Why No Tugs MV Dali/Key Bridge Baltimore

  Переглядів 299,382

TimBatSea

TimBatSea

Місяць тому

You might be wondering why the MV Dali didn't have tugs on here transit through Baltimore harbor. These are my thoughts.
If you got anything from these videos, you can support the channel by Jointing our Patron Crew. https:www.patreon.com/timbatsea
For the best coverage of the topic and all things shipping, goto Dr. Sal's Channel. https: / @uct_ybgksiwb3wp4acpnf5na
And please help me grow my other channel, SV Paquita
https: / @svpaquita

КОМЕНТАРІ: 2 600
@jeffhays1968
@jeffhays1968 Місяць тому
In N.H.our deep water port has a narrow channel, ledges, and two turns to get in and two bridges. 3 tugs and a local rover pilot all the way in, and all the way out.
@river4462
@river4462 Місяць тому
Tugs automatic in Hawai'i safety
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you for watching Jeff. CUOTO
@user-zj2im5nt6e
@user-zj2im5nt6e 28 днів тому
​​@@river4462 I HOPE YOU HAWAIIANS SNAP FORWARD AND DEMOCRATS AND GET FREAKING GET THEM ALL OUT OF THERE AND STOP 🛑 STOP HIRING FAMILY MEMBERS THAT HAVE NO IDEA WHAT THE HELL THEY'RE DOING TO MAKE MONEY AND NEPOTISM CRAP VOTE THEM ALL OUT HAWAII AND VOTE FREAKING TO GET OPRAH AND ALL THOSE FREAKING PIECES OF SHIT OUT OF FREAKING HAWAII AND SHIT HAWAII IS NOT FOR FREAKING BILLIONAIRES TO MAKE THEIR OWN PRIVATE LITTLE RESORTS AND STUFF , WHAT ARE THE DEMOCRATS OUT THE WORST THAT CAN HAPPEN IS REPUBLICANS WON'T DO ANYTHING BETTER OTHER THAN THAT GET THEM ALL THE HELL OUT OF THERE BECAUSE I'M A LION AND I MOVED OVER TO THE STATES TO NEW JERSEY AND I DID TEST THE GODDAMN DEMOCRATS AND I DETEST WHAT THE HAWAIIANS THINK OF AS A THEIR LAND TYPE THING HOW DO I SAY IT'S OUR LAND SO WE SHOULD BE RUNNING IT KNOW YOU RUNNING INTO THE GROUND AND FREEING FAMILY MEMBERS AND FRIENDS TO REALLY PUT IT INTO THE GROUND
@davenorman6717
@davenorman6717 27 днів тому
@jeffhays1968 Old sailboat captain here....always enjoyed seeing those Moran tugs side by side at the docks in Portsmouth...guessing ship captains enjoy them by their sides !
@river4462
@river4462 27 днів тому
@@davenorman6717 seems tugs would understanably go hand in hand with cargo and other vessels. Automatic☮️🤙🏽🏝
@edweb9751
@edweb9751 Місяць тому
Skipper, that was the first thing I said and wrote about on the Alex Chistoforou blog immediately after it happened. I wrote that in my day as a seaman 65+ years ago we would have had two tugs, one fore and one aft in confined waters, but I guessed everything had changed now. Since then another commenter wrote that-that used to be the case at that port, but it was changed to Tugs only for ships of one hundred thousand tons and above. I can only guess saving money becomes paramount over safety, two tugs could have pulled her to safety without any of loss of life, once again the bean counters get priority over safety. Regards Ed.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@GilmerJohn
@GilmerJohn 25 днів тому
Baltimore is a special case. It's losing ships to the Virginia ports which have several natural (closer to the open sea) and man made (few or no bridges over main channels and good railroad access to the "Inland Port." The "Baltimore Advantage" may well just the willingness to cut charges by cutting corners.
@davidkilts1670
@davidkilts1670 21 день тому
@@GilmerJohn They will lose them now for sure.
@telliott3590
@telliott3590 28 днів тому
Two tractor tugs (10,000+ hp) are required for each tanker exiting Valdez, AK in Prince William Sound (70 miles) and one has to be attached to the tanker for the first 20 miles. One also has to wait at the entrance until the tanker is 17 miles further out to sea before they can return to Valdez. Each tug has a 7 person crew trained for emergency response,
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 28 днів тому
Please see part 2 for clarification. Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@river4462
@river4462 27 днів тому
In the waters of Hawai'i the tugs can be 1-1.5 miles ahead of the barge....long tows almost exclusively Barges in Hawai'i have no brakes so if tugs are towing close hmmmmmm they need the distance. Not to forget the big 10 feet or higher swells and the sketchy channels
@anthony1636
@anthony1636 Місяць тому
Working on Tugs for many years I can only give you my own experience. It really does depend on the Port and its difficulties on entering on leaving and the conditions that are prevalent on the day. The standard procedure when the Port has an open entrance. Is to assist the ship when leaving the quay and once it is under its own power, it makes its own way. And the Tugs continue on their way. There was absolutely nothing wrong with the procedure. It was just a terrible accident and can only be blamed on mechanical failure.
@SgtBrendanN
@SgtBrendanN Місяць тому
And it isn't just a matter of being in a port. What about ANY bridge that a ship goes under that has 'wet' supports. How many are along the Intercoastal? Do they need tugs as well, just in case of power outages\maneuvering failures? I don't really see more tugs as the solution. More and better dolphins, fenders where possible etc... are better choices.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
💯!!!! Thank you very much for watching and commenting so perfectly Anthony. CUOTO
@disgruntledconservativevet1798
@disgruntledconservativevet1798 Місяць тому
I think this SOP should change. I was in the Navy for 25 years, and I’ve been on many combatants, and supply ships (engineering). We could loose power at anytime pulling in and out of port. I have seen it happen. Plus if we can give billions to other countries, Federal DOT can pay for a tug crew at each port of entry. If they’re going to give it away, at least give it to someone here.
@skipah01
@skipah01 Місяць тому
As a pilot myself, I still find it incredible that given the constrains of the channel and having to pass under such a critical piece of infrastructure, close proximity to the ship berths and tug berths, that an escort tug isn't standard practice here, and this situation wasn't highlighted as a potential high risk scenario a long time ago? Everything is fine until it's not.... As a pilot you have to have in your mind that this could happen at any moment on every job, and continuously be thinking of an emergency plan in the back of your mind. Nothing makes a Pilot happier than having the security blanket of having a tug or tugs with you. Huge thanks and respect to all Tug crews out there. You guys never get enough thanks for your work with us.
@disgruntledconservativevet1798
@disgruntledconservativevet1798 Місяць тому
@@skipah01 I 100% agree. You’re spot on.
