This Is the Biggest Problem With EV Adoption | WSJ

  Переглядів 622,970

The Wall Street Journal

The Wall Street Journal

День тому

Los Angeles County has more public DC fast chargers for EVs than any other city in the U.S. The majority of non-Tesla electric vehicles have a CCS port that works at these charging stations as well. The problem?
WSJ’s Joanna Stern hit up 30 EV charging locations in a Rivian R1T and found that 40% of them were broken. Here’s what’s being done to fix the EV charging mess.
Chapters:
0:00 Testing EV chargers in Los Angeles
1:52 Three main problems with the chargers
4:26 Why so many chargers are broken
6:10 The future of EV charging
7:36 What I learned
Tech Things With Joanna Stern
Everything is now a tech thing. In creative and humorous videos, WSJ senior personal tech columnist Joanna Stern explains and reviews the products, services and trends that are changing our world.
#EV #Tech #WSJ

КОМЕНТАРІ: 2 000
@VG-or1nu
@VG-or1nu 5 місяців тому
Renting an electric car and having to download the 30 apps was one of the most insufferable experiences ever I’ve been through
@economicblast
@economicblast 5 місяців тому
ik you joking but what was the actual amount of apps you had to download and why?
@ronald4life1
@ronald4life1 5 місяців тому
@@economicblast They are being silly, but the actual number is about 6x charging apps, and 1x for plugshare to find them. Note there is some overlap in apps where one will let you pay for multiple others.
@SelfMadeThousandaire
@SelfMadeThousandaire 5 місяців тому
​@@economicblastit was 5 for us when I rented an EV.
@schalitz1
@schalitz1 5 місяців тому
Agreed, same here. They need to make it easier if they ever want them to catch on. High tech solutions aren't always necessary.
@silvy7394
@silvy7394 5 місяців тому
I daily drive an EV and only have 3 apps. Plugshare, Chargepoint, and Shell Recharge I dont even need shell recharge, as chargepoint will activate those stations.
@Paul-ou1rx
@Paul-ou1rx 5 місяців тому
Imagine how upset you would be if regular gas pumps failed this often. But there are usually a few choices of stations within a few blocks of each other.
@SSGoatanks
@SSGoatanks 5 місяців тому
Can't believe governments think this is better than building trains and public transportation 🚝🛤🚋
@Maderasdesign
@Maderasdesign 5 місяців тому
I feel for renters and condo owners. But nothing beats never having to visit one if you charge at home.
@ErikS308
@ErikS308 5 місяців тому
The gasoline company selling to you maintain their pumps so they can make money. If the government puts their fingers in it, it will fail.
@noob.168
@noob.168 5 місяців тому
costco and sam's pumps are always broken.
@MrGoodeats
@MrGoodeats 5 місяців тому
oh no. it makes you just as upset. if not more because sometimes you are stranded or face extreme range anxiety. no fun. lol
@JackGirard1
@JackGirard1 5 місяців тому
The payment issues are the most baffling. I've seen maybe one broken card reader on a gas pump in the past 5 years.
@oculosprudentium8486
@oculosprudentium8486 5 місяців тому
And even then, you can go inside the store to pay for the fill up
@mpodolsky11
@mpodolsky11 5 місяців тому
I may be stating the obvious but is it possible the magnetic strip on the card needs to face the other way. On the vid itwas always facing the same way (toward the machine) It is counter intuitive but sometimes the reader needs the mag stripe facing away from the machine
@micahgreene4573
@micahgreene4573 5 місяців тому
@@mpodolsky11 she said she tried the card every which way
@JamesBrown059
@JamesBrown059 5 місяців тому
If you’re actually curious - it’s literally just unreliable confirmation of payment from terminal vendors (NAYAX being a big player) From unacceptable network latencies which time-out the charger, to disagreements on the application of the currently non-standardized charger output initialization. This is why DCFCs prefer you pay through their app as that gives them much more granular control of the process. OCPP 2.0.x is looking to address the issue of OEMs using separate networks and requiring their own apps.
@MaksymDomarev
@MaksymDomarev 5 місяців тому
Just buy Tesla no credit card involved lol
@LukaBeluga
@LukaBeluga 5 місяців тому
As someone who personally have drove from Atlanta, Georgia to Los Angeles, California in a Chevrolet bolt EV, I completely agree with all of the points that she said in this video, they are all valid, all across the United States 😢😢😢
@Notme-tq4xs
@Notme-tq4xs 5 місяців тому
Get a Tesla, works much better.
@thedopplereffect00
@thedopplereffect00 5 місяців тому
With 50 kW charging? Must have taken you a couple weeks or more.
@asajayunknown6290
@asajayunknown6290 5 місяців тому
You obviously have lots of spare time, and tons of patience 😊
@tranceporter7426
@tranceporter7426 4 місяці тому
In a Bolt?!? You must be a masochist
@user-vm5ps9ik8c
@user-vm5ps9ik8c 4 місяці тому
Lol bro a bolt gets you like 160 on 80% charge. 😊 I use it for my daily commute to work and sometimes some day trips but never in my life for an extended trip that's crazy
@willie346
@willie346 5 місяців тому
The real question is why are broken chargers not promptly fixed. I know of specific chargers that have not been repaired for months.
@RyanWilliams222
@RyanWilliams222 5 місяців тому
That, and why are they breaking so often?
@danielzhang1916
@danielzhang1916 5 місяців тому
I would be okay with 5-7% broken, but not 30% out of order, that is ridiculous and unacceptable for people
@petehelme7714
@petehelme7714 5 місяців тому
if it's a place running chargers like from ChargePoint, perhaps they didn't keep the maintenance contract going. a lot of the larger companies are waiting on replacing existing hardware with a newer generation rather than fixing the old units. then you run into parts availability too.
@petehelme7714
@petehelme7714 5 місяців тому
@@RyanWilliams222 pay attention to gas station pumps. they break too, but there are just so many of them around, one just moves on to the next pump and/or station and doesn't really notice.
@thedopplereffect00
@thedopplereffect00 5 місяців тому
It's not profitable
@CSHarvey
@CSHarvey 5 місяців тому
Fun part of CCS is that the large connector and cable weight causes leverage that pulls the communication pins apart during the handshake. If the connection clip is loose enough and you dont hold the plug in the socket during the handshake, the plug weight can actually cause it to pull just far enough off the pins to sever the connection and disrupt the handshake. Excellent industrial design!
@ai4px
@ai4px 5 місяців тому
You are correct. Also the locking tab pulls down and out necessitating keeping a wooden stick to prop up the plug handle.
@thomascrabtree
@thomascrabtree 5 місяців тому
The Tesla charger is also CCS (NACS - which is CCS1), the big chargers you're seeing in the video are CCS2. That's why Tesla chargers can only charge up to 350kW, usually 250kW to be safe... CCS2 which is common everywhere outside the US in the rest of the world including Europe, Asia etc can charge up to 700kW safely even from home (especially since most countries use three phase 220-250v at home from standard sockets). Essentially Americans need charging stations, the rest of the world can fast charge at home (if you have a regular socket on your drive or garage) and so the bulkier connectors aren't such a big problem and the hit to the electricity grid is much more evenly distributed.
@holmiumh
@holmiumh 5 місяців тому
@@thomascrabtree You are drunk. Go home.
@thomascrabtree
@thomascrabtree 5 місяців тому
@@holmiumh Sorry you don't like facts
@Notme-tq4xs
@Notme-tq4xs 5 місяців тому
@@thomascrabtree Nobody is charging at 700kw
@cmw3737
@cmw3737 5 місяців тому
27% out of order is amazing. Only 10% having payment issues seemed miraculous until I saw that having to download a different app for every charger wasn't seen as an issue. When trying to use non-Tesla chargers the amount of different apps needed was the biggest pain of all, with every locality seeming to have a different provider.
@CrazyWatcher670
@CrazyWatcher670 3 місяці тому
I wouldn’t be baffled if every charger would ask different apps.
@francisbayona
@francisbayona 5 місяців тому
Such a great video about the realities of EV ownership, especially if you’re an apartment dweller in LA with no dedicated home charging in the parking garage
@djpalindrome
@djpalindrome 4 місяці тому
This. EV snobs are privileged elitists who think single family home ownership is the norm.
@hisownfool1
@hisownfool1 4 місяці тому
My complex has four chargers and they are often out of service. The management calls and response from the operators is slow.
@mrc1436
@mrc1436 4 місяці тому
Only the realities for non Tesla owners
@robertkubrick3738
@robertkubrick3738 Місяць тому
Or even if you were renting a house. You can't rewire a house you are renting unless you are leaving the charger if you move.
@williammark1762
@williammark1762 5 місяців тому
This was one of the main reasons I went with a Tesla. I didn’t even bother looking at other options and wouldn’t until this mess is resolved.
