J most definitely had backing vocals on her part

Not quite but for the most part….I really like ISA here…she put some real emotion here…and she kinda made it her own

Sieun is a force to be reckon with in this industry…good lord

itsandree the first part of the song yes, but the 2nd half of the song she didn’t have back track at 2:34-2:37

pls tell me this isnt pre recorded, its their pure live vocals right? they sound so incredible 😭😭

Yes!!! They gotta shove on our faces. Not complaing tho!

I've been their fan since debut aka this song (So Bad) but when I saw "so bad no autotune," I thought the title was saying they sound so bad with no autotune 😂😂😂 I need sleep

I thought it meant they will be sounding nasty without auto-tune 💀

LMAOO LOVE IT

I know!! And I was like "no autotune, pfff, we'll see about that" because everytime there's live or no autotune in the title it's just a clickbait, but man I was so surprised to find out this was actually live and without autotune :dd. We need more groups like them!!

AND THE WINK

Incredible high notes…unbelievable…effortless

She really is talented. Focusing on dancing skills and vocal technique to put together what we see here requires a LOT of training

@@rafael257 hi I love your Kakashi pfp

@@thek-nerd3143 💖thanks💖

I know right. I enjoy live singing more tbh

Wish twice was able to do this

You’re saying that but just think about the idols. They have to dance to hard choreographies and if their voice crack once everyone is saying they are too bad. Idols can’t always sing live You know I think STAYC have lyp synced a lot of time in So Bad’s era For the next time, just think about the idols, they are all humans

Singer can't sing everyday like this, it's bad for their throat sometimes backing vocal will help them rest their voice. So many singer's throat become weak when they're older bc they don't rest their voice

@@isabellegrand8029 2nd gen and 3rd gen sang live a ton and theyre doing perfectly fine. stayc sings live in most of their non-comback stages (like radio shows and stuff) and yes they do get voice cracks (sieun had one while hitting a high note) but they dont feel bad about it bc their ceo told them that voice cracks meant that they were doing good and working hard. i think idols should sing live when they get taught to have a good 'its okay to not be perfect' mentality. if course its okay to lipsync so that their voices dont get harmed but kpop is losing its touch because not many groups sing live anymore.

One of the greatest kpop songs period.

@@inquisitvem6723 for me it is actually the greatest

i think its the best snese boombayah or just the best debut ever tbh

Wait.... this was the debut song? I thought they had a different song for debut?!

I KNOW RIGHTTTTT

crazy solid vocals indeed

Sumin too for me

Seeun!

I appreciate the convo but pls don’t alllivesmatter my comment I highlighted those voices because there’s a quality in them that the other three don’t have and that’s ok

@@thecrooner6573 i mean theyre allowed to comment what they think..

@@ajahneely3876 didn’t say they couldn’t, just giving a grievance

HER SMIRK

so true !!

yes

okay bro thats too much. Theire voices are good and everything but they arent the best singers. You dont need to compare everyone though

@@calledtim_ you clearly didn't read the "I feel" part, and also nothing was compared.

@@calledtim_ i wasn't comparing anyone. they might not be the best singers period, but they're the best live singers imo. especially sieun and yoon.

not mbc hearting these replies 😭

@@berk.. 🤣

Agree…on top of that…Isa’s parts didn’t have any prerecorded vocals…same for Sieun …

She already has recognition, but really, deserves more

This song deserve a win. Such a good song. Still one my fav stayc's song.

And most of their songs (if not all) have that kind of harmonization towards the end. Usually Sieun and someone else.

And then there’s popular girl groups who can’t even hold a tune on stage

@@AmiAki twice?

@@cartduet5810 please don't bring other groups like twice in here! we don't want to start any unnecessary fanwars

@@AmiAki LMAOOOOOO

And some 3rd Gen too..lol

인조적 예쁜 ㅇㅈㄹㅋㅋ 그걸보고 열등감이라고 하는거임ㅋㅋ

@@user-ip3kj8ro3o ? 내가 특정 누구를 보고 인조적이라한것도 아니고 스테이씨는 다 자연스럽게 예쁘다는 뜻으로 얘기한건데 갑자기 시비?ㅠ 느그언니가 인조적으로 예뻐서 괜히 혼자 찔리는거임?

@@AA-jo3ow 존못녀 또 어디가서 얘는 성형일거야~ 이러면서 악플달게뻔함ㅋ

actually i like the fact that they were not so pro then. they were so natural and cute.

@@meow5274 yesss! We can really see how they progress as a team and as an individual as well. I'm happy that they're in a company that knows how to produce music and manage their artist/s.

そーなんですね

진짜공감..

저도 완전 공감이요ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 히메컷도 예쁘지만 또 히메컷시키면 라도님 히메컷 시키고싶은 심정😡😡😡😡

agree

박남정딸..이쁘네 박시은 ㅎ....

They do

NMixx already did too

Main vocalist for a reason.

And she's even smiling and proud at herself i love her

I miss 여자친구 😢😢😢

진짜 스테이씨 뭔가 여자친구 보는거 같아서 찡함..

(여자)아이들

제2의 여자친구 같은 느낌도 있는것같아요..ㅠㅠㅠ

@@user-pl1tn2to3v 그냥 스테이씨라구 해줘요...

Yeah i love her smile

she is so beautiful its crazy