Trying to Land a Plane (to Prove the Dunning-Kruger Effect)

  Переглядів 2,839,048

Be Smart

Be Smart

Рік тому

SUBSCRIBE so you don’t miss a video! ►► bit.ly/iotbs_sub
We’re on PATREON! Join the community / itsokaytobesmart
↓↓↓ More info and sources below ↓↓↓
You may not be an expert, but perhaps you feel pretty confident that you could ride a motorcycle, or give someone a decent haircut - if you absolutely had to - right? Not so much, according to the psychological phenomenon known as the Dunning-Kruger Effect. Turns out we’re all at risk of being overconfident about something. Watch Joe put this theory to the test as he tries to land a 737 (in a simulator, of course). Oh, did we mention Joe's not a pilot?
References: sites.google.com/view/be-smar...
-----------
Special thanks to our Brain Trust Patrons:
Mark Littlehale
Ali Freiburger
Mehdi Damou
Barbora Bei
Ken Board
Clinger-Hamilton Family
Attila Pix
Burt Humburg
Roy Lasris
dani bowman
David Johnston
Salih Arslan
Baerbel Winkler
Robert Young
Amy Sowada
Eric Meer
Dustin
Karen Haskell
Join us on Patreon!
/ itsokaytobesmart
Twitter
/ drjoehanson
/ okaytobesmart
Instagram
/ drjoehanson
/ okaytobesmart
Merch
store.dftba.com/collections/i...
Facebook
/ itsokaytobesmartpbs

КОМЕНТАРІ: 4 200
@besmart
@besmart Рік тому
Turns out it’s harder than I thought. But we all got a chance to learn about unconscious overconfidence. Where else do you see the Dunning-Kruger Effect show up in the world?
@GFKCEG
@GFKCEG Рік тому
Now try to do any other random specialized job in the world guided by an expert, just to "prove a point"...
@aparks1437
@aparks1437 Рік тому
everywhere 😟
@eustache_dauger
@eustache_dauger Рік тому
Politics
@wolfrig2000
@wolfrig2000 Рік тому
Truck driving, everyone thinks they know how a truck works, and they think they're all the same. Every load, every trailer, every trip is different and you're literally just winging it with your experience every second of every day, especially with the terrible drivers in the cars being the worst drivers ever.
@doxielain2231
@doxielain2231 Рік тому
Everywhere, unfortunately.
@AmyDentata
@AmyDentata Рік тому
I've only read a little about the Dunning-Kruger effect, but I think I have a pretty solid understanding of it
@hillbillysamurai
@hillbillysamurai Рік тому
Nice
@Eastmarch2
@Eastmarch2 Рік тому
I see what you did there
@gouravsamantroy4344
@gouravsamantroy4344 Рік тому
😂
@hadishstreet3066
@hadishstreet3066 Рік тому
Hahahaha
@stephennelson6975
@stephennelson6975 Рік тому
The first rule of Dunning-Kruger club is you don’t know you’re in Dunning-Kruger club.
@djrt8179
@djrt8179 3 місяці тому
When people say "I could land the plane", you did exactly what they think they could do . No one thinks they'd have a commercial-level landing, but people think they have the possibility to make sure everyone lands without dying. You literally proved that it's possible.
@Spunkton
@Spunkton 3 місяці тому
Only on the new-gen plane that could land itself tho. On the other planes he set one on fire and one crashed, it just didn't show in the simulator itself.
@-Cheif
@-Cheif 3 місяці тому
That’s what I figured. I bet I could land it. Would it be a good landing? No of course not, the plane will probably be damaged in the millions for repair, but I would be able to walk off of it rather than be carried away in a body bag.
@DanteHaroun
@DanteHaroun 3 місяці тому
Literally
@SPASPAWIZ
@SPASPAWIZ 3 місяці тому
It seems that with more coordination it’s quite possible to land the plane. You can’t say everyone is going to “crunch” the landing gear. If he didn’t make that same 1 mistake twice it would have been a complete success. P.s. every single large commercial aircraft has autopilot for flying and landing for at least 20 years now. I was a guest in the cockpit for a commercial flight and the pilot asked me if he should manually land the plane without autopilot so I could watch, and he did. They are pretty smooth he did it like it was nothing, perfectly, and we were laughing and joking around with the other crew in the cockpit.
@danielbrandstetter8713
@danielbrandstetter8713 3 місяці тому
@@Spunkton you're missing his point. When someone says "I could land a plane" they mean "I could put this plane on the ground without killing as many people as if it crashed uncontrolled", which the video absolutely showed. You would have caused millions in damages, but at least people wouldn't be dead. Both crashes would have resulted in damages and fires, but the emergency crews would have been standing by because ATC would know that there is an untrained civilian flying a massive plane. So most would have survived.
@thewebwingman
@thewebwingman 6 місяців тому
Pilot here, the fact that you actually made it TO the runway in IFR is better than a lot of pilot trainees do.
@monkeymox2544
@monkeymox2544 5 місяців тому
I'm curious, do pilots these days generally use autopilot to land, or do they do it manually? Presumably they still have to keep in practice in case the autopilot fails?
@thewebwingman
@thewebwingman 5 місяців тому
Depending on the equipment and category of approach you can either use Autoland, or (my preference) disconnect the autopilot 200 feet or more above the ground and hand fly the last part of the approach.@@monkeymox2544
@NightlyWatch
@NightlyWatch 5 місяців тому
Autopilot is disabled during landing, too many variables so little time to avert if something goes wrong, as well as other things.@@monkeymox2544
@bharkbh
@bharkbh 5 місяців тому
Manually, although for the early approach phase, the plane flies on autopilot, you baby sit it until on final [around 1 nautical mile out (VARIES)], then you disengage the AP and hand fly the aircraft carefully to touchdown, in case of an emergency or bad weather, A CAT III verified aircraft can perform a landing via the computer (auto land), although this is not always available, and in very bad weather conditions planes will simply not be permitted to fly.@@monkeymox2544
@noname-yy3zy
@noname-yy3zy 5 місяців тому
​@@monkeymox2544 depends on the plane does bigger ones is literally 1 button click and it does the line up altitude throttle flappers wheels for you. 99.9% automatic... Smaller planes align themselves (most of them) then you just put down the flappers and wheels when you're at your desired speed like 120 knots (depends on the plane etc.) in those planes you might have to do the throttle automatically. Basically pull it all the way down half slow when you touch the ground (also raise the pitch a tiny bit). But yes it all depends on the plane. Also you are trained for worst case scenarios so you should be able to manually land the plane, in fact its quite easy if you know how to align the plane. (the tower will often tell you the speed, altitude etc.) Edit: bruh he basically said everything i said in the video...
@Poorschedriver
@Poorschedriver 4 місяці тому
There's a difference between a crash, and a crash with fatalities. If a good landing is one you walk away from and as far as I'm concerned you did an impressive job. Plus taking into account BOS has a huge runaway and many emergency services, if the pilots stroke out on my flight I'd definitely want you to land it.
@Th3_Gael
@Th3_Gael 3 місяці тому
My first time with my instructor, while he was lining up the runway he said "every landing is a crash, either controlled or uncontrolled, but any crash you walk away from is a good landing"
@user-nf7ui7dz1z
@user-nf7ui7dz1z 3 місяці тому
Landing a 737 with no flying experience: I’m not at all confident that anyone besides myself would be smart enough and brave enough to even attempt this and actually have a good chance at success. I would 100% step up and say “Everyone please relax, I’ve got this” to the entire 737 plane full of people and see if there’s another person on board that was not a total panicky idiot, and if we’re extremely lucky there would be someone and then I would be even more confident and would ensure everyone on board that we will all be landing safely and they would be with their loved ones shortly while reassuring them again of our absolutely certain ability to get us on the ground safely. I’d give it a 99.999% chance we succeed as long as we keep coms with our real pilot on the ground and or air traffic controllers. It might not be perfectly straight, and someone still may need to come onboard to help us park, or drive us up to the gate but I know for an absolute fact that I can check my ego with pride and would for sure let that happen if needed. We would all be very happy regardless, and I would laugh at our story and my inability to drive her once on the ground about not being able to park this big old’ plane but could manage figure out how to get us all on the ground safely!
@wagadoogado
@wagadoogado 3 місяці тому
There's a quote on the videogame War Thunder that talks exactly about that. It goes as following; "The plane is on the ground and the pilot is alive, a great landing it is!"
@ScooterinAB
@ScooterinAB 3 місяці тому
But there are airports with runways that aren't very big. Narita (Japan) has an infamously short runway because of huge failures in acquiring land for the airport that led to decades of protests that are technically still ongoing. But there's also the fact that take off and landing are the most dangerous times. Chances are, any untrained landing is going to end in fatalities, not end with a mere crash.
@andy5959
@andy5959 3 місяці тому
​@user-nf7ui7dz1z You are completely insane.
@KevinStoffel
@KevinStoffel Рік тому
I AM a pilot, and I instructed in a 737 simulator for about a year and a half. The first of your actual manual landings was not a crash. I don't know why he told you that you "crushed the gear". Your rate of descent was fine at touchdown. In fact, it was even softer than the auto-land did. And the 737 is capable of REALLY planting onto the runway, which is actually a safer landing in adverse weather. I'd call that first landing a success. Though, the rest were... well... rough.
@besmart
@besmart Рік тому
Putting this feather in my hat for the rest of my life
@bubbleboi28
@bubbleboi28 Рік тому
are you saying he's certified for Ryanair?
@rob.ale90
@rob.ale90 Рік тому
@@bubbleboi28 on manual, yes
@KevinStoffel
@KevinStoffel Рік тому
@@bubbleboi28 overqualified, actually
@DoorThief
@DoorThief Рік тому
It was a bit hard to tell, but it's possible he landed too far forward on the front gear before the back gears. I've heard the larger planes are meant to land on the rear gears, which can take a lot of punishment, unlike the front. But I have no clue what I'm talking about, so take what I'm saying with a grain of salt
@BillinND
@BillinND Рік тому
As a 20 year pilot I’m impressed that he could even make it to the runway especially in the weather. Keep hitting the Microsoft flight sim. It’s clearly paying off.