@robertgrant721
@robertgrant721 5 місяців тому
Precisely
@anthonyc8499
@anthonyc8499 5 місяців тому
Everyone gaining access to Superchargers makes non-Tesla EVs a non-issue.
@meganote
@meganote 5 місяців тому
@@anthonyc8499 Hopefully that will be the case eventually... probably about 2+ years down the road. Currently the number of Tesla SCs available to non-Tesla vehicles is pretty limited, but slowly expanding. For instance, if you go to the Tesla charging map, it only shows 2 non-Tesla chargers available in California. So it's currently still quite an issue and will take some time to implement.
@TK-gd9td
@TK-gd9td 5 місяців тому
closed proprietary systems are almost always better in these early development stage situations. same reason why apple is so much more optimized since even the beginning days
@hedonismbot1508
@hedonismbot1508 5 місяців тому
​@anthonyc8499 Rather, it will once the other cars actually start coming with NACS plugs and Tesla actually enables their full network to other cars. I'm personally looking to get a Model Y after the Juniper redesign, and charging is just one of several reasons it would best suit my needs.
@MattHirsch
@MattHirsch 5 місяців тому
They didn't even discuss the problem of derated chargers, where you plug in and it charges much slower than it should.
@brianm6965
@brianm6965 5 місяців тому
The problem there is that they have to know what they’re looking for to notice. That is… knowing the maximum DCFC rate of your car which I’m guessing you have to Google when you do a rental.
@brushlessmotoring
@brushlessmotoring 5 місяців тому
Sometimes that is the car though, if it has a cold battery, it will limit too.
@VoltLover00
@VoltLover00 5 місяців тому
So many were broken she didn't even get to that part. Also, I doubt she knows what derating is
@franknew9001
@franknew9001 5 місяців тому
This was a great video. I did learn from this video that I will be keeping my ICE car for a long, long time. It would've been interesting to know how much added range Joanna got on the Rivian, how much it cost, and how long it took. I recently saw a similar video where a guy wanted to charge a Rivian in LA and between waiting for an available charger and finding one that worked, it took over an hour to get about 250 miles of range, and it cost $60. I understand these public charging rates in California are extremely high. I just drove 815 miles from Florida to Maryland in my Lincoln Town Car, getting 25.7 miles per gallon. On my trip, from one gas station to the next one, I drove 342 miles and cost $45 to fill the gas tank in about five minutes. I made the trip in one day, taking about 14 hours due to heavy traffic in some areas. If I was driving an EV, with the extra time charging and trying to find a working and available charger, it probably would have meant staying overnight at a hotel, adding at least $100 to the trip. I definitely won't be buying an EV anytime soon.
@angy97
@angy97 5 місяців тому
EVs are for around town errands or commute, not long distance travel… you pick the wrong use case
@gbmoney8746
@gbmoney8746 5 місяців тому
Nah if you buy a Tesla there are none of these issues and it’s much cheaper to operate than a gas/ICE car. This whole video was about non-Tesla chargers.
@CautionBarrier
@CautionBarrier 4 місяці тому
@@angy97 ICEs work for town errands AND long distance travel. There's no need for a specific use case.
@RUAChristian
@RUAChristian 4 місяці тому
@@angy97Not so. In CA, they’re planning on banning sales of gas cars in the near future.
@kng128
@kng128 2 місяці тому
Yeah, after 100 years of ICE cars and being born into a world where there are 20 megawatt fuel dispensers at every intersection sure does make life easy.
@pittsee
@pittsee 18 днів тому
I’ve never seen a video telling me “if you want an EV get Tesla” so much 😂👍🏼
@valramos2003
@valramos2003 5 місяців тому
Would have been interesting to see Joanna’s heart rate at these chargers to see which one was the most frustrating.
@therolando608
@therolando608 5 місяців тому
The grocery store I go to has had only 1 of 4 Chargepoint Chargers operational for almost a year now. It is insane. I and other users have filled several maintenance requests for them and nothing has gotten done.
@danielzhang1916
@danielzhang1916 5 місяців тому
it's ridiculous that 30% of chargers are out of order, how are people supposed to use them
@Distress.
@Distress. 5 місяців тому
​@@danielzhang1916they don't care. Teslas network is great because without it you can't use their cars. The other companies got paid by the government to install chargers, whether they work or not is not their problem, they got paid.
@thedopplereffect00
@thedopplereffect00 5 місяців тому
And it never will because they don't make money from them being operational
@Lightdog555
@Lightdog555 5 місяців тому
I believe many of the chargers are owned by individuals so they might not have the resources to keep them all fixed if they aren’t making a lot of money
@esecallum
@esecallum 5 місяців тому
Starting Friday, dockworkers in all Swedish ports will refuse to offload Teslas, cleaning crews will no longer clean showrooms, and mechanics won’t fix charging points as the labor dispute rages on.
@awdgsx415
@awdgsx415 5 місяців тому
This is why I decided to opt for a Tesla. I really wanted to jump into the new i4 but logistics when taking long road trips to northern california to visit family forced me to go with Telsa and their superior Superchargers. On our recent road trip up north to saw us making a charge stop at a popular exit (Harris Ranch). There was about 6-7 non Tesla chargers with only 5 working and a line of 14 cars waiting to charge!!! That's insane!! Never seen that before. So I could totally see why the EV adoption will take a long time to happen. There was about 80++ Tesla Superchargers at the location.
@rudycampilii1621
@rudycampilii1621 5 місяців тому
I have never had a problem finding a gas station, ever!
@onomatopoeia162003
@onomatopoeia162003 4 місяці тому
maybe when people were still using horses. LOL
@kng128
@kng128 2 місяці тому
Good thing there have been decades and decades of people driving cars so you don't have to be inconvenienced!
@igvc1876
@igvc1876 7 днів тому
@@kng128 good thing we have early adopters to suffer through this so I can get it when all the problems are resolved
@kng128
@kng128 7 днів тому
@@igvc1876 In my area there are 6kw chargers all over. At the doctor’s office, city hall, libraries, public pay-to-park lots, playgrounds, driving range, across the street from my office, more down the street. Extremely convenient. I can early adopt because in 2009 my wife and I paid off our cars. We’ve been putting “car payments” money into brokerage account since. We don’t take loans for cars anymore.
@EmmanuelHernandez-yz1wy
@EmmanuelHernandez-yz1wy 5 місяців тому
Tesla owner for 4 years here. Never not once have I ever run into an issue with a Tesla Supercharger not working when I show up. Can't imagine what its like for people dealing with this issue.
@FabyRamone
@FabyRamone 5 місяців тому
And if they are not working, the car will tell you ahead of time, very often at the stall level.
@plinden
@plinden 5 місяців тому
Never not once have I ever
@Cryaboutmyhandle
@Cryaboutmyhandle 5 місяців тому
Car owner and builder 30 plus years. Not once have had a pump issue. Amazing eh?
@obstinatehammer7113
@obstinatehammer7113 5 місяців тому
Wait until next year💀
@SilverandButters
@SilverandButters 5 місяців тому
​@@Cryaboutmyhandleyou are so amazing that you own a car and can build them
@hkad6252
@hkad6252 5 місяців тому
Title should be: Why are so many EV chargers broken in the US? Here in Germany I have never encountered a charger that doesn’t work. Public CCS chargers outnumber Tesla chargers 10:1. All charging tarifs/cards work on basically every charger. The infrastructure is way ahead of the market, most charging stations are empty most of the time.
@TechieBaby
@TechieBaby 3 місяці тому
Hands down the Most practical review on EV.
@bsaxman2012
@bsaxman2012 5 місяців тому
Being a Tesla owner, I've never experienced any of the frustrations demonstrated in this video in any of my long distance trips (I charge at home for local driving). It's easy to see why most car companies have announced deals with Tesla to gain access to the Tesla Supercharger network.
@sa34w
@sa34w 5 місяців тому
Tesla is a beast when it comes to charging that’s their USP
@PNWeBike
@PNWeBike 5 місяців тому
Same. I have to believe that people who purchase non-Tesla EVs did so while being mislead about the charging situation. No one willingly buy into such an unreliable system like that. It’s not wonder virtually every EV manufacturer other than Tesla is struggling.
@KayakFishingAddict
@KayakFishingAddict 5 місяців тому
Yep, never an issue with Tesla and the supercharging network. Can’t wait until other cars have the NACS connector *and* work at a Tesla Super Charger! We’ll all have congestion problems but at least we’ll be able to buy an EV Truck that doesn’t look like a DeLorean on steroids.
@gbmoney8746
@gbmoney8746 5 місяців тому
@@PNWeBikeyeah the old reason I bought a Bolt was because the plan was to never use it for roadtrips (charge at home). Second car is a Tesla Model Y of course haha
@sptrader6316
@sptrader6316 4 місяці тому
Yes, many other vehicles will be able to use the Tesla chargers = longer wait times for Tesla owners.
