Reading through all these comments proved to be really painful.

A maioria dos comentários é de brasileiros, como sempre. Se eu faço um vídeo em inglês falando do Brasil, por mais irrelevante que seja, aparecem vários brasileiros de imediato.

"Lula introduced social programes like Bolsa familia???" NO, wrong information. Lula unified three already existing social programs (Bolsa alimentação/ Bolsa escola/ Auxilio gas) and changed the name. So unifying something that already existed and changing the name is not the same as "Creating" .

This is a good analysis of the political situation here in Brazil but a poor analysis of the economic situation. Brazil's economy is considerably diversified, our deficit spending is insignificant compared to the EU and specially the US, our balance of trade account is hugely positive for us (a unique thing among EM) and our inflation is below EU levels. So how come our economy is "collapsing"? Get your facts straight

I wouldn't say the congress it's dominated by right wing parties. Actually, it was always dominated by center wing (?) parties, which goes to the side thet benefits them the most.

Because of the supreme court

It sounds like Lula will have a lot of the same obstacles that Bernie would have had if he had won. I guess we will see if it's possible to make rapid progressive changes with a conservative/neoliberal congress getting in the way. I personally don't believe much can be accomplished and that will probably bolster the support of his opposition.

Lula literally promised beer and steaks in every house as a promise. Lets see how that works out for him and his voter base Lmfao

funny how this video is EXTREMELY biased

Comentários em ingles com nick de br nem leio kkkk

because most people don't want to work

I find it funny how our economy is characterized as collapsing. No it’s not! Yes we still have to find a virtuous path of growth after the complete debacle between 2015-2018, but for example we have very strong monetary institutions and zero debt in foreign currency (state debt today is all in our local currency as opposed to, for example, Argentina.) Yes we have very thought years ahead, but I am consciously hopeful that it will enable us to solve part of our long standing problems.

Hey guys i have a request for you guys can you please please do mini coverage on nauru's new port development project and go there for reporting and filming of report and please try to also interview someone adb about that 😀 👍 😊 🙏

As a Brazilian I can say that the political scenario in Brazil is turbulent since I know myself, the opinions are polarized, we don't have honest politicians, no government was corruption free. For example, Lula had some corruption scandals, mensalão, petrolão, or even bolsonaro, that used 8 thousand reais with ice cream💀. I don't see any change in this scenario in the future, because most of the Brazilians are completly clueless about how the country works.

he is very popular all over Latin America, here in Chile TV chanels are still talking about Lula's winning and inauguration .

Theres a media blackout on whats happening there on this yt platform i cant find much on it

Você fala do governo Bolsonaro como se não tivesse havido uma pandemia que afetou a economia global durante ele

You’ll have to ask Klause and the Prussian mafia.

O que me impressiona é aparecer brasileiro aqui pra dizer que o congresso não é dominado pela direita. Nem parece que conhecem os partidos daqui, é do tipo que deve achar que o PSDB é um partido de esquerda por ter "social-democrata" na sigla ou que o PP é progressista. É se fazer de burro ou apenas fingir que é.

Lula had a big chance to put the country on the right track back in 2003, but he prefered to surf on the commodity boom, instead of investing on the country's industrial development. Besides that he didn't threat the privilege of the rich, it was quite the opposite, the rich became richer during his presidency. Although the poor achieved some dignity, the status quo remained intact. I'm glad Bolsonaro lost, but I don't have high expectations regarding Lula's third mandate and I believe there were candidates who were more willing to make progressive changes than him.

Lula before being elected: "I'm going to raise the minimum wage!" Lula now: "it's just a joke guys... we can't spend 200 reais with you because it's going to be a wasted money..."

o $i$tema escolheu, e os burricos que se acham "politizados" quando leem isso se revoltam, mesmo sabendo que é verdade rs..

Lula was consider guilty of several crimes in several courts, not just of moro. He was free by his alies of supreme court that he put there. One was literaly his lawery before becomig supreme court judge

Democracy requires civil engagement and constant dialog between parties to offer solutions.. now this moron was caught with his hands in the cookie jar and I am sad to say that someone wanted him back out and in power to further polarize Brazil and undermine the current functioning political system. Gone are the days when the worker's party advocated for the proletariat.

