Why Russia Tried to Block This Canal

  Переглядів 4,329,991

The B1M

The B1M

День тому

The Vistula Canal is more than just a piece of infrastructure.
Head to brilliant.org/TheB1M/ for a 30-day free trial + the first 200 people will receive 20% off their annual subscription.
Full story here - theb1m.com/video/why-russia-t...
This video contains paid promotion for Brilliant.
Additional footage and images courtesy of Besix, GRUPA NDI, and Maritime Office in Gdynia, ABC News, sara.liz.joy, Besix, janiejaffe, bradmilison, Poland Daily Live and Sputnik News.
Research sources:
3seaseurope.com/vistula-spit-...
www.reuters.com/article/us-po...
csengineermag.com/besix-in-po...
www.theguardian.com/world/202...
www.gov.pl/web/special-servic...
gcaptain.com/poland-opens-new...
www.globalconstructionreview....
www.economist.com/europe/2022...
www.newcivilengineer.com/late...
For more by The B1M subscribe now - bit.ly/the-b1m
We're raising awareness of construction's mental health crisis through our Get Construction Talking initiative. There’s a video series on our channel and you can find support or donate at - www.getconstructiontalking.org/
Follow Get Construction Talking
Instagram - / getconstructiontalking
Twitter - / getconsttalking
LinkedIn - / about
Listen to The World's Best Construction Podcast by The B1M
Apple - apple.co/3OssZsH
Spotify - spoti.fi/3om1NkB
Amazon Music - amzn.to/3znmBP4
View this video and more at - www.TheB1M.com/
Follow us on Twitter - / theb1m
Like us on Facebook - / theb1m
Follow us on TikTok - / theb1m
Follow us on LinkedIn - / the-b1m-ltd
Follow us on Instagram - / theb1m
The B1M Merch store - theb1m.creator-spring.com/
#construction #infrastructure #engineering
We welcome you sharing our content to inspire others, but please be nice and play by our rules - www.theb1m.com/guidelines-for-...
Our content may only be embedded onto third party websites by arrangement. We have established partnerships with domains to share our content and help it reach a wider audience. If you are interested in partnering with us please contact Video@TheB1M.com.
Ripping and/or editing this video is illegal and will result in legal action.
© 2024 The B1M Limited

КОМЕНТАРІ: 3 300
@TheB1M
@TheB1M 2 місяці тому
Head to brilliant.org/TheB1M/ for a 30-day free trial + the first 200 people will receive 20% off their annual subscription 🏗
@DetroitMicroSound
@DetroitMicroSound 2 місяці тому
Because a state committing genocide on it's neighbors, cares about endangering nesting birds.... Sure.
@Matti_us_Alpe
@Matti_us_Alpe 2 місяці тому
To be honest, can someone explain why a water lock was needed?
@CoffeeAndPaul
@CoffeeAndPaul 2 місяці тому
​@@Matti_us_Alpe, that's a good question. I looked it up. Apparently Baltic seawater by way of the Gulf of Gdansk supply ~85% of the horizontal water supply (rain being vertical) into the Vistula Lagoon, all of it through the Strait of Baltiysk, the Strait being the Poles' only way into the lagoon before they built the canal. The water levels between both estuaries, the Gulf & the lagoon, are normally less than 0.8 meters' difference unless there are windstorms. In heavy storm conditions with high winds, though, the water level in the lagoon could reach as high as 1 meter above Sea level, which would damage parts of the lagoon. There are 2 reasons to build the locks. They built the locks to keep exchange of the Gulf's & lagoon's respective waters to as bare a minimum as possible. This preserves the lagoon's salinity level. The second reason is storm control. The wind storms I mentioned can raise the lagoon's water height to as much as 1 meter above Sea level, potentially flooding the lagoon polders (sp.) which help the locals control against river floods (the Vistula River, the 9th longest River in Europe, empties into the lagoon). An opened canal can use the different water heights to allow the lagoon an emergency outflow to the Gulf, keeping the flood-control polders undamaged. I learned a lot looking up the answer for your question! Thanks for asking.
@terryhoath1983
@terryhoath1983 2 місяці тому
@@Matti_us_Alpe First of all, don't say or write, "To be honest". It infers that you are a liar most of the time. Secondly, there was absolutely no need for the lock. It is a piece of gross over engineering, insisted upon by the Brussels/Bruxelles Mafia to help their grasping friends. Instead of asking about the lock, perhaps you could ask why a Belgian construction company was foisted on the Poles adding dramatically to the cost. If they had asked me, I could have designed and project managed a canal for them a/ WITHOUT A LOCK b/ draft only limited by the depth of the lagoon, 3/ allowing for at least 24 ships each day in each direction. Sunshine does not say whether his ships are 12 in each direction or 12 in total each day and, without those concrete spiders, only a fraction of the CO2 emitted to the atmosphere and for less than one tenth of the cost of this thing Their excuse for the lock is that the AVERAGE level of the water in the lagoon is marginally higher at this point than the AVERAGE level of the water in the open Bay of Gdansk. There is an inference on the video that the Vistula flows into the lagoon causing this difference, the water having to flow many miles to the North-East to flow out of the Russian passage. The Baltic has hardly any tidal range. There are, however long shore currents in the Baltic which have lead to sediments from the big rivers forming these huge sand bars. The eventual passage of these rivers to the open sea is therefore obstructed by their own sediment. The draft of barges on the Vistula is seriously restricted by sand bars in the river during the Summer months. The Vistula has snaked across the coastal plain and changed its' course frequently. At various times, it has entered the sea though this lagoon but it doesn't anymore. Having entered the Baltic about 19 miles (30 kms) to the West of the lagoon for a few centuries, a more direct route has been hard engineered and the Vistula now enters the Baltic about 14 miles (22 kms) to the West of the lagoon. Contrary to what is stated in the video, the canal is not called "The Vistula Canal", it is "Kanał żeglugowy. Nowy Świat" which literally translates as "Canal Shipping New World". Although the lagoon is open to the sea at the Kaliningrad end and in theory, the water should be at the same level, there is a tendency for water to pile up a little at the upper ends of inlets and estuaries, and although the Vistula does not enter the lagoon, there is some drainage from lesser water courses. Don't misinterpret the film at 5.58. That showed the water being allowed through the coffer dam for the initial filling of the lock when construction of the lock was complete. There was also a question about different cyanobacteria in the water on each side of the spit. I say "Sod the cyanobacteria !" My answer would have been to have great chunks of rock (20 tonnes ...many full freight containers weigh more) quarried from somewhere up the Vistula and brought down on barges. The rock could then have been laid in the Sea and in the lagoon in the shape of fans and creating a funnel across the spit about 10 times wider than the existing canal. A narrow channel could have been cut across the spit down the centre of the funnel. As soon as there was a connection between the lagoon and the Sea, using the differential in water level the canal would have done nearly all its' own dredging with the sand carried out into the the sea with the rock subsiding and being augmented as necessary to provide a hard banks for the canal .... NO CONCRETE !!! If aby of the rockk chunks were dislodged in an occasional violent storm (This is the Baltic, it isn't the Atlantic), then a crane barge could be used to put them back in place. The dredging could then have been finished off with mechanical dredgers, ideally spreading the sand on the landward side of the rock banks. Until such time as the level in the lagoon falls to the level of the sea the canal would have self-dredged and any sandbank that may become a nuisance could be dredged and the material dumped behind the rock flares. During construction, a temporary pontoon bridge could have been built to carry the very small number of vehicles that use the spit road . It is a dead-end road running for about 15 miles (23 kms) serving a few small settlements along the spit terminating close to the Kaliningrad border. Bearing in mind the small amount of traffic that uses the bridges(which have been built at monstrous cost, I would have constructed a concrete barge 60 ft (18 m) wide and 400 feet (a little over 122m) long. This would be the floating bridge. Piers would be built out into the canal with a waterway between them of 425 ft (130m) The bridge would be anchored to one pier and using a floating cable from the bank, the loose end of the bridge could be allowed to float into position using the gentle current and metal ramps lowered into place to allow use of the road and then pulled out of the way to allow passage of ships. When the current isn't enough, a small tug would do the job. Because there is so little traffic using the bridge, I suggest that the bridge should be in place for 3 hours for road vehicles and then 3 hours for the ships ... or, if the number of ships was not great, 4 hours for the road and 2 hours for the ships. People on land would know exactly when the bridge would be open for them. On the basis of alternating 3 hours, the ships would have 90 minutes out and then 90 minutes in. This would leave 4.5 hours at a time when ships could not use the canal but passage would be far faster than using the stupid lock and a lot faster than using the Kaliningrad passage if travelling to or from the West. I hope this answers your question and a bit more.
