Fiona Hill - Rather than a Real Threat NATO was an Irritating Barrier to Putin's Imperial Ambitions.

  Переглядів 153,516

Silicon Curtain

Silicon Curtain

День тому

GUEST: Dr Fiona Hill is a British-American foreign affairs specialist and author.
----------
From 2007-08 Putin came to believe that the West was in decline, degenerate and weak. It’s at that moment he pronounced a more assertive Russia, and started to act accordingly on the world stage, and in relations to neighbouring countries, with the invasion of Georgia in 2008, and Crimea in 2014. NATO provocation is one excuse given for Russian aggression and is prominent in domestic Russian propaganda. But it’s unlikely he saw NATO as a threat and must have known they had neither the intent nor capability to directly threaten Russian territory. Afterall, why would they when Europe’s economy depended on Russian gas and oil? Rather he may have seen NATO as an irritating barrier to his new imperial ambitions to unite the Russian speaking world, and former colonial territories.
----------
SPEAKER:
Fiona Hill is a British-American foreign affairs specialist and author. She is a former official at the U.S. National Security Council, specializing in Russian and European affairs, and was a witness in the November 2019 House hearings during the first impeachment of Donald Trump. She earned a Ph.D. in history from Harvard University in 1998. She currently serves as a Senior Fellow at the Brookings Institution in Washington and will take up office as Chancellor of Durham University in England in summer of this year. She recently served as deputy assistant to the president and senior director for European and Russian affairs on the National Security Council from 2017 to 2019. From 2006 to 2009, she served as national intelligence officer for Russia and Eurasia at The National Intelligence Council. She is author of “There Is Nothing for You Here: Finding Opportunity in the 21st Century” and co-author of “Mr. Putin: Operative in the Kremlin” (Brookings Institution Press, 2015). Hill has researched and published extensively on issues related to Russia, the Caucasus, Central Asia, regional conflicts, energy, and strategic issues.
----------
BOOKS:
There Is Nothing for You Here: Finding Opportunity in the Twenty-First Century (2021)
Mr. Putin: Operative in the Kremlin (2015)
The Siberian Curse: How Communist Planners Left Russia Out in the Cold (2003)
----------
#ukraine #ukrainewar #russia #zelensky #putin #propaganda
#war #disinformation #hybridwarfare #foreignpolicy #communism #sovietunion #postsoviet
----------
WATCH NEXT:
John Sipher
• Russia Must not be All...
David Satter
• Resurgence of Soviet T...
Mark Galeotti
• Mark Galeotti - Crimin...
Vlad Vexler
• Vlad Vexler - The Long...
----------
CHAPTERS:
00:00 Introduction
----------
PLATFORMS:
Twitter: / curtainsilicon
Instagram: / siliconcurtain
Podcast: open.spotify.com/show/4thRZj6...
Linkedin: / finkjonathan
Patreon: / siliconcurtain
----------
Welcome to the Silicon Curtain podcast. Please like and subscribe if you like the content we produce. It will really help to increase the popularity of our content in UKposts’s algorithm. Our material is now being made available on popular podcasting platforms as well, such as Spotify and Apple Podcasts.

КОМЕНТАРІ: 1 000
@toby9999
@toby9999 Рік тому
Russia attacks it's neighbours, russifies them, takes away their independence, persecutes its citizens, commits genocide and then wonders why said neigbours don't want a repeat.
@andremacko5408
@andremacko5408 Рік тому
Completely agree. Although I'm sure Dr. Hill understands that point, she seems to avoid directly stating that and goes off onto tangents and into nuances about Western diplomatic misplays in dealing with Russia. Poppycock! The interview hit it on the nose at the start of the interview when he said Putin based his expansionist play on MYTHOLOGICAL history. Also the academic failure of Western academicians to clearly state the difference between Rus'-Ukraine and Moscovia-Russia (Rosiya) plays into the Kremlins hand in falsely blending the history of two different territories and definitely time lines.
@captain34ca
@captain34ca Рік тому
America showed them how.
@krakhedd
@krakhedd Рік тому
@@captain34ca America didn't even exist before the Russian Empire, bub. Try again!
@pouncepounce7417
@pouncepounce7417 Рік тому
@@captain34ca Yeah all the area the US conquered from canada....
@BearAnkles
@BearAnkles Рік тому
@@captain34ca clown comment
@divumque
@divumque Рік тому
The USA occupying Europe? Those who believe this absurdity need to see how happy are countries like Poland, the Baltic countries, Romania etc welcoming American forces and American military sites in those countries. American and NATO forces in general represent the security of these countries and a barrier against Russian aggression.
@teutonalex
@teutonalex Рік тому
America just attacked an allied country (Germany), destroyed its economically vital energy infrastructure and caused a massive ecological disaster in the Baltic sea. The America that built the post 1945 world order no longer exists.
@paolodandrea4299
@paolodandrea4299 Рік тому
It's a fact tho that the USA is occupying Europe, or at least part of it. I was born and raised in Italy and I can tell you that Italian sovereignty is limited based on USA interest, so I have a really hard time to see Russia as my enemy since they never did nothing harmful to Italy
@ennediend2865
@ennediend2865 Рік тому
@@paolodandrea4299 You should check the definition of "occupation"... You should try Russian occupation You would know the difference . Washington didn't chose G. Meloni as PM : Italian people elected her...
@paolodandrea4299
@paolodandrea4299 Рік тому
@@ennediend2865 this might sock you but there isn't any Russian military bases in Italy but there is plenty of US military bases. When it comes to Meloni sure she was elected by Italians but right before the elections that everybody new she was going to win the co-founder of her party Grosetto flew to Washington to assure US that nothing was going to change. If you are aware of Meloni political history you would know that her foreign policy is completely different of her views before becoming PM
@eh1702
@eh1702 Рік тому
“ It's a fact tho that the USA is occupying Europe” What utter crap! Almost everybody in Europe has never personally seen an American military uniform or vehicle. Utter stupid ignorant bilge.
@martindice5424
@martindice5424 10 місяців тому
Fiona Hill is a very knowledgeable woman. A privilege to listen to her.