@tylerdurden2644
@tylerdurden2644 Місяць тому
Thanks Tim. So many are pushing the emotional buttons right now so good to hear reason.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching. I appreciate your kind words. CUOTO
@nialloconnell5895
@nialloconnell5895 Місяць тому
Thanks for that Tim. Been following Dr. Sal's channel for a while now really great in-site to all things shipping and 20 odd years as a fireman massively experienced guy.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
💯 Dr Sal is the man! Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@davidjanis1997
@davidjanis1997 Місяць тому
@@TimBatSealink to dr Sal ng
@MaxAbramson3
@MaxAbramson3 Місяць тому
Thank you for your opinion on this. I've developed a lot of respect for the tugboat operators and what they can do. I've seen them really haul tail in an emergency and prevent real damage. It's my professional opinion that this tragedy would not have happened.Had they held onto one of the tugs going out.
@CMDRSweeper
@CMDRSweeper Місяць тому
What is going on with shipping is criminally good... Compared to traditional media, we have gotten the technical details rather than the wash of emotion material they usually do. Like the old school reporting back in the old days, just specialized in one field.
@LVrJ100
@LVrJ100 Місяць тому
Ships when passing near or under large structures should keep only minimum speed (2kts). Also its better if escorted by tugs. Here, at Baltimore, many wrong decisions by the port mgmt. 1. Ship was set free to head before crossing the bridge. 2. Need of tug boats was omitted at this critical passage. 3. Very less dolphins to protect the bridge from impact. 4. Traffic was not stopped and maintenance work on the bridge was also going on. 5. No VHF communication for the maintenance workers on the bridge.
@rickrogers2649
@rickrogers2649 Місяць тому
Hi Capt Tim, I used to work at the Texaco terminal on the Chelsea River in Mass.(long since gone) I saw a Gulf tanker hit the drawbridge at the mouth of the river one night. Thank God there was not the kind of damage as in Baltimore. Part of the sidewalk went into the river and I'm sure some motorists waiting for the drawbridge to close were briefly terrified. To your point there were several tugs pushing so hard on the starboard side of the tanker that they were on what looked like a 30 degree angle from the torque of their engines but they could still not keep the tanker off the bridge. Prayers for those lost in Baltimore and God Bless all professional mariners in the dangerous work you do. PS...I love Dr. Sal's channel too.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
💯!!!!!!! Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@Steve-ev6vx
@Steve-ev6vx Місяць тому
Yeah I was thinking the tugs would have to be under control to do anything. They wouldn't be able to go hook up to and stop the ship in that situation.
@user-co7fb6qe5w
@user-co7fb6qe5w 28 днів тому
Could somebody please give us American citizens some answers? Why was a ship plagued with electrical problems allowed to leave dock? Enroute to a 27 day journey to SriLanka. I would of thought they must pass a safety checklist prior to voyage. Where is the investigative report on what and why this happened? Black box? Ship's logs? Was the pilot impaired? What is mandatory requirements for ship both entering or leaving any US port? Responsibility of harbormaster pilot? We need answers. This does not pass any smell test.
@campervanmarkmotorwayrunne3410
@campervanmarkmotorwayrunne3410 28 днів тому
COME ON MAN ! PLEEEEEZE...WHO PAID YOU TO SAY THIS CAPTAIN GOOFBALL. YOU CANNOT SAY A GOOD LIE. NO MORE OF YOU FOR ME.ADIOSE AMEGOSE. GEEZE !
@lynnhauenstein4136
@lynnhauenstein4136 28 днів тому
@user-co7fb6qe5w I hear you, and agree, how did this happen...un seaworthy container ship, 3 football fields long, pushed off docking spot.. Went down straight line to Key Bridge...never made it under wide middle portion...ship went dark, lost steering...that ship should have been lined up, for center of Bridge. I am told no need for tugboat.. 5000 meters earlier, Even if went dark.. Tugs on each side may have been able to guide ship thru center. But locals say Tugs never used and no help...maybe needed, consumers pay more.. , how did this on straight center line end up crashing into bridge pylon ?? I just hope this event studied as much as DEEP HORIZON, in Gulf by the coast guard. Suits for negligence, or poor matainence, coming..and obvious....cost, for shipping company to repair Bridge, funerals and loss of life...some dude texts on You Tube. Tugs too expensive. Just an accident...now more fed rules. Experienced Tug boat guy or he says.
@rael5469
@rael5469 Місяць тому
I felt terrible for the people who lost their lives on that bridge and it helps to be able to go to a channel like Tim's here where we can make sense of it all. To Tim and Sal and some others, a tip of the hat to you all and thank you for having your channels. They are entertaining and informative.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much. I really appreciate that. CUOTO
@annsheridan12
@annsheridan12 Місяць тому
Having the workers on the bridge saved many lives because the police vehicles were there controlling traffic and when they got the mayday they blocked traffic at both ends saving many lives.
@rael5469
@rael5469 Місяць тому
@@TimBatSea See You On The Ocean ?
@alannewman85
@alannewman85 Місяць тому
Very well said - a calm, pragmatic, unassuming and humble way.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@michaelnotigan7796
@michaelnotigan7796 Місяць тому
Tim, I'm retired USCG who worked on boats and cutters on the Delaware, Hudson and Upper Mississippi. I live close to the Delaware River, off Roebling NJ. Whenever a ship calls into Fairless Steel, one or two McAllister or Moran Tugs escort the ship to it's berth. What is shocking in this tragedy in Baltimore is to see those exposed bridge abutments in what effectively is one of the busiest ports in the Eastern US. That bridge will be rebuilt. But it must come with a total rethink, reengineering and implementation of making these bridge pier abutments more protected from these larger and larger container carriers that are calling into our old US ports; built in a time when ships these sizes of today were nothing but a pipedream on some naval architects drawing board. And yes, maybe even tug escorts if need be. Think of all the other exposed bridge piers right this very moment and we should all come away not surprised that it hasn't happened up to now (exception of the Tampa Skyway incident). Subscribed, as I see you call into ports on the Delaware quite often!!
@vance7274
@vance7274 Місяць тому
Mike... Take a look at the bridges built in Japan by Sumitomo Mitsui. They always protect the bridge pylons with "standoff aprons" or abutments as you refer to them. To me this is a no-brainer, but I am not an engineer, just another person expressing my opinion, right or wrong. I agree with your assessment 100%. Beyond that, I have been in and out of ports in Asia and Europe aboard ships with high freeboard and therefore subject to being pushed around by the wind. As you know from your USCG experience, it doesn't take much wind. Were I the decision maker, I would mandate the pylon abutments and tugs with a release point well beyond the bridge.
@michaelnotigan7796
@michaelnotigan7796 Місяць тому
Thanks for that info, Galen!@@vance7274
@whiteyfarm
@whiteyfarm Місяць тому
Hi. I worked on the Ohio, and Mississippi Rivers for 14 years. Most of the bridges I saw there had really substantial abutments or a number of pier cells filled with concrete and soil to guard the bridge piers. The builders of those bridges just assumed that one day a large tow of 15,000-20,000 tons would lose power or steering and crash into something while going under the bridge. When I saw the photos of the FSK Bridge in Baltimore my first thought was, WTF, where are the pier cells guarding those spindly looking bridge supports. Why would such an important structure be standing there naked waiting for something to come along and tap one of its supports and bring it down. The reason is that the people who paid for building the bridge didn't want to spend the extra money to protect their investment. It is easier to shift the cost to the shipping companies, and eventually the consumers of the products that they are carrying, or when disaster finally strikes, shift the blame to the ship operators. I am sure that the gov't entities that built the bridge are sending their thoughts and prayers to the families of those poor folks who lost their lives in this tragedy.
