the choreo couldve been so much better for this song, but that shot of winter was killlllller

Winter looks like an anime character Karina is the femme fatale Giselle is just classy Ning ning is an ace I am still waiting for my album to be shipped and honestly can't wait...SM thanks for the effort of promoting our girls, they're literally everywhere ❤️

Why aren't we appreciating how much their stage presence improved. Especially Winters.

this choreography and this voice are crazy, Winter literally slays everyone by getting this

The choreography is nice but this song deserved a more powerful choreo. The girls are slowly improving which is good.

카리나가 은근 블러셔 강조한 메이크업이 개찰떡이네...저번에 시그 사진도 그렇고 이 영상도 그렇고 메컵 너무너무 예쁨ㅠㅠㅠ 에스파 강한 컨셉 땜에 블러셔 잘 안한다고 그랬는데 좀 자주 해주라,,,넘모 잘 어울린다

I'm so obsessed with Winter's move at 2:49!! It's such a perfect dance move with the song's melody😩💕

I love Winter facial expressions.. she killing it

Karina's vocals are literally NO JOKE! Her tone is so rich and strong. Wow Karina I’m so proud of you you did so well and worked hard on yourself.！

Karina in white reminds me of her legendary sbs gayo fancams so stunning and charming

The choreo’s not my favourite, but that shot of Winter at 3:11 omg... my heart skipped a beat❤️❤️❤️

Winter better make own solo debut or solo mv now. Im really like she voice

카리나 메컵 해주신 분 누구냐… 지금까지 본 메이크업 중에 제일 잘 어울리는듯 너무 예쁘다

카리나 이 메이크업 너무 잘 어울림 진하고 쎈 화장 말고 이런 밝은 게 어울려 묶머 너무 예뻐 ㅜㅠㅠ 에스파 다 피지컬 왤케 좋아 넘 예쁘네

I feel like they’re getting better with their facial expressions, I hope that in the future they’ll give more stage presence because they have the capacity to do it since they’ve a really powerful concept

Idk why you guys hate the choreo. Whenever I listened to this song I can't stop to do a lil steps from this choreo. This is such a vibe song. The choreo will never stop me to listening to this song.

Fact: AESPA ARE GETTING BETTER EVERY COMEBACK. THEIR VOCALS, DANCE,RAPS,VISUALS improved alot !WE STAN MULTITALENTED QUEENS!

it’s insane how talented karina is. the main dancer who also raps and sings amazingly.

I'm in love with Winter's charisma

This song definitely deserve to be a title track. So good!

As long as Aespa is around, K-Pop will never get boring

I love how aespa always try different type of music. They don't stick to one particular style

Love winter's dance lines so much!!

the break dance is my favorite part. I love when kpop songs have electro/industrial elements, it sounds really really good

I can't take my eyes off karina even though she's always at the back. she's so captivating 🥺❤️

karina aura is always overflowing naturally, her subtle expression sharp gaze. With her powerful but so controlled dances movement together with her pops and locks, details from head to toe?! She's a legend!

Fallin in love with karina's vocal and winter performance😍

I feel like I’m the only one that loves the choreo and song 😭 maybe i just get it

지젤 랩이 너무 좋아서 멤버들이 다 노래도 잘하고 노래도 잘 부르고 니닝 비그노트도 딱 맞고 춤도 너무 파워풀해서 지젤님 랩이 너무 좋아요rr🎀🎀🎀♥️

The fact that Karina’s been hitting high note without restraining nor any tension. She did it effortlessly and that's before she became a trainee. Girl is on fire!!! Love her vocal tone too!

usually aespa have hard core and iconic coreo like next level and black mamba...sm is really lacking about planning and promoting their artits..why this one for studio choom when they can dance so so well..for me karina is one of the best fourth gen female dancer

Pretty sure Winter's voice could shatter glass if she wanted to.

