When Sgt. Harris Bagged 5 Panther Tanks with 5 Shots | 14 June 1944

  Переглядів 734,482

The Tank Museum

The Tank Museum

День тому

Bagging 5 Panther tanks with just 5 shots, Sgt Wilf Harris showed that the Sherman Firefly could take on the best the Germans had to offer - and that British tank crews were just as good as their German equivalents.
Set in Normandy in 1944, World War Two historian John Delaney presents a fascinating story from history that deserves to be better known.
If you enjoyed this video, please help us make more ► Support The Tank Museum:
► Patreon: / tankmuseum
► UKposts Membership: / @thetankmuseum
Find out more about the Sherman Firefly here
► • See Inside Sherman Fir...
And the Panther here
► • Tank Chats #16 Panther...
00:00 | Intro
00:52 | Preparing for Battle
02:00 | The Attack
06:50 | Counter Attack
12:04 | The Damage
This video features archive footage courtesy of British Pathé.
#tankmuseum #TankActions #Lingevres

КОМЕНТАРІ: 741
@thetankmuseum
@thetankmuseum 6 місяців тому
We hope you enjoyed the first episode of this new series - let us know your thoughts and what you'd like to see next!
@autistic_m4a3_76w_hvss
@autistic_m4a3_76w_hvss 6 місяців тому
In all fairness. I wanna see a Video on Creighton Abrams. I hear that he's was one of the Best Tank Commanders, but I don't hear anyone telling me why.
@KGmodels
@KGmodels 6 місяців тому
I would love to see a video on the Warsaw uprising and the Tanks used there for the Polish legacy.
@davidthomas5848
@davidthomas5848 6 місяців тому
Has to be the first tank on tank battle. I know a bit was done as part of the Mk4 vid
@zvexevz
@zvexevz 6 місяців тому
This is exactly the kind of content I'd love to see more of. Detailed descriptions of real tank battles, preferably informed by both personal accounts and the work of historians. In my opinion it is much more interesting than discussions of armour thickness and suspensions (not that those aren't important!).
@Blitz9H
@Blitz9H 6 місяців тому
Thank you! Very well done and I absolutely appreciate these war stories. Please continue this series. Any stories involving the A30 Challenger? Or perhaps some Korean War?
@andyhowson1589
@andyhowson1589 6 місяців тому
My grandfather was with the DLI during this action. He took over from the artillery observers when they were put out of action. He directed further artillery and organised the decimated infantry despite being wounded in the arm himself. He was awarded a DCM for his actions that day. Myself, my father and my son visited Lingeveres several years ago to see where this event unfolded. There’s a nice memorial to the DLI at the side of the church.
@americanbychoice4301
@americanbychoice4301 3 місяці тому
@250txc - your name is befitting; txc = toxic
@jacktattis
@jacktattis Місяць тому
@@250txc Why?
@moistmike4150
@moistmike4150 6 місяців тому
I had a Grampa in the 3rd Armored Division in WW2. He was a 19yr. old who trained as infantry, but ended up a replacement loader in a Sherman that had lost its previous two loaders in combat (he had black-and-white pictures of the welded-in "turret-hole-plugs" from which both prior loaders lost their lives). He ended his few months in combat during The Battle of The Bulge, when, while riding in what his battalion commander told them was a "Kraut Scrubbed Area" with his turret hatch open, his Sherman got hit by what he believes was a German 75mm AP round which touched off their tank's forward, right-side ammo rack. All he remembered was a loud "bang" and when he woke up, he remembered screaming in pain while his tank commander pressed freshly fallen snow into the burn wounds on his face and upper-body in an attempt to provide him some temporary relief. He later found out that he and his tank commander were both blown clear from his tank's turret after the initial hit, and shortly afterward the rest of the ammo in the tank brewed up and burned the rest of his crew to death. He had temporarily swapped positions with his gunner, and was fortuitously riding with his head out the gunner's hatch (which, in the event, doomed his gunner to a fiery death). As a child, I remember it taking a long while getting used to my Grampa's facial deformities due to his severe burn wounds. He never complained and neither did my Grandma, although my Mom would tell me in later years that as a child she remembered him waking up screaming in the middle of the night and manically saying he had to get his buddies out of his burning tank. What a horrific war. In my book, they're absolutely the Greatest Generation and through their sacrifices they undoubtedly saved the world.
@lonniemonroe2714
@lonniemonroe2714 5 місяців тому
Now look at what Democrats world wide have done. We on the edge of even greater destruction & ruin
@Craig52-zq1bt
@Craig52-zq1bt 4 місяці тому
God bless your Grandfather. My Grandfather served in WW2, my Father in Korea and me in Viet Nam. Your Grandfather is our Brother.
@Micha-wb9oz
@Micha-wb9oz 3 місяці тому
@@250txc Shut up
@chrismair8161
@chrismair8161 Місяць тому
From a Tyrant hell bent to change the world into his Idea on the bodies of the vanquished and the weak. America out produced the Germans but at what cost with a Tank that was not up to scratch with even a Panzer IV with a 75mm L36. With hope and a sturdy ride. Their only chance was in numbers against a Tiger I and II or the Panther with a long barrel 75mm! Finally the M26 with the 90mm showed up. The Panther tank Vs. an M26 in Cologne was filmed. That was a Gun Duel fitting the Combatants!
@DarioMelkuhn
@DarioMelkuhn 20 днів тому
Yes they did save the world, how they are turning in their graves now at the state of the world. It is hard to find any with the calibre that these lads had now days. WW2 in my personal opinion the only just war in many decades.
@JustSomeCanuck
@JustSomeCanuck 6 місяців тому
A Sherman Firefly of the 6th Canadian Armoured Regiment took out 5 Panthers with 6 shots on June 9, 1944. You know, just in case you think what's described in this video only happened once.
@JimbobTwentySeven
@JimbobTwentySeven 6 місяців тому
The Sherman Firefly seems quite good
@AWMJoeyjoejoe
@AWMJoeyjoejoe 6 місяців тому
​@@JimbobTwentySevenErgonomically not very good. Very cramped interior, but that gun was a beast!
@floriangeyer3454
@floriangeyer3454 6 місяців тому
17 pounders remained in service for decades. They knew why they kept them.