@raivisk72
@raivisk72 2 місяці тому
Since you’re looking at a project in Baltic Sea region, when can we expect a video about RailBaltica?
@DannyMancheno
@DannyMancheno 2 місяці тому
Canal: $500,000,000.00 Escaping russian influence: Priceless
@nntflow7058
@nntflow7058 2 місяці тому
It's not even that expensive compared to Poland's Tax revenue they gather each 😂
@matteofalduto766
@matteofalduto766 2 місяці тому
For Everything Else, there's MasterCard
@coffeegator6033
@coffeegator6033 2 місяці тому
Not to mention that bribes that were certainly costing them even more to get through russian waters.
@tatianaes3354
@tatianaes3354 2 місяці тому
@@nntflow7058it is so expensive that the project will turn profit only after 700 years
@JaroslavBrabec-iz5eb
@JaroslavBrabec-iz5eb 2 місяці тому
This canal is a crime against nature and common sense.
@Red.Hot.Chili.Beans63
@Red.Hot.Chili.Beans63 2 місяці тому
So nice that the Russians are concerned about Poland's financial health. What a nice and helpful neighbor!!!
@user-ly5pd1sb7z
@user-ly5pd1sb7z 2 місяці тому
мы любим Польшу .
@masterchinese28
@masterchinese28 2 місяці тому
Haha! :)
@tardvandecluntproductions1278
@tardvandecluntproductions1278 2 місяці тому
They also seem to be very educated on EU law, more then the EU itself. /s
@AquaManiac23
@AquaManiac23 2 місяці тому
@@user-ly5pd1sb7z But we don´t like you.
@stiegelzeine2186
@stiegelzeine2186 2 місяці тому
Yeah and this love for animals and our planet… they really love nature even more than königsberg‘s native citizens who got thrown out by those war criminals
@apveening
@apveening 2 місяці тому
Minor detail: Those funny shaped blocks for the breakwaters were designed in the Netherlands for the upgrade of the Afsluitdijk. On a recent video about that upgrade, it was mentioned that these blocks were going to be used world wide, nice to seen an example.
@aymonfoxc1442
@aymonfoxc1442 2 місяці тому
Denmark and the Netherlands have long been leaders in land reclamation technologies. It's cool stuff 😎
@philippejoseph8604
@philippejoseph8604 2 місяці тому
There are other specific design such as the Sogreah one.
@mecx7322
@mecx7322 2 місяці тому
It is not the first time we see Dutch activity in the area. Entire Vistula estuary ( Zulawy ) was managed by Dutch immigrants in XV and XVI century. They built an extensive system of canals, locks and dams and reclaimed some areas below sea level.
@ytjos222
@ytjos222 2 місяці тому
major detail: the whole project is Dutch design and engineering.
@richardkroll2269
@richardkroll2269 2 місяці тому
The Dutch are masters at pushing back against the power of the Sea starting with the huge Zuider Zee Project. When I was a young boy my family visited the Dutch Coast and we heard and about the immensity of the project. I lived very close to the Alden Hydraulics Laboratory of Worcester (Massachusetts) Polytechnic University where they had single buildings dedicated to layouts of the hydrology of such projects including nuclear power stations.
@MrSaemichlaus
@MrSaemichlaus 2 місяці тому
Remember kids: whoever doesn't want you to grow and become stronger and more efficient, is not your friend.
@dexterek011
@dexterek011 2 місяці тому
Yes. We known that Germans, who are blocking practically every infrastructure project in Poland, are our enemies.
@templeodoom4634
@templeodoom4634 2 місяці тому
Wish I met you 20 years ago ❤
@mattgillard8253
@mattgillard8253 2 місяці тому
USA regarding the rest of the world.
@xandr13
@xandr13 2 місяці тому
No shit Sherlock.
@nikobellic570
@nikobellic570 2 місяці тому
Every country about every other country ​@@mattgillard8253
@gaaaaavin
@gaaaaavin 2 місяці тому
Gotta say, insinuating that the truth lies "somewhere in the middle" when one side is Russian state propaganda is not a good look. Hard to "both sides" that one tbh.
@ascra1693
@ascra1693 2 місяці тому
I haven't watched the video yet but I believe this comment to be completely true
@gaaaaavin
@gaaaaavin 2 місяці тому
​@@ascra1693I'm just some guy. You should make up your own mind.
@Andy_M986
@Andy_M986 2 місяці тому
The West and it's allies,do nothing but spread false Propoganda, always have done.
@ascra1693
@ascra1693 2 місяці тому
I watch a lot of Russian and Chinese propaganda so I know the type of stuff they say, that's why i believed it to be true.. and now that I have watched the video its very clear your comment is 100% correct
@Snoopster12345
@Snoopster12345 2 місяці тому
Exactly my thought. Was surprised to hear that
@walterjurewicz1567
@walterjurewicz1567 2 місяці тому
Not every infrastructure project needs positive rate of return. There plenty of examples of train routes that are not profitable but are needed to connect rural communities.
@qwormuli77
@qwormuli77 2 місяці тому
Or standing armies. Those rarely turn out financially beneficial, but still for some strange reason most countries in the world prefer having one of their own.
@kaitnip
@kaitnip 2 місяці тому
@@qwormuli77 Sensible chuckle.
@glacieractivity
@glacieractivity 2 місяці тому
I think that a sensible 650-year down-pay plan to break even is worth it just to make Mordor slightly upset. Most of us are happy with some inconvenience to avoid interacting with moronic bullies daily. I quote: ""Never argue with idiots; they'll drag you down to their level and beat you with experience." Well played Polish friends. Well played.
@Raussl
@Raussl 2 місяці тому
@@droopy_eyes it literally shortend the route to the Baltic sea for one of the largest Polish ports and made possible Russian interference impossible. That alone makes it worth building 5 times over.
@Raussl
@Raussl 2 місяці тому
@@droopy_eyes my points have nothing to do with invasion...you are connecting dots that aren't even there.
@waitingforacentury
@waitingforacentury 2 місяці тому
Just like in business, it's not always about direct profits, but also about not letting your competitors (or enemies) get wealthier and more powerful.
@utriaininja
@utriaininja 12 днів тому
Russia's pockets would be a lot fatter if they were a bit more business minded with its neighbors.
@V3G4N01
@V3G4N01 День тому
​@@utriaininjaсоседи отправляют оружие, чтобы убивать русских солдат. Это не располагает к сотрудничеству.
@aleksanderwierzejski1346
@aleksanderwierzejski1346 2 місяці тому
Water levels on bay and sea are actually the same. Lock exist to prevent sea water from entering the lagoon.
@misspatvandriverlady7555
@misspatvandriverlady7555 2 місяці тому
I was wondering why there would be a significant difference in water level between the two… 🤔
@petrnemec1421
@petrnemec1421 2 місяці тому
This detail bothered me too. Both waters are sealevel and they literally meet several kilometers north. How could they be different levels if none of them is river that is higher. THX I thought I was going crazy thinking I'm alone on this one.
@aleksanderwierzejski1346
@aleksanderwierzejski1346 2 місяці тому
@@petrnemec1421 Polish opposition (at the time) was against this investment. BTW God knows why... So they tried to push all buttons available like envinronmental objections, etc. They were against cutting trees (feeble and weak at this point), advertising some special bugs and plants that will suffer if the canal was to be build, etc. Therefore - to avoid constant beating the eco-madness-drum the investor decided to put up a lock.
@MassiveBuild
@MassiveBuild 2 місяці тому
It created an artificial island in the lagoon, which is planned to be a bird habitat. The island is tentatively named the Aestian Island, after the ancient Baltic tribe that lived in the region
@Theman-qs9vw
@Theman-qs9vw 2 місяці тому
They mention that in the video
@kutyna4nogi141
@kutyna4nogi141 2 місяці тому
@@hia5235 B.S.
