The R&S MXO4 is too powerful for its own good (and Dave's sanity)

  Переглядів 16,508

EEVblog2

EEVblog2

Рік тому

The new Rohde and Schwarz MXO4 oscilloscope is too powerful for its own good, and Dave's sanity. Why doesn't Single Shot mode just work?
If you find my videos useful you may consider supporting the EEVblog on Patreon: / eevblog
Web Site: www.eevblog.com
Main Channel: / eevblog
EEVdiscover: / eevdiscover
AliExpress Affiliate: s.click.aliexpress.com/e/c2LRpe8g
Buy anything through that link and Dave gets a commission at no cost to you.
T-Shirts: teespring.com/stores/eevblog
#ElectronicsCreators

КОМЕНТАРІ: 61
@briancox2721
@briancox2721 Рік тому
"The tool on the stool needs to be smarter than the tool on the bench." - One of my ME profs.
@bsodmike
@bsodmike Рік тому
Love it... haha. PEBKAC is another one - "problem exists between keyboard and chair"
@jaakjaak0427
@jaakjaak0427 Рік тому
These days, that means RTFM because the tools are so capable, you can't find all the capability poking around within any modern mid range and higher scope. I showed a lot of smart engineers capability in the products they already owned, at HP/Agilent, Tektronix and R&S.
@martinkuliza
@martinkuliza 11 місяців тому
@@bsodmike If you need to explain PEBKAC........... yeah , NO !! You probably shouldn't make the comment. i think you can assume that everyone here knows certain basic things one of them being PEBKAC ALSO.. it's actually PEBCAK , but you can go either way , but it started as PEBCAK. but. ... You never explain it
@Bllinker
@Bllinker Рік тому
Imagine clicking on that grayed out 'N single' box and it telling you precisely why it's grayed out. Now that would be a very nice UI feature. Maybe some day
@mikeselectricstuff
@mikeselectricstuff Рік тому
Yes, every UI ever would benefit from this - figuring out "why is this greyed" is often the least intuituve thing to find the answer to. unfortunately many UI systems treat "greyed" as "disabled" and hence not able to initiate any action, like showing help messages.
@matt_phistopheles
@matt_phistopheles Рік тому
A few modern digital cameras do this now and it's really helpful. I agree that every UI should have this feature.
@gblargg
@gblargg Рік тому
Pop up saying what needs to be changed to edit it, and offer to make those changes by tapping Yes.
@mikeselectricstuff
@mikeselectricstuff Рік тому
This is like the RTB/RTM scopes- normally, you just get a history of the last of segments depending on the memory settings, but there is also a "Nx single" setting that sets how many segments "single" captures. Essentially this boils down to : 'run' then 'stop' gives you the last segments, 'single' gets you get the _first_ segments. This gives more flexibility than the more conventional segmented approach on other scopes. e.g. last segments are handy to trace back after an event, first segments to capture startup/boot behaviour. I did a vid about this ukposts.info/have/v-deo/h2Cpjo6Ef4Gdq40.html If "Nx single" defaults to 1, then it behaves like other scopes. I wonder if this resets if you to a 'preset' or whatever they call the return-to-defaults button.
@EEVblog
@EEVblog Рік тому
Ah, yes I forgot the RTB2000 has the NxSingle mode also. I've never used it. Not sure why the MOX4 was set to a high value, I don't remember adjusting it. The MXO4 has permanant automatic history mode which is in addition to the usual segmented memory capability.
@pauldenisowski
@pauldenisowski Рік тому
When I start with a Preset (green button), the MXO4 works as one would expect (default of single acquisition, configurable to N acquisitions) ukposts.info/have/v-deo/n5uYgJl7sG6Wxmg.html
@chouseification
@chouseification Рік тому
When your scope comes with Clippy... :D
@IanScottJohnston
@IanScottJohnston Рік тому
Rename the button “Single (on steroids)”
@Kirillissimus
@Kirillissimus Рік тому
Technically the button still just does a single acquisiton sequence. It is just that the sequence is much more complex than one might expect or be used to.