@chaptermasterpedrokantor1623
@chaptermasterpedrokantor1623 6 місяців тому
@@JimbobTwentySeven Not the best, as they suffered from all the problems that Shermans were known for, and the price of including a huge 17 pounder gun into the turret meant it was extremely cramped. But it is a prime example that it is better to have an okay solution to a problem right now, then wait for a perfect solution to maybe come tomorrow. It could take out the big German tanks, and that was precisely what was needed at the moment. But it did get a bit of a somewhat mythical status among the Brits and the armies that were equipped by them. The Americans tested a few and were not impressed, preferring their 76mm equipped version which morphed into the Easy Eight. The really fun part happened after the war, when the Israeli army got Shermans and progressively upgunned them. First with the French derivative of the Panther 75mm gun and later with a 105mm gun.
@0lionheart
@0lionheart 6 місяців тому
@@AWMJoeyjoejoe I still laugh at how the commander and gunner had to close their eyes when the main gun fired, to not essentially flashbang themselves. But it worked so well, they had to paint the ends of the barrels because the Germans would target Fireflies first
@stephenbrookes8681
@stephenbrookes8681 6 місяців тому
This highlights the advantage defenders have over attackers. Defending allows effective abmush positions to be set up, allowing significant damage to be inflicted before any return fire can be brought to bear. The german tanks were highly capable, but they did not have the overwhelming superiority that many claim. The German army simply spent most of the latter years operating a fighting retreat, thus allowing their armour to operate from prepared defensive locations.
@minuteman4199
@minuteman4199 6 місяців тому
You hit the nail on the head with this comment. This is exactly what the issue was.
@FieldMarshalFry
@FieldMarshalFry 6 місяців тому
Yeah, the tactic of "counterattack IMMEDIATELY" made them extremely predictable, giving Allied troops time to set up defensive and ambush positions, the same thing happened when Joe Ekins offed Michael Wittmann, they knew the counter attack was coming so set up a trap the Panzers rolled right into
@ragnarok1499
@ragnarok1499 6 місяців тому
Also a side note of (whatever the tank version of trigger discipline is 😂) when that one sherman was knocked out the panther followed up with several more hits and judging by the pictures into the exact same place, whereas the British crews hit and double tapped if they had to. Just kinda shows how panic potentially sets in after getting ambushed.
@chaptermasterpedrokantor1623
@chaptermasterpedrokantor1623 6 місяців тому
@@FieldMarshalFry The British army of 1944 had made the German tactic of the counterattack a cornerstone of its tactic. Advance using overwhelming artillery support and the creeping barrage, secure position, bring artillery forward, then give the counterattacking Germans a nice welcome with a hail of artillery. They're brutal WW1 style tactics, but they worked because of the stubborn German counterattack doctrine. And if the initial infantry attack was timed well with the creeping barrage it kept British casualties down. Sadly that was not always the cause. And understandable, it takes nerves of steel to stay close to incoming artillery fire.
@j.f.fisher5318
@j.f.fisher5318 6 місяців тому
except if you have an idiot like Michael Whitman go all leeroy jenkins on you an ruin the ambush.
@Alex-cw3rz
@Alex-cw3rz 6 місяців тому
9:11 what amazing courage draper possessed it's like something out of a movie, jumping back into a tank on fire and being fired at to save a comrade.
@Spectre-wd9dl
@Spectre-wd9dl 5 місяців тому
More than just a comrade. Never been in combat but I'd imagine a lot of those tank crews were closer than most families.
@Alex-cw3rz
@Alex-cw3rz 6 місяців тому
The maps are great it really helps to understand what is going on from a 2d environment
@stco2426
@stco2426 6 місяців тому
Yes, I agree. I would prefer the scale of the tanks to be a bit more regular though. It's hard to understand space and time when the tanks are so huge. Great addition, though.
@johnathanh2660
@johnathanh2660 5 місяців тому
Which then begs the question... For the crews, buttoned up, unaware what they're about to face. Having studied a map for a few minutes before hand. How disorientated would they have been?
@DanteTheAbyssalBeing
@DanteTheAbyssalBeing 6 місяців тому
Had my heart going listening to this. Incredible story.
@clanpsi
@clanpsi 6 місяців тому
I like how the gunner does all the work but gets pretty much none of the credit.
@tommckinley111
@tommckinley111 6 місяців тому
commander locates the targets, loader loads the gun, driver positions vehicle, its definitely teamwork for survival.
@paulbellingham3948
@paulbellingham3948 6 місяців тому
You will see in every contact, all branches, people doing the same things, top brass biggest gongs, privates smallest.British forces always been the same
@spudgunn8695
@spudgunn8695 6 місяців тому
​@@paulbellingham3948hence why British squaddies at the time referred to military award OBE's to officers as the "other buggers efforts" award!
@morstyrannis1951
@morstyrannis1951 6 місяців тому
It takes an entire crew to fight the tank but somehow those handing out awards overlook this. Sadly nothing has changed. Look at the lists of who receives various awards when Buckingham Palace passes out peacetime medals. Both military and police hand out medals in direct proportion to rank.
@canoli72
@canoli72 6 місяців тому
Rank hath its privilege. 😊
@pdunderhill
@pdunderhill 6 місяців тому
My old Headmaster HM Jennings MC would very occasionally describe Tank Battles in North Africa. Shake the partly cast iron desks we had with the lights flickering, count in thirteens until you hit a number divisible by seven and still play a game of 'Buzz'. He was, I think the first Tanker to join the Guinea Pig Club after 3rd degree burns in France. He couldn't but be aware of his external appearance, we, very nasty Children, called him Claws not knowing he'd returned to three different Tanks in one action to rescue Men. I still have a Prep School Term Report which I treasure because of the beautiful script which he'd had to relearn.
@Splodnik
@Splodnik 6 місяців тому
I wonder if he was the same man who shouted at me to stay off the cricket pitch at Tunbridge Wells Common when my rubber-band powered model aeroplane alighted upon that hallowed turf?
