GOOD, BLOODY GREAT to hear the support for UKRAINE AND ITS PEOPLE FROM THIS BOARD. ALL THE BEST TO THE COUNTRIES CONTRIBUTING FOR THIS VERY BRAVE COUNTRY FIGHTING FOR YOUR FREEDOM AND LAND. PLEASE SEND MORE AID AND WHATEVER UKRAINE NEEDS NOW OR AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. NORTHERN IRELAND SUPPORT UNITED KINGDOM . XX❤

To blond Ukrainian warrior medic Yulia u are such inspiration I' got sentimental when you described your experiences that a lot of people died in your arms soldiers, elderly innocent civilian people women and children I' felt that your words through my heart and soul, u made history!!! Ukraine will win this war so no soldier have to be a dog of war no more!!! Yulia!!!

Wonderful and important Gathering of clever leaders. I Hope we all take it seriously as it is! Please spread the word and this Victor Pinchuk Foundation series! This is the way! Slava Ukraini & The World!

Excellent program, Thank you all for your courage to STAND TO THE COMMUNIST PUTIN!!!! JULIA THE SOLDIER I ADMIRE YOUR COURAGEOUS WORDS AND STORY. MAY GOD KEEP PROTECTING YOU AND ALL THE BRAVE PEOPLEVAND SOLDIERS IN EUKRAINE. SLAVA EUKRAINE❤

You’re right…don’t wait for the US or EU to figure out who is ready to give what and when. Do it yourself Victor. Don’t wait.

Full scale and unprovoked war of aggression. Russia is just a gas station with nukes. Taking apart washing machines to get microchips. And having supply chain problems. Thank you for your honesty from day 1.

Great panel. Proud of the Danish support of Ukraine. Slava Ukraini!💙💛

I don’t think Trump will do that at the expense of Ukraine. Most Republicans support Ukraine. Thank you to the USA and President Biden for his support for Ukraine !

Everything depends on the US and EU. If they want to win we will win. If not Russia will win. It’s as simple as that.

Prof. Tim Snyder ❤️. Greetings from Poland 🙂

This is such a profound important discussion -and its been held at a dinner party with people enjoying their food?! People need to take this seriously. How is this debate relegated to dinner-hour-entertainment?? This must be taken more seriously.

Well said Hillary Clinton.

Ukraine is a clear message to all of us, giving Ukrainians what we already have, Sweden.

I 'm ashamed to be Italian .. we still have inside the government political leaders with ties and cooperation with Putin party .. and the Kremlin' ..

💙💛Glory to Ukraine! 💙💛Glory to the heroes! 💙💛Please remember Ukraine!💙💛 Please continue to help Ukraine NOW!!! not in 2025 or next month we must help Ukraine months ago with what they need and ask for! with love from sweden 💙💛The latest we sent to Ukraine from Sweden is the most we have sent so far since February 2022.💙💛 S.O.S. mayday mayday💙💛 💙💛Слава Україні! 💙💛Героям слава! 💙💛Пам'ятайте про Україну!💙💛 Будь ласка, продовжуйте допомагати Україні ЗАРАЗ!!! не в 2025 році чи в наступному місяці ми повинні допомогти Україні кілька місяців тому тим, що їй потрібно і що просять! з любов'ю зі Швеції 💙💛Останнє, що ми надіслали в Україну зі Швеції, - це найбільше, що ми надіслали з лютого 2022 року.💙💛S.O.S. Mayday Mayday

Its so refreshing 😌 ❤ to listen to such an intelligent group of people. Thank you for your intelligence and posting your meeting ❤.

I'm a Canadian who has lived in Czech Rep. for 30 years...I can say that nobody among my Czech Family and friends were or are surprised about what Russia is doing...and I think I can safely say this about the vast majority of People in former Soviet Republics like the Baltics and countries formerly subjugated under Soviet "sphere of influence".. Is it any wonder why these nations (who have long proud histories before Soviet Domination) beat a hasty path to the EU and NATO when the opportunity arose. Western Europe and the "West" in general have been asleep at the wheel while Putin and his revanchist, history revisionist criminal mob were making it clear what their intentions were for the last 20 years. Western Europe is only now waking up...and we here are saying "I told you so". NATO has never been a threat to Russia's security or existence...but is has been threat to it's revanchism and imperialism. Until the Russian's "idea" of themselves changes...we will always have to deal with Russia's mythological understanding of itself and it's place in history and the world...and it's this collective Rusky Mir belief that will always present a danger. As unfathomable is this war seems to many...nobody here was or is surprised.

do prdele...if Julia's words arent enough none will be...Mr. Ferguson's words rang poignantly true...I experience every day how proximity and history create greatly different understanding and sense of urgency...my friends and family in Canada cant feel the danger and the urgency like we here in Czech Rep, or in Poland or in the Baltics or other places with proximity and history of Russia's aggression in the past and now...Mr. Ferguson is dead on about the concept of imagination...it couldn't be said better

I like the sense of urgency that I saw.