@Redslayer86
@Redslayer86 Місяць тому
I've been looking the last few days as I was crossing, and have realized that the bay bridge also has ZERO defense against ship impacts.
@TheBlindbowman
@TheBlindbowman Місяць тому
@@whiteyfarm the best part of this event is the fact people with true skills are stepping forward to give first hand over-site from years of sea duty ...each of us see things from our own skills and expertise. and i fully agree with you both ...it is a day when davy jones locker claims land lovers , the sailors know what i mean .we trust our crew and their skills we see the oceans and the sea and we have accepted our risk to be who we are , these people did not . they just wanted to get to the other side ..they will never be forgotten ...RIP to all stay safe stay free
@kimpeters4187
@kimpeters4187 27 днів тому
Tim my name is Kim. I liked what you said regarding speaking about things you know little about. I flat refuse to get into an argument about something I know little or nothing about. Operating Tug Boats or 1,000 foot ships would be one of those things, hence no stupid questions. I've been watching with interest your comments and those of Sal's "What's up with shipping". My experience in boating is high performance offshore pleasure and racing boats, just sayin. Thanks very much for your explanations and content, stay safe!
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 26 днів тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@skipah01
@skipah01 Місяць тому
Forgot to mention, I've used a tug to lean on the quarters at various speeds up to 8-9 knots, and is very effective to steer and control a vessel. As you point out, pushing at the bow is not very effective, due to being so close to the ship's pivot point, only gain really is some bodily shift. Leaning or pushing on the quarters works so well due to the distance aft from the pivot point, essentially a longer lever. If you don't already use or drill this technique with the Pilots at your port, definitely worth raising and having a go with them. An excellent emergency situation tool.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
True. Thank you for watching. CUOTO
@stevewinwood3674
@stevewinwood3674 Місяць тому
You care to say which harbor you work in?
@phoebus
@phoebus 27 днів тому
@@TimBatSea You didn't say why that ship made a almost 90 degree turn in about 30 seconds to plow into the bridge. Unless you can tell us why that ship went from going straight down the middle of the channel on it's way to go under center span to making a hard turn to starboard in a short amount of time to hit the bridge you haven't told us anything .
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 27 днів тому
@@phoebus actually AIS data shows 11 degrees of turn. Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@phoebus
@phoebus 27 днів тому
@@TimBatSea Well that's bull. Are you telling me that you are only seeing 11 degrees of turn to starboard on the videos? If you are then you have no credibility. You don't go from seeing the side of the ship almost full on to only seeing the bow with a turn of only 11 degrees. There was a small turn to port a second or two just before impact, that small turn was probably about 11 degrees.
@mattWallJsy
@mattWallJsy Місяць тому
Awesome explanation as always! Concise and informative 👍🏽
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much Matt! CUOTO
@garyn2842
@garyn2842 Місяць тому
Well said Tim, thanks for your insight. You AND Dr. Sal are great. Two different perspectives. Real, honest, and spot on. Have been following both of you. Thanks! Keep up the good work.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@pauloneil8531
@pauloneil8531 Місяць тому
You are correct. The two tugs taking the Dali away from her berth let her go when she had steerage and a strait shot down the channel to Bay. Others need to keep in mind the ship is over 900 feet in length and was fully loaded. The head pilot did order an anchor to be dropped to try and shift the direction, but it didn't work.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@rickc9873
@rickc9873 Місяць тому
Well said Tim !
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching Rick. CUOTO
@steverogers6131
@steverogers6131 Місяць тому
Thanks Capt, Dr Sal and you are my go to in all situations marine. Your experience and insight helps sift through the volumes of information. Terrible situation. Hope you are not tied up too long. Bsafe, CUOTO
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching Steven. CUOTO
@samaipata4756
@samaipata4756 Місяць тому
It is always great to hear about the impacting technicalities from a professional, thank you!
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching Sam. CUOTO
@EuroWarsOrg
@EuroWarsOrg Місяць тому
Synergy embraced DEI
@129jaystreet
@129jaystreet Місяць тому
Yep, it's taken precedence over qualifications.
@129jaystreet
@129jaystreet Місяць тому
And it is everywhere.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@rd-qn3tf
@rd-qn3tf Місяць тому
Great editorial on this subject. Thank you.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@Adam_Poirier
@Adam_Poirier Місяць тому
Spot on and excellent explanation Tim, thank you. It's very difficult to read some of the comments online or even listen to some of the news outlets when they just have no clue… There's so many people that just don't have an understanding of basic weight and inertia, never mind marine education lol. Take care my friend.
@aday1637
@aday1637 Місяць тому
Well I do have perspective, having operated several boats in the same water for many years, had an uncle who operated a tug in that harbor, etc and a tug would have, could have prevented such. A slight bump, change in direction would have could have saved the bridge. Your comment makes you seem an expert looking down on all the little people who you seem to think have no common sense because they don't own a ship, nonsense.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
😂😂😂"Hold my beer" Adam. 😂 Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@Adam_Poirier
@Adam_Poirier Місяць тому
@@aday1637 no, sir I was really only referring to the comments that I have read that say"why didn't the idiots driving that boat just put it in reverse?"
@sellis330
@sellis330 Місяць тому
Thanks for the excellent explanation and great content!
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you for watching. CUOTO
@prjndigo
@prjndigo Місяць тому
*WHY NO BARRIERS* Sunshine Skyway was fourty four goddamned years ago!
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you for watching. Most bridges built after Tampa are much better protected. CUOTO
@paulmoir4452
@paulmoir4452 Місяць тому
@@TimBatSea Up here in Halifax we retrofitted protection to our bridges after the the risk was identified in '77. Lots of depth but tugs are required through the harbour. It's not that expensive and it does make sense. Cough.
@michaelsommers2356
@michaelsommers2356 27 днів тому
The Key Bridge was built before the Skyway came down.
@General_Confusion
@General_Confusion Місяць тому
The uprights on that bridge did seem to be extremely vulnerable with no abutments surrounding them, that ship managed to hit that pylon and knock the bridge down before anything below the waterline hit anything. The upper bow of the ship should never have been able to get far enough to hit the bridge. The bridge may have been there for a long time, but it wasn't built or upgraded to contend with the ships we have nowadays. Just my 10 cents, it was an accident waiting to happen.
@louisglen1653
@louisglen1653 Місяць тому
Governments regardless of country like to spend money on new projects because they attract a lot of attention. Spending money on upgrades doesn't.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@SgtBrendanN
@SgtBrendanN Місяць тому
The bridge does have dolphins, but they are small, and quite a distance from the supports themselves. The ship hit at an angle that avoided the dolphin.