@Roll_the_Bones
@Roll_the_Bones 6 місяців тому
I'm of the last generation who were taught by "old soldiers" from WWII, although they would have been close to retirement then. Our chemistry teacher had lost a leg, and lurched about on his tin one, our RK teacher had been a prisoner of the Japanese Army, in Burma, and our Latin teacher (I didn't do Latin myself...), had been in France. They rarely, if ever, mentioned their service, although our RK teacher had once exploded in rage, shouting about his terrible experiences, when mocked for his belief by a couple of punk-rocker boys in class. I think, had they made a presentation of their wartime lives, we would ALL have been fascinated, and would have respected them greatly for it.
@stephensmith4480
@stephensmith4480 6 місяців тому
@@Roll_the_Bones Same here. We had a Teacher called Mr Holt, he was a giant of a Man who walked ramrod straight. His shoes were always polished like Mirrors and his attire was immaculate always. He had a very calm way about him and we all liked him. One day he lost his Temper as a couple of the usual trouble makers were acting up in class, his voice suddenly changed and it frightened the life out of us, i had never heard anyone shout so loud and then in an instant, he went back to his usual calm self, you could hear a Pin drop in that Classroom. We were talking to our History Teacher, a Mr Drake and we told him of this episode and how we had never heard Mr Holt raise his voice before, he told us that Mr Holt was in The Grenadier Guards during The War and that he had seen a tremendous amount of Action and he had been wounded. I never forgot that, that would have been about 1970.
@davidcarr7436
@davidcarr7436 6 місяців тому
My uncle was a tanker during the war with the Kings Own Calgary Regiment, Royal Canadian Armoured Corps. He saw a great deal of action and survived the war. Much respect for the "tin can cowboys." 🌺🍁🌺
@250txc
@250txc 3 місяці тому
BS
@THEFORBIDDENMAN-lk7of
@THEFORBIDDENMAN-lk7of 2 місяці тому
MUCH RESPECT TO ALL THE CANADIANS, ECT AND ALL THE OTHER NATIONS WHO GAVE THEIR LIVES AND SURVIVED, NOT ENOUGH IS SPOKEN ABOUT THEIR COURAGE AND SUCCESSES, I THINK IT WAS YOUR COUNTRYMEN WHO GOT WHITTMAN AND PUT AND TO HIS MYTH OR SHOULD OF DONE
@michaelbevan3285
@michaelbevan3285 6 місяців тому
Villers Bocage cost the Germans dearly too. It wasnt the walkover that has been suggested. Wittman left his Tiger behind and had to walk back to be rearmed with a spare tank.
@JohnyG29
@JohnyG29 6 місяців тому
Judging from the records (which are sketchy) they lost between 8 to 15 tanks including 6 Tigers (16% of all the Tigers in Normandy at the time) with many other damaged. It was definitely a bloody affair - glad I wasn't there!
@chaptermasterpedrokantor1623
@chaptermasterpedrokantor1623 6 місяців тому
There is the real events of what happened at Villers Bocage, and the myth that the Germans created and which has been accepted almost verbatim by almost everybody, including the British and historians who never bothered to check what really happened.
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony-
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony- 6 місяців тому
@@JohnyG29 They also lost 17 Tigers and 30 Panthers in Operation Goodwood.
@JayvH
@JayvH 6 місяців тому
Weren't the Tigers of Villers Bocage recovered and repaired?
@michaelbevan3285
@michaelbevan3285 6 місяців тому
Wittman's Tiger was lost. It was hit by a 6 pdr that had been manhandled up a lane and a shot went into the engine. Only for his crew's quick escape, did he evade death or capture that day.
@richardpinchin3749
@richardpinchin3749 6 місяців тому
My Grandad served with the Durham Light Infantry and briefly described the advance on Tilly-sur-Seulles in his memoirs. Thank you for providing me with more detail on the advance and describing how hard the fighting was.
@nomdeplume798
@nomdeplume798 6 місяців тому
My late father in law served with the Green Howards, part of 50th Northumbrian Infantry Div. He landed on Gold Beach on the 6th June. His Bn. served in the same area.
@250txc
@250txc 3 місяці тому
BS
@sdfmills9909
@sdfmills9909 5 днів тому
What’s wrong with you?
@oliverh5367
@oliverh5367 6 місяців тому
This was amazing to watch, I even loaded up google maps to see where the fighting was and the different positions of the tanks. The war memorial is still there with bullet holes in its stone!
@MrTuftynut
@MrTuftynut 6 місяців тому
Fascinating and so well made acount of this battle and the ferocity faced by both sides. I loved the moving battle maps and original footage. The Panzer Lehr were a formidable unit, but so were our tankers when armed with the 75mm/Firefly.
@Daniel_McGarry_Paolini
@Daniel_McGarry_Paolini 5 місяців тому
This is the best video narrative of an armoured action I've ever seen. Really hoping this new series can cover some Canadian tank actions of Italy and Northwest Europe. Well done to the team who made this.
@marvwatkins7029
@marvwatkins7029 5 місяців тому
It's great to see The Tank Museum (aka 'the Bovington Boys') following the examples of Mark Felton, Dark Docs, and others with exciting actual tank combat stories. Keep 'em coming!
@m26a1pershing7
@m26a1pershing7 5 місяців тому
mark felton is a nazi apologist and dark docs just reads wikipedia pages
@OliverFlinn
@OliverFlinn 5 місяців тому
Mark Felton aka the wikipedia historian?
@robinwhitebeam3955
@robinwhitebeam3955 6 місяців тому
There is so much detail about the Invasion of Normandy that is untold , a well made film of a dramatic story, thank you.
@adamwright9741
@adamwright9741 5 місяців тому
Thanks for your extensive use of maps and showing positional movements. A lot of documentaries don't do this and I am always left with the situation being as clear as mud, for me.
@CheekyMenace
@CheekyMenace 5 місяців тому
Between the explanation, war footage and the diagrams showing the movements, it really allows the imagination to run wild picturing the battle taking place. I would love to see more of these please! Great work!
@anselmdanker9519
@anselmdanker9519 5 місяців тому
Thank you for covering this incident. Wilfred Harris promoted to squadron quartermaster and served with the War Office police.He passed on in 1988.
@andhelm7097
@andhelm7097 6 місяців тому
Thanks for covering this, i recall reading about this exploit in Osprey Duel book 😊 firefly vs Tiger 1.
@russwoodward8251
@russwoodward8251 6 місяців тому
Excellent graphics, great film, photos and especially good narration too. Thank you very much.
