Exactly. It would be the perfect anime adaptation.

the music in Tokyo Ghoul is amazing, can’t deny that

@@cherobu2288 still mediocre compared to Bleach OST

@@Stagfire222 Yo, when I listened to "Here to Stay" after many years, I almost teared up

Funnily when i was reading re as it was coming out each week, i remembered reading an interview ishida did when the anime came out and he actually choose the artist who made unravel so once more ishida picked one of the best parts of the anime

Bro I literally have a tg manga pfp that's how much I have been waiting for recognition

Only waited 9 years for this shit

They changed so much from the manga and no one believed me when i said the manga was better

@@katharsis101- same here

Finally

The anime was bad because the manga was bad... Re never should have happened and the season 2 deviation didn't matter because the content the manga covered for that part was only Kaneki and Banjou's relationship... The entire manga fell apart after Yamori died

@@Digger-Nick wdym re was way better cuz it had more plot and complex characters

@Mugen No Juunin really? I kinda liked it back when they just left us on a cliffhanger for like 3 years

​@@Digger-Nick 🤡

The worst part of Tokio Ghoul was Season 3+ where it did in a extreme speed up and follow the Manga. But even if they made it properly the Story itself (that came from the Manga) was trash. 90% of ppl dying coming back as Ghouls is so beyond bad :,D Not following the Manga was the right way, and deciding to go back to Manga at Season 3 was the beginning of the end. Season 1 and 2 were beautiful and close to art, everything after that belonged in the trash.

Did you read it on a website? If so can I ask for the name, I wanna read it too with the best translation possible!!

@@kirabean5441 I ended up reading it on 2 different sites that being Manganato or something like that and Comick. Both TG and TG:re are on both so it’s up to you

@@uwuwithcthulhu2300 Thanks! It's difficult finding a good translation, I wanna read the whole story without anything being lost.

It was hard to follow tbh the fight scenes layout and fluidity were pretty bad

@@uwuwithcthulhu2300 Comick is great! I usually read on mangareader or mangadex, but Comick's quality for TG was incomparably better for some reason.

I am Tokyo ghoul

The "I don't want to die" hits even more once you know what that character turns into and what his entire arc develops

"it's ghouling time" was better

@@diamondspeek what happens to that guy and who is he?

@@dubbyplays My guy, that's the main character...

Me neither

@just i c e why the hell u bots doing this shit

on god i couldn't believe my eyes when i saw gigguk uploaded a video about tokyo ghoul of all things

Indeed I'm impressed

@@huckpo283 right, it's just so odd

I even had the misfortune of seeing it censored, which makes it unbearable to watch

@@malade3000 Do yourself a favor and read the manga or watch a vidoe essay if you don't have time for all that

I mean lots of tvs and movies shorten a lot of their source material to make it fit, that's just how to works. Now I'm not saying that's a good thing, I'm just saying how it is. Although makes you wonder what would've happened if they had managed to get all of the story in properly.

@@tvheadcontent Um you realize HALF of the manga is a massive time skip and spirals into a complete trainwreck because the writer completely gave up...

@@Digger-Nick Valid points? NOT ON MY WATCH! I am a anime elitist and I can never be wrong! You are just a bigot and using hate speech at me. :( Anyway, Kirito from SAO is a well rounded character with a great personality. (for real though your name made me snort loud af lol, this is a joke reply. Good point on your part )

Tokyo Ghoul Re:Birth❤️📌

@@astraeus5 yess

Yeah man I watched the anime about a year ago and I'm reading the manga right now and I must say that the manga is a masterpiece and the anime is just as bad #TokyoGhoulBrotherhood

This and Akame ga Kill need the Brotherhood treatment.

@@warcodertrue man

are there any recommendations for this guy's work other than Tokyo ghoul?

I gave season 1 a rewatch and wanted to read the manga for obvious reasons. But the art seems kinda messy and plainly bad at that point😕😕

@@ikmaen he "recently" began a new manga called Choujin X. ~30 ish chapters out at the moment of writing this and while it's a tone quite different from TG, its still great and features his amazing art.

Ishida's art style is so great. I recognize the drawings in a single glance.

The cover art was one of the reasons I started reading it haha

The Manga is amazing. TG needs a proper faithful anime remake.

Aight I wanna give the manga a shot Ive watched s1 from where should I start the manga?

@@Arun-gl6wz The beginning. The anime and manga are completely different, 100%.

@@Arun-gl6wz If the anime is like C tier the manga is S+ top tier, that's how good the manga is compared to the anime

simp men up

Oh my gosh, it's almost ten years later? Wow.

Not suprising it's like Death Note

Meh, it's decent. People still talk about mediocre or bad shows after a few years

@@balabanasireti nobody but u manga crybabies are calling it a bad show

or it's still being talked about cause it's terrible

I mean, it is. It all started with dumbass human cannibals.

Elfen Lied...

Keep going, the ending of “Tokyo Ghoul re:” is well worth it!

