Such an amazing song. Especially with Neil Tennant from the Pet Shop Boys as a backing vocal. Such a harmonic composition, it's unreal

To me this will always be his best track, sad, dark, strangely uplifting... a classic :)

This song is amazing - Robbie Williams and Guy Chambers were dynamite together. Also, pure genius to have Neil Tennant and Neil Hannon on backing vocals. Just class.

'I didn't lose my mind, it was mine to give away'. One of the best lines ever!

This is one of my (if not the) favorite Robbie Williams song, I don't understand why it did not chart better. The backing vocals are also fantastic. When I was a kid, I thought "That background singer has a voice like the frontman of Pet Shop Boys" I just learned this year that it IS actually him.

This song is legendary, the ending is chilling I cannot get enough of this song.

This song saved my life. I was going thru a nasty breakup from a best friend about 20 years ago. I was sad and angry and once I listened to this song it put words on my emotions. 😢This was excactly how I felt at the time. This song helped me thru. Thanks Rob❤

Absolutely obsessed with this song! Especially after watching the docu. God! This man built a true legacy that very few would even dare to achieve... Robbie, love you even more.

Who would have imagined Robbie breaking free from Take That ... and then releasing this absolute critical belter of a classic. Robbie's first step to greatness.

Honestly this has got to be the most personal song Robbie has ever done and that is probably the underlying strenght to it. It's a real shame this gem is so often overlooked, I find it one of the best he has ever created and is no small matter for an artist who made a ton of incredible music.

My brother loved you so much… he is died now…. I am her sister,but listened your song Robbie from 17 when you are was in Take That!!! I still love your songs ❤

I was 12 when I’ve heard this song for the first time 😅. But I can say that especially today, there is almost no more such soulful music. This song is definitely legendary 🤘

Robbie helped me to express my anger from the past in his words through this song. It's amazing the impact that he has had on my mental health. I love all of his songs. His songs mean a lot to me, and listening to him is really good for my mental health.

Awww, the good old days when pop music wasn’t simplistic garbage. Back when lyrics had meaning and videos had stories.

"I didn't lose my mind, it was mine to give away". Awesome 😎

How did this not reach #1…

My fave Robbie song. And i always think the music sounds like a Bond theme

I am not a fan of Robbie's music in general but I think this one is head and shoulders above his other offerings. I love the sentiment and the bitterness he barely disguises. Top song 👍

Best Robbie song for me. Here 23 years later in 2021...What a gorgeous time it was to be 14 in 1998. Beautiful times. Watched this over and over on mtv. Always chilling at the end.... boom

If you are watching this in 2024, stay strong 💪, we have got you. Just remember that you are a Legend❗💯😉

Probably the most underrated song of all time.The beggining of the song is so sad,but at the same time so beautiful. The vídeo is pretty good to...Fantastic song by Mr Williams

This song its so underrated, most people knew about him after "sing when you`re winning" but he made some of his best songs before that album imo

My favorite line of the song "I dont want to hate but it's all you've left me with" powerful

By far the best song/video he ever did. Still sounds amazing all these years later.

Best Robbie Williams' song, by far.

I was 21 when this was released. It was amazing then and it’s aged brilliantly - it’s so well produced and the vocals by Neil Tennant and Niall Hannon only make it better. The video is effing brilliant too 👍🏻

This song is an absolute masterpiece

THE best pop song of the last 30 years. Totally under-appreciated. Audiences are too dumb these days.

No Regrets and Karma Killer.....My all time favorite Robbie Williams songs. Thank you Robbie.

I find it sad that he wrote this song about his manager when he was in take that and the time he had back then. The amount of sadness he must have felt when he was there is shown right here in this song, it's heartbreaking. Even so, it's still such a beautiful piece of music

[Verse 1] Tell me a story Where we all change And we'd live our lives together And not enstranged [Pre-Chorus] I didn't lose my mind it was Mine to give away Couldn't stay to watch me cry You didn't have the time So I softly slip away... [Chorus] No regrets they don't work No regrets they only hurt Sing me a love song Drop me a line Suppose it's just a point of view But they tell me I'm doing fine [Verse 2] I know from the outside We looked good for each other Felt things were going wrong When you didn't like my mother Ad [Pre-Chorus] I don't want to hate but that's All you've left me with A bitter aftertaste and a fantasy of How we all could live [Chorus] No regrets they don't work No regrets they only hurt (We've been told you stay up late) I know they're still talking (You're far too short to carry weight) The demons in your head (Return the videos they're late) If I could just stop hating you (Goodbye) I'd feel sorry for us instead [Bridge] Remember the photographs (insane) The ones where we all laugh (so lame) We were having the time of our lives Well thank you it was a real blast [Chorus] No regrets they don't work No regrets they only hurt Write me a love song Drop me a line Suppose it's just a point of view But they tell me I'm doing fine [Outro] Everything I wanted to be Every time I walked away Everytime you told me to leave I just wanted to stay Every time you looked at me and Everytime you smiled I felt so vacant you treat me like a child I loved the way we used to laugh I loved the way we used to smile Often I sit down and think of you for a while Then it passes me by and I think of someone else instead I guess the love we once had is Officially dead

He was mad however hurting and in love still you can tell every emotion in his voice those lyrics came from a broken heart.

His voice, his personality...a complete genius artist. I am in love with him.

Without a doubt one of his most underrated songs, and yet it's also one of his best. I can relate to this on so many levels.....

This is one of his most under rated songs. There are some people here saying this was their sad, break up song or it helped them at a certain time in life. Also remember that around this time, Robbie was fighting big demons himself, especially ones of self worth.

