M2 Bradley vs BMP-3: Battle of Infantry Support Machines

  Переглядів 16,365

Defense TV

Defense TV

11 місяців тому

Since there is a potential supply of M2 Bradley to Ukraine, the question of how it compares to the Russian BMP-3 arises. Also, considering both are modern IFVs that are recognized for their exceptional levels of protection, firepower, mobility, and passenger capacity, a decent comparison would be worthwhile to know which one will prove to be more effective in the war zone.

КОМЕНТАРІ: 79
@TROOPERfarcry
@TROOPERfarcry 8 місяців тому
It's weird how emotionally-invested some people are to either side or tech.
@Jay-ye5gk
@Jay-ye5gk 7 місяців тому
If u ever got drafted into war u would care too
@TROOPERfarcry
@TROOPERfarcry 7 місяців тому
@@Jay-ye5gk That probably sounded smart to you, but you should re-evaluate that.
@Jay-ye5gk
@Jay-ye5gk 7 місяців тому
@@TROOPERfarcry or maybe you should think before u speak
@TROOPERfarcry
@TROOPERfarcry 7 місяців тому
@@Jay-ye5gk Sure, dude. Sure.
@cstgraphpads2091
@cstgraphpads2091 7 місяців тому
@@TROOPERfarcry I mean, they're not wrong.
@yaboyed5779
@yaboyed5779 6 місяців тому
Bradley for its armour and optics, BMP 3 for its fire power and amphibiousness.
@TROOPERfarcry
@TROOPERfarcry 8 місяців тому
The BMP automatically ejects the brass out of the back? That's cool.
@edthebumblingfool
@edthebumblingfool 7 місяців тому
it ejects the crew out of the top, not cool.
@stephenmyers7076
@stephenmyers7076 6 місяців тому
@@edthebumblingfool😂😂😂😂😂
@Frog13799
@Frog13799 8 місяців тому
Simple the BMP will engage the Bradley with missiles or 100mm gun, the ATGM can be fired on the move unlike the TOW
@cstgraphpads2091
@cstgraphpads2091 7 місяців тому
The 9M117 Bastion missile used on the BMP-3 can't reliably be used on the move either as the laser designator has to remain on the target. TOW also has better armor penetration. The Bradley can also engage two targets at the same time with TOW, unlike the BMP-3.
@Jim-zn9qy
@Jim-zn9qy 8 місяців тому
The Bradley's are to damn tall to hide,to slow to run and can't swim
@edthebumblingfool
@edthebumblingfool 7 місяців тому
BMps cant really swin if they are more than a few month old.
@cstgraphpads2091
@cstgraphpads2091 7 місяців тому
They don't need to swim though. This isn't even a good comparison since they aren't even vehicles for the same purpose. The Bradley was designed as a reponse to the BMP-2. The BMP-3 can't exactly hide either. WIth the Bradley's height, it is better able to take advantage of hull-down positions.
@stephenmyers7076
@stephenmyers7076 6 місяців тому
Bradley wasn’t designed to hide. That’s for the bmp-3 to do.
@jaygo71
@jaygo71 4 місяці тому
Love the Bradley graveyard east of Robotyne.. there's even some dead Leopard 3s there! 😂
@brianmurray1395
@brianmurray1395 2 місяці тому
And a few Abrams
@ry0usama511
@ry0usama511 2 місяці тому
When did Leopard 3 exist 💀
@VaclavCermak
@VaclavCermak 8 місяців тому
That depleted uranium ammo is just too bad.
@jasip1000
@jasip1000 7 місяців тому
What I miss when talking APC’s or IFV’s, is how is it inside for the infantry, how is the comfort, the mounting and dismount, weapons and equipment storage and so. I been riding two different APC/IFV as a soldier, the American M-113 APC and the Yugoslav M-80 BVP IFV.
@ian2372
@ian2372 5 місяців тому
Inside an ifv, comfort is always the last thing considered in the contract. Only Israel gives a shit about its crew and soldiers, as seen in the merkava and its survivability as well as comfort.
@jasip1000
@jasip1000 5 місяців тому
@@ian2372 yes but I was talking APC’s and IFV’s not tanks like the Merkava.
@azzlack99
@azzlack99 4 місяці тому