I think it’s a bold thing to think “these two species can’t coexist” when lions coexist with zebra’s and have for thousands of years.

@@orppranator5230lions and zebras my favorite anime characters

OMG YES

At least with Full metal the first series was essentially to diverged into an anime only later on in the series because the anime caught up with the manga. At least with brotherhood it followed the entire manga. That's why we got the satisfying ending because it again followed the manga.

i got a lot of time left. i will try to get the reboot even if its after my death.

@@oOZellzimaOo The Promised Neverland part 1 is one of the greatest anime series of all time, there is nothing to improve

Its gnna surpass fmab fs

the ending where ishida started to worn out and rush the ending makes the manga production itself a tragedy just hits for me, it ended just like what kaneki said in first chap

@@hinori106 I like the way it ended. Where kaneki is happy with his family and doesn’t have to suffer anymore

The finals arcs of :RE were rushed and a bit of a let down. That said, if you read Ishida's post about being burnt out and jaded due to his work load (that was released shortly after :RE ended in 2018), the curtain gets pulled back and you start to get why it ended the way it did. At least it wasn't Attack on Titan...

@@jorge15266 I think they still pull of some greatness with the final arcs. It’s not like it’s bullshit

@@ThePlanet3ater just my preferences, theres a dream theory going around when the manga first ended and i prefer that because the happy ending seem a bit too sudden with so many questions left unanswered. I was very dissapointed when the manga ended but this theory came out it gave me sense of relief. Kinda neat the ending can be interpreted as both happy and tragedy depends on reader's view and preferences

There's hope reboots for animes usually take about 10 years before they're even thought of

@@rishisaaptachaAoT ending got adapted and that was a dumpster fire

@@revolioclockbergjr.6780 no it wasnt lol

Hard agree! One of the better manga I've read over all so far. I've read a few, too. I'm currently reading TG, and I'm almost done, sadly. I'm gonna be sad when I'm done tbh.

@@CrowCoded did you like the ending?

I finished it today and my god, I don’t think I’ve felt sadder about finishing a piece of media. I think it’s my favorite manga ever

I’m not mad at the rushed ending, mostly because he acknowledged it and told us why, he was burnt out on Tokyo Ghoul.

@@KiddBuu_ yea and I’m glad that after years of recuperating he’s back but this time doing things his own pace instead of a weekly schedule

@@KiddBuu_ Just wish Ishida went on hiatus and vacation instead of rushing :re ending to get his mind refreshed and find inspiration again. His Tokyo Ghoul series is one of the best mangas, the best stories out there, and to have it get a rushed ending feels like a waste like a giant house of cards tumbling.

Sui Ishida's art throughout Tokyo Ghoul was my biggest complaint of the manga. It makes amazing panels most of the time but when there is a slugfest or some fast paced action the art becomes incomprehensible, there are no sharp outlines and it becomes hard to tell what the fuck is going on.

@@jaceharrison7936 i think he addressed that in his afterword. that if he took a break he felt he would probably just never go back to it. so he pushed through and just. gave it an ending, and closed the book on the series.

They gave more shits about Boruto than Kaneki. But at least, they can do edgy stuff like Akudama Drive.

He said "i am the Tokyo Ghoul"

@@jakey14344 and boruto still became a shit show. sadge

Yeah they really, REALLY shafted TG with that. Not only did the anime turn a beautiful and tragic manga into a generic battle Shonen seasoned with edginess, but they rushed the hell out of it too... After I eventually read the manga, it made me genuinely pissed off at how badly it was adapted and how much characterization and depth was so carelessly left out of the anime.

Tokyo ghoul: re ❌ Tokyo ghoul: highly compressed ✔️

Marie-Antuanette Syndrome, yeah, when extreme stress can cause one's hair to lose melanin at very quirk speed, the late queen only needed one night, if I'm not mistaken

@@ninimtvarelashvili3406 i always thought this was just a myth and never really researched/proven

@@Squitox3 It does exist in Medicine, scientists just don't know exactly what is the pathophysiology, but they speculate that it could be either autoimmune disease and could be related to alopecia somehow. It's also called canitis subica or Thomas More Syndrome.

​@@ninimtvarelashvili3406Melanin doesn't spontaneously dissappear from already grown hair, though. Stress and other illnesses can cause you to grey prematurely, but that means that hair starts growing grey at the roots. You can see it in very long dark hair on elderly who haven't dyed their hair: The ends of the hair still have colour, and colour starts lessening in stages. No-One goes grey or white in a day, not even when you are very sick.

its a seinen bro, its either shitty or bad CGI shitty

What was your first and second anime?

@@oenkapoen1396 Magic Knight Rayearth and then Naruto lol

@@lumilenm__m5304 epic, i tried to watch naruto but it was just to long. magic knight rayearth is it good?