@alterdavidj
@alterdavidj 5 місяців тому
6 year Tesla owner here. I've never experienced broken Tesla Super Charger. I'm hoping with almost every EV manufacturer adopting NACS and getting access to the Super Charger network starting in 2024 that other EV owners can have the same amazing experience as Tesla owners. I love Tesla but support the adoption of electric transportation even more.
@Cryaboutmyhandle
@Cryaboutmyhandle 5 місяців тому
What's it like destroying the environment and acting like you arent?
@CharlieBam
@CharlieBam 4 місяці тому
I've seen some insane lines for chargers here in my city, the bottleneck with charging times is pretty crazy. This generation of evs are not generally green unless you put some serious miles on the original battery. Then its marginal. The heavy mining required to source and process the raw materials is shocking and largely ignored when calculating how green they are. Not to mention the forced child labor and slavery associated with many of the sources. Kind of weird how many of my fellow liberals dont care that the price of their car is a result of child slavery and tax payer subsidy. The vehicles weigh a ton, you burn tires more than 2x as fast (which is a key source of carcinogens and pollutants in our air and water), the level of infrastructure development is going to be insane when you realize the energy we get from fuel is now going to need to be fed through the existing grid. We will need a level of infrastructure to support this that people don't understand because they aren't electrical engineers. Look at the cost and industrial effort behind building, installing, and maintaining just one transformer. Or the cost for just one mile of transmission lines. It's incredible. Evs are primarily a way for governments to pretend they are "taking action" without actually doing anything or offending their rich donors. They can put these costs on the taxpayer and average person instead of addressing where the massive power usage is actually happening. It's the people with lots of money and power who do what they want and don't care.
@gamingwitharlen2267
@gamingwitharlen2267 3 місяці тому
A electric car is more efficient and the natural gas is more efficient to make. We can also convert to renewables. @@Cryaboutmyhandle
@carlosarriaga7428
@carlosarriaga7428 3 місяці тому
@@CryaboutmyhandleWhat’s like creating pollution in the air?
@Cryaboutmyhandle
@Cryaboutmyhandle 3 місяці тому
@@carlosarriaga7428 how is 50 tons of ore for one battery with a 7 year shelf life. That needs fossil fuel to be build charged and maintained, better for the environment?
@garydmercer
@garydmercer Місяць тому
I will not buy a vehicle with a CCS charging port. Terrible. Only Tesla NAC super chargers are decent. I will only buy an EV with the NAC adapter already installed. Most car manufacturers and adopting the NAC charging standard. That is the way to go.
@patriot388
@patriot388 4 місяці тому
Hmm.. I pull into a gas station, fill up, and I'm out in 5 minutes! 😂
@khoa2610
@khoa2610 2 місяці тому
hmm remember when someone would say "why would i need to buy this liquid to put into an automobile when I can just feed my horse some grass/hay?" yup, that's what you sound like.
@david_lawrence_h2703
@david_lawrence_h2703 Місяць тому
@@khoa2610 Perfect.
@elscruffomcscruffy8371
@elscruffomcscruffy8371 Місяць тому
Good option until the system irons out its problems.
@MR_THINQ
@MR_THINQ Місяць тому
Same here, gas re-fuelling is soooo quick and reliable - it’s the future! 👍🏻
@COSMACELF1802
@COSMACELF1802 13 днів тому
5 minutes? You really like to take your time. I'm out in just 3 minutes. Gas filling is far more reliable and faster than EV's. EV's only work for people that can charge at home and even that's a joke. Imagine having to plug in your car every night when you get home. I prefer a wireless solution... gas!
@ronald4life1
@ronald4life1 5 місяців тому
So in Germany, they require you bring your own cable for Level 2 (non "super") charging. This is because the cables are the number one thing that breaks on these. So if everyone has their own cable the likelihood of it breaking is minimal. So all drivers keep the cable in their car and plug it in. They've as a result been able to deploy tons and tons of level 2 chargers which makes sense.
@thedopplereffect00
@thedopplereffect00 5 місяців тому
That's ridiculous. Imagine going to a gas station and then requiring you to bring your own hose
@thedopplereffect00
@thedopplereffect00 5 місяців тому
Or going to a restaurant and having to bring your own utensils, 😂
@colinm1502
@colinm1502 5 місяців тому
The plug in on charger would get high mate and de-mate and need to be replaced.
@orineman139
@orineman139 5 місяців тому
@@colinm1502 and how is that different to the plug on a charger cable getting many mate/de-mate cycles? Either way, it's a wear item that's going to need replacing every so often.
@Chamieiniibet
@Chamieiniibet 5 місяців тому
@@thedopplereffect00 or having a cable to plug your phone/laptop/appliances to a wall socket.
@blusox78
@blusox78 5 місяців тому
Quick answer is that most charging companies don't regularly maintain their chargers. I don't know if this is because they are not connected so the company does not know if they are working or not. Some big charging companies are now buying Tesla charging hardware, so hopefully they also adopt the Tesla maintenance model. Like may hear are saying, if you use a Tesla and it's charger network then you hardy have any issues.
@thedopplereffect00
@thedopplereffect00 5 місяців тому
They don't make money selling electricity, they make money collecting government grants to install the cheapest option
@gund89123
@gund89123 5 місяців тому
This creates a monopoly though that’s the concern.
@jensenraylight8011
@jensenraylight8011 5 місяців тому
so, they no longer like money right? and they're asking to be Disrupted someone should grant them their wish
@sebastianorye2702
@sebastianorye2702 5 місяців тому
@@gund89123 To an extent. Tesla is selling its hardware globally (so far have made 2 UK deals), however, there are competitors. In the US, for NACS, it's an open patent for all to use freely. Tesla is also outsourcing its plugs production in order to not make it a US monopoly. Anyone can make the NACS plug, despite Elon personally owning the patent.
@leonidfro8302
@leonidfro8302 5 місяців тому
Quick answer is - nobody interested in maintaining those chargers, as (almost) nobody profits. Tesla profits albeit indirectly, so their chargers are maintained.
@bigwhig3126
@bigwhig3126 5 місяців тому
Why didn't they just stick with the Hybrid concept and simply beef up the battery capacity so that it could run on electric for short hops and switch over to gas when on long trips? That would have saved an awful lot of headaches.
@nelsond5361
@nelsond5361 5 місяців тому
Great Journalism 👍. I loved every bit of this video
@Broadbent906
@Broadbent906 5 місяців тому
Not just an LA or USA problem, in Sydney Australia there's always 25-60% of DC chargers out of order at any given time. Takes a long time to fix, I assumed it was a monetary issue.
@oculosprudentium8486
@oculosprudentium8486 5 місяців тому
Compared to how many gasoline stations that has 90% of their pumps working Plus it seldom takes more than 5 minutes to fill your tank And get at least 350 miles driving range And in almost every city, there is a gas station every mile
@dylanbea8789
@dylanbea8789 5 місяців тому
Its the same in the UK, lucky I can have a home charger as my house has a drive, if I didn’t have my own I would not get an electric car, it’s actually impossible using public charges, it’s to hit and miss to rely on
@jimmcfarland9318
@jimmcfarland9318 5 місяців тому
I love the internal combustion engine!
@COSMACELF1802
@COSMACELF1802 13 днів тому
Yes, I love ICE too. No problems like EV's. But, some day, EV's will get it right and we can switch without the head aches. ... give it 20 years.
@bechirannabi7050
@bechirannabi7050 5 місяців тому
A nice overview of the challenges related to the energy transition leading to sustainable change, emphasizing current issues and problems associated with the use and implementation of electric vehicle chargers.
@JoshuaStringfellow1
@JoshuaStringfellow1 5 місяців тому
While the the charge point does have to communicate with multiple different types of cars and their firmware, it should all be standardised. The issue to an extent is implementation of the standard. These implementations will be improved and refined over time, as will the charging hardware, payment integration, etc. It's going to be messy, but should get better.
@ThomasGlynnJr
@ThomasGlynnJr 5 місяців тому
Yeah, it will NEVER happen. Think Android and it's hundreds of different manufactures that use that software. It's why app makers hate making apps for android - it'll work on one brand, but not another. That will never be resolved unless each brand gives up its reason for existing in the first place...
@JoshuaStringfellow1
@JoshuaStringfellow1 5 місяців тому
@@ThomasGlynnJr Bad analogy for a couple reasons. Android isn't a standard, it's an operating system and a moving target. Android, despite not being a standard, is hugely popular and the dominant mobile OS. A better comparison for charging communication protocols would be other standardised communication protocols. Think IP, TCP, HTTP, HTTPS, TLS(SSL), ICMP, etc. All of these - and many more - were used to load this website, stream the video, and then publish your comment and notify me of it. They all have several implementors, and they all work well enough that they're fundamental to the internet and modern society.