@General_Confusion
@General_Confusion Місяць тому
@@SgtBrendanN Yes I've seen them, but when this bridge was built in the mid 70s, ships were tiny in comparison to what they are today. The first container ships had only been around for about 5 years and they were tiny. No additional protection for the actual bridge seems to have been added since that time. For such an important bridge in such an important shipping lane and harbour, that seems a pretty shocking state for it to be in.
@stargazer7644
@stargazer7644 Місяць тому
The ship was actually aground before it hit. It didn't much matter.
@catdaddy3728
@catdaddy3728 Місяць тому
Excellent professional explanation sir! Always gonna have hindsight views that have all the answers. You nailed it! Thanks for your years of experience! This like so many unfortunate events will go down in history to learn from it and move forward. Stay safe!
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@gus473
@gus473 Місяць тому
⚓ Sal sent me..... 😎✌️
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@mostlyvoid.partiallystars
@mostlyvoid.partiallystars 26 днів тому
Samesies 🎉
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 26 днів тому
@@mostlyvoid.partiallystars Thank you very much
@barryobee1544
@barryobee1544 Місяць тому
Thanks for your detailed explanation. I was wondering about this!👍
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching Barry. CUOTO
@bobraymond6135
@bobraymond6135 Місяць тому
Good info Tim. Makes sense that after they got the vessel on a straight direction, that it would make sense that it could navigate the rest of the way out. Will be interesting to see what they find out.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching Bob. CUOTO
@walterchapin33
@walterchapin33 Місяць тому
Thank you for sharing your knowledge
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching Walter. CUOTO
@tracedehaven2190
@tracedehaven2190 Місяць тому
The rail incident you refer to was not trivial. A barge operating in a fog turned up a wrong channel. Lacking appropriate radar training, the captain blundered into a railroad bridge, and pushed the track out of alignment. Eight minutes later, an Amtrak train attempted to cross that bridge and derailed. It was horrific. 47 people died and 107 more were injured. If I may quote the Wiki: "The towboat's pilot, Willie Odom, was not properly trained on how to read his radar and so, due to very poor visibility in heavy fog and his lack of experience, did not realize he was off course. The boat also lacked a compass and a chart of the waters." There was a reason for those regulations. This was not trivial. Interested readers may read further: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Bayou_Canot_rail_accident
@slypen7450
@slypen7450 Місяць тому
Willie Odom turned down the wrong channel. Not up. A man must know his limitations. Obviously he didn't know the course in the icw. He could have stopped and pushed against the bank instead of fkng guessing and waking the captain and giving him a wrong position. He seen the bridge light and thought it was an industrial site further into the course westward. Minor detail Bet Willie will never live it down what a tragedy! Imagine waking up in that mess.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@Jennifermcintyre
@Jennifermcintyre 27 днів тому
That sounds like a horrific avoidable tragedy!!
@peterpumkineater6872
@peterpumkineater6872 28 днів тому
Tugs left ship after it made the turn into the channel. Job done, returned to port.🎉
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 28 днів тому
SOP. Please see part 2 for clarification. Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@Salty80556
@Salty80556 Місяць тому
Another great video. Your concern and knowledge helps us all. I hope this investigation will be thorough and proper. It seems from what I have seen, the entire problem escalated after the power outage and engine shut down. From you and other UKposts channels; i.e. Chief Mako.... There is an immense amount of paperwork about the work done, the schedule of work and inspections. My personal prayer is that the investigation will find EVERYTHING was done right and this was a very terrible accident. I also offer my condolences and prayers for the families of those lost. Stay safe and keep up the good work.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@kenaston4220
@kenaston4220 Місяць тому
Thanks Tim, you explained something that I had no concept of.... I thought a tug would have been able to control a "loose" ship, I didn't realise a loose ship at 8 knots has so much inertia, that no tug would have held it! I suppose even the ship itself, with full available power and control, takes a great effort and time to respond to the helm. Lets hope there are no knee jerk reactions because of what happened.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you for watching! I am sure heads will roll. CUOTO
@leechowning2712
@leechowning2712 Місяць тому
Much like people who ask why a train could not stop when it saw a stuck car from a half mile away... it is too big for most people to realize how big it is.
@river4462
@river4462 Місяць тому
Should have been more proactive instead of all the reactive drama. Tugs waiting nearby even before anything out of the ordinary happened.
@Knirin
@Knirin 29 днів тому
770,000 KJ of kinetic energy by the way compared to the 888 KJ of a 2 ton car going 70 Miles per Hour.
@mercuryshadow09
@mercuryshadow09 29 днів тому
Tugs basically bump the ship to keep it on course.
@6by6by6
@6by6by6 Місяць тому
That bridge had been standing for nearly 50yrs without incident as thousands of ships had passed under.Sometimes all the holes in the Swiss cheese line up and things go wrong, it’s more unbelievable to me that this doesn’t happen far more often than once in 50 years..
@davidotness6199
@davidotness6199 Місяць тому
The odds are... now established.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
💯 Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@edkiely2712
@edkiely2712 28 днів тому
That's what they want you to believe! Just so happened that the redundancies failed and the ship CONVENIENTLY and SUDDENLY turned right into the pylon!
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 28 днів тому
@@edkiely2712 please see part 2 for clarification.
@jonathanr2830
@jonathanr2830 Місяць тому
Very informative and helpful. Thank you very much!
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching Johnathan. CUOTO
@user-nj6nq9cc8o
@user-nj6nq9cc8o Місяць тому
i agree with your analysis. being a Master also for 20 years, also conformed that when ship already gain momentum with massive weight of the vessel tugs become helpless. we can just imagine during manuevering while docking or undocking that sometimes tugs cant control the sudden movement of the ship how much that she had made already of 8 kts. but anyway lets pray for the family of the victims for this accident.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
💯!! Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@skipah01
@skipah01 Місяць тому
Great video. As a harbour Pilot myself, I'm glad I'm not the only one astounded that there wasn't at least one escort tug as standard practice until clear of such a tight channel and critical piece of infrastructure. As you point out, it's only a few miles from the berth, and the consequences as we have seen are catastrophic.
@SmallSpoonBrigade
@SmallSpoonBrigade Місяць тому
The part that really amazes me is the complete disregard for any possible failures. I can sort of understand thinking that outgoing vessels aren't going to have mechanical failures that quickly, but what happens if there's a sudden medical emergency of some sort that incapacitates the pilot and anybody else there that can operate the vessel, or there's just an old fashioned mistake? The bridge had no protective engineering that I can identify in case of a ship contacting it. Nothing to prevent a ship from colliding in this fashion and apparently no tugs either. What's more, one doesn't need to be a pilot to know that without properly functioning engines and the rest of it, there's not much that anybody on the ship could do.
@Raiders33
@Raiders33 Місяць тому
That's not what Tim said. Listen from 6:00 onward. Paraphrasing, he said that the two McAllister escort tractor tugs would not have been able to significantly affect the steerage of the ~100,000-ton Dali at the 8+ knots it was traveling when this particular accident happened due to two complete power loses. And at 8:45 he said continuous escorts in the future for all ships would be cost prohibitive and unnecessary.