@vincei4252
@vincei4252 Рік тому
I'm sorry, Dave, I'm afraid I can't do that. Please consult Chat GPT for clarification. The bots are taking over ....
@vincei4252
@vincei4252 Рік тому
I really like the way it tells you the capture end time down to the nansecond. I wonder whether you can have the scope sync to a ptp time source so all instrument clocks are sync'd within microseconds of each other.
@Kirillissimus
@Kirillissimus Рік тому
That is one of the best unique features of new R&S scopes - they don't have any segmented memory "modes" and all the stuff is always on and the data is available even if you forgot that you may need it!
@amirb715
@amirb715 2 місяці тому
all R&S scopes work like this. RTB/RTM/RTO/RTE I have worked with are all like that. But the default is usually Nx=1 capture so it behaves like you'd expect.
@pauldenisowski
@pauldenisowski Рік тому
When starting from a Preset, the single shot mode should work as expected (default is 1 acquisition, can be configured to make N acquisitions). The grayed out "N-single / Avg count" is due to settings left over from a previous user session. ukposts.info/have/v-deo/n5uYgJl7sG6Wxmg.html
@vintagetubeamplifiers
@vintagetubeamplifiers Рік тому
This is way beyond anything I'll ever need but I always enjoy all of your videos. My Tektronix 2235 is all I'll ever need, thanks!
@outsideworld76
@outsideworld76 Місяць тому
My first ever scope was the Tek 2235 AN/USM-488, it still works and I still use it from time to time. My daily drivers are a TDS3014B and Agilent DSO7104A. I have way too many analog oscilloscopes :D
@johnwest7993
@johnwest7993 Рік тому
It appears to be some sort of RTFM problem. I've run into them before. :)
@NikiBretschneider
@NikiBretschneider Рік тому
There are two main branches of DSOs. The first is general purpose lab DSO, which, in some way, emulate the behavior of analog oscilloscope adding some more features to it. These things are very intuitive, you probably never open the manual. And there is also the second branch containing heavily specialized devices, presented MXO4 is a good example of a such thing. You definitely need to read the manual of such device and doing measurements is not a straightforward process due the fact, it needs some planning. UI of these things somehow expects you are using features like loading, defaulting and saving presets, which gives you (at least) predictable starting point. Typical workflow begins with planing the whole process, then loading default settings, then setting all you need to se to do the planed measurement and attaching the probing equipment, then saving that settings (just to have some point, where it is easy to return to), then doing measurements, saving results and analyzing them. These extremely complex equipment carry ability to somehow mimic the general purpose devices, but it's crucial to build some default preset (or more of them) to create an easy to use start point. They offer such a huge amount of menus and submenus with a lot of options, that it is almost impossible to hold complete situation awareness, which lead us to situations, where some setting, accidentally left from previous session, lurks in the deep darkness of complexity of that device waiting to kick your ass at the moment you wouldn't expect this, which is what happened in this case. The level of complexity of a general purpose equipment is much lower, which give those issues almost no place to hide. Which implies, that these heavily specialized beasts require complete different workflow than general purpose ones. Just my own experience.
@isoProxanol
@isoProxanol Рік тому
Ya they need a different workflow, but I'd also assume that a person paying 10k+ for such a scope should know what they are doing. Personally I rather go with such complex menus as they allow you more stuff to do. It takes more effort but it outweighs the advantages and possibilities. You can also always mess up a measurement with a simple device too, think about aliasing.
@ontrakcontrolsystemsinc.9147
@ontrakcontrolsystemsinc.9147 Рік тому
I bought one and had the same frustrating experience with signal shot mode. There are a few other discrepancies in the operation of this scope,however, once I figured all the quirks out, I realized it blows myTek MSOX44 out of the water.