@emeraldbonsai
@emeraldbonsai 5 місяців тому
You have to remeber every time a standard is made 2 more will be made to unify the standards XD
@broli123
@broli123 5 місяців тому
@@emeraldbonsai Ah yes the world post-late-capitalism, we are finally here.
@Tschacki_Quacki
@Tschacki_Quacki 5 місяців тому
@@broli123 Has zero to do with capitalism since CCS was politically motivated (which explains why it's such a mess).
@Patrick_3751
@Patrick_3751 5 місяців тому
The UKpostsr Aging Wheels did his own experiment on public EV chargers, and he revealed a 4th major problem with them: Many do not charge at the full rate/capacity they are advertised at! Which means a charge advertised as only taking 15 minutes can take hours to complete!
@lukerinderknecht2982
@lukerinderknecht2982 5 місяців тому
The guy from the Motorcoach World channel also did a road trip this summer in an electric coach bus and had a similar experience.
@CodyDavis91
@CodyDavis91 5 місяців тому
Except for the Tesla chargers which were flawless. Don't wrap up Tesla in the legacy auto garbage.
@mrnarason
@mrnarason 5 місяців тому
Yeah, I'm surprised they completely forget to mentioned that in the video
@robertkubrick3738
@robertkubrick3738 Місяць тому
@@CodyDavis91 Chicago, Chicago, not teslas kind of town! Not when it's cold anyway.
@johns9969
@johns9969 4 місяці тому
On a biz trip to Austin, got an EV rental. Could not find a working charger in the week there.left it with 5% charge.
@osigano
@osigano 4 місяці тому
Your pieces are so good Joanna. I will watch whatever you do, even if it’s a review of junk food. ❤
@Junior2uu
@Junior2uu 5 місяців тому
I love this video you went straight to the point not Bias no propaganda no hate just the truth as an EV driver my self I have this same experience here on the east coast thank you for this.
@vincentorlando6767
@vincentorlando6767 5 місяців тому
Excellent reporting identifying problems is first step in providing improved solutions
@turnersinsurance8656
@turnersinsurance8656 Місяць тому
I actually believe the 'hold up' or 'hesitation' to most NEW buyers of EVs is actually the 'AT HOME' charging, or specifically, LACK THEREOF... for instance, if you are an apartment dweller, or live in a group living arrangement where 'general parking' is the norm, you'll lack the ability to simply plug in when you are at 'home'... which is the MAJORITY of power any EV ever receives. I get that 'travel' charging is a big concern, but the REALITY is that most EV owners miles per year are actually right AROUND where they live and work. Until we develop an EASY and AFFORDABLE and ADAPTABLE 'at home' charging option, the U.S. adoption of EV ownership, specifically of single-vehicle households, ESPECIALLY in larger cities and metro areas, will be hindered by the real-world question: 'how, or where, do I charge every NIGHT?'
@markvicferrer
@markvicferrer 5 місяців тому
Sunny LA is the best case scenario. Imagine going through this during inclement weather or low temperatures.
@StephenShankland
@StephenShankland 5 місяців тому
Not everybody can charge at home, or charge fast at home, but being able to do so is so, so much better than having to visit gas stations. I've had problems with busted DC fast chargers, but I almost never charge at charging stations. Growing pains of the EV industry.
@VoltLover00
@VoltLover00 5 місяців тому
Repeatedly fast charging decreases battery life, far better to slow charge at home
@StephenShankland
@StephenShankland 5 місяців тому
@@VoltLover00 we charged for a long time at one kilowatt with regular 110 volt AC power. Not very practical unless you have 2 days to recharge your EV after a long battery draining trip. We upgraded to 7 kW charging now. Much more useful, still not what I would consider fast charging compared to 150W or 250W Tesla superchargers.
@thedopplereffect00
@thedopplereffect00 5 місяців тому
If you can't charge at home, don't buy an EV. not worth the drama
@martalli
@martalli 5 місяців тому
Charging at home is really the way to go. 66% of housing units in the US have a garage or driveway. For those people an EV would be easy to own and live with.
@oculosprudentium8486
@oculosprudentium8486 5 місяців тому
As for the Charging At Home situation Just you wait and see when your house become Uninsurable because of owning those 4 wheeled Crematoriums.
@elbowsout6301
@elbowsout6301 5 місяців тому
It's a cop out for the charging companies to say that it's complicated to connect to many different vehicles that's why we have standards. They are just 2 computers talking to each other through a cable that's like the most basic type of a networked connection you can possibly have.
@thedopplereffect00
@thedopplereffect00 5 місяців тому
It really isn't complicated at all. The communication even has a dedicated set of wires
@elbowsout6301
@elbowsout6301 5 місяців тому
@@thedopplereffect00 Right!!!!
@chychywoohoo
@chychywoohoo 2 місяці тому
I rented a Tesla. The charging is a huge issue and i didnt even have an issue with broken charges. Its simply takes too long and there arent enough if them. There needs to be WAY more charging stations which means upgraes to the grid. There would need to be stations at every parking spot in apartment compelxes.
@gorogo04
@gorogo04 5 місяців тому
Thank You Joanna, for this information.
@steveurbach3093
@steveurbach3093 5 місяців тому
Unlike Gas Stations, many (most), are unattended (no operator on site). So when there are 'issues'. someone (you?) must tell the service provider/owner (most sites are just leased property) and they need to schedule a tech site visit. How many qualified (per model) techs are there in LA (or any other location) ? This issue is not just limited to EV. How long do you have to wait when your Dishwasher breaks down? OMG 3 weeks in the Bay Area for warranty work! We need a better way for repairs. (I did not mention the Vandalized Elephant)
@noseboop4354
@noseboop4354 5 місяців тому
There's also the fact that a gas station is a way simpler device than a charging station, it's basically just a hose and a pump, so much more rare for it to break down.
@thedopplereffect00
@thedopplereffect00 5 місяців тому
​@@noseboop4354pumps are fast more complex than you realize because of saftey issues with flammable liquids. EV charger companies only exist to collect government cheese on the initial install money
@robertkubrick3738
@robertkubrick3738 Місяць тому
Never had my dishwasher leave me stranded on the road, and she looks gorgeous with bed hair in the morning.
@user-hf4tv2kr2u
@user-hf4tv2kr2u 2 місяці тому
I am a Chinese and in a small city in China, I have a BYD electric car. After watching this video, I believe that there is already a significant gap between the development prospects of electric vehicles in the United States and China, and there is no chance for the United States to surpass China.
@wjlambert
@wjlambert 5 місяців тому
PlugShare is a great crowdsource tool to help EV drivers to find high-rated stations. But, yes this is a problem that is slow to find a standard resolution
@Derkaramma
@Derkaramma 2 місяці тому
I’m so excited to get my R1s! We have the charger installed at home already and will primarily charge that way but 100% I know I will have trouble the first few times I charge in public lol like getting gas for the first time
@michaelappel9421
@michaelappel9421 5 місяців тому
Dear Joanna - I feel with you … got my first EV four weeks ago and … same issue. BUT: I live in Spain … worst infrastructure here than you can imagine but also getting there. At least I know now, I am not alone 😂
@xxwookey
@xxwookey 5 місяців тому
Yeah Spain seems to be a long way behind on charger installation. I hope to see that improve soon as I'd love to drive an electric camper down there, and I'm not sure how good an idea that is yet.
@ScottWallace5
@ScottWallace5 5 місяців тому
Well done and love the reporting! Downloading an app just to charge though is super frustrating and hope that gets built into the car better. Until then, I just recommend a Tesla, for it's #1 supercharging network.
@ErikGeurts
@ErikGeurts 5 місяців тому
While by no means faultless, DC rapid charging reliability here in Europe is actually pretty good. A nice example is Dutch operator Fastned (live in several countries across the EU and also in the UK) where I can see how many stalls are available on the station I'm heading for, even when I'm still 15 or even 30 minutes away, on my dashboard display even through Android Auto. Plus they have auto-charge, so no messing with cards or apps after the initial setup. And their up time record is insanely great, it is in fact one of the most important things they focus on as a business. Other charging networks have similar reputations (Ionity for example). Constant remote monitoring of charging stalls and stations, pro-active servicing, and using top of the line hardware appears to be the way they achieve such results. From what I've seen and heard, US charging networks can learn a lot from how things are being done in Europe.