@dougaltolan3017
@dougaltolan3017 Місяць тому
Tugs make great fenders.
@Sadie04074
@Sadie04074 Місяць тому
Apparently the pilots attempted to get the tugs back (NYT) in an attempt gain control of their vessel, but unfortunately they were too far away to make it. Sure, it is expensive to have the extra safety precaution, but so is paying for a multi-billion dollar replacement bridge and six lives. Add in the economic impact and we could be talking about 100s of billions of dollars. It could have happened at 1:30 PM and we would be talking about 1000s of lost lives. @@Raiders33
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Tugs don't make good fenders if you are on one.
@ecossearthur
@ecossearthur Місяць тому
Great update as always.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much! CUOTO
@rinrat6754
@rinrat6754 Місяць тому
Your perspective is really useful and very well presented.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@wgowshipping
@wgowshipping Місяць тому
Just posted this great video on my page as this is a real world perspective. LIVE THE TUG LIFE!
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much! I appreciate that. CUOTO
@JohnHuntt
@JohnHuntt Місяць тому
Thanks for clearing up the issue of not having tugboats guiding the ship out. JH
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching John. CUOTO
@armastat
@armastat Місяць тому
@@michaelpezzullo3591 Bureaucrats was the term he was hunting for.
@user-co7fb6qe5w
@user-co7fb6qe5w Місяць тому
​@@michaelpezzullo3591so on the same thought process if we add another 20% container to each ship prices will come down? What is the real cost? Where do guidelines emphasize safety first/ profit 2nd? Way too many conflicting 'expert' opinions. Biden and congress immediately on right there with conclusive solutions before a thorough investigation has been complete? What about Eazt Palenstine, Ohio. Maui? Selectivereactions. Why?
@syashadeed7552
@syashadeed7552 29 днів тому
​@@michaelpezzullo3591😂 That is such a LIE. I think $2 per container would cover it and that's it.
@E_Clampus_Vitus
@E_Clampus_Vitus 29 днів тому
He didn’t clear up anything. If one tug isn’t enough, the ship should have enough tugs escorting to control the ship. If this isnt possible, the ship should be allowed in the bay. We can regulate ship size.
@fredschroyer584
@fredschroyer584 28 днів тому
Very helpful, thank you. You place the tug's rolein clear perspective.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 28 днів тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@nevcowpoke1482
@nevcowpoke1482 Місяць тому
Thanks Tim, I appreciate your perspective, you’re a true mariner!
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much! I appreciate that. CUOTO
@jerrycomo2736
@jerrycomo2736 Місяць тому
I think current dolphins are insufficient to protect bridges. Bows of modern ships have such a large overhang (flare), by the time the underwater portion of the ship hits the dolphin, the deck level of the ship may still hit the bridge. The new bridge design should consider this. Bow thrusters: How effective are bow thrusters when a ship this size is moving at 8 knots?
@DB-thats-me
@DB-thats-me Місяць тому
Thrusters are of no use during a power outage. 🤔
@mikestevens9455
@mikestevens9455 Місяць тому
Note the nearby power lines to the bridge that is a dolphin ! The bridge had only concrete piling about 100 feet out USELESS. After the Sunshine skyway collision in ‘81 ??, they proposed dolphins for this bridge but deemed too expensive (now LOL)
@jkbrown5496
@jkbrown5496 Місяць тому
That seems to be a factor here. The ship damage is at the bow main deck so that looks like what took out the pylons. Bridge was built in the late 1970s. The Dali is neoPanamax so about 50' wider than a Panamax ship of the past. That give about 25' more reach from the flare. Waterline looks dented but apparently didn't take out the dolphin wall that kept the current off the pylons.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching Jerry. Thrusters have no effect when underway an as stated below, no power - no thrusters. As to dolphins, I don't believe there are dolphins that will stop a 100k ton ship moving at that speed. After the Tampa bridge disaster, they start shoaling around dolphins and bridges. This would likely be the only chance at stopping or diverting a ship this big and fast. CUOTO
@hrhtreeoflife4815
@hrhtreeoflife4815 Місяць тому
8 knots is way too fast! Newport Harbor is limited to 5 knots.
@KF8OD1
@KF8OD1 Місяць тому
Thanks Tim!!
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you for watching. CUOTO
@boomerangfishact6754
@boomerangfishact6754 Місяць тому
Thank you for your perspective.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you for watching. CUOTO
@dougbourdo2589
@dougbourdo2589 Місяць тому
Well put Tim. Thank you.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much Doug! CUOTO
@natelammers652
@natelammers652 Місяць тому
A lot of people say they should just go really slow. They don’t understand that the wind and current can greatly affect these monster ships at slow speeds. Also, Dead slow ahead on this thing is probably 7-8kts. Taking the engine off to try and keep speed down means reduced water flow over the rudder and more of a chance for things to get out of control. It’d be interesting to know how many tens or hundreds of thousands of tug/barges and ships have been under that bridge since 1976. Just a bad chain of events. If they had lost the plant minutes earlier it might have just ran aground.
@SmallSpoonBrigade
@SmallSpoonBrigade Місяць тому
It's a chain of events that was completely preventable. If going slower isn't practical due to the currents, that just makes having proper protection for the bridge in terms of more concrete at the base and higher up. Proper dolphins in the water to help direct the ship around the pylon and more tugs to help keep the ship from colliding with the bridge. If that isn't enough, then it's completely unacceptable to have a bridge over a section of water with those ships. Either nix the bridge or nix the docks. We're fortunate that there were probably only 6 casualties. This could have happened with even less lead time or during a busier part of the day.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
💯!! Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@luisderivas6005
@luisderivas6005 Місяць тому
@@SmallSpoonBrigadeEven at a leisurely 9knots or 10mph, the mass of a fully loaded container ship imparts an instantaneous force exceeding 2 Million HP! Shoring up the pylons with protection for this would double the cost of the $1.2B bridge, and possibly damage the ship to the point of foundering.
@larrywiniarski1746
@larrywiniarski1746 Місяць тому
@@luisderivas6005 It wouldn't double the cost. You just made that up.
@SmallSpoonBrigade
@SmallSpoonBrigade Місяць тому
@@luisderivas6005 If it truly can't be shored up enough, and tugs can't do the job, then they shouldn't have been running ships that size past that bridge. As I said, the whole thing was completely avoidable.
@dykNEWS
@dykNEWS 28 днів тому
Tim, Thanks for the analogy. Tug boats are use to help guide Ships to open sea and from a cost stand point, wages associated with the work versus the cost of repairing a damage bridge of this magnitude should never be questioned. All of the bridges around the US should be protected from shipping ports because the weight & size of ships in 2024 are not the size of yesteryear vessels and our homeland would be better protected. Now the World know how well we protect out bridges. !!
