One should be able to make a top list of passer rating between both QB, I at least know there's for fewest

You're forgetting that the Saints had a historically bad defense that year.

They both would've won with this performance if they were playing 2 different teams this day

Hey guys, the NFL released the top 10 Quarterback duels of all time, do you guys think this game should've been in the top 10? I mean, there were THIRTEEN touchdowns thrown, fourteen if you include the pick six.

Lee's On Stream so did the giants. In fact the Giants only have had a defense ranked higher than 24th once going all the way back to 2013. But sure...Eli Manning was the reason they lost games like this. In fact the 2015 giants went 6-10. They would have gone 10-5-1 that year if a football game was 58 minutes. The giants defense blew the lead/tie 6 times in the last 2 minutes. That’s...historically hard to do.

ghost in the shell357 id say mahomes Goff this past year tops this

@@MarkHeinsius Mahomes and Goff are both interception machines.

Inaren Commander mahomes had 12 int’s to 50tds last year has no interceptions this year where are you getting your info from dude

Markey11 He threw two picks in that game and also fumbled twice so it wasn’t great

@@MarkHeinsius not at all

Sure as hell doesn't feel like it

for real i remember watching it live at Buffalo Wild Wings w my friends.. was the same week the Seahawks played Dallas when they had no Romo lol

4 dumbass

FutureisBrightForUs 4😢

5 :0

It's up there. I'd put the Broncos vs Cowboys in 2013 above it tho

Packers Cardinals Wild Card game in 2009 season was a tad better

@@Pancakes26 that's game happen in the 2000s not 2010s

@@Pancakes26 but the packers lost so it's not cool

@@chuyozuna2398 Technically the game happened in 2010.

Don’t know about decent. Still bad. But miles better than what Daniel Jones has now.

Yea wtf was that

Don't punt the ball out of bounds when the Saints have 20 seconds and 3 timeouts. A skilled directional punter could kick a 32 yard punt out of bounds to the Saints 43. Then the Saints have just 17 yards to go to get to the 40 for Kai Forbath, who has a 57 yard career long. I'll take my chances with the big boot. Really, you should be blaming Wing for the facemask, not for kicking it in bounds. If Wing tackles correctly here, the Saints have to attempt either a 60 yard field goal or a 44 yard hail mary.

didn't the giants lose like 5 or 6 games that season due to last minute field goals or questionable decisions in the final minutes/seconds of the fourth quarter? I know my Pats snuck a win on them with gostowski's 54 yard kick.

They were hoping that fumble came sooner or the kicking team would be in his face 3.6 seconds after he catches it an hit em hard or strip it but nope

TheAireaidLord that’s why coughlin got fired

Online madden is the biggest joke.

Daniel as a Bills fan I respectfully disagree 😂😂 loved that guy

Daniel The 2015 giants defense still gives me nightmares to this day

As a phins fan I hate him

@@RonnyTheGamer Jarius Byrd Rob us all he wanted was his money

Nothing compared to seeing Brandon Browner in black and gold again...

2018 33-18 lmaoo

Omar Yahya Eli 2 rings,Brees 1

Charles Buckley yet Eli isn’t even in the Top 10 when it comes to quarterbacks 🤣🤣

@@tmc31390 what good is top 10 if you got one title

Exactly

He was underrated and overlooked his entire career

@@jameylanier4817 the people who watch football like that know how reliable he was

4:09 begs to differ

@@aaronloiselle3651 Peyton's had those moments too

Three of them were to Odell

@Rowdy Jr. Saints didn't throw it at the one

@Rowdy Jr. dam son

Let's go NYG ANDREW THOMAS BABY!

Superdome football

Giants fan and this still makes me fucking furious. The ending was worse than the Desean Jackson game. Refusing to punt the ball OUT OF BOUNDS like we didn't learn the first time and commiting a fucking FACEMASK when all you had to do was cleanly tackle him to send it to OT. Not to mention this was one of the worst defenses ever assembled that threw away one of Eli's best quarterbacked games and best years

It's beautiful. Let me also mention how people fail to realize that Drew and throwing on the run was a perfect marriage. He still does it but the range isn't as open as it once was in his younger days. Greatest passer of the football ever.

It's therapeutic to watch man. It's graceful

For real. It was sickening to watch.

可iiGold burnt toast

No kidding, including almost costing us this one at home.

Brandon Browner was a holding machine....It drove me crazy.

One if the reasons NE cut him after SB49. Belichick offered for him to stay if he converted to a Strong Safety so Patrick Chung could be used in mixed Strong Safety/CB roles with McCourtey strictly at Free Safety. Browner declined and got cut.

Haha good luck with that 😂😉

Ryan Irwin- Diehl He deserves it honestly, he kicked Patriot ass in the SuperBowl twice

Obviously it’s not guaranteed someone would’ve thrown a TD but I feel like with how that game was going it was inevitable 😂

Christian Perry hopefully

the saints would be 2-14 every year if they didn’t have brees

You realize having brilliant offensive performances like this was a regular thing for Peyton manning right?

@@nelsonalexanderjimenez8120 obviously yes, the point is just that Eli often just had really shitty teams

@@nelsonalexanderjimenez8120not when it mattered the most. Dude lived off his defense

Now there is thanks to the Rams and Chiefs

ok

⚜️⚜️⚜️

Steelers lost the Super Bowl on my birthday, it was all Steeler themed too.

Pancake 26 The broncos lost the Super Bowl 43-8 on my birthday too.

Indians lost on my brothers birthday

bigblue999 the saints lost the minasota miracle on my bday as well lmao

@@riley5270 Damn I feel bad for all of you. My birthday was pretty good!

Eddie May apart from Brees lacks the Arm strength like Brady and Rodgers but makes up in accuracy

@@nilemcdonald9370 wouldn't be surprised if Drew's power maybe because of the shoulder injury way back when he played for the chargers

P o l a r B e a r he was never known to have great arm strength but he made up for it with great deep throw accuracy

Manning's brain+Rodgers' body+Brees' accuracy+Brady's "clutch" factor+Russel Wilson's mobility=perfect 2010s QB

LMAO nope

@Just Jenn yep

@@colinbarlow6662 Nope Brees just got his 8 playoff win this season!!!All the 5,000 yard seasons don't change the fact that he barely makes the playoffs but his stats are great.

@Just Jenn wins don’t mean anything...Tyrod Taylor has more Super Bowl wins than Dan Marino...does that mean he’s better?

@@mikecheeze4312 who's the goat though?

😁

@@NFLVault I tell nothing but the truth and what's truth is this channel being the near perfect foundation to discover some of the greatest bouts or unbelievable conclusions in NFL history. But side note thought what the heck is a tackle anymore?

What about manning?

why “actually” he was an elite QB back then

That's still depressing. Those refs should have been fired. I honestly think Saints would have beat Patriots. I'm not sure if they would have killed them, but they definitely would have won and it would have been a much higher score. Brees vs Brady Superbowl would have been sick, and Brees would have gotten a second ring and retire as one of the all-time greats

*would've

Jesseg0815 would’ve could’ve should’ve... didn’t

Animesh Gandhi ur the one that’s delusional

Yea that was dope