@tonespeaks
@tonespeaks 5 місяців тому
@ErikGeurts How come Canada doesn't have the same issues? It is really simple, America tends to resist progress with all its might. EV sales other than Tesla and a few others are poor, because the car the dealer doesn't want to sell is the EV. EV would likely put Dealerships out of business. When it comes to charging stations, there are some simple reasons there are so many problems: Costs, Costs and costs. It cost Tesla about 1/5 what it costs other companies to install a Charging Station... there are a variety of reasons for this. The other issue is maintenance, this is really difficult because you need trained staff and you need a number of stations to justify having staff and etc. If maintenance is contracted out to 3rd Party, they aren't likely to drop what they are doing to address the issue and so on. The biggest issue is cost, but it is not really just about how much. The problem is that companies were making EVs and doing nothing to support the expansion of the charging network. 80% of EV owners charge at home, so this created a supply v demand issue. The chargers were available but they spent most of the time unused. Basically, I'm saying there was no coordination. Now that the Government(s) have bought into the EV transition there is more coordination, but still not enough. They have allocated some $$$ but where is the coordination?? This is the problem and it isn't likely to be fixed anytime soon, so this is why Tesla / NACS was the only hope. Tesla simply asks/voting its users where they would like a station put and there it goes. Tesla to the rescue, but there is a problem.... Government doesn't really support NACS as the standard yet, hopefully this will change soon.
@thisiswaytoocomplicated
@thisiswaytoocomplicated 5 місяців тому
As a European I cannot even remember when it was the last time I actually had to swipe a card. That means they are really still using the magnetic strip there. Which is of course prone to be unreliable. Seems like a wonder they are not using embossed cards and coal paper any more. 🤣
@Cryaboutmyhandle
@Cryaboutmyhandle 5 місяців тому
@@tonespeaks evs won't be putting dealerships out of business. They will put people out it cars minus the elites.
@JamesR1986
@JamesR1986 5 місяців тому
@@tonespeaks Canada absolutely has the same issues that the US does, as demonstrated by any EV reviews done by The Straight Pipes.
@tonespeaks
@tonespeaks 5 місяців тому
@@JamesR1986 Sorry, but i must strongly disagree. EV adoption in provinces like Quebec are high and there is a pretty healthy EV community in Canada. In Quebec you can even charge on the street, at Lightposts.
@howzhowzhowz
@howzhowzhowz 4 місяці тому
Have been experiencing the exactly same problem since i bought my car! I'm currently live in a college town in the midwest and renting an apartment. The apartment does not have charging facility so I have to charge my car on campus. Well, surprise surprise there are only two Level 2 charging station on a 60000-people campus, where one of them is broken for 2 months. Now I have to charge my car everyday and walk 20 minutes to classes. I come from a small city in China where now there are at least 10 charging stations every TWO blocks!!! US really has a big problem on public EV charging.
@igvc1876
@igvc1876 7 днів тому
maybe should have thought about it before buying an EV
@howzhowzhowz
@howzhowzhowz 7 днів тому
@@igvc1876 that’s exactly why I bought a PHEV but not a EV lolllllll, btw a quick update our university recently installed 10 more chargers
@folarinosibodu
@folarinosibodu 4 місяці тому
I did that exact experiment and experienced the exact same thing. Broken. Broken. Broken.
@RolandGustafsson
@RolandGustafsson 5 місяців тому
I just got back from a 6400 mile road trip in my Tesla Model 3 and had zero problems, all the Superchargers I used were working. This mess referred to is everything EXCEPT Tesla. Can't say this strongly enough! Tesla roadtrip experience is fantastic. There's a reason that the other EV makers are making deals to use Tesla's Superchargers. I've owned my Tesla for nearly 4 years and have ZERO problems charging. ZERO! 😛
@TrendyStone
@TrendyStone 5 місяців тому
I drove to California and back three weeks ago and had zero problems with Tesla's supercharger network. And never once had to wait for a stall.
@COSMACELF1802
@COSMACELF1802 13 днів тому
@@TrendyStone For now... but just imagine every car out there is EV and wanting to use that supercharger... let's see the world in 10 years.
@TrendyStone
@TrendyStone 12 днів тому
@@COSMACELF1802 Supercharger stations are expanding at 30% per year. There are currently 280 new stations under construction and 547 stations awaiting permits, which will add to the existing 6,000 stations with 55,000 individual charging stalls.
@Stromschlag
@Stromschlag 5 місяців тому
Living in central/Western Europe and driving an EV it's absolutely stunning how insanely poor the charging station situation is in the US. It feels like the US is at least 10years behind. Would be interesting to know why, also seeing that there is no "EMP/EMSP" role in the US market (charging tariff cards that work/roam across all networks). In Central/Western Europe nowadays you don't need to worry anymore about chargers not working, we are at up-times of 95% and greater - for modern HPC (fast chargers) it's even more like 99% and more.
@xxwookey
@xxwookey 5 місяців тому
Are uptimes really that good? I think it depends where you live. The UK is OK, but there are non-trivial numbers of chargers with problems although we are weeding out the bad networks so I think things are improving, but only just keeping up with the rate of adoption. The US does seem to be particularly bad for some reason.
@Stromschlag
@Stromschlag 5 місяців тому
@@xxwookey yup, I am sure. I work in the industry and am in this topic since 2008 :) Of course, there's always regional outliers... When calculating uptime on station level (all charging stations of one CPO at one location) we are indeed already at 96% and more. For modern HPC - Alpitronic and the like - we are indeed at 99%.
@jeremyfink7805
@jeremyfink7805 5 місяців тому
You lie. I rented an EV and drove in France last year. It was a horrible experience. What saved my bacon was being able to destination charge.
@MrJoostHoorn
@MrJoostHoorn 5 місяців тому
@@jeremyfink7805actually the situation in france greatly improved this year
@synth.s
@synth.s 5 місяців тому
You are living in a small country, which is probably not even half the size of orange County, and since it's Europe then I can assume only a few thousand people can afford to purchase an electric car(socialist economy) so you can't compare your country small scale in every aspects to the massive and enormous infrastructure size of USA and huge.number of EVs just in California which need to get charged on daily basis due to longer commuting!!!
@donaldavis
@donaldavis 5 місяців тому
As a Tesla owner for years, I decided to rent an EV (a VW ID4) thinking it would be no problem. Boy was I mistaken. The most frustrating auto experience I've had in years was trying to get the car charged at multiple charging stations. I'm not driving an EV besides Tesla until this problem is fixed (when? how long??)
@pantherfinn
@pantherfinn 5 місяців тому
The parallels to iPhones vs Android is striking
@Azrael8
@Azrael8 5 місяців тому
Thanks for making the case for the NACS/ Tesla charging standard.
@crftr-com
@crftr-com 5 місяців тому
Did you watch the video? NACS is still untested for non-vertically-integrated scenarios.
@danielzhang1916
@danielzhang1916 5 місяців тому
all the automakers are switching to Tesla standard, it's about time everyone gets on the same page
@petehelme7714
@petehelme7714 5 місяців тому
@@crftr-com yep and it's very controlled currently for CCS-1 vehicles with Tesla's own Magic Dock. The payment and authentication methods for how it'll work with adapters is still unclear.
@djp1234
@djp1234 5 місяців тому
I want to buy an EV, but first we have to fix the problem of para sites buying up multiple houses, so that people can afford houses and have a place to charge EVs.
@AdamBechtol
@AdamBechtol 5 місяців тому
MMmmmm
@PassportBrosBusinessClass
@PassportBrosBusinessClass 3 місяці тому
I bought a new Cadillac Lyriq AWD. I opted for 2 years of free charging with EVgo. There are only 3 EVgo stations within 20 miles and 2 of them are unreliable. Fortunately, I had a Lectron Vbox charger installed in my house. I can charge overnight to 100% within 8 hours. No need wasting time or money on public charging.
@michaelobrien4723
@michaelobrien4723 4 місяці тому
You did a very good job doing the animation, the layout and explaining. I am impressed.
@omartin30
@omartin30 5 місяців тому
Nice job presenting this story, thanks. We purchased our Tesla Model 3 in Apr. 2019 for the supercharger network access. It has never disappointed when doing frequent multi thousand mile road trips. We travel 3 to 3 1/2 hours between stops and charging. With 250KW charging speeds duration of charge time around 15 mins. We have another Tesla on order so on the way to becoming a two Tesla family. Oh yea, never have needed to wait in line for a charging cabinet.
@VoltLover00
@VoltLover00 5 місяців тому
Who? Who asked? Not what this story is about
@josephpiskac2781
@josephpiskac2781 5 місяців тому
Excellent investigation. From the little I have viewed on UKposts it appears the cost of EV charging is similar or exactly like expensive gasoline.
@DaGodfaddah
@DaGodfaddah 5 місяців тому
This is why I replaced my EV w/ a plug-in hybrid. The way these other chargers are maintained are ridiculous. Not to mention that sometimes you end up paying more per mile to charge and that doesn’t take into account the amount of time you’re wasting. If you’re lucky you’re not being blocked by an ICE car. If I had to have an EV I’d have a Tesla...but for the range that I need it’s at least another decade before I consider another EV.
@mcswagsurfin
@mcswagsurfin 4 місяці тому
This sounds like a local CA problem, and service providers not properly setting up infrastructure, leading to wasted money/efforts. I just completed a 2500 mile road trip in China with Tesla Model 3. All Tesla supercharging stations worked seamlessly.