Karina's closing voice is very addictive

Only handful of idols can switch from singing, dancing, to rapping while serving visuals and Karina is definitely one of them. She's so talented! Such an ACE!

i understand how people see the choreo as underwhelming but tbh it really fits the beat with the hype bouncing n the industrialness of vibe

윈터 클로즈업 됐을 때 표현 강약조절 갓벽 와 미쳤다 진짜

I love how the choreography is opposite to the power of the song. It's not overly energetic, it matches perfectly.

I love how Karina executes each movement. You can see every detail and feel her movements through the screen. Especially during her rap when she popped up. Her isolations and popping in the chorus are so mesmerizing and clean. I really wish she had her own dance break but that's alright she already showed exactly why she is main dancer, centre and fotg and will forever be a main slayer. I hope she herself posts more of her dancing because I can tell how passionate she truly is

1:38 닝깅이 이 파트 음색이랑 안무 너무너무 좋다,,

おぉ～ ウインターカッコいいな👍 ダンスも声量も言う事がないぐらい素晴らしい😆

True fact : aespa members charisma are literally out this world

Cant take my eyes off karina. she's a great performer. When she dances in the back, my eyes will always be on her. She was like a magnet that made sure people only saw her. Choosing Karina as center is the best choice.

Girls deserved better. It's their best title track but people were so quick to hate it

This song has something that no ther has for me. My favorite of all times.

I think the fact that the choreography is easy is really good for me. I'm tired of extremely difficult and generic choreography. And break dancing is definitely amazing!

Because even when the camera is focused on the other girls *NINGNING* manages to stand out, she shines too much, her beauty is offensive hahaha too wonderful!!

I miss this concept😢

I believe it's a great song that could've used a great matching choreography. What in the seven hells is that choreo

Karina main slayer, even with the less screentime she still ate

Winter girl, you have the wrong hair The hair you wore with this outfit on the MV was fire 🥹🔥

This is my favorite aespa song because it makes you question who the main vocalists are. All four of them pop off vocally here.

Winter's arm accessory reminds me of Rikku's from Final Fantasy. I remember painting her onto canvas over 10yrs ago and wished an accessory as such was available back then. Winter's one actually looks way cooler, too. Now I want them again lol

This is so good. They are so charismatic. Cant stop replaying

I saw Winter on the thumb so I came here, she's certainly a goddess

I don’t get why so many people call this choreo awkward. Maybe in one or two bad performances, but not here. This choreo is great.

just listened to this song for the first time AND DAMN IS THIS PART INTIMIDATING 3:00 😭

Karina is so pretty, charismatic, ethereal, talented, great performer and dancer. She always shines no matter what. This girl was born to be an idol !! 🤍

Karina never fails to catch everyone's attention. She is a performer who gives her 200% into each performance. That's why the impact in her own parts was so memorable even though she was 3rd in the line distribution and had lesser screentime. That's an ace, center, and fotg!

Information!!!!!! aespa now is the only 4th generation group to perform in Tokyo Dome and not only one time but two time and tomorrow they will perform their again which make it three times

10M go mys

카리나 이날 메이크업 너무 잘어울린다 의상도 반사판같아서 안 그래도 반짝이는 사람이 더 반짝이네

Karina serving visuals on top of singing, dancing, and rapping. A main slayer indeed!

このカリナ最高に綺麗…いつもだけど

'Girls' has won its 2nd win on MCountdown today! Congratulations to aespa and MYs.

Ok but Giselle really did well and did her best to keep up with the members,her stage presence has improved a lot. She's grown more confident and her rap is getting better. Fighting Gigi

choreo feels so awkward idk why but i’m in love with the song and aespa, love em

이노래가 광야의 정점인듯 가사도 ㅈㄴ잘씀

Let's go 10M!!!!

Karina looks so gorgeous, top3 visuals in kpop if we're being honest

Karina looks like an actual angel, it's a blessing to watch her perform! Born to be the center

Let’s go 10M

*It's 2023 and this performance remains legend❤️‍🔥*

Karina is so captivating Her charisma,stage presence,the facial expressions and her dance moves are top tier

my girl Giselle improved so much! I'm proud of you Aeri

Girls in studio choom 10M!!!

