Grande film, l'enigma a cui si riferisce il titolo non é certo quello della logica vuota e formale del professore, magistralmente caratterizzato come arrogante dall'attore e distorto e beffeggiato dal regista [che infatti gli fa dire: "Non ho imparato a capire, ma piuttosto ho imparato a ragionare"]. E' un film profondamente anti-borghese, il prof rappresenta la logica formale del nascente capitalismo, che Horkheimer vede fin dalla nascita sconnessa dalle necessitá materiali delle classi meno abbienti e lontana dalla furbizia popolare, che alla fine arriverá sempre piú in lá della logica vuota. Logica che in questo caso non fa altro che riprodurre il paradosso di Epimenide il Cretese.
@stfnbaМісяць тому
La traduzione in italiano qui non penso sia corretta: avendo controllato i sottotitoli in ingelse a me viene cosí: La domanda domanda del logico é: “se tu venissi dall’altro paese [di quelli che dicono la veritá], mi risponderesti di ‘no’ se io ti chiedessi se tu fosti venuto dal paese dei bugiardi?” Quello che viene dal paese dei ‘veritieri’ risponderebbe di no [non vengo dal paese dei bugiardi] Quello che viene dal paese dei bugiardi risponderebbe di sí [mentendo: ‘non vengo dal paese dei bugiardi’]
@MarcusLeziria2 місяці тому
Her name was Miranda
@valentinas.35132 місяці тому
Straordinario
@enzomarrocolo46732 місяці тому
Picnic ad Hangin Rock Miranda ti amo Enzo la vita e questo Film ❤ migliore numero 1❤ 🍀😿😘💓
@elgrande882 місяці тому
not bad
@Sindacatovangogh13 місяці тому
Che doppiaggio
@LauraDegliEsposti-ec2yp3 місяці тому
Magic masterpiece unique future
@srabanibhattacharya72393 місяці тому
The music gives me goosebumps..
@user-up9nh8yq2e3 місяці тому
wouldn't be the same without the soundtrack.
@versiincontroluce34544 місяці тому
This music is just my feeling now, unforgettable as a first love...❤️
@cumchazky_krab4 місяці тому
Почему то я начинаю плакать от этой музыки
@yaelpalombo40934 місяці тому
💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
@grittakuhlmann89274 місяці тому
...die Mode müßte mal wieder zurück kommen, dann müßten die Männer mit dem zufrieden sein was sie sehen würden 😊
@Yameron5 місяців тому
Donno whats with this tune but remeber as a teenager it profoundly touched my core...
@markwalford-groom6 місяців тому
still amazing it is now 2023
@eddiecromwell29546 місяців тому
I love this movie!
@1nikkigiese7 місяців тому
oh, im am i bothering you with how good this is?
@criticalmass1817 місяців тому
Been to Hanging Rock several times....Just as haunting as the soundtrack. There is NO hanging rock, though. 1/10 for the hanging rock expectation. 10/10 for the movie and soundtrack.
@dk04837 місяців тому
Amazing how many people are still drawn to this music and the movie. The most mesmerising, haunting and atmospheric piece of cinema/music. I have similar feelings about Bladerunner and Vangelis soundtrack.
@happierabroad7 місяців тому
The answer to the mystery is in the opening scene, where Miranda says that "we are in a dream within a dream" citing a famous poem. Therefore when they vanish, they are simply exiting the matrix and illusion of this world, which is a dream according to many spiritual traditions. I can't believe none of you noticed that except me. If you are a spiritual truth seeker, you are more likely to see these kind of things.
@loisknott37638 місяців тому
Fantastic
@mauriziodagostino43398 місяців тому
Certo che Robert De Niro senza la voce di Ferruccio Amendola sarebbe come la Bandiera Italiana senza il rosso ed il verde
@janaka12448 місяців тому
Moje studia filmowe i ten konkretny czas związany z tą muzyką właśnie. Na zawsze w ❤
@shapeofsoul19549 місяців тому
Чарует и уносит в место, которого не существует..
@davidegiandomenico13099 місяців тому
la seconda parte?
@federicasarcinelli67329 місяців тому
io avrei fatto la stessa domanda, magari invece di una pulce qualcos'altro, ma è quella più facile.😀
@derekmalouf580010 місяців тому
Memories of haunting soundtrack through my teenage years, bought the original soundtrack with original organist, loved the haunting yet magical sounds, eventually visited Mt Macedon and around the Grampians
@coloursofmusic681010 місяців тому
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
@bogdankeler98010 місяців тому
Romantic aristocratical time which past away and we are missing so much
@benwinter242010 місяців тому
The great God Pan . . or the mermaids siren song , Lucifer Medusa Madonna Venus . . if you prefer
@benwinter24203 місяці тому
Statue of Liberty
@benwinter24203 місяці тому
The maze between mother & son synchrotron . . Christ & Virgin Mary
@benwinter24203 місяці тому
The messenger
@mebius981611 місяців тому
Сочетание панфлейты и органа... это что-то!! Музыка производит неизгладимое впечатление!..
@erika767411 місяців тому
This music is hauntingly beautiful!
@gersonfittipaldi4039Рік тому
La seconda parteeeeeee
@louisestevenson5102Рік тому
BRAVO
@pieropane1634Рік тому
questa domanda usa la doppia negazione, il che significa che se la persona risponde "sì", sta implicitamente negando di venire dal paese in cui tutti dicono bugie, il che significa che viene dal paese in cui tutti dicono la verità. Se la persona risponde "no", sta implicitamente negando di venire dal paese in cui tutti dicono la verità, il che significa che viene dal paese in cui tutti dicono bugie.
@stfnbaМісяць тому
avendo controllato la traduzione inglese del dialogo, a me sembra il contrario.
@ecclesiastes7Рік тому
Pure genius, melding Romanian folk music, the doina, with a film set on the other side of the word, Australia of 1900. The girls are gorgeous and lively yet the music tells us something awfully sad and tragic is happening. Such is the impact of the music and scenery that it stays with you forever.
@nannifilippone3567Рік тому
the magic of this music and the film itself are unirivalled, as many Peter Weir's movies.
@MikeLeePhotoРік тому
This music is the definition of "Haunting"
@subashpadiyar6258Рік тому
Same tune at different pitch- teaches rookies like me
@subashpadiyar6258Рік тому
Haunting tune never to be forgotten... Very easy dippiction of higher notes with lower. Resolution of lower notes enhances the magic of weaving it thru the primitive flute. Magic pure Magic!!!
@stevieroger7478Рік тому
This is one of the most beautiful and emotion-evoking pieces of music I've ever heard. And it fits so well with the events of the film.
@TheoBassРік тому
I'm reading the novel now, after seeing the film for the third time. It doesn't hurt to be reading it with this indelible soundtrack in my head!
@shekharmukhopadhyay1563Рік тому
This background music haunted me since last 30 years. The mysterious movie never faded in my mind because of this heart touching music.