Raphael Treza can you please share a link for the qawwali "nukta yar parhaya"

Raphael Treza Far the best video ever made concerning Gypsy culture. Thank you.

Yasin Shah

Tiger Spirit i agree it is the only real documentary on the internet. Good job.

Raphael Treza Just fantastic! Such a slick, classy production. Thank you, Raphael Treza.

😄

💜💙💚💛❤..I love ur comment bro... u have lovable good heart...❤💛💚💙💜

you are welcome again any time for visit India :)

Thank you for telling this story. It reminds me of eerie and unlikely things that happened to me too. Once a Gypsy played the Bach Chaconne on his violin for me, in an attic in Hamburg. Never forgot.

I`ll bet you came back as a vegan ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Yes and ditto USA and Brazil

If trsvel there as a man, sure. Not recommended to women though

@@alissaa2809 yeah for a.Woman it's too dangerous

@@yasirkareem4392 Goa is ok and not dangerous

❤ from India......!!! yes it is very much cultural....but nothing worry to understand..!

Совершенно верно подмечено! Эти Цыгане и Индусы ведут себя как дети. Они не повзрослели. Они в школу не ходят. Толку от них - 0. Во взрослую жизнь они так ни когда и не войдут. Будут кочевать как бомжи пока не сдохнут. Классная жизнь правда? Толи дело эти "дикие" Европейцы Американцы Азиаты - работают люди день ночь , двигают вперед науку технологии, прогресс , ядерную физику , ракеры запускают в космос итд .. - ДИКАРИ =)))

Вы пишите про юность, эти же пляшут до старости.

бедные ласточки😥

@@KmksKmks-yw4lk вечные дети)))

Зачем ловили ласточек? Что с ними делали?

Привет из ТВЕРИ...😊👋👋👋

This is 8 years old. These are the future. If you know anything about climate collapse. ❤ and they are dancers and singers!!!! What a beautiful future it will be with them leading it. ❤

​@@robinflach4572r

Jesteś obywatelem świata pozdrawiam z Polski🌹

Overthrow your government and form a democracy already like adults.

Lol, true

What do you mean? Please elaborate.

Цыгане выходцы из Индии. Они и похожи: черные, песни и танцы похожи. Потом они ращбреличь по всему миру. Раньше к нам в Казахстан Алматы тоже много цыган ходило, приставали, просили милостыню. Сейчас слава Аллаху нет. Зато таджиков как собак нерезанных: Россияне выгнали 1 млн таджикских гастарбайтеров, так они пришли к нам в Казахстан, Алматы, ходят здоровые мужики толпами, пристают к женщинам и детям , просят деньги. Почему не борются за свои права и жизнь в своей стране? А еще непонятно откуда, много черных, грязных негров?

And a film maker who doesn't push his opinion.

Привет из Твери... Я случайно нашла этот фильм... сейчас буду его смотреть с помощью нейронной сети,которая мне переведет текст на русский язык . Вы меня заинтересовали своим ответом и я точно хочу посмотреть что в этом фильме ☝😊

I would too. It's art, and just to be able to share the story of such people with my kids and grandkids would be amazing.

I love it, I’ve watched it so many times, I want to visit them!

U WANNA BUY DVD????

You can live a magical life too. Create it.

If we go back to homesteading, we would be happy as well.

I wholeheartedly agree!!! I have never seen a people so beautiful and happy!! Even the tribe that doesn’t bathe for religious reasons! Sure, their hair was dusty and bit matted but they still shined with a beautiful enthusiasm for life!! I am sure they have suffered tragedies in their lives just like everyone else but they don’t let that stop them from living!! Everything they do seems to be some sort of celebration of life, even their clothing! They are simply a stunning people and an excellent example that you don’t need a giant pile of money to live a rich, colorful, interesting and happy life!! Cheers

i was thinking all the same things...not only are they happy and beautiful, but there is such a great confidence in all of them. its like self consciousness doesnt exist in their culture.

@@kristimcgowandarkoscellard3126 Well said Kristi

@@billmurray1431 Thank you 🙏 Bill. I was stunned by this wonderful documentary! Knowing that a people like this exist in the world of today makes my heart smile and gives me hope maybe one day we can all have such a beautiful enthusiasm for life!! Cheers

At least someone sees the truth

I’m so sick of the BBC’s trash

Bingo....you get it....