@KeritechElectronics
@KeritechElectronics Рік тому
Ha! Sometimes you just get a bad dice roll. Good it wasn't a critical fail, with the scope emitting lots of magic smoke... I'd play with it, but normally it's far too advanced for what I do in my lab. I like the dual generator feature though. Damn useful for decluttering your test gear space.
@JanCiger
@JanCiger Рік тому
Dave, it tells you the History mode/depth is on at upper right under the Acquisition section of the status bar.
@EEVblog2
@EEVblog2 Рік тому
No, that is not the same thing, it's always there for Run/Stop mode. That's the "always on" history mode I mentioned. Totally different thing to the N-Single number count. It does show "1" but onyl after you have pressed Single, not before in Run/Stop when it shows the auto history number.
@WeFixTvs
@WeFixTvs Рік тому
wow nice
@tomasbergh
@tomasbergh Рік тому
Was the segmented memory disabled on the rtb2004?
@HSong-qr7dn
@HSong-qr7dn Рік тому
That's the software option you need to pay for 😢
@tomasbergh
@tomasbergh Рік тому
@@HSong-qr7dn Yes, Rhode has a lot of software options that are extremely costly.
@HSong-qr7dn
@HSong-qr7dn Рік тому
@@tomasbergh True! I compared the price of hardware plus software for rtb2004 and rtm3004, then realised that MXO4 is a cheaper option.
@tomasbergh
@tomasbergh Рік тому
@@HSong-qr7dn maybe but then you have also softwares for the mxo4 that should be added?
@yurkshirelad
@yurkshirelad Рік тому
The almighty Dave was almost bested!
@sbelectronicaindustrial6652
@sbelectronicaindustrial6652 Рік тому
This is a true power machine.....
@PeetHobby
@PeetHobby 11 місяців тому
Title must be: Dave acts like a boomer again. Read the manual, yes after first pressing random button like we all do, but after that just read the manual! 😁
@poppopen7475
@poppopen7475 Рік тому
Please explain the waves, Professor, please reply
@universeisundernoobligatio3283
@universeisundernoobligatio3283 Рік тому
A finger problem?
@enzofitzhume7320
@enzofitzhume7320 Рік тому
USD 8,440
@jaakjaak0427
@jaakjaak0427 Рік тому
Because one has R&S roots and the other has Hameg roots? Or... damn this thing doesn't work like other scopes I'm used to, and someone said something about rtfm but I don't know what that is... (because seriously, you will never have awareness of capability of you don't rtfm)
@EEVblog2
@EEVblog2 Рік тому
Reading the manual doesn't help much in this instance.
@tookitogo
@tookitogo Рік тому
Roots: nonsense. R&S didn’t make any scopes until they bought Hameg. R&S made other test equipment (RF stuff mostly), not really “normal” stuff like oscilloscopes and power supplies. Their purchase of Hameg is what took them beyond RF into more mainstream test and measurement. (In fact, the first R&S oscilloscope wasn’t released until 2010 - a full 5 years after they acquired Hameg.)
@KeritechElectronics
@KeritechElectronics Рік тому
@@tookitogo that's an interesting story; R&S would be generators, frequency meters etc., kinda like with Brüel & Kjaer, Marconi Instruments or Radiometer. Hameg scopes were fine in my book, not as glorious as Tektronix (still dreaming of getting a vintage one) but still very good and reliable. I was kinda wondering what happened to the company... now I know :)
@tookitogo
@tookitogo Рік тому
@@KeritechElectronics Yeah. Hameg was always high quality, but not super advanced. They certainly didn’t target the high end market that R&S did. Buying Hameg extended the R&S brand into the lower end market, but also extended Hameg’s product lines into the higher end market. Frankly, it’s impressive that R&S has been able to go as high end as they have in oscilloscopes in just over a decade! I suppose their expertise in things like high end spectrum analyzers spilled over. I really wanna try the latest Tek scopes though… we have multiple R&S scopes at work, and they’re good, but not as responsive a user interface as Keysight. And then there’s LeCroy - we have a few of those and they’re awesome. (The best was a loaner unit they let us use for a few months. But as a 4ch, 8GHz scope, it’s several orders of magnitude out of my budget! 😂)
@jaakjaak0427
@jaakjaak0427 Рік тому
@@tookitogo Yeah, well, what do I know, I worked at R&S in the scope side and worked with the people that created the R&S scopes in Munich as well as meeting the Hameg side which at the time, still said Hameg on them.
