Who is the greatest NFL quarterback?

Finally a Rodgers and Brady debate 😱

Does anyone else remember when shannon said Brady is the greatest player in the NFL's 99 year history after sb51

Tom Brady has been great with average to above average receivers. The only time Brady has had an elite receiver to throw to, he almost went undefeated and if not for a crazy catch by David Tyree, he would've had a perfect season. I think that is what makes him the greatest. For the most part, he never played with a Jerry Rice, Marvin Harrison, or even a Greg Jennings.

why would anyone dream about football in the bed next to giselle???

This whole Brady and Rodgers debate is stupid. Rodgers, as a talent, is one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history. His ability to make accurate passes outside of the pocket and evade pass rushers is what makes him special. However, athleticism is only one component of quarterback play. While Rodgers has the athletic intangibles which Brady doesn’t possess, Brady has mastered the art of execution in critical moments of the game, whether it be in the regular season or playoffs. Four out of the five Super Bowls the Patriots have won, Brady led the game-winning drive and capped off his 5th ring with the greatest comeback in Super Bowl history. Furthermore, his knowledge of defenses, command of the offense and his study habits are better than Rodgers and are arguably second to only Peyton Manning. Brady possesses a higher regular season winning percentage than Rodgers, has more game-winning drives than Rodgers, has a better playoff record than Rodgers and is statistically better than Rodgers in the playoffs for the past 5 seasons. Since Aaron Rodgers won his only Super Bowl in 2010, Brady has appeared in four Super Bowls and he’s won two of them. If the argument is Rodgers is the greatest quarterback of all time based solely on athletic ability, it’s a short-sighted argument because it ignores other components of what makes a quarterback great. Execution is a better standard to judge quarterback play by and Brady is on another level in regards to that. Brady is clearly the greatest quarterback of all of time. It’s not even close.

Skip always had to find a way to bring Lebron into things.

Notice how this wasn't even hardly an argument when Manning was in the league? It was all about Brady vs Manning. Now that Manning is gone sports media had to come up with something to debate so now it's brady vs rodgers. Guess who the only constant has been for the last 17 years? The goat TB12

Shannon "yea because you're the teacher's pet"

I hate tom Brady...but he is the goat. I will miss him when he is gone. The pats dynasty is unmatched in history. And im an eagles fan. Rodgers does make unbelievable plays..but the consistency and chips are just not there.

Russ Wilson is also a very underrated QB who is dangerous anywhere on the field *except the 1 yard line of course*

Aaron Rodgers is a BETTER passer, Tom Brady is the KEY ingredient to the NE Patriots attacking system. It is a difficult discussion as if you take out both QB's and switch teams, they would both struggle. I think that Brady and the Pats play a structured way that suits him perfectly, whilst A-Rod plays in a more free-flowing game (compared to the Pats). They wouldn't have the same number of rings at different teams. But hey, that's just what I think.

Shannon "Michael Jordan never had a ball stolen from him that's what you told me" 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Rodgers already has said multiple times Brady is the goat

He throws the ball better, but that doesn't make him a better QB. There's more to being a QB then throwing. Leadership. Clutch factor. Football IQ. Brady is better at that than Rodgers.

Shannon "pull that stat up pull that one" 😂😂😂😂😂

Tom Brady is the Greatest Quarterback I have ever seen. (Coming from a Cowboys Fan) and if I I had to pick one QB to have for my franchise I’m going TB

Shannon prefers style over substance. You can have your incredible throws, I'll take my 5 rings!

Brady is the greatest QB based on his accomplish. Having skills is nice and all but at the end of the season only one team wins and that’s all that matters

For Shannon to point out last year's super bowl as an argument against Tom's greatness is really absurd. Tom played an amazing game, as he always does in the Super Bowl.

Its a team effort and the qb that has the best leadership and does less blaming wins in my book #HatersGonnaHate

NOT THE CUT THUMB 😂😂😂

>Tom brady throws too much pick Let me make my best Colin impersonation "Oh no Brady threw a pick! He threw a picky!" Reality, the great ones throw picks. You need to risk getting rejected to get an attractive girlfriend. Folks, I don't care if my quarterback takes chances. I WANT a quarterback who is willing to make the big throw. 7 out of 10 of the QBs who lead in all-time interceptions are HALL of FAMERS Steve Jobs took risk. Elon Musk takes risk. I want my star quarterback taking risks. COMING UP, the one thing everyone is getting wrong about the Cowboys

After the comeback in the SB, Shannon said "Brady was the greatest NFL player of all time" - since then he's spent his whole time trying to convince everyone that he ISN'T the greatest 🤔

I can't wait for this Sunday's game.

Rings matter wins matter ... Brady is better alot of things go into that but that doesn't mean Rodgers can't catch up Rodgers is still great

Jenny is the greater moderator than Molly 😍😍

Shannon "I'm glad you finally admitted that" 😂😂

This debate is gold!!