@MattH-wg7ou
@MattH-wg7ou Рік тому
Isnt it amazing how much SA can be drained simply by being in the weather?! I hate being IMC.
@nbrosens
@nbrosens Рік тому
For real man, I was expecting it to go much worse.
@cristobalpatino3256
@cristobalpatino3256 Рік тому
Im a 737 pilot While not great, for a person with no aviation background, both tries were actually pretty good
@RedBroski
@RedBroski Рік тому
I'm a student pilot, and yet I feel like I know absolutely nothing about what I'm doing....all of the time 😆 But yeah.... He did good considering he isn't in any actual classes.
@cheapskateaviation
@cheapskateaviation Рік тому
@@RedBroski Yeah, I don't think its till you're a student pilot that you realize just how overwhelming it can be. Even simple things become hard because you're so task saturated. Good luck on the training!
@TheThumbsUpChannel
@TheThumbsUpChannel 4 місяці тому
I feel like the hardest part is knowing how to channel into the right radio frequency to get help from the runway you are going to
@sientguy
@sientguy 3 місяці тому
Just talk into the microphone while pushing the push to talk button. Whoever is on the other line of the current frequency will help you all the way.
@Kenionatus
@Kenionatus 3 місяці тому
​@@sientguyThe problem is that you might already be out of range of everyone on the frequency.
@baltulielkungsgunarsmiezis9714
@baltulielkungsgunarsmiezis9714 2 місяці тому
Yea, if someone asks if you know how to land a plane say you know how to operate the radio. The emergency frequency is 121.5 MHz and will always have someone lisening unless your out of range of everyone.
@Edss-nr6xw
@Edss-nr6xw Місяць тому
@@baltulielkungsgunarsmiezis9714 Even then you have UHF. Tune to different frequencies on the MCDU and callout. Stay in the lower frequencies like single digits. Kinda sucks having to spray and pray but it's better than nothing. If the plane has wifi and you can see an airports IATA code on one of the DU's you can Google their ATC's frequency. All of this assumes you have time though. I'd assume that autopilot and autothrottle are already on in this scenario. Commercial jets have TCAS so other airliners will most likely deviate. Now smaller planes without TCAS. Someone who doesn't know anything about an airplane will probably just be scared and confused about why the plane is yelling at them to climb/descend. Assuming automatic TCAS isn't on.
@baltulielkungsgunarsmiezis9714
@baltulielkungsgunarsmiezis9714 Місяць тому
@@Edss-nr6xw A smaller plain tho is easyer to fly manually. Its more responsible, big engines take longer to spin up and bigger objects take longer to slow down.
@cablewaffel7957
@cablewaffel7957 3 місяці тому
This reminds me of when I was learning to drive. From what others have told me it seems that this is a pretty universal experience, but when I started learning to drive I was cautious because I knew that I didn’t know much. But by the time I went through the process of having a permit, taking the tests, and getting my required hours of experience I was confident in my abilities. So I wasn’t all that cautious after I got my license. And within the first year, like many others, I got into an accident. The accident really showed me just how inexperienced I was and it made me much more cautious as a driver and I think I’m a much better driver because of it.
@noirnoir3701
@noirnoir3701 3 місяці тому
I wish everyone has the same self awareness and ability to self-reflect like you here. World will be a utopia.
@danielharrington5690
@danielharrington5690 3 місяці тому
​​​@@noirnoir3701 as if all of the world's problems are caused by lack of individual self reflection. Unicorns would decend from the heavens to facilitate efficient trade and end starvation and suffering all around the world! And there would be no need for silly things like resources, or armies or borders because we'd all be super self reflective
@avadrumm
@avadrumm 3 місяці тому
When I was first learning to drive (in the very first driving lesson, when I had never driven before) my driving instructor showed me how to put the car in reverse and how to change gears and then he was just like: "Ok, now drive the car onto this 60km/h road". I definitely did not feel confident that I knew what I was doing.
@allengreen424
@allengreen424 3 місяці тому
I fell asleep at the will 2 years after I got my license
@Kimmie6772
@Kimmie6772 3 місяці тому
I recommend driving to a place you haven't been before/are unfamiliar with once and a while if you get too cocky. I'm terrible at directions and suddenly forget how to read signs from being panicky. Muscle memory controls a lot more than people think and is probably why it's even possible to blank out while driving in the first place.
@SirKenNorth
@SirKenNorth Рік тому
As a pilot I would say that on your second attempt you would probably have saved all lives on board, despite damaging the plane. In an emergency situation I'm happy to call that a successful landing.
@adrianchoo3696
@adrianchoo3696 Рік тому
I agree. Couldnt have asked for a better outcome! That touchdown looks like maybe 800-900fpm+ heavy, will probably have structural dmg but all lives saved maybe minor injuries nothin too serious. I mean, untrained, first time in a full motion sim, getting instructions via radio or from the back and having to figure out what the instructions mean. The stress levels would be immense esp in a real life landing. So he did great!
@Hobadee
@Hobadee Рік тому
If you can walk away from the landing, it's a good one. If you can use the plane again, it's a great landing. If the plane doesn't require any repairs it was a perfect landing.
@kosmokritikos9299
@kosmokritikos9299 Рік тому
Well, they used to say any landing you can walk away from...
@Kamel419
@Kamel419 Рік тому
As they say, any landing you can walk away from is a good one
@nibs991
@nibs991 Рік тому
I used to hear, any landing you can walk away from is good one, any you can fly the plane again…
@IsYitzach
@IsYitzach Рік тому
The second and third attempt, while technically a crash, would probably totally survivable by most if not all passengers. That's good enough for a novice.
@PatataMaxtex
@PatataMaxtex Рік тому
A good landing is one you (and everyone else on the plane) can walk away from, an excellent landing is one after which you can use the plane again.
@Vonononie
@Vonononie Рік тому
He got on the runway which is probably better than most people
@KlausJepps
@KlausJepps Рік тому
You are right, but Joe expected not to crash, and that was the point.
@yardpup01
@yardpup01 Рік тому
Joe made it to the runway with out automation in IMC conditions. That's really impressive.
@vexorian
@vexorian Рік тому
Tell that to the families of the 1% passengers that died
@RobertHollander
@RobertHollander Місяць тому
I've encountered the term, "Dunning-Kruger Effect," countless times. I think it's totally awesome that you actually had Dunning included in your video.
@RealSiViX
@RealSiViX 6 місяців тому
Pro Tip: When you're landing, don't use the stick to climb/descend, if you're off the glideslope, adjust your throttle in small increments (you will get a feel for it after enough practice), more throttle will cause you to climb and less throttle will cause you to descend... When you try to make these adjustments on the stick, pulling up will cause you to lose speed and can lead to an aerodynamic stall, pushing the nose down causes an increase in speed which can cause you to overshoot your landing, you want to adjust your speed while maintaining the optimum descent angle for your aircraft...
@zodiacdriver3852
@zodiacdriver3852 5 місяців тому
This is how I learned about that: If you want to go up, pull the yoke, if you want to descent, pull the yoke further. 😂
@SpottinPlanesForLife
@SpottinPlanesForLife 5 місяців тому
Me who already knows that 😂😂😂😂😂
@_purge9488
@_purge9488 4 місяці тому
Pitch for airspeed, power for altitude. Could never forget it 😂
@ignorance72
@ignorance72 4 місяці тому
This is true for light aircraft, but on large airliners it doesn't really work. The aircraft has too much inertia and just doesn't respond quickly enough to changes in thrust. That's why they primarily use pitch to control the descent rate while letting the autothrottle maintain airspeed.
@cdesha
@cdesha 4 місяці тому
Doesn’t work in airliners.
@wittycommentator
@wittycommentator Рік тому
Now that I'm aware of the Dunning-Kruger effect, I think I have what it takes to land the plane
@cringeaccount3343
@cringeaccount3343 4 місяці тому
The dunning kruger effect strikes again!
@Chloe-dc3bm
@Chloe-dc3bm 4 місяці тому
Give me a 5 minute rundown. I'm landing that plane like a pro!
@Chloe-dc3bm
@Chloe-dc3bm 4 місяці тому
Expert pilots are just mad that gaming nerds could do what they do with a couple hours of flight sim😂😂😂
@Dmoc6703
@Dmoc6703 3 місяці тому
@@Chloe-dc3bm I got the chance to take off, fly, and land all on my “own” in a real plane with zero training whatsoever😅, and I found out that even flying straight is WAY more complicated than I expected, and I had played a lot of simulators. Now honestly landing was easier somehow, but hella scary, I felt like I was at a 45° angle
@KoreyThatcher
@KoreyThatcher 3 місяці тому
If I had air traffic control talking to me, I could definitely land the plans
@robertfletcher3421
@robertfletcher3421 Рік тому
Joe, I would like to have seen you do this with Tom Scott as your co-pilot.
@besmart
@besmart Рік тому
Willing to try again! Let’s go Tom!
@maartendj2724
@maartendj2724 Рік тому
Tom Scott will only do it with the seats reversed lol
@simonmueller2878
@simonmueller2878 Рік тому
Yees that would be so great.