@@oenkapoen1396 It's a shojo action anime, if u like retro stuff you might like it but to be fair, I could only sit trough it the second time bcos of nostalgia. the episodes are too... half baked lol I'd say watch something else if you have free time to watch anime

honestly, almost everything in the manga hit hard

True, no need a philosophical reason, just a simple reason like that make us see Kaneki as a real person, not just some made-up manga character to serve the plot

@@butituti9036 i agree. Even the "bad" ghouls have the saddest back stories T^T

true it's such a simple but completely realistic and understandable reason, it makes him infinitely more relatable than if he had some grandiose motivation like defeating some big bad evil or something, nah the guy just wants to live peacefully with his loved ones and the circumstances of the world he lives in make that always a struggle for him and so he must fight

For me it was what Garnt showed in the video, with Takizawa writing his will. Even in the anime it was damn powerful and harsh. At first it's treated as a way to show off the characters' personalities in a silly way, only to be reminded that all of these characters have lives that they're DEATHLY afraid of losing.

Me2

Hopefully enough popularity for a reboot

Bet they didn’t even understand the video and use it to justify their edge.

Fuck yeah, Tokyo Ghoul is magnificent

@@MrSonictheOtter nah, tokyo ghoul time has passed. It wont be able to get more popularity let alone reboot

Agreed I'm on number 4 at the moment it is amazing

Agreed May reread soon

Licht und Schatten, Glassy Sky, Unravel, hell even Asphyxia are some of the best songs I've heard in anime, it's up there with Overlord openings and endings.

When people ask how much the artistic direction is lost, I show the infamous comparison of "I am a Ghoul" moment.

100% Agree, that's the case for a lot of anime when animating moving frames its basically impossible to get anywhere near as detailed as a Manga. only cases where the anime looks equal or better is when the manga has a simple art style that can be easily reproduced.

Ishida's art is mid at best

Beautiful and gruesome too

Ik its what I love about reading the manga over watching the anime

@Bazinga thx

Idk bout pacing, cause I'm pretty sure thats on you, but agree.

Why? Rarely does an anime ever beat the source material when it comes to storytelling and character development.

I love the manga so much

As someone who prefers anime but has read a lot of manga, I really think its true that the manga is better most of the time (with Light Novel adaptations even moreso). I get how this sentiment can be obnoxious and annoying but part of the problem is how its said, coming off as confrontational instead of encouraging. Anyways, I would encourage you that the next time you see someone say "the manga is better" to maybe check it out.

i do recommend you to read it the manga has such a vivid style it will catch all of yours senses ^^

It is certainly one of the elite best in all manga (its a bit basic at first no doubt tho)

Same

Of all the mangas in existence, this one moved you? Ok

@@gunnellagannin terms of shocking panels, I’d say Tokyo Ghoul is up there for sure. Not Vagabond Berserk Jojos level imo, but it’s so different that the specific emotional appeal of one doesn’t apply to another

😂

"Thank but no" lol i remember anime in minutes

i know and i was damn confused on why he join the enemies and left his friends behind to join them

Jokes on you, this is after watching the anime and the parody that i started to read the manga. And i effectively make sense because it does not fucking happen since this is where the story stray away from the manga

@@hestan723 √A = Route Aomori, an alternate storyline where he joins the enemies instead of making a group of his own with his allies like he did in the manga. (Somebody told me this is what happened there, I haven't gotten around to read the manga yet.)

yeah man I watched Angel Beats over the course of 3 nights and turned off the news and internet and pretended I wasn't in the worst timeline. So cozy.

Same man , good times

Feels like yesterday that Tokyo Ghoul was “that new popular show” and now it’s only a few years away from being “an oldie.” If it’s not already considered old.

Man the sub 2010's was when I watched so much anime and I think I can only watch a few anime a year now. Wish I could go back to the times when I didn't have any knowledge on any anime

@@isaachester8475 Old, but not too old I think. The manga ended just less than 5 years ago roughly.

Right there with you

I’m glad you and your fellow Tokyo Ghoul fans got to see this bro! (This is Aidan from twt btw 😅) Getting a anituber goat talking about your peak is a big honor! 🔥

@@TheYoungFan0 Yeah fr

“kaneki it you??? you were the tokyo ghoul all along??” is my favorite line

Nah in the second season when the main villain introduced themself and said "I'm the Tokyo Ghoul Root A" that was peak fiction bruh

did i miss something

In the part where one of the Aogiri members stocked still motionless then utters *"He's beginning to believe"* while Kaneki stops the Kagune using only his emergence...

No no no the best part is when kaniki says I am the Tokyo ghoul and then tells Jason I'm going to unravel your intestines and then unravel plays in the background.

Personally, I think "edgy" is too vague to be criticism. And while some works considered "edgy" lack direction as you say, others don't have that problem and are still considered "edgy" nonetheless. For example, works that are mean-spirited and are made to rip on something else are considered "edgy" as well. Like Gigguk said, it's more of a feeling, not a genuine criticism.