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 28 днів тому
Please see part 2 for clarification. Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@scottford8736
@scottford8736 28 днів тому
I always appreciate your knowledge and experience
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 27 днів тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@paulrosa6762
@paulrosa6762 Місяць тому
Dr. Sal’s is great! Thanks Tim
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Agreed! Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@brianally1531
@brianally1531 Місяць тому
Thanks, Tim. After I had commented on your previous video it occurred to me that this would be a great subject for another. I've seen several comments online from people wondering exactly this.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching Brian. CUOTO
@Raiders33
@Raiders33 Місяць тому
@@TimBatSea Thanks also, Tim! But to be clear --- in your opinion, if the two McAllister tractor tugs (the Bridget McAllister at 5,080 HP and the Eric McAllister at 5,150 HP) had continued to escort the Dali in the channel could they have affected the Dali's steerage enough to prevent it from hitting the bridge with the Dali's two power loses?
@82rah
@82rah Місяць тому
Thanks for your insight Tim.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@46bovine
@46bovine 27 днів тому
Thank you for a great explanation!
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 27 днів тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@SmudgerSmith-lh7wv
@SmudgerSmith-lh7wv 27 днів тому
Ex-Marine Accident Investigator, Canadian govt.:Two tugs should have escorted the ship past the bridge, but the ship has to go slow enough so that tugs can be effective. So in future you will find the ship on a slow bell,with two tugs escorting, and seamen on the forecastle ready to drop both anchors. You can see from the moment the forecastle deck working light comes on that there was nobody up there until then. Port Authority not proactive enough to protect bridge. Also bridge pedestals should have berms to protect them.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 27 днів тому
Please see part 2 for clarification.
@scottM-ws7yo
@scottM-ws7yo 25 днів тому
I disagree with some of your points. Some ships, especially container vessels and car carriers, have a minimum speed of 8-9 knots and standard harbour tugs simply cannot keep up. Maybe be in future dedicated escort tugs will be used. Secondly, there 100% would have been ships crew standing by the anchors on the forecastle. Saying you couldn’t see them on the footage is just ridiculous… Shaquille O’Neill would have been impossible to see on that footage.
@ocendo1
@ocendo1 22 дні тому
@@scottM-ws7yo 8-9 Knots is to fast and anchoring is restricted in that canal.That is why ship need tugs all the way inn and out of port.
@scottM-ws7yo
@scottM-ws7yo 21 день тому
@@ocendo1 Yes it’s quite fast for a ship this size but a normal speed to transit a channel. 7-8 knots is equivalent to first gear on a ship like this.
@SmudgerSmith-lh7wv
@SmudgerSmith-lh7wv 19 днів тому
@@scottM-ws7yo Hardly! Although steerage gets worse as speed is lost, these ships can still steer at Dead Slow Ahead. They just require more rudder power. If the engine is stopped, rudder power can be augmented by a ‘kick ahead’ with the main engine. I served my Apprenticeship on a thousand-footer, and saw that is often done by pilots and the Master.
@paulcollins557
@paulcollins557 Місяць тому
Their risk benefit analysis told them they could afford the risk given thd benefit. I dare say tugs of the size required are 20,000 / hr. So someone made the decision and lost.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@patriciawalker9371
@patriciawalker9371 23 дні тому
You knew plenty and explained it well! Thank you!❤❤❤
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 23 дні тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@marzymarrz5172
@marzymarrz5172 29 днів тому
Thank you for your very reasoned explanation of the role of tugs in this sad situation. Very helpful.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 28 днів тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@kushgood4202
@kushgood4202 Місяць тому
They used to take the ships in and out of the channel with tugboats i dont know why they stopped doing that
@martijnm4905
@martijnm4905 Місяць тому
Probably the extra expenses made them stop doing it. But it’s purely the assessment of the probability of something going wrong, which is near 0, but on the other sides the what’s the result when it goes wrong, which we see is catastrophic. So was it a risk worth taking? Probably in lots of places with a similar layout people will rethink their policies now.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@roswellramseur621
@roswellramseur621 28 днів тому
Can't put a price tag on safety.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 27 днів тому
@@roswellramseur621 Really? Do you drive the safest car? Do you live in the safest house in the safest community? Do you have the safest fire suppression system in your house? Do you have.... This can go on forever. The point is, we bitch about taxes but we can't even fix the roads or bridges. I think we all put a price on safety but we aren't willing to pay it.
@charlottetracy3970
@charlottetracy3970 Місяць тому
Tim great talk...we have to remember that in life, accidents happen,,no matter what we do!
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
💯!!!! Thank you very much for watching Charlotte. CUOTO
@user-cz2bd8oj5s
@user-cz2bd8oj5s 27 днів тому
You are a good speaker Tim. Thanks for sharing your insights. I learned a lot about tugs and how important they are in keeping our ports safe.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 27 днів тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@B81Mack
@B81Mack 29 днів тому
I'm glad you posted this because I was curious about why tugs don't escort these ships past all bridges.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 28 днів тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@williamlloyd3769
@williamlloyd3769 Місяць тому
Appreciate your insights. Seems everyone is throwing up / mentioning tugs as a solution without any analysis as to why or why not. PS - Any bridge built to current standards would be built totally different. New foundation will be outside the shipping channel and /or protected by a large dolphin or both.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
💯!! Thank you very much for watching William. CUOTO
@ShakeMixPoundRoll
@ShakeMixPoundRoll 29 днів тому
​@@TimBatSeaCompare FSK BRIDGE to Kerch Bridge
@user-dk8lo6fw3u
@user-dk8lo6fw3u Місяць тому
So the takeaway message is considering the narrow passage and the immense size and momentum of the ship, additional safety factors, such as a tractor tug and dolphin barriers wouldn't have effectively averted the collision. Also, the design of the bridge and its immense span isn't designed to withstand those shear forces. The disaster; a Shock, but not a Surprise.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@richardwest9054
@richardwest9054 29 днів тому
Well spoken response to the question. Thank you.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 29 днів тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@SamJustinsAdventures
@SamJustinsAdventures Місяць тому
Thank you you’re awesome and appreciate the working knowledge and perspective
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much Sam! CUOTO
@bobuncle8704
@bobuncle8704 Місяць тому
Thank you for this. Things make so much more sense when someone who actually knows a thing or two, rather than all these pundits out there spouting all their conspiracy theories.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching Bob. Yeah, it makes my head explode at times. CUOTO
@allenkramer2143
@allenkramer2143 Місяць тому
Came over from What's going on with Shipping. Yea, most of the time a tug is on, the ship is at low speed, which reduces manoverability. Once the ship gets up to speed, E = MC² applies. The weight of the ship and SPEED equals the energy the tug would have to shoulder over. With such a short distance from the beginning of the event to it's conclusion, there probably wasn't much the tug (s) could do even if they had been there.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Dr Sal has some very smart viewers. Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@rbrosz
@rbrosz Місяць тому
E=MC²? The ship was going so fast it was approaching the speed of light? Or was it powered by a nuclear reaction? 😁 I think you're looking for KE=½ mv²
@kennethcarr2511
@kennethcarr2511 Місяць тому
Thanks Tim
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching Kenneth. CUOTO
@baitwaitfishing7625
@baitwaitfishing7625 Місяць тому
Follow-up too previous comment. Captain Sulley just basically had to plop down on some water that didn't have a bridge or current and darkness of Nyquil or night to deal with.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@Raiders33
@Raiders33 Місяць тому
www.youtube.com/@TimBatSea Thanks Tim! But to be clear --- in your opinion, if the two McAllister tractor tugs (the Bridget McAllister at 5,080 HP and the Eric McAllister at 5,150 HP) had continued to escort the Dali in the channel could they have affected the Dali's steerage enough to prevent it from hitting the bridge with the Dali's two power loses?