@geofflepper3207
@geofflepper3207 2 місяці тому
​@@hia5235 In the 1850s a huge storm created a 150 metre wide channel in the peninsula into Lake Ontario by Toronto thus creating an island. That island still seems to be doing just fine. In fact better than it would be doing if it was a peninsula because if it had still been a peninsula when the age of the car arrived people inevitably would have built a road from the mainland across the entire piece of land and humans would have ended up disturbing it much more.
@jCo1
@jCo1 2 місяці тому
​@@hia5235you must be part of the Russian govt. 👀😂
@WangAiHua
@WangAiHua 2 місяці тому
@@hia5235 Funny---RuZZia is more concerned about other country's environment than with their own!
@mmkrk4071
@mmkrk4071 2 місяці тому
Elbląg is not a major port in Poland, but it allows for a little easier distribution of cargo traffic in north east area of the country.
@PenskePC17
@PenskePC17 2 місяці тому
I was wondering why this Canal wouldn't have already been built if this was such an important harbor. It makes a lot more sense now.
@sion8
@sion8 2 місяці тому
Maybe now it could be?
@CarPhotos
@CarPhotos 2 місяці тому
@@sion8 nope Zalew Wiślany(Vistula lake) its not so deep to use bigger ships. Average 2,7m deep
@greg-warsaw4708
@greg-warsaw4708 2 місяці тому
@@CarPhotos Exactly! The new proudly-built canal opens up traffic... to a very minor, insignificant port.
@sion8
@sion8 2 місяці тому
@@greg-warsaw4708 Okay.🤷‍♂️
@kacperrydecki2036
@kacperrydecki2036 2 місяці тому
From elblag but live abroad and coming back this year I’ve seen that part of town spring back to life after years of slowly rotting away
@slawomirkulinski
@slawomirkulinski 2 місяці тому
Elblag was an important port in medieval times. For example it was exempted from taxes when trading with United Kingdom. A substantial number of Englishmen lived in the city.
@alspence6992
@alspence6992 2 місяці тому
Yes and it's funny this video didn't mention the Elbląg Canal.
@ohasis8331
@ohasis8331 2 місяці тому
Funny how aggressive nations often get concerned with another country's economic well being, environmental concerns and social well being whenever they act independently.
@user-zb9lv3gh8s
@user-zb9lv3gh8s 2 місяці тому
Those Russians are such good hearted people
@ohasis8331
@ohasis8331 2 місяці тому
@@user-zb9lv3gh8s Their generosity and consideration is exceeded by only one other nation who shares a border with them.
@7ElevenTruther
@7ElevenTruther 2 місяці тому
​@@user-zb9lv3gh8sIf only their generosity could be repaid by allowing every single russian national to enter a care free permanent nap in a...communal dirt bed.
@mmdirtyworkz
@mmdirtyworkz 2 місяці тому
Yes, USA is the cancer, you are right
@dwhitey
@dwhitey 2 місяці тому
Same as how fossil fuel industries suddenly care about the environment whenever there's a proposed green energy project. Funny that
@KamilsView
@KamilsView 2 місяці тому
A BIG LIKE for the correct pronouciation of ELBLĄG! Spot on, mate!
@miguelrodriguez-kw6je
@miguelrodriguez-kw6je 2 місяці тому
ELBING
@usernamename2978
@usernamename2978 2 місяці тому
But sad about the chav English.
@KamilsView
@KamilsView 2 місяці тому
What??? @@miguelrodriguez-kw6je
@KamilsView
@KamilsView 2 місяці тому
Chav English? What do you mean? Not posh enough? @@usernamename2978
@user-fw8xi5tr2f
@user-fw8xi5tr2f 2 місяці тому
the brexit makes these bloody brits learn polish
@wojtekpolska1013
@wojtekpolska1013 2 місяці тому
you kind of overstate the importance of Elbląg port. its in fact a pretty small port, thats why the canal that was built is small too. overall it wont have an enormous impact for polish economy, but removing any russian control over our country is always a good thing
@radioideaxp
@radioideaxp 2 місяці тому
To explain: we have ports for cargo in Szczecin, Świnoujście, Gdynia, Gdańsk and maybe Kołobrzeg can be modernized. This canal is not for big cargo because Elbląg is not for that.
@CharlieTheNerd91
@CharlieTheNerd91 2 місяці тому
Back in the mid-90s, when I was a child, maybe 6 years old or so, my mother told me she would take me on a boat ride through a lock in Hamburg, Germany. We did it, and it was nothing special to me then. Today I look at it as a very fond memory, and I think it was a very cool thing for her to take me to :)
@ICU1337
@ICU1337 2 місяці тому
This story is missing meaningful details...
@CharlieTheNerd91
@CharlieTheNerd91 2 місяці тому
@@ICU1337 Which ones? :)
@Z4Zander
@Z4Zander 2 місяці тому
I look upon a trip through the Panama Canal as a highlight of my life.Pity I didn't have the cameras I own today.
@ICU1337
@ICU1337 2 місяці тому
@@CharlieTheNerd91 lol like the rest of the story lol🤣
@thomaschristopher8593
@thomaschristopher8593 2 місяці тому
@@ICU1337 it's not a story, it's a vignette.
@truebluereef419
@truebluereef419 2 місяці тому
Russia, that neighbor that doesn't like you landscaping your own front yard as you please.
@margo7059
@margo7059 2 місяці тому
В это никому не нравится )) Румыния сейчас на Украину агрится по поводу канала в устье Дуная. А США вообще всем угрожают,если кто-то что-то строит.
@movingshapes
@movingshapes 2 місяці тому
@@margo7059as always the orc is making idiotic comments. Danube is a river, which is a completely different context, isn’t it, orc?
@usernamename2978
@usernamename2978 2 місяці тому
Кому именно?
@jabloko992
@jabloko992 2 місяці тому
Yes, they would prefer to do the landscaping for you...with missiles and artillery.
@ilaser4064
@ilaser4064 2 місяці тому
@@margo7059 now you'll provide examples for your kremlin talking points....
@LordOceanus
@LordOceanus 2 місяці тому
The artificial island they made here is an excellent example of working with the planet in development. In this case the land of the Vistula spit is home to nesting grounds for many bird species. Running the canal through it destroys some of that available area but building the artificial island very close nearby negates the habitat loss. In fact it looks like once the island is complete it will provide 3 or more times the land than was used for the project. Overall the species reliant on the spit, Humans, and migratory birds get what they want out of the project. The poles get a canal and the birds get a new but local and probably even safer nesting site. Yes it will take a few years for that benefit to be realized but its a solid plan overall.
@MrBalonpl
@MrBalonpl 2 місяці тому
It is worth adding that the port in Elbląg is a small, insignificant port in Poland. Currently, mainly yachts use the canal.
@dorka4538
@dorka4538 2 місяці тому
So taxpayers provided the filthy rich a way to the BS without paying Ruzzia for it.
@jaszaesel5390
@jaszaesel5390 2 місяці тому
Gdynia used to be a small insignificant village.
@p0358
@p0358 2 місяці тому
@@jaszaesel5390 Gdynia has deeper waters, Elbląg does not
@_ata_3
@_ata_3 2 місяці тому
Congratulations to Poland!!! 🍻
@ms-ht1cj
@ms-ht1cj 2 місяці тому
Nothing to congratulate, it was a waste of money. Stupid idea.
@Exodius3
@Exodius3 2 місяці тому
@@ms-ht1cjRuski beep beep boop
@FUZASHIII
@FUZASHIII 2 місяці тому
@@ms-ht1cjyou seem upset, Ivan 😢go drink some vodka 😉
@MrGunnar69
@MrGunnar69 2 місяці тому
@@Exodius3 Is criticism of wasting tax money Russian propaganda now? You are really well trained obedient dogs. Wow wow.
@Jymboslicx
@Jymboslicx 2 місяці тому
​@MrGunnar69yeah ngl looking at the video thought it woulf be something more interesting but it honestly just seems extremely pointless and a waste of money that can go towards other stuff
@TigerXGame
@TigerXGame 2 місяці тому
Anyone know why Poland didn't opt to build a lock big enough to handle all sizes of modern cargo ships? Seems like a minor difference over a distance of only 1km. The entire thing seems unpractically small.
@NomTix
@NomTix 2 місяці тому
Simply beacuse it wasnt needed. Main cargo ports are in Gdansk and Gdynia that are already right next to the baltic sea. That canal was built simply to allow locals to travel with their boats without russians standing on their way
@Micro-bit
@Micro-bit 2 місяці тому
There is no real need for this canal - Elbląg (Poland) is not a crucial port. Currently, the canal is used by several private boats/kayaks a day, which incurs a cost of $10,000 per unit. Probably, its strategic significance is the biggest clue.