So I have a question for you. What shows do you think are edgy with your definition? I have seen multiple people say shows like: Re-Zero, Devil man Crybaby, Akame ga kill, Tokyo Ghoul, Deadman Wonderland etc... are edgy shows. But in that same thread that was asking for: "What are the edgiest shows you've seen?" No one/or very little ppl ever mentions shows like: Berserk, Attack on Titan, Cyberpunk Edge Runners etc... All have dark tones to them. Just to expound and potentially start a discourse - Ultimately, I think part of the problem here is that people have different definitions of the word "edgy". Some think it's a good thing while others think it's a bad thing. Those who think it is a good/ok thing are quite honestly mistaken. They are defining edgy as: " dark & cool/mysterious" That's not what edgy is. Dark, cool & mysterious is dark cool & mysterious; We have words for those already. Edgy is something or someone, being or trying to be, intense/dark and or errant/deviant, for the sake of being so, cause its cool. 1. Characters can be edgy, but that's not synonymous with bad/edgy writing since that can be WHO the character is - people like that exist. 2. Writing can be edgy. Per the definition of edgy, this is basically when the writing is dark but is just plain and simple, badly written/executed to the point where the meaning, impact and experience are lost/overshadowed by merely the darkness itself. So, for all intents and purposes, it becomes writing/a story that is dark, intense etc... to be just that - cause its cool. Which should not be the case since the dark writing/stuff should be there to SUPPORT and CREATE, meaning impact and experience. [ Also, last side note (For Gigguk & others): Just bc something looks edgy, doesn't mean it is. Looks alone is not what makes edgy. This can be said for multiple other things. Ex.) Just bc it looks bad doesn't mean it is, looks don't determine what is of actual, meaningful quality. ]

I think the Edge line has more to do with emotional investment, which is admittedly tied to direction, but still more subjective. This is why Edge is associated with immaturity; younger audiences get invested more easily, and older audiences are more jaded to stories in general as well as their younger selves.

imo edgy is just another term for "teen angst" used by people being lazy when critiquing a work. I think its more a problem of people failing to critique work for actual failings. Its very similar to political statements meant to dehumanise the opposition so you can just point out failings because they hold the opposite view to you, rather than having meaningful discourse.

@@JLRB00 you need a tl;dr on that essay, but I'll answer the question at the top. I'm honestly not too in the weeds on anime, so I don't have a lot of examples to pull from, but shows like SAO and whatever the one is with the guy who makes a gun and gets way too cozy with a vampire or whatever that looks like a *child*, those shows are almost all edge and no substance. Bad things happen to the main character and a harem happens because the author was horny and the MC is the only character with any fleshing. It's that kind of egotistical worldview of "I'm so tragic and no one understands me" that rejects even the notion of other characters being more than set-dressing. Re: Zero definitely has some edge to it, but there sometimes needs to be leeway in that judgement when looking at the story being told. MC again ends up with a gaggle of gals following after him, but there is depth to other characters that not only disagree with MC but also outright oppose and fight against him. These other characters gain depth from empathizing with seeing a person going through trauma and also having different tolerances for their how far they extend personal sympathies as they interact. This is the substance that's needed behind the edge to really cut deep, because if all you have is edge then you'll only ever be skin-deep. Edit: the "leeway" I'm giving RZ is due to the broad scope of the story. If you were to either add more characters or better flesh out the ones in play, you'd end up with something similar to the run-length of the original Fullmetal Alchemist anime. That's not all bad, Hughes had more of an impact for the exposure we had with him, but it dilutes what should be the core of the story which is of two brothers trying to reconcile their shared grief.

What u mean the anime was amazing they give us both human and ghoul prospective and good plot all it lack is the engaging cinematic scenes like Chainsaw man

@@astraeus5 csm is overhyped and ass stop the brain roadkill

@@astraeus5 the anime cut away 70% of the manga fights fyi 💀

​@astraeus5 bruh it was trash I was confused as hell during season 2

​@@yanakal652seaspn 3

We would have probably gotten the Kaneki v Suzuya fight drawn shame we didn't :/

Dragon arc has the greatest potential so far, I would spare any previous arc to get a better narration of it (except Rushima Island, oh god it went so wrong but still bearable). Just imagine Washuu members or other CCG regions across the world to response to the whole mess. it was too rushed even at the confrontation between Kaneki and Furuta. like how Furuta got kicked the day he was promoted. also Rize was treated so bad, she was disregarded. also the clowns were so wild imo. There's more but that's not the point. Arima's death was a flag and the beginning of an end, not the end itself. There're some cons at the end for the most part howerver, it could be better if ishida stopped for a while and handled it properly. Tokyo Ghoul was one of the gracious things he and we had, as it developed his art and fame, and for us, it was thought-provoking interesting and phenomenal. it is hard to see a mangaka puts his soul in the work like Ishida, the fact Tokyo Ghoul was done in 8 years never fails to amaze me regardless the art and quality. I would never sayisfy my appreciation for the man's work. he's the best.