@ned900
@ned900 Рік тому
Gold Standard Guest
@bungalowjuice7225
@bungalowjuice7225 Рік тому
Dr. Fiona Hill! What a pleasant person! Glad she is on our side.
@lawrenceralph7481
@lawrenceralph7481 Рік тому
Big mouths causing trouble is damaging, no matter what side.
@tigertiger1699
@tigertiger1699 Рік тому
We in the west are incredibly lucky and well served..
@alanbrookes6637
@alanbrookes6637 Рік тому
Fiona is exceptional, intelligent & sincere.
@tigertiger1699
@tigertiger1699 Рік тому
@@alanbrookes6637 Sure is… though I not sure that I like “sincere” …. People can cut off your head will bro g sincerely sorry about it.. How about she’s is straight, open and honest..
@lawrenceralph7481
@lawrenceralph7481 Рік тому
@@alanbrookes6637A liberal intent on evangelizing democracy, even when it may not be in a location or at a time in US interests. This war was avoidable. She missed the signs and misjudged the actions. Neville Chamberlain was articulate, wise and sincere. Louis XVI was forgiving, educated, generous and weak. Czar Nicholas was reserved and dumb. All were the wrong men at the wrong place at the wrong time. They took the wrong action. Fiona is that girl.
@alexv850
@alexv850 Рік тому
Great interview. The best in depth analysis on thy net. Agree 100 % with Dr. Hill. Never bow to sick dictators. Slava Ukraine from Hungary. Glory to the heroes of Ukraine. 🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
@johntucker5994
@johntucker5994 Рік тому
I love listening to and learning from Dr. Hill and have tremendous respect for her. Congratulations and best wishes to her in her new position as Chancellor of Durham University in northeastern UK. This new appointment will bring her back to the County of her birth, no doubt to be closer to her family. It also must be very gratifying for her to serve as Chancellor at such a historic and prestigious university. For the daughter of a coal miner, Dr. Hill has led an incredible and impressive life. Everyone should remember: Dr. Hill's boss, John Bolton, who was born in the U.S., was un-American, cowardly and cynically motivated to sell more copies of his book when he refused to testify before the U.S. House or Senate in the first impeachment of President Trump over his extortionary telephone call with Ukraine's President Zelinsky. (Why CNN gives John Bolton any air time as some credible, respectable commentator is beyond me; but that has been par for the course for CNN.) Remember also: It was left to John Bolton's underlings, Dr. Fiona Hill and Alexander Vindman, both immigrants to the U.S. and both naturalized U.S. citizens, to take the heat (including death threats) and testify truthfully before Congress at great personal cost. So, we all owe a debt of gratitude to Dr. Hill for her integrity and courage.
@Muddy283
@Muddy283 Рік тому
Wow! Fiona Hill none other!! Who will be next on your illustrious list of interviewees?? How do you get all these heavyweights??? This is an *absolute* must watch. Getting out the popcorn right now.
@SiliconCurtain
@SiliconCurtain Рік тому
Got another big one at the end of the month 😜
@aaronwalsh8469
@aaronwalsh8469 Рік тому
@@SiliconCurtain found your channel few weeks ago. Great insights into Russia and the Ukraine war. Keep up the good work. There’s a good channel with Jake broe , he does almost daily videos about the Ukraine war . He has a lot of viewers . Maybe get contact with him and do an interview. Grow your channel.
@rwbmusic
@rwbmusic Рік тому
Roger Waters, and others who insist that Russia was provoked, needs to hear this perspective from Fiona Hill and amend their stance.
@steve-real
@steve-real Рік тому
22:37 “And it really does come down to the fact that Russia, unfortunately, over the last 23 years, has evolved into a system where only one man counts. And it’s gone back to kind of, as you say, to the period of the Czars were we’re now in a kind of succession crisis.” - Fiona Hill great observation and a bit concerning to be honest
@PeterA650
@PeterA650 Рік тому
And this is exactly how this war will end. Putin will die, then succession chaos will and in-fighting will bring about the military collapse.
@SiliconCurtain
@SiliconCurtain Рік тому
It’s actually worse- because in tsarist times there were a range of advisors around the tsar, and competing class interests. Today’s Russia has far fewer checks and balances than the Soviet Union even! It’s like the bit in Star Wars when a Sith Lord takes over the republic and kills everyone….
@steve-real
@steve-real Рік тому
@@SiliconCurtain When Putin dies it’s going to be a mad dash for power and position. I don’t know enough even to guess what may happen next.
@decaesaris5093
@decaesaris5093 Рік тому
RuSSia wasallways that way during all its existence. Now just dropped off its mask(yrovka)
@ulrikschackmeyer848
@ulrikschackmeyer848 Рік тому
At least the Zar did not have nukes in the Eremitage.
@resrussia
@resrussia Рік тому
Yes, a sequel! Dr. Hill is one of the best observers of Russia.
@resrussia
@resrussia Рік тому
Also, your series is excellent. I enjoy listening to the commentary from your experts. This is UKposts at its best.
@tonyv5202
@tonyv5202 Рік тому
​@@resrussia 🤡
@resrussia
@resrussia 11 місяців тому
@@Knucklehead4400 Thank you for your comment. However, you didn't explain why you think Mearscheimer's analysis is better than Hill's.
@andrewackerley9985
@andrewackerley9985 Рік тому
We're very proud of Fiona Hill here in the UK. A very clever & knowledgeable lady who left England for good reason & much bigger opportunities in the US. Girl Done Good! I'm equally glad she may be returning to Britain in some small way, with her connection to Durham University. Great stuff. Putin is toast. Sláva Ukraini!
@kevinwillis6707
@kevinwillis6707 Рік тому
He definitely miscalculated NATO response, now his ego has him trapped in a costly war that eventually will have Russia conceding defeat. Dr Hill sums him up accurately.
@FirstLast-di5sr
@FirstLast-di5sr Рік тому
I have the utmost respect for Dr. Hill, thank you both for doing this interview!
@rikcoach1
@rikcoach1 Рік тому
There are bad people in the world. This is why we need to stop the predators and not go easy on them. Its normal to have compassion for people and to be understanding of their “come from.” But, at the end of the day we must deal with bullies, predators, victimizers despite our compassion.