@NomTix
@NomTix 2 місяці тому
Also it wouldnt be just the lock that would have to be deeper and bigger but also Vistula Lagoon is not deep enough for cargo traffic.
@michanowak3001
@michanowak3001 2 місяці тому
Elbąg is just low priority and not so big port. Vistula lagoon is just not so deep for big ships. There is plan to make it a bit deeper so port can utilize full use of this canal. And currently Poland is increasing throughput of much better located ports on east Gdańsk/Gdynia only 60 km away and Szczecin/Świnoujście on most western part of sea side.
@TurboBorsuk
@TurboBorsuk 2 місяці тому
Probably EU wouldn't greenlight this project if it were to become yet another cargo port competing with German ports.
@roberts1938
@roberts1938 2 місяці тому
A canal is like a road, only it runs on water. Poland did right to build a road that is short and independent of Russia's moods. In this way, several small ports were connected, enabling the development of these regions, which are also very beautiful for tourism. There is no problem in going on a beautiful holiday trip in a small or larger boat.
@ShinryuZensen
@ShinryuZensen 2 місяці тому
Poland is an independent nation, with its own identity and people that should be able to do whatever they want within their territory. My home, my home renovations.
@matrix01234567899
@matrix01234567899 2 місяці тому
Respect for saing Elbląg correctly
@PeteDarrell1972
@PeteDarrell1972 2 місяці тому
Elbing!
@Gaymany2
@Gaymany2 2 місяці тому
​@@PeteDarrell1972إلبينج*
@mickimicki
@mickimicki 2 місяці тому
​@@PeteDarrell1972 Not for a long time
@headhunter1945
@headhunter1945 2 місяці тому
@@mickimicki It was under German rule for a longer time than it was under Polish rule. More importantly, though, Germans founded the city, not the Poles.
@homieles
@homieles 2 місяці тому
Damn you guys sound like the city should belong to Germany
@smiechuwarte-qt8pn
@smiechuwarte-qt8pn 2 місяці тому
Another interesting fact is that yachts can pass by on their way to the Masurian lakes. According to information from the Maritime Office, over 1,300 yachts have passed through so far.
@jacek5384
@jacek5384 2 місяці тому
Masurian lakes are not suitable for sea yachts - too shallow waters. Apart from that the only water connection between Great Mazurian Lakes Route and Baltic Sea runs not through Elbląg, but through Gdańsk, Wisła river, Narew River and Pisa River. Pretty long way round possible only for boats with very little submergence, not sea-ready yachts.
@realulli
@realulli 2 місяці тому
@@jacek5384 What is the water depth there? E.g. catamarans frequently have drafts of less than 1.5m. If you don't want to go under bridges, you don't even have to unstep the mast.
@jacek5384
@jacek5384 2 місяці тому
@@realulli To all the way from the Wisła River outlet upstream through Wisła, Narew and Pisa rivers to Great Masurian Lakes Route one will need a boat with submergence rather like a kayak. That shallow there, particularly Pisa River very shallow river. From Elbląg port one can go by water to another part of Masurian Lakes, not really popular for yachting and smaller lakes. Anyways not suitable for seaborne yachts or any boat with submersion more than about 50 cm.
@jakubagudza2642
@jakubagudza2642 Місяць тому
thats false the biggest thing that can pass through the canal are kayaks but even then due to the amount of paperwork that has to be done its faster to just carry them across next to the canal
@tylermech66
@tylermech66 2 місяці тому
The fact they built that in just five years with only that much money is amazing to me after hearting about so many modern infrastructure projects going horribly. Poland stronk.
@rafarewaj5572
@rafarewaj5572 2 місяці тому
I must sat that I'm used to native English speakers having truly atrocious pronounciation of Polish names, to the point where I myself as a Pole could not guess what they are trying to convey, so when I heard you saying "Elbląg" and it was absolutely 100% spot on, to say I was taken aback woud be a massive understatement, I guess it took some practice, nice mate. Now to the core, yeah there was a discord from local officials of whether they're gonna be responsible for deepening the track, but once that is settled, it's all cool. As for the russian objections, well there is only one good place for them, trash bin. By the way, there is one great project in the works here right now called CPK (Central Communication Port), it's gonna bring together air, rail and roads. You'd be more than welcome to make a video about it! Cheers~
@69Gapcio
@69Gapcio 2 місяці тому
👍
@_DREBBEL_
@_DREBBEL_ 2 місяці тому
I’m glad they learned there’s no stoping the free nation of Poland.
@TJW68
@TJW68 2 місяці тому
Weird that an open lagoon would have a different water level than the outside sea.
@AttilaAsztalos
@AttilaAsztalos 2 місяці тому
...maybe due to tides...?
@thatrandomguyontheinternet2477
@thatrandomguyontheinternet2477 2 місяці тому
Hydronomics go brrrrr
@ARW.7
@ARW.7 2 місяці тому
I thought the same, mostly because the open sea is just down the coast a little with no canal required? 🤷🏻‍♂️ clearly not as simple as that 🤔
@justliberty4072
@justliberty4072 2 місяці тому
The flow through the connection between the lagoon and the sea depends on the difference in water levels. The greater the difference, the greater the flow. Ignoring short term fluctuations including tides, the lagoon has inputs of direct runoff from land and from rivers. The output is through the connection across the spit. The average difference in water levels will stabilize such that the inputs equal the outputs. If the connection were wider, the water level difference would be less and if the connection were narrower, the level difference would be greater.
@ronald3836
@ronald3836 2 місяці тому
@@AttilaAsztalos apparently the Baltic Sea does not have significant tides.
@Bentriverrusher
@Bentriverrusher 2 місяці тому
You know what kind of neighbor you are when next door spends billions to dig a trench just to escape dealing with your chip.
@carolwalters7069
@carolwalters7069 2 місяці тому
AWESOME! Good for Poland. Independent thinkers, thinking about taking care of their people. Wonderful! 😊
@jmi5969
@jmi5969 2 місяці тому
7:20 - I'm afraid that "medium ship", in international commerce, means something more substantial. With 4 meter limit on draft the canal cannot accommodate anything seagoing - that's the job of nearby ports of Gdunya and Gdansk.
@funtasta
@funtasta 2 місяці тому
Not true. The sea ships up to around 8000 DWT will be able to reach Elblag through this channel.
@wieczor89
@wieczor89 2 місяці тому
First realistic approach in comments - new channel is too shallow, past and present vessels movement didn't require such an investment. More efficient and needed might be setting sailing route through Vistula river from Gdańsk to Bydgoszcz / Solec Kujawski to distribute goods from Gdansk/Gdynia real seaports
@jmi5969
@jmi5969 2 місяці тому
@@funtasta This is it, small-scale local shipping while nearby existing ports can take anything that can cross the Baltic.
@cehaem2
@cehaem2 2 місяці тому
@@funtasta Meanswhile, Gdynia and Gdansk are far away from achieving max capacity....So, where's all the traffic at Elblag harbour?
@funtasta
@funtasta 2 місяці тому
So why Gdansk is still being extended? :) The main purpose of Elblag is supporting role to big Gdansk or Gdynia. Armatures of smaller ships can use cheaper harbor, or store load for longer time there. Simply a bit different clients can be serviced in Elblag.
@llew-AZ
@llew-AZ 2 місяці тому
That is some cool engineering! I never heard of the project. UKposts is a great source.
@PanProper
@PanProper 2 місяці тому
Na YT każdy dzień budowy jest uwieczniony. To chyba najbardziej udokumentowana budowa w historii...
@Archers2005
@Archers2005 2 місяці тому
My father who is from Elbląg was talking about it ever since I was born and probably before that too as the talks and the idea to build this was made well over 50 years ago. They started on the job 1 year before my father passed so he didn't witness the completion.
@Greg_Abandoned
@Greg_Abandoned 2 місяці тому
the date of opening (17th Sep) was carefully picked
@drsnova7313
@drsnova7313 2 місяці тому
It's infrastructure. It doesn't NEED to provide some return on investment. It just needs to be useful, which, clearly, it seems to be.
@Really250
@Really250 2 місяці тому
If it is useful it will by definition have an ROI. For example Reducing time = less travel time, quicker turn around time.