Meh, sounds like an excuse. If it's true, then his manager or studio probably forced him to keep going

Meh, sounds like an excuse. If it's true, then his manager or studio probably forced him to keep going

Oh it makes sense why choujin X has a flexible release schedule then

Salute in silence (cause we don't exist until the manga we read becomes an anime ☠️)

@@Nottheone777 haven heard a truer line in a long time

@@atmghst7112 🥺

There are two wolv-

at the end of the last manga book the author wrote saying that he was feeling stress and trapped by writing the series (starting around Tokyo Ghoul vol.7, 25 volumes before the series ended) this was probably the main reason for rushing

@@Roi55 I think he was talking about the anime since he didn’t read the manga re

@@Galvatronover but i felt parts of the manga was also rushed, but you are right the anime is rushed even more

@@Galvatronover The anime is bad because the manga was bad... Re was the nail in the coffin

@@Digger-NickI’m late to this and I’m not gonna argue but the fact you are even comparing the anime to it’s manga counterpart is crazy. Anime is such a shit dumpster fire of trash I hate it so much. Manga even if you consider it trash it’s still leagues better. I’d be more entertained staring at my poop in a toilet than the anime, it’s even bad at being a basic recap past season 1, and even if it was decent it would still fail at being a recap. I could almost rather wipe my butt with sandpaper like Kondo in Gintama than watch the re seasons aswell. Also the animation is not that good and I don’t like artstyle for anime. Music is good atleast, but too much would go in or happen while it’s playing to even appreciate it. Pretty much, I sincerely, completely believe the Tokyo Ghoul anime past season 1 should eat shite and die in my honest opinion. I swear in one episode they skipped like 30 chapters and mashed them together. Like what. So stupid I’m eternally going to damn this adaption to hell and wouldn’t even use it to wipe my ass or blow my nose.

Yeah reading that afterword he did was heartbreaking. The toll was too much for him. The man worked on his manga for 7 years straight with no breaks. Not even once if I'm correct. Cant blame him for thinking he would quit. Thank God he is doing ok and still passionate about manga with Choujin X which has been great so far and is taking his time for releasing chapters

Burnout sucks. I hope he is doing better now.

Yup, at that point I'm thinking that it is for the best as he can't just continue TG anymore. At least it wraps up

That sucks hope he’s doing ok but eh it could’ve been worst

@@manuelalbertoromero9528 his new series takes a completely different release schedule, whenever he feels its ready he just drops a chapter. And while its VERY inconsistent I can only assume hes feeling bettet. Highly reccomend it btw, really feels like hes expressing himself in an artstyle he enjoys.

That's not even the worst of it

Man please read the manga, things there have some logic and the events actually connect with each other

Yeah I hated the new seasons after that

it is labeled pshychological horror for a reason, it seems edgy until you read his monologue when a centipede roams inside his eardrums, "and then I heard a distant laugh,.. It was me"

@@silverfang4972 its also a real thing, relatively sudden color change to white by extreme trauma

Same. It may not have been a masterpiece but I loved it with its faults and all

@@efive850 thats the problem, it was a masterpiece, the manga was. but you wouldnt know that if you didnt read it, because the anime was awful.

@@seiaka Yeah I didn't really watch the anime much, only the 2 seasons years ago. I read the manga recently and love it but I can't deny it has it's faults and in my opinion not at masterpiece. Still really love it though.

Tokyo ghoul was the first manga that I read start to finish.

im sure someone can

You can't beat reading the manga while listening to these bangers

*One of the things the anime had going for it was Yutaka Yamada. But seriously, his compositions are the only things that make this show memorable. His work on Vinland Saga completely outclasses TG too.

Licht und Schatten goes hard

@@nightgard Auferstehung is one of my favorites

for realz! I listen to Glassy Sky so often when I'm sad

I think that's the anime curse of trying to fit 300+ chapters of details into 48 episodes. The anime swerved around all the emotion and impact of the story in favor of the fighting (even though tokyo ghoul isn't a battle series). The whole point is the mystery, thriller, character development and emotional impact of the story, which can't be captured well when condensing that content into 48 episodes. Hell season 1 was a good adaptation but that still didn't even touch on what made TG great. Like how Kaneki volunteered to go with Jason to aogiri and enduring torture. Mostly skimmed over to condense the story

"They are two wolves inside of me"

The better version for that average manga it Parasyte

Better read Parasyte instead

@Bully peter scam link fr

facts

If only. We gotta look at it from the studio's point of view. Manga is being produced constantly. Hardly any time to go back and adapt the older stuff.

Soul Eater deserves one too.

It wouldn't really matter all that much as to which studio did it. Best hope it that it had a good team and overall better planning from the production comittee, along with airing at a late timeslot to avoid major censorship.

Bro why are people suddenly acting like A1 is a good studio? What happened? What changed in the last decade for the memes about how mediocre they were to go away?

Pity...

I've heard this forever and always told myself I would read the manga to see if the readers were right. I'm glad gigguk now is modivating me to revisit this series. Now I've heard the same thing about soul eater. I'm hoping the manga also blows my mind away

The anime did give us an amazing soundtrack however. Just wishing they'd redo it this time staying more faithful to the manga but keep the amazing soundtrack.