@wakkawakka7624
@wakkawakka7624 Рік тому
That would be very entertaining
@orsaz924
@orsaz924 Рік тому
Might be the most unreliable flight crew ever 😂😂 jk
@infomercialwars
@infomercialwars 5 місяців тому
I've played flight sims since I was a little kid, I bought some commercial simulator time for my 30th birthday I didn't crash it a single time and could even do a ILS approach. It was really fun and I plan on doing it again for my 40th. The hardest part really is getting used to the coordination required for using rudder, throttle, and the yoke at the same time while monitoring your speed it's very different than playing a sim on your computer
@lukedrew2950
@lukedrew2950 2 місяці тому
You should consider pursuing a lisence :)
@Edss-nr6xw
@Edss-nr6xw Місяць тому
0:45 I'm an avionics technician. I've dabbled in Microsoft Flight Simulator and know a decent amount about how planes work. I can't land one. But I know that COM1 or COM2 is probably already set to the nearest ATC tower, look for the Push-To-Talk button on the CCD, press it and ask them to guide me through it. The good thing is autopilot will help a lot. The bad news is you still have to get the jet in the right configuration for approach, descent and landing. You also have to line up with the runway correctly. I've seen crosswinds nearly make senior pilots cause a tail strike or wing strike. If there's a crosswind you're boned.
@2009dudeman
@2009dudeman Місяць тому
I have always said, I can guarantee you that while having never flown an aircraft bigger than a suitcase, I can land a plane. I make no promises about the number of casualties however, even a crash landing is a landing and I never promised anyone would survive, lol. That being said. I think a decent number of people, if they can keep calm, could land a plane with at least one of the passengers surviving. In a modern plane even with adverse weather, probably some people will survive which is still better than none.
@Edss-nr6xw
@Edss-nr6xw Місяць тому
​@@2009dudeman Most people don't know this but planes are made of aluminum. It's light weight and usually hundredths of an inch thick. A scratch big enough to catch your finger on the skin of the aircraft (the green under panels, it's green because it's bare aluminum with primer on it) is required to be depth tested to see if it's within limits. Happened where I work recently. Someone scratched the skin and NDT had to come out with an ultrasonic test set to determine the thickness of the skin in that spot. It was within limits (thankfully) but people who don't understand how fragile the fuselage skin is wouldn't understand why such a tiny scratch is cause for major concern. Aluminum is delicate. Over time as the fuselage expands and contracts due to extreme temperatures at higher altitudes and cabin pressurization that tiny scratch will become a crack in a relatively short amount of time. Eventually it will lead to rapid depressurization. Aluminum is malleable and flexes well. That's also its weakness. For reference, thicker aluminum foil is around 0.072 inches thick. A lot of planes have skin thicknesses around 0.125 inches. Not even an entire one-hundredth of an inch thicker. I'm not an engineer by any means. But that alone doesn't give me much hope for the odds of a decently hard landing going well. Because I *seriously* doubt with the yoke in the hands of a completely inexperienced person they will be able to keep the jets landing gear parallel with the runway. _Especially_ if there's a crosswind. A tail strike would be devastating. A wing strike would be bad too. All in all, in my experience, engineers focus their effort on the computer systems and flight surfaces on board to mitigate the need for a hard landing... in the hands of an experienced pilot. We're talking about someone who potentially hasn't even played microsoft flight simulator taking a stab at it. My money is on the decimating themselves and anything nearby.
@2009dudeman
@2009dudeman Місяць тому
@@Edss-nr6xw none of that is relevant to the fact that having even a completely unaware person in the cockpit with ATC provides a higher chance of survival for people on the plane, than lacking the cockpit empty in case of pilot incapacitation, which has a result of 100% fatalities. Cool that you are in the industry, but having a person that's alive and can follow an order from someone, on it's own, provides a higher chance of survival than a person that's incapacitated and can't follow orders. We saw it here where listening to the actual pilot tell you how to program the plane resulted in a rather 'normal ' landing. Adverse weather just increases the risk of critical damage, it doesn't make auto pilot non-functional. Besides, chances are the pilots are incapacitated long before diversion to better weather isn't possible, at which point you can be talked through the process.
@orangeshirt6443
@orangeshirt6443 Рік тому
When you realise you can have the Dunning-Kruger effect in relation to knowledge about the Dunning-Kruger effect..
@deanfowlkes
@deanfowlkes Рік тому
You’re blowing my mind, Orange!!
@deanfowlkes
@deanfowlkes Рік тому
That is so meta.
@omniyambot9876
@omniyambot9876 Рік тому
Ironically, this is what I was thinking when the discoverer himself is talking about it..
@MCRuCr
@MCRuCr Рік тому
people that question themselves usually do not suffer from the dunning kruger effect. Introspection is like the best way to prevent it
@SuicV
@SuicV Рік тому
@@MCRuCr Or maybe that's what one would think if they don't know enough about it...
@ekids.bassment
@ekids.bassment Рік тому
There is also a positive side to the Dunning-Kruger effect, because if people really knew what was ahead of them, a lot of people wouldn't have started the journey in the first place.
@nathanjasper512
@nathanjasper512 Рік тому
Stephen King once said, "if you don't start out a little too big for your britches how do you ever hope to fill them?"
@BruceCarbonLakeriver
@BruceCarbonLakeriver Рік тому
Fax!
@cybhunter007
@cybhunter007 11 місяців тому
First step in avoiding a trap is knowing of its existence
@purpl3grape
@purpl3grape 11 місяців тому
@@nathanjasper512 Oh I misunderstood, I was starting out a little too big for my bitches.
@kimbersal1
@kimbersal1 3 місяці тому
Love all of your videos, but really liked this one, Shirley!
@UniquePerspective
@UniquePerspective 3 місяці тому
I was put in a really difficult situation when I was hired as an automation programmer without having the necessary knowledge (after the owner's suggestion). In my first month the only other programmer quit, leaving me with a bunch of delayed projects and a huge mess of programs. I often found myself telling the owner that my job is really hard because at every step I had to consider what I didn't know. But this made me very aware of the fact I didn't know enough and I setup procedures for testing and QA that in the end I ended up being the best programmer the company ever had. I had no idea about this effect but with methodical thinking I was able to discover it and overcome it. Now I also know the name for it.
@Sarah_D.
@Sarah_D. Рік тому
I've been watching a lot of flight videos lately. So, how confident am I that I could land a plane? Assuming full automation and ideal conditions, close to 100%. A fully manual landing, also 100%. Granted, survival of the plane and passengers in that situation would probably be around 0%, but I could definitely get the plane out of the sky and onto the ground.
@Megaman634
@Megaman634 Рік тому
If you squint real hard it's a landing
@1224chrisng
@1224chrisng Рік тому
yeah, most people tend to be quite adept at this Lithobraking manoeuvre, which is also true with cars after a few drinks
@davidblanchard66
@davidblanchard66 Рік тому
Had us in the first half Ngl😂
@lynn858
@lynn858 Рік тому
Valid! Specific parameters such as: “survival of all on board” and “plane is still capable of flying afterward” really do make all the difference here.
@primordial_platypus
@primordial_platypus Рік тому
Any landing you can walk away from is a good one.
@pushing2throttles
@pushing2throttles Рік тому
I have a bachelor degree in aviation: I became a pilot in college. This donning-krueger affect I think it's very real and without knowing it, I experienced it during my flight training. That's where good instructors come in. Because you don't know what you don't know, it's a very fine line to know when you did something well or need improvement. Flight training is all about training, training, and training some more; you build from the previous lesson and before you know it, you're proficient. Handle an emergency while you're task saturated... do that and you can be taught to fly. What he said about chain of events is so true. There's never ever any one reason why accidents happen; it's always a chain of events and we strive to stop that chain of events at any one point.
@ihtfp69
@ihtfp69 Рік тому
You can do this at Embry-Riddle. I was always fascinated with this degree. However, it costs a lot of money.
@macfady2181
@macfady2181 Рік тому
Swiss cheese effect, sometimes all the holes line up and you end up with a major incident.
@Nekotaku_TV
@Nekotaku_TV Рік тому
*Dunning-Kruger
@bittnerbs
@bittnerbs Рік тому
@@ihtfp69you can do this at Embry-Riddle, but be prepared to pay 2x as much as anywhere else to get the same degree and ratings.
@waytospergtherebro
@waytospergtherebro Рік тому
You should re-take basic English.
@sean19
@sean19 3 місяці тому
Well done . I've always wanted to try out a proper simulator
@davidbanfield3280
@davidbanfield3280 3 місяці тому
Great video. Well put together and well presented.
@topcropphoto6859
@topcropphoto6859 6 місяців тому
From what i hear, you landed it better than most Ryan Air pilots
@SusannaSaunders
@SusannaSaunders 3 місяці тому
LoL 😂yeah I can believe that!
@joshuadalton6063
@joshuadalton6063 3 місяці тому
Why are you degrading his ability like that? *most*? :D
@partially_discombobulated9818
@partially_discombobulated9818 3 місяці тому
Ryanair, who belly flop every landing from at least 50ft ...yup
@jessiemarie636
@jessiemarie636 3 місяці тому
😂😂
@calalos
@calalos 3 місяці тому
After a couple of Ryan air flights I thought “this cannot be normal” and “are they landing like this on purpose?” Go figure they do, they are trained to land with a faster approach to reduce the chances of having to abort the landing, no matter the weather or wind situation. They argue is safer but mostly is to reduce the chances of delays and costs caused by aborted landings.
@halfrhovsquared
@halfrhovsquared Рік тому
I am a pilot. I can tell you that flying IS mentally exhausting. On the subject of "Dunning-Kruger", long before I had even heard of the study, I would talk of the five stages of competence: Unconsciously Incompetent - You don't know what you don't know. You have absolutely no idea what you must learn. Consciously Incompetent - You now have some idea of the enormity of the task before you but you still don't know how to do it. Consciously Competent - You can now do it. However, you must think about it in order to be able to do it. You cannot do it automatically. Unconsciously Competent - Now you can do it without thinking about it. You can walk AND chew gum. This, often inevitably, leads to: Unconsciously Incompetent - You are not paying attention to what you are doing. You have over-estimated your ability and have grown complacent. ("The Killing Zone"). The trick is to remain somewhere between Step 3 and Step 4. Allow your automatic responses to do the thing (be "pilot flying") whilst your conscious mind pays attention to your performance (being "Pilot Monitoring").