Yes. I also live in rajasthan village & this is a rare video i can relate to our life & felt authenticity.

@Richard Carpenter If I was a snowflake I would be defending the BBC, what a fucking moron and do not waste my time with a response you cretinous fool

Philipina is Tagalog, mahal Kita

India loves you brother. You’re always welcome to our beautiful country we respect you🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳❤️❤️❤️😍😍😍

​@@Ok-up7tyyou have good heart and wise people welcome here in europa

Can’t understand why you did a research for your gypsi roots, now you know it for your whole life and you live in shame 😂

Welcome to Punjab Rajasthan 🤗

Пока я читал твой комментарий, у меня пропали часы. У тебя правильный ДНК 😂

me too

4:22

I'm in a blessed marriage- it's great!

That’s what i thought ...

Me too

They aren't tribals.

@@mangopudding5979 They are. Everybody is a tribal person in a tribe.

@@Wuehewnqnejejwebdbd they are not. You don't know anything.

@@mangopudding5979 can you please explain for us 'stupid' people?

@@brimleyhillmassive they are Kalbeliyas, they are Gypsies, Gypsies aren't tribals.

Are you a Romani brother?

Ukraine, where they lynch romanis

Beautiful. Well said.

Not true Frank. You can be free and liberate others by doing it wherever you are! It just takes courage and imagination. Much love.

Yes, Frank.....very well said!!Blessings

Agree

Amen to that Frank, I kept thinking about the joy in which they live and here I am in America living with all the luxuries I can possess wishing for a simple life like theirs, how ironic....

It came out amazing. I just watched it. It's big deal. You will see more like-minded visitors shivaji.

तुम सुंदर लोग हो! दिल का गुप्त व्यक्तित्व सबसे महत्वपूर्ण सौंदर्य है और होठों पर मुस्कान किसी भी चीज़ से बेहतर है।

@@EcoSpeeder that's good to know Michael, have a blessed day 🤝

Soy gitano español una etnia que proviene de la india hace más de 700 años

💩💩💩💩

Are you Naga?

@@Arthurian. No.... I'm not from the Northeast

@@Arthurian. himalayan is not north east

@@akapasokopo Exactly and he said he is NOT from the northeast.

Keith Bentley you are welcome always 😊

come to South India. Kerala.

+panisher worst place don't know Malayalam get ridiculed

clone jr ? ???they speak English as well.

no we dont.

Frfr

YES! so its not only me. Thanks for confirming

As a spaniard, they look very similar to us, specially the spanish gypsies, which we have lots of here in Spain. It leaves me wondering about the gypsies' history.

@@mallobag yes definitely

@@AmiPropagator ⁸

Both aspects are equally necessary!

Best thing is , they are very happy with their life. 🤩😌

@@amalprabhatkujur9899 NO bbc only show negative side of india always

Nope!... I belong to tribal community of Jharkhand. Atleast basic things are necessary. Rest is okay. We people can live with those odd. We have our own majboories.

Can you live this kind of life deprived from lots my resources?

Wow, how very wonderful to find out this interesting info, regarding part of your family's ancestry. I'm sure your family are beautiful looking peoples. Rajasthan is a truly historic, majestic & stunning region in Northern India. I also have some ancestry from Northern India & Rajasthan. I'm told by many South Asian/Indian peoples, that i look very Kalashi or Kashmiri, hence my name here. The Pakistani peoples tell me i look like their peoples, especially from the North of Pakistan, so who knows! haha It's just nice to know where some of our ancestors come from. I'm ethnically diverse, so it's really good to know & be able to put some pieces of the puzzle together. I'm proud to know & i'm sure you are too. Take care.