@moscuadelendaest
@moscuadelendaest 2 місяці тому
Theo thing is, it's not useful at all
@kendoluke809
@kendoluke809 2 місяці тому
@@moscuadelendaest Yup useless shit. For small yachts only.
@Mr_Topek
@Mr_Topek 2 місяці тому
​@@kendoluke809 There aren't really any other boats going there anyway. It serves its purpose.
@john_something_or_other
@john_something_or_other 2 місяці тому
@@moscuadelendaest It means fewer ships are reliant on Russian "co-operation". Do pay attention.
@ArturGranatyr
@ArturGranatyr 2 місяці тому
There are no different levels between lagoon and the Baltic see. It cannot be as the material itself did mention that lagoon connects naturally with the Baltic on the russian side. The locks are there to avoid to much salination of the lagoon.
@aoilpe
@aoilpe 2 місяці тому
You forget the influx of water by rivers…
@adamliske
@adamliske 2 місяці тому
And tides.
@aoilpe
@aoilpe 2 місяці тому
@@adamliske Tides are negligible in the Baltic Sea- except when winds come in the play…
@margo7059
@margo7059 2 місяці тому
Да, собственно по поводу засоленности лагуны российская сторона и возражала.
@callsigndd9ls897
@callsigndd9ls897 2 місяці тому
@@aoilpe The water level in the Baltic Sea can change by plus/minus 1 meter depending on the wind direction, and even more during a storm. Due to only a small breakthrough in the Russian part, the water level in the huge lagoon does not change as quickly as in the Baltic Sea, so a lock is required.
@Czeckie
@Czeckie 2 місяці тому
2:13 for the usual destination it's like 30-40km shorter. That's not worth mentioning. This is geopolitical project, no eventual cost savings entered the calculus
@flyingpanhandle
@flyingpanhandle 2 місяці тому
Investments by governments don't always need to make their money back. It's about what they enable. What does this one enable? Free passage of ships without interference from a foreign state who aren't the best neighbours. Whats the monetary value of that?
@dariusz.9119
@dariusz.9119 2 місяці тому
I wish they mentioned that in the video
@margo7059
@margo7059 2 місяці тому
Ещё интересно какой грузооборот у порта ))) Если для частных яхт роют канал за государственный счет, то )))
@garryferrington811
@garryferrington811 2 місяці тому
Nobody ever asks why freeways in the US don't pay for themselves. Although maybe they should.
@Angel9932
@Angel9932 2 місяці тому
@@garryferrington811 Freeways can increase economic activity which then increases tax revenue. Just because there are no tolls involved doesn't mean that the government doesn't see a benefit.
@GdzieJestNemo
@GdzieJestNemo 2 місяці тому
that's the plan, for now it's nowhere close to fulfilling that goal
@tosa305
@tosa305 2 місяці тому
Way to go Poland!!! I admire your strenght! Greetings from Finland🇵🇱🇫🇮!
@tilmanbenatzky3480
@tilmanbenatzky3480 2 місяці тому
The lock is largely intended to prevent salt water from the Baltic Sea from entering the lagoon.
@Gregowski
@Gregowski 2 місяці тому
Finally episode in Poland! Warsaw skyscrapers next?
@salsarriba5695
@salsarriba5695 2 місяці тому
better no... enough scandals for 1 country..
@varoonnone7159
@varoonnone7159 2 місяці тому
Your most famous buildings are concentration camps
@kacperabramczyk4257
@kacperabramczyk4257 2 місяці тому
@@varoonnone7159 That were built by the germans.
@user-nm6sp1eg5o
@user-nm6sp1eg5o 2 місяці тому
​@@varoonnone7159build by germans and filled by fench railways what prodditroffited by transporting jews to the camp for death. Btw your famous buildind notre dam cathedral burned because you cheap busterds hired few muslims to do Simple work. ..and Poland have the tallest sky scraper in EU.
@MartinMaarva
@MartinMaarva 2 місяці тому
@@varoonnone7159 How do you call a concentration camp in Poland?
@BartoshRPG
@BartoshRPG 2 місяці тому
Thank you for highlight this subject.
@patrykzar
@patrykzar 2 місяці тому
I live in Warsaw and seeing 7:59 this cityscape makes me really happy that despite the history Poland has managed to record an economic growth over the past 30 years, getting to the point we make multi billion investments and Become an attractive business hub for companies like Deloitte, Microsoft, Google etc.. I hope this had work won’t get ruined..
@Samuel_J1
@Samuel_J1 2 місяці тому
A very logical canal location. How easy/difficult will it be to make it bigger to suit large ships? And was the island designed to be a wildlife habitat or does it have another purpose?
@Deckzwabber
@Deckzwabber 2 місяці тому
It might just be a nature compensation measure. Either because of legal requirements, or because it unlocked additional subsidies. Large infrastructural projects are often required to 'offset' the ecological disturbance that they cause. Creating a new habitat could have been such an offset measure.
@Kuryux
@Kuryux 2 місяці тому
had to dump all that dirt somewhere aint it?
@czerskip
@czerskip 2 місяці тому
The location is illogical because literally nobody needs that canal. The only reason to build it was too steal public funds by the former criminal government.
@frisianmouve
@frisianmouve 2 місяці тому
It's a naturally occuring spit of land
@tjurzyk
@tjurzyk 2 місяці тому
Idea is that birds will nest on that island, and they needed to dump all that sand somewhere. There is a plan for a second island from deepening waterway to Elbląg port, at the moment there is legal battle about who should pay for it, local or central government. As for the size of canal itself, there is no need for bigger one, and likely never be as Elbląg port is rather small and expanding it would cost too much. Personally I would rather see those money spent on expanding port of Gdańsk, or building container terminal in Szczecin but on the other hand it may be needed for military use unfortunately.
@tomaszzakrzewski3790
@tomaszzakrzewski3790 2 місяці тому
Construction of this channel was a highly controversial topic in Poland. Elbląg is not significant small harbor. There are now already big modern ports nearby: Gdańsk and Gdynia that are on open sea. So, building that channel was more of a political manifestation than economically driven decision.
@user-io9pf9gf5g
@user-io9pf9gf5g 2 місяці тому
Pewnie masz racje, ale ten projekt pokazał że możemy brać się za duże przedsięwzięcia, kto wie jak patrzyło byśmy na CPK gdyby nie powstał ten kanał
@CryptocurrencyInsider
@CryptocurrencyInsider 2 місяці тому
Poland’s economy is only growing. They’ll need more ports.
@cyjanek_potasu_kcn4582
@cyjanek_potasu_kcn4582 2 місяці тому
​@@user-io9pf9gf5gto tak jakbyś pojechał teraz na stację benzynową, kupił 1000 litrów wysokooktanowej benzyny, a następnie rozlał ją całą na jakimś pustkowiu. Pokazuje to że możesz sobie na to pozwolić, ale również ujawnia że jesteś kretynem Przekopu przez mierzeję nie usprawiedliwia nic. Jest to tanie zagranie pod publiczkę, które wyrządziło, wyrządza i jeszcze wyrządzi mnóstwo szkód finansowych, środowiskowych i logistycznych
@karoltylke4220
@karoltylke4220 2 місяці тому
​@@user-io9pf9gf5g nie widze zadnego powiazania miedzy tym kanalem a CPK. skala obu jest nieporownywalna (kanal - 2mld zl, CPK i powiazane przedsiewziecia - ponad 200mld), a w Polsce istnieje juz masa znacznie wiekszych inwestycji infrastrukturalnych niz ten kanal.
@PanProper
@PanProper 2 місяці тому
Bzdury piszesz...Ciekawe... z głupoty czy z polecenia ?
@kacperslaczka6290
@kacperslaczka6290 2 місяці тому
To be fair: Lots of Poles were also opposed to this project, because since the beginning it was planned to be of such small size that wouldn't make it useful for transport. General idea obviously might be good, but the way it was planned makes it mostly waste of money, fortunately only $450 millions. Building bigger canal would make it an alternative to going through Russian waters, although at a higher cost. Still, making it wider is needed for this project to have any sense. It'd cost more, but even if it wouldn't bring enough profit to ever pay for itself, it's just about national safety, and canal is short enough that it would be relatively cheap, especially given that building such canals is cheaper in Poland than in Western Europe or US.