@paultyson4389
@paultyson4389 5 місяців тому
Great video. Brilliantly narrated. I have read so much about Michael Wittman's devastating exploits at Villers Boccage but never anything about this action that followed quickly afterwards. As you say, it must have helped to restore the faith of the British in their tankers and their Shermans. My gosh, the losses amongst the supporting infantry were horrific. It is great to see a serviceman who performed so admirably in the actual fighting, get to the top of NATO forces. I recall the videos on the death of Wittman and four of his Tiger tanks in August. Eakins, normally the radioman, took over as a gunner in a Sherman firefly and took out three of the Tigers, though it was the Canadians who destroyed Wittman's Tiger. Thanks again.
@andredulac4456
@andredulac4456 6 місяців тому
Pierre Billotte entered the Chat. 13 panzer III and IV destroyed with his B1bis in one fight, received 140 hits, no damage. Bonjour, Aurevoir.
@jaysherman2615
@jaysherman2615 6 місяців тому
Funniest thing about that engagement is he was in a group with other tanks and one of them just sort of drove off and nobody really knows where they went.
@robstafford8306
@robstafford8306 6 місяців тому
Am from Sunderland, at that time part of Durham County. Have been to the DLI museum in Durham lots of times. Did not realise that they fought in this action.
@THEFORBIDDENMAN-lk7of
@THEFORBIDDENMAN-lk7of 2 місяці тому
WITH LOTS OF RESPECT - WE GLAD YOU DID, I MUST GET UP TO DURUM AND LOOK THE MUSEUM UP SOME TIME, THANKS FOR HIGHLIGHTING IT
@Simon_Nonymous
@Simon_Nonymous 6 місяців тому
Nice to see a new presenter with his own style!
@SvenTheSveed
@SvenTheSveed 6 місяців тому
A well researched and well thought out production, well done and thanks to all involved.
@Pat14922
@Pat14922 5 місяців тому
Excellent graphics, Made understanding the stages of the battle very clear.
@ArmoredXJ
@ArmoredXJ 5 місяців тому
Great video! Awesome step by step summary of the battle. Incredible, what it takes to make those calls under combat.
@Dalesmanable
@Dalesmanable 6 місяців тому
Villers Bocage was a match of 2 halves, each side winning one day. Overall, the Germans lost slightly less but a much higher proportion of their assets and leaving the Allies with greater superiority.
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony-
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony- 6 місяців тому
Yeah the Germans losing a tank was worse in the long run than the loss of a Sherman or a Cromwell.
@FieldMarshalFry
@FieldMarshalFry 6 місяців тому
Plus it was under conditions heavily favourable to the German heavy tanks
@HaVoC117X
@HaVoC117X 6 місяців тому
@@FieldMarshalFry What??? How does hedgerows and towns help the german heavy tanks desinged for open spaces and long ranges? The events of Villers-Bocage put an end to the plan to take CEAN within the first week after D-Day. It took them almos two month as a consequence. In the discussion of the Aftermath on the Wikipedia article the following ist written: In early August, up to 100 men, including Bucknall, Erskine, Hinde and other senior officers were sacked and reassigned. Historians largely agree that this was a consequence of the failure at Villers-Bocage and had been planned since the battle. Trying to turn Villers-Bocage in a 50/50 situation or even trying to turn it into a positive event for the allies is quite silly. It was the corner stone for the attritionall battle at Cean and the horrible losses during operation Goodwood (500 operatinal tank losses in 48h traded for around 100 german tanks, the fight started with 1100 allied vs 370 german tanks). Do you have any understanding how overwhelming the allied supply was. Total air superiority, heavy ship based artillery, outnumbering the enemy at least 4 to 1 in men and equipment and at any case.
@Frserthegreenengine
@Frserthegreenengine 5 місяців тому
I would say it was more of a defeat for the Germans, especially in strategic terms. Most people tend to forget that most of Witmanns unit got destroyed after Witmanns solo run. As while he might have destroyed more vehicles single handedly, his presence did alert the British that an attack was coming and when the rest of Wittmann's unit arrived, the British were now fully alert, were well dug in and prepared, the rest of the German Tigers and supporting Panzer IVs were quickly knocked out by the British. Wittmann actually did a lot more harm than good when he went off on his own self-glory hunt.
@HaVoC117X
@HaVoC117X 5 місяців тому
@@Frserthegreenengine Britain failing their objective despite superior forces...... defeat for the germans. According to Monty Market Garden was 90% a succsess.
@4343Butch
@4343Butch 6 місяців тому
Just to say I really like the map format that you added into the video, it makes it easier to understand the action. Please keep up the good work
@joeokabayashi8669
@joeokabayashi8669 5 місяців тому
Fantastic video! I look forward to more videos in this format and series. I would like to see the Tank Museum follow up with PDF content as gaming scenarios - maps, situation, orbat,...victory conditions....
@i-a-g-r-e-e-----f-----jo--b
@i-a-g-r-e-e-----f-----jo--b 5 місяців тому
Excellent video, thanks! I'm looking forward to more of this series.
@scatton61
@scatton61 6 місяців тому
An amazing story. Thank you
@cedhome7945
@cedhome7945 6 місяців тому
Now if someone can persuade a film company to make a British tank movie this sounds like a candidate !
@mstevens113
@mstevens113 6 місяців тому
But the US won the war single handedly, everyone knows that😂
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony-
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony- 6 місяців тому
We need a series like Band of Brothers on units like the Sherwood Rangers and the Durham Light infantry. They were always right in the thick of the action!
@pete1942
@pete1942 6 місяців тому
@@Bullet-Tooth-Tony-would be fantastic, but the big money comes from America, so it’s the American stories that get told…
@morstyrannis1951
@morstyrannis1951 6 місяців тому
@@pete1942sometimes it’s the Brits’ stories that get told but they’re appropriated by the Americans. Looking at you U-571.
@AWMJoeyjoejoe
@AWMJoeyjoejoe 6 місяців тому
@@morstyrannis1951 That film was an atrocity.
@ColinFreeman-kh9us
@ColinFreeman-kh9us 11 днів тому
Amazing format I really enjoyed it. I can’t believe it’s the first time I’ve heard of this battle
@garethbarnes3680
@garethbarnes3680 6 місяців тому
That 17pdr gun in the Firefly was a seriously good weapon...many say better than the 88?