@Forest_Knight
@Forest_Knight Рік тому
Fiona is great as always. On Putin as a "history man": he showed this streak just a few years into his presidency, when he had the grave of Anton Denikin, a Russia imperial general, moved back to Russia. He made a point it was funded by his own money.
@enidsnarb
@enidsnarb Рік тому
Not only is her viewpoint one of the most astute and accurate on Putin but her northern accent is perhaps my favorite in the English language !
@jessehachey2732
@jessehachey2732 2 місяці тому
I know right! I’ve got a huge intellectual crush on her! 😍
@andyhurrell
@andyhurrell Рік тому
Fiona Hill knows her onions. Five stars. Thank you.
@Forheavenssake1ify
@Forheavenssake1ify Рік тому
She is correct, the US struggled strongly against entering BOTH the first and second World Wars.
@macmcleod1188
@macmcleod1188 Рік тому
Unfortunately the neocon movement is much more aggressive. But outside of that, the US did also intervene in the Shah of Iran situation. I view that as our worst misstep. They had a democratically elected leader who hated the United States so the US overturned that government and help install a dictator. A really horrific dictator. And that was before the neocons. The US has also been implicated in collapsing currencies. I think World War 1 & 2 changed American leadership to be more interventionist.
@jasonlast7091
@jasonlast7091 Рік тому
This woman is a geopolitical celebrity in my book. I don’t know how you scored this interview but it has to be the most valuable yet, by far. God I would love to ask her so many questions.
@richardgough1393
@richardgough1393 Рік тому
Fiona will become Chancellor of Durham University next year. My partner works there and I'm really hoping to meet her.
@jimgraham6722
@jimgraham6722 Рік тому
It is not a cultural conflict. Ukraine's value to Russia lies in its natural resources, land, oil, gas and minerals onshore as well as offshore in Sea of Azov and Black Sea. Just as the English did in invading Scotland, should Russia prevail it will as far as possible clear the 'little Russian' population driving them as refugees to the West or exhiling them to the east per Stalin's example with the Tartars. With the native population cleared or subjugated, Putin and his cronies will swoop on the spoils.
@richarddriscoll666
@richarddriscoll666 Рік тому
its a narrative based think tank she represents Raythion and friends....
@bellbookcandle3051
@bellbookcandle3051 Рік тому
@@richarddriscoll666 *Raytheon* 😐
@roymaddocks3184
@roymaddocks3184 Рік тому
Fiona is featured on quite a few other excellent videos as well
@ronaldbarrett3112
@ronaldbarrett3112 9 місяців тому
Fiona Hill is a bright, intelligent spot in the media-news world. Thanks to Fiona Hill we learn lots about our world.
@gap6533
@gap6533 Рік тому
Between Ukrainian voices describing the cultural and informational realities of the war, and eminent experts like Fiona Hill providing global context, this channel is a very valuable source for understanding the invasion. 🇺🇦
@davewiggin7305
@davewiggin7305 Рік тому
If you and Fiona have only covered 25% of the questions you were going to ask, when do we get the other 75? Brilliant interview
@SiliconCurtain
@SiliconCurtain Рік тому
🤞 I hope to get the chance!
@20chocsaday
@20chocsaday Рік тому
I wonder how things work out if Ukraine allied with North Korea.
@ulrikschackmeyer848
@ulrikschackmeyer848 Рік тому
@@SiliconCurtain Please tell Dr Hill that we are many who thirst for those deep, thoughtful, (and it at all possible: constructive ) answers! Your collaboration could really create a new, more solid foundation, make a difference, turning the 'click bait tragedy' of general UKposts, into a sincere popular movement even? Of course not appeasement, Heaven forbid, but a growing group of people advocating, demanding? even, that this conflict based on 'cross-purpose, BUT APPARENTLY MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE worldviews' not ONLY be taken militarily seriously, but ALSO psychologically, philosophically etc (you could ask Vlad Vexler to join in). In order to find a more PERMANENTLY VIABLE solution.
@ewoksalot
@ewoksalot Рік тому
Dr. Hill, Julia Ioffe, Alexander Vindman... there are so many great voices that provide so many different perspectives on the Russian/Slavic world. Really appreciate Dr. Hill's insight.
@brycecousens8859
@brycecousens8859 Рік тому
Yet another amazing guest and discussion. Great stuff.
@ronaldkincaid4404
@ronaldkincaid4404 Рік тому
Until the FSB is dug out of the Russian body politic there is no real hope for meaningful rapprochement with the RF.
@SiliconCurtain
@SiliconCurtain Рік тому
Absolutely
@timtrewyn453
@timtrewyn453 Рік тому
You have hit the nail on the head.
@josephballerini3730
@josephballerini3730 Рік тому
A very inconsequential observation: Fiona Hill has my favorite British accent. Very soothing. I know she has said her Northern England accent was a negative back home. I love it.
@JoaoMariaNunes
@JoaoMariaNunes Рік тому
giving Ukraine to the Russians to appease them, reminds me of what we did back in the 30's with the old Bohemia ( Czech Republic ) when we closed our eyes to Adolf's pretensions...just to prevent a war, and we know how well it played out
@Ms_Ve
@Ms_Ve Рік тому
Fiona Hill is a planetary treasure.
@PowhiroMus
@PowhiroMus Рік тому
Please do a sequel, Fiona is one smart, articulate woman with huge insight, experience and appreciation,! An obviously talented analyst who always manages to distil complex issues down to easy, simple explanation. You only touched on it at the end but I've always viewed Putin the Putrid as a cunning but unsophisticated ruthless conservative thug. To me he seem threatened by the emerging Russian contemporary view of life and wants to return, for safety, to the conservative, "old" world that he knows and feels comfortable with. He likes being an autocratic leader for life, a dictator or tsar. He feels threatened by modern culture, modern democracy, independent thought. He cannot stand Ukraine being an independent country free of subservience to Moscow and worries that the Ukrainian independence example threatens his rule of Russia, essentially the existential threat to Russia that democracy and freedom of thought means. Please invite Fiona to discuss this aspect.
@tobiwan001
@tobiwan001 Рік тому
The Russian economy depended on Europe. Not the other way round. As can be seen in the data. 85% of Russian exports went to Europe. Putin just thought Europe would not care about the annexation of Ukraine. And that it would be easy.