@cehaem2
@cehaem2 2 місяці тому
Jakie narodowe bezpieczenstwo? Przekop dla motorowek? Kolego, to byla kolejna okazja do wydojenia budzetu, dania kolesiom dobrej fuchy i przy okazji zaprezentowanie sie na zapleczu Tuska jako dobry wujek. Tymczasem 70 km dalej na zachod jest Port Gdanski...
@kacperslaczka6290
@kacperslaczka6290 2 місяці тому
@@cehaem2 W przypadku poszerzenia kanału moglibyśmy zdywersyfikować swoje porty morskie. Obecnie mamy 4 większe porty, Gdańsk (70 mln ton), Gdynia (20 mln ton), Świnoujście (20 mln ton), Szczecin (10 mln ton), jest jeszcze port Police w Szczecinie z niewielkim obrotem, i kilka innych niewielkich, np. Hel czy Elbląg. Z tych mniejszych portów Elbląg ma jeden z największych potencjałów jeżeli chodzi o położenie geograficzne i dość dużą ludność i kapitał na inwestycje. Gdybyśmy rozbudowali port w Elblągu I utrzymywali w nim większe obroty mielIbyśmy w razie np. akcji sabotażowych wymierzonych w nasze porty zagwarantowane większe bezpieczeństwo, tak samo w trakcie wojny. W takiej sytuacji bardzo dobrze byłoby mieć kanał w tamtym miejscu. Nie jest to najważniejsza kwestia bezpieczeństwa narodowego, nawet nie top 10, ale za parę miliardów złotych inwestycji rozłożonych na kilkanaście lub więcej lat (tj. kilkadziesiąt milionów zł rocznie) możemy zrobić inwestycję, która może zarobić na swoje utrzymanie, a przy tym przyczynia się do poprawy bezpieczeństwa zaopatrzenia.
@cehaem2
@cehaem2 2 місяці тому
@@kacperslaczka6290 Port Gdanski ma ma lata niewykorzystane moce przeladunkowe. Po Elblagu dalej hula wiatr...A jakie najbardziej na wschod polozony Elblag ma "potencjal", tego chyba nie wie sam autor. Tym bardziej, ze za rogiem jest Gdansk. Projekt byl czysto polityczny.
@Premislao89
@Premislao89 2 місяці тому
We have this problem that many people will see even the best idea as the worst because the wrong politician proposed it instead of just thinking what's best for the country. Currently the new coalition is looking for reasons not to build atomic power plants and air cargo hub that would bring us a ton of money. For me such actions are treason and I hope one day they will be tried for opposing such beneficial developments.
@neon825
@neon825 2 місяці тому
​@@Premislao89 No one is stopping atom don't lie. The current rulling party is the only one in recent history that builded big infrastructure projects. Look at the state of Polish roads before 2007 and after 2016 or Gazoport w Świnoujściu that Pis renamed in 2016. What did Pis build beside this przekop/rów? They had 8 years.
@HwanSangHyang
@HwanSangHyang 2 місяці тому
There is simillar canal in South Korea. Because the mouth of the Han River was the border with North Korea, Ships can't enter Seoul directly. Although there was controversy, Korean government completed a canal called 'Ara Canal' in 2012. However, because the port city of Incheon exists next to Seoul, not many ships enter Seoul through the canal there.
@elfarcherdv
@elfarcherdv 2 місяці тому
I really feel like rail investment between Elblag (sorry not fining the a) and Gdansk (not n) would have been a far more cost effective solution to their problems. A solitary port doesn't require a $450M infrastructure investment to save when there is an alternative 20 miles away
@callsigndd9ls897
@callsigndd9ls897 2 місяці тому
This canal is not only used for the transport of goods, but also for boat tourism. In the long term, it will bring a boost to the city when sailors from western Poland, Germany, Denmark or Sweden are no longer forced to sail through Russian territory.
@TomaszOrynski
@TomaszOrynski 2 місяці тому
​@@callsigndd9ls897Boat tourists were never forced to go through Russian territory. There are two inland waterways suitable of taking even larger yachts connecting Elbląg to the sea - Szkaprawa and Nogat rivers are both navigable, they are second class waterways with over 2 metre depth. Nogat route is longer but allows to visit Malbork with it's world famous castle. Both connect to Wisła, which is the biggest Polish river.
@PanProper
@PanProper 2 місяці тому
​@@TomaszOrynskiciekawe czemu teraz wolą korzystać z przekopu ?
@TomaszOrynski
@TomaszOrynski 2 місяці тому
@@PanProperKto woli korzystać z przekopu? Kajakarze? :D
@PanProper
@PanProper 2 місяці тому
@@TomaszOrynski Żeglarze i motorowodniacy...
@worldatmyfeet7898
@worldatmyfeet7898 2 місяці тому
Another weekly banger from the B1M once again.
@Vaidehi2002
@Vaidehi2002 2 місяці тому
It was good but definitely not a banger 👍
@pkaczyn
@pkaczyn 2 місяці тому
There are other similar story-projects: to connect the island of Uznam and the town of Świnoujście with with the rest of Poland, reunited at last. And in Łodź, Poland's 4th largest city located in the middle, there is a tunnel built to connect two different rail networks... an overlooked project since 1918... when the country was reunited from three parts.
@koshersalaami
@koshersalaami 2 місяці тому
Nice of you to explain canal locks to those unfamiliar with canals. The same system is used on small canals built to carry mule-towed barges in the US in the 19th century, like the C & O (Chesapeake and Ohio) Canal, where the locks still work.
@moodlampActual
@moodlampActual 2 місяці тому
Honestly it does seem small for a canal. I doubt this buries their reliance on kaliningrad. Why didn't they make it much larger to begin with?
@aoilpe
@aoilpe 2 місяці тому
Not needed- no big ports…
@M3rl1n177
@M3rl1n177 2 місяці тому
Because this canal is for small and medium sized ships. Our ports responsible for container ship handling are located in the west
@jestestuman
@jestestuman 2 місяці тому
There was huge discussion about this project in Poland. This was one of points against project in this form.
@maciejadamfiszer3525
@maciejadamfiszer3525 2 місяці тому
Because it opens Vistula river directly to Baltic ports. Big ships don't fit that river.
@shycracker
@shycracker 2 місяці тому
​@@maciejadamfiszer3525i was wondering why so many comments asking about it's size without firsy looking at map at see how big the river it was supposed to be connected to
@Tiax776
@Tiax776 2 місяці тому
Good job, Poland. If I had the money, I'd come and visit your lovely country one day.
@qzg7857
@qzg7857 2 місяці тому
Its not that expensive (as other European countries)
@user-jn1tr8mo3g
@user-jn1tr8mo3g 2 місяці тому
You won't be disappointed.
@3komma141592653
@3komma141592653 2 місяці тому
Danzig is around the corner, so well worth it.
@mibars
@mibars 2 місяці тому
Good news! If you want to visit Europe and are on a budget then Poland is a way to go!
@bengagnon2894
@bengagnon2894 2 місяці тому
Full of fascists and neo-nazis at the government level. The dream country.
@GreedoShot
@GreedoShot 2 місяці тому
crazy that they did all this for less than 16% the cost of JPMorgan's newest office building
@Scapestoat
@Scapestoat 2 місяці тому
I love how explaining a simple, widely used thing as a "lock" (we call it a "sluis" in the Netherlands!) is needed. To the Dutch, it is just something nearly everyone knows. You did a very good job of it! The swinging bridges are also quite common here, especially in city centres. But for an out of the way project like this it feels like it would make more sense to go for a very high un-openable bridge (on mounds of earth on either side). Since it's not a harbour area for loading and unloading ships, the space on either side isn't needed for anything else. You could even make them slightly bigger, and have a nice park on the rises, with maybe a cafe on one of them. :) I am sure ecologists can help ensure that that doesn't negatively impact the local environment, and I am sure that a bird sanctuary can be formed on the side that doesn't have a cafe.