@paulclarke1207
@paulclarke1207 6 місяців тому
From what I've read, it arguably was better than the 88 as an anti-tank weapon, and at very least on a par with it. The 88 had a much better HE round though, so it was more versatile, and therefore probably a better gun overall. That said, the 17-pdr was an absolute game-changer for British crews who had spent most of the war being outgunned by German armour. Not any more!
@garethbarnes3680
@garethbarnes3680 6 місяців тому
@paulclarke1207 I'm sure I read the 17pdr had a higher muzzle velocity so as an anti tank gun it just had the edge with the extra umph
@tomhenry897
@tomhenry897 6 місяців тому
No British had ammunition problems
@lyndoncmp5751
@lyndoncmp5751 5 місяців тому
The 88mm, especially the Tiger I's L/56, was more accurate at long range, did more damage and as has been said was a superior dual purpose gun with greater HE power. In controlled shooting, something like 2 out of 3 rounds hit a tank sized target at 2,000 metres.
@jacktattis
@jacktattis 2 місяці тому
@@garethbarnes3680 with APDS the 17pounder was better than the German APCBC but slightly inferior to the APCR by 16mm of penetration at 2000 yards
@recklessrt
@recklessrt 5 місяців тому
What an inspiring and courageous story - Thank you!
@scottmeeker9971
@scottmeeker9971 3 місяці тому
The greatest generation. Thank you for sharing.
@BrianWMay
@BrianWMay 6 місяців тому
Fascinating, thank you.
@The-RA-Guy
@The-RA-Guy 5 місяців тому
Thank you for doing such an amazing job keeping the tank story available over the years. A small amount but your work is priceless
@casparcoaster1936
@casparcoaster1936 5 місяців тому
Great story, many thanks!! Proves what all of human experience proves... man to man....whoever is lucky, lives.... (till they ain't)!!!!!
@theblackprince1346
@theblackprince1346 6 місяців тому
As I've heard the saying go "there's three things certain in life: tax, death and German counter attacks" 30 Panthers sounds horrific. Great video guys, was on the edge of my seat for this one.
@michaelguerin56
@michaelguerin56 6 місяців тому
Excellent video. Thank you.
@petersterling5334
@petersterling5334 5 місяців тому
Incredible Courage and Skill by the British Tank Crews and Sgt Harris!!
@kaoskronostyche9939
@kaoskronostyche9939 2 місяці тому
Good animations. Clear and easy to understand. Cheers!
@andrewcombe8907
@andrewcombe8907 6 місяців тому
This video shows how hard the fighting was around Caen. The criticisms made of Monty and the Commonwealth forces by the Americans and some revisionist historians were just not warranted. It also confirms the PIAT was an effective tank killer.
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony-
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony- 6 місяців тому
Yes, people tend to forget the British and Canadians fought the bulk of the German armoured forces in France 1944. 9th SS, 10th SS, 1st SS, Panzer Lehr, 12th SS, 21st Panzer, 2nd Panzer, etc.
@lyndoncmp5751
@lyndoncmp5751 5 місяців тому
Any criticisms by Americans for the slow progress in taking Caen are made totally redundant in light of their own even slower progress in attempting to take Metz/Lorraine and the Hurtgen Forest etc not long after. Not to mention falling asleep in the Ardennes.
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony-
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony- 5 місяців тому
@@lyndoncmp5751 Yeah I do find it really hypocritical when all the buck is passed around, at the end of the day both sides ran into heavy resistance. There seems to be a version of history that attempts to portray the British as "inept" and the Americans as "amazing" when comparing the progress of the campaign in France. I tend to take a more objective view on the subject.
@lyndoncmp5751
@lyndoncmp5751 5 місяців тому
@@Bullet-Tooth-Tony- Its astonishing when you think about it. In general the Americans moved no faster than the British and Commonwealth forces in Africa, Italy and NW Europe. People always talk about how quickly Patton's 3rd Army got across France yet British 2nd Army did 400km in just 5 days from the Seine to Brussels. This gets ignored. This was actually faster than Patton's army moved.
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony-
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony- 5 місяців тому
@@lyndoncmp5751 Yup that was Horrocks corps, Monty would have been proud of him no doubt. Dispells the myth of British "slowness"
@mattclark3392
@mattclark3392 2 місяці тому
Amazing video - yet another example of how it was much easier to defend in Normandy than it was to attack...
@andygass9096
@andygass9096 4 місяці тому
excellent vid, fantastic detail at the level that can be related too.
@philipstrutt1086
@philipstrutt1086 5 місяців тому
What a story. So many incredible WW2 tank battle stories from both sides. Makes me want to boot up war thunder.
@norsehall309
@norsehall309 6 місяців тому
G'day from Australia, every one a Hero, war is Hell.
@THEFORBIDDENMAN-lk7of
@THEFORBIDDENMAN-lk7of 2 місяці тому
WELL SAID AND SADLY NOT ENOUGH IS HEARD ABOUT YOUR NATIONS STRUGGLES AND SUCCESSES
@roygardiner2229
@roygardiner2229 Місяць тому
I only discovered this channel a couple of days ago and now cannot stop watching the videos. This one was rather uplifting after watching the video showing the bloody mayhem of the battle at Villers-Bocage. As I am not trained in military tactics or strategies I am interested in trying to extract the "lessons learned" from these deadly battles. It seems to me that the German tanks often had a technical advantage but not always. The British in their characteristic way started the war with inferior equipment but rapidly improved it. The Firefly tank seems to have been a very fearsome vehicle. I wonder what was learned tactically. Clearly, the situations were often chaotic and one comment below I thought rang true: the Germans often had the advantage of starting from very strong and well prepared defensive positions. However, when chaos ensued all bets were off and instinct, courage, improvisation and determination really came to the fore.
@LakeCountryFireworks
@LakeCountryFireworks 5 місяців тому
...Outstanding History Story!...
@darrencorrigan8505
@darrencorrigan8505 6 місяців тому
Thanks, Tank Museum.