@BruceCarbonLakeriver
@BruceCarbonLakeriver Рік тому
yep, hence I love checklists and their procedures. They actually give you a reason to go through every step without being fully "automated" on doing them. Although I'm pretty sure many airmen had the situation where they said check although it wasn't, also by habits after doing a known checklist for the umpteens time. ^^
@halfrhovsquared
@halfrhovsquared Рік тому
@@BruceCarbonLakeriver - Likewise. I am a great believer in the efficacy of checklists. Quite often, for some things, i don't even use written checklists. I use "visual" checklists. For example, I am preparing to leave the house to travel. Rather than write up a checklist. I put all the things I need to take in one place so that I know that I have everything when that area is clear. A rather simplistic example but I think it illustrates the kind of thing that I mean.
@BruceCarbonLakeriver
@BruceCarbonLakeriver Рік тому
@@halfrhovsquared Me too! And I feel like a nerd about this. But guess who didn't have forgotten something? Yep, me :) Checklists FTW! :)
@MissMoon....
@MissMoon.... Рік тому
Well put! 👌🏽👌🏽
@paulmryglod4802
@paulmryglod4802 6 місяців тому
I used to race motocross and we would talk about the most dangerous racers. We agreed that beginners were somewhat dangerous, especially in the first turn. However, it was the newly ranked novices (one class up from beginners) who were the most dangerous. They start to believe they have it all figured out and push beyond their capabilities and frequently cause the worst accidents. Expert class was the safest, and fastest class. Everyone knows what they are doing, and can reliably predict what others will do.
@notmyworld44
@notmyworld44 4 місяці тому
I've seen this young man before and really enjoyed this. I subscribed.
@devanhusmann9297
@devanhusmann9297 5 місяців тому
Duel survival is a show that actually gives alot to take away in the way of understanding and knowledge of what to do in specific scenarios but also goes through and explains things that are commonly thought of in said spot is incorrect.
@magister343
@magister343 Рік тому
I remember reading that the Dunning-Kreuger effect was strongest for highly competent experts (PhDs, the worlds bests surgeons, etc) when dealing with fields other than their specialty.
@omniyambot9876
@omniyambot9876 Рік тому
Wow! That's interesting. Especially when you dig deep knowledge in your field, you should realize how much respect you have to give into other fields..
@arthanor9631
@arthanor9631 Рік тому
That's really surprising. The PhDs I know essentially all suffer from imposter syndrome, they're far from being overconfident even in their own fields. I can see older, successful, established Phds being the opposite though.
@omniyambot9876
@omniyambot9876 Рік тому
@@arthanor9631 yeah. I think serious doctors are much more humble considering the amount of complexity they are dealing with..
@wholeNwon
@wholeNwon Рік тому
I talked with the world-famous Andreas Gruentzig, M.D. (Heidelberg) just days before he flew his Beechcraft into the ground. I was told that he was sure his altimeter was wrong, though I have no direct knowledge of that.
@MP4_mafia
@MP4_mafia Рік тому
I believe it's called ultracrepidarianism
@mrobject9113
@mrobject9113 Рік тому
This is 100% the case in survival scenarios as well. It's well documented that since the new survival shows have become more and more popular (think Survivorman, Survivor, Man vs Wild) more and more people incorrectly assume they can survive in the wilderness and end up getting lost in a large forest requiring rescue.
@Skim_beeble7125
@Skim_beeble7125 Рік тому
Or we live in the modern world and it’s more accurately reported
@kingetzel2755
@kingetzel2755 Рік тому
@@Skim_beeble7125 - Prior to the modern era more people probably could survive in the wilderness, as far more people had to out of necessity.
@kingetzel2755
@kingetzel2755 Рік тому
Beyond those shows, in my experience most people who hunt/fish/grow crops overestimate their ability to survive after a cataclysmic disaster/event. And while they would likely survive better than someone without those skills, they probably wouldn't do as well as they initially thought.
@ScienceBitch123
@ScienceBitch123 Рік тому
Or people thinking they can be an effective President of the United States or CEO because they've seen other people do it, but wind up being a disaster
@Jmoneysmoothboy
@Jmoneysmoothboy Рік тому
@@kingetzel2755 How many cataclysms have you experienced lol
@dw7922
@dw7922 3 місяці тому
This is a great concept. Can’t wait to watch.✈️
@pilotpawanc
@pilotpawanc 3 місяці тому
Loved your analysis from the practical data. I myself have flown Cessna and i know that flying a sim and the real deal is way way different. Our virtual worlds have exposed us to more and more to this affect and the need to fit socially actually cause most of us to - fake it, till we make it. Cheers!!!
@MisterBrickFilms
@MisterBrickFilms Рік тому
I'm an archaeologist, and each time we do activities in which we interact with visitors, I know I'm bound to get that one person who's going to know everything better than me because they watched a documentary. And oh boy that particular person will let you know that they possess The Knowledge.
@Ryattt81
@Ryattt81 Рік тому
Actually, thats just not true....historically speaking novices are actually more likely to complete a task with more success than a relevant expert....I saw a documentary about this.
@SupremeOverlord10
@SupremeOverlord10 Рік тому
Yep, you just proved the point.
@wiredforstereo
@wiredforstereo Рік тому
Same is true for vegans, interestingly enough.
@smurfyday
@smurfyday Рік тому
@@wiredforstereo The number of people who bash vegans versus the numbers of vegans who actually behave the way they're accused of, it's like 100-to-1. And I'd take a proselytizing vegan over a hateful meat-eater any day. Keep burning the planet, my friend.
@roberson644
@roberson644 Рік тому
Well the question is: How do you become an expert? By reading, and watching, and gaining experience from other experts. Takes a significant amount of time, but at some level of study, you become an expert yourself. And at that point, you yourself contribute to the knowledge base.
@firstclaw1
@firstclaw1 3 місяці тому
So the quote from Socrates: "I know that I do not know." is more current than ever. Thanks for the video. Well made. It was fun, and I do appreciate the interview with Mr. Dunning. PS: (SCNR) It seems many people with a little knowledge "in the death zone", who have an outrageously huge self assurance like to go to politics... And too many tend to believe them as these guys radiate confidence.
@Errcyco
@Errcyco 28 днів тому
On a single prop/basic plane, it’s amazing how intuitive something you felt was rocket science becomes when you realize you have to fly it or crash.
@Chris-ok4zo
@Chris-ok4zo Рік тому
I can imagine those gamers into sim games thinking, "how much that flight sim setup cost?"
@FunnyGore
@FunnyGore Рік тому
Don't call me out like this
@deanfowlkes
@deanfowlkes Рік тому
Literally in the $millions.
@Pilsnor
@Pilsnor Рік тому
As a sim racer and aviation nerd, i would love to get the chance to crash in one of these beautifull machines, i used to play alot of flight sim as a kid
@deanfowlkes
@deanfowlkes Рік тому
@@Pilsnor - There are ways that you can do that. Expect to pay $200-500 an hour for that privilege.
@Pilsnor
@Pilsnor Рік тому
@@deanfowlkes that does actualy not sound too bad to be honest 😅
@Crawzitow
@Crawzitow Рік тому
“An expert is a person who has made all the mistakes that can be made in a very narrow field.” Niels Bohr I love this quote, i always put it in the end of all my classes. Both from the angle of how important mistakes and exposure/experience is to building knowledge and also to dispel the myth that the best professional never had a mistake or is beyond failing. I think a lot of what has been learned had huge prices, how many first aviators died? But being able to learn from their mistakes without paying the same price is what makes the right education a miracle. Forming pilots, surgeons, nuclear physicists without deaths is a miracle.
@zodiacdriver3852
@zodiacdriver3852 5 місяців тому
Simple rule: Beginners make beginner's mistakes, experts make expert's mistakes!
@PAVANZYL
@PAVANZYL 3 місяці тому
According the Bohr, I would be an expert at marriage!
@bobkoroua
@bobkoroua 3 місяці тому
I was considered an expert by others in my industry and was asked to train new staff. It used to make me angry as hell. So many things that I was never taught but had to learn by trial and error and they would have me train others.
@ryanquinn1257
@ryanquinn1257 3 місяці тому
Another quote I like along these lines is an amateur practices until they get it right and professionals practice until they can’t get it wrong.
@BrettMoore66
@BrettMoore66 4 місяці тому
Back in my twenties I discovered the paradox of "The more you know, the more you realize you do not know". I love learning new things and whilst UKposts is good to show you what might be possible, nothing replaces research, trial and error ie 'practice makes perfect'. I watch a lot of 'Air Crash Investigation' so I have a realistic approach to whether I could fly a large plane. Id be screwed and everyone would probably die hahaha.
@SacksOfWine
@SacksOfWine 3 місяці тому
What a great video. I just wanted to add to your median driver comment. I think that is mainly because people only ever remember the bad drivers on the road. They don't remember any of the good times.
@zacharytaylor190
@zacharytaylor190 Рік тому
This guy, a non pilot, just executed a hand-flown ILS to minimums, and he managed to get to the runway. That's kind of impressive ngl.
@Alex-Livingston
@Alex-Livingston Рік тому
Wouldn't call it on the glideslope per se but still impressive lol
@Boostiverse
@Boostiverse Рік тому
I get what you mean but it’s not impressive because he just showed anyone can do it
@baadlyrics8705
@baadlyrics8705 Рік тому
@@Boostiverse no, defintely not anyone.. Put someone in that seat with NO knowledge of planes at all and look how it goes
@mikoto7693
@mikoto7693 Рік тому
@@baadlyrics8705 Agreed. A flight simmer does know more than someone who knows nothing about aviation, but I never for a moment thought that one of us could fly and land a 737 without ripping the plane apart and killing everyone or very nearly everyone aboard. Full autopilot ILS landing, sure but not manually.
@thesupreme8062
@thesupreme8062 Рік тому
@@mikoto7693 that's a gross exaggeration.
