Who is for 2022

I love both of them the animation is so good

the text: 2022 the light:2023 the shadow:2023 ___________________________________ so TEAM BOTH 👇🧐

Puppet fans 👇

2022 got the better balls, but 2023 has much better lighting and character design

2022 for sure

I like them both they both have improvements and both I wish were still in 2023

Love 2022 and 2023

The lighting and animating in 2023 is much better, but something about the pose of the puppet and the turn at the very end in 2022's is just so perfect

2022 my respect. This music is very good

The "Rhyme" of the old is better, but overall than "Rhyme" is good...12/9

Puppets voice is so beautiful 😊😊😊 and puppet always cares for everyone and tries to protect everyone but puppet can't do that alone 😢

2023 team 👇🏼

Nothing is better than the og

I especially love the flashing lights and threatening stances of the animatronics in the 2022

I liked that. The souls were different colors, and the ending scene of the first one was better. However, the second one was better animated I feel like.

Puppet is supposed to have white balls so good job

Its so hard to choose cuz both of there ending are so so so good

I think 2022 looks great!! (First time hearing this song ITS GREAT!!!❤)

I'll choose both, because their are my favourite.. Poor Puppet.. 🙁

I like the editing and the soul light things’ colors more in the 2022 version, it felt more lively. But I perfer the animation on the 2023 version

What is the name of the song please?

What the 2024 version of FNAF will be like

It's crazy how well art can change between one year ❤

Team 2022 👇🏽

2023 team

i love 2023, but i like the colorful soul spheres in 2022

in 2022 somehow it’s so alive... but in 2023 everything is more interesting and colorful (not counting the fact that all souls are white)

Team old 👇

2022 team 🎉 👇

I do like how in the more recent ones the souls are just faintly colored

I feel like you add more color to the orbs you add the animation and it just becomes perfect

Team 2023 👇

What is this Song called again?

Her/Hes voice is so sweet and calm

I like 2023 but the orbs and how they were colored in 2022 i like that better

2022 team 👇

New

His voice,his voice was majestic

I like to believe that the characters start harmonizing and singing these songs when no one’s around

2023 button 👇

2023

I personally prefer rhe second one but the orbs in first one gives off a Coraline feeling when she was collecting the souls and I think that would make the second one better

The 2023 would be almost perfect if each the lights spheres have colors.

If you couldn't see the bottom year 👇

I've never been so heart warmed and scared at the same time. 2023 for the win. It's better in every way possible, Good improvement.❤

In 2022, the balls have colour, and that's the only thing I like more

Such improvements!! The newest one definitely pulls more heartstrings ❤

The song reminds me of Stolas singing "Owl in a Cage" it's great

This is the second Ive seen so far and Im noticing that with both it seems the effects and light colors are better in the old but detail and light pathing is better in the newer ones

In any case, Charlie’s pissed that she died

I love both but 2022 has glowing orbits. And its really pretty for me. So i like 2022 more

Wow I haven’t heard this song in years. So nostalgic

Satysfying music, idk why

I love them both😍

I like the way the balls moving in Puppet's hand in 2022 version

2022 because it's cute and colored balls

The song made me feel a rush of saddness wash over me feeling bad for all the children like they were real kids that died

her voice was so amazing

I like the 2022 more for the most part. The only thing is that i love the 2023 scene with the floating orbs.

It's so amazing ❤

Definitely 2022 the red lights are shaking and it's just AMAZING

This unlocked a lost memory

BOTH ARE REALLY GOOD !

2022 got that among us at start💀💀🤔

Team 2022❤

I like 2023 graphics/design wise, but I do think the multi colored orbs should have stayed.

2022 has nice anination yet the lighting in 2023 seems more dark and fitting and the colouring was more seen while 2022 looked cool at the end!

See parts of 2023 and 2022 would go perfect together

Out of all seriousness this song is so pretty and i love it

2022 is more nostalgic 👍

I sleep to this every night. Im crazy

People say balloons is the saddest fnaf song but for me i always thought that painted faces was sadder

My eyes : ⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️

GORGEOUS 😍

Puppet is like the soul keeper

I have to go with old because 2023 has just white like the colors of the ball

I like how you tried to show how less is more with the 2023 one

Old is gold

Both animation are good 😊😊😊

Puppet is my most favourite animatronic in fanf❤❤

2022 is really cool, I think 2022 is better❤

I feel like it wouldve been pretty cool if for the remake they made the 4 original balls to be the same colors as the first one to represent the 4 original souls, and have the rest of the balls around the end have a bunch of differnt colors to match a lot of the other animatronics (some examples are a much lighter blue, lighter yellow, white, lighter orange or red, and a red and blue one) to represent the toy animatronics

what a beautiful song bro 😢

I like 2022 but i like the ending of 2023

It looks better in each one at different times like in the red I like 2023 better but the spinning glowing balls I like 2022 they should mix them for 2024

Both the animations are good in their own way so ✨️Both✨️ 👇

The puppet is my favourite character in the series

Honestly I like both❤

The new is more detailed but I like how each soul is a different colour

2022 cause the ball colors represented the different souls for the animactronics instead of all of them being the same color

I can't chose their both so great😭😭😭😭

Uma mistura dos dois ficaria incrível

Can't beat the 2022 og, but 2023 is pretty good.

My eyes:⬆️⬇️

I liked everything

Aquí los que se quedan con 2022🎉

2022:letras y esferas 2023:reloj,diseño de los niños y animatrónicos y la animación (Ya me los ví completo y me gustaron los dos 😁)

Me encanta puppet es la mejor 🤍🖤

2023 but the ending could be more “shakey”