What Is The Government Doing About HDB PRICES??! Ft Minister Indranee Rajah

What Is The Government Doing About HDB PRICES??! Ft Minister Indranee Rajah | TDK Podcast

День тому

Are million-dollar homes going to be the norm? Why do we have to wait so long for a BTO? What happens to my HDB after 99 years?
In this episode, TDK sits down with Minister Indranee as she shares her insights on housing affordability and accessibility.
*This video was filmed before Budget 2023 announcements.
-
This episode is sponsored by the Ministry of National Development.
For more information, visit: www.hdb.gov.sg/residential/bu...
-
The Daily Ketchup Podcast is powered by Audio-Technica.
Get $10 off selected microphones from the AT20 series with ‘TDKAT10’ at sea.audio-technica.com
Get up to $30 off at Ergotune with promo code "22+TDK": ergotune.com/?ref=TDK
Get up to $45 off at EverDesk+ with promo code "22+TDK": everdeskplus.com/?ref=TDK
Subscribe for more content like this: bit.ly/dailyketchup
We're also on Spotify: bit.ly/dailyketchupSpot
If you have any stories to share, let us know here: forms.gle/XRRtnMG1w56M8yrFA
For business/sponsorship enquiries: singapore.sales@grvty.media
Work with us : grvty.media/careers
Be part of our projects : Stay tuned ;)
=====
Follow Us On Our Socials
• Facebook: / mosg.tv
• Instagram: / dailyketchup
• Website: mosg.tv
Cast:
• Johnathan Chua / johnathanchua
• Daniel Lim / danlim11
• Jonathan Paul / jonathanpaul.sxw
• Denise Oh / ohthedenise
Behind the Cam:
• Nashrul Merza
• Julian Chin
• Daren Khek
• Charlene Goh
• Amirul Nashtrie
Edited by:
Carmen Chuang

КОМЕНТАРІ: 79

@TheDailyKetchupPodcast Рік тому

Which Minister do you wanna see next on our podcast? What should we talk about? Let us know below! 👇

@150Maweek Рік тому

Yes! Have minister Indranee again to talk about parenthood and child bearing policies👍🏼

@gparamaeswary7276 Рік тому

😂

@Jinnlongg Рік тому

TDK really up their game, inviting ministers onto their podcast. It’s very nice to see a change of pace, such a chill and casual way ministers portray themselves in a serious mannerism in the House and in a podcast setting like as though you’re talking to them like friends. You don’t usually see them like this. Very refreshing. Maybe invite Pritam Singh as the next guest?

@BluuKiss Рік тому

Good time to have a discussion about people's decision to have children or to be childfree!

@colorsangell7789 Рік тому

Love these interviews with ministers!

@et803 Рік тому

Sponsored podcast. Questions are probably prepared beforehand but who knows?

@andrewrollout1657 Рік тому

@@et803 They also interview Oppo (eg Jamus) so as long as they let him prepare beforehand, it’s fair to both sides.

@lllengl.9660 Рік тому

Agree with Dan that people may be too picky. But then again, shouldn't the buyer be picky as the house can cost up to half a million or more?

@felixisaac Рік тому

As well as that they will be living there (presumably) for the rest of their lives. Though I see where Dan is coming from. If you want to have a "cheaper" alternative, you have to adjust your expectations.

@tilarmeister Рік тому

Power sia these interviews! So happy this channel can connect people and ministers together!

@coach.jaytee Рік тому

Love these longer form interviews with ministers!

@zenweaver Рік тому

Get Leon Perera next please

@manyue2003 Рік тому

Why is land cost calculated into HDB prices in the first place ? The land is owned by govt not the buyer.

@jojotan98 Рік тому

I wanna listen to more ministers podcast!!! ❤️ thank you minister Indranee 🤩

@khorpeggy Рік тому

The parenthood provisional housing scheme (pphs) mentioned is only provided to couples with monthly household income less than 7k, this actually excludes quite a fair bit of middle income couples.. still don't think it solves the renting problem

@MsCorydorus Рік тому

thank you Minister. Excellent interviewers.

@jackywong4806 Рік тому

It’s hilarious when minister comment if the “liability” refers to what. Nice podcast

@HCL882 9 місяців тому

Shes so nice outside the house and thank you for reminding us the heart of our founding fathers

@nilnil8072 Рік тому

I would ask that the ministry to look into property developers that purchase freehold land from buyers and sell it as 99 year lease. I believe this will disadvantage both the new buyer and the state. Far East was the first to do so. I would also recommend anyone who purchase private 99 property, on who owns the land.