The laziness of analysts arguments astonishes me. Shannon's argument is talent, so Mike Vick is the best qb ever? Skip's is rings which means Terry Bradshaw's just as good as Brady? They need substance to their arguments rather then just this is my opinion so it's right.

So just cause arod is physically better that makes him a better qb come on now 🤦🏾‍♂️ Brady is the goat

Rodgers is a better leader than he gets credit for. Look at how he treated Crosby after he missed all those field goals against the Lions. Crosby hasn't missed since that game. That's pretty damn good leadership imo.

Some say when you are ready to win you have to be ready to make sacrifices like giving up money to build around you.

Brady’s hard work beats Rodger’s talent end of discussion

Rodgers could argue the those kinds of what ifs but Brady has 5 rings and Rodgers has 1.

I think my teachers didn't feel comfortable, but I didn't notice anything except the competitions.

I know we'll never stop talking about this until someone retires, but I mean can't we just talk about the game and admit both are two of the best to play

Brady has FIVE rings, this discussion is over.

”Skiiip!.... Why you talking???” 🤣

I love how Shannon talks about personal stats and talks down on Brady for having a better team but when skip points out that he had the single best super bowl game and still lost, the argument is thrown away

"Let's look at dak Prescott QBR now" - shannon the goat

As a Cowboys fan, brady is the GOAT. Stop comparing rodgers to that man

why the volume of all the FS1 shows got so low recently??

Hard work beats talent when ralent fails to work hard.. 🙌🏽🙌🏽

Brady is the GOAT

Two teams that beat Rodgers in the NFC title game, they loss to Brady in the super bowls..Seahawks and Falcons...Brady is the GOAT

At least Brady went to 4 AFC Championship games and two Super Bowls in between his last SB Championship and the Seahawks win, he also had an Undefeated Season in there and a year where his knee was torn off his leg in 08'

Skips face in the thumbnail is priceless lol😁

2:25-2:28 Shannon using his white people voice

DAN MARINO WAS A BETTER PASSER THAN AARON RODGERS

This show is THE BEST thing to watch on a daily basis!

Actually before making the comparison between Rodgers and Brady... lets ask another question between QB who are more equally accomplished.... Is Aaron Rodgers better than Peyton Manning????

Tom Brady is the GOAT

Rodgers has the talent advantage. Never forget the team stat that is super bowl rings.

I love how Skip has sneaky comments and Shannon always reacts don't do that Skuuuuuip, don't do that! Batman and Robin here. I love this show.

My favorite part is knowing how much Aaron Rodgers and Tom Brady like eachother and these shows wish otherwise

tom brady is the best of all time, arod is the best in the league simple

Hahahahahaha. Brady vs Rodgers? This must be a Saturday Night Live skit. Rodgers isn’t even better than Drew Brees, no way he measures up to Brady....

Shannon "stop it Skip Bayless" 😂😂😂😂😂😂

Wow a Rodgers v. Brady debate. I wonder if they ever talked about it before on the show

Skip is always bringing up LeBron

Shannon "skip its not ur turn to talk why are u talking didn't ur teacher tell u bout interrupting when others are talking"

Shannon is awesome! love him torpedoing all of Skip's arguments.

Just a small stat td's to int Since 09...brady 322-85..rodgers 310-65..brady 5 SB 3 rings...rodgers 1-1...what am i missing..one was in his prime and one was leaving his prime and is now 41...brady 44,069...rodgers 38,577

Rodgers doesn’t comeback from 28-3

So because you can throw a pretty ball you're the GOAT?

Yet Tom Brady said that he's been blessed by the system he's in and all the coaching staff around him and all the players around him. He said that he wished every QB could play in his circumstances and he also said Aaron Rodgers would put up 7000 yards in that system.

Funny how almost no one mentions Charles Haley who got his 5 rings in half of the time that it took for Brady to get his 5. But no one hardly mentions him and he was a beast at linebacker/defensive end.....

Aaron Rodgers is in the toughest conference and tom Brady is in the weakest conference but give Aaron mike tomlin

5 > 1 🏆

Brady: 6 Super Bowls (4 Super Bowl MVP's) / Rodgers: 1 (1) Brady: 9 Super Bowl App. / Rodgers: 1 Brady: 5 Time All Pro / Rodgers: 3 Time All Pro Brady: 3 League MVP's / Rodgers: 2 League MVP's Brady: 4-Time NFL TD Leader / Rodgers: 1-Time NFL TD Leader Brady: 2-Time Passer Rating Leader / Rodgers: 1-Time Passer Rating Leader Brady: 14 Pro Bowls / Rodgers: 7 Pro Bowls Brady: 64% Career Comp. Percentage / Rodgers: 64.8% Career Completion Percentage Brady: 81,693 Career Passing Yards / Rodgers: 47,402 Career Passing Yards Brady: 590 Career Passing TDs / Rodgers: 374 Career Passing TD's Brady: 237 Career Wins / Rodgers: 109 Career Wins Obviously Brady has played several more seasons than Rodgers. However, Rodgers turns 36 in December, and Brady is still putting up comparable numbers to Rodgers. The likelihood that Rodgers will ever catch Brady in ANY of these categories (besides league MVPs) is virtually impossible. People bring up Rodgers passer rating. He's only led the league in Passer Rating once. Yes he throws less INTs. He also takes less chances, and wins less games. If you're not winning football games, TD-INT ratio doesn't really mean much. There is no comparison between these two players. Rodgers is likely the best thrower of the football in NFL History, but if the stats above prove anything, there's more to playing QB than not throwing INTs.