@deeglloyd
@deeglloyd Рік тому
Fantastic interview. Dr. Hill is a national treasure. "Putin provoked himself" what a quote. I hope there is a sequel!
@Paulus8765
@Paulus8765 Рік тому
Which nation?
@deeglloyd
@deeglloyd Рік тому
@@Paulus8765 I'm claiming her for the USA, of course!
@Paulus8765
@Paulus8765 Рік тому
@@deeglloyd Unfair - I claim her for Northumbria.
@bellbookcandle3051
@bellbookcandle3051 Рік тому
@@Paulus8765 Well, you _did_ have her first. 😏👍
@eh1702
@eh1702 Рік тому
It’s significant that Dr Hill said that as a female, a working class female and a working class female with a northern accent - she knew that she could never have the career she wanted, (specialising in Russia) in a UK context. She knew she would all the time be defined by Britain’s toxic nexus of public-schoolboy sexism and classism. This is why she said she leaped at the chance of American postgrad work, career and citizenship.
@mr.bertnearnie3603
@mr.bertnearnie3603 Рік тому
I always enjoy listening to Dr. Hill!
@piseag458
@piseag458 Рік тому
Great interview she's articulating my thoughts about all this with putins Russia she's like an agony aunt .. and helps my understanding of global politics, I feel continually incredulous and outraged about russia dragging us all back in time like this ,its truly terrifying and awful.So glad for Silicon curtain and people like Fiona to help us try and make sense it of all.Wonderful ,thankyou!
@ennediend2865
@ennediend2865 Рік тому
Absolutely 👍👍👍 Only Russia is the threat! But a dictator will always need a reason...
@ashscott6068
@ashscott6068 Рік тому
Yep. If you don't want your neighbors joining a defensive alliance, STOP INVADING YOUR NEIGHBORS.
@danalden1112
@danalden1112 Рік тому
Much respect for Dr. Hill
@jezalb2710
@jezalb2710 Рік тому
Thank you. Fiona is fantastic.
@trevorhutchings4941
@trevorhutchings4941 Рік тому
I so enjoyed this interview with Fiona Hill, extremely enlightening. Thank you
@jezalb2710
@jezalb2710 Рік тому
It is great
@SteveMenardDesignDXM
@SteveMenardDesignDXM Рік тому
During the 1960s and 1970s, the French-speaking majority of Quebec finally came of age and took its rightful place as an independent 'nation' within Canada. I was born in this Quebec, as part of the 10% English-speaking minority. Over a span of a decade, we saw many of our linguistic rights diminished, leading to the limiting of our ability to maintain our size and influence through the education system. Though there were some tense periods with scattered acts of violent protest and political kidnappings, the 'two solitudes' have come to a mutual understanding, and now our issues are being handled exclusively within the political sphere. I'm pointing this out in order to draw a certain parallel between the English-speaking minority in Quebec and the Russian-speaking areas of Ukraine. Any and all disagreements with regard to language and culture are always best solved through discussion, mutual respect, and an exchange of creative ideas that lead to solutions. Back in 1977, we didn't want the UK or the US to come in and take over our territory in order to preserve our culture, language and way of life. We settled things internally. That's what I would have expected in Ukraine. What has happened since that fateful day of Feb 24, 2022, is beyond unfortunate, and the violence is senseless.
@peterwebb8732
@peterwebb8732 Рік тому
The point you make, is that there was a reasonable alternative, which means that Putin's war was not a "last resort" and is thereby unjustified.
@badhombre4942
@badhombre4942 8 місяців тому
@@peterwebb8732 Another brain dead moron spews western lies. Google the Minsk agreements and check how Merkel, Orland and the former President of Ukraine boasted that their support for these agreements was just a lie to build Ukraine's military to fight Russia.
@grzzz2287
@grzzz2287 Рік тому
Excellent podcast, Fiona is one of the best Russia experts out there and is always worth a watch. Keep em coming!
@michaelmullins3396
@michaelmullins3396 Рік тому
The late Professor Stephen Cohen could have thought Hill a few things about Russia, hill is a Propaganda tool of Washington.
@terryhand
@terryhand Рік тому
Just simply getting guests of this quality is an acheivement itself.Outstanding interview.
@MrBrunoMi
@MrBrunoMi Рік тому
Totally aligned with this comment
@daniellepilon7433
@daniellepilon7433 Рік тому
Sequel please!!! Can’t get enough of these two.
@NightOwlinNewOrleans
@NightOwlinNewOrleans Рік тому
Dr Hill is one of my go tos for insight and analysis. Always thoughtful clear.
@francescamelandri3895
@francescamelandri3895 Рік тому
Dr Hill's clarity and expertise are a guiding light , great to see her on your wonderful channel
@esakoivuniemi
@esakoivuniemi Рік тому
Dr. Hill is spot on on so many things. Yet, I think she overlooks the benefits of simplifying things. There are some fundamentals we should keep in mind. First, we cannot change Russia either by force or by persuasion. We sure won't be able to change their worldview through negotiations or by trying to lecture about our ways to them. So, we should assume they will remain the same. That being the case, the only way to stop the war is to give Ukraine the tools it needs to defeat Russia in the battlefield. Even Russian defeat will be a temporary. Russia remains the same. The only long term solution is to accept Ukraine (and potentially Georgia & Moldova) into NATO. After that, Russia has nowhere to expand. If we also keep up the sanctions regime, they will have hard time building up their military power again. Then we'll wait. Patiently. Decades. Maybe even centuries. At some point Russians will change their system, or The Russian Federation will collapse. Until then, only a strong western military power - and readiness to use it - will keep them at bay. I don't see how more nuanced or complex considerations could change these fundamentals.
@ulrikschackmeyer848
@ulrikschackmeyer848 Рік тому
Very grim prospects, indeed. That would be 'beating Russia on Russia's own terms'. But I fear that in the end you may turn out to be right. However, I sure that you will allow the rest of us trying to figure out various 'seemingly miraculous' ways to see if the 'stalemate of mutual suffering' can be shortened.