Rightly said so. ❤

2 years since the war started and they can't get their sh*t together

“sense of urgency is simply not clear enough” - sums it up perfectly.

👍👍👍👍Great presentation 👍👍👍

Why is Germany sending more armaments to Ukraine, including the long range Taurus missiles so Ukraine can defend itself? 💠

God bless Ukraine 🇺🇦 🙏 ❤ .

Good on Denmark. Europe appears to be waking up at last.

Bravo, Niall Ferguson. 👏👏👏

Bad idea to serve the food while doing speeches.

The Russian trolling on this video is very poor They are obviously missing Prygozhins troll farm

Munch security confetnce 2024 Please conduct seasfire agreement instead of support countries of weapons because to keep peace agreement frist priority according to international law in the world. With Best Regards Ms.Howida United Nations International Volunteer

I hate to tell you so. I didn’t need to be an elite politician, or military planner, to know that this was EXACTLY how this war between Ukraine and Russia was going to turn out.

Have a good and nice lunch.. UKRAINIAN DESERVE EVERYTHING..GOD BLESS AND PROTECT ÙKRAINE..LORD WE PRAY that LORD can FIND THE BEST WAY FOR UKRAINE PEACE.. SECURITY AND HAPPINRSS ❤❤❤❤

I personally think Ukraine 🇺🇦 bless every angel who are waiting to live with freedom in their country without interference from other countries n my point is I feel they have done enough by the war being in their country which has ruined a beautiful picturesque place anyone would love to be part of them not just that so determined people that has gone though he'll n back two years later bless them all, I watch them everyday n you can tell they will not stop until they win this war to say now we can all live with freedom n help one another as before the war. I needed to win for every single person as you have all been so brave n helped pull one another round when feel down so yes I think they have done their share with what they have done, some countries would not have even tried to go for Russia people was afraid but they will not be now, I think its our turn to give and other countries give with a big heart, do not look for America to give give give let's have one last go, let's do it now, l would like to give 500 hundred pound it's not alot but its a little bit to help, I love my Ukraine 🇺🇦 guys very much they work so hard bless them all, so brave, determined, courageous, strong, dedicated awesome guy's, Glory to Ukraine 🇺🇦, Glory to Ukraine 🇺🇦 and God bless you all everyday, I love you all toooooo biiitttttzzzzzzzz xxxxx xxxxx

The international approach to support Ukraine seems to lack a more complete understanding of the conflict's paradigm. The consequence of ignoring who is conflict and why leads to reductionist outcomes like war. Unfortunately, it is late and casualties keep on growing on both sides with no positive results for one or the other in conflict. Support to Ukrainians must be a combination of strategies to convince Russians to withdraw from their territory, not because "the force" is on the side of the Ukrainians but because not doing so is in detriment of basic quality of life, cultural virtue, and wealth of the people of the entire region. The future of all Europe (Russia included) is at stake! These talks need to address the participation of Russian organizations that are inclined for maintaining Ukrainian sovereignty and the autonomy of its Ukrainian government. Russian Universities, churches, media, unions, business associations, research institutions, even their military must understand the severity of the problem and how it has been reduced to a clash of force when it needs to be broken down into the multiple parts that make the problem solveable through dialogue, laws, treaties, or schemes. Structured programming describes ways of solving problems that kids in school learn. A similar approach to the conflict will certainly give way to both parts seeking a cease of fire, with agreements that can receive civil support, and could be supported afterwards by political movements. Let's not just put the solution in terms of ammunition needed, this is not Homer's Iliad but a XXI century conflict in which human intellect must prevail over violence. Can't we do that too? My highest respect to Ukrainians and their brave men and women in their fight for independence

Thanks for being realistic

Victor Pinchuk is worth $1.44 billion. How much money has he given to Ukraine? Have any of his children fought on the front line? Highly doubt it.

Fredriksen and Clinton impressed the most!

If war was fast-food, they would all be dressed like Ronald Mcdonald.

Too much talk We need action!

And Mike Johnson told GOP congress to go on recess for 2 weeks? Unreal

Problem is that Putin has the west "buffaloed", to use a term coined by the legendary Wyatt Earp! It's a sad state of affairs.

In Belgium Prime Minister De Croo and his party are the biggest supporters of Ukraine. Still I think he can do better. 7 billion Euro intrest should be send immediately and also the F16's. Their is no reason for any delay.

#SlavaUkraini

The demise of western dominance.