You guys can take this however you want to, but one thing I keep thinking is that I do not know the name of Joe Montana’s field-goal kicker.

I thought skip was a Dallas Cowboys fan but rides Brady on the low

Rodgers only has a stronger arm than brady. Brady is a better all around qb than him

Shannon always yelling at skip for talking but he always interrupts skip every five seconds when it's his turn 😂

Well Said Skip.👏👏

I do not know why this is even a discussion... like I literally don't. The debate was always "Brady or Montana" for Greatest QB of All Time. Brady then wins the Atlanta Superbowl, and now all of a sudden it's "Brady v.s. Rodgers???". So we're gonna act like Rodgers passes MONTANA out of no where. Rodgers is a phenomenal QB, but as of right now he is not even top 5 all time. When you are saying the word "GOAT" - you take into account the championships, the titles, the accolades, the QB play, the football IQ, etc... Rodgers is no where near Brady in terms of overall achievements. If we are talking about who is playing better at QB right now, then it is Rodgers without a doubt. Tom Brady is the greatest QB of all time, and it surely does not look like anyone will pass him. 1. Tom Brady 2. Joe Montana 3. Peyton Manning 4. John Elway 5. Drew Brees

Brady 35 Rodgers 28 But Tom brady is more accomplished!

Well we know pretty soon, watching the game now, both quarterbacks know whats at stake

Every time I start getting frustrated listening to Shannon I just remember the clip of him saying after the pats falcons Super Bowl “Tom Brady is the greatest player in the history of the nfl” why do they never bring this up!?!!?!?!???

For everyone here that says that Rodgers is better than Brady. You BETTER say Elway and Marino are better than Montana or you're a hypocrite. Because Elway and Marino were both more talented with better arm strength and threw "prettier" balls. But Montana won, just like Brady.

Rodgers is no where near Brady

Rodgers is something like 1-41 in games against .500 or better teams when losing by more than 1 heading into the fourth quarter...it really isnt close lol

Shannon "that's an act" 😂

I can't wait for this game to start on sunday so I can see how brady going to destroy rodgers in that game

Peyton Manning is a greater quarter back then Aaron Rogers... Stats, Arm, Rings, MVP’s. Revolution change to the game. But this discussion is stupid Rogers not even close to Brady...

8x sb appearances 5x sb champ 3x regular season mvp , 3x all pro , 13x pro bowl , most wins by a qb , best season by a 39 year old , best season by a 40 year old , top 5 in all time passing yards , top 3 in career tds , best comeback in sb history, most passing yards in a sb ( 505+) he broke in sb51 and broke it again in sb52, 35 4th quarter comebacks, has passed to 71 different recievers , has the most games started by a qb , most points scored in 1 quarter and many more

This is old school skip bayless. I don't like TV skip sometimes but his actual journalism was top notch.

Let's go brady you got this dude

Shannon "Aaron can make passes that even tom Brady laying next to his beautiful wife Gisele can't even make"

I love how stats only matter on games Aaron Rodgers does bad. Skip doesn’t even mention Rodgers having the all time best passer rating. He doesn’t mention having the best TD/INT ratio in NFL history that no one is even close to matching. He only mentions stats on that 1 game where he barely beat a backup in the super bowl run even though his guy just lost to a backup in the Super Bowl. This is another piece of evidence how much of a joke it is that Skip Bayless still has a job.

I’m a packer fan and its not even close. Brady is the best. Theirs more to playing quarterback then ability and skill. Leadership and being a great teammate are a huge as well and Rodgers doesn’t even come close to Brady in this aspect.

Just absolutely NO comparison here... TB12: G.O.A.T. PERIOD

Shannon literally said Brady was the greatest football player ever after the Atlanta superbowl.. has Brady digressed since then? No, he went to another super bowl and threw over 500 yards breaking his OWN record.. lmao. How is this a debate?? Obviously Rodgers is more talented, but you play to win... and yeah, Rodgers isn't in the same atmosphere in that category.

4:48 skip couldn't believe shannon lmao

Shannon "Skip don't do dat"

If Aaron so good y he cant win nothing

Brady has a better resume than Rodgers

Shannon "now he's human" 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

If Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers where to trade their best assets: Brady's being Belichick and Aaron Rodgers being his receiving Corps including Jimmy Graham, Tom Brady would still have more wings and probably be undefeated right now