@izabellahortega2971
@izabellahortega2971 Рік тому
Currently at an Aviation camp where I get to fly planes, with an instructor of course, this video can not have been posted at a more perfect time!🤣
@Emerald_Forge
@Emerald_Forge Рік тому
Good luck with your training
@LuinTathren
@LuinTathren Рік тому
Good luck!
@tiffanysandmeier4753
@tiffanysandmeier4753 Рік тому
I went to one when I was in high school. The flight part was so fun. I was too nervous to land. I will never forget that flight. Also it was a hot day and when we were taxiing out and a tar patch stuck to one of the tires.
@roarrman
@roarrman Рік тому
Any reccomendations??? I want my PPL for the fun of flighting
@xbrandi12345x
@xbrandi12345x Рік тому
​@Don't Read My Profile Photo dude....why??? Too many people do this and it's totally pointless and more of an annoyance than anything. You aren't actually joining a conversation, you are interrupting one to basically say "look at me!" and what exactly do you gain from doing this?? You could do some really cool stuff with your UKposts but you chose to do this "don't read" stuff. Why?? What is the end result you are expecting from doing this??
@adiakiyes6354
@adiakiyes6354 5 місяців тому
The Dunning-kruger effect may also apply in health care facilities. As a radiographer working in CT-MRI department is very tough job your dealing with machines and patients. Some procedures are complicated like Ct-mri guided biopsy, angiography or all examinations applying IV contrast.
@ReadABookAndLearn
@ReadABookAndLearn Місяць тому
In regards to the statistics about partially experienced pilots being more deadly than new pilots…I’ve been a carpenter for 25 years now and when I was just starting out the guy I worked for made a comment about how this same phenomenon manifests itself in my profession. After I had been framing houses for about six months I was feeling like I finally understood how (when I started I was completely inexperienced with building things or even using tools) a house is built, and my confidence led me to take on a side job building a deck for my cousin. When I told my boss he replied, “Keep in mind you know just enough to be dangerous.” What he was saying was that I think I can build a house on my own, but there’s still so much I have to learn that if I do attempt it on my own I will likely make mistakes that I’m not even aware of, and could build something that isn’t structurally sound, which could be very dangerous to the homeowner if a structural failure occurred. Now, 25 years later as a very experienced contractor I realize how little I knew, but how confident I was in my abilities.
@KoshPilot
@KoshPilot Місяць тому
The killing zone typically happens between 50-300 hours of flight time.
@lajya01
@lajya01 Рік тому
This "killing zone" curve is exactly the same as for motorcycles.
@o0alessandro0o
@o0alessandro0o Рік тому
And probably the same for everything else that has a "kill zone", I'll bet. Familiarity breeds contempt - until it's bred out of you by ohgodohgodwe'reallgonnadie. Still, I am convinced that people who need to acquire a domain skill on a routine basis (e.g., software developers) have a slightly higher tolerance to the DK effect - by pattern recognition if nothing else. That is to say: by the fifth or seven time that you went "how hard can this be?" and then followed up with "oh god this is hard", if you are tempted to go "how hard can this be?" again you will probably get that feeling of foreboding that goes "oh wait, I've seen this movie, I think I know how it ends". Spoiler warning: it never ends well. The usual result is that, instead of underestimating te required effort by two orders of magnitude, you might only underestimate by one. Ain't that great? Insert AI joke here.
@damianbigelow9511
@damianbigelow9511 Рік тому
@@o0alessandro0o Somthing that takes skill to keep you alive needs to respected at All times. Ego = Accidents . In most cases that iv observed at least.
@o0alessandro0o
@o0alessandro0o Рік тому
@@damianbigelow9511 That's... True, objectively speaking. I'm not sure it's entirely germane to my original point, however.
@damianbigelow9511
@damianbigelow9511 Рік тому
@@o0alessandro0o no not at all realy but I agree with you. Iv seen this myself when I 1st acquire my motorcycle license. The people that came with no experience are all still alive that I know of. But out of the 5 people that came in with "claimed experience" 2 of them were killed the 1st year on the rd legally and 1 a couple years later. All 3 at excessive speeds on a road that couldn't possibly support high speeds. Their egos litraly killed them..
@Angel9932
@Angel9932 Рік тому
As someone who just recently completed the motorcycle training course, acquired my license and began riding, I remind myself of this before every ride to bring me back to reality so I try not to exceed my current skills.
@adrianjones8073
@adrianjones8073 Рік тому
As a pilot, it is quite flattering to hear that you are so fascinated with our work. In the same way, I am fascinated with scientific topics in which you are the professional, haha. Landing is typically the most delicate and often stressful part of flying, and you actually did better than I was expecting. Great video!
@brucesmith5426
@brucesmith5426 4 місяці тому
Landing is definitely the most stressful. Esp. if the ILS system is down or the airfield doesn't have one. Take off is not much of an issue and once in the air at altitude there's not much to be worried about.
@haltux
@haltux 3 місяці тому
@@brucesmith5426 Interestingly in a glider it is the opposite. Landing is less stressfull than taking off. There are way more things that can go wrong at landing than at taking off.
@brucesmith5426
@brucesmith5426 3 місяці тому
@@haltux I couldn't tell you about a glider. In a true glider you could be correct.It could be as most don't have any type of thrust involved for T/O. But any landing is just a controlled crash.
@infinity_sh4816
@infinity_sh4816 3 місяці тому
a
@daleburnfart6845
@daleburnfart6845 3 місяці тому
You know what is scary? You dont recognize how valuable your knowledge and ability is and you need others to remind you. This is not a grey hound bus even though because of the can of tuna with wings feeling ppl get from the cramped seating. For reference look at how much a bus driver makes compared to a pilot and if you still cant figure out your value after that you should probably stop piloting especially with passengers. You want to have a pity party and fly into a mountain, do it alone please, thanks.
@hypercomms2001
@hypercomms2001 6 місяців тому
I actually landed an airbus A320 at Cairns Airport QLD, with Zippo experience... while flying the Ansett Flight Simulator near Tullamarine Airport in 1989 on a Saturday morning as I got to know the senior engineer there... It was fun... But as an avionics engineer, I know a fair bit about aircraft.... Of course there is a big difference knowing that I am sitting in a simulator, then actually sitting in the cockpit of an aeroplane with to disable pilots....
@cynicalrabbit915
@cynicalrabbit915 6 місяців тому
Decades ago I got to take a ride in a Cessna 150 with a student who was in an aviation school. He showed me all the pertinent controls and the artificial horizon, then let me take control. Keeping the plane level was a major task. If you start climbing the plane starts losing power as the throttle was set for level flight, not climbing to a higher altitude. Simce then I've "flown" using Microsoft flight simulator. More times than I count I either crashed or accidentally landed the plane in a field and was taxing around. I did eventually get ahold of a generic flight manual and could accurately calculate a flight path when the wind would be trying push me off course. The only way I'd ever volunteer to go play pilot would be if everyone else passed up the opportunity. I am under no illusion that I could confidently and safely land a commercial aircraft,
@Gamayun.
@Gamayun. Рік тому
Even worse, the simulation is an ideal scenario. Clear skies, good weather, no turbulence, no other planes, no worries about if you can land and where, no screaming passengers, along with the fact that you know it isn’t real so you aren’t as freaked out and stressed as you would be.
@gildedbear5355
@gildedbear5355 Рік тому
Well, you don't have to worry too much about other planes. ATC would be vectoring the other planes away from the emergency landing that you're making, because you're going to crash and there will be a fire.
@ProphetC2
@ProphetC2 Рік тому
The only accurate part is "no streaming passengers". Everything else has been in MS FS since at least 2004.
@gnarthdarkanen7464
@gnarthdarkanen7464 Рік тому
Yeah, in an actual crisis, Gilded Bear is correct. The MOMENT you've announced the in air emergency, even while ATC is telling you how to switch the transponder to emergency frequency, other controllers are clearing the sky as far and wide as they can possibly make it for you... You'll pretty much have the whole of the airspace to yourself.
@BohdanMelnychuk
@BohdanMelnychuk Рік тому
Hm, wasn't he in IMC in the last attempt?
@chanceslaughter3237
@chanceslaughter3237 Рік тому
you remind me of my dad every time I think I accomplished something
@happylight1015
@happylight1015 Рік тому
I'm a pilot myself .First of all great content . For some clarification . Being a pilot isn't about just handling the controls , it's about doing and knowing much more things . Some of which are knowing how the weather behaves , emergency procedures , laws in the air ,aircrafts systems etc...besides the landing techniques differ between weather conditions . Watching many documenteries about the human body for fun does not give anyone 1 percent of the knowledge of a real doctor . Again great content , keep it up !
@MrCoffis
@MrCoffis Рік тому
To say it more simply, as a pilot you need to be a manager and have a vast amount of knowledge and skills that you can instantly recall to make the right decisions that will bring the aircraft safely back to the ground.
@happylight1015
@happylight1015 Рік тому
@@MrCoffis Nicely briefed .
@kellydalstok8900
@kellydalstok8900 Рік тому
Have you heard of the space comma? It’s usually not a sign of competence in any field. (Spoiler: the right way to write it would be comma space)
@happylight1015
@happylight1015 Рік тому
@@kellydalstok8900 Thanks for the info and I'll make sure to remember that before my next flight. Maybe knowimg that can help me develop my skills in training.
@allamasadi7970
@allamasadi7970 Рік тому
@@MrCoffis flying safely is also about gaining sufficient experience of what certain g forces feel like on the body and being aware of optical and other physiological illusions
@Lovelessh3art
@Lovelessh3art 3 місяці тому
Nincompoopery is a word I didn't know I needed to hear. What a wonderful word
@dingdingdingdiiiiing
@dingdingdingdiiiiing 3 місяці тому
There's a video of someone who was a passenger in a dual motor small airplane he sat next to the pilot and was curious about the plane enough to have asked a few questions, one of them was how the radio worked. Soon after takeoff, the pilot went unconscious. The passenger, decade or so ago, had 3 lessons in a single motor Cessna. He was able to call the tower and they scrambled to find a pilot familiar with that exact aircraft. It still took him several tries at the runway and the landing wasn't really smooth, but he made it. Mind you, small airplanes like that are considered easy, an airbus is something else entirely. A random person landing it per instruction alone would literally be a miracle. Knowing that, I still think that I, having zero flight experience, could land a small Cessna (and survive), but a passenger jet, no, most definitely no.