Antient slavs/serbs where in north india and later some agaun with Alexander the great. North indians 100 milions of them have slavic r1a dnk. Also serbian language is most similar to sanskrit

@@NB-kq7lm Residents of India do not have "Russian DNA." Indians are not descendants of the Russians. Please don't spread false information. Study from reliable sources

@@applepie5921 who mentioned russians. North indians have r1a halppgrouo like most of slavs or what was old name for all slavs serbs or sorbs. In india they called them sharbs

@@NB-kq7lm Serbs have nothing to do with India. Majority of Serbs are not even genetically slavic (r1a) and ancient indo- iranians were from eurasian steppe region. Greeks had never controlled large territory of modern day India and their (greeks) kingdom in india were completely destroyed by indo-scythians

Pacero i agree, you need a medal for this great work

I agree, really nicely made it, he is a good movie maker.... but, need some energy in his voice hehe

I'm telling you🙌🏻🌻🙌🏻👌🏻

I had some bad experiences with indians that just made me sad ... it’s like your r not Indian you don’t count, I can’t even get myself to watch Bollywood any more, for some reason watching this helped cobra brought me here 😔

@@dannym6552 ok..then why u nagging here..👀😒🙏

@@dannym6552 What do you mean by you don't count?

@@dannym6552 its possible that most ppl you interacted with, are seeiing a white dude for the first time and dont feel comfortable right away. As an indian who lived in AZ NY Australia, it happens everywhere. And thats allright.

@@dannym6552 Many city people aren't that friendly, the real India is in the villages man. I'm sorry for what ever your had to face for being a white guy. This happens for anyone anywhere around the world.

Save

They’re happy because the heart of human happiness is living with a community that loves eachother and has a real culture (not corporate bs masquerading as culture) Individualism and corporatism has ruined the west and is ruining the developing world. Accepting everyone and loving everyone in communities is the only way we can be truly happy

Ze hahahahahaha you're Dog, American say NO😂

Oh wow you are an Indian? So am I.

Yes Sir, the music used within this documentary is amazing! I have watched this countless times & every time i watch it, i dance. I love it & i love the Rajasthani Kalbeliya peoples. Their culture & way of life is priceless. My best wishes to you.

I'm Russian and I don't know why I'm watching this video, but I like it.👍👍👍

Eh I feel like Europeans dance more

@@AKu-xs5vg no we don't unfortunately. India is magic

No we don't.

India is as diverse as Europe, maybe even more. So while Kalbeliya dance a lot, many other ethnicities don’t dance outside of functions or dance less

it is not something alien to see a indian, I hope?

How? Please elaborate.

Привет Вам из Твери👋👋👋😊... я там живу.. именно из моего города тот самый Афанасий Никитин 👋👋😊😊

28:28 famous moment

Yes bro Roma people are our brothers we Indians love you

Roma's are Indian tribe too.💖so much unfold history...

@@karmandhillon5044 we're all one tribe. all of us. Amazing documentary

@@raybusa3211 gypsy are from scityians turcic iranic aryans from middle east went in iran steppe after in india back to europe with turcic selciuk india is not they home but israel est iran iran central asia east europe where scityians they father settlet dachae and masaget

@@raybusa3211 india south east asia is only cousin not brothers central asia middle east is origins of gypsy semitics

Меня тоже, с одной стороны, из побаиваюсь, так как они ну очень загадочны! С другой стороны очаровательны и очень берегут каждого из них, это поражает.

I stopped watching him,once he revealed his leftist liberalism stand......to bad...

Ye Luo agree.

Even I as an Indian did not know how beautiful these people are India is surely a diverse country

It is breathtaking .I watched this Documentary 3 times and it gives me a sense how beautiful humans are when they are not controlled by an evil mind controlling System that we have now in most of the world!Yes evil mind controlling that uses humans as parasitic hosts to suck the life out of them.Basically this describes life in the Western world that charges rent,tax and debt to enslaves the people and that destroys the Planet in the process.The ones that do that consider them-self superior but are in realitythe dumbest of the dumbest without any understanding and wisdom.

​@@ashimohta6279 ROTFLOL IDK exactly where you were living but if have a chance then take a look at your surroundings within 10 KM to know more.

Can you name a few documentaries that are disrespectful to the locals?

This must have been a privilage to join those beautifull people on their yourney!

♥️

Its called no shower.

@@fatloser7244 dumb racist..

@@joaninhassassina Mean

Indian is a nationality not an ethnicity. It's a highly mixed place.