@t-and-p
@t-and-p 2 місяці тому
If it's ok to ask, is "sluis" pronounced "sloos"? The reason I ask is that, on the canal system in the UK, we call the installation itself that allows a vessel to move between water levels a "lock", but the little mechanisms that open to physically change the water level inside the lock "sluice gates" or "sluices". It'd be really interesting if that linked the Dutch name to the British name 😊
@Scapestoat
@Scapestoat 2 місяці тому
@@t-and-p Hello! I'm not sure if English has an "ui" sound. It is one of those Dutch "we need more vowels, so lets just mash two together and give it a sound that isn't quite what you'd expect" double-vowels. But I can tell you it is not the same sound as in English. However, they both have the same origin; the latin word "exclusus"; to exclude. English language etymology sites tend to favour French as the source. But since in old French it is "escluse", and the earliest Dutch use of such a word was "sluse" (borrowed from French), later changed to "Sluis", and seeing that around that time English adopted the "Sluice" spelling, it seems likely that they got it from Dutch engineers working in England (who could do wonders, like pump out moors with windmills, that the English could only dream of). I fear I sound pedantic when I say this, but as for the naming; the whole thing is a sluice, and the sluice-gates are simply the gates on the sluice. So you'd be accurate calling it a Lock or a Sluice. A Dutch person would call the gates "sluice doors" (sluis deuren). :) And as for Dutch influenced English words; I would guess that about half of them are. The rest are French or Norse. :D
@mattclarke3621
@mattclarke3621 2 місяці тому
Glad to see someone else telling the Russians to get stuffed and doing something positive for themselves at the same time..
@badAim2
@badAim2 2 місяці тому
So here's a thing not mentioned in the video: It is true that our government spent so much money on it that it may return in 650-1000 years, but guess what else is the problem? It's the port in Elbląg. In order for everything to work, the port as well as the river that ships could use to reach it have to be refitted for bigger ships and just to work in general. And you see.. That's something the city and local government have to do because the government said it's their area, their job. City of Elbląg as well as Voivodeship administration don't have this much money to make it happen. And that's not all... Almost 50% of the area around the port and river where work must be done is in private hands, only 25-30% is owned by the town/local gov and the rest, 25% is own by the state. This creates a huge problem. Government said they will donate to the city 100M PLN for 51% share in the port (so it's no longer administrated by the town) which obviously the town doesn't want to agree on. This way we have something that may never work as it should. Imma skip stuff like the lack of interest in sending by ship anything over there, horrible solution of swing bridges etc. The only good thing is just that we are free of Russian bs. Was it worth it? Dunno, maybe... Maybe not
@TomaszOrynski
@TomaszOrynski 2 місяці тому
They would also have to raise viaduct that crosses the river, otherwise bigger ships could only call at the first part of the port.
@shotime95
@shotime95 2 місяці тому
Way to go Poland! 🇰🇷 ❤🇵🇱
@ThePaciorr
@ThePaciorr 2 місяці тому
cabbage bro
@Artisjohny
@Artisjohny 2 місяці тому
Poland is becoming strong and economicaly powerful. Love That.
@Tarets
@Tarets 2 місяці тому
As a Pole all I can say is: XD
@margo7059
@margo7059 2 місяці тому
😹😹👍
@Artisjohny
@Artisjohny 2 місяці тому
@@Tarets Why? You aint pround how your country is thriving?
@TomaszOrynski
@TomaszOrynski 2 місяці тому
@@Artisjohny it is strong and economically powerful. That's why it can afford to waste money on such useless projects like this.
@Tony-.
@Tony-. 2 місяці тому
A very interesting project, and this is the first time I’ve heard about it, I was really surprised
@srennielsen4545
@srennielsen4545 2 місяці тому
I was there in the summer of 2023. The canal is done very nicely and has some “wow” factor to it. Quite impressive. Our first stay in poland, driving from Denmark.
@KeanoMUFC1
@KeanoMUFC1 2 місяці тому
Thank you for the more objective look on this topic!
@richyzig
@richyzig 2 місяці тому
Thank you, another really well made video.
@silviodc1309
@silviodc1309 2 місяці тому
Why is the water level different on both sides? Isn't the lagoon connected to the sea on the russian side?
@justliberty4072
@justliberty4072 2 місяці тому
Every river that empties to the sea is connected to the sea. And every river that connects to the sea is at a higher level than the sea, if you go back upstream a few km. This lagoon is, in that sense, like a big river. It is fed upstream by streams, rivers, and runoff.
@TheCountess666
@TheCountess666 2 місяці тому
my guess would be because the open area is too small to allow all water needed to equalise the difference between high and low tide through every 6 hours.
@gayprepperz6862
@gayprepperz6862 2 місяці тому
Way to go Poland 👍👍👍
@tomryner5830
@tomryner5830 2 місяці тому
I need to go to Bydgoszcz soon! We Love Poland 🇵🇱 . Not mainly because of my wife’s ancestry but because of the people, food and Pivo!
@rael5469
@rael5469 2 місяці тому
For God sake why wouldn't they make the canal deep enough right from the start......when it is starting out from scratch????? Unbelievable.
@JohnSmith-yv6eq
@JohnSmith-yv6eq 2 місяці тому
testing the waters???
@rael5469
@rael5469 2 місяці тому
@@JohnSmith-yv6eq Yes but they already had all of the men and equipment in place.....doing the digging....building the lock. I can't get over the fact that they wasted the opportunity to do it right the first time. Now it will cost WAY more to correct the first design.
@nexor7809
@nexor7809 2 місяці тому
@@rael5469 its because of the environment
@XXLPIakat
@XXLPIakat 2 місяці тому
Poland wouldn't have to build a Canal if Königsberg was returned to its rightful owner and not have been ethnically cleansed by the Soviets.
@grisza77
@grisza77 Місяць тому
Really? Check germany's effort to block off Świnoujście port.
@colinscutt5104
@colinscutt5104 2 місяці тому
Great piece of foresight well done Poland , Solidarity
@stuartarestad7768
@stuartarestad7768 2 місяці тому
I try to learn something new everyday. I never heard of the country Kaliningrad or the Vistula Canal until watching this video. A nice video. Thanks for sharing.
@kreiseltower
@kreiseltower 2 місяці тому
it isn't a country. It is a city or let's say county. A Russian enclave
@jakehowie442
@jakehowie442 2 місяці тому
Why did they not build a wide, deeper canal initially for larger cargo ships. Also raising water level seems time consuming
@TomaszOrynski
@TomaszOrynski 2 місяці тому
because there is no port capable of taking wide, larger cargo ships. This canal leads to an insignificant river port.
@Macen
@Macen 2 місяці тому
The lagoon is shallow, cant handle large cargo ships
@96SN95
@96SN95 2 місяці тому
How is it the lagoon is at such a different elevation from the sea, needing locks at the polish canal, being that the two are connected?
@przemekelac9356
@przemekelac9356 2 місяці тому
A storm from the north raises the sea by about 1 meter.
@MustadMarine
@MustadMarine 2 місяці тому
Nice construction. The lock is to reduce current flow interfering with ship transit, I'm sure. Otherwise, it would not be necessary due to the sea level equilibrium on both sides.
@Natediggetydog
@Natediggetydog 2 місяці тому
This wouldn’t be an issue if they’d just give Königsberg back to the Germans
@dsmith8104
@dsmith8104 Місяць тому
Just give it back to Poland they owned it first 😂
@michaelvalor9480
@michaelvalor9480 14 днів тому
Or Lithuania. Or, since there's still some prejudice towards them, Roma
@user-fw6kz1kc4n
@user-fw6kz1kc4n 2 місяці тому
Good for Poland. Saves time, cash and you keep control of your own shipping. Nothing wrong with that in my opinion.
@namyzarc6269
@namyzarc6269 2 місяці тому
How on earth is the water level different when there's an opening to the ocean only 30 km away from the canal?
@jamescole3152
@jamescole3152 2 місяці тому
Excellent! Tides but do the Russians have locks? I don't think so.
@marcmcreynolds2827
@marcmcreynolds2827 2 місяці тому
Even a relatively small marsh throttled by an ocean inlet will see a significant time lag between water levels. For a straight-through canal, that can mean a strong current, persistent silt buildup, etc.
@przemekelac9356
@przemekelac9356 2 місяці тому
A storm from the north raises level by 90 cm relative to the lagoon!
@lylestavast7652
@lylestavast7652 2 місяці тому
Had no idea this situation even existed ! Anything to open sea access is probably a good thing both short and long term.
@bratbrata4974
@bratbrata4974 2 місяці тому
Imagine that you live with someone in an apartment. And this person blocks you from using the part of the apartment that you own. What are you doing? You take a hammer and hammer down the door. And that's exactly what we did. We have opened up new possibilities.