Well the history is much more complicated here in Brazil, on one side you have the "Lula afetivos" (people who like Lula, whatever and however he does it) and on de other side you have the "Bolsominhos" (same here but follow blindly Bolsonaro). Lula was not only convicted by the judge, Moro, who used maybe not soo well defined methodes to get his proves of Lula being involved directly with criminal activities (nobody gives signatures for this, as there are still a lot of people who think he was innocent), but Lula also was convicted by the second court with a panel of judges, and also in the high court. Lula got out of prison because high court judges appointed by him and Dilma, made the decisions made by judge Moro invalid because, in their opinion, Moro was not in the right jurisdiction to rule over Lula´s crimes. Lula got out of jail and would be judged again by another judge from the right place, but the process had to be done all over again. As Lula has more than seventy years the crimes had expired. As there were many things done wrong by Lula and the PT (Labor Party), they opened a gap for Bolsonaro to fill. Both are populists and have portions of media helping them, also both have an organization to work online for them to make "fake news" by telling half truths. This is not a problem only in Brazil, just to name some problems made the same way are, Brexit in the UK, Trump maga gangs, all made by doubtful media outlets or online spreading information directed thru influencers. We have two words for shit here in Brazil, "bosta" and "merda", that´s exactly how I describe Bolsonaro and Lula. As there is a large portion of the Brazilian population that has not formal education, they can be easily manipulated by any misinformation. Look where we are now, no trust in government, no trust in justice system, no trust in formal media and no trusty environment online. (online being manipulated a lot by foreign companies and governments) But there is still some positive, Brazil is big, has fertile grounds, has a clean energy grid and does not depend on foreign energy, has lots of mineral resources, has a good climate, and has people that forget quickly bad times. Also Brazil is not involved with any conflict in the world and as Ukraine, another large food producer in the world, is in conflict with Russia, Brazil can have opportunities to do well in next years. Also China needs a lot of food, the USA boycotting tech products from China will result in higher demand of Brazilian proteins for China.

This video is going to age SOOOOOOOOO welll. But it will not be fine wine. 🥶

Because poor people dont learn.

Pretty accurate!

A few things: Bolsa família was not created by Lula.

guys, do not forget that what was shown here is just a superficial view of governments, no government was perfect, but in the first Lula government, Brazil had a great economic growth thanks to the great increase in the value and commercialization of commodities that reached the South America in that period, was not a direct result of his economic policies. In addition, the large expenditure on aid and the increase in bureaucracy for entrepreneurs generated financial losses that affected subsequent governments such as Dilma, Temer and Bolsonaro. I believe that for foreigners access to this type of information is not easy, do not blame the author of the video for the lack of it, after all, not even most Brazilians can understand these details.

I live in Brazil for the last 33 years…I don’t like leftists!, hate comunists, but Lula’s period was amazing for the population and country…Boldonaro’s was the biggest deception!!…🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️

6 months later, he is doing great

The question is: who put that shit back??? The most part of Brazilians really don't know. The Brazilian jundicial power, maybe? We don't know because we cannot talk about that in our new dictatorship, actually.

The issue isn't the radicalness of his presidency, it's if he continues to be part of the norm.

The supreme court released him from jail, granted him candidate rights and made sure the the election couldn´t give another result; the supreme court in Brazil is an anemy of the people.

(Português) O cara viu MUUUITA notícia mal informada fazendo esse video kkkkkkkkk. (English) The dude saw MAAANY misinformed news when making this video LOL.

good video!!!

It's good to watch the point from a forgein, but when you live this reality you know what is the right side and i am not talking about Lula or Bolsonaro i'm talking about the future and ideas tô we get there

You should be ashamed for tuis report. We have a saying. The press is something pay them well and maybe they may even tell the truth.

This is the Brazilian version of Biden…. Ugh

We're now talking Faz o L to everyone here

Lula criou o family handbag skkdkskfkakdkakks

Lula is the best president for all! 🇧🇷🥰

What has happened to people that protested against his re-election …lots of people missing?

Pq descobriram que é o que queriam na verdade com a arquivologia mesmo. Só que não é perfeito mesmo.

Desde mexico!!! Apoyo a Lula!!! Dejen al hombre trabajar para que estimule la economia y que estados unidos caiga!! Arriba México y Arriba Brazil!!! Estamos hartos de tantas corrupción que suprimen nuestro crecimiento. Mexico ya tiene un buen líder. Lula es otro.

Voting is a big mistake. If humanity is wise we will love one another and stop this wasteful and ignorant method of electing leaders. Wise men need to elect wise men to lead by the grace of God. Pretending that every person over 18 is truly qualified to pick a world leader is heresy, a lost cause.

Almost a year elected and he didn’t give for his sheep’s Steak, basic sanitation and gas voucher. Do the L!