AoT animation and story telling isn't that great, lol. I'd say TG deserves the Madhouse treatment, but Madhouse only cares about HunterxHunter so they'd prob drop it after 1 season...

Bro when he said he loved his mom and touched his chin 😭

@@pineapplekun8769 Yeah Kaneki's life is so so sad and bleak even from the start. Someone on reddit literally went panel to panel on all of TG and TG:Re and recorded every single time he lied when he touched his chin and man it's crazy how much I missed.

I wonder if some essence of finality and confusion you describe is present in the anime because the naming is so fucking dumb lol

me with the exact same experience lel

I would not blame the studio for this one. This is more so a case of poor management from the production comittee and executive producers involved.

@@carloscauan7967 to add onto this I believe Root A was also meant to be an alternative take on the second half, with Kaneki making the choice of joining Aogiri Tree. Ishida specifically wanted it to be different from the manga.

​@@benjimoskau8172 I was gonna ask why but if the author insisted they do something different then that makes sense I suspect he wanted to be surprised? That would be a selfish request, but understandable One of the saddest things about being part of entertainment is inevitably getting spoiled unlike the audience

Root A is absolute trash. Boring overall, nothing memorable.

@@nelisezpasce The thing is that it's not just that the author wanted a different story. Author apparently wrote full draft on it which the studio and product team barely managed to adapt. Root A is basically missing big chunks of what the author wanted.

Root A was a disaster i swear.

@@ghoulchan7525 and Ishida Sui made a masterpiece from the aftermath 😂

Wait,what trailer ?

Honestly I didn’t hate Root A but Re holy fuck was that dog shit, root A had some feeling towards it, Re just felt like an entire new universe that didn’t make sense

@@beastyboy101bo ☠️ are you talking abt the re anime or manga? Cuz I can’t speak for the anime as I haven’t seen it, but the manga certainly stays faithful to og, and is a great continuation

RE(edit) was not good. I legit read it and was like what in the world is going on. Nothing was explained just WAM time skip no context. Was a huge turn off never finished it. Read the recaps.

@@seemlesslies read it? As in your read a recap for root A? Root is season 2 of the anime so what exactly did you read?

For many years, it was unanimously believed that the mess that is Tokyo Ghoul √A was solely Studio Pierrot's fault. And there were a few reasons why people believed it. Studio Pierrot has a mixed reputation for having produced anime such as Naruto, Boruto, Bleach, Kingdom, and Black Clover. These anime would often be criticised for several reasons such as sub-par animation and visual quality, excessive filler episodes, pacing issues and more. Because of the general media perception that animation studios matter the most when judging anime, it's easy to see why Pierrot is constantly discussed when talking about the Tokyo Ghoul anime. Also, after Tokyo Ghoul √A finished airing, Sui Ishida's drafts of √A were released online and circulated rapidly among the anime community. To everyone's dismay, the drafts were very, very different that what was shown in the anime. Scenes like Kaneki proclaiming that he will kill the One-Eyed King, Touka seeing Rize in Anteiku's basement, and Tatara forcing Kaneki to eat Taguchi did not make it to the anime. Here are the links to the drafts I managed to find: sunset-tower.tumblr.com/post/129424575942/thank-you-so-much-for-you-post-about-the-anime sunset-tower.tumblr.com/post/129418629852/ishidas-root-a-storyboard-drafts-are-so-fun-to sunset-tower.tumblr.com/post/129451544167/how-does-tatara-make-kaneki-to-eat-her-corpse-and This led to the anime-manga community creating the narrative that Pierrot ignored Ishida's drafts of √A when making the anime. One anituber even made a rant video about the drafts, which I think accelerated the narrative even more. However, this cannot be further from the truth as there was an interview with Shuhei Morita (Director of Tokyo Ghoul S1 and S2) in 2018, around the same time as the Tokyo Ghoul :re anime was airing. Link to interview: www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/88fddm/im_shuhei_morita_the_director_of_anime_series/ Before I talk about the interview, I needed to clarify a few things about the nature of √A. When √A was announced after Season 1 aired, it was advertised as a season based on Ishida's original story concept that deviates from the manga. The drafts are proof of this because they showed scenes that were not in the manga. www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2014-10-11/tokyo-ghoul-2nd-anime-season-video-teases-new-story-by-creator/.79825 The reason why I am saying this is that a major criticism about √A is it not following the manga, whereas it was Ishida himself who wanted √A to deviate from the manga. However, the anime-manga community largely blamed this decision on Pierrot because of the animation studio stigma. So if you are unhappy with the fact that √A deviated from the manga, then blame it on Ishida, not Pierrot, even if you respect him. Back to the interview. Basically, Morita stated that the reason why the anime was different from the drafts is that the producers interfered with the original vision. To understand what he means, we need to talk about the production committee. The majority of the anime-manga community believes that the animation studio is generally responsible for how a work is adapted. This is not the case most of the time, as it's the production committee (manga publishers, merch, TV companies etc.) that decides that. In the case of Tokyo Ghoul √A, here are the main producers: - Marvelous - TC Entertainment - Pierrot Now you are probably thinking: "Pierrot is on the production committee so they should have some responsibility in how the √A story was handled". However, that is not the case. Pierrot is ranked at the bottom of the list so they really have little say in the decision-making; they simply do what other producers ordered them to do. Back to the topic, Morita wanted to follow Ishida's drafts, but the producers' interference prevented Ishida and Morita's vision of √A come to fruition. This could be because the producers find Ishida's original story to be risker than the manga story in that it may not make a lot of money. The result was a mixture of anime-original and manga-canon scenes that didn't really make much sense. My intent with this comment is not to change your opinion on Tokyo Ghoul √A, but rather to bring light to a topic that is severely twisted by the anime-manga community for a very long time. Thank you for reading. This post was largely inspired by these 2 posts: twitter.com/Namaryuu/status/1494343939557675009 twitter.com/dotdotKam/status/1492920227104837633

