Jews like Noam and Ilan do more to counter antisemitism than any of the other stuff combined.

I can't even remember what I read last week. Prof Chomsky, who is well into his 90's, still remembers facts from 1966. Its amazing.

Dr. Chomsky is a living treasure.

In my high school days, I picked up a copy of the book Gaza in Crisis: Reflections on Israel's War against the Palestinians by Chomsky and Pappé. The work of these two brilliant men produced a lifetime of enquiry and study, and have profoundly influenced my thinking since. These are two wonderful human beings, fighting for a just cause.

Noam Chomsky. What a phenomenally inspirational human being. Unimpeachable integrity, out of this world psychological balance, sublime self effacement And a purring Rolls Royce of a mind , unstinstintingly, unwaveringly dedicated to the service of our common humanity .

I adore this man more than any other single human being on the planet alive today. We are so blessed to have him.

It's the 30th of October 2023, the 23rd Day of Israel's siege in Gaza. Would it be possible for Ilan and Noam to do a follow-up discussion? The world is on the brink of destruction

Hope Prof Chomsky gets 200 years old ❤️

Even in his advanced years, still as sharp as ever! Mr. Chomsky, one of my favorite speakers...even though I disagree with much of his entrenched left wing talking points. Great discussion.

Multiple of major truth tellers of these times in the same discussion! I don't know why I am watching this almost one month later!. Thanks to you all for having this discussion!

Breath of fresh air. Both Pappe and Chomsky are lucid on these issues.

Actual lecture starts at 9:00

I am alumnus of Exeter Univ. and used to work on Prof Chomsky's book Generative Grammar, Proud of the university's discussing Palestine and Israel conflicts. Hope it will contribute to the resolving the problems

We are privileged to attend this conversation between two of the most prominent historians of contemporary era!

Amazing gathering! Thx

So good to hear this, much gratitude to the speakers here.

This was refreshing

Thank you all; and special thanks to Prof.Chomsky & Prof.Ilan Pappé and whom organized this event ..

Thanking UKposts for giving us this opportunity to listen to such highly intellectual teachers.

Oh my goodness. The Jordan River. My eyes are wide open. Bewildered

Bless Chomsky! He is one of the Philosopher Kings Plato was talking about.

Noam I could listen to you talk all day,you are the most intelligent and interesting person I've ever come across. - just wish I could remember half of the factual information that you share with us-Thankyou.

Very educative and informative 👌

Eu me sinto honrada de ter nascido tantas décadas depois desses homens e vê-los juntos e dividindo essa mesma sala de debate

Gratitude for your great service to truth and global understanding and peace.

Thank you for inligting us with the knowledge to comprehend what we creaved

Absolutely enlightening. Thank you for doing and posting this.

Glad you mentioned Prevent.

Watching from Australia.

So worthwhile to hear!

The truth will out. It may take many agonizing years, but the light will shine on the truth.

Enlightening me about what I wasn’t thinking of

Dr. Chomsky, hooray for your strength and dedication! Did you hear Dr. Jeffrey Sach's address to the UN Security Council on November 22, and if so cold you comment?

I hope you are all well now.

I have no idea why we call ourselves civilized. What is being described is not civilization, it is barbarity and we are fine BarBarians. I read somewhere that it is a conspiracy theory to state that the so-called rich Western countries are determined to kill off "useless eaters" but it really appears that the browner nations and the poor everywhere are being left to fend for ourselves (I'm only poor in Western eyes, otherwise, I'm fairly wealthy in comparison).

Ilan Pappe hasn't chaired the Emil Touma Institute until 2006, according to his Exeter University site.

those guy papé and chomsky are big brains

Holy moly! I thought Howard Hughes passed away a long time ago!

Bonsoir est ce qu on peut avoir la traduction en français svp ?

❤

I really want to hear Chomsky’s opinion on 15 minute cities, compulsory vaccination, WHO, WEF, the farmers protests. No one seems to ask this, Ilan Pappe got close but I’m not satisfied😂

Please. Find a way to turn up the volume on Your end. We can only tune up so much. Noam was barely audible.

Yellow is my favorite color 😎🙌💛🤍🕵️‍♀️🕰👂💯

Only Norman Finkelstein is missing from this pre eminent trinity of scholars on this subject.