The 7th free ukrainian lunch! And you tell your people that there is no such thing as a free lunch!

All these moneys they are wasting in travelling and meeting, could help Ukraine with those.

Hillary Clinton you should be running America

Russia has soldiers from other countries. Why can we not do the same. Someone needs to grow a pair.

What is the intent of NATO with respect to russia?

Ukrainians will never forget your father in law had been coerced in giving up Ukraine nuclear potential in particular, by the husband of the woman in the centre of the panel so now she's been trying to clean up the mess.

You should all unite all thise have their robots to make an sercuit to make component to make PCB containing how to make many drones missiles All fabric about steel allunminum. Give them a pattern to make the body of all weapons. I'll give you fabric that you could help steel fabric and 3M fabri in helmets. They are all over the world.

Thenkju you end demokracis

Europe is sleping, republicans shames of States are with Putin, soldiers and people of Ucraine is dying! Be strong Ucraina! I'm sorry for people of Ucraina! Slava Ucraina! A big hug for army and particularly soldiers of AZOV, from albania!

People with suicidal intiutions discussing in one room and are not even aware.

MAGAtt Moscow Marjorette Traytor Grinch would say that the crippled and dead heroes deserved what happened to them. I say: Слава Україні! Героям Слава! Мученикам вічна подяка!

Не учу и мне без него не нормально

It was embarrassing to listen to Mr. Yermak’s broken English. Was it so difficult to have an interpreter?

WWIII

who funds this "gatherings"

Dogs of War, should be the takeaway from this program…

Corruption at great level

Fashism is not the answer

Hot air has never achieved anything

Bann Tik Tok

Clinton should be in jail.

😂😂😂😂hahahahaha why ! hahaha😅😅😅😅

It looks like meeting communist party.

Where was this collective European concern about Ukraine's victory in 2014 after Russia's two invasions and annexation of Crimea in 2014? For 8 years, Europe pressured Ukraine to trade land for meaningless peace treaties with Russia which it used to build it weapons and forces for the next invasion in 2022. As it did with every American President since President Eisenhower critical of Europes's inadequate funding of their own defense, Europe ignored President Trump's calls for Europe to spend at least 2% of GDP on defense three years after NATO countries unanimously pledged to do so. After most European countries cut their defense spending from 3% to 1.3% of GDP since the end of the Cold War, only 3 NATO members paid at least 2% of GDP for defense in 2014. Ten years later, only 11 of 31 NATO countries fulfilled this commitment while the EU sent Russia billions in Euros as profits for oil and LNG imports annually. Anthony King, a professor of war studies at the University of Warwick, wisely said, Europe has 'systematically demilitarized itself because it didn’t need to spend the money,” thanks to an over reliance on U.S. military dominance around the globe. “They have basically gone to sleep.” Seeing Hillary Clinton on this panel is proof those organizing this panel discussion willfully ignore her contributions to Russia's predictable aggression as a result of her famous "reset" with Russia in March 2009. After Russia's invasion, the Obama-Biden administration provided minimal support to Ukraine with tepid sanctions on Russia and non-lethal military aid . The fact is the Republican led U.S. House of Representatives passed a comprehensive aid package including $61 billion in new aid to Ukraine last December. President Biden threatened to veto it and his Democrat party in the U.S. Senate defeated this bill.

All the losers in one place...

You talk and talk but you do nothing.

Украинка попала в плен русским садистам её избивали каждый день плена , это очень хороша что выступила на Мюнхенской Конференции

It very sad that west promise ukraine that west is stand behind but now they are not there...at the end they will fled like Afghanistan and Ukraine will be destroyed...where is humanity just provoke n left hopeless.

What a shitshow.🎉

All that money

Hilary Clinton ,an important American with proud European Welsh history protecting the freedom we value so much.

Timmy Snyder. Stop casting spells with your paws. Send in your kids. They will do well as well.

Ермак учи инглишь не позорься

Slava Russia💪

What a deluded bunch of warmongers… not a single one of them mentioned peace .

There are 500 years of war of Western colonialists against Slavic people. Sloveni wake up!

Let's not kid ourselves. In perhaps a year, NATO's largest military force will no longer be on the European continent. Then each country will look after itself and the Baltic states will have to pursue a more realistic foreign policy for existential reasons. Kaja Kallas should behave like an adult and assess the situation realistically.

These criminals and traitors have no rights to speak on behalf of the Malorussian people.

Ukraine wants your CASH CASH CASH CASH CASH MONEY 💰💰💰💰

It's good to see Hillary Clinton in attendance and support. May God bless Ukraine!!! 💙💛 From America !!!💙❤🤍

No it's not and you are about to see I just enjoy being dumb it's real until triggered ❤️🇷🇺🇺🇦🦾😇🕊️