@esakoivuniemi
@esakoivuniemi Рік тому
@@ulrikschackmeyer848 To be frank, I did not even paint the most pessimistic possible future. Imagine what will happen if Russia won't be defeated in Ukraine and it is able to rebuild it's military. Ukraine won't be Russia's last victim in that case. Anyhow, I do hope someone will come up with a way(s) to ensure more optimistic future. I'd be very glad to be proven wrong.
@rimmerblues1586
@rimmerblues1586 Рік тому
I very much agree with your assessment as that's how i too see it. Cornering a wounded, injured & aggressive animal is dangerous (as i believe Pootin may have analogized something in past speeches and such) but for the foreseeable i don't see any other way. Even now they're trying to make alliances in places like Africa to keep "The West", etc. off balance and sadly they accept it either due to historical reasons or monetary payments, but i don't see Russia helping the development of these places it appears more just offering weapons and fuel and occasionally food (likely stolen from Ukraine) so basically _feeding_ the corrupt govs of the world, whereas China looks to do it better by seemingly offering development in order to extract the resources of these places while Europe kinda dithers about. And this is the thing, the US was slowly drawing-down it's European forces in order to pivot to Asia and most thought that was where the next big conflict was to emerge which likely added to the Kremlin's calculations to go for it now. It has been a rude awakening for the EU - Europe as a whole - and other 'Western'-aligned nations whom seemed to had closed their eyes and crossed their fingers with a "nah, it'll be fine" attitude, now likely they're going have to increase military spending towards the old Cold War levels to bolster against a re-asserting Russia (which would no doubt please the US to ease their strain as they want to look to the Asia-Pacific) and decide what connections they want with other nations of the world to lessen the influence (corruption?) of Russia & China and be potentially left behind in the resource acquisition game.
@zie9171
@zie9171 9 місяців тому
As Russia seeks alliance es around the world and in Africa. I wonder how much the West regret destabilising S Africa and handing it on a plate to the ANC. At the very least, the previous government sought to quell Russia and keep them away from the borders and the rich resources found there in!!!!!!
@robertbrennan2268
@robertbrennan2268 Рік тому
Extremely illuminating insights from Dr Fiona Hill in conversation with Jonathan. Quite brilliant. Many thanks.
@EeeEee-bm5gx
@EeeEee-bm5gx Рік тому
As much as there are amazing guests, the host has an amazing voice and a way of speaking. My ears are smitten 🥰
@SiliconCurtain
@SiliconCurtain Рік тому
😝 I actually can’t hear my voice back on recordings - I hate the sound of it!
@jmolofsson
@jmolofsson Рік тому
@@SiliconCurtain That's human! A trait shared by many.
@appstratum9747
@appstratum9747 Рік тому
A real pleasure to watch this, Jonathan, with some very new and interesting snippets of information from Fiona about the Yeltsin/Bush exchanges from the 90s. A very stimulating discussion, too, of the situation in Europe and Russia and the geopolitical perspective from the United States. You've had a succession of really great guests, excellent conversations and value by the bucket load. I'm not you're how you're managing to be so successful at getting such excellent people to contribute! But really, you're doing a fantastic job. Great to watch. Do keep on with this. Please don't stop!
@stellascott4584
@stellascott4584 Рік тому
I think you are both missing the point about Zelenskiy saying Putin is ”nobody”. Actually, I had to go back to the interview and listen again when I started seeing people saying referring to Zelenskiy saying that Putin is a nobody. That's not what I heard and that's not what he said. Furthermore, I don't think that was due to his lack of command of the English language. To be clear: Zelenskiy did not say Putin is ”a” nobody. He switched over to English because he wanted to make it very clear that there would be no one there on the other side of the table for the purpose of a diplomatic conversation and making binding agreements. The chair would be empty, even though a body would be sitting in it. Hence it’s not interesting to even go there. Of course, Putin is somebody, but the problem for Zelenskiy, in an attempt for diplomatic and constructive negotiations, Putin cannot be trusted in these matters in any way whatsoever. He will always break any agreement, which has been proven time and time again throughout the history of his ever-increasing dictatorial rule.
@davidmiles-hanschell
@davidmiles-hanschell Рік тому
Absolutely right; he is definitely the 21st Some body; Vladimir Putin will some how, must be persuaded to bring WWW3 to an end; granted immunity from war crimes and allowed to live out his days somewhere; the prospect beckons, that if not the game, is over for us all
@SiliconCurtain
@SiliconCurtain Рік тому
This is get, and it’s worth addressing in a future interview. The point I was trying to provoke, was that Yeltsin magicked this sinister character into power practically from nowhere. He was a real nobody, and there were thousands of ex KGB thugs who could have just as easily been picked to be the Putin type figure to fulfil the plans of the KGB and Yeltsin
@ulrikschackmeyer848
@ulrikschackmeyer848 Рік тому
Thank you so very much for that input. In times of conflict it is of cause impossible to avoid the simple ridiculing of the opponent. But I am strangely uplifted by reading your comment, that Zelinsky, of all psychologically and morally entitled people, nevertheless keeps himself to a higher and more meaningful standard! You, Dear Lady, are one of the persons making the 'The Comment Fields of UKposts' a 'noteworthwhile' place to visit! One of the 'participating citizens' the original creators of UKposts must have dreamed of.
@jameswilson1363
@jameswilson1363 Рік тому
Ms. Hill, its a pleasure too enjoy your dissertations, out with cameras and stern faces.
@TKMcClone
@TKMcClone Рік тому
I've listened to maybe a dozen Fiona Hill interviews in the past 12 months and I always get something new. Thanks so much for another great discussion.
@michaelogden5958
@michaelogden5958 Рік тому
Thank you, Dr. Hill and Mr. Fink for this presentation.
@Leo-Orbis
@Leo-Orbis Рік тому
Intelligent, insightful pragmatism! A sequel would be wonderful.
@jed4119
@jed4119 Рік тому
What a coup! The great Fiona Hill so knowledgeable and interesting. Please do speak to her again if you can.
