHINee, to the core. I always will ❤ I love you and I miss you Jonghyun, you did so very very well and even if you were never able to see it you helped so so many people with your voice and personality, with your songs and your presence. Your being made the world a better place. Now rest well my dear little, beautiful Angel 🕊️❤

Dear Jonghyun, another one of our angel is gone today… please take care of him for us from where you are… Rest in Peace Moonbin 🤍🕊️

This makes me tears up every single time

Here because Moonbin just died and I remembered of Jonghyun 😢

I don’t know how they got through this concert and especially this song.!! 🌹💎💎💎💎💎

I was studying and music was on shuffle. The song came on unexpectedly and I couldn’t help but burst into tears. I miss Jonghyun so much and came to watch their performance because I needed some comfort to cry whole heartedly. It’s 2023 and I still can’t move on. I’m really happy to see the other members smiling these days.

sometimes i came here to listen this song and hoping to not to cry, but i fail everytime. now that moonbin is gone too, i cry even more. I love both of you guys with all my heart, you did so well and you gave hope to a lot of fans. i'm so sorry i love you.

It feels so good to cry hearing this song with heavy heart of missing you so much jonghyun.... I just came here to cry because i miss you so much today.... I want to see you .....😭😭😭😭😭

is 2024 and i miss you so much..

Today is the 6th year sonce he left us.... I missing him so much... Rest in peace my lil angel

После смерти Мунбина, почему я вспоминаю и тебя Джонхёна 😭😭😭😭

I immediately started crying when I saw the empty mic and when Jonghyun’s voice started playing in the background Now I know what to think of when I need to start acting again

Always and forever I will come back to this and silently pay my respects to Jjong. We all love you and miss you terribly!

2024, Sending love to Shinee and Jjong. We love you.

この日、19歳の私が初めて1人で行ったコンサートでした。応募当初はドキドキしながら1人でも楽しんでやる!と胸を高鳴らせていましたが、悲しみと寂しさと、、、言葉にできない感情を持ちつつ当日東京から大阪に向かいコンサートに参加しました。 コンサートが始まってから感じられるようで感じられない一つの席を恋しがって、涙が止まりませんでした。 1人で慣れない場所に向かい、言葉にできない感情でいる私はうまく息ができなくて座り込んでしまった時、隣のお姉さんがお水しっかり飲んで飴ちゃん食べなさいって飴をくれたこと鮮明に覚えてます。本当にありがとうございます。 感謝の気持ちを伝えつつ最後まで見ることができましたが、表せられない苦しさでうまくその方に伝えられたでしょうか。今になって動画をきちんと見られるようになりましたが、この場所で支えてくれたことに感謝を伝えたいです。SHINee Worldになれて、SHINeeからもたっくさんの愛を教えてもらってファンのみんなにも支えられて幸せでした。本当にありがとうございます。 いつまででもSHINeeという存在が輝いているものになりますように、メンバーみんなが幸せでありますように。。。大好きです。愛してます。

Мое сердце каждый раз разбивается, как в первый, когда вижу это💔

I spent my whole day listening to "Cocktail" by Jonghyun and suddenly I decided to come here. I haven't watched this for a long time, I don't even want to admit that it's been 7 years already. I'm unable to control the tears running down my face, just like 7 years ago, when I got the news. We miss you!

dear jonghyun, i regret that i haven’t stan shinee before you left us. dream calm

a thousand i watching this video a thousand i cry 😭 miss you jonghyun

天国にいるジョンヒョンへ 貴方の事は決してメンバー全員、そしてファンのみんなが貴方を心から愛していて１日たりとも忘れていないからね！ ずっと一緒だよ？

I'm not even a Shawol but I've seen SHINee growing throughout the years. This video popped up all of sudden today and as soon as I saw 5 mics, I know this was going to be a painful performance. When Jonghyun's part was being played, tears started falling. It feels as if he was singing with them from the heavens. It's 2024 and you are still remembered. You did well.

I came here again. I miss him so much. Really i miss. I want to attend his lives and I want write a comment. And I want he see to my comment. And replay. I want hug and I want not letting go of it. I love u Jonghyun 🤍💎🤧 I am not Shawol but i support them. And I love them. I am Bilingers. I proud love you🤍🤍🤍

It’s been almost 6 years and to this day it still feels so surreal. It almost feels like he’s just on hiatus or in the military. It’s hard to comprehend or imagine a future without him, especially in troubling times when you know he would be a voice of advocacy and wisdom, and a source of comfort and love. He may no longer be physically with us, but his spirit and impact is still here and will carry on for years to come ❤

Прошло 6 лет.... легче не стало. Время не вылечило. Я думала что смогу посмотреть и постараться не заплакать, но на первой же партии Джонхена сдалась... Мы всё еще помним тебя, наш прекрасный мальчик, наша звёздочка 💔 смотри как эти ребята стараются, даже втроём. Вы начали этот путь вместе, и с гордостью продолжаете. И неважно сколько ребят я вижу, четверых или троих, их всегда пять💔

This is the first time that I have heard of this song and it’s so beautiful but wow I got chills and I started to tear up, how did they even get through the concert when they felt pain and everything after losing a friend/brother 😢😢

как же болит душа, как же сильно колит сердце. я скучаю.. только здесь можно поплакать и придти за утешением. Сейчас уже 2024 год, надеюсь он там счастлив..