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
I do not believe they could while the ship that size was moving at that speed. Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@EleanorWinner-st1yb
@EleanorWinner-st1yb 29 днів тому
Lots of us are wondering the same thing. I live in Baltimore. Been over this bridge many times . Passed under it too .
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 28 днів тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@elizabethbrassfield6418
@elizabethbrassfield6418 Місяць тому
Thanks for you illustrations and explanations
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@boblister665
@boblister665 29 днів тому
In the 70's my dad ran tugs towing dump scows for a dredge co. They got a job in Beverly Ma. that required going through two bridges that were not aligned. Their tug was a single screw 300HP. antique, after one white knuckle pass dad quit until the bought a 2000 hp. twin screw tug. He said if you take down a bridge you never work again
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 29 днів тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@cactus-ya-ya
@cactus-ya-ya Місяць тому
I expect to see "feel-good" legislation. I'd like to see more bridge pier protection systems. I also think we're looking at least one year for bridge engineering and fabrication time with the full project running 3-5 years. Would also expect to see a McDermott sized barge crane showing up in the next 72 hours.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Donjon is enroute. Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@douglascorley6630
@douglascorley6630 Місяць тому
Navigate to them Waters at night time you guys are badass
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you for watching. CUOTO
@thereissomecoolstuff
@thereissomecoolstuff Місяць тому
The word is regulatory official vs politician. Good vid Tim.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@mad1s
@mad1s Місяць тому
Thanks for covering that. I was wondering about the procedures in that part of the country
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@kirkreusch5704
@kirkreusch5704 Місяць тому
I found Dr Sals channel through this catastrophe! He has an excellent channel and has done a terrific job of covering this.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
💯!! Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@user-dv7hb2sc9m
@user-dv7hb2sc9m Місяць тому
I appreciate hearing your humble opinion whereas I asked about Tugs from an ignorant position = like I know nothing. It's very safe being an Armchair Warrior.... lol, I know the area & have friends who now have some problems getting to work but they'll figure all that out. At least Baltimore was promised a big chunk of change for structural upgrades although I doubt they had planned to use the money on a new bridge? All that said, thanks for explaining some of the water depth & other considerations that we'd never know? Only someone like you could share it w/ us...... you be safe out there// peace & GB ALL
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@terrycannon570
@terrycannon570 Місяць тому
Thanks for clearing this issue up for us. As no one who has ever worked on a ship or a Tug I was asking myself the same question (Why No Tuggs) Now I know . Thanks again.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@ventures3602
@ventures3602 29 днів тому
Thanks for your take on this Tim, I was wondering the same thing!
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 28 днів тому
Thank you for watching. CUOTO
@robmcd
@robmcd Місяць тому
Tugs aren’t to blame here but Tugs will definitely need to increase their numbers to prevent this tragedy in future. Bridges with a certain pilon width say 1200ft and narrower require a tug for 1NM from the stern. We’re not savages we’re a sophisticated society and this is what we do to ensure safety for the ship, the crew, infrastructure, workers and citizens.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@tommussington8330
@tommussington8330 Місяць тому
The landlubber analogy would a tractor trailer be able to stop the motion of a 100 car train and locomotives if they lost brakes I think not.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
💯!! Exactly!! Thank you very much for watching Tommus. CUOTO
@abritishexpatinthephilippines
@abritishexpatinthephilippines 27 днів тому
Very interesting video.much appreciated insights ❤
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 27 днів тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@DROcchipinti
@DROcchipinti Місяць тому
Nice job Tim
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Oh shoot! I know you! I was hoping you could weigh in and take some of the heat with me Cap! 😂
@JamesRook
@JamesRook Місяць тому
I'll defer to your knowledge of the how things marine work, but even though you mentioned it, I feel you lost the main point of why no tugs - costs. I've lived in Baltimore since 1955 and well remember the controversy over building a bridge versus another tunnel. The cheaper bridge won of course, but using tugs as escorts past the bridge was a big issue because of this exact possibility. It was supposed to happen, but the shipping companies won out because of the added expense. You can say it's overkill, but then so is a lifejacket until you need it.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you for watching James. CUOTO
@charlie15627
@charlie15627 28 днів тому
The issue isn't with tugs but with the seriously deficient amount of pylons and other structures shielding the bridge supports.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea 27 днів тому
Please see part 2 for clarification. Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@elewmompittseh
@elewmompittseh Місяць тому
Thank you, this is exactly what I keep asking!
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching. CUOTO
@MrRgr004
@MrRgr004 Місяць тому
Very good video, crystal clear, like your comments about the crew and pilots on board the ill fated vessel.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching! CUOTO
@DB-thats-me
@DB-thats-me Місяць тому
A lot people don’t get the idea that a tug of say 5000hp doesn’t have much effect on a vessel, of this size, that is underway. The ship at 8kn would probably take more than it’s own length to stop at FULL astern power and it has 55,000hp!
@SmallSpoonBrigade
@SmallSpoonBrigade Місяць тому
A couple things, one why was it going so fast if the tugs couldn't manage it. And secondly, the tugs wouldn't need to stop the ship, the tugs just needed to keep it going straight through. Once the ship was through the bridge they had pretty much as much space to stop as they needed to. Which is to say that the tugs just needed to be able to supply enough force to the ship to keep it from changing course. Which quite honestly, isn't much of an ask. The ship wants to go straight by default so it just has to supply enough push to make up for any wind or currents. I used to know one of of the local harbor pilots here and I'm well aware of the fact that the stopping distance on one of these ships is long, typical docking around here involves starting to slow miles before you're at the actual dock. And that even with the emergency stopping procedures you're still talking something on measurable in miles. Or to look at it a different way, if tugs wouldn't be enough, then why is the ship moving that quickly and why is the bridge not properly engineered to deal with this. This collision was going to happen eventually. This isn't the first time a ship has knocked over a bridge, and it won't be the last. So, to put so much faith in the ship to not have any mechanical problems and the pilot to not make any mistakes seems rather fantastic.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Very true! Thank you for watching! CUOTO
@DB-thats-me
@DB-thats-me Місяць тому
Unlike a car, ships steer by water flowing past the rudder. This means the faster they go, the more responsive they are. (Up to a limit). Further, this steering force us hugely augmented by the wash coming from the propeller. At 8kn the speed of the water past the rudder could well be in the order of 20-30kn! With the prop stopped this falls to hull speed. Still works but greatly diminished. Depending on what angle the rudder was at when the lights went out, the rudder will simply stay there.