@angiemf9033 Рік тому

Wow wish I was at MI’s constituency. She was present till way past midnight to meet the residents. Many years ago, I waited till past 11pm & was sent home without meeting the minister.

@wowokingxoxo Рік тому

The more new citizens we bring in , the more subsidies are given to them in a BTO, new citizens raid the reserves built up by old citizens. SInce BTOs are scarce, why allow new citizens to compete against old citizens who have served NS?

@Lo0pDotCom Рік тому

Any chance to cover to those who cannot afford to buy HDB but to Rent HDB… but seem the rental has keep rocket b4 Covid and now worst … Thanks

@CapDingo1975 Рік тому

Why not have public housing only buy and sell back to HDB rather than sell privately? This way HDB can ensure its not for profitability and control how much you get back when you upgrade.

@MorendraNodi Рік тому

even if the HDB were to do that, all these Singaporeans complaining about high HDB resell price will complain about how they can no longer make massive profits or "upgrade" to Condos! Classic Singaporean thing, complain about it all. also practically speaking since Singapore is a free market economy, if HDB gets the monopoly of all flats (where MOST singaporeans live), it would be a massive headache for the government to manage it. Also not to forget the longer process to find the suitable buyer vs seller for each transaction.

@nicrome Рік тому

22:40

@gparamaeswary7276 Рік тому

Hmm. I am 67yrs old. I was the only one among my friends who lived with my MIL when we bought an Hdb flat. The rest of them all bought their own matrimonial hdb flat.

@mcql7001 Рік тому

This interview is just great, entertaining and informative at the same time! 👍

@testor9 Рік тому

what is affordability? HDB Loan for half a life time?

@tanchormay6447 Рік тому

This is such a helpful video. ❤

@melarrow6202 Рік тому

Brilliant classics peaceful guitar

@DerrickNinon Рік тому

put a capped on resale pricing? if you buy 400k, the max you can sell is 150% 600k. or any extra profits from selling go back to the government. I believe this can control the misuse of hdb. only allowing investor to buy condo instead of ec and hdb.

@pathfinder1672 Рік тому

You are mixing up HDB buyers and investors. There is no misuse of HDB for genuine HDB buyers. If you own a 3 room HDB flat and you want to upgrade to 4 room HDB flat due to growing family needs, don't you want to sell at market price so that you can use the 'profit' to pay for your next HDB purchase and renovation cost? You said allow investors to only buy condo, care to elaborate how do you determine who are investors and not genuine HDB buyers?

@meklavier4664 Рік тому

implement a rule, those who buy a condo, must sell their hdb flat.

@LivanVellnight Рік тому

@@pathfinder1672 What's wrong with capping the amount on appreciation for resale pricing then? What's wrong if everyone makes the same amount of 'profit' to pay for their upgrade to a 4 room flat? Isn't public housing's aim to be affordable? Why should we be trying to make more 'profit'? Isn't that an investor mindset? Furthermore if you sell at market price, you're also upgrading to a 4 room flat at market price. So you're selling higher to buy higher. Who benefits from this? It only serves to hurt those who don't own a flat yet. Lastly like you said, how do we determine who are investors and not genuine HDB buyers? It's a difficult thing to do in the first place. And with the news report of BTO flats not being stayed in for years and then being sold in the open market after 5 years. Is this not evidence of the misuse of the current HDB system? In fact everyone plays the same game, all HDB buyers whether they like it or not have to think like investors because of the current system.

@mrtienphysics666 11 місяців тому

"We intend to keep the value of these homes up, it will never go down. Because it will be renewed, the surroundings will improve, and as Singapore prospers, GDP goes up, the value of homes will go up." Lee Kuan Yew 2013

@SubZero-qi9hk Рік тому

HDB Houses are more like an Investment rather than called HOME in this Century. With that Peak Prices for a Pigeonhole,not everybody can afford it. That is come of the reasons why Youngsters aren't tying knot and couples who can afford either they are childless by choice or having 1 or 2 child.

@SaiSai-sr6ox Рік тому

Then why dont the news also report of hdb that is being sold at low price so that the high price sale does not sent an alarm out.