Come here 13 december 2023. Just remembering joghyun

Miss you jonghyun

jonghyun always had such an unique voice..miss you.

we miss you so much jonghyun. not a day goes by that i dont miss you. tonights been specifically hard, i saw a post of you and couldn't stop thinking about you to the point where ive just been lying in bed crying nonstop. i miss you so much jonghyun you will forever be a part of my life and i'll love you forever. Even though we can't communicate using the same language, we use music instead.

i'm a new SHINee stan and i knew jonghyun touched so many lives and my heart breaks everyday for his members and fans! this video gets me everytime it's so sad that i knew of SHINee after jonghyun is gone and jonghyun is my bias but once i realized my bias was gone i cried so hard i miss him so much everyday! i regret not listening to them sooner and being apart of the memories with him and the other members and fans!💔😭

i miss you jjongie, i hope you found peace

永遠にSHINeeは５人です。SHINeeが大好きです。

I believe jonghyun was right up there with them cheering them on ❤️‍🩹

When I thought I have fully recovered from lossing Jong, then gone, Moonbin, it brought me back here. Wishing they would meet somewhere.

I got a bracelet with their birthstones - Onew, Taemin, Jonghyun, Minho and Key to match this order onstage . Message received, Jonghyun . I still have the moonstone you left for me to find .

I’m back here today… if you know why, you know why

Farewell my love❤️

It's 2023, and I still can't move from Jonghyun 😢😢 too much memories and art work in music He left behind 🥀

Its crazy how my heart is beating fast just imagining what they thinking about.. all the emotions and the song❤. Rest easy buddy. Just got to know them recently. They are beautiful men with great talent cant wait to learn more about them.

To everyone who comeback here for reassurance. Hope Jonghyun’s voice singing with 5HINee somehow gives you comfort.

This is probably peak of not only for the 5 of them but the entire industry because this really proves that even if shinee lost their member/brother, he still on stage with them forever. ❤❤❤❤❤

i was thinking about jonghyun today, i came here to cry and reflect. we love you so much shinee.

I swear i don't even know how they managed to sing, i would be sobbing so much that my voice wouldn't come out just like now

сейчас 2023 год,но мы до сих пор помним наше солнце💔

Til today when SHINEE is mentioned, shown, or anything. They are still called "5 Member Group SHINEE" an they ever will. You left the earth but not your group and your Fans hearts

I never heard of this group before but I still cried

Уже прошло больше 6 лет, как твоя душа осталась с нами. Тебя очень не хватает нам. Наш очень красивый мальчик. Ты всегда с нами. На первой партии я уже очень сильно заплакала💔

Today is Shinee 15th anniversary ❤

Just a tragedy. He should still be there with them and enjoying his life. Just too sad. RIP. I hope you are free of pain.

Very very emotional also a very beautiful way to honor Jonghyun🌹

2024 SHINee 5 forever ❤

Happy birthday jjong there’s always a space for you in our hearts no matter where you are.

Место где можно поплакать...

hi jjong, it’s 2023. we miss you, we remember you. we love you. 🩵

The team just looking at the empty mic stand breaks my heart. Your brothers and your fans will never forget you. I hope while you are up in the stars that you'll no longer be in pain. We miss you Jonghyun, fly high... 🕊

Today marks the 6th anniversary of our dear Jjong’s departure, I hope he’s happy and watching over our boys 🖤

I come back to this and remember him once in awhile, but end up crying every time…such a moving tribute to an angel😞🩵 Still with you in 2024, Jonghyun🩵🩵

Раз в два месяца возвращаюсь сюда, чтобы послушать песню во исполнении Джонхена и ребят. И каждый раз я плачу, начиная с того момента как начинается партия Тэмина. Мне тяжело осознавать то, что этот лучик света вернулся к небу. Покойся с миром, Джонхён 🕊️

it's been more than 12 years since I chose Jonghyun as my bias and one of my wishes were to see him and get his signature, but he left fist, and my wish will never come true.. I really miss him a lot 🤍🤍

this song is so emotional it makes me cry every time It's good to come here and cry when I miss Jonghyun

I finally got the courage to watch this. ❤

Thanks to the author and I want to finish that every day , even after so many years , when I listen to this song , I always remember Jonghyun

Hoy falleció moonbin de astro, y quise venir a recordar también a otra estrella del cielo que hoy le hará compañía 🕊️

Its 2024 I am still listening to this song.

6 years since we lost our beautiful angel Jonghyun :( We miss you so much, you did so well 🩵 Rest in peace

the microphone part make me cry

I literally cried. One of their greatest members is gine but never forgotten

coming here again after 2yrs. i lost another angel, another star has begun shining in the sky. jonghyun i miss you. please look over us along with binnie. 😞🖤

I don't know the band or the members, but I cried so hard watching this. You don't need to know them to see and hear what they are feeling. 😔

i cry every time i listen to this. but this time it was different.. i mourn Jonghyun but I also cry because I know he'd be so proud of how far Shinee's come. Love you

Siempre vuelvo acá para recordarte, mi estrella brillante. Espero que andes bien, y sigas brillando. Te amoo por siempre

🌹🌹 спи сладко, солнце

And when they place the roses - tears come!!

Я никогда не увлекалась творчеством этой группы, не знаю особо ничего про Джонхёна, кроме того что он умер, не знаю о чём эта песня, но когда я её слушаю, на глаза слёзы наворачиваются....