@brsrc759
@brsrc759 2 місяці тому
I don't understand the point of the lock. If they just leave the channel open the water levels will just equalize
@Roly679
@Roly679 2 місяці тому
Does appear to be quite a lot to spend when there the portsof Gdynia and Gdansk are only 60km away that can take big ships. And other internal canals go to Elblag anyway.
@jammiefortier1480
@jammiefortier1480 2 місяці тому
if it allows military craft to transit then it is worth the cost.
@angelm.gutierrez359
@angelm.gutierrez359 2 місяці тому
Freedom is priceless ❤
@dgillies5420
@dgillies5420 2 місяці тому
4:30 is an outstanding video sequence of the ocean buffeting the breakwaters while the area inside still as ice. I understand that it's probably 100% shut off from the ocean at this point but with only a small opening I think you can guess that the small wave will not make much of an impact when it expands into this breakwater area.
@victorlopez3665
@victorlopez3665 2 місяці тому
that canal was built for military intentions and is just a bonus that small cargo vessels can fit as well
@rlbk3649
@rlbk3649 2 місяці тому
if its for small cargo vessels that waht military intentions you are talking about? military kayaks ??
@victorlopez3665
@victorlopez3665 2 місяці тому
frigates, destroyers, corvettes, every other vessel smaller than a carrier@@rlbk3649
@bartekd9885
@bartekd9885 2 місяці тому
Just to give some more information - it's not like Elbląg is a huge port, it's rather on the smallest scale. But still canal gives some more oportunities.
@FR-PL-UA-WARSZAWA-FUVI
@FR-PL-UA-WARSZAWA-FUVI 2 місяці тому
The Poles knew long before 2022 that no free country should depend on Russian gas. Therefore, they also built a LNG harbor and now get their supply from the Emirates and the USA. The Yamal gas pipe is closed, but not the one connected to Norway.
@Fanro3
@Fanro3 2 місяці тому
yk that exporting gas through pipes instead of ships is not only much cheaper, but also much more environmentally friendly. I'm not saying nations should completely depend on it, but declining an offer like that is plain stupid
@kindlingking
@kindlingking 2 місяці тому
Jesus Christ, do you people hear yourself? "No free country should depend on Russian gas" yes, they should depend on American gas which is many times more expensive and transported in much less ecological manner. Ask Germany if that worked out for them.
@soloroy6020
@soloroy6020 Місяць тому
I've been there 2 weeks ago with my camper van. What a beautiful canal. Well done Poland.
@musFuzZ
@musFuzZ 2 місяці тому
"each block had a hole in the middle to reduce water pressure and increase stability throughout the wall" Can anyone link to/explain how these blocks work? i'm very confused as to how the hole in the blocks help anything 4:21
@sapujapu9959
@sapujapu9959 2 місяці тому
After some googling, no paper I've found offered any further explanation on why the hole in Xblocplus 'reduces wave pressure' on the blocks below, but the second major reason for the hole is that 'it makes the pick-up, transport and placement of the block much easier - the application of the blocks is thus substantially quicker and safer.' ; ' This hole is used for fast and very efficient placement with a clamp.'
@pikeyMcBarkin
@pikeyMcBarkin 2 місяці тому
Another great video! Thanks everyone involved!
@ADVRaiderKTM
@ADVRaiderKTM 2 місяці тому
Can someone explain why the bay and the lagoon have different water levels? The lagoon is connected directly to the Baltic Sea, at which point the water level becomes in the lagoon than the sea?
@nikobellic570
@nikobellic570 2 місяці тому
Sea levels rise and fall with the tides. Perhaps they want a fixed water level inland
@tessjuel
@tessjuel 2 місяці тому
I don't know the details, there may be other reasons for the gates. But although the tidal effect in the Baltic Sea is only a few cm it's still a lot. The Wisła Lagoon has an area of 834 km² so for each cm of tide almost 1.4 million m²/hour has to pass through the two canals on average.
@williamlloyd3769
@williamlloyd3769 2 місяці тому
Without the locks, as the tides rose and fell in the Baltic Sea, it would cause a current through the narrow opening which would be dangerous to shipping.
@tesos2866
@tesos2866 2 місяці тому
The water level varies on both sides due to wind, tides and currents, the loch raise or lowers in both directions as needed. Also if they did not have lochs the current through the channel would be very strong, swapping directon with the tides, navigational and erosion problems would become issues. There are no pumps or seperate sources of water needed because it is just equalizing the water level depending on which direction the ship is heading.
@TheRoweros
@TheRoweros 2 місяці тому
​Well sea rise in that area is 2cm ​@@williamlloyd3769
@danex8301
@danex8301 2 місяці тому
I'm impressed how well you pronounced Elbląg. About the project, many said that it's a waste of money because Elbląg isn't an important port. However if we suppose the canal is useful, it should've been bigger to allow bigger ships
@True_NOON
@True_NOON 2 місяці тому
6:46 true but it is an 'avoid the enemy' project then it being usable at an only 425mill pricetag then thats preatty good use of cash in my opinion
@AndresRamirez-fi5uw
@AndresRamirez-fi5uw 2 місяці тому
I assumed the sea and the lagoon would both be sea level as they are connected further up the spit in Kaliningrad
@mr.v3061
@mr.v3061 2 місяці тому
As a Belgian, i am getting more and more impressed by my Polish friends. I'm happy you guys are taking on a leader's role instead of following what other's tell you to do.
@PanProper
@PanProper 2 місяці тому
Po zmianie rządu twoja radość stała się nieaktualna...
@mururoa7024
@mururoa7024 2 місяці тому
It's interesting to note how most mega projects in Europe cost far less than if they were build in the US. One has to wonder why.
@BB-hx4mj
@BB-hx4mj 2 місяці тому
One word - outsourcing
@uhohhotdog
@uhohhotdog 2 місяці тому
They know what they’re doing
@Septimus_ii
@Septimus_ii 2 місяці тому
Not always
@kaseyc5078
@kaseyc5078 2 місяці тому
Higher wages in the US.
@dx-ek4vr
@dx-ek4vr 2 місяці тому
A huge reason for it is a combination of Bureaucracy and something called "NIMBY" or "Not in My Backyard".
@ClingyParasite
@ClingyParasite 2 місяці тому
The Polish sure are brilliant people, making such a cool looking and functioning canal
@travelchoice89
@travelchoice89 2 місяці тому
Understanding the geopolitical implications of Russia's attempt to block this canal is crucial, and this video offers a comprehensive explanation.
@oseqq
@oseqq 2 місяці тому
As a Pole from the region of the canal: building a new cargo train line or extending existent between Gdynia (major port hub; 90km away) and Elbląg (city behind the canal) would be faaar more cost effective. The project was more of manifestation of political will, then economical decision.
@cehaem2
@cehaem2 2 місяці тому
PiS wanted to piss off Tusk in his own backyard and get political backing on a long neglected area. Elblag has always suffered from being overshadowed by Tri-City's presence around the corner.
The Insane Scale of Europe’s New Mega-Tunnel
27:51
The B1M
Переглядів 13 млн
Europe's Megaproject to Replace Russian Railways
11:22
The B1M
Переглядів 1 млн
Самый большой бутер в столовке! @krus-kos
00:42
Кушать Хочу
Переглядів 6 млн
"Поховали поруч": у Луцьку попрощались із ДВОМА Героями 🕯🥀 #герої #втрати
00:15
Телеканал Конкурент TV - новини Луцька та Волині
Переглядів 91 тис.
Why Hundreds Of U.S. Banks Are At Risk Of Failing
14:19
CNBC
Переглядів 192 тис.
How the UN is Holding Back the Sahara Desert
11:57
Andrew Millison
Переглядів 11 млн
The Secret Security of America's London Embassy
12:33
The B1M
Переглядів 1,4 млн
This is The World's Most Remote Infrastructure Project
32:14
The B1M
Переглядів 2,1 млн
The $3BN Plan to Connect Malaysia to Singapore
7:32
The B1M
Переглядів 187 тис.
Flying to RUSSIA on a STOLEN AIRPLANE & INTERROGATED at the Border!
33:01
Why Japan is Hollowing Out a Mountain
8:05
The B1M
Переглядів 2,9 млн
What Happens If You Jump Into A Black Hole?
17:25
PBS Space Time
Переглядів 102 тис.
Самый большой бутер в столовке! @krus-kos
00:42
Кушать Хочу
Переглядів 6 млн