@jezalb2710
@jezalb2710 Рік тому
She has been a guest on many other channels. Bbc4 too
@shaney8275
@shaney8275 Рік тому
Thank you, Mr.Fink, first for sharing the interviews for those of us in the public who wish to hear serious dialogue about what are serious geopolitical problems. Second, for having Dr. Hill on your show. I have been following her ever since she testified in the impeachment hearings, listening to her interviews with some regularity. The woman is about as impressive an individual as one can find, and while I'm happy for her that she has taken the position at University, I'm almost sad, as I was hoping she might run for office here in the States. The world needs people like her. Her integrity, down-to-earth attitude, and obviously her knowledge are what we need now, more than ever.
@davidmiles-hanschell
@davidmiles-hanschell Рік тому
Thank You so much Jonathan for posting this interview with Dr.Fiona Hill whose lucid analysis of a predicament that has enmeshed all whether we like it or not, it is like a tiny beacon from afar, shining into my consciousness, from a very dark place. I look forward to the next time you speak with her and those of her calibre and integrity.
@ulrikschackmeyer848
@ulrikschackmeyer848 Рік тому
Beautifully put. I second that.
@Bradonomous
@Bradonomous Рік тому
I am forever impressed by Fiona Hill - she is a really practical thinker with simple, useful, well-evidenced insights.
@eh1702
@eh1702 Рік тому
And yet Dr Hill would have got nowhere if she had carried on in the UK. She would probably be a temporary lecturer in some middling university somewhere. She knew that her potential in the US would be determined by her abilities, whereas in the UK she was a lower class provincial female with a “thick accent”, a perpetual outsider. US government & diplomatic, and even academic structures, were open to her in a way that British ones would never be.
@aarav2179
@aarav2179 Рік тому
Great respect for Dr. Hill.
@ulrikschackmeyer848
@ulrikschackmeyer848 Рік тому
Dear Jonathan. Thank you VERY much, for making new questions that go a layer deeper. I mean listening to Dr Hill is ALWAYS fascinating, even when it is 'the same old questions', but this time was even more brilliant! And thanks a lot for your long format contributions. You really contribute with a lot of insight. Two points beyond that. One nitty little presentation detail. When you read aloud, or check a question or argument, you lower your eyes JUST enough to break you otherwise quite acceptable line of sight with the interviewer. To me it breaks the feeling of your otherwise inspiring presence! I'm not a tech nerd, so I can't tell you HOW to fix it, but an improvement would make it a lot easier for me to focus on your brilliant content. Secondly, like many other, I hope for, and would like to hear about WHAT could 'a relatively as happy as possible end' be? Or a reasonable road there? I mean if we assume the the West cannot, or will not risk, bringing a STUNDE NULL (the complete Nazi breakdown realised by all Germans) to the Russians/Putin, how COULD one persuade the Russians or their leadership (be it Putin or not) to get out of their traumatic, 'old-fashioned' (for want of a better term) look on the West or indeed the World and into the growth and prosperity of a NON-zero-sum-future? I allow myself to believe in a brighter future for a non-imperial Russia. Because, as a Dane, we've experienced being a superpower (of our known world) through several periods in history: the Vikings, the North Sea Mare Nostrum of King Canute the Great, the Baltic Mare Nostrum of King Valdemar the Victorious, the Danish lead Kalmar Union (Europe's largest country pre-Columbus), the world third largest fleet at times in 16-1700's. Never the less we've (almost voluntarily) given up on world dominance. And today Denmark (along with our Scandinavian 'partners') is regulally scored among the most prosperous nations on Earth. And hailed as democratic paragons! In English textbooks of 'development of national economy' there is a phrase in the how-to chapters called 'Getting to Denmark' . In French textbooks it's called ' La methode Suedoise'. And we are regularly scored as the happiest! So it IS possible to be rich and happy, post-imperial-dreams. Just saying. Sorry about the rant, not completely without national pride, but I felt that it HAD to be solid, convincing AND proud to be appealing to Russians. As I understand it, is that not what Russia wants for herself?
@skipsteel
@skipsteel Рік тому
Congrats on having Fiona Hill on your show, she is a well respected mind on global politics.
@junahn1907
@junahn1907 Рік тому
Putin is a nineteenth century mind, losing a 20th century war, against a 21st century world.
@kyleodland6249
@kyleodland6249 Рік тому
Great quote!
@birchstudio2900
@birchstudio2900 Рік тому
I've been waiting for this all my life - we the victims of the Soviet Union are finally being seen.
@tepsurka
@tepsurka Рік тому
So glad to have discovered Dr Hill for myself. She dispersed my doubts whether the West was competent to read Russia and to counter-react on its vicious moves in East Europe. She is gorgeous.
@roseblue3368
@roseblue3368 Рік тому
Great interview and debate you understand each other so well its precious!!! More please🙏
@dsjwhite
@dsjwhite Рік тому
Amazing, thank you. A wonderful conversation
@carolyncolinhogarth8732
@carolyncolinhogarth8732 Рік тому
Thank you....Strategic issues are not killing innocence. That is a crime against humanity....
@neilclay5835
@neilclay5835 Рік тому
She's brilliant isn't she, Fiona. I could listen to her mull and think out loud so coherently for hours. Quite difficult to interview seamlessly on a video call I'm guessing, as she rekindles her idea and drops yet another gem of insight as she's ending a path of thought. Great interview.
@SiliconCurtain
@SiliconCurtain Рік тому
Too many ideas for a single video… I must try to arrange a follow-up!
@donhansen1175
@donhansen1175 Рік тому
The west should have stood up immediately when Russia was starting this. It is the same with China. We have, in each case, failed to sew that stitch that would have kept the sweater (the peace) from coming unraveled. Dictators must know for certain that if they misbehave they will take an immediate serious consequence and zero benefit. Don Hansen
@nerdyali4154
@nerdyali4154 Рік тому
Unfortunately not an option for a democratic leader. If the West is being blamed even by many of it's own citizens for the war now, can you imagine how much more strident that blame would be if earlier action were taken?
@marisabenson1222
@marisabenson1222 Рік тому
Dr. Hill 100%
@sama3033
@sama3033 Рік тому
Blindingly intelligent women like Fiona make me weak in the knees. I could listen to her for hours.
