The difference between OOK, FSK and GFSK modulation

  Переглядів 16,923

Milan Karakas

Milan Karakas

5 років тому

The difference between OOK (On/Off Keying), FSK (Frequency Shifting Keying) and GFSK (Gaussian filtered Frequency Shifting Keying) is evident.
paypal.me/OneTimeYTubeSupport...
The worst kind is OOK because data rate 'modulate' main frequency and it produces wide spectra. Much better is fsk, which is very similar to TTY or teleprinter if baud rate is very low. Even better is GFSK, which is FSK with slow transition between two tones or two frequencies. There is also ASK (Amplitude Shifting Keying), but Si4432 has no such ability to produce this modulation. ASK has much narrower 'footprint' than OOK because it does not goes from zero output to maximum, but rather from some 5% of the power up to 100%. No abrupt switching. Car keys has OOK (well, mostly) because it is easier to apply on small transmitter - just turn on and off TX, and that is all. Since it is short burst, nobody cares. But for communication between two transceivers, we should use GFSK - much less wasting power to unwanted side-bands.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

КОМЕНТАРІ: 26
@MilanKarakas
@MilanKarakas 5 років тому
For longish time bothered me how they did actually that famous GFSK. Now found answer and want to share it with you. Thanks.
@Rees3901Gmail
@Rees3901Gmail 2 роки тому
goof video , but what is FLRC modulation?
@MilanKarakas
@MilanKarakas 2 роки тому
@@Rees3901Gmail FLRC? I have no idea.
@Al-vc1kw
@Al-vc1kw 6 місяців тому
@@Rees3901Gmail The Fast Long Range Communication (FLRC) modem uses coherent demodulation of GMSK signals with additional forward error correction (FEC) and interleaving techniques. (WiMOD iM282A Datasheet V1.0; Page 8)
@AkwkyAkass
@AkwkyAkass 3 роки тому
Thank you, good sir! I've been searching for some modulation audio and this is the only video so far with an actual sound, instead of just math and too basic explanation. This is pretty relaxing to hear too, actually. Thanks
@anishandrews
@anishandrews 2 роки тому
Thanks for giving such an insight into GFSK visually.
@Inspironator
@Inspironator 4 роки тому
One of the GFSK modulations demonstrated appeared to be 2-level while another was either 4- 6- or 8-level. That was very interesting. Thanks
@Frejjan
@Frejjan 5 років тому
Nice. I like these short videos that shows me something I didn’t know
@MilanKarakas
@MilanKarakas 5 років тому
Thanks. I just barely can do anything. YT put me down so low...
@puneethprahalad7386
@puneethprahalad7386 2 роки тому
Thank you for explaining this.
@cabrerahidalgo
@cabrerahidalgo 4 роки тому
Absolutely clear. Thanks so much!!
@smoua4588
@smoua4588 Рік тому
Thank you so much for this video!
@Frejjan
@Frejjan 5 років тому
Heh, it hit me during dinner today how digital signal modulation using FSK works because I watched this video. Thanks =P
@MilanKarakas
@MilanKarakas 5 років тому
I am glad I can help.
@midoedo
@midoedo 8 місяців тому
Can you help identify an unknown signal which I believe it's fsk or msk I need a serious assistance and who would help me analysing and decoding would be really appreciated and rewarded
@ellatlantida
@ellatlantida 3 роки тому
hi, i need to know a data modem with 2gfsk & 4gfsk modulation to be not loose speed in amplifier connection needs the same modulation supporting from amplifier i have read..if the amplifier is only says gfsk supporting the 2gfsk & 4gfsk without diference in total data speed or not?
@polyawyvern
@polyawyvern 4 роки тому
Interesting!
@cabrerahidalgo
@cabrerahidalgo 4 роки тому
I have a question. Which is the difference between 2FSK and 4FSK? Thanks for you support!
@DoctorSantosh
@DoctorSantosh 4 роки тому
If you're still looking for an answer, 2 is for the two tones/frequencies. 4fsk has a faster rate of "characters" per second.
@kunalsalvi8382
@kunalsalvi8382 5 років тому
Ok, very cool 👏
@MilanKarakas
@MilanKarakas 5 років тому
Thanks.
@hugocarneirojunior
@hugocarneirojunior 2 роки тому
This is possible make slow motion in carrier signal of dmr, p25, fsk, gmsk, or 3g 4g
@MilanKarakas
@MilanKarakas 2 роки тому
For me - no. I have only PSK on this module. And not every module on 433 MHz or 868 MHz has ability to slow down that much.
@wellboyscience8478
@wellboyscience8478 2 роки тому
Out of band emission is not good
@MilanKarakas
@MilanKarakas 2 роки тому
True. It is waste of RF power.
modulation explained, with demonstrations of FM and AM.
12:23
PhysicsHigh
Переглядів 96 тис.
Understanding Frequency Shift Keying
8:55
Rohde Schwarz
Переглядів 47 тис.
BMW просто издевается над нами! Силы на исходе…
1:34:41
ИЛЬДАР АВТО-ПОДБОР
Переглядів 3,4 млн
#1412 64-QAM QAM64 Quadrature Amplitude Modulation
11:31
IMSAI Guy
Переглядів 5 тис.
How To Set Up A Pirate Radio Station Without Getting Caught
5:15
Ringway Manchester
Переглядів 262 тис.
#44 Hacking and Cloning a Garage Door Opener using SDR Radio
11:39
Andreas Spiess
Переглядів 146 тис.
Understanding APSK and QAM
10:17
Rohde Schwarz
Переглядів 72 тис.
SX1276 LoRa vs Si4432 FSK, тест дальности
18:47
Сергей Давиденко
Переглядів 5 тис.
FREQUENCY MODULATION - PART I - BASIC PRINCIPLES
28:37
PublicResourceOrg
Переглядів 271 тис.
Dave Rowntree: Hacking the Radio Spectrum with GNU Radio
29:07
Electromagnetic Field
Переглядів 16 тис.
ALL Old Modem Sounds (300 baud to 56K)
2:10
lAMNOTGOOMBA
Переглядів 622 тис.
BMW просто издевается над нами! Силы на исходе…
1:34:41
ИЛЬДАР АВТО-ПОДБОР
Переглядів 3,4 млн