@oldesertguy9616
@oldesertguy9616 6 місяців тому
Great information. I think sometimes the Germans believed their own propaganda and thought their tanks invincible. I watched a documentary once where a Panther crewman stated how they didn't even worry about Shermans, only to state a couple minutes later that his tank was disabled, by a Sherman. When you look at the battle of Arracourt you can see that Sherman versus Panther was not as big a mismatch as the Wehraboos would have you believe.
@tomhenry897
@tomhenry897 6 місяців тому
75 or 76 When use to 75s it’s a surprise when one has a 76 since both look the same
@ikillstupidcomments
@ikillstupidcomments 6 місяців тому
Depends heavily on which variant. 75mm Shermans weren't up to fighting late-war German tanks, but 76mm variants were. The same's true in reverse of course, throwing a PzIII against a Pershing or T-34-85 would not go well for the German crew.
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony-
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony- 6 місяців тому
@@ikillstupidcomments And the Centurion too.
@chaosXP3RT
@chaosXP3RT 6 місяців тому
​@@ikillstupidcommentsPanzer 3 wouldn't stand a chance against a Sherman
@johnathanh2660
@johnathanh2660 5 місяців тому
@@ikillstupidcomments It depends on the ammo. The thing I find frustrating in all of this is that one regiment had to hand back their Comets and land in D-Day with Shermans because they hadn't completed their conversion training. Had they been held back two or three of weeks (given that the battle of Normandy was eleven) how different would the fighting around Caen have been with some Comets.
@grahamjesson5464
@grahamjesson5464 6 місяців тому
if i'm not mistaken, the second essex reg. was on that eastern flank of the village and faced flame throwers and heavy artillery fire until the support of tanks came along alot later to save the situation. They had a seriously hard time. So brave those chaps, don't know if there is any pompadours still alive today.
@HydroSnips
@HydroSnips 6 місяців тому
Essex were resting on that day, resting and rebuilding - they had made an earlier attack on Lingevres, on June 11th. They got into the village but drew back under heavy resistance into an orchard just on the outskirts (“Essex Wood”) where they were attacked overnight by infantry and a halftrack with a flamethrower. They clung on despite heavy casualties but got withdrawn by Brigade on the 12th because it was such a precarious spot.
@yoschiannik8438
@yoschiannik8438 6 місяців тому
I love how evrebody acts as if Wittman had singelhandedly won the day, instead of being straight up responsibale for hir units anhilation.
@johnathanh2660
@johnathanh2660 5 місяців тому
The joys of propaganda. And then there's the way that to this day the 'prowess' of the Tiger and Panther are hailed. When most losses were due to mechanical defects (and the crews destroying them as they retreated). It's a pretty poor weapon system that can't be kept in the fight. The most effective tank was the PzIV. The Germans should have been building these. But that doesn't fit with the propaganda myth.
@yoschiannik8438
@yoschiannik8438 5 місяців тому
@@johnathanh2660 The panzer 4 was putdated, even before Toger and phanter went into service. Tiger was the best Nazi Tank by 44, which says more about the nazis and less about Tiger....
@johnathanh2660
@johnathanh2660 5 місяців тому
@@yoschiannik8438 The PzIV could be built at far greater volumes than any other tank and Panthers and Tigers were comparatively rare and worse mechanically unreliable. The Tiger had an Achilles heel, its' final drive, which often failed and this resulted in a mobility kill. Compare that with a PzIV which compared favourably to most British tanks and most variants of the Sherman.
@stuartb9194
@stuartb9194 6 місяців тому
Great story, well told and animated. What a price to pay though
@midnightvibes5485
@midnightvibes5485 6 місяців тому
Most situationally aware German play- I mean tankers.
@AdamPerkinsPhD
@AdamPerkinsPhD 6 місяців тому
Thanks for a great video
@calebcosman8884
@calebcosman8884 3 місяці тому
Wow, amazing. Loved this videos with graphics.
@HD4all
@HD4all 4 місяці тому
interesting and detailed report, thanks!
@WesternAustraliaNowAndThen
@WesternAustraliaNowAndThen 6 місяців тому
Such an interesting story. One of my great regrets is that I will never get to visit the Tank Museum in person.
@winfieldjohnson125
@winfieldjohnson125 6 місяців тому
Australia has an awesome, if somewhat smaller Armor and Artillery museum....Somewhere in the North. I watch a regular series they release every Weds. where they show restoration projects they have ongoing.
@newcastlerabbit
@newcastlerabbit 4 місяці тому
Thank you, very interesting.
@filmandsong05
@filmandsong05 5 місяців тому
haven’t heard many stories of the british tankers, thanks, great stuff
@justincharlton-jones4787
@justincharlton-jones4787 5 місяців тому
4/7 Dragoon Guards were part of 8th Independent Armoured Brigade along with The Sherwood Rangers Yeomanry (SRY) and 24 Lancers. The SRY had fought in tanks all through North Africa from Alamein to Tunis, but, in order to balance the experience in the Army's armoured brigades prior to D-Day, the 4/7 and 24 Lancers were transferred to 8 Armoured Brigade in exchange for the Staffordshire Yeomanry and 3 Royal Tank Regiment (who had also fought in North Africa) who were moved to bolster the newly created 29th and 27th Armoured Brigades respectively. 8 Armoured Brigade's role in NW Europe was primarily to provide armoured support to Infantry Divisions. This usually meant that a Regiment of tanks would be allocated to each infantry Brigade and each infantry battalion in the Brigade would be allocated a squadron of tanks to support it. Consequently, the major commanding each cavalry squadron was under the command of an infantry colonel. One of the problems this created from time to time was the infantry commander not being willing to take advice from a junior, but frequently more experienced squadron leader. I don't wish to infer any criticism of the DLI and their CO, I wasn't there, but it was noticeable that the attack on the village made more progress after the sad death of the infantry CO, when the squadron leader took command. I noticed that in a number of previous comments people were surprised that the gunner in Sgt Harris' tank hadn't been awarded a medal. This shows a lack of understanding of the role of the tank commander. Putting it bluntly, a good tank commander kept the rest of the crew alive. The drivers, gunner and operator all had a part