If the established institutions/agencies of the states doing unfair to the people at large, disorganized crime starts. Of course there is no such firm body to analyize in real time to punish such institutions which are doing illegality.

Committee established in 1953

Start at 09.00 min

20:00 Norm gets a mention. _JC

So Gandalf in our age is called Noam Chomsky. I'm okay with that.

63 likes, Noam remembers facts from 1966.

Police protection?

I was told there would be self hating Jews here. Please point me in their general direction.

Born in 63

it's interesting to reevaluate 2 years later, in light of up to date knowledge about how Covid and the vaccines themselves actually behave, what Chomsky says starting at 45:07. if I'm interpreting correctly, Chomsky says that everyone knew that failing to roll out the vaccines to every poor country worldwide immediately, wealthy people in wealthy countries were basically committing suicide.

FromEgypt, we love our President sissi.

wow, amazin video. how come no comments?

where's the gofundme to get pappé a good mic

Ben Shapiro would lose his mind over this 😂

Stop Genocide and massacre in Palestine

Chomsky makes mistakes too. His misstep on the Khmer Rouge as one example

You have a yellow cup.

CHOMSKY GOT THE ENTIRE COVID19 SCENE WRONG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ha, business has been devoid of moral responsibility from the beginning. 😅

Google UKposts censors. And I hate that. If you.would like to know more ask. I no longer provide knowledge without being commissioned.

He lost me when he talked about the plandemic and Black Lives Matter and sanders. 😂

Kalau islam memprioritaskan kehalalan kebenaran keadilan dll walau dimusui. Allahswt pasti esa, kalau dua pasti bebenturan kekuasaan. Kita ikut anis menyita koruptor koruptor yang diloloskan hakim hakim titipan dll. Sebenarnya kekayaan alam emas dll itu cukup untuk memuliakan segenap rakyat dll mati syahid langsung merasa disurga

"I am happy to be a fascist!" - Miri Regev, Israeli Minister of Culture

42:00---Indeed the GOP is absolutely DESPERATE to stop people voting for the changes they really want, and I hope/pray that most Americans rise against their shameful and criminal acts against democracy for the Mango Mussolini and his moronic minions.

If I could ask Chomsky anything it would be: You talk highly of internationalism; what is so different between your idea of internationalism and Zionism? In my mind they are closely related.

53, I have 5 pierced holes in my left ear, and 3 holes in my right. Hmm😎🙌👂🕵️‍♀️🕰

He got it wrong about BLM.

Secuarlizim

Except for Noam’s comments on the unreliable vaccines, this is great!