This song is simply ahead of it's time. It is so endearing to listen after so many decades. It just sounds so current

Only when you experience lack of love you are able to understand every single word of this song😔.

Robbie Williams seems to be one of the best singers ever! This song is great his collaboration with Neil Tennant from PSB. Lithuania :)

My favourite song by robbie Williams and fantastic backing vocals by Neil Tennant and the lead singer of divine comedy 👍👍👍

Amazing song

Backing vocals by Neil Tennant of the Pet Shop Boys and Neil Hannon of The Divine Comedy

One from absolutelly best songs from him 😍😍💟💟

So much charisma. This song is amazing.

Robbie Williams's best song !

1998 feels like yesterday

"I don't want to hate but that's all you've left me with.."

I watch this video with sadness knowing what trauma he was going through. I wish he had of had better support around him. I am so glad he was able to grow strong and survive that industry.

3 voices of generations on one song awesome , Robbie Williams, Neil tenant and Neil hannon 🤘🤪🤘

A young robbie williams would have made an excellent movie villain. He has that look about him.

One of the most powerful songs ever, sounds upbeat… but is one of the saddest LOVE songs ever, yes the obvious love Robbie had for his band mates, @1.14 “No regrets now… they only hurt!” you can see in his face how it had crushed him, thank god they made up…so happy for them all.

Only when you experience lack of love you are able to understand every single word of this song😔. Thank you for the Pet Shop Boys influence. One from absolutelly best songs from him 😍😍💟💟

Just a beautiful song

More than underated song. Excellence in pop rock. Robbie is great !

Neil Tennant and Neil Hannon's voices really make this song special!

I remember buying this on cassette when I was 15 and listening to it on repeat! Still a fave song of mine.

This really feels like a heart break, amazing song, through the years never gets old

i just now realize how good this really is!

I am only 16 years old but I love this song so much mainly because the lyrics to this song are so powerful, meaningful and conflicting emotions can be felt. I never get bored of listening to this song, I was born in the same year as this song was released in 1998 :)

Best Dark Pop Song ever, thanks RW...The Netflix Documentary describes from a Bad Boy to be a Better Man...

Still one of his best in 2023 ❤ xxx

I’m a pink Floyd fan a Metallica fan an oasis fan. And Robbies music is genuinely up there for me. Idc if it’s pop it’s amazing music he’s got countless amazing songs

His story told in a beautifully sad way 💔

Great song, wonderful voice, the best of the best. You are big robbie❤️

Robbie Williams and Guy Chambers have written some of the greatest songs in pop music history

I love his voice

I MISS THE 90's :(

This is one of Robbies best song. Great sound and melody to this song. It's nice he got to collaborate with the pet shop boys.

Every once in a while I remember what a brilliant song this is and I have to listen to it right away.

One of the best break up songs ever!

IMO, his best song. And he's done some stunners.

One of his greatest! Love NT backing vocals!

I love Robbie Williams and Pet Shop Boys They together = amazing job

His songs should be playing everywhere... so good to listen !!

Work of art!!! The best song of Robbie for me!!! Underrated by the way...

"gooobyyyyee" greatest cameo ever in a pop song

2020 and still hits hard 😥

Love his personality..extremely funny and sensitive 😘

Respect forever! No regrets, Just walk away.

I randomly had this song pop into my head this morning. It's aged really well. Shame he didn't make more of this calibre.

потрясающий Робби. потрясающий голос и песня просто отличная)))

One of my all time classic and favourite song - among others Robbie's songs of course !!!! Robbie you are unique !!!

I believe this is Robbie's first true creative showing. His hits before this were about boyhood. This is his first song about depression.

Robbie Williams is a giant ! This song is pure class! 💯❤👍👊💪👏🏆

The intro transports me back to the 90s instantly

Thank you for the Pet Shop Boys influence.

When Robbie re joined Take That he changed the final line to ''I guess the love we once had is officially alive!''

This Song is deeply underrated. For me it‘s his best Song. 🥰

Not heard of this song for years and it came into my head as I was falling asleep and cant stop listening now

I don't think the word masterpiece would be out of place here

It is definitely my favorite song. The last scene is creepy but fascinating.

Great pop song right up there with Feel

I was 8 when I first heard this song now I'm 29 brings back all the memories and goosebumps too ❤️

this song makes me cry everytime.,...still in 2018

This song reminds me of the past.the good and the bad times.love Robbie 4ever

Angsty Robbie, will always be my favourite Robbie 🙌🏻 25 years this song has been in my life. Right from my parents break up, and the pain of having my life turned upside down as child, subsequent struggles with relationships, a massive fall out with my sister, my battle with depression, through to most recently being betrayed by the person I believed to be my soulmate. This song beautifully portrays the pain of depression and end of a chapter in life. It really, more than any song, shows you where Robbie was in that time in his life. I’m glad he found happiness and peace in the end.

couldve stayed to see me cry, you didnt have the time so i softly slipped away. those lines got me through a tough moment in my life. cheers robbie

Great song about Take That. Got a lot of meaning to it. One of the best songs he did.

Oh wow, this takes me back to better years, thanks Robbie.

I could relate to this when he released it, I still can. I was so angry. I even wrote the lyrics in a notebook so I could feel better somehow and cope. I feel catarsis from the past now, I didn't know Neil Tennant was singing, I was so young I couldn't tell and I didn't know much about the PSB either, well I love them now, all I know is that this song was love at first listening and I really needed it, Thank you Robbie and Neil.

One of his finest!!! There is something very special about it. Profound in every way possible. ❤