@@lachlanle7940 Woah, that was an interesting read, thank you

@don't be surprised Oh wow! Thank you for giving full context! Sadly I think I know who that anituber is.......

Ok but if the anime was just good in the first place you wouldn't need to read the manga

imo the manga wasn't that good either

since the reason you read it was √A, did you continue on from S1 ending or just decided to read from the start? if the latter, would you say it's worth doing so?

I don't care!!

@@luminescentcore Them's fighting words.

@Bazinga thx

The first season is pretty solid even if some details are skipped it was still on track to properly adapot the events of the manga. Then they literally just did whatever the f they wanted dissapointing pretty much everyone.

I feel S1 was good enough but manga the true way to go

@@maineman5757 Ikr, you know it's fuck up when you don't even have season 3 and they skip to Tokyo Ghoul RE. Like wtf? If you're manga reader, you will be hella dissapointed that you won't even watch the anime and if you anime only you will be confused why Kaneki suddenly become investigator.

GLASSY SKYYYYYYYYYYY ABOVEEEEEEEEE

I discovered tokyo ghoul by watching the anime first so when i finally got to read the manga i was very positively surprised that there was so much more to it

The anime left out some details but ultimately was bad because the manga was bad.

This, yep you took the words out of my mouth. The 1st season was great, afterwards it was just confusing as hell

Mee too, that art Is incredibile to me

I love how he mix a watercolor and actual manga style together to create that unique style. The only reason I don't completely hate season two is because of the 12 endings portraying his style.

THIS, Tokyo Ghoul is one of the few manga where the art style completely suits the tone and theme of the story. While I'm sad to admit this, Sui's latest work Choujin X was nowhere near good compared to TG since I feel the artstyle doesn't fits the theme so far. While there are great manga out there without great art, a great art could really improve the depth of the story. TG was one of the rare case where the art and the story was match made in heaven.

@@Username-cs1bi I personally think it's too early to tell, but I do agree that the story is somewhat weak right now in comparison to Tokyo Ghoul, and doesn't exactly fit with the art. But I think Sui Ishida is again, focusing on developing the characters and liking to take his time, and personally, I think he's having more fun writing Choujin X than Tokyo Ghoul, especially with the comedy involved. I just read for what it is, just a fun but can be dark manga, which I think is how Ishida's approaching it.

Ishida deserves a manga route reboot like Brotherhood to do this justice

Right dude!! The fights are underrated!!

And then you read Tokyo ghoul re, and you can't comprehend wtf is going on in the fights anymore :( something changed.

@@GreMLinSLoveCoOkies i dont think thats true for all the fights tho, usually its balanced out with cool art and dynamic poses but yea it can be hard to follow exactly

That's not what happened. Ishida wrote a love letter to the fans when he ended the manga saying he eventually ''fell out of love'' with his work and that's why he rushed it, or else it would be unfinished. Anime studios have nothing to do with manga publishing and publishers, so an anime studio can't push for something that is entirely different from their work.

The best thing about the anime is the ost in general in my opinion. But "Unravel" especially

We cannot talk about Tokyo Ghoul, without mentioning the famous piano arrangement of "unravel" by Animenz, the most influential ani-pianist of all time. ukposts.info/have/v-deo/q3WCmmujmqSbwKM.html I truly believe that this piano arrangement made a substantial contribution to Tokyo Ghoul's popularity and to the reputation of the ani-piano community. Not only is this the most popular anime piano arrangement of all time (currently sitting at 88M views) but Animenz described it his most difficult so far. The variety of advanced piano techniques, combined with its high faithfulness to the original song was what gave it such a notoriety. It has also become Animenz's signature song that he would play it in every of his live concerts. I would even say that the piano arrangement pushed the limits of what a piano arrangement could be.