Both of these distinguished professors are just prolonging the agony of the middle east conflict pretending and trying to get weak minded people like most of the viewers here to believe that there is " justice" in the world between nations; a concept which is not extant in international relations. What they should be doing is acting like mature adults with wisdom, not like self perpetuating agents of ethereal visions. In short they continue the political masturbation of the people who want nothing but to terminate the State of Israel. The problem those people have really has more to do with the shame of many Arab people feeling powerless that a small despised minority, the Jews, suddenly empowered itself and made them and their political leaderships look and feel foolish and inadequate. They don't like it that the refugee nation of Israel beat Arab states and armies in battle and that "white" people beat "people of color" and colonized them. The actual material issues are picayune compared to the issues in the entire world, let alone the middle east. The territory involved is tiny. A few thousand square miles, most of it desert, with no oil or natural resources. (If you exclude the Negev desert, which had tens of thousands of Bedouin, many of whom cooperated with Israel and fought for it in 1948, then the balance of the Palestine Mandate territory has been split between Israel and the Palestinian Authority in roughly equal measures.) The scale of death likewise pales compared to everything else which has gone on in this part of the world. Lebanese Civil War, 200,000 dead. Syrian civil war 500,000 dead. Iraq war 750,000 dead. Iran-Iraq war 1,000 000 dead. Algerian civil war 200,000 dead. Israel/Palestine: In 1948 Israel lost 6000 dead. Palestinians: Aref el Aref's book gives 2000 dead (13,000 "nameless"). BTW, many of the Palestinian refugees "drifted" back to their homes or other Arab areas after 1948; the number can only be guessed at. Assume the right of return: fine. It may be a right, is it a solution? )Even Chomsky agrees on that point. Returning to Palestine, what will the refugee or his children or more likely grandchildren find? An Arab Islamic country? Does he dream of coexistence in a binational state (an idea of some Zionists, never reciprocated by any Arab people) like Noam Chomsky, who still calls himself a Zionist? Will the returning refugee find his street? his neighborhood? More likely he will have the experience of many Palestinians who returned to see their old homes, saw different streets, views, people, sometimes the same house, feeling indignant, angry and sad, but kick out the new tenants? A sad shake of the head. Where is the old baker? The girls' school? the little brook, the stand of trees, the field where we used to play? In life there is loss. Instead of trying to cultivate pipe dreams as an arc of international affairs, these old guys should do the right thing: tell their people: yes there is loss. Yes, there is mourning. Yes you can't make eggs out of an omelette. Tell them the truth: that the Jews didn't come as a conquering army to rob the land of its non-existent resources, of its own grinding poverty. The Jews didn't even want to come. They came because of the tsunami of hate, murder and destruction that was blown their way and they washed up on the shores of Palestine, where at least if they dug into the ground their kids could read the ancient buried things. Israel was not built by Zionists. Zionists wanted to cut a deal with, move in pacifically, maybe some wanted to buy out the inhabitants, maybe some wanted to kick them off the land. Regardless, the vast majority of the Jews came because they were refugees with no place else to go like Mr. and Mrs. Pappe, whose son you hear. It was not ideology that drove them. It was biology, the instinct to live and to protect ones' s wife and children, The Palestinians it is true are not at fault. They were the innocent victims of the Tsunami. against the Jews. But then the Jews revolutionized and turned themselves from this bunch of desperate and despised penniless refugees into a nation. And when the Arab states, in their horror and shame, gave effect to their worst tribal instincts by expelling their Arab Jews who landed in Israel, these Arab states thus had a hand in molding the new nation. A flight of fancy in a moment of anger took wing. Now these two strains of the Jews, the European and the Arab Jews lived together in uneasy (dis)harmony, until recent decades when they they started to intermarry and make babies that were neither European Jews nor Arab Jews. There is a new nation. The Israel nation. They are Jews but they are not "the Jews." The "Jews" are an ancient minority group moving from country to country for almost 2000 years. The Israelis are not "the Jews." They are a nation that enjoys political independence and sovereignty. These two distinguished professors should be telling their supporters, most of whom are young and unsophisticated (appearances to the contrary notwithstanding) to stop their obsessive search for the bad guys who are behind all problems. The most intractable problems arise from the desire to do good. They should be telling their audiences to deal with reality. SHIT HAPPENS. And most of the time it's irreversible. By constantly picking at the scabs without acknowledging the loss, our two professors persist in placing themselves at the head of the problematics instead of the problem solvers. I suspect they know full well that the Israelis are a nation, not less than than the Palestinians. That the Palestinians indeed suffered loss, and that the loss cannot be made up no matter what. That the Arab Muslim land of Palestine, part of the great Islamic Umma, where the sound of the muezzin is heard, where sheep loll on the meadows, where bedouin farmers till the rocky soil on the terraces and the sounds and smells of the old souk both repel and inspire, all that won't come back. You can't do it with some Potemkin style building blocks. By failing to tell the truth our friends here don't allow their flock to do what the human heart needs to do in times of loss: to mourn. Mourning is good for the soul. To acknowledge the truth of loss is cathartic. These old boys deny their followers the emotional catharsis that would better prepare them for the new world of reconciliation and acceptance. By drumming the old war drums dressed in academic accoutrements, they do no favor to to their followers or anyone else naive enough to believe in fairy tale solutions and cartoonish thinking. Who knows? Maybe things will turn around on a dime.לאלוהים פתרונים

Beardo weirdo

Them Israel haters is fun to hear

Nakba was result of Palestinians backing Nazis during WWII Opinion: The longer only one side of the so-called Palestinian Catastrophe is cultivated, the longer hatred will continue to be nurtured, while historical facts point to Palestinians openly supporting Nazi propaganda during WWII

So many clowns)))

Chomsky is overrated, and Pappe is a fool!

Gender studies….. with attitude pronunciation… uh boy…. bye…