These people are not Indians. They're of a different ancestry. Their skin is much darker than the average Indian

HotSabta they are Rajasthanis who are fair if you will see South Indians and up Bihar jharkhand oddisa Bengal Maharashtra other north Indians states people are as dark as coal

My mother and Sister have the eyes of a deer (black)... I and My father have the Tiger's Eye. Brown

@Chaudhry Vikrant ror Wrong and wrong, We didn't come from Central Asia or from Europe, if anything North Indians have only migrated outside, out to middle east and also to central Asia, the Mittani tribe of Middle east was one such, besides the findings in Harappan sites like Kalibanga and others, shows the same DNA we have now. thus confirming we just moved from Indus valley to Ganga valley in the east. and the people in the Indus valley were the same as us. Stop already with this Aryan Invasion theory.

Helen Alford Thank you for saying that. So many view my people as evil, not realizing the position they forced us into in the first place.

Your points are irrelevant, especially because immigration has nothing to do with this. All humans deserve safety, decent living conditions and the right to practice their culture and be with their family - that's a basic agreement that civilised people have come to. Roma people are not separate from this. Quite honestly when people use the term 'integrated' for people who have abandoned their community and culture it sounds a lot like fascism.

I live in a neighbourhood in the UK where about 70% of the population are Muslims and the other 30% are Slovak Roma. Not saying everyone always gets on perfectly, but for the most part it works. We had a street party last week with games for the kids, I know nearly everyone in my street. My little stepson plays out every day and we don't worry about him. I know that people are just people, we have different cultures but most people in the end just want to be happy and have a peaceful life with their family. That understanding and being able to live in peace with other people as a result, brings happiness. What you are saying is all about fear of what you don't know. I don't live in a 'mono-cultural hellhole', whereas you probably do.

You're making a lot of assumptions here Fillip and misrepresenting what I said. I feel that I shouldn't be having this discussion because immigration has nothing to do with the video and I don't as a rule respond to this 'white power' drivel. However, your comments really made me think. I don't know what your history is like but this made me think of the way the Aboriginal peoples of Australia must have felt during the program by the white settlers to 'breed the blackness out of them'; a program which involved removal of children and the almost total destruction of an ancient race of people. That program only ended in the 1950s or 60s. However, that was a form of genocide which really happened. In fact when you look at history and the world today white Europeans control the majority of the world's resources and the power - we are the aggressors on the global stage not the victims. We aren't likely to see the 'breeding out' of the white race, but if it happens it will be because people fall in love and nature takes its course over the generations. It will be because of people coming together, not because of hate. Perhaps if we all end up one colour, although that would be sad as diversity is a great thing, it might stop people killing and hating each other so much? Peace.

Yup India and Hinduism as a culture is thousands of years old... its an ocean of mini cultures.. every state speaks a diff language.. dress differently.. eat differently.... India as a country is more Diverse than the entire Continent of Europe

Those looks only come from the fact that they don't interbreed with foreign peoples or people that are racially dissimilar to them. Due to their isolated location they have bred themselves to the Pinnacle of their genes outward characteristics. Probably also due to the fact that Gucci looks for people with those facial features.

Living in the middle of nowhere, those ladies impeccable manicure, makes me feel embarrassed 🙈 👍🏻😊

Men too.

Many live like that in the U.S they're called homeless and they openly defecate like this culture

@@Jessica-to8um One thing about these people that should threaten the conventinal american; They (the Cobra Gypsies despies being mentally managed by govt institutions! They really exhibit powerful genetic spiral intllegence...remarkable adaptation to exist in Nature's desert thrush. Aldo (Leopold) these are your dream chela (apirants)...a clan people who revel in "listnening to the land" simultaneously thriving in a Pan-centric adaptation of Rajathstans timeless hinduesque culture..including a nutri-metabolic cycle that rotates on wholesome vegetarian meals prepared on (god forbid mainstream American open pit fire kitchens) with (did you notice foodies) yummy Cha-patis (fresh ground wheat tortas) ; thee ubiquitous bread of a thousand million Indians citizens EACH & EVERYDAY in the sub continent. A clan that includes so much animal/wildlife respect & interface ...according to America's shamanic spokeman on Cultural Survival... is a clan that mostlikey free and clear of habitat depression and mental illness

Germany here. I am sure they also never had to fill out an income tax declaration

@@DevNull66 being kalbeliya is bad life if you lived such life

Na América sorrimos também e somos muito felizes, inclusive aqui está cheio de ciganos , indianos e pessoas de todos os cantos da terra, venha e veja com seus próprios olhos

Sylla Atlas moo

how he did them nothing lol

I was going to say much the same - so many happy eyes! Unlike us with our stressed out 9-to-5 jobs. Admittedly we have a lot of technological luxuries because of those jobs but boy do we ever pay a spiritual price for them.