@mahendirangopal3885
@mahendirangopal3885 8 місяців тому
Too much costly
@poppopen7475
@poppopen7475 Рік тому
Professor, explain in detail. Please respond to my conversation. I want you to explain me from the beginning. Please reply.
@andymouse
@andymouse Рік тому
While your waiting there are lots of "Learn Electronics" videos on youtube, I'm am sure you will find something there...good luck !
@shazam6274
@shazam6274 Рік тому
"Vee maake dis good! Yoo must do as vee say in da buk, even if it is not in da buk! Yoo veel like it, yes!" Years ago I ended up with 3 Hameg scopes at work, because no-one else in engineering could get them to work to make standard scope measurements. I kind figured it out, but depending on "where you came from" with the button presses they would respond differently. Finally sold them by weight for scrap with the emphasis in the sCRAP. Also try ordering parts for these gems sometime. 🤣
@ogitakasi3030
@ogitakasi3030 Рік тому
I really hate R&S scopes... Always counterintuitive and like I'm not gonna bother reading manual Imma use Keysight
@GameProgrammer79
@GameProgrammer79 Рік тому
RS can't get this stupid with their flagship 12-bit scope.
@fernandogalloso359
@fernandogalloso359 Рік тому
$22,000 piece of crap. sorry!!!.I like the simple not the complicated.
@EEVblog
@EEVblog Рік тому
If you need to do complicated thing then the you need the complicated device, not the simple device.
@mrpetit2
@mrpetit2 Рік тому
$24,640 to be precise... (MXO44-2415@tequipment). So it's not a problem I'm likely to encounter 😅
@eimparas
@eimparas Рік тому
First!
@EEVblog2
@EEVblog2 Рік тому
Say Hi to your mum for me.
GADGETS VS HACKS || Random Useful Tools For your child #hacks #gadgets
00:35
Машины в 2018 и в 2024
00:15
Gazan
Переглядів 2 млн
Эффект Карбонаро и пончики
01:01
История одного вокалиста
Переглядів 7 млн
Analog VS Digital Scopes for Glitch Captue
11:18
EEVblog2
Переглядів 23 тис.
Bode plot on Rigol DHO924s, don't power off in this state.
7:33
steve levesque
Переглядів 1,6 тис.
Matrix PSU Unboxings & Teardown
28:02
EEVblog2
Переглядів 17 тис.
Everything you need to know when buying/using an Oscilloscope! EB#49
12:40
EEVblog #842 - Rohde & Schwarz HMO1202 Oscilloscope Teardown
50:02
EEVblog #1220 - Siglent SDS5000X 1GHz Oscilloscope Review
1:06:55
EEVblog
Переглядів 71 тис.
Burg Wachter PointSafe P1E Teardown
13:29
EEVblog2
Переглядів 9 тис.
The PA042 SAMSUNG S24 Ultra phone cage turns your phone into a pro camera!
0:24
СЛОМАЛСЯ ПК ЗА 2000$🤬
0:59
Корнеич
Переглядів 1,9 млн
Рекламная уловка Apple 😏
0:59
Яблык
Переглядів 737 тис.
ИГРОВОЙ ПК от DEXP за 37 тысяч рублей из DNS
27:53
Ремонтяш
Переглядів 401 тис.
Такого вы точно не видели #SonyEricsson #MPF10 #K700
0:19
BenJi Mobile Channel
Переглядів 3,2 млн