@michaelboyd856
@michaelboyd856 Рік тому
I remember when my dad got our first flight simulator. He had (short-lived) asperations of learning how to fly, so he bought some gear to make the practices more realistic. Like I said, he gave up pretty quickly, but I loved the simulator and played for years. The one frustration I had was that, unlike my dad, I couldn't seem to land any of the planes. I started to feel better when I met someone with the same problem-my uncle, a former air force pilot who's been flying 737s since I was an infant. He was a co-captain when he realized that he couldn't land planes on Microsoft Flight Simulator, so part of his job was literally to handle the landing of the plane he couldn't land in the simulator. That made me feel a little better lol
@jima1135
@jima1135 Рік тому
For some reason I read that as "who's been flying 737s since *HE* was an infant." 😂
@threemr01
@threemr01 Рік тому
I love that, essentially, at 2:52 Dunning is telling us most people who think they know what the D-K effect is, display themselves the effect: “[it’s] an*entire family* of effects, but the one that everybody knows is […]”. Touché, Dr. Dunning!
@ThePuertoRicanGirl57
@ThePuertoRicanGirl57 2 місяці тому
Seeing Nahant which was in one of the leading patterns to approaching the Boston Logan airport and seeing the tower where I fly into when I know im arriving home was very interesting while watching this. I literally saw my own neighborhood in this video about a plane flying overhead while hearing the actual real life planes flying overhead near my house.
@uptown3636
@uptown3636 Рік тому
The apprehension in Dr. Dunning's voice when he says "Uhhhh, interesting--don't tell Elon Musk" was priceless.
@FelipeKana1
@FelipeKana1 Рік тому
Wait, when was that?
@uptown3636
@uptown3636 Рік тому
@@FelipeKana1 18:45
@trapezeable
@trapezeable Рік тому
So What would Elon Musk do with that information?
@Markle2k
@Markle2k Рік тому
What was he talking about? Was he referring to his own ignorance about the knowledge of Musk’s knowledge? One of the benefits of a PhD is that you have to teach complete newbies in your field, and neophytes, and undergrads majoring in your field. PhDs can speak to and explain at many levels. It is an incidental part of the degree process. Musk has spent the better part of two decades understanding “rocket science” and has demonstrated the ability to explain what is going on to complete idiots.
@Muskar2
@Muskar2 Рік тому
I'm also curious what he was referring to, and have little clue. My best guess is that he's referring to the fact that Elon has defended the name "autopilot" in Tesla's cars for their ADAS as an imperfect system, and that Dr. Dunning has something to say about that since this autopilot apparently is pretty powerful/reliable, given some location information. But maybe it's related to Dragon/Starship landings? Or something else?
@Crawzitow
@Crawzitow Рік тому
In my field (surgery) we say that there are two “peaks” of mistakes in the practice, from the “young” surgeon (based on ignorance/inexperiece) and from the “older” surgeon (based on overconfidence). You gotta keep a very high degree of self confidence to cut people open, but its also very healthy to have a certain dose of fear/doubt to not cut your own fingers off 😂
@MarvinHartmann452
@MarvinHartmann452 4 місяці тому
Or forget an instrument in the patient.
@gayusschwulius8490
@gayusschwulius8490 3 місяці тому
As a lawyer who has a lot of cases revolving around medical malpractice (on both sides, so I sometimes represent the suing patient and sometimes defend the accused doctor/hospital), I can 100 % confirm this. The vast majority of cases we have are either surgeons who have less than 5 years or more than 30 years of experience.
@Migmaqiw
@Migmaqiw 3 місяці тому
“Hey what’s this thing?” *pokes with scalpel*
@Dev1nci
@Dev1nci 3 місяці тому
The best time to come to terms with the limit of your knowledge is when you need something repaired and the repair doesn’t go well. It can be difficult to know if the repair is especially complicated or if the specialist is to blame.
@user-gh1pj3tr5t
@user-gh1pj3tr5t 5 місяців тому
I think that I'm really good at knowing what I'm not good at and what I don't know. In fact, I think that for a long time I underestimated myself. It's not difficult to say "I don't have experience in this area...let me go do research or ask someone else", yet people act like it is. I am a therapist and I can't even begin to estimate the number of undergraduate counselors who have tried to compete with me on things that they have absolutely no training on. It's really not difficult to be self-aware enough to know what you don't know.
@7sevin7
@7sevin7 Рік тому
Because I've watched this video on the Dunning-Kruger effect, I'm 100% confident I know everything about it and I'm now a qualified expert on knowing what I don't know.
@mondoseguendo6113
@mondoseguendo6113 Рік тому
After reading your comment I’m quite confident in my ability to land a commercial airliner.
@SofaKingShit
@SofaKingShit 4 місяці тому
It's the Dumming-Kreuger effect you maroon.
@alexschmitz49
@alexschmitz49 Рік тому
I'll be quite honest, I was impressed with his ability to single pilot hand fly an ILS in IMC conditions in a 737. Bravo.
@kentslocum
@kentslocum 4 місяці тому
This video perfectly demonstrates the importance of Crew Renource Management and the priority structure of Aviate-Navigate-Communicate. The pilot flying needs to focus on keeping the aircraft in the air. The other pilot needs to focus on navigating, reading checklists, and communicating with air traffic control. It's pretty crazy to juggle all of those tasks by yourself, let alone without any real piloting experience.
@saelaird
@saelaird 3 місяці тому
The effect is super easy to understand, and I'm confident that I know all about it.
@stedwards311
@stedwards311 Рік тому
I have to object to "technically, I crashed" after the second landing. You may have damaged the plane and started a fire, but you were in the air, and now you're not, and you're still alive, and that means that you, sir, have just landed. It might not have been pretty, and it may *also* be accurate to say you crashed, but if I'm the proverbial passenger asked to land the plane, my take is simple: any landing that everyone walks away from is a good landing, period.
@kewakl8891
@kewakl8891 Рік тому
Flight attendant: "Does anybody know how to land this plane?" Me: "Once!"
@qwut9544
@qwut9544 6 місяців тому
One way or another, sooner or later, if I were seated at the yoke the plane would make contact with terrain or water.
@user-jq2rf4nf3o
@user-jq2rf4nf3o 6 місяців тому
That's all it takes,You're hired!
@realbarries
@realbarries 4 місяці тому
5:37 I hate whoever hung those paintings
@GabrielSBarbaraS
@GabrielSBarbaraS 3 місяці тому
Same problem here with simulator, during landing, taking off and flying was good, The landing mostly got me, usually from over shooting the runway. I was a maintenance person in a flight sim facility.
@Mic_Glow
@Mic_Glow Рік тому
The difference between watching someone do an unfamiliar task and doing it yourself is HUGE.
@nyeahgarner2420
@nyeahgarner2420 Рік тому
I'm just an ordinary guy. No special knowledge, no education beyond the basics, but, one talent I've always had. I've always been able to do ANYTHING I could watch someone else do. This realization isn't absolute in that, even though I have extensively proved this fact to myself over decades, I'm still hesitant to jump into something. My first job at fifteen, I learned in one hour how to cook/bake everything in the restaurant without fail. I've rebuilt cars just by watching someone else. I only call a service person due to time constraints, otherwise I fix everything in my house, cars, or electronics.
@BruceCarbonLakeriver
@BruceCarbonLakeriver Рік тому
@@nyeahgarner2420 same with me, then I went to engineering school and (except for the higher classes) I was bored like hell xD
@MrMockingbird1313
@MrMockingbird1313 6 місяців тому
Hey Joe, I am 67 years old. I have know several "geniuses". This includes two world famous inventers. What I discovered, in line with Dunning - Krueger, is that the most gifted often have a delusions that they are also experts in many unrelated fields. For example, if an inventor designs advanced military aircraft why would he also expect expertise in aircraft subassemblies? Also, chemistry, botany, handy capping race horses, global warming, and plate tectonics? I suggest the most gifted are also the worst offenders of Dunning -Krueger effect. This was a good video.
@Simon-bu4kc
@Simon-bu4kc 3 місяці тому
yes, that's observable even in daily life with friends/mates that are very skilled and trained in various fields of study or work. the big difference I feel however is the self-confidence and lack of ability to see own mistakes. someone who's smart and accomplished in any kind of topic often kind of understands what it takes to be an actual expert and while those kind of people might initally think they are in the right they are also very quick to realize their partner in discussion has way more experience and knowledge to offer and turn down their personal pride. the least knowledgeable proclaim the loudest is an important part of the dunning-kruger-theorem if I'm not mistaken. secondly at least for some I see this "false self-confidence" in smart people as kind of a defense mechanism against Dunning-Kruger effect because if you have to little confidence in your knowledge you will start to loose voice against someone with less reasoning in certain topics
@jjr1728
@jjr1728 3 місяці тому
What about labrador owners? Would us labrador owners be considered as superior by virtue of the fact that labs are the cutest dogs?
@BisexualPlagueDoctor
@BisexualPlagueDoctor 3 місяці тому
@@jjr1728the cutest dogs are the ones you own dammit, no dog is better than another (except for the dogs that are just straight evil because god damn some of them want nothing but mayhem and violence)
@jjr1728
@jjr1728 3 місяці тому
@@BisexualPlagueDoctor no. Labradors are the cutest.