@zhen86 7 місяців тому

minister confirm say it is affordable

@kingsufi6164 Рік тому

Actually..... the one concern is the rising cost of rental. Landlord can up price 50% of original rental price....... how eh?

@cleonchua3029 Рік тому

Great that these platforms are around to ask these questions. But would really would have really wanted to be asked as well was for singles. The HDB resale prices are really high if we want to stay near our parents.

@vhalia Рік тому

Enjoyed this episode and the explanation by Minister Indranee

@redwings1974 4 місяці тому

Curious as why install solar panels on top of hdb flats, yet the electric bills did not go down. Shouldn’t solar panels help reduce electric usage from the grid?

@cresmarc820 Рік тому

Jialat, flat so expensive. Pay so low. Tell me how

@Kenney1234 Рік тому

up ur skill

@donykoh Рік тому

Why not correcting yourself why pay so low?

@Jack-hy2ki Рік тому

Why not upgrade yourself and get Higher pay job? Btw flat is not expensive.

@NoMusicNoMeaningful Рік тому

minister will ask you to work more job work harder

@cashcash7669 Рік тому

time to do one with leong mun wai

@Jack-hy2ki Рік тому

Might as well just find any uncle at coffeeshop for interview. 🤣

@ahleong19 Рік тому

Will be quite hard to edit.

@nicrome Рік тому

“The gahlmern”

@levitiucs Рік тому

900k 😢 soooo expensive for a BTO

@LonganLee Рік тому

The people can speak up if they want. But most have accepted their fate. Many are afraid to speakup in sg democracy

@NookTommy Рік тому

Plus the quality of new btos now are horrible. Prices up, quality down

@limcaifeng8174 Рік тому

love the insights shared by minster Indranee! she seem really nice 🥰

@hendericklow5783 Рік тому

Nan Chiau!!! 🤣🤣🤣

@Ben-kh2rh Рік тому

Algoooo!

@manyue2003 Рік тому

I hope the daily ketchup will present the other side too, not only PAP.

@blankasterisk5030 Рік тому

Do you mean members from other political parties? They already have. Worker's Party Jamus Lim ukposts.info/have/v-deo/joGSpp-lhXqckYE.html SDP's Chee Soon Juan ukposts.info/have/v-deo/jnqjrqVppqF-1YU.html ukposts.info/have/v-deo/pXF5qntsnHqkrmQ.html

@ahleong19 Рік тому

Jamus came the last time too.

@kyonnarie968 Рік тому

Aigoooo

@LonganLee Рік тому

This Channel is great! It frequently invite many PAP ministers or MP to reach out to the masses. Hope the good work of this channel is Sponsored so that they have funds to continue their good work. I am a strong PAP fan. Hope thru this channel our youtha can be Influenced. We should tell more young people to support this channel so they can be influenced.

@providencez9496 Рік тому

Of course it is affordable. Problem with Singaporean is they always want big, good location near public transport, near amenities and high value location so they could resell if they wanted to. Another problem is their combine salary doesn't allow them to. Plus some might even already have a few child. Then obviously that's a poor planning on the buyer's side.

@c.rystalls Рік тому

They want big house, near mrt, good amenities, nice view. But only want to pay $300K 🤡

@TheMrlim1996 Рік тому

good to see a more candid side of the ministers regardless is it the incumbent or the opp

@desaturated6049 5 місяців тому

Tanjong Pagar GRC huat ah!

@beyondee Рік тому

hi Jared, ignore them, i think your joke quite funny

@h3llmag3 Рік тому

Those Jokes hahaha

@martinlee7102 Рік тому

NOTHING

@ishouldntbeonthisplatform_ Рік тому

Poor dan 19:35 -19:50

@benwong2061 Рік тому

Algoooooooooooooooooooo

@eightfoldsg Рік тому

So dear minister. Why singles always draw the short end of the stick. 35 year old eligibility is lol.

@meklavier4664 Рік тому

because the job of the government is to promote family first. have you not seen our rate has drop to 1.0

@kenwdesouza Рік тому

Short end ? so you deserve a Flat more than a married couple with kids? dont be entitled pls...

@eightfoldsg Рік тому

@@kenwdesouza Sure. Let's start by asking the married who do not have babies to cough out the grants and profits earned from their BTOs.. Family first makes sense, but don't punish singles to stay with their parents until 35.

@fr0sty1983 Рік тому

@@meklavier4664 If their job is to promote family first why 5 room bto prices is so high?