⁠@@ian2372not true. Western armies in general developed tanks AND IFVs which are pretty survivable in comparison to their Russian counterparts, e.g. German Puma. The myth of the Merkava also kinda got busted, I‘d not say it’s the safest tank in the world. That one rather goes to the Abrams, Leo or the Challenger. Leo & Chally have been hit worse in Ukraine & didn’t explode completely (while some still burned out after multiple FPV drones hit them).
@user-el5yw3fs4b
@user-el5yw3fs4b 8 місяців тому
we've already seen Bradley on the battlefield - it's a crawler coffin
@codypierce2970
@codypierce2970 8 місяців тому
And the hundreds if not thousands of BMPs that have been scrapped aren't lol?? At least when a Bradley gets knocked out the crew still survives
@user-el5yw3fs4b
@user-el5yw3fs4b 8 місяців тому
you 're pitchfork shots that were more of a stroke of luck . Have you seen the footage where the upper part of Bradley is simply missing ?@@codypierce2970
@Masterafro999
@Masterafro999 8 місяців тому
@@codypierce2970 bradleys through their turrets just as far. and if they dont...well some one most probalby died when the super heated jet or a ke round entered the fighting compartment. the bmps are build to swim. that already makes them lightly armoured by default. they tend to not fare well against at threats but neither does the bradley are close to all ifvs. maybe the namer or t15 would fare significantly better. in terms of infantry support i´d take the bmp. against armor probaly the brad
@codypierce2970
@codypierce2970 8 місяців тому
@@Masterafro999 I'm taking the Bradley all day every day. It's far more survivable. Just ask the Ukrainians who have been in one when it's been hit, and walked away saying if they had been in a BMP they'd be dead. No one cares about the ability to swim if it sacrifices armor to the point it has on the BMP. The only time they've gone directly against each other it was an absolute slaughter in favor of the Bradley
@Masterafro999
@Masterafro999 8 місяців тому
@@codypierce2970 when did the Bradley fight against a bmp3?
@user-ds2rh4ms7e
@user-ds2rh4ms7e 10 місяців тому
Они очень разные.
@brianmurray1395
@brianmurray1395 2 місяці тому
The BMP 3 can easily penetrate its opponent’s armour however Russia does not WANT TO USE DU which contaminates the ground its crew. DU should NEVER BE USED! It contaminates the surrounding grounds with dust (radioactive) for centuries to come.
@garynew9637
@garynew9637 8 місяців тому
Bradley looks like it was designed by a 10 yo.
@andrigeogiou8420
@andrigeogiou8420 3 місяці тому
BMP 3s ,are clearly superiors
@florentinoiraola7349
@florentinoiraola7349 Місяць тому
for me i like m2 Bradley since in desert storm
@blackpanther6655
@blackpanther6655 3 місяці тому
armour goes to the bradley the rest goes to the bmp3
@camau79
@camau79 3 місяці тому
The Bradley took the title of ronson lighter from the Sherman 😂
@rusman69wahid94
@rusman69wahid94 7 місяців тому
Uncomparable....soze of gun does matter plus Amphibious capability.
@thatotherguy821
@thatotherguy821 8 місяців тому
I dont think this is a good comparison as: the Bradley had one of the most disasterous conseptions in modern r&d history. This is due to the incompetence of the pentagon in deciding what they wanted. The process put simply is that the bradley is the jack of all trades but master of non.
@edthebumblingfool
@edthebumblingfool 7 місяців тому
it did fine in Iraq and is performing better than BMPs in Ukraine.
@pozarnic
@pozarnic 10 місяців тому
почему про бредли говорит только хорошее о модернизированные версии?То что везут на украину старые версии.
@77advanced
@77advanced 10 місяців тому
Bradleys burn so well in Ukraine. Without even reaching the enemy.
@earthislandepicwubbox
@earthislandepicwubbox 9 місяців тому
Lancets💪
@stephenbrand5661
@stephenbrand5661 8 місяців тому