@Mephilis78
@Mephilis78 3 місяці тому
Like Neil Tyson talking about things he has nothing to do with on Joe Rogan show. "We don't have flying cars because bridges exist"
@_r._7513
@_r._7513 3 місяці тому
There should be trainings that teach non-pilots how to activate the autopilot and automatic landing on planes, just like how we have CPR training. I know it would be much more expensive and more difficult to implement. In addition, some may say it would be unnecessary since a passenger at the cockpit would be guided via comms, but I believe training would make the process smoother as passengers who completed the training would likely get a sense of déjà vu from the training and remember what some of the controls look like. That could be very helpful in such a stressful situation where a person could easily panic and glance over the controls without knowing which ones they are being instructed to activate.
@boanerges5723
@boanerges5723 2 місяці тому
I got to play in a 747 sim once years ago and it was a little shocking to me how slow it was to respond to input. I also needed a great deal of assistance for the million switches, knobs, and buttons. I doubt i could have landed without any help.
@tzeneth
@tzeneth Рік тому
Oh god, I love that pilot. "We're all counting on you." If only he said it multiple times in the video. :P
@Scintillate9
@Scintillate9 Рік тому
I’m glad someone else caught it lol
@leandrog2785
@leandrog2785 Рік тому
He would never say that IRL though, this would be a very stupid thing to say, since it would put unnecessary stress on the non-pilot pilot.
@paulaneilson5110
@paulaneilson5110 Рік тому
All I could think about was Airplane - only other thing missing was the profuse sweating 😅
@KayBeeLPKarsten
@KayBeeLPKarsten Рік тому
@@SentientSingularity 17:56 This and the "we are all counting on you" made me so happy. Airplane is a classic. And the owe so familiar memes... 😂
@KayBeeLPKarsten
@KayBeeLPKarsten Рік тому
@@paulaneilson5110 And the autopilot did not inflate. Sad!
@TeslaMaster2
@TeslaMaster2 Рік тому
As the Darkest Dungeon narrator would say: "Remind yourself that overconfidence is a slow and insidious killer."
@Pakmann2k
@Pakmann2k 4 місяці тому
As an actual "private pilot" I used to work for an airline on the ramp and became friends with some sim techs, it cost me a lot of burritos at 3am to get some time in a 757, 737, and A320 Sims. I only had 100 hrs and probably a million on flight simulator. It was much harder than I imagined. I successfully landed the 737 and 757 several times in perfect conditions but never the bus, slippery plane and hard to slow it down without stressing it. That doesn't mean I could do anything other than straight up stick flying, radios are a whole other thing and an ILS approach, forget about it. Never gonna happen.
@robr177
@robr177 Місяць тому
Wayne Gretzky made me want to play hockey in the 80s. His slapshot hit the top corner blocker side every time. That's the Dunning-Kruger Effect. He made it look easy. When you see someone do something who makes it look easy, you don't know what they did to get where they are. You don't see how they are doing what they are doing. I played 5 years before I realised I'll never be that good.
@1981dAVIDE
@1981dAVIDE Рік тому
I believe I'm currently working for the Dunning Kruger company
@endermaninacup
@endermaninacup Рік тому
13 hours ago!?! My brain is malfunctioning
@bluethunder_
@bluethunder_ Рік тому
How in the world does this say this comment was posted 13 hours ago? The vid was posted like 5 minutes ago?
@Emerald_Forge
@Emerald_Forge Рік тому
@@bluethunder_ The video may have been unlisted then uploaded later
@imethanOW
@imethanOW Рік тому
@@bluethunder_ guys guys… they might be a supporter of the channel or something stop freaking out
@besmart
@besmart Рік тому
Hint hint Patreon
@DomyTheMad420
@DomyTheMad420 Рік тому
when i was a young kid at some random sports & 'remote control crafts' store at some random place with my random uncle i once stumbled upon a legit simuator setup for flight sims. i spent the next hour trying to just bloody land. my uncle wanted to leave after an hour but APPERANTLY he was so amazed i was silent and focussed that he let me be. took me over 2 hours of repeated attempts to finally make it to 3 safe landings in a row. Ever since i've never ever believed i could land a real jet (without serious) training.
@rexkwondo21
@rexkwondo21 Місяць тому
I watch lots and lots of videos on aviation. This video of yours is very humbling 😂
@chasedusina
@chasedusina 4 місяці тому
First try you crushed the gear? I feel like you confirmed Dunning-Kruger Effect. I think in a situation in which a random person is relied upon to do a landing this would merit an amazing achievement saving the lives of many.
@Captain-Cosmo
@Captain-Cosmo Рік тому
My wife was a flight attendant. We traveled a lot, and it was a running joke that maybe THIS would finally be the flight where I might be needed to be the emergency volunteer (with no flight training) to land the plane safely. Of course, this is really the stuff of movies, like Airport 75 and Airplane. But it's an effective way to illustrate DK. Thanks!
@crispy9175
@crispy9175 Рік тому
It's happened quite a lot in real life though. Just recently down in Miami a passenger had to land when the pilot had a heart attack and I'm pretty sure she didn't have any experience.
@CramcrumBrewbringer
@CramcrumBrewbringer Рік тому
Odds are someone in the crowd actually is a pilot
@hellterminator
@hellterminator Рік тому
@@crispy9175 On small planes. It can't happen on a big airliner since 9/11 because a passenger will not get into the cockpit.
@crispy9175
@crispy9175 Рік тому
@@hellterminator that's assuming both pilots and all flight attendants are incapacitated at the same time. But yes, it's definitely not as likely to happen on a big commercial jet.
@RobBCactive
@RobBCactive Рік тому
I've flown solo, but I know just looking at the bank of instruments in an air liner that I'd be lost.
@caseymichel1113
@caseymichel1113 Рік тому
I’m a pilot and can assure everyone out there than almost no one would be able to land a 737 without some kind of training lol. With that being said it wouldn’t take much training to be able to land a 737. A person with a private pilots license and a atc in their ear could put a 737 on the ground safely.
@TheErilaz
@TheErilaz Рік тому
How many hours do you think is necessary to perform a safe landing aka a landing that everyone can walk away from?
@waynebimmel6784
@waynebimmel6784 Рік тому
Do you think some flight simulator experience would enable one to bring the plane down without killing everyone? I am having an argument with my brother. Only requirement is that there are survivors.
@schwig44
@schwig44 Рік тому
@@TheErilaz They already implied the answer, 40, that's what it takes to get a PPL
@planettobi
@planettobi Рік тому
@@schwig44 maybe even less, you do solo landings at 10-20 hours so with some luck you'd be able to land the 737 with help
@calebsmith1548
@calebsmith1548 Рік тому
@@waynebimmel6784 His first landing "started a major fire." It is entirely possible to evacuate the airplane during a major fire, so there would be some survivors, you just wouldn't have everyone survive
@light-master
@light-master 2 місяці тому
Would have loved to have seen this with you flying one of those motion controlled simulators that let you feel all the bumps and jarring that would happen on touchdown.
@christopherm-84
@christopherm-84 4 місяці тому
I've also played a lot of flight simulator and have also fallen into that trap. This video opened my eyes and brain😂 I knew a guy who also had lots of online sim flying experience and when his friend offered him a trip in his real cessna and asked if my friend wants to try he obviously said yes but once he touched the yoke and the plane shifted a little he said nah ah it's alright, you fly rather😮😂
@Finkelfunk
@Finkelfunk Рік тому
This effect was pretty obvious to me when I switched operating systems from Windows to Linux. Now I had watched a fair share of videos about all sorts of different things and how to set stuff up, but when I had the first issues I was completely at a loss for a solution in that moment. Some things took a lot more time and getting familiar with before I was able to actually execute them well, things like customization options which I thought were super easy turned out to be FAR above my skill level yet. But through pushing across that hill I now slowly start to actually be able to understand what I actually can and cannot do with my system. This was a very nice demonstration for me on how I vastly overestimated my skill set, especially since I always considered myself to be a bit of a tech-savy.
@eroraf8637
@eroraf8637 Рік тому
Google is your friend. Literally 80% of my ability to code and troubleshoot boils down to being good at finding info on forums.
@HesderOleh
@HesderOleh Рік тому
I use Linux without a GUI for my job and for research. But I know that I can mess things up that would take so long to repair that I keep my data separate from the OS/docker, load the data that I want to the OS file system, manipulate it there, and then manually backup data after analysis. That way I can't accidently corrupt my data, and when things go wrong I just use a new image/docker/fresh install. I want to eventually use linux with a GUI as my day to day OS, but I remember how lost and overwhelmed I get when certain tools I need have compatibility issues, and how many different ways there are of setting different settings, that I know that I eventually would be able to get over major hills. In this case, even after you become an expert, a lot of it will actually seem quite simple, and you will wonder why you felt so intimidated before, because it wasn't really that it was hard, it was just unfamiliar.
@guisampaio2008
@guisampaio2008 Рік тому
Well i did a ton of stuff right away when i got it
@palmberry5576
@palmberry5576 Рік тому
@@eroraf8637 yeah, especially since a lot of platforms / frameworks seem to not understand the importance of having docs other than very terrible docs made directly from their javadocs annotations
@Perseagatuna
@Perseagatuna Рік тому
just knowing about linux apart from "haha penguin OS" is probably enough to consider yourself at least more tech-savvy than the average
@sir_dragonfly7287
@sir_dragonfly7287 Рік тому
I used to watch videos like that and in depth explanations of how all the systems of an aircraft work. Eventually, I started taking flight lessons and flying real planes, and I realized that, while those videos helped me a lot, there is a huge difference between learning about flying a plane and actually doing it.