WINTER💗

They all improved so much in this comeback! Especially Winter with her facial expressions and stage presence. Let’s hope this keeps up in all the other performances. Tbh, didn’t really like the dance break choreography but they did good with what they were given. Keep fighting!💙🌙⭐️🦋

카리나 여쿨 메이크업 착붙이네… 이 때 까지 봤던 스타일 중에 제일 잘 어울린다

Aespa comeback soon pls SM

Let's make it 10M, Mys!!

Karina’s aura is so captivating, she's so consistent in her dancing and her stage presence is on top, proud of my girl, she's getting better every day.

그냥 지린다.. 에스파 세계관 비주얼 춤선 갓벽하다 세계관 계속 이어줘 ㅠㅠ 자기전 1일 1에스파 필수관람;;

This song truly deserved better, the storyline, the vocals, the raps, the dance break, the choreography and styling all made girls my favourite comeback from them

this is my favorite video of giselle so far, all the shots of her and she just killed it while looking amazing!!

WINTER AS THE THUMBNAIL IS PERFECTION-

強い、かわいい、かっこいい。

2nd best GG. people expect way too much from them.

KARINA'S IS REALLY AN ACE AND ALL ROUNDER OF AESPA. She's a main dancer, lead rapper, and sub vocal. Her visual, charisma and stage presence is another level. I'm so proud of her!!

와 카리나 이번 영상에서 진짜 예쁘다..볼터치 진짜 잘어울린다

Love how half the people watching missed the point, as usual😔. This is not an easy song. This is actually a really hard dance, because it has lots of quick, precise hand movements mixed with big dynamic moves, unusual poses, and a complicated beat. Plus, the dynamics of the moves have to be done right to give it the right effect. That slowdown effect dance break isn't done digitally, they're doing it themselves, which is why it's so cool. Karina is the best at this kind of stuff, of course, but the rest of the girls are also doing a really good job. For everyone getting on Giselle, this is the kind of dance where training shows, and she has the least if I recall. She's basically been surviving on pure talent and a little bit of training, and she's actually done great. I suspect she's been working herself half to death to make sure she's keeping up, and this is just the kind of song that happens to really show which movements have been trained into muscle memory and which haven't. She's a little off in some parts yes, but you can see that she's concentrated on being on the best and in time with the others on the moves that count and the moments where she's center. I see no reason to bash her, she's clearly going above and beyond to handle a concept which is technically out of her skill set, and she's doing a great job of that. Also, I want to point out Winter for using more facial expression since no one else is mentioning it. I didn't really think she needed to, since I think the way she dances is pretty expressive, but I could see the first time I watched this that she was making an effort to emote with her face more than normal. Ningning continues to be excellent and a really solid all-rounder. She was killing it on those vocals. I think this dance is a perfect match to the song. It makes them look like they're fighting and conveys a fierce vibe without requiring them jump around everywhere, which also makes it look more elegant. I suspect they probably could sing this song live, if sm ever let them. I really hope they do. I love this comeback so much!

I get that the choreo is part of their concept but that beat drop went so hard and the dance break didn't. The one thing I do love is that that choreo for 3:33 is literally just "let Winter do her freaking high note". Some things just can't be done while dancing and I hope this type of realism is added to kpop choreos in the future.

I fall in love more every time I look at Winter

Karina, Giselle, Winter, Ningning are amazing and cool they're doing so so well ♡

ファイナルファンタジーみたい。綺麗

They all are *improved* so much! Look at *Ningning and Gissel literally ate* like dance and stage presence OMG! *Karina is already the Ace and Winter stable Queen* ✨✨

What's beautiful about Karina is that she never holds herself back so she never lacks. She offers all that she got and that's her 101% performance everytime.

i wish to see winter in long blonde hair 🥺 but she looks good with short hair too🥰❤️

AESPA ON TOP

Karina looks *insanely* good! and omg Ningning's outfit !