😔

Bolsonaro is ex prisioner too

The way Lula's arrest and release were shown in this video is very resumed and overlooked. He was convicted and he is guilty. Even if it was politically motivated, his arrest was lawful and had overwhelming public support at the time. What happened was that the supreme court had previously judged him guilty (the supreme court in Brazil judges cases if the cases get to them.), but not coincidentally, just when Lula was about to be a candidate again, the political rivals were not as strong and the overall support for Bolsonaro (which appointed the supreme court judge that had the final say to free Lula or not by the way) had decreased, the supreme court decided that as of 2019 those convicted in the second stance were not to be arrested until they were finally convicted and that the case should not have taken place in Curitiba (where Lula's illegally acquired real state was) it was supposed to take place in Brasilia (the federal district), thus annulling the case and forcing the federal police to start all over again with new evidence, this would be "ok" if the crimes had not expired in 2020 were he not have been convicted. And all of that happened right after his age became greater than 75, thus reducing the time needed for a crime to expire in half. So, his release was a political move that just exploited a massive loophole in the system, but that does not exclude all of the photos of him, furniture, documents, 130+ visits in 2 years to the country house that "was not his", the pedal boat with hid grandkid's names on it, the triplex he lived in. He was convicted of concealment of assets, passive corruption, and more. HE IS A CRIMINAL, the fact he is now a president is outrageous. Unfortunately, most people don't know all of these technical terms or do enough research, they just see he's free and assume he's not guilty, which is not the case at all. PS: Bolsonaro is a corrupt dumbass too, they both should be in jail.

Lula. Instead of looking abroad why don't you save the Amazon forest?

The Brasilan people loves Bolsonaro, and hate Lola thief!

Well a quick glance at Venezuela convinced millions of idiots to say" I like free stuff" (until the well runs dry and you run out of people to mooch off of) besides if things get bad I can just sneak into the US or Canada. Good Luck!

É o maior estadista que esse país já viu. Avante, presidente.

Smart Matic

Not sure how current present president lead the nation. Will see

I hate living in Brazil

Simples porque a gente e um bando de masoquista maluco

Enquanto esse cara estiver vivo e o PT existir, o Brasil nunca irá pra frente

This channel is corrupt by the Matrix

God bless Democracy 🙏

Fun fact: He is The first president in Brazil to be elected 3 times Fato curioso: ele é o primeiro presidente no Brasil a ser eleito 3 vezes.

Brazilians must be proud of their president Lula da Silva

we didn’t.

You forgot to say that he was not consideres innocent at the end of his judgment

I would like to see more videos that prioritize factual information rather than attempting to manipulate viewers. It is important to acknowledge that a controversial juridical maneuver, implemented by Supreme Court judges who have close ties to Lula, played a role in his eligibility to run in the presidential election. This situation raises legitimate questions about the impartiality of the judicial process. Lula was sentenced to 12 years in prison for corruption but became eligible to run in the presidential election through a juridical maneuver that is unprecedented in any democracy worldwide. It should be noted that the judge who played a key role in his imprisonment did not act alone; the sentence was handed down by multiple judges and courts. It has been proven that Lula was involved in one of the worst and largest corruption schemes in the world. Brazil's National Oil Company suffered significant losses totaling $5 billion due to this corruption scheme. Numerous individuals involved in the scheme chose to plead guilty in exchange for reduced jail sentences. One piece of evidence that undermines the credibility of your video is the fact that Lula's Party governed Brazil for 14 years but failed to deliver on their promised meals of breakfast, lunch, and dinner to the impoverished population. These factors highlight the need for a comprehensive and balanced perspective in videos, ensuring viewers have access to accurate and unbiased information.

Lula is a Brazilian Obama

GOD BLESS PRESIDENT BOLSONARO AND BRAZILIAN PEOPLE. 1 MILLION PEOPLE ON THE PAULIST AVENUE. 25.02.2024

He's a Brazilian Obama

❤

I think any president would have been popular during that commodity boom Brazil was going through. Helped them avoid the 2008 crisis.

Why the WEF put Lula back in charge?

que reportagem tendenciosa! vocês são muito desonestos com o seu publico e qualquer um que tenha o minimo de inteligencia sabe que muita coisa ai é MENTIRA.

Bolsonaro , Lula , we deserve better.

I'm speaking for a lot of us right now: we chose the better option, or the less worse if you prefer. Another 4 years of Bolsonaro would be a huge no-no, and whoever disagrees isn't (or wasn't, to be precise) really keeping up with all the absurdity that was routine in the last administration...

Author in sad tone 12% people are poor I m like ever visited asian countries

Time to flee to portugal, guys! Getting permission to live there is easier for brazilians!

it was a tough choice given his party's past, but it was necessary to defend our democracy. we had our own capitol like the united states. I wish strength to all peoples in struggle!

because the truth is above the lies, the hopes are higher than the fear, and the love won the hatred.

As a former Petrobras employee, I can tell how bad he was.

Lula was not exonerated, the supreme court changed a ruling and said another court needed to trial him, which never happened because by them the time the state had to persecute him had passed.