to play in the operation of the tank, but the commander made the tactical decisions and (particularly in the Normandy Bocage) had a much greater likelihood of being killed as it was extremely difficult to command a Sherman tank without your head out of the turret. The fact that the gunner was mentioned in despatches is testimony to the accuracy of his shooting. Most regiments were only equipped with enough Firefly tanks to have one per troop, so the majority of the tank engagements in NW Europe were fought by Shermans with the standard 75mm gun. The Sherwood Rangers Yeomanry, who saw more action than any other armoured regiment in WW2, first in North Africa and then in Europe, learnt the hard way how to knock out German tanks in the close Normandy countryside. They would put down a phenomenal amount of fire on any enemy tank, forcing the crew to close up and rely on their periscopes for visibility. They would also 'brass up' any suspected infantry position with MG fire, forcing the Germans to return fire and reveal their location; they never moved without a round of AP 'up the spout'. This meant that the crews spent many hours every night re-arming their tanks when they might have been asleep, but their willingness to use their ammunition gave them a tactical edge. For example on 26 June in Fontenay, A Squadron OC, John Semken found himself face to face with a Tiger Tank, only 120 yards apart. Semken fired immediately and in the space of 30 seconds his tank hit the Tiger 10 times. Although the Tiger only suffered superficial damage, the periscopes were all smashed and, with the weight of fire on them, the Tiger's crew bailed out. The SRY's commanders were also adept at stalking German tanks and no-one was a greater exponent than Sgt, George Dring MM. That same day, in the advance on Rauray, George Dring destroyed a Panzer IV, a Tiger (crew bailed out), another Panzer IV and then a second Tiger, which he brewed up. Finally, as it was getting dark, he destroyed another Panzer IV at 1,200 yards with an AP round from his 75mm. The SRY didn't receive any Fireflys until late July 1944. On Tuesday 1 August, during the battle for Point 361, George Dring with his 75mm destroyed a Jagdpanther and another Tiger which he stalked on foot and then moved his Sherman into position to engage. If you want to know more about the SRY in WW2, then I recommend 'An Englishman at War', 'Tank Action' and 'Brothers in Arms'. The SRY won more battle honours and more awards than any other Regiment in the British Army in WW2, . In the opinion of General Horrocks they saw more action than any other armoured regiment in WW2. Consequently they also had more soldiers killed and wounded than any other armoured regiment. The film footage at 1'.40" shows an 8th Armoured Brigade 'O' Group. The man on the left in the black overalls with his back to the camera is Colonel Stanley Christopherson, CO of the SRY and he is talking to John Semken, who commanded A Squadron, SRY. At 24 John was one of the most experienced squadron leaders in the British Army.
@kukatahansa
@kukatahansa 5 місяців тому
Great info about The Sherwood Rangers Yeomanry! Thank you for your input.
@KMac329
@KMac329 6 місяців тому
What great courage, skill, and heroism, yet what appalling casualties. I salute and honor all the Bristish soldiers who served in this battle, indeed, in all the bloody battles of World War II.
@HD4all
@HD4all 4 місяці тому
interesting and detailed report, thanks
@RasmusDyhrFrederiksen
@RasmusDyhrFrederiksen 5 місяців тому
Thanks!
@GetUpTheMountains
@GetUpTheMountains 6 місяців тому
Great video, looking forward to this series. This presenter reminds me of the historian talking about the Luftwaffe from that Mitchel & Webb Look. 🤣
@danielescobedo56
@danielescobedo56 3 місяці тому
WHAT AN AMAZING HISTORY LESSON. THANK YOU AND THANK YOU TO ALL FOR YOUR SERVICE.
@bigsarge2085
@bigsarge2085 6 місяців тому
Incredible.
@MrDeeyal
@MrDeeyal 5 місяців тому
This channel produces such fantastic content. ☺️
@robwillett7832
@robwillett7832 6 місяців тому
Great video.
@bankerduck4925
@bankerduck4925 6 місяців тому
Amazing story.
@eric-wb7gj
@eric-wb7gj 2 місяці тому
TY 🙏🙏
@nomdeplume798
@nomdeplume798 6 місяців тому
One of the last still images shows the crew of a Sherwood Rangers Yeomanry tank christened Akila, which should have read "Achilles" but the trooper who painted it couldn't spell it. The image can be seen in "Brothers in Arms" by James Holland.
@robert-trading-as-Bob69
@robert-trading-as-Bob69 5 місяців тому
The direction and positioning of the a tank is of vital importance, as is the situational awareness of the crew commander, so the DCM is well deserved, but for the talented gunner to get a MID only is criminal.
@alvarvillalongamarch3894
@alvarvillalongamarch3894 19 годин тому
Danke!
@BeatRoot14
@BeatRoot14 6 місяців тому
I remember first hearing about Sgt Harris from Steel Division 1944. Oh this happened on my birthday
@davestory6123
@davestory6123 6 місяців тому
My old regiment great history
@mabbrey
@mabbrey 6 місяців тому
great vid
@theromanorder
@theromanorder 6 місяців тому
Please do more evaluation of tank doctrine videos
@GTX1123
@GTX1123 5 місяців тому
The Germans feared the Firefly. That thing was lethal. Whenever they engaged British tank columns they always looked for that menacing 17 pounder sticking out of the Sherman turret so they could attack them first. This then caused British tank crews to use a camo paint scheme to make it look like the 75mm pea shooter. The fact that the cargo net caught on fire from the backflash of the 17 pounder on Roberts Firefly tells you how fierce the propellant charge was in the larger shell casing for its munition. This is of course how the Firefly got its name.
@michaellangevin3943
@michaellangevin3943 3 місяці тому
Noticed that when talking about "stalled" Montgomery was in the video, as usual. LOL
@jacktattis
@jacktattis 2 місяці тому
Who took Caen and sacrificed men and equipment to allow the US to break out in Operation Cobra? Who was put in charge of two US Armies to straighten the Bulge by Eisenhower no less? Whose subordinate advanced 200 miles in 11 days against a very good enemy.? Who took the surrender of the Germans in the North which upset Ike? Who NEVER lived in Villas and Palaces but in a truck with a bed a table some chairs and his trunk? Who ate the same rations as his men ? Who never stole a brass razoo in his trek across 3 theatres , unlike Clark and Bedel-Smith ? MONTGOMERY IS WHO
@billyost1479
@billyost1479 5 місяців тому
Real heroes during a time which has long since been forgotten.