@stevewinwood3674
@stevewinwood3674 Місяць тому
Yes a true escort tug can have a big effect on a ship that size. The escort tug can steer a ship that size.
@russell7489
@russell7489 Місяць тому
Bigger tug, see my post for why that works
@garbo8962
@garbo8962 Місяць тому
Here in Philly they always have one or two tug boats traveling with much smaller freighter ships by the Tacony Palmyra & Betsey Ross bridges. The Betsey Ross is approximately the same length & age of the Key bridge while never having a container ship and bet 90% less ship traffic but has huge Dolphin protection. The few million they saved years ago will now cost them countless billions of dollars.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you for watching. CUOTO
@DurzoBlunts
@DurzoBlunts Місяць тому
In Jacksonville I don't think I ever saw a car carrier coming in with a tug escort under the dames point bridge. Though car carriers are smaller albeit only slightly.
@jerrykinnin7941
@jerrykinnin7941 Місяць тому
Thanks for the explanation.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@rp1645
@rp1645 Місяць тому
Thank you so much as a TUG Captain Professional Mariner 😊 talking about how Tugs would have been positioned and NOT having power to STOP this massive container ship. After the terrible Oil spit in Alaska. I remember the build up to escort and I will say super Tug builds with massive ( BALLARD pull) the term means a super tug with winches being able to pull with winch without turning over. Company had to build these super tugs just for the Alaska Pipeline terminal and be hooked up with there cable ropes to Oil tankers. This was very expensive builds to make these tugs. On the new bridge on Tacoma Narrows. They had to have a very powerful Tug there all the time they were raising the new spans because of very swift current at tide changes. It had to help the barge with new section of bridge say still. Even though that barge had (4) portable BIG thrusters on each corner of barge. That Tug stayed at bridge site 24/7 think of the cost. Escort tugs are an expense that no one wants to pay for.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@rp1645
@rp1645 29 днів тому
@@TimBatSea I am highly recommend your channel and you as a Professional Mariner and very important issue on this bridge collapse collision. About the Tugboat usage in Dock assists with very large super size ships. And especially important about your great information on even if a tug or two would have been escorts or even lines up to stern. Very important as a brake style to slow forward motion of again will say super large ships we have today. I hate how new build tugs are going to this "O" emissions to meet Port requirements Tugs have to be as you the Tug Captain. Have to have that massive Diesel engine that doesn't have all this emissions BS. You need pulling or pushing power ( hopefully you as a tug won't tip over) pushing on the bow in an emergency. Tugs have rolled over in the past. That great video of the Navy tug alongside a Nuclear sub and sub just continues to move and eventually the tug gets dragged under and SINKS. That's the ONE big issue I worry about you personally in your Profession job, you arein. I really like your video talking about Tugboat life, even showing the footage of buying food for the crew. A well feed crew with great MEAT dinner is a happy 😊 crew and that so important to you in bridge, as your crew handle those huge tow line any time of day.
@paulholmes-vu1eh
@paulholmes-vu1eh Місяць тому
Great opinion..👍
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you for watching Paul. CUOTO
@georgecarlson1460
@georgecarlson1460 Місяць тому
Excellant presentation. The idea that a tug would have made all the difference with an uncontrollable 100,000 ton vessel is ludicrous.
@Ranman1
@Ranman1 Місяць тому
It’s literally thier jobs to control those ship’s! It all comes down to money and convenience. They refuse to put up ship barriers or use tugs. A more apt comparison is the Skyway bridge in Tampa in the 80’s. Guess what they do down their since, in addition to the ship barriers, they are escorted by tugs! At least that is my understanding.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
💯!! Thank you very very much for watching. CUOTO
@PBVader
@PBVader Місяць тому
I would highly disagree with OP. See RanMans comment on how the prices are going to go up anyway. Remember, it didn't have to be this way.
@kylebarcinas5919
@kylebarcinas5919 Місяць тому
Ive been waiting to hear tims opinion because hes a vet when it comes to driving big ass boats 😂❤
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@julesjames593
@julesjames593 Місяць тому
No blame. But the cost of keeping the harbor tug on contract for another 30 minutes to clear the bridge is a few thousand dollars. Two minutes of a tractor tug to re-direct that bow could have saved a billion dollar re-build.
@129jaystreet
@129jaystreet Місяць тому
Keep in mind corporations always want profit to be private and risk to public.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching Jules. I don't believe there is a tug on the planet that could have stopped this. CUOTO
@jcl410
@jcl410 Місяць тому
Then there's another bridge 15 miles south of Baltimore. Do you pay for tugs there too?
@michaelsommers2356
@michaelsommers2356 27 днів тому
@@jcl410 _"Then there's another bridge 15 miles south of Baltimore. Do you pay for tugs there too?"_ And there's the bridge-tunnel at the entrance to the Bay. Do you keep the tugs all the way to the ocean?
@paulhalvorseth4465
@paulhalvorseth4465 Місяць тому
I was an engineer...not deck dept, so not qualified to comment really, but back in the 70's a typical stern drive 2000 hp tug MIGHT be capable 12 or 13 kts. As you said...almost totally ineffective on a ship doing 8 kts as reported. I shudder to think what could happen with a line on the ship....seems to me the tug would be at extreme risk to be caught in irons and rolled. Maybe the new 10000 horse tractor tugs have less risk.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
@raymaulder7383
@raymaulder7383 Місяць тому
Common sense there Tim. Sal is well worth the visit too. Thank you.
@TimBatSea
@TimBatSea Місяць тому
Thank you very much for watching and welcome to the channel. CUOTO
Why No Tugs Follow- Up (Pt.2)
15:13
TimBatSea
Переглядів 45 тис.
What caused the Power Failure : The Dali Incident
23:47
Chief MAKOi
Переглядів 441 тис.
Анна Трінчер - Бар за баром (Official Music Video)
02:38
Анна Трінчер
Переглядів 1,6 млн
Арсенал VS Челсі - Огляд матчу
07:44
Setanta Sports Premier League
Переглядів 284 тис.
Lower Dartmouth Ferry
2:21
mark kirk_01
Переглядів 4
New Evidence on Theory of 'Black Box' Being Switched Off | SY News Ep314
11:52
eSysman SuperYachts
Переглядів 392 тис.
What it Takes to Keep a Tug Boat Crew Happy
23:38
TimBatSea
Переглядів 238 тис.
Francis Scott Key Bridge Collapse
4:57
BLAK MATH
Переглядів 11 тис.
Tour of my new boat!
35:28
TimBatSea
Переглядів 138 тис.
Loss of Propulsion
18:18
TimBatSea
Переглядів 67 тис.
US Army Corps of Engineers Baltimore's Salvage Plan | MV Dali & Francis Scott Key Bridge
18:40
What is Going on With Shipping?
Переглядів 320 тис.
Why the Blackout & is Negligence of the Crew Suspected? | Q&A
26:27
eSysman SuperYachts
Переглядів 165 тис.
Meeting a 1300 Foot Container Ship
30:11
TimBatSea
Переглядів 91 тис.