As a TK super fan trust me, when you hear the rest of his discography unravel becomes mid lmfao

The root a ending theme fits more than unravel. There is a sort of nuanced beauty to it that's trying to tell the story from both sides

and we shall not speak of the live action movie

Yea I was just talking about how pierrot looks to be doing well with bleach and that they NEED to remake the abomination they've created with re: especially. Whoever/the group who was in charge of deadlines and dates to finish the sequels of tokyo ghoul were stupid idk how these people get these jobs and fail so badly, like changing the route of the story or compressing hundreds of chapters into 12-24 episodes?

Not to mention he always remains focused on being gentle and protecting those he loves.

@@cortomaltese5206 the "flipping a switch" he had was amazing, the instability of his mind but him trying his best to keep it together while being thorn apart inside

Kaneki's the goat, litterally.

He wasn’t even a loser, he was just a normal guy who wanted p

He was never a weak loser lol

So far Choujin X is moving pretty well. I kind of like the more laid back attitude of the series compared to Tokyo Ghoul. Tokyo Ghoul was great for being dark and edgy. Choujin X has its own persona and I am glad Ishida sensei decided to make it different in style compared to TG.

@@jayaniceday3602 I like the fact that Ishida has mire creative control but his new schedule makes waiting for new chapter a pain

@@zemox2534 For me, I actually don't mind. I go enjoy Spy x Family, Monster 8, both on Manga Plus, and when Choujin X comes out, I go happily read that. With this said, once the first real big cliff hanger comes out...I will probably be shouting MOARRRR! :P

Here's the manga PV ukposts.info/have/v-deo/boV-e5CZjn1qumQ.html

yes definitely choujin x is looking good so far and has a LOT of potential

Is there a colored version. Would love to read it since the show was so bad.

I know right? It’s such a great feeling of validation when they admit you’re right! Kinda like Promised Neverland. 9 times out of 10, the manga/visual novel is better than the anime adaptation (unless it’s ufotable).

@@BonazaiGirl it feels even greater when you've been with the manga from the start and just now they're being exposed to the greatness of the source material 😂😂

@@epistolarydreams7555 I'm not really sure, but the base manga is great as is you won't even mind the black and white. But if you find a good colouring of it, send it my way!

Tokyo Ghoul needs a remake ? No, not really. It's not manga accurate, but it's still good. Berserk tho...that needs a remake. Original series, artstyle and animations were awesome, but new one...it sucks and it desperately needs remake (if they made it same as original anime artstyle, then that would be great).

the more we raise hell the more likely they are to redo it like they did with FMA and brother hood

The saviour

We will watch your career with great interest

When I heard that line, everyone in the cinema started celebrating and crying

I love the part whenever I scroll down the youtube comment section and I read the "original" cringe comment, "It's cringe time" and start cringing all over youtube. This is truly the most dead joke that refuses to die.

This is too fucking overused, continue.

technically that was the Jason fight ngl

@@IAMNOTRANA i love the part where everyone said "it's askin' time" and never actually did it

The manga is great, Season 1 of the anime is great and it needs a proper remake.

Bro was so happy he decided to write a light novel 😭

Yea man It still bogles my mind how Pierrot messed TG up that badly, the reboot needs to come fast

@@ReidAstrea given how low-budget :re feels, I don't think anyone is ready to invest in a reboot anytime soon

What a magnificent manga(s) Tokyo Ghoul is, it deserves the best adaptation

Omg ive never seen someone else who GETS it, 1000% agree

True.

lmao fr

If you think Tokyo Ghoul is underrated, you should check out the Ajin Demihuman manga, it's like Tokyo Ghoul, but with more interesting strategy, and is waaaay more unrecognized.

@@s-zz ajin was goated for sure 🙌🙌

@@KyleYousef. its not that you dont understand the hype, its the fact that you don't understand Tokyo Ghoul at all.

holy sh#t dude 😂 not even book lovers will say this type of sh#t. you are deeply troubled

@@bayro7 nice bait bro

@@stormedmint3325 dude just look at ur pfp, touch grass

@@bayro7 wdym

Book readers sometimes are snobs, but this.... This is something else You have never seen before? It portrays as much emotions as normal text. For example metro 2033 it has book amount of text and illustrations from time BUT I DO NOT TREAT IT AS A GLORIFIED COMIC BOOK

It was a touching moment for me also. I didn't like Juzou in Tokyo Ghoul at first but he became one of my favorite in Re thanks to his character development.

@lim sowq yep, started going downhill after the big arima fight and the last arc is a trollfest by ishida.

Juuzou is the best boy who deserves the world

I really like hiw much impact Shinohara has in Juuzou. He's great mentor that change a heartless brat into respected team leader. Like this boy doesn't even care at anyone in beginning, but his panel when he sees Shinohara gets injured is really powerful, showing how much now he has someone to care about.

Suzuya was easily my favorite character in the manga. When he was first introduced, I was thought, "Oh, here's an over the top edgy character for some fanservice" but oh boy was I wrong. Through his relationship with Shinohara and eventual leadership role, he proved he was more than just a zany guy with interesting stitches. Truly a worthy successor to be CCG's reaper.