@rickvanheerden788
@rickvanheerden788 5 місяців тому
Very interesting. More please! And yes, the popular dogma of the invincibility of German armour needs to be challenged!
@OliverFlinn
@OliverFlinn 5 місяців тому
Harris got 5 panther tanks because of his skilled Gunner.
@richardthornton3775
@richardthornton3775 6 місяців тому
That was great narration to accompany that fantastic film, thank you🙏 I have had many discussions with my American counterparts over time about this period of WWII. And in many cases they have used the, lack of success after the D-Day landings by British & Commonwealth troops, as an indication of how much further the US army managed to advance. This film would be a good watch for them, I will ensure I share it👍
@ToddSauve
@ToddSauve 5 місяців тому
Sometimes Americans are full of baloney. The Canadian army landed on Juno on June 6, 1944 and by the end of the day had taken 7 miles of territory from the Germans. The next day by noon that had moved up to Bretteville and Putot, about 13 miles inland. No one, whether American or British, kept up with the Canadians. So inform your American friends of how full of baloney they are.
@jacktattis
@jacktattis 2 місяці тому
When in fact the Brits/Cwealth were off the beaches before the US and I believe one. U.S. Commander was very close to evacuating his men.
@trailingarm63
@trailingarm63 5 місяців тому
Pleased to hear that by grafting the 17 pounder onto a Sherman we had something that could compete with the German armour. Very brave men on both sides of the conflict.
@jm9371
@jm9371 6 місяців тому
Crazy story.. Good job A squadron, 4/7th Dragoons.. wow!
@user-qs7gx7rp7m
@user-qs7gx7rp7m 5 місяців тому
Knew an old RCAC tank driver once upon a time. Had survived 4 lost tanks he was crew in and made it from Normandy to Germany & back home to a modest life. His hands and forearms were covered in a remarkable mix of skin colours due to much burn scar tissue. His drink of choice was Old style Dutch Geneva gin. I tried it thrice with him. Barely survived the experience. That's why I truly know he was tough . . . and suspect he appreciated the pain-killing properties of gin from his days in Holland. He was from Cascapedia, province of Quebec.
@gregjenkins2925
@gregjenkins2925 5 місяців тому
men of incredible Courage and Bravery.
@adriaanboogaard8571
@adriaanboogaard8571 5 місяців тому
Great Story.
@CanOfRabbitHoles
@CanOfRabbitHoles 5 місяців тому
Oh my god. I've only just realised he says "and TANKS for watching" in the intro! Sly buggers haha
@Paladin1873
@Paladin1873 6 місяців тому
A brutal fight, to be sure.
@benkeller6027
@benkeller6027 3 місяці тому
Panther tanks are quite intimidating to see in battle. These tanks were well designed and looked amazing.
@steventrostle1825
@steventrostle1825 4 місяці тому
My Father fought in a light tank under Paton, those light tanks were actually only designed to stop 12.5mm rounds so they would hide the tanks if they saw Panthers or most any other tanks approach, dig foxholes and fight with bazookas. There were 75 vehicles, tanks , half tracks, duce and a half and jeeps when they went ashore After D day, they entered Germany ahead of all other divisions with 21 vehicles. Dad received many metals but did not talk about the experience, he lost too many friends. Anyway all the Allies who fought in Europe and Asia were part of the GREATEST GENERATION- not taking away from our troops today. Thank You
@Ulani101
@Ulani101 6 місяців тому
A deadly beast; the good old Firefly. In capable hands, the 17 pounder was deadly, as many German tank crews discovered the hard way. Good show, old boy. 👍
@matthewlok3020
@matthewlok3020 6 місяців тому
Among them Michael Wittman
@Neodreth
@Neodreth 6 місяців тому
Deadly maybe, because of his canon but beast, not even close. It still had the paper thin armor all Shermans had. Tanks like the Tiger on the other hand totally deserve the title of both deadly and beast.
@AWMJoeyjoejoe
@AWMJoeyjoejoe 6 місяців тому
​@@NeodrethPaper thin? 75mm on the front angled to give an effective thickness of 89mm. Stop believing the myths. Sherman was well armoured for it's weight class.
@Neodreth
@Neodreth 6 місяців тому
@@AWMJoeyjoejoe There are plenty documentaries out there with WW2 veterans talking about the Sherman and not a single one of them talks about effective thickness and well armored. In fact they say exactly the opposite so allow me to believe someone who actually fought the war inside them tanks instead of you.
@BjornTheDim
@BjornTheDim 6 місяців тому
​@@NeodrethYou are comparing a medium tank (and a tank destroyer) to a heavy tank. They have different missions and different capabilities and shouldn't be compared. However, the M4 Sherman had decent frontal armor when one took the sloping into account.
The Tank the Tiger Feared, the Sherman Firefly | Forged for Battle
23:47
Evolution of WW2 German Tank Destroyers
24:59
The Tank Museum
Переглядів 112 тис.
Level 1 to 100 Mystery Buttons
00:46
A4
Переглядів 8 млн
船长被天使剪成光头了?#天使 #小丑 #超人不会飞
00:28
超人不会飞
Переглядів 24 млн
When a King Tiger Was Rammed by a Sherman
8:46
Yarnhub
Переглядів 2,3 млн
Why Did German Tanks Perform So Badly in The Battle of the Bulge?
11:47
The Intel Report
Переглядів 1,5 млн
Tank Chats #153 | Jagdpanther | The Tank Museum
25:03
The Tank Museum
Переглядів 796 тис.
Evolution of The  Churchill Tank | "No Damn Good"?
24:11
The Tank Museum
Переглядів 364 тис.
See Inside King Tiger | Tank Chats Reloaded
21:38
The Tank Museum
Переглядів 2,3 млн
Inside The Chieftain's Hatch: Panther II
22:21
World of Tanks - Official Channel
Переглядів 546 тис.
Radical or Ridiculous? | T-14 Armata | Tank Chats #171
20:00
The Tank Museum
Переглядів 1,8 млн
The WW2 Tank Battle Caught On Film! (WW2 Documentary)
19:36
Battle Guide
Переглядів 6 млн
See Inside Panther | Tank Chats Reloaded
21:53
The Tank Museum
Переглядів 382 тис.
Level 1 to 100 Mystery Buttons
00:46
A4
Переглядів 8 млн