@vipahman
@vipahman 5 місяців тому
I bought a Model 3 and mostly charged at home. With a longer trip in the works, I went to check out the local Supercharger and talked to some other drivers. I was pleasantly surprised to learn that the Tesla system was just plug and play. The credit card is attached to one's profile and the car and charger 'communicate' with each other. It's the most seamless experience and since then I've never had a bad experience or a wait longer than 2 minutes. Tesla really knows how to woo you! Next stop Cybertruck.
@markrix
@markrix 5 місяців тому
Cyber block? Ah you can be the envy of the lamest
@gus473
@gus473 5 місяців тому
You know, I think they just know how to do software in the House of Elon! The app is a big part of my Starlink system and it is awesome, trouble-free, and has gotten better over time! 😎✌️
@user70331
@user70331 5 місяців тому
Same with evgo have autocharge, just plug in and it use account info with Vin to charge
@petehelme7714
@petehelme7714 5 місяців тому
there is a standard for plug & charge payments, as part of ISO 15118. Cars like the Ford Mach-E, Porsche Taycan and Lucid Air etc. support this and have this similar experience at EVGo and EA. Tesla and Rivian currently don't support this standard (their plug & charge protocols are proprietary), but they may be compelled to in the future by way of federal regulation.
@WallyHays
@WallyHays 5 місяців тому
@@gus473Software? Maybe. Talk to me when the car doors can open in cold weather.
@davidgeller6109
@davidgeller6109 5 місяців тому
Awesome video Joanna, as always! I've had the chance to charge my Rivian at a Tesla station twice (Moses Lake, WA), and both times, the experience was perfect. Electrify America, in the Seattle area, has been spotty. EVGo appears to be, at least here, more reliable. They also have plug-and-go support for Rivian, so the process is more straightforward. When they work, the nice thing about taking a leisurely 20-30 min. to charge is I get to watch videos, like yours.
@PoeticJusticeSC
@PoeticJusticeSC Місяць тому
Wow, crazy. We've had our Tesla for 5 years now and honestly have seen zero superchargers that we could charge at. Literally zero issues. Tesla's charging network is better than the cars themselves.
@mpodolsky11
@mpodolsky11 5 місяців тому
I may be stating the obvious, but from what I saw on the video the magnetic stripe on her card always faced the machine. It is counter intuitive but sometimes the reader requires the mag stripe to face away from the machine.
@totallypluggedin
@totallypluggedin 5 місяців тому
Based on my experience what you show in LA seems to actually be better than here in Florida! The Tesla network is absolutely the way to go… very high 98% reliability and even if there’s an odd charger out of order, the software will let you know before you get there. Even in that instance, you’ll be dealing with let’s say one stall out of order out of maybe a dozen at one location. Thank you for bringing this issue to light, this is by far away the big bad news in EV life and it seems it’s wide spread. On a recent trip to the UK I ran into similar problems. I think investors in the non-tesla networks should pay close attention to this problem. If they don’t fix these problems before Tesla’s super chargers are scaled they will be out of business. This is not a new problem either, I’ve been using charging networks since 2014 and this has perpetually been a problem. The only network in the USA which has solved the problem is Tesla . The recent decisions by most vehicle manufacturers to adopt the Tesla standard is the writing on the wall. I’ve driven my tesla over 216,000 miles through 40+ states almost exclusively using Tesla super chargers and almost never have a problem. If buying an EV, go for it, make sure to ask the dealer if the car will accept NACS in the near future and be aware than in the interim you’ll have to deal with the issues in this video until then (mostly this will not effect you if doing home charging, but definitely something to be aware of if you take road trips!)
@sebastianorye2702
@sebastianorye2702 5 місяців тому
99.97% actually ;)
@totallypluggedin
@totallypluggedin 5 місяців тому
@@sebastianorye2702 lol thank you for the correction!
@TJPavey
@TJPavey 5 місяців тому
Americas unwillingness to step in and regulate standard like ports and communication is crazy. Look how nice things are in Europe by comparison. They set a standard and it largely just works the vast majority of the time.
@TrendyStone
@TrendyStone 5 місяців тому
It's happening organically. Everyone is adopting Tesla's NACS standard in 2025. CCS and CCS2 will die in the US. Not a moment too soon!
@ericcarabetta1161
@ericcarabetta1161 5 місяців тому
Because America is more concerned with who gets to have the monopoly and profiteer off of the entire system, rather than ensuring the system is standardized and reliable.
@brent4073
@brent4073 5 місяців тому
Go live in Europe then. See how much more you pay in taxes and see how heavily regulated your life is and how you wont be able to build and do whatever you want over there. Sure, you can drink in the parks and walk everywhere which is nice but do it.
@TrendyStone
@TrendyStone 5 місяців тому
There is a reason the EU can't compete on tech and doesn't have a strong venture capital culture. Ireland does pretty well but generally the EU is an over-regulated mess that stifles innovation. Thus...you buy iPhones and use Google, Instagram, etc. sending your money to US companies.
@ericcarabetta1161
@ericcarabetta1161 5 місяців тому
@@TrendyStone, capitalism stifles innovation, not regulation. You’re thinking of exploitation. Regulation does limit that.
@MrWeebable
@MrWeebable 3 місяці тому
Charging stations not being fixed means these stations are not profitable when they work. If your profit-making machine was out of order for a day, you would immediately start fixing it because you're missing out on money to recoup the investment on that machine. The reason the stations exists at all is probably some type of subsidy for the construction of the station.
@davepetro5676
@davepetro5676 4 місяці тому
As electrician I fix EV charging station. Commercials and residential. And as electrician I don’t fix them anymore because they take along time to pay. For repair. Now I just fix residential now. I may just stop fixing them. Both the credit card and the electrical I fix. I just keep busy wiring up houses. Residential, commercial. Some power down power up. And most charging station will last to 3 years commercial I was in a friend EV going on a trip. We hit broken charging station I call to get credit to charge the car in fix the station 4 or 5 people car waiting and I was not waiting so I fix station while my friend EV was charging and charging my friend car right away. So we could move on.while I was there I fix other stations I did tell my friend in bring extra tool boards and hand in trunk because I’m not waiting for 5 cars in line. I charge part and no labor just electricity to charge the car. 6 different station we stop at to charge at I fix 9 EV chargers. They were happy because they save money on the repair and I got parts paid and free electricity. On that road trip. $210 parts And 98.00 free electricity Fixing 9 EV charging station Cost them $308.0 That could been $1000 to $1200
@Bobrogers99
@Bobrogers99 5 місяців тому
Standardization will help. Each station should have a self-check routine that can automatically report being out of order. Security cameras may reduce the vandalism factor. On the horizon are better batteries that charge faster and hold more, but we'll still have all the legacy cars to service.
@johnsmith-cw3wo
@johnsmith-cw3wo 5 місяців тому
they just show how bad alternatives in US are... Tesla charging network in China just one of the many and mediocre at best... Also, Tesla uses a different connector type (compatible with the Chinese GB/T standards for AC and DC charging)
@hbaldinr
@hbaldinr 5 місяців тому
I went to the US a couple of months ago and rented an electric car and it was insanely frustrating this issue. Almost every charger was broken, the ones that were working had people that let the car almost 24/7 or I had to download an app that was only available on the US App Store , which makes absolutely no sense. It was a experience to never get another electric again
@Elcomendante64
@Elcomendante64 5 місяців тому
I live with in the USA but drive to Canada and i had the issue of network apps being available only in Canadian app store and not available in the USA app store which my phone is set to. Presumably Canadian ev drivers in the USA will have this issue in reverse too. Fortunately there is a way to change the country app store on the iphone or so I hear, haven’t done that yet. Maybe on the next trip.
@PiergiorgioPirro
@PiergiorgioPirro Місяць тому
Misleading title: there are definitely bigger problems with EV Adoption, like battery production and disposal, the capacity of our actual power grid, vehicle weight, and so on... (If you are wondering, I am not a fan of the combustion engines either... both technologies have huge problems, and I think that the only viable solution is that we move beyond the era of personal transportation by car.)
@MrProy33
@MrProy33 18 днів тому
Without watching, I'd guess the price tag. Any money saved on gas is lost on sticker price, charging costs, wasted time, higher insurance, foam filled tires, apps/monthly fees, the total lack of resale value, and the eventual cost of battery replacement. Or it could be the poor quality, lazy construction, delayed servicing, and lack of parts problems. Could also be a conversation about the lack of infrastructure to support the folly problem. Or it could be the necessity for hazardous rare earth materials that require horribly un-ecological mining and deforesting operations. Or the battery fires. Or the problems with adding an influx of 6000 lb passenger cars to our aging road and bridge system. Gosh. There are so many problems. I'm curious what you think the "big one" is.
@COSMACELF1802
@COSMACELF1802 13 днів тому
You missed the big one... government is making a lot of money from Gas Tax. They will soon lose that money and come after the EV owners for it (plus some more for their trouble).
