That one change in the line "you cannot pass" really does show the difference in a book, and a film, and how were percieve them. In a book, a scene can hold your attention through pure description, and dialogue alone, whereas in a film, a scene has to be presented fully to the viewer in a way that captures the audience's attention in that moment. For the film, "you shall not pass" works really well with the flow of the words and the way they are being shouted, and it intensifies the scene even further with the music behind it as well. As a result it has become one of the most recognizable scenes in film history. However, in the book, Gandalf isn't even necessarily shouting at the Balrog. Gandalf is speaking to it in a very "matter of fact" way as if he holds all of the power, not the Balrog. In the book, Gandalf is letting the Balrog know that it cannot pass over the bridge. If Gandalf spoke without a lot of emotion in an epic moment that has been built up for the audience, it takes some of the emotional weight out of the scene, whereas in a book it can retain its weight, and importance to the reader, and even add to its importance. It's just crazy to me how the human mind comprehends the subtle details of different entertainment mediums so differently. Books, and films are as different from each other as pen and paper D&D is to an RPG video game. Books allow the reader to go through a story at their own pace, in their own mind, whereas a film is just one isolated representation of an idea from beginning to end, and it moves at its own pace scene by scene.

Book or movie, I get choked up here every time.

Tolkien was many things but loose with his use of language he was not. More than any other author, he meant exactly what he wrote.

Your narration is superb. A lot of lore UKpostsrs have deep knowledge but imperfect narration that takes you out of the immersion. Yours not only harmonize, but strengthen the immersion. Your cadence, your voice, but most of all your prose is so pleasant to hear. Its during your description of Tolkien's draft that made me pause the video and hit subscribe ❤

Absolutely brilliant analysis. Great video. Thanks

Goosebumps on that final reimagining of Gandalf’s speech 😮 Your videos are fantastic! Such great production value and delivery!

Another stunning video! I love your deep understanding of the sonic beauty of Tolkien's language. Thank you, sir.

Hearing this read out gave me goosebumps

Well-said, very informative about the nuances of what Gandalf's message is, and better than I've been able to explain Gandalf's magic. In the extended version of Return of the King, in the scene between Gandalf and Saruman, the film does a good job of evoking that when Gandalf speaks like this, he is not describing intent, but truth. "Saruman, your staff is broken" and how it immediately breaks to obey his words.

I just stumbled upon your channel, what a hidden gem! Subscribed!

A beautiful video, as always! I offer one correction: the Flame imperishable is not a 'symbol' of Eru. It is something very real, and Eru wields it! We read in the Ainulindalë that Melkor "sought the Flame imperishable in the void" but that he looked for it in the wrong place, because "the Flame imperishable was (always) with Eru"! It burns within Eru. Eru also has the power to send out the Flame and infuse other things with it. We read he infused the Ainur and Ea (the universe) with the Flame. From that moment on, the Flame also burned within the Ainur and Ea (the universe). The Flame imperishable, then, I would say, is that power which lends being, existence, reality to things. As a power it is always within Eru, and it is his to wield as it pleases him.

Your channel needs to be spoken about throughout the realms of YT! Although the amount of your videos created are minimum at this time, the quality and substance of them rank with all of the best channels I've seen about the Legendarium! I look forward to more of your outstanding content as well as watching your subscriber base grow!

Loved every second of this ❤ Thank you for making This Video!❤

A very entertaining video, looking forward to more. You have an excellent voice for video narration.

You’ve got yourself a subscriber. I absolutely love your style of narration.

This is a very high quality material channel, thanks the recitation, the notes on books, the draws and paints are top level, the voice is good, I really like it! Well done. I'm reading the HoME started by volume VI, as I want to read the HotLotR first and foremost, however happens that I got the 12 individual volumes, perfect to manage the ones illustrated by John Howe, I have the 10 volumes there waiting for me to tackle them, and this video giving notes about the exact location is very good as the other one giving the names of Sauron also. Kudos my friend. Congratulations.

There are some really cool pics/paintings in the video. I enjoyed the narrative as well. Gööd job!

Cool words dude, big approve 👌 seriously though I love this channel! Please keep doing what you're doing!

I'll echo so many others; another great video and analysis. I had never heard the story of why the film came up with "you shall not pass". Looking forward to future content. Thanks.

I loved it. Thank you

This was really good.

Well done.

Gandalf turns to the balrog and booms : "You ain't shit!"

Brilliant! You've earned a subscription from me.

I still like Ian McKellen's version better. Not "it is impossible for you to pass", but "I will personally prevent you from passing." Its much better suited to the confrontational nature of the scene.

Brilliant!

The references to a deep and rich past in 'The Lord of the Rings" drew me inexorably to the rest of Tolkien's writings. First and foremost, to the "Silmarillion". I had to understand 'Strider's' song on the journey from Bree to Weathertop. I needed to know who the Numenoreans were. Above all, I had to know the significance of what Gandalf was saying to the Balrog. Even though I've read and reread Tolkien's writings, this was delightful. Thank you.