🤣 Yeah, Russia's STILL using those same pictures of the Bradley's and Leopard 2A6 in the minefield from the first week of Ukraine's summer counteroffensive! The big difference between the Bradley and Russia's IFV's is that the Bradley can actually protect the soldiers inside of it and keep them alive. We've seen a Ukrainian Bradley take a direct hit from a T-72's 125 mm high explosive shell and still keep its crew alive. No BMP-3 could even come close to doing that, no matter how many logs or sandbags or cope cages the Russians tried to stack on top of it!!
@codypierce2970
@codypierce2970 8 місяців тому
BMPs burn better apparently 🤷‍♂️
@templardisciple3387
@templardisciple3387 8 місяців тому
Ya so? So do bmp lol
@theanglo-lithuanian1768
@theanglo-lithuanian1768 7 місяців тому
According to Oryx 283 BMP3s have been destoryed....
@juanachicahualachavez1291
@juanachicahualachavez1291 8 місяців тому
El M2 Bradley es el mejor tanque ligero de infantería y es dé USA 🇺🇸🇺🇸
@mikeinal5521
@mikeinal5521 10 місяців тому
Check your facts
@georgiyotov5413
@georgiyotov5413 9 місяців тому
Already checked,they burn well,for now in Ukraine.
@codypierce2970
@codypierce2970 8 місяців тому
​@@georgiyotov5413just like the BMPs lol 😂
@pymathus2283
@pymathus2283 4 місяці тому
No ones arguing the BMP's don't, but you Americans have so much propaganda up your arse believing your vehicles are made by god, bradley is just as much as a coffin, and soon the Abrams will be, if it ever comes out of hiding.@@codypierce2970
@jaygo71
@jaygo71 4 місяці тому
​@@codypierce2970 and Leopards.... 😂 Yukyukyuk Kekkekkek Lololol
@mustaphafatti9827
@mustaphafatti9827 8 місяців тому
Ha ha ha not the same Bradley we see burned like a wood
@codypierce2970
@codypierce2970 8 місяців тому
And the BMP burns like wood soaked in gasoline lol
@mustaphafatti9827
@mustaphafatti9827 8 місяців тому
@@codypierce2970wake up is afternoon are you still sleeping not time for dreams
@user-yf3mh3ru7o
@user-yf3mh3ru7o 11 днів тому
Mfs russia lost more
@datacollector345
@datacollector345 10 місяців тому
Yeah pretty sure burning Bradley
@scottwilliamtoombs
@scottwilliamtoombs 10 місяців тому
(1:32) BMP-3 / better turret design - but should have an outer shell, as deflector shielding, ((which should be supported by a second roller bearing ring)) = ({{shield bolts/ exhaust bolts}}) {should not} {{sheer}}, on outer race ring, on impacts. 😎🤔🤌Looking better! - (4:21) the front pin shields, need to clear each other - {outer damage will prevent inner inspection}. \Tapering in would be better, taking in rounds/ Reactive plates for rear access and high polish the rest: as {paint can flaten the light}./!\ (7:29) Just shim in a thin liner of copper & weld a lower bead, to build up to corner of plates - +20% of defection.
Why the Russian Army BMP Vehicle is Worse than You Think
13:57
Task & Purpose
Переглядів 2,3 млн
BMP | The Industry Fighting Vehicle
33:11
Armor Cast
Переглядів 508 тис.
Пескоструйный АППАРАТ! #shorts
01:00
Гараж 54
Переглядів 3,1 млн
The New StrykerX Will Be Unmatched
8:09
Military TV
Переглядів 117 тис.
A-10 vs SU-25 Which is Better?
9:47
Military TV
Переглядів 142 тис.
Rheinmetall Lynx KF41 Infantry Fighting Vehicle Review
8:02
Military TV
Переглядів 77 тис.
Is the T-14 Armata Better Than The Panther KF51?
9:05
Military TV
Переглядів 47 тис.
The Army's Testing of a New 50mm Cannon for Bradley Replacement
11:10
Defense TV
Переглядів 507 тис.
Russian T-72 Destroys The M1 Abrams with Its First Shot
8:09
Defense TV
Переглядів 745 тис.
10 regrets of experienced programmers
8:16
Fireship
Переглядів 607 тис.
M4 iPad Pro Impressions: Well This is Awkward
12:51
Marques Brownlee
Переглядів 2,5 млн
Как установить Windows 10/11?
0:56
Construct PC
Переглядів 1,7 млн