There are several things id like to point out as someone who has lived in brazil from 2005- present day 1.Bolsa familia was inefective, it gave monthly to families only 89 reais, while the auxilio brasil gave 600, that's why they changed the name, completeley different program that began in 2021, together with many other programs introduced in his goverment in the past like Auxilio gas moradia and others. 2. lulas 1st term was quite beneficial to the country, but the second one brought inflation and corruption all the way towards dilma impeachment, from money laundering in the Minha casa minha vida (Program that helped brazilians with housing) that has resulted in halted construction until this day while bolsonaro helped house over 400k (most in the country's history) , lack in payment towards petrobras workers and other state owned companies. 3.Although some claim that Lula's prossecution could have been politicaly motivaded, that was not the reasin his sentencing was terminated, the evidence statcks up all the way towards him, and he tried to gain "Foro Privilegiado" (Privileged forum) by Trying to become the minister of the civil house, an action advised by one of his friends in a tapped phonecall, that was later confirmed by another tapped phonecall between Lula and the then president Dilma (Whose presidential campaign used laundered money from Petrobras from OAS) 4.Food insecurity is highly debated subject, while the new ministress of the Climate change and wildlife Marina Silva (The one in the video :D , that's so cool you guys could interview her!) claimed that there are 120 million currently hungry, different sourses cite 60 million while the Traditional media uses one by Pensann, that concludes that there are about 33 million, although brazilian poverty also reached a historic low in 2020; only 0.8% according to the World Bank and MSM sources. Making it the country with lowest poverty rate in Latin America. 5.There is no easy way to bring civilization to these "OUTCASTED" and distant bretherin of mine, doing-so would require to deforestation of a large portion of the Amazon rainforest, to build highways, landing strips, wind turbines, water stations, power line system and much more to make life and the economy better for the Brazilian and Native tribes in the north. PersonalNote: While singing his presidential term documentation he made up a story about the pen that he was holding, claiming that said pen was a gift from the 80's, eventhough said pen was only made in 2002 and for over 20k dollars. I'm open for criticisims towards my comment; as i am only human and up to correct my mistakes without making the supreme court be formed mostly by members apointed by my political party and trying to impose "regulation" and restrictions on this opus of mankind, the Internet.

As an american as long as he protects the amazon i will support him. Everything else is for brazillians to decide if he is the best. And hope he understands that 49 percent didnt vote for him and try to represent them too.

This makes me not like bolsanaro. Lula parece bom. Preciso de aprender mais.

Political Prisioner this is the True.

I vote in President Lula because: 1- capability to discuss with Congress and pass the Tax Reform. Bolsonaro won with mojority of the Congress, but did not discuss with congressists and even less inaugurate his mandete with ministers stablisheds. 2- institutional security, because in Bolsonaros's rule our Supreme Court and Congress were frequently threatened of a military coup. 3- best diplomatic relationship. Bolsonaro insulted Marcron's wife, make Brazil abandon the status of developing country to declare ourselves as "rich country" and lost the proeminency as lider of Developing Economies. Bolsonaro has some positive points in economie, because the Economic Liberty Decree, that help little business and to proceed with the Retirement Sistem Reform, started in Temer's rule, but all of this ocourred in 2 years of caos in government. Many os his ministers were fired beacause incapability to democratically discuss with Congress, anding with Paulo Guedes (our most powerfull Economy Minister) taking the lead and making the system work. In Pandemic, the paralyzed governmet was evident. The Congress and Supreme Court revolve the problems with the virus, while President Bolsonaro appeared publicly on his channel to say "don't get vaccinated so you don't become an alligator", "the vaccine passes HIV", and even more nonsenses. In the and, on electoral year, he appear saying that "the pandemic was a disaster". 600000 people died. Lula was condemned, but his process was demonstrably skewed, so much that the judge that envestigated, judge and condemned him is now a Senator fo Republic. The Supremo Court and UNO concluded that the judge was partial in his actions and the process was reversed. Until today, our brazilians do not understend what was the concrete proof of involviment of Lula in corruption scandals. In Bolsonaro's rule, a Education Minister was imprisioned, and the president himself had contact with criminal lider, but no one of the conservatives want do talk about this.

Sou Brasileiro! Esse video não mostra a verdade. Vergonha!

He is a bandit.

Lula is the best president in Brazilian history and the best head of state on the planet.

The most shame of Brazil population

This video doesn’t mention covid economic effects. So disingenuous.

Por mais q eu n apoie o Lula eu espero q ele seja um presidente descente.

Completely unbiased report 😂

LULA HAS 7% OF POPULATION ON HIS SIDE( NORTH WEST OF THE COUNTRY) 93% WERE WITH BOLSONARO...HOWEVER LULA WON WITH THE HELP OF THOSE THAT COUNT THE VOTE.

This video is just a lie

Em 10 meses o Brasil já está voltando aos eixos, recorde positivo na balança comercial, previsão de crescimento pelo FMI atualizada acima das espectativas, o próprio FMI já prevê que ao final do ano o Brasil será a 9 economia do mundo.

We didn't they installed him like Biden.

What a biased video. Shame on this media outlet.

The bias is insane lol