@zukacs
@zukacs 5 місяців тому
I guess that LA is full of legacy systems because they were the first adopters of the tech. New stations across the country I imagine will use up to date plug-n-play systems.
@CHunter415
@CHunter415 5 місяців тому
It’s interesting that you faced “legacy” hardware issues when EV chargers haven’t been around even a decade! This will probably always be an issue and while I agree EVs will grow in percentage of automobiles on the road, I believe these issues coupled with EV costs will force ICE and other power forms to also continue to be around creating a multitude of types of automobiles for the future.
@andrewdiamond2697
@andrewdiamond2697 5 місяців тому
A decade ago I was using Windows 7 and Windows XP...so...
@engineeringVirtue
@engineeringVirtue 5 місяців тому
Plugin hybrids are roughly ten years old. Fords C-Max was released roughly in 2012 with 600mile gas plus 30mile electric range to cover short daily commutes and long roadtrips. These vehicles were for overnight charging at home or at a hotel, but charging networks like ChargePoint came into existence at roughly the same time as Tesla's network. That said, they were originally mostly free with almost zero demand and mostly for employee, govt building, or mall use. And, the charging standards have slowly evolved and new tech like DC charging implemented. Now, many will need to switch again to the Tesla cable connector format.
@danielzhang1916
@danielzhang1916 5 місяців тому
yeah EVs are only at 8% market share, it could take years to reach at least 15-20%, we are way behind on building charging infrastructure, it's ridiculous that 30% of chargers are out of order, cost and other problems need to be resolved before the market will take off, I don't know if demand for EVs will ever reach 50%
@segalliongaming8925
@segalliongaming8925 5 місяців тому
@@andrewdiamond2697Really? Comparing car operating systems to Windows is like asking for the Blue Screen of Death while you’re on the highway …
@rkevic
@rkevic 5 місяців тому
When she said legacy I was like this is brand new tech.
@kensai7
@kensai7 4 місяці тому
Same issues in Europe, but it's getting better with "roaming" services; i.e. download the app from one EV charging provider and it always can be used in roaming for other providers.
@Mladjasmilic
@Mladjasmilic 5 місяців тому
I am working with EVSE only (AC chargers). The job of the charger is to check first is it safe to charge. Some chargers do a current leakage test and if your car has internal fault, it would not be allowed the charge. But not all chargers have the same strict threshold, so they might charge one car, but not the other, and your car might work on one charger, but not the other. Another thing might be bad ground, if soil is too dry, grounding resistance might be too high and it might not pass the grounding test. Simplest solution would be just to tell the user what the fault was. Some people do not like everything dumbed down, and having live display of voltage, current, power drawn, max power charger can deliver
@newscoulomb3705
@newscoulomb3705 5 місяців тому
6:10 Based on a still small sample of data, the PlugShare ratings for non-Tesla EVs using Tesla's "Magic Dock" Superchargers are about 20% worse than the ratings provided by Tesla owners, so the Superchargers also are clearly not a panacea.
@jerryinmon2731
@jerryinmon2731 5 місяців тому
Why would you think it would instantly work as good as Tesla cars with vehicles from other manufacturers. It's going to take a little time to figure out the best way to make this happen.
@newscoulomb3705
@newscoulomb3705 5 місяців тому
@@jerryinmon2731 I don't disagree, but not giving networks and automakers that same opportunity/time wouldn't be fair either. Based on what I've seen, of all the failures on the public charging providers, about a third are due to the provider and hardware, a third are due to the user, and the rest are due to the automaker/EV itself. Tesla currently doesn't have to deal with two of those issues at all, but when they finally do open to non-Tesla EVs, they will be dealing with all three. My main point here is that Tesla has a lot of work to do if they hope to even come close to providing the same level of service to everyone on their Superchargers as they currently provide to Tesla EV drivers. By the time they get around to that (as they no doubt will), the other charging providers will have also caught up or surpassed them.
@brushlessmotoring
@brushlessmotoring 5 місяців тому
But the difference is, Tesla will figure it out and software update all the superchargers to fix it at once, whereas Shell Recharge for instance doesn't even know they don't work, and doesn't care anyway.
@newscoulomb3705
@newscoulomb3705 5 місяців тому
@@brushlessmotoring Maybe, but we'll have to wait and see. Tesla's incentive for providing exemplary service really stops at their own customers. We've already seen this with "Magic Dock," where it is essentially just an attempt to tick a box so they can access public funds. Slower charging speeds, higher prices, etc. There's no reason to expect Tesla to treat their non-Tesla EV customers as well as they treat their Tesla EV customers.
@brushlessmotoring
@brushlessmotoring 5 місяців тому
@@newscoulomb3705 I just put up a quick video of non teslas at a super charger in Deep River Ontario - the Bolt user got his expected maximum charge speed of 75kWh and the F150 seemed to be working too. I know there were some issues with Ioniq 5 and EV6’s 800V system, but that may be common to other 800V systems on a 400V charger - I don’t disagree it’s going to be harder for Tesla, as they don’t control 3rd party car’s software, but hopefully NACS solves that in time too.
@rayoflight62
@rayoflight62 5 місяців тому
Here in Europe, most EV owners use the vehicle to run errands downtown, not to travel on the motorway. They mostly charge the vehicle at home. Because of grid limitations, service stations on the motorways (highways) can't increase the number of chargers, so there are long queues - when the chargers work. After a number of high profile EV fires and accidents, insurance companies have increased the premiums behind what is considered acceptable. Also, repair bills for EV are very high, and minor car collisions often result in a write-off. Because of a number of different problems, the uptake of EVs has decreased a lot...
@Ale-bj7nd
@Ale-bj7nd 5 місяців тому
Also because the plateau of people that can charge at home is small and a lot of them already bought an EV. You simply can't get an EV without the ability to charge at home.
@wouldntyouliketoknow9891
@wouldntyouliketoknow9891 5 місяців тому
The stupid part is that EV chargers should be super reliable. Gas pumps are pretty reliable - every once in a while you see one out of service, but they have very high reliability. And they have moving parts, an actual motor and belt and pump head and plumbing, along with a number of safety valves and product switching valves and sensors and stuff. An EV charger needs NONE of that stuff. No moving parts. Just a step down transformer, a high efficiency solid state rectifier with voltage regulation, payment processing equipment and a small control board to run everything. The payment processing equipment and the control board are solved problems, because the gas pumps use the same payment processing and ruggedized single board controller. And the transformer and rectifier being solid state with no moving parts, and for the transformer completely passive, they should almost never break. Its crazy that they are broken all the time. Its just bad design plain and simple.
@drbobinski1
@drbobinski1 5 місяців тому
I posted this story on another video about electric vehicles. A month ago we took a trip in our Model X to Chaco Canyon in New Mexico from Newport Beach CA (1600 miles total). The trip had us in very remote regions and back towards Page Arizona, through Zion UT and back to Las Vegas. And while this trip did require additional time and planning for charging, all the Tesla superchargers worked perfectly and were available when we arrived. The network is growing and I was pleasantly surprised how smooth the trip went. We have free supercharging for life so this does factor into our decision making-full disclosure.
@jaredspencer3304
@jaredspencer3304 5 місяців тому
This is tremendous reporting. A serious issue that I had no idea existed.
@That-Guy_
@That-Guy_ 5 місяців тому
The issues only apply to non-Tesla charges.
@jaredspencer3304
@jaredspencer3304 5 місяців тому
@@That-Guy_ Yeah, but that's half the market. If there's a problem with half of an entire industry, that's significant.
@WallyHays
@WallyHays 5 місяців тому
@@That-Guy_Jeez, you can’t say anything about EVs without some Tesla/Elon fan boy barging in and saying something condescending and off topic.
@That-Guy_
@That-Guy_ 5 місяців тому
@@WallyHays Just pointing out a fact. In the US there are 2 kinds of EVs, Tesla and everyone else. If only the other automakers had copied Tesla instead of looking down at them for so long.
@WallyHays
@WallyHays 5 місяців тому
@@That-Guy_ facts entirely unrelated to the comment you were replying to.
@dancox3251
@dancox3251 5 місяців тому
Had the same problem last time I was in LA, except it was finding a working _gasoline_ pump. Went to 4 different stations, broken pumps everywhere. Eventually waiting in a long line like everyone else for the only working pumps in the area. I think it's just a function of how poorly run the whole place is.
@AdamBechtol
@AdamBechtol 5 місяців тому
Mmmm
@jerrymiller9039
@jerrymiller9039 5 місяців тому
All of the stations you went to had working pumps. You just didn't want to wait in line
@TrendyStone
@TrendyStone 5 місяців тому
California is the state that lectures the other 49 but can't run itself. It has turned into a dumpster fire of a state. Great weather though! Just watch for the human feces on the street.