@jessehachey2732
@jessehachey2732 2 місяці тому
Well said! You should see all the trolls on her interviews on other channels, they’re triggered by strong intelligent, successful women, it’s both hilarious, sad and pathetic to see! She’s doing something right! I have a huge intellectual crush on her! 😍🤯
@sama3033
@sama3033 2 місяці тому
@@jessehachey2732 Has to be said, conservative men are just intimidated by strong women. I think this is the root of their misogyny. I feel sorry for the wives of these men, I really do.
@mchozen2958
@mchozen2958 Рік тому
Fiona Hill is my hero. Her perspective is unequalled. Thank you for the brilliant insights by both participants. A psychoanalyst’s view of puny Vlad would also be fascinating.
@ulrikschackmeyer848
@ulrikschackmeyer848 Рік тому
My very thought, and regularly suggested idea. I have a dream where the Ramsteinians unwaveringly box Russia in for the duration, and Dr Hill and Vlad Vexler come up with a plan to tempt the Russians (with or without Putin) into joining the NON-zero-sum game of the rest of the civilized world? That might just be our best shot at 'the fastest, sort of, happy-like end'.
@kythian
@kythian Рік тому
What an astute person. I have been much impressed by Dr. Hill in the past, and she continues to do so. Thank you for you service, Dr. Hill.
@anitaandazola2029
@anitaandazola2029 Рік тому
Thank you Dr. Fiona Hill for this and all your prior works, testomonies and analyses!
@liberalmatt
@liberalmatt Рік тому
She's a local (though admittedly obscure) celebrity for me (Co. Durham), with a modest yet well-earned profile. Great interview Fiona!
@ralfmatters448
@ralfmatters448 Рік тому
I would like to hear someone of Fiona's scholarship and experience speculate upon: a Ukraine 'victory' and what the west needs to do in calibration with the Kremlin to prevent another phase of Russian imperialism. Assuming we get past this phase of imperialism without nuclear disaster? I've heard some commentators estimate 20 million extreme nationalists in Russia, how do we engage constructively to diffuse this cycle of expansion and collapse?
@angusmatheson8906
@angusmatheson8906 Рік тому
Basically, Russia, post Putin, needs Marshall Plan 2.0. 4eparati9ns and punitive shit may be just and cathartic but it will only beget more misery and tragedy.
@decaesaris5093
@decaesaris5093 Рік тому
RuSSia as an entire could never be reformed. The only way to stop it is to let every state of it becoming independent. RuSSia will finish crumbled after this new war . Will stretch from Skt.Petersburg and Moskow up to Ekaterinburg.
@ulrikschackmeyer848
@ulrikschackmeyer848 Рік тому
I would very much second that motion. I have written likewise, on this channel and elsewhere. But no answer yet. Dr. Hill and perhaps Vlad Vexler could come up with an understandable, philosophically and practically coherent plan that the West could understand and back and Russia could accept and get behind? Never stop believing in miracles! Remember in Old Italian 'miracle' just meant '(currently) inexplicable' - strictly speaking it never meant 'impossible'.
@peterwebb8732
@peterwebb8732 Рік тому
Well we don't start by permitting those Russian Imperialists to benefit by violence. Getting what they want out of this war will only convince them that war works. The nuclear issue is never going to go away. Treating Russia softly because we are too afraid is only delaying the issue. Europe let Hitler get away with invading his neighbours, because they were afraid of another WW1..... and they got WW2. It is only by demonstrating conclusively that war does not "work" do we knock the props out from under the warmongers.
@peterwebb8732
@peterwebb8732 Рік тому
@@angusmatheson8906 ... Keep in mind that there was considerable foreign capital injected into Russia after the Soviet collapse. It failed due to corruption on a grand scale. Putin is a multi-billionaire on a wage of about $150k per year. Private companies were just as much targets for invasion and looting as neighbouring nations. That would have to change.
@NukeminHerttua
@NukeminHerttua Рік тому
Thank for the podcast Jonathan! I love the calm and to-the-point style of yours. Oh and thanks for Fiona for sharing her thoughts!
@dnpenn
@dnpenn Рік тому
I want to add my gratitude to that of others for your bringing Dr. Hill into your vlog. Its was so enlightening and engaging.
@viktorakse3326
@viktorakse3326 Рік тому
This one was phenomenal. Keep at it, I wanna see this channel grow
@orctowngrot8842
@orctowngrot8842 Рік тому
What a BEAUTIFUL discussion guys. Lovely nuance, deft examination of structure, the corrupting framing of policy based on limit personal perceptions. Prompt and illuminating examination of structures of both society and THOUGHT itself over decades. You point us all to the vital truism that ALL OF US, and especially public figures must be cautious of our private frame of understanding, and we all must be willing to change and grow. Thanks, both of you. Good health to both of you and may the glorious non event of peace settle on all of us.
@ulrikschackmeyer848
@ulrikschackmeyer848 Рік тому
Beautiful. I could not have put it better myself. Peace upon you, Brother.
@judithbradford9130
@judithbradford9130 Рік тому
Fiona Hill makes this middle aged woman fangirl like a teenage Beatlemaniac :) She's AWESOME!
@randr302
@randr302 Рік тому
♥️Fiona!!♥️
@louisalfieri3187
@louisalfieri3187 Рік тому
This was fantastic. Horrific but explained so well. So grateful for Fiona Hill!
@franksemi_modular
@franksemi_modular Рік тому
@Silicon Curtain You really have a nose for picking the most insightfull people👍Anders Puck Nilsen, Vlad Vexler, Carl Miller, Operator Starsky and many more.. and now Fiona Hill.. It's a pleasure to watch in this format 👍👍
@SiliconCurtain
@SiliconCurtain Рік тому
Thanks! I watch a lot of my speakers’ materials to ensure they have interesting views (and no Vatnik tendencies)
@RobBCactive
@RobBCactive Рік тому
Great job by Jonathan to research the guest interviews and look for new angles rather than carbon copy rehashes of interesting answers. A highlight was on the regression to "the political sophistication of a Viking fiefdom", it seemed to amuse Fiona. Fiona's appraisal of the complexity of causes and the mutual incomprehension that has lead to the tragedy was in-depth challenging but clear. The discomfort of hearing such appraisals without the comfort of obvious remedies is significant. Choosing the lesser of evils is always hard.