I love their faces. the most beautiful people in the world.

I agree. This is the Real Deal! Such a beautiful culture!

Do u face problem living there in europe? like racism and discrimination?

Yeah but they are nearly black,, on the eye colour shows similarity but still cool

@@Shivam-tn9xe yes ,roma people are detested all over the Europe ....

:)

+Marti woodchip I was just thinkingabout some words to write down here.. But you said everything, guess better than i could have done it.. So i feel you mate :) Great inspiering documentary!

Your comment hit the nail on the head :) we are so blessed!

+Marti woodchip : its all go back to one's roots.

+Marti woodchip because they appreciate what they already have.

Sunil beniwal you had a lucky chilhood :) this documentary is amazing and the people of your country too. Bless you!

westernization dude...i too had nearly same upbringing but my kids are forgetting this language in race of learning english..

What a fun childhood you had.The children look so happy and free.

@ Sunil Beniwal by due respect , I am an Indian too and your name suggest that you belong to Baniya or Jats society. and in this documentary they are showing Kalbeliya nomads, those who lives in wildness and moves around Wildness. you could have live around them in your vicinity. But you cannot claim to be one of them. as to my knowledge Beniwals are not nomads, I am trying to clear the facts. just being an indian, you cannot claim to be one of them.

@Redwoodrebelgirl Hallo, I understand that you think I am trying to underline Sunil (Male Name) statement. u are right he did not mentioned he is one of them, but he is trying to be a part of the narrative in the Documentary. That is the Fact which I do not agree with him, since in reallity, Kalbeliay Nomads are poorest section of the society and as in the Documentary in beginn showned, that caste System has been abolished in india, but in truth Rajasthan is one of those state in India, where Caste Base Crime are at highest, they rank each year among the top 3 out of 29 states in india. And let alone living in that region, does not give him insight of the life of this peoples. so one cannot claim or compare to have live the same experience as they do(For Example: One cannot compare His Life experince living as White Person in USA with the one of Afro-Americans living in 60s in USA, just because that white person was living in the same cityor vicinity). and apart from that, if he belongs to those community like Jats, as his surname suggest, then these people practice Crime in thousands every year against low society Kalbeliya or Dalits. and this are Facts!!!! Just because this documentary is a good one showing Kalbeliya Lifestyle, no one who do attrocities to them should walk away saying to have known them or their Lifstyle when in reality this people make their day today life horrible. I can go on listing the problems they face in the society their, but it will not end. I am explaining this to you since I belong to a minority community in my country(india) and experience personally what it means. My Grandfather use to have a big property alongside our family graveyard, open Land outside city boundary and each year such Nomads use to travel and camp on his Land for free for few months and move on. but still I wont claim that I know them as this Documentary trying to show us. In reality if People in india belong to upper or higher class then these Nomads, then they ignore them as if they do not exist........ this is the truth.

I know what you mean.. Something feels right about this.

We are all part of the same thing. It would make sense that pieces of our humanity are reflected in each other's cultures.

In a past life you might of been from India.

Don't chat shit bro, if you are so passionate about them why don't you swap lifes with them.

Then please come visit chandigarh, jaipur , mumbai and Lucknow also in this video only poor people are shown 🙄

You are so correct well put sir!

So very true Sir! It's an incredible journey, with these most interesting Kalbeliya peoples. So glad that you enjoyed it, as we all did. Take care.

There no culture in America, that just bussines.

In seguito avrà sicuramente pagato per l'ospitalità

kind advice, its good to be innocent but not naive. i was there 3 weeks before covid lockdown. i spent my christmas week in the desert and these people are motivated by only one thing when they see foreigners or tourists : its money. you see these poses they strike, each time you want to take a picture take out money first, no filming or camera without showing the bank note. thats why they they naturally will strike poses because its business. its expensive to just to see a show of these dances as all desert dance show agents and tours prey on them and want to keep exclusivity.