@adityagupta7525
@adityagupta7525 3 місяці тому
As an electrical engineer I already saw this coming. But nobody wanted to believe me when the hype train was on full speed.
@COSMACELF1802
@COSMACELF1802 13 днів тому
Yeah... but hopefully it will get better as companies are forced to standardize. EV plugs should all be the same. Imagine AC outlets were different in different states? LoL that's the EV market right now! what a joke. But I believe it will get better in 20 years. For now, I'm sticking to ICE... I don't want the problems of EV's.
@17R3W
@17R3W 5 місяців тому
Something that needs to be discussed more is level 1 charging. If you have a normal house hold outlet, you can simply plug your car into that, and recover more than the anount of electricity that you use in an average day.
@user-jf6pz5jx8g
@user-jf6pz5jx8g 5 місяців тому
This will continue to be a problem as more and more EV chargers come online to be used, And wait until thieves realize the value of the charging cables and start stealing them.
@SF1886
@SF1886 5 місяців тому
Almost all EV manufacturers are going to Tesla’s NACS and will be able to use the Supercharger Network beginning in 2025. Soon after all the companies that have broken chargers will be bankrupt
@user-jf6pz5jx8g
@user-jf6pz5jx8g 5 місяців тому
@@SF1886 I truly hope you are right
@brandoni.stanford6277
@brandoni.stanford6277 5 місяців тому
Telsa currently has a pilot with their magic doc system at certain superchargers. This means there is a doc that can charge non teslas and it works fine.
@AndrewMackoul
@AndrewMackoul 5 місяців тому
There have been reported issues with a few automakers at those superchargers. I wouldn't say it works fine 100%.
@COSolar6419
@COSolar6419 5 місяців тому
Unfortunately the percentage of SuperChargers currently equipped with the Magic Dock CCS adapter is very small. Tesla’s plans for Magic Dock expansion are known only to them. There are other issues with nonTelsa EVs using the Magic Dock sites but that isn’t too surprising given that the Tesla network was designed exclusively for Teslas. They were not considering the needs of EVs at the time. If they intend to be an open public network they will need to.
@VoltLover00
@VoltLover00 5 місяців тому
Except Tesla's chargers can't charge non-Tesla's at full speed
@brandoni.stanford6277
@brandoni.stanford6277 5 місяців тому
Appreciate the feedback here.
@Elcomendante64
@Elcomendante64 5 місяців тому
@@VoltLover00never knew that. What speed do they charge non teslas at?
@swtexan6502
@swtexan6502 2 місяці тому
"Things are a mess in LA." That's a bit of an understatement.
@jojopuppyfish
@jojopuppyfish 5 місяців тому
Joanna Stern is awesome. Really a great reporter/journalist.
@darealphantom
@darealphantom 5 місяців тому
This video is inadvertently a commercial to purchase a Tesla good job guys 🤣
@Brianuwu622
@Brianuwu622 4 місяці тому
with tesla u wait in a 2 hour line instead 😂
@Smaggle84
@Smaggle84 5 місяців тому
We had this problem before the EV-trend started, once every 3 months or so you enter a gas station and one of the pumps are out of order, it's super annoying when all the pumps are occupied and the 2 minute fill up from empty to full could easily become 3 or even 4 minutes if you have to queue.
@hackman88
@hackman88 5 місяців тому
it's a bigger problem for EVs because there are fewer chargers than gas pumps and it takes longer to charge than to fill up with gas.
@Smaggle84
@Smaggle84 5 місяців тому
@@hackman88 Yeah, I was being a bit sarcastic.
@drew6116
@drew6116 4 місяці тому
GMAFB!! Charger port problem was so easy to foresee. It should be the same one size fits all rule as our 110v outlets at home and work.
@balkanleopard9728
@balkanleopard9728 3 місяці тому
You should try the disjointed charging mess in Europe (Yes! there are places outside the US of A). Every country is totally different, charging systems vary all over the place. Chargers are mostly located (scattered around like confetti) out in the weather in poorly lit, inconvenient, locations - and it's app after app, after app. The cars are generally fine, the public charging networks are rubbish.
@samuxan
@samuxan 5 місяців тому
I've never encounter those kind of problems in my country with CSS. The usual problem is that the chargers are disconnected, most companies just turn them off at the hours of the day when electricity is more expensive
@ThomasGlynnJr
@ThomasGlynnJr 5 місяців тому
Oh yeah, that's a great idea - just when the population needs it. Like for an emergency or evacuation... 🙄
@av1330
@av1330 5 місяців тому
or you know just charge more during peak times?
@jamesbell739
@jamesbell739 5 місяців тому
This is what happens when you have a bunch of companies all making propietary tech, not even thinking of the connection between it and other software. It's been a long standing issue. I hope it gets fixed now that the Tesla charger is going to be the industry standard.
@xxwookey
@xxwookey 5 місяців тому
The charging standard is at least a standard, albeit not an open one. Fuel pumps and card readers are nearly all proprietary too but they still manage to make them work reliably. Tesla's stuff is all just as proprietary as the rest of them. Their advantage is that they only have to deal with one sort of car and one payment provider. Not sure they will work that much better with all cars.
@jamesbell739
@jamesbell739 5 місяців тому
@@xxwookey The tesla style plug becoming the industry standard is the 1st domino to drop. This is basically what happened with the USB-C plug and Apple. But to your point, there shouldn't be issues with payment systems that have been around and functional for decades. They should also build in the capability of working with other companies because that will bring in more revenue when it comes to who can use what chargers... These are decisions based in capitalism not common sense. They should never be a problem.
@oculosprudentium8486
@oculosprudentium8486 5 місяців тому
I'm laughing at the whole stupidity and craziness of these EV conundrum. No one with gasoline fueled engines has these connections problems!!
@xxwookey
@xxwookey 5 місяців тому
@@oculosprudentium8486 To be fair that is a rather simpler interface: the nozzle has to fit in the hole (and the nozzle has a back-pressure autostop built in which is quite clever). Electricity needs a handshake between the charger and the car and an interlock on the connector. Which isn't that hard either, and both the Chademo spec and Tesla's all in-house implementation of CCS work fine, but 20 car companies and 30 charger companies seems to have managed to write subtly incompatible implementations of the protocol. Then there is a whole extra layer of payment systems. Not that many petrol/gas pumps have built-in payment devices, although again, when they do it's a solved problem. And none of them have apps you have to download to use them, which is just a terrible 'solution'.
@jamesbell739
@jamesbell739 5 місяців тому
@@oculosprudentium8486 It's not uncommon with tech. NO different that Apple finally giving in to the USB-C charger. Just has never affected cars like this. It will work itself out as the industry starts adopting standards. I just sucks that the consumers are the ones stuck.
@zerokool-2058
@zerokool-2058 5 місяців тому
All EV’s should have the same charging port. This should be a standard! Also we need charging lounges, so you can quick charge and go in and use the rest room if need be. They can be small lounges. Just bathroom, some snacks or so.
@joannyesia7460
@joannyesia7460 3 місяці тому
This is already happening in 2025. All evs are going to teslas nacs charger
@kenpumford754
@kenpumford754 3 місяці тому
I leased a Mustang Mach E and installed a home charger so as to not have to deal with the headaches shown in this video. The few times I did go long distance, I was lucky there weren't more than one or two other cars charging when I was at Electrify America stations, because at most 50% of the stalls were working.
Tesla vs. Ford vs. Hyundai: Which EV Has the Best Tech? | WSJ
10:41
The Wall Street Journal
Переглядів 207 тис.
Electric Vehicles' Battery Problem
17:30
Wendover Productions
Переглядів 3,1 млн
Why Egypt Can’t Afford Its $58B New Capital City | WSJ Breaking Ground
8:12
The Wall Street Journal
Переглядів 1,4 млн
This Is How Easy It Is to Hack EV Chargers | WSJ
7:55
The Wall Street Journal
Переглядів 370 тис.
Why Hybrids Are Beating EVs In The U.S.
14:48
CNBC
Переглядів 851 тис.
Why Major Meal Kit Companies Lose 90% of Customers in a Year | WSJ The Economics Of
8:35
Inside Amazon’s Meticulous Same-Day Delivery Strategy | WSJ Shipping Wars
8:18
The Wall Street Journal
Переглядів 841 тис.
Why Mexico’s $29B Train Megaproject Is So Controversial | WSJ Breaking Ground
6:33
The Wall Street Journal
Переглядів 393 тис.
Are used EVs a rip-off?!
23:32
carwow
Переглядів 1,2 млн
EV Road Trips Suck Now (Except in a Tesla)
35:40
Aging Wheels
Переглядів 1,1 млн
Why Tokyo's Metro Is Profitable and New York City’s Isn’t | WSJ U.S. vs. Japan
6:17
Can The U.S. Power Grid Handle The EV Boom?
15:26
CNBC
Переглядів 452 тис.