At approximately 3:45 the narrator said the word subscribe in the text and the subscribe button lit up. So I had to. You got me.

I really enjoy the manner in wchich you present the content on your chanell. And the art you use is exeptional to; any chances to get some references re the artists?

The beacons are lit!! Btw amazing content..

I've pondered on the line given by Gandalf to the Balrog and its true meaning... Thank you for bringing these words and their true meaning and intent towards the Balrog. There is no mistake in casting spells and words alike. Tolkein knew that for Magick to work, that intention and Gnosis was the key to unlocking Magick. By casting Spells of words as if they had already passed. This is one aspect of the Magicians' toolkit in occult practices. Bravo Tolkein and Bravo, sir, for an amazing piece of Tolkein law.

Make a video, what would happen if you wore all the rings of power in total 20 rings I think. Good work🎉

Your narration reminds me a bit of Kenneth Branagh narrating Walking With Dinosaurs, nice

The "flame of the sun" indicated the "flame of Heaven/the flame of God" on opposition to and authority over the "flame of hell". Additionally, in context, "shall not" is weaker than "cannot". The former indicates struggle, spoken _with_ authority; the latter indicates an absolute certainty spoken _in_ authority.

Gandalf actually does say "You cannot pass" in the movie, when he first turns to face the Balrog. He just also says "You shall not pass" at the end of the fight. ukposts.info/have/v-deo/fJd_pqylkGee0GQ.htmlsi=rz_ukANj-fxk85H9&t=109

Changing the phrase to "you SHALL not pass" turns the statement into a declaration, not simply a challenge or battle of will. In military orders, the word "shall" is unequivocal and leaves no room for interpretation. All instruction that follows "shall" are taken as absolute...which is why - to me - "you shall not pass" is more mighty than "you cannot pass"

Shout-out to The red book😂

The Balrogs pledged themselves to Melkor during the discord of the Music, not in Utumno...

Anor means Sun in Sindarin. The flame of Anor basically points to the light of the Two Trees, in the sense that it is a reference to Laurelin, one of the Two Trees whose remnant is based on the creation of the Sun. As theorized, if the use of the flame of Anor is provided by Narya (Ring of Fire), this indicates that the origin of the power of the rings of power is connected with the light of the Two Trees, and there may be a connection between the Silmarils that mediate this and the Three Rings of the Elves, as fictionalized in the series The Rings of Power.

I'm gonna need more wall space...

Did you paint the "You cannot pass" poster image yourself?

I really want to hear silmarillion through your voice

I wonder then, why does the Balrog still choose to test Gandalf and pass the bridge...

I have to be honest your videos make me feel like I am experiencing the movies again. I don’t know why but you feel like a historian in Minas Tirith trying to write theory’s on the world around you.

👍🏻

👍👍

The Secret Fire, or the Flame Imperishable is the Spirit of Eru: his power and presence within Eä--in other words, the Holy Spirit of God. Fire is the symbol of the Holy Spirit in Christianity, and Tolkien himself confirmed this in an interview with Clyde Kilby. What he is telling the balrog is that he, Gandalf, does not stand alone against him, but stands with the power of Eru, which *cannot* be defeated.

In many illustrations of the Balrog in Moria it is generally portrayed as being huge, but was that really the case? I'm thinking about such a huge creature trying to travel through tunnels made by dwarves for dwarves. I can imagine the menace of the black shadow and flame around it as being larger, but might the Balrog be closer to man size, one that could pass through dwarven tunnels?

The authors of the period, of which Tolkien is a master, understood the English language, better than we do today. There was formal language, informal language, familiar language common language, slang language and even uncouth language. The very same idea would be expressed differently in each. You can not pass implies, at least to my understanding, that the Balrog is physically unable , for whatever reason, to pass. You shall not pass, to my mind, implies that Gandalf will not allow the Balrog to pass. It is akin to I forbid you to pass. Just a thought anway. Cheers

you know .. i really wanted to watch this video and listen to your points .. but when the first thing i hear is "check out my merch" i already reload the YT page and look for something by somebody who doesn't directly to push some stupid merch nobody really needs upon me!

What if he said it in spanish? 🤔 would is it still work?

Gandalf stood on business.

That little change in the dialog doesn’t make the scene in the movie any less awesome. And I’ll take that over the disastrous Rings of Power any day.

For those of us who actually read the books his speech was plain and simple. Glad it gave everyone else a headache

Well when I wrote this I kind of meant fire of the gods just sounds better to say flame of anor lol

That's Tolkien. Drawing off of world mythology and weaving a remembrance of the Old Magics; when the world was still new and the speaking of a name or the declaration of a threshold held power.

How did gollum cross the bridge?

thanks for dumbing down the Great Wizard’s words for us mere mortals to understand… 😉

But what of Tom Bombadil and Goldberry? Every. Fucking. Film. Has. Ignored. A. Single. Appearance. of Yave. Every time.

“Anor”. Or “Arnor”? Sorry, check LOTR and JRR’s own pronunciation of names…. Yours is a bit off.