:)

What song did you use in the beginining?

i wish he offered more insight on the bloody thing. but all he does is state the obvious on everything that goes on.

india (rajsthan) really beautiful place n lovely pepole .they r to gud ...i had beautiful experience .

Maravilloso!!!

I can see how the karma sutra came into existence 😏. One of those beautiful women dancing in front of you would be intoxicating . I am american , they remind me of the American version of hippies . But without all the stupid annoying political views that alot of these american hippies have . The gypsy life seems to look to me one of you live you love you dance you enjoy you die . T R U E freedom God bless you my friends 🙏

Wild, natural and romantic. Beautyful People! A wonderful Film. Thank you!

31:00 the arranged bride doesn't look too happy : (

Makes you wonder who’s better off here!

must have missed the marriage ceremony segment, lol

Haha he liked your comment! What a fabulous polite person

Lolz.. everyone is funny and sweet here..

:)

I agree

thank you for your anderstening but we still dont know how we come in Europe and we have much teory for my pp hoo its eternal wanderer even there is a theory that we were Alexander the Great took his army because he was only sorry for the people of the desert that is now called a Gipsy or (ROMA). and to thank him, we went to war and conquer the world ... because we now have the world's 250 million gypsies, thank you for your interest in this documentary. my regards .. :)

watch Latcho Drom

Lacho Drom hem tumendje..:)

I wonder if these people know that millions of people all around the world watch their video on the internet. I am sure some of the very educated ones are aware of it

I totally agree. Awesome.

Roma Nuh Bhadi Lhulu

I'm blue collar, most of my forebearers were as well. I guess that is why I want to meet folk like these.

I'm from the same city rajesthan and rajesthan is awesome state in India for tourists and there have lots of different places and culture.

Judson Owens They're nothing but nut jobs and freaks

hi

Exactly! I felt a part of it, like I was there! The way they look at you thru the camera blew me away! It felt like they could actually see me!! I really liked what you said about ... "longing". It really makes you feel like you want to be a part of their life. May God protect them and keep them safe.

Judson Owens Beautifully put Judson At the age of 62 do you think it's too late for me to get involved with these people and actually enjoy life for what it is

Cool huh

Pre-Date (Peesh daad) Aryan cultures and names all over the world

@@xodemoon7593 stop with the aryan nonsense

@@ruperslayz actually aryans are the locals of north most part of india, even im aryan like many of indians. Aryan is also a very common indian name. The aryan that Hitler claimed is not aryan at all actually, including the swastika, which is also taken from Hinduism, and its a holy symbol here only a little different from na*i swastik. Orignal Aryans are actually tall , brown, and have han asian features, they have their community in leh, that is near Himalayas. India's one of the race is indo aryan, that is majority of north indians.

The only Gypsies I have ever heard of are Romanians or in Romania so this documentary was certainly interesting

I thought the same. I would not survive for long in this dessert

haha, I wouldnt be there in the first place

Not a day, I can't live there even for 1 minute.

Wow everyone thank you so much for the likes 😊!

True

yes somethings probably we couldn't have on our society

If it's so wonderful to and live like this...

You said what I was thinking!

Ariel hhh

I'm n indian🇮🇳. Just learned abt them from doc. Grt

Go there, spend some time with them. It might not be the most physically comfortable experience but they will embrace you as one of their own.

Same here, I know exactly where you're coming from

Hey G, I know what you are going through and what it feels like. I am personally from Kenya and if it's okay with you, we could exchange contacts and check up on one another every now and then via WhatsApp. Let me know.

Sell your things and roam around world . Visit thailand , india , nepal , vietnam . Cheap and real

I can call you 😢

All Romas came from India and without Roma or Indians the world would be colourless and boring.

Romas are the ones who taught Turkish people all the traditions?

@@mangopudding5979 That would be a funny way to put it :))) I said the Roma has a huge impact on the present day culture of Turkiye.

How do you know all these things?

@@mangopudding5979 those are no secrets.

Why does this, for so many of the reasons you listed, reminds me of the 70s era hippie culture Americana. It has that same sentient Docu-News footage of that American era.

@@goodasgoing This Indian culture has existed for a very long time Perhaps the “American hippies” were inspired by this culture. ❤

Camera is terrific

I liked so much too, but I ask why Treza was go to two concerts and don't let us to see the musicians, I feel we lost a lot of their music.