@SiliconCurtain
@SiliconCurtain Рік тому
Glad you said this - I keep all the questions I’ve every asked, and try to vary the angles in each interview. This also means the channel will have to diversify to cover China, turkey, Africa, Middle East and India soon…
@thomasnuyts9725
@thomasnuyts9725 Рік тому
Glad Jonathan wants to diversify towards India. Looking very much forward to seeing that. Great insights gained today. Thank you Mrs Hill.
@stellascott4584
@stellascott4584 Рік тому
@@SiliconCurtain, I love that as a future perspective. The World! And perhaps that might bring you to the BRILLIANT Maria Ressa? I have been thinking of suggesting her for a while, as a person with profound perspectives on democracy and dictatorship.
@dlmsarge8329
@dlmsarge8329 Рік тому
@@SiliconCurtain I know many of your viewers , myself included, would really value you covering those areas as well! Your guests are always interesting and your questions always insightful. We appreciate your style of conversation that highlights such a variety of perspectives and backgrounds. You've got me hooked!!
@RobBCactive
@RobBCactive Рік тому
@@SiliconCurtainthe effort you put in is what kept me coming back, after the first interview I saw. It took a while but the subs have grown significantly now, you have a valuable archive 😁
@tomd5678
@tomd5678 Рік тому
That's what happens when you allow bullies to gradually increase their aggression. Hill is an inspiration. An example of courage and integrity
@richardkey1678
@richardkey1678 Рік тому
Excellent , even though your interviews are usually an hour long, they are too short, thank you.
@SiliconCurtain
@SiliconCurtain Рік тому
We were pushed for time - but this means hopefully there will be a part 2 🤞
@dennisgarber
@dennisgarber Рік тому
I listened at 2.5 speed, and it was a short interview. I listened to Fiona's Mr. Putin, from the the library, at 1.55 speed. It still was a long book. But it had a few essential points that I am glad I got to hear. I thought it was written by one economist, but I missed her name on the title.
@superstrada6847
@superstrada6847 Рік тому
One can listen to Fiona Hill forever. She is the epitome of a free human being.
@raneroth7981
@raneroth7981 Рік тому
I love these - and the frequency of new episodes is mindblowing.
@SiliconCurtain
@SiliconCurtain Рік тому
It’s also tiring!!! All done on top of a full day job and family commitments… 🤪
@anonymusum
@anonymusum Рік тому
That was a very interesting and informative interview. Thank you!
@bobbymurphy4384
@bobbymurphy4384 Рік тому
Great Podcast as always. Fiona is a great guest 💗
@northerngirl4666
@northerngirl4666 Рік тому
if Russian wants to stop so called America’n control, Putin should get rid of ALL brand companies in the country. No Coke. No iPhones. No jeans. No everything! It’s not American political control, it’s the lifestyle that everyone wants. Remove all that and what do you have left? When I visited Poland in 1979, people followed me and offered money for the jeans I was wearing! They didn’t want the Canadian political structure - they just wanted stuff! So remove the lifestyle, and you would end up with a medieval society. Everyone everywhere want stuff. Simple as that!
@darius1988
@darius1988 Рік тому
Amazing guest and host! Thanks for insights! Greetings from Lithuania
@concernedrabbit9075
@concernedrabbit9075 Рік тому
Think of the advice we give children if they are bullied at school. " tell someone you trust " then when they do nothing happens to the bully especially if teachers don't see it happening. From our simplest social institutions we have little success stopping bullies. The victims are just supposed to youghen up. Sociopaths always know what buttons to push because they study people for vulnerabilities. Intellectuals never understand Sociopaths and think they can persuade with clever arguments. The sociopath never intends to stop trying to meet their own needs and thinks it's funny watching the intellectual seeking a logical solution.
@DJWESG1
@DJWESG1 Рік тому
Not many ppl are prepared to call out schools, hidden curiculums , socialisation and tory/conservstive ideology as being the main problem the world faces. When they spent their whole lives telling people the opposite.
@vthompson947
@vthompson947 Рік тому
Wonderful writer and analyst. Durham University is very lucky.
@tezzaNZ
@tezzaNZ Рік тому
Great interview as always Jonathan. Insights from people who know what they are talking about!
@nikolaivdb
@nikolaivdb Рік тому
What a lovely talk with Dr. Hill, great content as always. thanks!
@brianfreeman8290
@brianfreeman8290 Рік тому
Just getting a guest of this stature on your channel has earned you a new Subscriber !
@SiliconCurtain
@SiliconCurtain Рік тому
👍
@SiliconCurtain
@SiliconCurtain Рік тому
Stay tuned two more really well known guests in the coming weeks…
@markthompson180
@markthompson180 Рік тому
Fiona is right on-track. Unfortunately, I don't think Americans have ever really understood how Russia tends to operate or sees the world. Even back when the Soviet Union collapsed, I remember people here in the US reacting in a way that suggested that the "Russia problem" was solved and that going forward, it would only be a matter of time before Russia was "fully democratic" and integrated into the West. Well -- that didn't happen, and decades after that point, we are now in a situation where things between the "West" and Russia pretty much resemble how they were during the Cold War.
@geraldjones8010
@geraldjones8010 Рік тому
She'd make a fantastic president,so smart
Fiona Hill on Putin's Plans If Jan. 6 Had Succeeded | Emma Barnett Meets
23:42
Первая поломка Scirocco! Балацко попал на мотор.
1:13:12
Manufacturing In Australia | Q+A
10:02
abcqanda
Переглядів 214
Bill Browder: Surviving Vladimir Putin's Wrath
1:03:44
The Aspen Institute
Переглядів 96 тис.
"Putin is Pushing Our Buttons", Fiona Hill on Russia's War in Ukraine
58:26
Intelligence Squared
Переглядів 277 тис.
Fiona Hill: Balancing act: Russia, US and the world
50:31
SKAGEN Fondene
Переглядів 339 тис.
Anne Applebaum on Ukraine: One Year into the War
53:29
Conversations with Bill Kristol
Переглядів 370 тис.
Wolfram Physics Project Launch
3:50:19
Wolfram
Переглядів 1,5 млн