@helenmurphree3434
@helenmurphree3434 Рік тому
Exactly what I thought about learning to drive using the simulator vs actually driving on the road
@adammcveigh
@adammcveigh 4 місяці тому
As a flight instructor, this is one of the things I need to make sure people are well aware of on day one - ESPECIALLY those people who have flight sim experience. Flight sim is great for learning the techniques and procedures to programme an aircraft but does not do anything to teach you how to 'fly'. Another thing I've learnt over the past 10 years flying is that each time I complete a new rating/licence (CPL, multi, instrument rating, flight instructor) I gain a lot of understanding of what I previously didn't know and scarily, how close I've perhaps come to ending up in a dangerous situation without even realising it - this is why the Dunning-Kruger effect is so important for NEW pilots to know about. The cockiest, 'know-it-all' pilots that I see everyday are the fresh PPL's whilst the most cautious and safe pilots are the guys with thousands of hours who fly a wide variety of aircraft, not just airliners. The saying really is true - "There are old pilots, there are bold pilots, but there are no old-bold pilots". If I can give any new pilots a few pointers: 1 - Use flight simulator to practice what you learn in flight school, but don't think you know anything just because you've done it before in flight simulator. 2 - Knowledge is key. The more you can learn about principles of flight, meteorology, aircraft general knowledge - the bigger your bank of knowledge to fall back on is when crap hits the fan. 3 - Learn from others. People make mistakes. Learn from those mistakes so you don't have to. 4 - Stay well within the envelope. Until you have the experience having sat with someone who knows the envelope and can show you, don't venture to the edge of the flight envelope on your own because things like spins and load factor do things to the aircraft that are very counterintuitive and the recovery from undesirable states can be complicated for each aircraft and may vary for each type. Believe me, spinning an aircraft is fun until you don't mean to spin it. 5 - Allow the process to happen through time. As I said, each time I achieved a new rating, I learned so much about what I didn't know. That's kind of what the guy in the video is saying what makes an 'expert pilot'. You can't fake your way to knowing more stuff. It just comes with time, practice, hours in the air, reading the books. Enjoy the process, be aware of your ignorance and be prepared to learn and do that learning in a safe environment surrounded by people who have been there and done it.
@jjr1728
@jjr1728 3 місяці тому
Should labradors be required for aircraft over say 8 passenger capacity? You know like a mascot like how dalmatian doggos are for firemen? Pilots should have labradors. Alcohol and at least one lab in the cockpit
@vahnn0
@vahnn0 3 місяці тому
I've never flown a plane or learned to fly one (besides flying FA-18s a Jane's sim when I was like 15), and I flew a and landed a single engine prop plane with, while handling ALL the controls. There was even a strong crosswind. Pilot told me to roll the wing down into the wind. VERY different plane, and very different situation, but still. He said I practically aced the landing.
@PainflyErect
@PainflyErect Рік тому
I'm an aerospace structural analysis engineer with over 10 years of experience. I think I gained a lot of confidence when I realized there is no way in hell I know everything, ask dumb questions (even when I feel like I'm expected to know it), and have other people look at my work.
@penunyabiz
@penunyabiz Рік тому
i saw tons of the dunning-kreuger effect in art school lol its amazing to me to see how confident an artist can get with a few successful projects under their belt. I, myself might be smack dab in the middle of this effect but being self aware about your abilities can definitely help you check your ego.
@omniyambot9876
@omniyambot9876 Рік тому
I do electronics since 4 and I'm always confident I could make a particular circuit irl from my head. But everytime I try I feel absolutely the most idiot person in this planet.
@happysmash27
@happysmash27 Рік тому
I wish there was a way to get more good feedback on my 3D art. Although I've learned a lot and can do pretty well in some areas, there is still so SO much I do not know especially in fundamentals like anatomy that I really really would like to learn more of, but I usually do not get much good feedback at all when I ask online.
@What_was_wrong_w_jst_our_names
@What_was_wrong_w_jst_our_names Рік тому
Well we’ve seen what happens when we turn away some people from art school
@roygb
@roygb Рік тому
@@What_was_wrong_w_jst_our_names based
@ptok-4.684
@ptok-4.684 5 місяців тому
20 years ago or so, I was obsessed with microsoft combat flight simulator - my mom & stepdad & I were down in Kitty Hawk, and we decided to visit the Wright Bros. Memorial and go up in a Cessna puddle jumper. My stepdad told me to sit up front with the pilot so I could land if something happened to him. It was a good, uneventful flight, and when we came around and lined up with the runway, the pilot looked at me and said " you wanna' land ? " & I said " sure, I'll give it a shot ! " He just shrugged his shoulders, chuckled a bit, and did not let go of the controls....
@MrKoblepot
@MrKoblepot 4 місяці тому
Motorcycle rider here, noticed the same pattern about hours and confidence. Noob are taking care, experienced pilots too, but just when you start to develop some skills and abilities as a fresh rider you're exposing yourself to shtf. Saw multiple cases like this.
@squidwardfromua
@squidwardfromua Рік тому
As a person who have played racing games a bit and now learning to drive in real life on mechanics, I felt the power of Dunning-Kruger effect
@stryker1797
@stryker1797 6 місяців тому
Depending on how you've played them, the gap between your knowledge and reality may vary a lot. Also depends on what you mean by learning to drive. Is it common driving like getting your driver's licence, or are you talking about race-driving?
@donnycorn3086
@donnycorn3086 3 місяці тому
​@@stryker1797and in addition, what game, and the experience and lesson from playing the game, since Mario Kart is also called a racing game alongside games like Forza, Need For Speed, GRID and such. I'd prefer not talk about Forza Horizon.
@Eowar
@Eowar Рік тому
"There are known knowns; there are things we know we know. We also know there are known unknowns; that is to say we know there are some things we do not know. But there are also unknown unknowns-the ones we don't know we don't know." - Donald Rumsfeld unintentionally summarizing the Dunning-Kruger effect.
@leandrog2785
@leandrog2785 Рік тому
There are also unknown knowns, which are things you take for granted and never think about, so you don't know you know.
@Eowar
@Eowar Рік тому
An unknown known sounds like Socrates/Plato's idea of 'anamnesis': that we have innate knowledge that we're unaware of and learning involves uncovering what we knew all along.
@johnnymentero6313
@johnnymentero6313 3 місяці тому
I practiced taking off and landing for hundreds and hundreds of hours precisely for that reason. "In case one day it may be needed" Only problem, the simulator I found was a fighter jet. But I think with the proper guidance I should be able to land a plane safely. Although I always thought if that situation ever comes about, I first would like to ask if it'd be possible to do a test run at about 3, 4, maybe 5000 feet first. OR... to follow all steps till right before touch down, take off from there, take note of any corrections of anything I missed, then turn around and do the actual landing.
@TheRetroGamers
@TheRetroGamers 3 місяці тому
Been using that thought for most of my life. You don't know what you dont know till you find out how little you do know.
@Brian-bp5pe
@Brian-bp5pe Рік тому
Old saying among pilots: In an emergency, any landing you can walk away from is a good landing. Speaking to overconfidence: it is amazing how many people with a driver's license think they are good drivers.
@SlimThrull
@SlimThrull Рік тому
"Is there anyone here who knows how to land a plane?!" Raises hand "You do??" "I mean... I've played flight sims before." "Sir, please put your hand down." "okay."
@GewelReal
@GewelReal Рік тому
simmer > person that really doesn't know what to do
@Sovek86
@Sovek86 Рік тому
Ehhh, you'd be surprised just how in depth some of us go and how much we know. In fact someone with 500 hours of time flying their fake 737 would have a far better chance at landing than the 150 hour C152 pilot. I've seen videos where they do this kind of comparison and you can tell the 152 pilot is in WAY over his head and he knows it.
@baadlyrics8705
@baadlyrics8705 Рік тому
@@Sovek86 true, id like to see this video with someone actually deep into a sim 747. I bet hed pull it off very well
@duitk
@duitk Рік тому
Someone with sim experience would be much better than someone with 0 idea of how to fly an aircraft. However I think the flight attendants could do a better job than 99 percent of people so unless you are a pilot or at least an aerospace engineer, you should keep your hand down unless you are literally the only person still physically able to try.
@duitk
@duitk Рік тому
@Joseph flight attendants receive emergency training and the know the procedures to follow when the pilots are incapacitated, they should in theory remain calm in case of an emergency which is very important. If my memory serves me correctly they have assisted pilots in certain emergencies of a similar nature before, let me go dig that up.
@aaronkaw4857
@aaronkaw4857 3 місяці тому
My favourite instance of the Dunning-Kruger Effect is itself: its generally portrayed message is different to the original Dunning-Kruger paper: people are closer to the average than they think, speaking of self-assessed underperformers *and* overperformers.
@Lampe2020
@Lampe2020 6 місяців тому
With all of the automation in modern airplanes and a little help from ground control I could probably get such a plane relatively safely to the ground, at least when the runway is pretty long and I have enough fuel to go around and try again a few times. But I've never put that knowledge to the test and that probably better stays that way XD
@sayanchakraborty2619
@sayanchakraborty2619 Рік тому
“Knowing how much you don't know gives life a purpose.” Great quote, Joe 👍🏻
I'm not a pilot. Can I land a 737?
26:22
Tom Scott plus
Переглядів 3,5 млн
Something Strange Happens When You Follow Einstein's Math
37:03
Veritasium
Переглядів 4,9 млн
Повістки у Києві: «Яке право вони мають забирати всіх мужиків?» #війна #мобілізація #військові
00:41
Слідство.Інфо | Розслідування, репортажі, викриття
Переглядів 1,4 млн
Unforgivable!! The Tragic tale of Air Algérie Flight 6289
25:23
Mentour Pilot
Переглядів 3,1 млн
Could This Change Air Travel Forever?
14:08
Mustard
Переглядів 7 млн
The Better Boarding Method Airlines Won't Use
8:28
CGP Grey
Переглядів 25 млн
Challenge Accepted! Can Tom Scott Land a B737 By Himself?!
40:40
Mentour Pilot
Переглядів 1 млн
We should use this amazing mechanism that's inside a grasshopper leg
19:19
The Most Misunderstood Concept in Physics
27:15
Veritasium
Переглядів 13 млн
How the Berlin Wall Worked
12:12
neo
Переглядів 2,7 млн
DEADLY Attitude! The Truly Shocking story of Pakistan Airlines 8303
54:24